Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCouncil Actions 12-05-05 Fitzpatrick 37260-120505 ROANOKE CITY COUNCIL REGULAR SESSION DECEMBER 5, 2005 9:00 A.M. ROOM 159 AGENDA Call to Order--RoII Call. (All Council Members were present. Mr. Lea and Mr. Wishneff arrived late.) A communication from Mayor C. Nelson Harris requesting that Council convene in a Closed Meeting to discuss vacancies on certain authorities, boards, commissions and committees appointed by Council, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711 (A)(l), Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. Approved (5-0, Council Members Lea and Wishneff were not present when the vote was recorded.) File #110-132 A communication from the City Manager requesting that Council convene in a Closed Meeting to discuss acquisition of real property for a public purpose, where discussion in open meeting would adversely affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the public body, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711 (A)(3), Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. Approved (5-0, Council Members Lea and Wishneff were not present when the vote was recorded.) File #132 1 Items listed on the 2:00 p.m. Council docket requiring discussion/ clarification, and additions/deletions to the 2:00 p.m. agenda. (15 minutes) General topics for discussion by the Mayor and Members of Council. (5 minutes) Topics for discussion at the Council/School Board retreat on Tuesday, January 3, 2006. (5 minutes) BRIEFINGS: · Citizen Survey Results · RRHA Project Update · Update on Street Restoration Standards · Zoning Ordinance Revision · New Parking Ticket Procedure 45 minutes 10 minutes 20 minutes 10 minutes 20 minutes A JOINT MEETING OF COUNCIL AND THE ROANOKE CITY SCHOOL BOARD WITH THE CITY'S REPRESENTATIVES TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY WAS HELD AT 12:00 P.M., IN ROOM 159, NOEL C. TAYLOR MUNICIPAL BUILDING. 2 t. ROANOKE CITY COUNCIL ROANOKE CITY SCHOOL BOARD MONDAY, DECEMBER 5,2005 12:00 P.M. ROOM 159 AGENDA 1. Call to Order/Roll Call School Board 2. Welcome and Opening Remarks: Mayor Harris Chairperson Stockburger 3. Presentation ofthe City/School 2006 Legislative Program. 4. Remarks by Council Members, School Trustees. and Staff. 5. Remarks by Senator Edwards. Delegate Fralin and Delegate Ware. THE COUNCIL MEETING WAS DECLARED IN RECESS TO BE RECONVENED AT 2:00 P.M., IN THE CITY COUNCIL CHAMBER, FOURTH FLOOR, NOEL C. TAYlOR MUNICIPAL BUILDING. THE SCHOOL BOARD MEETING WAS ADJOURNED. 3 ROANOKE CITY COUNCIL REGULAR SESSION DECEMBER 5, 2005 2:00 P.M. CITY COUNCIL CHAMBER AGENDA 1. Call to Order--RoII Call. The Invocation was delivered by Council Member Alfred T. Dowe, Jr. The Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America was led by Mayor C. Nelson Harris. Welcome. Mayor Harris. NOTICE: Today's Council meeting will be replayed on Channel 3 on Thursday, December 8, 2005, at 7:00 p.m., and Saturday, December 10, 2005, at 4:00 p.m. Council meetings are offered with closed captioning for the hearing impaired. 4 ANNOUNCEMENTS: THE PUBLIC IS ADVISED THAT MEMBERS OF COUNCIL RECEIVE THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA AND RELATED COMMUNICATIONS, REPORTS, ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS, ETC., ON THE WEDNESDAY PRIOR TO THE COUNCIL MEETING TO PROVIDE SUFFICIENT TIME FOR REVIEW OF INFORMATION. CITIZENS WHO ARE INTERESTED IN OBTAINING A COpy OF ANY ITEM LISTED ON THE AGENDA MAY CONTACT THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE, ROOM 456, NOEL C. TAYLOR MUNICIPAL BUILDING, 215 CHURCH AVENUE, S. W., OR CALL 853-2S41. THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE PROVIDES THE MAJORITY OF THE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ON THE INTERNET FOR VIEWING AND RESEARCH PURPOSES. TO ACCESS AGENDA MATERIAL, GO TO THE CITY'S HOMEPAGE AT WWW.ROANOKEVA.GOV.CLlCK ON THE ROANOKE CITY COUNCIL ICON, CLICK ON MEETINGS AND AGENDAS, AND DOWNLOAD THE ADOBE ACROBAT SOFTWARE TO ACCESS THE AGENDA. ALL PERSONS WISHING TO ADDRESS COUNCIL ARE REQUESTED TO REGISTER WITH THE STAFF ASSISTANT WHO IS LOCATED AT THE ENTRANCE TO THE COUNCIL CHAMBER. ON THE SAME AGENDA ITEM, ONE TO FOUR SPEAKERS WILL BE ALLOTTED FIVE MINUTES EACH, HOWEVER, IF THERE ARE MORE THAN FOUR SPEAKERS, EACH SPEAKER WILL BE ALLOTTED THREE MINUTES. ANY PERSON WHO IS INTERESTED IN SERVING ON A CITY COUNCIL APPOINTED AUTHORITY, BOARD, COMMISSION OR COMMITTEE IS REQUESTED TO CONTACT THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AT 853-2541, OR ACCESS THE CITY'S HOMEPAGE ATWWW.ROANOKEVA.GOV, TO OBTAIN AN APPLICATION. 2. PRESENTATIONS AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: NONE. 5 3. CONSENT AGENDA Approved (7-0) ALL MATTERS LISTED UNDER THE CONSENT AGENDA ARE CONSIDERED TO BE ROUTINE BY THE MEMBERS OF CITY COUNCIL AND WILL BE ENACTED BY ONE MOTION. THERE WILL BE NO SEPARATE DISCUSSION OF THE ITEMS. IF DISCUSSION IS DESIRED, THE ITEM WILL BE REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA AND CONSIDERED SEPARATELY. C-l Qualification of the following persons: Edward W. Barnett as a member of the Roanoke Arts Commission to fill the unexpired term of Mark C. McConnel, resigned, ending June 30, 2007; and Phyllis A. Johnson as a member of the Towing Advisory Board, for a term ending June 30, 2008. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Receive and file. File #15-110-230-543 REGULAR AGENDA 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS: NONE. 5. PETITIONS AND COMMUNICATIONS: a. Presentation of a resolution adopted by the Library Advisory Board with regard to the Comprehensive Library Study. Stanley G. Breakell, President, Spokesperson. (Sponsored by the City Manager.) Referred to the City Manager for report to Council. File #323 6 6. REPORTS OF OFFICERS: a. CITY MANAGER: BRIEFINGS: NONE. ITEMS RECOMMENDED FOR ACTION: 1. Acceptance of a Summer Food Program grant from the U. S. Department of Agriculture Food and Nutrition Services; and appropriation of funds. Adopted Budget Ordinance No. 37260-120505 and Resolution No. 37261-120505. (7-0) File #60-67-236-304 2. Amendment of the City Code to update code enforcement regulations. Adopted Ordinance No. 37262-120505. (7-0) File #24-32 3. Amendment of the City's Fee Compendium to reflect revised market space fees, effective January 1, 2006. Adopted Resolution No. 37263-120505. (7-0) File #42-60-289 4. Appropriation of $465,000.00 in connection with Social Service Programs. Adopted Budget Ordinance No. 37264-120505. (7-0) File #60-72 5. Approval of the terms of a Performance Agreement for an Economic Development Grant between the City of Roanoke, Faison-Southern Lane, LLC, and the Industrial Development Authority. Adopted Ordinance No. 37265-120505. (7-0) File #207-450 7 6. Execution of an Amendment to the Lease Agreement with the Virginia Department of Health with regard to City-owned property located at 515 and 530 Eighth Street, S. w. Adopted Ordinance No. 37266-120505. (7-0) File #22-373 b. DIRECTOR OF FINANCE: 1. Financial report for the month of October, 2005. Received and filed. File #10 2. Adoption of a resolution authorizing the sale of $3,975,000.00 taxable bonds to provide funds for acquisition of land for redevelopment and delegating authority to the City Manager and Director of Finance to complete the sale of bonds. Adopted Resolution No. 37267-120505. (7-0) File #2-53 7. REPORTS OF COMMITTEES: NONE. 8. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: a. Proposal of the City of Roanoke to amend the City Code to repeal Chapter 36.1, Zoning, and to adopt a new Zoning Ordinance, new Chapter 36.2, Zoning. (Ordinance was tabled by Council on Monday, November 21,2005.) Adopted Ordinance No. 37268-120505. (7-0) File #24-51 b. Proposal of the City of Roanoke to rezone all property in the City in order to implement new Chapter 36.2, Zoning, and Vision 2001- 2020, the City's Comprehensive Plan, and to adopt new zoning maps. (Ordinance was tabled by Council on Monday, November 21, 2005.) Adopted Ordinance No. 37269-120505. (5-2, Council Members Lea and Wishneff voted no.) File #24-51 8 9. INTRODUCTION AND CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS: NONE. 10. MOTIONS AND MISCELLANEOUS BUSINESS: a. Inquiries and/or comments by the Mayor and Members of City Council. Council Member Cutler commended Kenneth S. Cronin on his appointment to the position of Director of General Services, effective December 1, 2005. File #45-184 Council Member Cutler advised that the City deployed another group of firefighters to Cameron Parrish, Louisiana, on December 3, 2005, to help restore the area as a result of hurricane activity. File #70-1 84 Council Member Cutler advised that at its 9:00 a.m., work session, the Council received a summary briefing on the City's 2005 Citizen Survey that was conducted by The Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research which revealed that 85.8 per cent of Roanoke's citizens are very or somewhat satisfied with the quality of City services. File #563 Mayor Harris and Vice-Mayor Fitzpatrick commended citizens of the City of Roanoke and City staff upon completion of a multi-year process to implement a new Zoning Ordinance for the City. File #5 1 b. Vacancies on certain authorities, boards, commissions and committees appointed by Council. 9 11. HEARING OF CITIZENS UPON PUBLIC MATTERS: CITY COUNCIL SETS THIS TIME AS A PRIORITY FOR CITIZENS TO BE HEARD. MATTERS REQUIRING REFERRAL TO THE CITY MANAGER WILL BE REFERRED IMMEDIATELY FOR RESPONSE, RECOMMENDATION OR REPORT TO COUNCIL. Mr. Clarence E. Martin, 155 Huntington Boulevard, N. E., suggested that Roanoke's holiday tree be known as a Christmas tree. File #240 Mr. Robert E. Gravely, 727 29th Street, N. W., spoke with regard to the spending of taxpayers' money. File #66-79 Mr. Winfred Noell, 2743 Northview Drive, S. W., presented a summary of neighborhood meetings which have been conducted with regard to construction of a football stadium at Patrick Henry High School. File #467 12. CITY MANAGER COMMENTS: The City Manager commended the Old Southwest Parlor Tour which was held on Saturday, December 3 and Sunday, December 4, 2005. File #87-165 The City Manager commended the City's Department of Parks and Recreation on the beautiful decorations of the season at Mountain View Recreation Center. File #67 CERTIFICATION OF CLOSED SESSION. (6-0, Council Member Dowe left the meeting following the Closed Session.) 10 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE MAYOR 215 CHURCH AVENUE, S.w, ROOM 452 ROANOKE, VIRGINIA 24011-1594 TELEPHONE: (540) 853-2444 FAX: (540) 853-\ 145 C. NELSON HARRIS Mayor December 5, 2005 The Honorable Vice-Mayor and Members of the Roanoke City Council Roanoke, Virginia Dear Members of Council: This is to request a Closed Meeting to discuss vacancies on certain authorities, boards, commissions and committees appointed by Council, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711 (A)(1), Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. Sincerely, c...~~.~ C. Nelson Harris Mayor CNH:snh CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W" Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 The Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, Virginia Subject: Request for closed meeting Dear Mayor Harris and Council Members: This is to request that City Council convene a closed meeting to discuss the acquisition of real property for a public purpose, where discussion in open meeting would adversely affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the City, pursuant to S2.2-3711.A.3, of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. Sincerely, J Darlene L. B City Manage DLB/s c: William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Mary F. Parker, City Clerk CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, VA Dear Mayor Harris and Members of Council: Subject: Citizen Survey Results This is to request space on Council's agenda for a 45 minute presentation on the above referenced subject. Respectfully submitted, DLB:sm c: City Clerk City Attorney Director of Finance City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey - Conducted by: The Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research I Methodology - · Random Sampling Design · Survey Instrument Focus: New Items and Methodology · Dates of Administration: 5/23/05-8/9/05 · Survey Pre-test · Survey Administration Via Telephone · 505 Completed Telephone Interviews · Sampling Error: :t4.4 percent · Survey Length: 18.5 Minute Average 1 I "! Respondent Demographics Population 2003 Respondents 2005 Respondents Gender 53.1% Female: 63.9% Female: 63.Mf! Female; 46.9% Male 36.1 % Male 36.4% Male Age 39.7% <40 yrs. 33.9'k <40 yrs. 23.8% <40 yrs. 60.3% 40+ yrs. 66.1 % 40+ yrs. 76.2% 40+ yrs. Race 26.7% Black 19.3% Black 21.1% Black 69.4% White 79.1 % White 75.9% White 3.9% Other 1.6% Other 3.0% Olher Income 65.1 % < $50.000 72.8% < $50,()()() 68.7% < $50,000 34.9% $50,000+ 27.2% $50,000+ 31.3% $50,000+ - Citizen Ratings of the City of Roanoke As A Place To Live: 2000-2005 - 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 o II 2000 . 2001 .2002 02003 .2005 0.2 1.2 0.6 0.2 0.6 Excellent/Good Fair/Poor Don't know/Refuse 2 Citizen Ratings of Quality of Life in the City of Roanoke -- 100 79.4 79.3 77.2 75.1 1i!l2000 80 . 2002 60 o 2003 . 2005 40 20 0.8 0.8 1.0 0.0 0 Excellent/Good Fair/Poor Don't knowlRefuse Level of Citizen Satisfaction With Overall Quality of City Services: 2000-2005 -- 100 95 90 91.0 85 87.0 88.5 84.9 85,8 80 75 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 ...... 'Very' or 'Somewhat' Satisfied 3 Citizen Ratings of City Services as 'Excellent' or 'Good': 2005 2003 Ratings Appear in Parentheses (95.1) Fire Protection Services - 92.29(, (93.0) Emergency & Rescue Services - 91.7% (94.1) 911 Emergency Call Center - 91.5% (92.6) Public Library Services - 90.79(.' (84.6) Weekly Trash Collection - 85.9% (75.6) City Beautitication Programs - 81.9% (79.] ) Police Services - 80.4o/r.' (81.8) Emergency/Disaster Mgmt. - 80,]% (8] ,9) Mowing/Maiot. of City Parks - 79.3% (74.2) Recycling Services - 77.7% 05.6) Pick-up of Large Items/Bmsh - 76.5% (75.4) Convenience of Bill Payment - 72.5%. (74.9) Bagged Leaf Collection - 71.6% - (75.5) Cultural Activities/Events in the City -70.5% (78.4) The City's Recreation Programs - 69.0% (75.4) Clean/Maiot. Parks/Rec. Facilities - 68.7'k (70.0) Maint. ofeily-Owned Buildings - 68.7% (69.1) Street Lighting - 68.7% 174m ClcanlMaint. Community Rec. Cntrs. - 67.20/. (NA) Maint. of Trees Along Streets/In Parks - 67.2% (65.3) Removal of Snow/lce From Streets - 66.9% (72.5) Mowing Rt.Ways/Medians/Roadsidcs - 66.7% (67.9) Animal Control- 65.3% (69.4) Quality Civic Center Cultural Events - 64.9IJE (NA) Quality New Sidewalk Construction - M.gok (69.3) Building Permits ApplicationlReview - 62.1 % Citizen Ratings of City Services as 'Excellent' or 'Good': 2005 Continued 2003 Ratings Appear in Parentheses (66.7) Building Inspections - 61.4'/(, (65.6) Loose LeafColIectioll- 60.5'1,: (64.:1) City Gov. Suppon Nbrhd Orgs. - 54.9% (54.7) &:on. Dev. Assist. to Business - 58.4f"!c, (62.0) Quality Civic Center Events - 58.7% (NA) Quality Athletic FieldslFacil. - 57.8% (64. I) Getting [nformationlo Citizens - 56.7'lc (614) Street Sweeping - 542% (46.0) City Parking F<lcilities - 54. 1 % (63.5) Maint. Storm Drainage Syst. - 52.7% ... (502) Promoting Env. Awareness - 508% (56.2) Regulation/Zoning L<lnd Use - 50.! % (52.4) Effuns to Improve Housing- 500% (NA) Maint. of Existing Sidewalks - 49.J'Yc (52.(l) Response to Cifizen Requests - 48.6% (53.6) Transportation Planning for Traffic - 48.6";0 (50.9) Availability of Civic Center Pilrking - 45.2% (54.3) Property Code Enforcement - 4JR"{, (48.2) Street Paving, Maintenance/Repair - 40.4% (42.3) Weed Abatcmell! - 37.6% Ratings For Services Provided 8J Autonomous GO\'f'rnmf'nt Organizations (80.4) Valley Metro Services - 79.79(. (84.4) Water Services - 79.3% (82.2) Health Department - nw% {81.6) Sewer Services - 74.5'7,-, (60.S) Roanoke Public Schools - 62.2'-'/', 4 City Services With At Least A Five Position Rank Order Increase Since 2003 -- . City Parking Facilities (From 47th to 34th) . Removal of Snow and Ice From City Streets (From 28th to 16th) . City Beautification Programs (From 151h to 6th) . Street Lighting (From 26th to 17th) . Economic Development Assistance to Businesses (From 37th to 29th) . Recycling Services (From 17th to 9th) . City's Efforts to Promote Environmental Awareness (From 45th to 38th) . Current Level of Bagged Leaf Collection Service (From 21 sl to 14th) . City Efforts to Improve the Quality of Housing in the City (From 42nd to 35th) . Maintenance of City Owned Buildings (From 25th to 20th) Services With A Percentage Rating Decrease Since 2003 (Citizen Ratings of 'Excellent' and 'Good' Combined) City Service 2003 Rating 2005 Rating % Decline Mainlt'IlJIKC or Storm Drainage Sy,lems 03,S'" 52.7'+ -HU\ EI11\m.:~m~nt ofPmP'Ol1y MainterwrKelNui,aoce Culli's 54.J'k 43.lN -10.5 Cily'~ R~l'reatiun Prugram, 7H..V;>' (l<.l.(l'k -'J.4 Street Sweeping 03.4'~ 54.2'k -Y.2 Street Paving. Maimenanre. and Repair 4H,2'it 40,4'* -7.1\ Citi;t;en, Gelling Intt,rmation Abollt City Service,/Activitie, 04, 1 ~i 50.7'~, -7...! Building Permits Applicalion "nd Revi~w ProLe" 09,N 62.]'* -7.2 Cleanlines, and Maintenance of Community ReL Cel1ter~ 74,or.. 67.2'''' -6.K Ck"nlines,./Maintenance of ParksIRcc Faci]ities in General 75.4<;f 6/!,7'k -0.7 Regulilti()nandhlllingf\lrl.~lndUse 56.N: 50,1'k -(l.] Mowing Right of WaY', Street Medians_ and Roadsides 72.5'f 6O.7'if 5.K A,""ilability of Parking at the Civir Center SO,Y'f 45.:Yi -5.7 BuiJdinglnspeLtions &>.7'if 61.4'Si -53 Curr~nt !.;;:vel"fL<.'(Is<:LeafC"l!el1ionServicc 6),o't 60,5'* -5.] Cu]tural Al1ivitiesund Evellts intheCity 75W 70.5'k -5.0 Transpllt1atiun Planning li,rTraffir 53.6'k 41U'{0 -5.0 Weed Abatemellt 42,Y+ 37.6c{ " Qualityol'CivicCenterCultura] Events 69.4'+ M.Q~f .4.5 5 Citizen Agreement on Roanoke Strategic Issue/Question Survey Items 2000-2005 * Response Catel!:Ory DilTerenl.'<< Citizen Agreement on Roanoke Strategic Issue/Question Survey Items 2000-2005 (continued) 60.2 NA 5(,.3 NA 4'.7 NA 40.5 NA 42.0 "'Response Category DiR'erence 6 Perceptions of Safety in Roanoke: 2003 & 2005 ..... Neighborhood 90.7 91.2 ParkslRec.Facllltles 73.7 69.0 Downtown 81.8 81.5 82.6 78A . 2005 02003 Civic Center Parking Lot City Parking Gerages 57.0 55.0 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 80.0 90.0 100.0 Percentage Reporting 'Very' or 'Somewhat' Sate City Government Customer Service Ratings: 2000-2005 7 Action Plan for Maintenance of Storm Drainage Systems .- . The City's consultant presented an overview of the storm water utility options and recommendations. City Council indicated a desire to take a regional approach to such a utility and asked the WVW A to consider this issue, but it has not advanced further at this time. Seek guidance on the appropriate next step. . Continue to develop budget and CMERP requests that will improve our ability to address storm water maintenance needs. . Purchase and deploy recently funded storm drain camera system. . Encourage the shortening of the loose leaf collection season to free up maintenance crews to work on storm water maintenance and other critical maintenance projects. 8 Action Plan for Enforcement of Property Maintenance/N uisance Codes .... . Continue working with RVTV and the Office of Communications to develop educational series on code enforcement. . Continue to cross-train inspectors. . Continue to canvass for nuisance codes and Rental Certificate of Compliance program, thus being proactive and not reactive to reduce the number of citizen complaints. . Recruiting inspectors for 2 vacancies. Continue to demolish derelict structures and mow weeds; the Dept of Housing and Neighborhood Services has eliminated an underpert()rming contractor from their weed abatement program. Action Plan for City's Recreation Programs _I Increa~e and amend ,the current use OfprogHlill evaluation forms 10 determine specific reasons why customers are dissatIsfied. It should be noted that participant eva]unllons for classes, tripS, events and athletic programs rate over 80%. Continue our recently strengthened partnership with Roanoke City Public Schools to revamp opportunilies for all middle school children during the after~school hours. Develop new partnerships with youth and adult service agencies 10 leverage resources for a diversity of marketscgments. Continue current plans for increasing the quality of our youth athletic coaches Continue the new system for communicating youth sp0l1s information to Ihe citizens 011 a regional basis. Expand upon our user groups and constituents by making our residents more aware of our programs and benefits ofparticipaliollthrough the implementation of the strategic marketing plan. Share our program successes by becoming more visible il1the media Enhance the use of non-participant survey methOdologies to improve program delivery and develop new oulcome based programs. Continue to implement the Comprehensive Master Plan tu develop new recreation facilities Improve the image of our program locations by enhancing the atmosphere of our facilities as well as the tuti conditions of our ball fields. 9 . Action Plan for Street Sweeping - The Sweeper Shop continues to suffer vacancies and an inability to attract qualified applicants. Staff will request Human Resources to evaluate this problem. The Division's website has been modi tied 10 allow residents to track street sweeping progress and schedules on-line. Evaluate the impact of only sweeping streets with curb and gutter and the impact of sweeping arterial streets less frequently in an effort to sweep all streets more frequently. Procure and deploy recently funded GPS enabled management system that is intended to increa<;e our ability to track street sweeping progress and productivity. . Due to heavy leaf drop in the fall, consider elimination of the late fall and carly winter residential street sweeping and modify schedules to focus on leaf collection on arterial streets and in storm drain sensitive areas, Action Plan for Street Paving, Maintenance, and Repair -- The Right of Way Excavation and Restoration Standard went into effect on 12/01/04 and is providing an enhanced level of inspection and an improved standard of repair for utility cuts. The pothole patching truck continues to be utilized in a wider range of weather conditions than previous methods. Even though the funds available for paving have increased, the increased cost of asphalt and milling continues to erode the Division's efforts to meet its goal of paving 57 lane miles per year. A multi-year plan to increase funding is in place. However, alternative pavement preservation techniques such as crack sealing and thin asphalt overlays will continue to be used, Advocate the collection of system wide inventory and condition information (currently included in the lTC's future projects list) in an effort to apply limited resources in the most efficient and effective manner possible. 10 . 1- . The Office of Communications continues to encourage citizens. the media, and businesses to sign up for the myRoanoke service. . The website is updated continually with new content, information, and successful applications such as Reverse 91 land eChecks. Continue to maintain production of the Roanoke Citizen Magazine. PLAY, and the municipal calendar. . Continue to promote City programs and services through RVTV and Inside Roanoke. . Will work more closely with City Departments to ensure that citizen communication is consistent, clear, concise, and of the highest quality. . Continue to promote City programs and events to local media, including increased promotions to smaller publications such as the Roanoke Tribune. Action Plan for Building Permits Application and Review Process 1- . The Building Inspections Division continues to use its comment cards in the Development Assistance Center to get first hand feedback trom customers using the DAC for plan/permit submission, etc. . In addition, the Division has recently implemented a combination permit system that will eliminate the need to obtain multiple permits for a construction project. This move along with reduction in permit fees is expected to streamline the application process. . With deployment of the primary plans examiner to Iraq last year. Building Inspections was required to adjust personnel to accommodate this function. With the plans reviewer back in place now. we have also made changes to allow backup support for this function to avoid delays in plan reviewer turn-around times. 11 . , I Next Steps .- . In January of this year, City staff provided Council with a comprehensive update of the action plans that were implemented as a result of the 2003 survey. . Staff is currently updating that document with all of the action plans that are being put in place due to this year's results. 12 (J'-"r- City of Roanoke 2005 Citizens Survey Summary of Results Prepared by: The Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research September 2005 Virginia 'I Tech Table of Contents Section Title Introduction 1 Methodology 2 Respondent Demographic Profile 3 Quality of Life 4 Services 5 Strategic Issues and Questions 6 Perceptions of Safety 7 Customer Service 8 Conclusion Appendix A Appendix B Appendix C Appendix D Appendix E Page Number I 2 8 10 13 18 22 23 26 2005 Survey Instrument Response Frequencies For Close-ended Survey Items Response Frequencies With City Service Items Tabulated Excluding Responses of "Not Familiar With Service" and "Don't Know" Responses For Open-ended Survey Items Cross-tabulations by Respondent Demographic Characteristics ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research Introduction The Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research (CSR) has been conducting citizens surveys with the citizens of the City of Roanoke since the year 2000, In 2005, CSR was once again asked to conduct a survey of citizens residing in the City of Roanoke, In previous years the CSR conducted the Roanoke Citizens Surveys in the fall. In 2005, due to a request by the City of Roanoke, the survey was conducted in late spring. The series of telephone surveys was designed to measure citizen opinions regarding municipal services and projects and to assess the strategic initiatives of the City of Roanoke government. Although different survey instruments were used each year for the survey administration, the surveys were designed such that comparability in citizen ratings of services and initiatives was possible across years, The overall objective of the survey process is to garner public input that will guide the use of City resources and foster continual improvement in the services provided to citizens. Presentations ofthe results from the survey are made by CSR each year to the Roanoke City Council and the City of Roanoke Department Leadership Team. For the administration of the 2005 Roanoke Citizens Survey, the CSR conducted a telephone survey of 505 residents of the City of Roanoke. This report summarizes the data collection procedures and results of the 2005 survey. Section 1 provides an overview of the survey instrument development and data collection procedures utilized by the CSR for the collection of the data. Section 2 provides a demographic profile of the survey respondents. 1 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~! Tech Center for Survey Research Section 3 describes the overall citizen ratings of quality oflife in the City of Roanoke across all survey years. Section 4 provides an overview of findings related to City services. Section 5 addresses survey results garnered from items addressing key strategic issues or strategic questions. Section 6 discusses survey findings regarding citizen feelings of safety in the City. Section 7 provides an overview of findings regarding City of Roanoke government employee customer service and government communication with citizens, Section 8 includes a concluding statement. The 2005 survey instrument is included in Appendix A. Appendix B provides tables of response frequencies to <;Ill close-ended survey items. Appendix C provides response frequencies with the City service rating items re-tabulated to exclude responses of "not familiar with service" and "don't know." Appendix D lists all responses provided by respondents to open-ended survey questions. Cross-tabulations of the survey data by respondent demographic characteristics are included in Appendix E. 1 Methodology Sampling Design A random-digit dialing (RDD) method was employed by the CSR for the administration of the 2005 survey. Both listed and unlisted telephone numbers were included in the sample for 2 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research this project. CSR worked with Survey Sampling, Inc. of Fairfield, CT, to define the parameters of the sample. The survey sample was randomly generated from numbers available to City of Roanoke residents. Because some exchanges border areas outside the City of Roanoke and because survey respondents sometimes report residing in a neighboring geographic area to the target area, a screener question was also included in the survey. The screener question confirmed City of Roanoke residence prior to beginning the survey with a potential respondent. Sample members reporting residence in a locality other than the City of Roanoke were eliminated from the eligible sample pool for calling. There were 299 sample members with this final call disposition code, When possible, this report provides comparisons by survey year for certain survey items. The City of Roanoke Citizen Survey conducted in 2000 was the only survey year in which a stratified sampling plan was utilized in which an equal number of sample members were selected for each quadrant in the City of Roanoke. The RDD method of sampling employed for the 2001- 2003 survey administrations are parallel to the sampling design used for the 2005 survey administration, When survey results are compared across survey years in this report, weighted data tabulations are used for the 2000 response tabulations in order to adjust for the equal number of sample members selected in each City quadrant. Specifically, because the actual population numbers of citizens residing in each City quadrant are not equal, the proportionate distribution of respondents is adjusted by respondent quadrant residence for the eligible 3 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research population proportions in the quadrant groups, The 2005 survey sample was chosen in an RDD fashion in order to provide a representative, random cross-section of adults residing throughout the City of Roanoke. Based on a total of 505 completed interviews, the survey has a sampling error of :t4.36 percent, Therefore, in 95 out of 100 surveys completed with this number of interviews using the same sampling methodology and parameters, the results obtained would fall in a range of :t4.36 percent of the results that would be achieved if interviews were completed with every potential respondent (in households with working telephones) residing in the City of Roanoke. Smaller sampling errors are present for items on which there is polarized response (e.g. 90 percent identical response on an item). Survey Instrument Design In order to achieve an optimal cooperation rate to the survey, all survey items were not asked in each survey administration year. However, the survey is designed to replicate many of the items asked in previous years in order to provide comparability across items. The 2005 survey instrument took 18.5 minutes on average to administer. A core group of survey items rating City services were retained for the 2005 administration of the survey. Key demographic items were also included in the 2005 survey instrument in order to gather basic information regarding the demographic characteristics of the survey respondents. 4 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research A number of new survey items were included for the first time in the 2005 survey. For example, new survey items were included regarding recycling, wireless Internet access capability in the downtown area, and the possibility of customer service information being offered in languages other than English, Survey items regarding services provided to citizens were grouped this year for the first time into a section of those services provided by the City and those provided by other government agencies and organizations, A primary difference in the 2005 survey and the survey administered in fall 2003 is the re- inclusion of a number of items addressing strategic issues that had been dropped in the 2003 survey (but administered in prior years), Although the 2005 survey included a large number of items addressing citizen perceptions of City services, respondents were not asked to rate the importance of each service in the 2005 survey as they were in 2003. A pre-test of the 2005 survey instrument was conducted in May of2005 in order to assess the length required to complete the interviews, and the wording of all survey items, The survey pre-test revealed the need to clarify the wording of some survey items. After minor wording adjustments to the survey instrument were approved by representatives of the City of Roanoke, final changes to the calling program were made by CSR. 5 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research Data Collection Procedures All telephone calls for the survey were made by CSR staff members utilizing a Computer-Assisted Telephone Interviewing (CA TI) system at the Blacksburg, Virginia location ofthe Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research. All calls were made during the period between May 23, 2005 and August 9, 2005, CSR wrote a calling program to be used with CAT! for administering the 2005 City of Roanoke Citizens Survey. The program provides scripted survey items, precludes out of range responses and facilitates real-time data entry of all responses gathered on the telephone. Each interviewer collecting data for the survey project participated in a project-specific training session for the project. All interviewers working on the project have worked on a variety of survey projects (indeed, many of the interviewers for this survey worked on administrations of the City of Roanoke survey in previous years) and have participated in multiple training sessions in both interviewing techniques and CA Tl. All interviews were monitored by a CSR Phonebank Supervisor in order to ensure accuracy and proper interviewing protocol. Clarifying notes for specific survey items appeared on the CAT! screens for interviewers to ensure that identical prompts were used for respondents requesting additional information about survey items or response categories. 6 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research CSR programmed all call scheduling such that each sample member remaining as a non- respondent was attempted to be reached at least six times at different times of day on different days of the week. A total of 2,346 telephone numbers were attempted during the survey administration. Sample members reporting residence in a locality other than the City of Roanoke were excluded from the eligible sample pool (N=299); likewise, respondents who indicated a language or hearing barrier such that they could not respond or request that another adult in the household respond, were also excluded from the eligible sample pool (N=40), Non-working telephone numbers (fax tones, out of service/disconnected numbers, automated disconnect services) were also excluded from the eligible sample pool (N=438). Non-residential numbers (N=280) were excluded from the eligible pool of sample members as well. After the elimination of all the ineligible records described above, the remaining number of eligible sample members was 1,289. A total of 505 interviews were completed for this study, Table 1 provides an overview of the final call dispositions for all sample members, Many sample members were never reached after numerous attempts and a final disposition of "no answer" was assigned, Therefore, the residency rate among these households is unknown, It may be assumed that a number of these households are indeed, ineligible sample members due to non-residence. CSR utilizes a standard conversion calling protocol in which all calls that are coded as "soft refusals" are re-attempted utilizing more senior interviewing staff. A call is coded as a "soft refusal" when the potential respondent refuses but does not indicate a reason for 7 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research exclusion from the calling pool (i.e, refusal due to illness, request to be removed from calling pool, etc.). Likewise, all telephone numbers deemed to be temporarily disconnected are attempted periodically throughout the duration of the study. Table 1 Total Initial Samnle 2,346 Ineligible Sample: Residence outside the City of Roanoke (299) Non-working telephone number (fax tones, out of service/disconnected numbers, automated disconnect services) (438) Non-residential telephone number (280) Hearinl!!lanl!ual!e barrier (40) Elil!ible Sample 1,289 Total Number of Comnleted Interviews 505 Non-respondents: Final disposition of no answer, busy, answering machine or callback after six attempts (437) Refusals (347) 784 2 Respondent Demographic Profile Four demographic variables were used in the 2005 survey to determine identifying demographic characteristics for each respondent. The four demographic items were: year of 8 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~! Tech Center for Survey Research birth, race, estimate of total family income in past year, and gender. The majority of respondents to the survey were 40 years of age or older (75%) and white (75%). The majority (61 %) also reported total family incomes ofless than $50,000 per year. More women than men responded to the survey (64% women and 36% men) -- this is a consistent finding in public opinion research using general population samples. Overall, the demographic characteristics of the 2005 survey respondents are similar to those among respondents in the prior survey years. However, there were some changes in the demographic characteristics of respondents since 2003, Specifically, the respondents to the 2005 survey were slightly older overall (75% were age 40 or over in 2005 and 66% were age 40 or over in 2003), With regard to respondent race, the demographic profiles are virtually identical across years (75% of respondents reported their race as "white" in 2005 and 76% reported having this racial designation in 2003). Fewer survey respondents reported a family income of less than $50,000 in 2005 than in 2003. Specifically, 61 percent of respondents in 2005 reported that they had a family income of less than $50,000 per year whereas in 2003,73 percent of respondents reported a family income ofless than $50,000 per year. Parallel to the 2003 survey, more women than men responded to the 2005 survey. In 2003 an identical percentage of respondents were women (64%) as in the 2005 survey. Similarly, an identical percentage of males (36%) responded in both the 2003 and 2005 surveys. 9 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research 3 Quality of Life in the City of Roanoke City of Roanoke citizens consistently give the City high ratings as a place to live, Indeed, in 2005, more than three-fourths of Roanoke citizens (77%) rated the City as either an 'excellent' or 'good' place to live. Figure 1 depicts the findings for this item by survey year. Three-fourths of Roanoke's citizens (75%) also rate the quality oflife in the City as either 'excellent' or 'good', An even greater number of Roanoke citizens rate the City's neighborhoods as good places to live. Specifically, 85 percent ofrespondents in 2005 agreed that Roanoke's neighborhoods are good 'places to live. Figure 1. Citizen Ratings of the City of Roanoke as a Place to Live 100 83.4 81 I 78.8 78.7 . 80 60 40 20 0 Excellent/Good 02000 .2001 rz:l2002 02003 .2005 0,2 1.2 0.6 0.2 0,6 Fair/Poor Don't know/Refuse 10 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research As depicted in Figure 2, citizen responses to the survey item asking respondents to rate the quality of life in the community have remained positive across all survey years. At least three-fourths of the citizens of Roanoke (75% in 2005) have rated the quality oflife in the community as either 'excellent' or 'good' each year this item was asked since 2000. The survey item regarding quality of life in the City was not asked in 2001. Figure 2. Citizen Ratings of Quality of Life in the City of Roanoke 100 79.4 79.3 77,2 80 60 40 20 0 . 2000 ~ 2002 lITI2003 1IIl2005 0.8 0.8 1.0 0.0 Excellent/Good Fair/Poor Don't know/Refuse As has been true in the previous survey years, there are some differences in citizen perceptions of quality of life in the City of Roanoke when viewed by certain respondent demographic characteristics. Roanoke residents with higher incomes rate the quality of life in the City more favorably than do those with lower incomes. Specifically, more than eight in ten 11 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research Roanoke citizens (86%) with incomes of $50,000 or more rate the City of Roanoke as either an 'excellent' or 'good' place to live and 69 percent of Roanoke residents with family incomes under $50,000 rate the City using the same categories. This difference was also evident in the prior survey administration years. Differences in perceptions of quality of life in the City of Roanoke were also evident when viewed by respondent age, Respondents who are 40 years old or more, tend to rate quality of life in the City more favorably than do those residents who are under 40 years of age. Specifically, more than seven in ten (77 percent) of respondents aged 40 years or more rate the quality oflife in the community as either 'excellent' or 'good' while 67 percent of respondents under age 40 chose these two response categories to rate the quality of life in Roanoke. This pattern of older respondents rating the quality of life in the City of Roanoke more favorably is evident across all survey years, However, it is important to note that it is still a substantial majority of respondents (even those younger than 40) who rated the quality oflife in Roanoke in favorable terms across all survey years. Quality of life in the City is also viewed differently according to the race of the respondent. Respondents who report their race as "white" are more likely to rate quality of life in the City of Roanoke as either 'excellent' or 'good' than are respondents who report their race as "black" or "African American", In the 2005 survey administration, 81 percent of "white" respondents rated 12 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research quality oflife in the City as 'excellent' or 'good' with 55 percent of "black" respondents using the same response categories to describe quality of life in the City. While perceptions among "white" respondents on this item were virtually identical to those in 2003, perceptions among respondents reporting their race as "black" are somewhat less favorable than they were in 2003 when 62 percent of these respondents rated quality oflife in the City as 'excellent' or 'good'. Similar to the findings in all prior survey years, there are less prominent differences in citizen ratings of quality of life in the City when the responses are viewed by respondent gender. This year 79 percent of male respondents and 73 percent of female respondents rate quality of life in the City as either' excellent' or 'good'. 4 City of Roanoke Services Citizens were slightly more satisfied in 2005 with the overall quality of services that the City of Roanoke government provides. Specifically, 86 percent of respondents reported that they are satisfied with the overall quality of services this year whereas, 85 percent of respondents reported they were satisfied in 2003. As is consistent with the survey findings from previous years, citizens in the City of Roanoke remain highly positive about most City services, Table 2 13 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research provides the ranking of all City services included in the 2005 survey based on the mean rating provided by respondents for each item. All responses of "not familiar with service," "don't know," or "refuse to answer" were excluded in the tabulation of the mean rank for each service. Tahle 2 l=Excellent 2=Good 3=Fair 4=Poor City Service Mean Rank Number Responses Emeraency and Rescue Services .. 1.63 '. . . 495 The 911 EmerQency Call Center 1.65 448 FireProtection Services ..... .1,66 , 489 Public Librarv Services 1,66 471 Weekly Trash Collection 1.77", . c502 City Beautification ProQrams 1,90 493 Police Services 1.92' 489 Pick-up of LarQe Items and Brush 1.97 497 RecVclil1Q Services ....;;., 2.00'- '. "462 ManaQement of EmerQency Situations/Natural Disasters 2.03 413 MowinQ and Maintenance of City Parks . ..... 2.06 .; <468 Cultural Activities and Events in the City 2,19 485 The City's Recreation ProQrams .,. 2.19 451 Current Level of Bagged Leaf Collection Service 2.20 468 The Convenience of Paying City Bills 2.22 .484 Removal of Snow and Ice From City Streets 2.24 502 Street Lighting ..... . ::1.24' . " .' 505 Cleanliness and Maintenance of Parks/Rec, Facilities in General 2.25 466 Mowing Right of Ways, Street Medians, and Roadsides 2.25 '.- 499"' Maintenance of City-Owned Buildings 2,26 457 Quality of CillicCenter Cultural Events 2.27 . , 462 Cleanliness and Maintenance of Community Recreation Centers 2.29 396 The MaintenanceofTrees Alona City Streets and Within Parks 2.31 491' The Quality of the City's New Sidewalk Construction 2,31 421 ~nimal Control 2.33 . 473 The BuildinQ Permits Application and Review Process 2.37 327 BuildinQlnspections 2.40 363- City Government Support for NeiQhborhood Organizations 2.40 426 14 Ciry of Roanoke 2005 Cirizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research Table 2 l=Excellent 2=Good 3=Fair 4=Poor City Service Mean Rank Number Responses Economic DeveloomentAssistance to Businesses 2.40 375 Qualitv of Civic Center Entertainment Events 2.40 472 Current Level of LooSe Leaf Collection Service 2.41 466 Citizens Gellina Information About Citv Services/Activities 2.44 476 trheQualitV afRQanoke's Athletic Fields and Facilities 2.46 455 City Parking Facilities 2.52 477 Effort$Ottlie'~tYto'lmprove QllalitY ofHousina inCitv .... 2,54 472 Street Sweeping 2.54 465 Reaulationand.zonil1g.for Land Use 2.56 395 City's Efforts To Promote Environmental Awareness To Citizens 2.57 457 Mall'lfenanCEl',dMlle'stOtm.Drainaoe.Svstems '" . ". 2.57 474 Maintenance of the City's Existina Sidewalks 2,59 475 ITransDortat1<m'.ijannll'la .PorTraffic . 2.60 463 Resoonse to Citizen Complaints and Reauests 2,62 477 ~vailabilitv'()f.Rllrkil'la .atthe 'ClvicCenter . 2.72 480 Enforcement of Properly Maintenance/Nuisance Codes 2.72 447 StreeIPavil'laiMallltEll'lallc::e'andReoair . . .... 2.77 502 Weed Abatement 2,86 458 The City services depicted in Table 2 are listed in descending rank order. According to the mean ranking of each service as depicted in Table 2, there were ten services that increased at least five positions in relative ranking since 2003 when compared to the other services included in the survey. There were no services that decreased five positions in ranking since the 2003 survey. The City services with at least a five position rank order increase since 2003 are listed in Table 3 in descending order ofrank increase. 15 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research Table 3. Ci Services with at Least a 5 Position Rank Order Increase Since 2003 Cit Parkin Facilities (From 47' to 34' ) Removal of Snow and Ice From City Streets (From 28' to 16 ) City Beautification Pro rams (From IS' to 6' ) Street Li htin (From 26' to 17 ) Economic Development Assistance to Businesses (From 37' to 29' ) Rec clin Services (From 17' to 9 ) City's Efforts to Promote Environmental Awareness to Citizens (From 45' to 38 ) Current Level of Bag ed Leaf Collection Service (From 215' to 14' ) Efforts ofthe City to 1m rove Quality of Housin in the Cit (From 42" to 35 ) Maintenance of City Owned Buildings (From 25 to 20' ) Table 4 depicts the ratings in 2005 of services offered by other governmental agencies in the City and their ratings in previous survey administration years. Responses of 'excellent' and , 'good' were combined for the table, All 'don't know/refuse' and 'not familiar' responses were excluded from the total number of responses for the percentage tabulations included in the table, Table 4. Citizen Ratine:s for Services Provided bv Autonomous Government Or anizations Bv Survev Year City Service 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 Health Department 83:3 81.2 81.5 82:2 78.0 Roanoke Public Schools 71.4 63.1 70.4 60.8 62.2 Sewer Services 78.8 73.2 88.2 81:6 74.5 Water Services 80.0 no 74.2 84.4 79.3 Vallev Metro Bus Transportation Services 72.6 no 86.8 60;4 79.7 Table 5 provides the combined percentage of 'excellent' and 'good' ratings for each City service included in the 2005 survey along with the citizen ratings the service received in the surveys since 2000, As noted in the table, all service items were not asked in each year. Items not asked in a given year appear as "NA." All 'don't know/refuse' and 'not familiar' responses 16 City of Roonoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ;r~! Tech Center for Survey Research were excluded from the total number of responses for the percentage tabulations included in the table. Table 5. Citizen Ratin!:s for Services Provided Directly by the City of Roanoke City Service 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 Animal Control.'. ... ;.. .. . 72.1 66.4 83.8 67.9 65.3 Availability of Parking at the Civic Center 51 ,7 57,9 66.2 50.9 45,2 BuildinlllnsPEictions '. 61.8 62.3 84.7 66.7 61\4 Citizens Getting Information About City Services/Activities 67.7 65,1 77.5 64.1 56.7 City Beautificatio,'fProaralTls .. .' ..... 81.4 79.3 88.3 75.6 81,9 City Government Support for Neighborhood Organizations 63.9 62.9 80,1 64.3 59,9 Cityparking;Facilit\esff; . .,::. ).;<...'. , 70>7. 46;0 56:3 46;0 54.1 .... City's Efforts To Promote Environmental Awareness To Citizens NA NA NA 50.2 50.8 Cleanliness'andMalntenance.ofCorrli'nul'lity Recreation Centers .NA NA NA 74.0 67,2 Cleanliness and Maintenance of Parks/Rec. Facilities in General 75.0 74.0 85,9 75.4 68.7 CulturaIA,ctivities<iOiliEvel'ltSil1tlle City / 69!8 70.2 85.7 75.5 70.5 Current Level of BaQQed Leaf Collection Service NA NA NA 74.9 71 ,6 Current'Level.ofl..oose1teafCcillectionService . .. Nt1\ N1\ .... NA . 65.6 60;5 Economic Development Assistance to Businesses 61 .5 62.1 82.5 59.7 58.9 Efforts of the Cit'ltollnp/,ove;QtialityofHousinQ in City NA' NA NA 52.4 50.0 EmerQencv and Rescue Services 93.6 91 .9 95,1 93.0 91.7 EriforcementOfPfOPertV/tvlainlel'lancelNuisance Codes NA NA NA '. 54.3 43.8 Fire Protection Services 95.4 93,3 94.8 95.1 92.2 Maintenanceof"CitV~()wned;Buildil'las .' 69:0 68;2 85.0 70.0 68;7 Maintenance of the City's Existino Sidewalks NA NA NA NA 49.3 Maintenanceot',tI.l8;Stormi.t:;)rainaQe;Svslems 66.0 63.1 85.7 63.5 52!7 Manaoement of Emeroencv Situations/Natural Disasters 81.9 80.0 91 .5 81 .8 80,1 MoWlnllandtvlalnlenanceofCitltPllrks NA NA' 93.6 81.9 7.9.3 Mowino Rioht ofWavs, Street Medians, and Roadsides NA NA 84.9 72,5 66.7 PiCk-UDOf l.arae;ltemsandBrush 63:4 68:2 .84.5 75;6" 76.5 Police Services 79,9 75,7 84.1 79,1 80.4 Public Libral\l sel\lices ." 84.9 91;7 95.3 92.6 9Cl.7 Quality of Civic Center Cultural Events NA NA 85.1 69.4 64.9 Quality'ofCivicCel1ter Entertainment Events NA NA 76.5 62.0 58;7 Recvclina Services 72.3 75.3 85.8 74.2 77.7 Regulation and Zoning for Land Use . 56.1 54.5 79,9 56.2 5Cl.1 17 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research Table 5. Citizen Ratin!!s for Services Provided Directlv bv the Citv of Roanoke Citv Service 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 Removal of Snow and Ice From City Streets 68.5 63.1. . 78.4 65.3 66.9 Response to Citizen Complaints and Requests 50.2 50.8 53.8 52.0 48.6 Street Liahtina 72.9 66.5 75.3 69.1 68.7 Street Paving, Maintenance and Repair 52,2 51.2 63.8 48,2 40.4 Street Sweeping 58.5 56.3 79.7 63.4 54.2 The 911 Emergency Call Center 93,0 87.9 95.6 94,1 91.5 Irhe Building Permits Aoolication and Review Process 64.8 61.4 86.3 ...69.3 62.1 The City's Recreation Programs 75.4 73.9 85.3 78.4. 69.0 Irhe Convenience of Pavina City Bills 75.9' 71.0 87.6 75.4 72.5 Irhe Maintenance of Trees Along City Streets and Within Parks NA NA NA NA 67.2 !The Quality of Roanoke's Athletic Fields and Facilities NA NA NA NA 57.8 The Quality of the City's New Sidewalk Construction NA NA NA NA 64.8 !Transportation Planning For Traffic 57.4 56,2 67.9 53.6 48.6 Weed Abatement 40.0 42.3 56.5 42,3 37,6 lWeeklv Trash Collection 87.7 76.4 90.0 84.6 85.9 5 City Strategic Issues and Questions The 2005 City of Roanoke Citizen Survey included a number of survey items addressing strategic issues and questions. Roanoke citizens remain quite positive regarding most of the strategic issues addressed in the survey. Although quite a few strategic issue survey items were also included in the 2000 and 2002 surveys, some were worded in a slightly different manner than in the 2005 version of the survey instrument. Most of the strategic issue survey items were 18 City of Roanoke 2005 Cirizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research cycled out of the 2001 and 2003 surveys to allow room for more detailed questions about specific services, Table 6 provides an overview of respondent agreement with the strategic issue/question survey items included in the 2005 survey with comparison to findings from the findings in prior survey years. The items in this table are presented in order of the highest to lowest agreement in 2005. However, there are some survey items in this section that used a response format other than the agree/disagree format. Items with asterisks used response categories other than the agree/disagree format. See Appendix A for the response categories for these items. Table 6. Citizen Responses Rel!ardin ~ Stratel ic Issues and Questions Survey Item 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 Roanoke's nei""\>orhooos are "ood o!actls.to IiVtl 83.2 NA 87.4 NA 85.3 Cltlan air and wattlr are valued by the Roanoke communitv NA NA 80,0 NA 8S.0 Downtl>WI1is\(,pr~tl<l~i<;<lesti11atio~offering NA 84.8 mix ofrestlll:uianWen~inmentJculfural attractions NA NA 82.4 City does good job offering multicultural events and attractions 8S.S NA 79,0 NA 79.6 Cityg()yerpm~~~~~i~99<I~Op.()f~istorical nreservatiownrptecti<in.i11the.Citv . 79.0 NA 78.8 NA 79.2 Neighborhoods provide needed businesses/services/activities NA NA 78.0 NA 78.0 T~~()n.\~~fc~rira1I()\VsgoOd.mix()f .transtX,l'tatioDQffiions . .... . 6S.0 NA 74.1 NA 77.6 Roanoke's greenway development effort IS a valuable asset to the City and its residents NA NA NA NA 7S,2 Th~isagoodDlixofbousingtypCls andaffordability in Roanoke 75.4 NA 77.0 NA 74.9 Roanoke's downtown IS (becoming) the region's economic en"ine and cultural center NA NA 73,S NA 71.9 Roanoke9~S"~()O<i.jobprpviding health/human services to citizens who need them 71.0 NA 72.S NA 70.9 19 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research Table 6. Citizen Resoonses Re\:ardin Strateeic Issues and Questions Survey Item 2000 2001 2002 2003 2005 Effectiveness of City government in meeting community needs' 79.4 80.4 74.3 68,8 69.3 The services provided by the City of Roanoke are worth the taxes oaid bv citizens 65.8 75.1 70.3 69.7 67.1 Educational resources and opportunities available to you and vour familv in Roanoke' 64.9 NA 64.3 NA 67.1 Roanoke does a good job of supporting existing businesses NA NA NA. NA. 66.9 City government does a good job of educating citizens about City services 74,3 NA 66.3 NA 65.9 (City)Community does good job promoting Roanoke as (top) tourist destination for outdoor/family vacations 74.3 NA 65.1 NA 63.4 City government does good job developing/redeveloping commercial and industrial areas in Roanoke 75,0 NA 63.7 NA 62.8 Roanoke actively expanding cooperative efforts with locall!.overnments in re"ion ' 58.9 71.1 53.7 64.0 62.6 City government performance is improving in Roanoke 72.9 75.9 63.1 61.5 61.2 Roanoke's air transportation system effectively links rel!;ion to maior national destinations NA NA 59.5 NA... 61.2 City officials actively involve citizens in business of City government 63.9 NA 65.5 NA 60,2 Roanoke does a good iob of attracting new businesses 65.0 NA NA NA 54.9 Roanoke does good job focusing on unique needs of vouths 56.3 NA 56.3 NA 49.7 How much of the time do you think you can trust the City to do what is rildlt' NA NA 49.3 47.9 45.1 City government's efforts to improve the local economv' 46.9 NA 40,5 NA 42.0 City officials do good job bringing higher paying jobs to City 53.2 NA 44.1 NA 38.8 Each year, the City of Roanoke Citizens Survey instrument included some items that allowed more specific information to be gathered regarding specific services or initiatives. Likewise, items were added each year to explore potential services or initiatives or new 20 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research programs. The 2005 survey instrument included a number of specific questions about recycling in the City. Specifically, citizens were asked if they currently recycled in the City, to which 60 percent of citizens reported that they do currently recycle in the City, Additionally, a number of questions regarding the specific types of items recycled by those respondents reporting that they currently recycle were added to the survey this year, Among the items recycled by Roanoke citizens who practice recycling are: newspapers (76%), junk mail (61 %), magazines (65%), computer paper (35%), cardboard (64%), clear glass bottles (76%), plastic (81 %), and cans (78%), Another new item in the 2005 survey asked citizens if they were aware that the Roanoke Civic Center offers free shuttle bus service to supplement its parking for large events. A full 83 percent of citizens responded affirmatively to this question. Slightly less than one quarter of these citizens (24%) have used this service. The 2005 survey instrument also included an item which assessed the extent to which Roanoke citizens are familiar with the free wireless Internet access capability in the downtown area and in the library. Almost six in ten citizens (59%) reported that they were aware that the City has free wireless Internet access capability in these areas. Indeed, 29 percent of citizens have used this service. 21 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research For the first time in the 2005 survey, citizens were asked if it would benefit them if City of Roanoke customer service information offered to citizens at the library and other City locations were available in another language, Almost one third (29%) of citizens responded that this service would benefit them. These citizens were then asked to specify in which languages they would like to see the information offered. The languages specified by citizens are as follows: Spanish (78%), Vietnamese (21 %), other languages (24%, specific responses regarding other languages specified are provided in Appendix D). 6 Citizen Perceptions of Safety Residents of the City of Roanoke have consistently rated public safety services such as police, fire, and emergency medical services favorably. Survey respondents expressed different perceptions of safety according to the location within the City being addressed in the survey item. Figure 3 depicts the findings for the survey items regarding feelings of safety since 2003, As depicted in Figure 3, perceptions of safety in the City among Roanoke's citizens have become even more favorable since 2003, 22 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research Figure 3. Feelings of Safety in Roanoke: 2003 and 2005 Downtown 1_2005 I L 02003 I Neighborhood Parks/Rec. Facilities Civic Center Parking Lot City Parking Garages 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40,0 50.0 60.0 70,0 80.0 Percentage Reporting 'Very' or 'Somewhat' Safe 90.0 100~ 7 City Government Customer Service A variety of items measuring citizen ratings of City government employee customer service are included in the survey. While citizen ratings of City government employee customer service have always been positive, in 2005 citizens rated the City's customer service more favorably than in 2003 on five out of seven aspects, The two aspects that did not receive higher ratings this year were virtually identical (within two percentage points) to the ratings received in 2003. Among the customer service-related survey items posed to respondents each year, citizens 23 City of Roanoke 2005 Cilizen Survey Summary of Results ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research seem to be the least satisfied with the availability of parking at City government offices. This is again the finding in 2005. Table 7 provides an overview of the survey findings from the customer service items included in the survey, Table 7 Citizen Agreement on Selected Aspects of Customer Service in the City 'Stron I A ree' and 'Somewhat A ree' Surve Item Citygovermnentemployees are generally friendly, courteous, and hel fill Cit overnment em 10 ees treat citizens fair! Ci overnmentofficeshours are convenient Cit overnment office locations are convenient Ci overnmelltem 1 ees l'ovide rom t service It is easy to contact the appropriate City government office when ou need a articular service or have a uestion Convellientpa,rtcitigatCitygovernment offic.es is enerallavllilable Ci olite and res onSlve 2000 86.8 78.7 75.6 69.3 .74;4 72.3 39;4 NA City Government Communication with Citizens 2001 87.9 79;4 77.8 75.2 77.2 70,9 43.6 NA 2002 85;4 81.6 79.0 73,5 77;4 70.1 43.1 79.6 2003 86.2 80.0 75.6 73.5 73.3 68,2 41.5 73.3 The 2005 survey instrument included an item regarding the method of communication citizens prefer when receiving information from the City. This item has been included in the survey instrument since 2001. The responses to this item regarding preferred methods of communication were as follows: I) a magazine mailed by the City several times a year (42%); an email sent periodically by the City (10%); visiting the City's web site (10%); watching the City's TV shows on RVTV Channel 3 (18%); reading the newspaper, listening to radio news, or watching news (64%); and other means of communication (6%, other responses specified in 24 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results 2005 88.9 81.0 772 72.9 78.0 66.7 45.9 75.4 ~ I ~r~~ Tech Center for Survey Research Appendix D). Figure 4 depicts the preferred methods of communication among citizens for receiving information from the City. Figure 4. Citizens' Preferred Methods of Communication for Receiving Information From the City 2003-2005 100 80 60 40 20 o El2003 112005 67.8 63.6 34.8 3.7 5.7 Magazine E-mail City's Web- site RVTV News (Radio, Newspaper, Television) Other Many of Roanoke's citizens have regular access to the Internet (65% up from 59% in 2003), and three-fourths (75%) of those with Internet access visit the City's web site. Many more citizens reported receiving the City's magazine called Roanoke Citizen at their home this year (58% up from 37% in 2003), Among those who reported receiving the magazine, more than three-fourths (78%) report that they read at least some of the articles in the magazine. Indeed, about one-third (28%) say they read the magazine cover to cover. The majority of survey respondents (64%) indicated that they watch the City's Inside Roanoke television show at least a few times a year (with 41 % of those watching the show at least once a month). 25 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results ~I CSR Virginia Tech Center for Snrvey Research 8 Conclusion Now with five years of data from the Roanoke Citizens Surveys, some strong trends in the perceptions and opinions of Roanoke's citizens are visible, Surveys in future years will continue to assess the satisfaction of citizens with City services along with citizen opinions on the direction of City programs and initiatives. The Virginia Tech Center for Survey Research appreciates having had the opportunity to work with the City of Roanoke on the collection of this important survey data. Staff members in the Office ofthe City Manager have served as valuable liaisons in the completion of this study in all survey years. A disk containing the SPSS dataset from which the 2005 data in this summary report were derived accompanies this report, All variable and value labels are provided on the SPSS dataset. An electronic copy of this report summary is also included on the disk. All electronic files of the survey instrument, report, data, html output and PowerPoint presentations of the data are the property of the City of Roanoke. However, the Center for Survey Research will retain copies of all project materials for a period of at least one year. No information from this survey will be shared by the CSR with anyone other than project team members from the Office of the City of Roanoke Manager without the express permission of that office. 26 City of Roanoke 2005 Citizen Survey Summary of Results Appendix A 2005 Survey Instrument CITY OF ROANOKE CITIZENS SURVEY 2004-2005 CALL RECORD Record Number Phone Number .FIPS Respondent Number Status . Priority Interviewer ID Number of Attempts Last Contact Last Disposition Callback Dateffime Interviewer Message Current Begin Dateffime Current End Dateffime Final Call Disposition Answering Machine Automated Refusal Service Busy Signal Callback Complete ComputerlFax Tone Disconnected/Changed Hard Refusal Hearing Barrier Incomplete Language Barrier No Eligible Adult No Answer ;Non-residential Number Not Roanoke Citizen Soft Refusal Temporarily Disconnected A. Hello, my name is and I'm calling from Virginia Tech on behalf of the City of Roanoke. We are interested in your opinions about important City issues, services, and programs. [IF NECESSARY: I need to speak with an adult in your household (AGE 18 OR OLDER). Would that be you?] [GO TO QI] YES I NO 2 B. May I speak with that person? [REPEAT FIRST TWO SENTENCES OF A, GO TO QI] YES I NO 2 C. When may I call back to speak with (him/her)? D. Just so that I will know whom to ask for, what is (his/her) first name? Q1. First, do you live in the City of Roanoke? YES [GO TO Q2] I NO 2 DKlRF 3 Endl: I'm sorry, our study requires that we speak only with individuals living in the City of Roanoke. Thank you very much for your time. Al Q2. How would you rate Roanoke as a place to live today, in 2005? Would you say excellent, good, fair or poor? EXCELLENT 1 GOOD 2 FAIR 3 POOR 4 DKlRF 5 Q3. How would you rate the City government's efforts to improve the local economy? EXCELLENT 1 GOOD 2 FAIR 3 POOR 4 DKlRF 5 Q4. How would you rate the educational resources and opportunities available to you and your family in Roanoke? EXCELLENT 1 GOOD 2 FAIR 3 POOR 4 DKlRF 5 Q5. How would you rate the quality of life in the community? EXCELLENT 1 GOOD 2 FAIR 3 POOR 4 DK/RF 5 Q6. How would you rate the effectiveness of the City of Roanoke government in meeting community needs? Would you say very effective, somewhat effective, somewhat ineffective or not at all effective? VERY EFFECTNE 1 SOMEWHA T EFFECTNE 2 SOMEWHAT INEFFECTIVE 3 NOT AT ALL EFFECTNE 4 DK/RF 5 Q7. Now I'm going to ask your opinion about some issues that are important in the City of Roanoke. For each statement please indicate your level of agreement. a. The first statement is...Roanoke City officials aClively involve citizens in the business of City government. Do you... strongly agree? somewhat agree? somewhat disagree? strongly disagree? DK RF A2 b. City government perfonnance is STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHA T STRONGLY improving in Roanoke. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF c. Roanoke City officials do a good job of bringing higher STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY paying jobs to the City. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF d. There is a good mix of housing types and affordability in STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHAT STRONGLY Roanoke. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF e. Roanoke's transportation system allows for a good mix of transportation options like auto, public transit, pedestrian, and STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHAT STRONGLY bicycle traffic. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF f Roanoke's neighborhoods are STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY good places to live. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF g. Overall, Roanoke's neighborhoods provide the necessary businesses, community services, and STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY activities that people need. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF h. Roanoke does a good job of focusing on the unique needs of STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY youths. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF i, The City does a good job of offering multicultural events STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY and attractions. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF J. Roanoke does a good job of STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY supporting existing businesses. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF k. Roanoke does a good job of STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHA T STRONGLY attracting new businesses. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF I. Clean air and water are valued STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHA T STRONGLY by the Roanoke community. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF m. The services provided by the City of Roanoke are worth the STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY taxes paid by its citizens. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF n. Roanoke is actively expanding cooperative efforts with other STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY local governments in our region. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF o. Roanoke's air transportation system effectively links the region to major national STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHA T STRONGLY destinations. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF p, Roanoke's greenway development effort is a valuable asset to the City and its STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHA T STRONGLY residents. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF q. City government does a good job of educating cilizens about STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY City services. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF r. Roanoke's downtown is the region's economic engine and STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHAT STRONGLY cultural center. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE OK RF A3 s. The community does a good job of promoting Roanoke as a tourisl destination for outdoor STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHA T STRONGLY and family vacations. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF t. Roanoke does a good job of providing health and human services to its citizens who need STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY them. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF u. City government does a good job developing or redeveloping commercial and industrial areas STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY in Roanoke. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF v. City governmenl does a good job of historical preservalion STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY and protection in the City. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF w, Downtown is a vibrant and dynamic destination offering a good mix of restaurants, entertainment, and cultural STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHAT STRONGLY attractions. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF Q8. How much of the time do you think you can trust the City to do what is right? Would you say, just about always, most of the time, only some ofthe time or never? JUST ABOUT AL WAYS 1 MOST OF THE TIME 2 ONLY SOME OF THE TIME 3 NEVER 4 DK/RF 5 Q9. Now I'm going to ask your opinion about some services offered by the City of Roanoke. Using the terms excellent, good, fair and poor, please tell me how you would rate each service. a, First, response to citizen complaints and requests? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF b. fire protection services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF c. emergency and rescue services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF d. weekly trash collection? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF e. pick-up ofIarge trash items and brush? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF f. recycling? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF g. police services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF h. public library services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF I. City parking facilities? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF J. management of emergency situations like natural disasters? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF k. mowing right of ways, street medians, and roadsides? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF I. removal of snow and ice from City streets? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF m. street lighting? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF n. street paving, maintenance and repair? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF A4 o. street sweeping? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF p, the 911 emergency call center? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF q, transportation planning for traffic? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF r. the quality of the City's new sidewalk construction? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF s. the maintenance of the City's existing sidewalks? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF t. the City's recreation programs? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF u. the quality of Roanoke's athlelic fields and facilities? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF v. cleanliness and maintenance of community recreation centers such as Eureka Park, Grandin Court, and Garden City? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF w. cleanliness and maintenance of parks and recreation facilities in general? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF x. cultural activities and events in the City? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF y, mowing and maintenance of City parks? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF z. the maintenance of trees along City streets and within parks? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF aa. City beautification programs, such as the hanging flower baskels and landscaping along City roads and community gateways? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF bb. animal control? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF cc. regulalion and zoning for land use? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF dd. weed abatement, or the cutting of weeds on vacant lots? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF ee. the enforcement of property maintenance codes and other nuisance codes? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF ff. efforts of the City to improve the quality of housing in the City? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF gg. economic development assistance to businesses? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKIRF hh, citizens getting information about City services and activities? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF II. the convenience of paying City bills? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF jj. maintenance of the storm drainage systems? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF Ide the City's efforts to promote environmental awareness to citizens? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF 11. maintenance of City-owned buildings? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF mm. building inspections? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF nn. the building permits application and review process? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF 00. City government support of neighborhood organizations? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF pp. the availability of parking at the Roanoke Civic Center? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF AS qq. the quality of entertainment events like concerts and circuses offered by the Civic Center? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF rr. the quality of cultural evenls like musicals and plays offered by the Civic Center? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF ss. the currenllevel of bagged leaf collection service? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKlRF It. the current level ofloose leaf collection service? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF QI0. Now I would like to ask your opinion about some services offered by other government agencies within the City. a. First, how would you rate the Health Departmem? Would you say or it is... excellent? good? [air? poor? NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF b. Roanoke Public Schools? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF c. Sewer services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DKlRF d. Water services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF e. Valley Metro bus transportation services? EXCELLENT GOOD FAIR POOR NOT FAMILIAR DK/RF Ql1. Have you or any member of your household participated in auy parks and recreational programs during the las~ 12 mouths? YES I NO 2 DKlRF 3 Q12. Do you curreutly recycle with the City of Roanoke? YES [GO TO Q14] 1 NO 2 DKlRF 3 Q13. Why do you uot recycle with the City of Roanoke currently? Don't Know = "DK", Refuse = "RF" GO TO Q15 Q14. Do you recycle... a, b. newspapers? junk mail? magazines? computer paper? card board? clear glass bottles? plastic? cans? YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO DK/RF DKlRF DKlRF DKlRF DKlRF DKlRF DKlRF DKlRF c. d. e, [, g. h. A6 Q15.. Are you aware that the Roauoke Civic Center offers free shuttle bus service to supplement its parking for large events? YES I NO [GOTOQI7] 2 DK/RF [GO TO Q17] 3 Q16. Have you used this service? YES I NO 2 DK/RF 3 Q17. Are you aware that the City has free wireless Internet access capability in the downtown area and in the library? YES 1 NO [GOTOQI9] 2 DK/RF [GOTOQI9] 3 Q18. Have you used this service? YES 1 NO 2 DK/RF 3 Q19. Would it benefit you if City of Roanoke customer service information offered to citizens at the library and other City locations were available in another language such as Spanish, or Vietnamese? YES 1 NO [GO TO Q21] 2 DK/RF [GO TO Q21] 3 Q20. In what additional languages would you like information to be offered? CHOOSE ALL THAT APPLY SPANISH I VIETNAMESE 2 OTHER (Please specify: ) 3 DK/RF 4 A7 Q21. How satisfied are you with the overall quality of services that the City of Roanoke government provides? Would you say very satisfied, somewhat satisfied, somewhat dissatisfied, or very dissatisfied? VERY SATISFIED 1 SOMEWHAT SATISFIED 2 SOMEWHAT DISSATISFIED 3 VERY DISSATISFIED 4 DK/RF 5 Q22. Now I'm going to ask you about your feelings of safety in the City of Roanoke. How safe do you feel in your neighborhood? Would you say you feel very safe, somewhat safe, somewhat unsafe, or not at all safe? IF ASKED ABOUT DAYTIME VS. EVENING PERCEPTIONS OF SAFETY: "We're interested in your overall perceptions of safety in your neighborhood." VERY SAFE I SOMEWHAT SAFE 2 SOMEWHAT UNSAFE 3 NOT AT ALL SAFE 4 DK/RF 5 Q23. How safe do you feel in the park or recreation facility closest to your home? IF ASKED ABOUT DAYTIME VS. EVENING PERCEPTIONS OF SAFETY: "We're interested in your overall perceptions of safety In the park or recreation facility closest to your home." VERY SAFE 1 SOMEWHAT SAFE 2 SOMEWHAT UNSAFE 3 NOT AT ALL SAFE 4 DK/DON'T GO THERE 5 RF6 Q24. How safe do you feel downtown? IF ASKED ABOUT DAYTIME VS. EVENING PERCEPTIONS OF SAFETY: "We're interested in your overall perceptions of safety downtown." VERY SAFE 1 SOMEWHAT SAFE 2 SOMEWHAT UNSAFE 3 NOT AT ALL SAFE 4 OK/DON'T GO THERE 5 RF6 Q25. How safe do you feel in the City's parking garages? IF ASKED ;\BOUT DAYTIME VS. EVENING PERCEPTIONS OF SAFETY: "We're interested in your overall perceptions of safety in the City's parking garages." VERY SAFE 1 SOMEWHAT SAFE 2 SOMEWHAT UNSAFE 3 NOT AT ALL SAFE 4 OK/DON'T GO THERE 5 RF6 A8 Q26. How safe do you feel at the Civic Center parking lot? VERY SAFE 1 SOMEWHAT SAFE 2 SOMEWHAT UNSAFE 3 NOT AT ALL SAFE 4 DK/DON'T GO THERE 5 RF 6 Q27. Do you have regular access to the Iuternet? YES 1 NO [GO TO Q30] 2 DK/RF [GO TO Q30] 3 Q28. On average, how ofteu do you visit the City's web site? Would you say you go there... at least once a day, 1 at least once a week, 2 at least once a month 3 less than once a month? 4 or never? [GO TO Q30] 5 DK/RF 6 Q29. Are there any services that are not curreutly offered that you would like to see available on the City's web site? YES (Please specify: ) I NO 2 DK/RF 3 Q30. Do you receive the City's magazine called Roanoke Citizen, at your home? YES 1 NO [GO TO Q32] 2 DK/RF [GO TO Q32] 3 Q3I. When you receive the magazine would you say you usually... read it cover to cover, 1 scan the articles and read the ones that interest you, 2 flip through it but don't read many articles, 3 or don't read it at all? 4 DK/RF 5 A9 Q32. On average, how often do you watch the City's Inside Roanoke television show on Roanoke Valley Television Channel3? Would you say... at least once a week, I at least once a month, 2 a few times a year, 3 or never 4 NOT FAMILIAR WITH IT/DK/RF 5 Q33. What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government? CHOOSE ALL THAT APPLY through a magazine mailed to you by the City several times a year? I through an e-mail sent to you periodically by the City? 2 by visiting the City's web site yourself? 3 by watching the City's TV shows on RVTV Channel3? 4 by reading the newspaper, listening to radio news, or watching news? 5 or some other way? (Please specity: ) 6 DK/RF 7 Q34. Now I'd like to ask you a few questions about the City's customer service in general. Please tell me your level of agreement with each statement. a. City government employees are generally friendly, courteous, strongly somewhat somewhat strongly and helpful. Do you" , agree? agree? disagree? disagree? DK RF b. City parking facility staff are STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY generally polite and responsive. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF c, It is easy to contact the appropriate City government office when you need a particular service or have a STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY question. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF d, City government employees STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY provide prompt service. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF e. City government employees STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY treat citizens fairly, AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF f. Convenient parking at City government offices is generally STRONGLY SOMEWHA T SOMEWHAT STRONGLY available, AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF g. City government office STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY locations are convenient. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF h. City government office hours STRONGLY SOMEWHAT SOMEWHAT STRONGLY are convenient. AGREE AGREE DISAGREE DISAGREE DK RF Q35. Finally, just a few questions about you. In what year were you born? 19 DK/RF 1999 AIO Q36. Do you consider yourself to be White, African American or Black, Asian, Hispanic or Latino, or a member of some other group? WHITE] AFRICAN AMERICAN (BLACK) 2 ASIAN 3 HISPANIC (LA TINa) 4 (SPECIFY: ) OTHER 5 DK/RF 6 Q37. I'm going to read several income brackets to you. Please stop me when I get to the bracket that includes your best estimate of your total family income before taxes last year. less than $15,000? 1 between $15,000 and less than $25,000? 2 between $25,000 and less than $35,000? 3 between $35,000 and less than $50,000? 4 between $50,000 and less than $75,000 5 between $75,000 and $100,000 6 over $100,000 7 DK/RF 8 Q38. GENDER IF: Y{)U CAN~T- TELL THE GENDER OF THE RESPO~'f. ~~: "J!lSt.onemore question: our sur.iey reqmresthat I aSk if you are male or female." , MALE 1 FEMALE 2 Those are all of my questions. Thank you for your help with onr study. Have a nice day/evening. INTERVIE~~,IJ<' ASKED: "This study is being conducted with support from the Office of the City Manager. Tl1,e!7$Uitswillbe reported to<lityCouncil. If you have any questions about the purpose of the stUdy, you can call,~G~ representative at 853_1643. Thank you again for your help with our stUdy." All Appendix B Response Frequencies for Close-ended Survey Items q1 First, do you live in the City of Roanoke? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 505 100.0 100.0 100.0 q2 How would you rate Roanoke as a place to live today, in 2005? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 150 29.7 29.7 29.7 Good 238 47.1 47.1 76.8 Fair 88 17.4 17.4 94.3 Poor 26 5.1 5.1 99.4 DKlRF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q3 How would you rate the City government's efforts to improve the local economy? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 21 4.2 4.2 4.2 Good 191 37.8 37.8 42.0 Fair 183 36.2 36.2 78.2 Poor 80 15.8 15.8 94.1 DKlRF 30 5.9 5.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q4 How would you rate the educational resources and opportunities available to you and your family in Roanoke? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 94 18.6 18.6 18.6 Good 245 48.5 48.5 67.1 Fair 100 19.8 19.8 86.9 Poor 34 6.7 6.7 93.7 DKlRF 32 6.3 6.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q5 How would you rate the quality of life in the community? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 109 21.6 21.6 21.6 Good 270 53.5 53.5 75.0 Fair 100 19.8 19.8 94.9 Poor 26 5.1 5.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 61 q6 How would you rate the effectiveness of the City of Roanoke government in meeting community needs? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Effective 42 8.3 8.3 8.3 Somewhat Effective 308 61.0 61.0 69.3 Somewhat Ineffective 93 18.4 18.4 87.7 Not at all Effective 47 9.3 9.3 97.0 DK/RF 15 3.0 3.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7a Agreement: Roanoke City officials actively involve citizens in the business of City government. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 30 5.9 5.9 5.9 Somewhat Agree 274 54.3 54.3 60.2 Somewhat Disagree 106 21.0 21.0 81.2 Strongly Disagree 62 12.3 12.3 93.5 DK 33 6.5 6.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7b Agreement: City government performance is improving in Roanoke. , Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 57 11.3 11.3 11.3 Somewhat Agree 252 49.9 49.9 61.2 Somewhat Disagree 112 22.2 22.2 83.4 Strongly Disagree 61 12.1 12.1 95.4 DK 23 4.6 4.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7c Agreement: Roanoke City officials do a good job of bringing higher paying jobs to the City. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 36 7.1 7.1 7.1 Somewhat Agree 160 31.7 31.7 38.8 Somewhat Disagree 134 26.5 26.5 65.3 Strongly Disagree 134 26.5 26.5 91.9 DK 41 8.1 8.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 82 q7d Agreement: There is a good mix of housing types and affordability in Roanoke. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 171 33.9 33.9 33.9 Somewhat Agree 207 41.0 41.0 74.9 Somewhat Disagree 63 12.5 12.5 87.3 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 96.8 DK 15 3.0 3.0 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7e Agreement: Roanoke's transportation system allows for a good mix of transportation options like auto, public transit, pedestrian, and bicycle traffic. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 176 34.9 34.9 34.9 Somewhat Agree 216 42.8 42.8 77.6 Somewhat Disagree 60 11.9 11.9 89.5 Strongly Disagree 42 8.3 8.3 97.8 DK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7f Agreement: Roanoke's neighborhoods are good places to live. Cumulative F reauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 187 37.0 37.0 37.0 Somewhat Agree 244 48.3 48.3 85.3 Somewhat Disagree 43 8.5 8.5 93.9 Strongly Disagree 30 5.9 5.9 99.8 DK 1 .2 2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7g Agreement: Overall, Roanoke's neighborhoods provide the necessary businesses, community services, and activities that people need. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 153 30.3 30.3 30.3 Somewhat Agree 241 47.7 47.7 78.0 Somewhat Disagree 55 10.9 10.9 88.9 Strongly Disagree 52 10.3 10.3 99.2 DK 4 .8 .8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 83 q7h Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of focusing on the unique needs of youths. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 63 12.5 12.5 12.5 Somewhat Agree 188 37.2 37.2 49.7 Somewhat Disagree 92 18.2 18.2 67.9 Strongly Disagree 105 20.8 20.8 88.7 DK 57 11.3 11.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7i Agreement: The City does a good job of offering multicultural events and attractions. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 180 35,6 35.6 35.6 Somewhat Agree 222 44.0 44.0 79.6 Somewhat Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 89.1 Strongly Disagree 41 8.1 8.1 97.2 DK 14 2.8 2.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7j Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of supporting existing businesses. , Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 90 17.8 17.8 17.8 Somewhat Agree 248 49.1 49.1 66.9 Somewhat Disagree 62 12.3 12.3 79.2 Strongly Disagree 39 7.7 7.7 86.9 DK 66 13.1 13.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7k Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of attracting new businesses. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 75 14.9 14.9 14.9 Somewhat Agree 202 40.0 40.0 54.9 Somewhat Disagree 109 21.6 21.6 76.4 Strongly Disagree 77 15.2 15.2 91.7 DK 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 84 q71 Agreement: Clean air and water are valued by the Roanoke community. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 220 43.6 43.6 43.6 Somewhat Agree 209 41.4 41.4 85.0 Somewhat Disagree 41 8.1 8.1 93.1 Strongly Disagree 22 4.4 4.4 97.4 DK 13 2.6 2.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7m Agreement: The services provided by the City of Roanoke are worth the taxes paid by its citizens. Cumulative Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 120 23.8 23.8 23.8 Somewhat Agree 219 43.4 43.4 67.1 Somewhat Disagree 65 12.9 12.9 80.0 Strongly Disagree 86 17.0 17.0 97.0 DK 14 2.8 2.8 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7n Agreement: Roanoke is actively expanding cooperative efforts with other local governments in our region. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid StrQngly Agree 80 15.8 15.8 15.8 Somewhat Agree 236 46.7 46.7 62.6 Somewhat Disagree 59 11.7 11.7 74.3 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 83.8 DK 82 16.2 16.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q70 Agreement: Roanoke's air transportation system effectively links the region to major national destinations. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 116 23.0 23.0 23.0 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 61.2 Somewhat Disagree 76 15.0 15.0 76.2 Strongly Disagree 76 15.0 15.0 91.3 DK 44 8.7 8.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 85 q7p Agreement: Roanoke's greenway development effort is a valuable asset to the City and its residents. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 187 37.0 37.0 37.0 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 75.2 Somewhat Disagree 37 7.3 7.3 82.6 Strongly Disagree 26 5.1 5.1 87.7 OK 61 12.1 12.1 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7q Agreement: City government does a good job of educating citizens about City services. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 108 21.4 21.4 21.4 Somewhat Agree 225 44.6 44.6 65.9 Somewhat Disagree 83 16.4 16.4 82.4 Strongly Disagree 78 15.4 15.4 97.8 OK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7r Agreement: Roanoke's downtown is the region's economic engine and cultural center. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 164 32.5 32.5 32.5 Somewhat Agree 199 39.4 39.4 71.9 Somewhat Disagree 72 14.3 14.3 86.1 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 95.6 OK 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7s Agreement: The community does a good job of promoting Roanoke as a tourist destination for outdoor and family vacations. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 127 25.1 25.1 25.1 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 63.4 Somewhat Disagree 96 19.0 19.0 82.4 Strongly Disagree 72 14.3 14.3 96.6 OK 17 3.4 3.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 86 q7t Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of providing health and human services to its citizens who need them. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 145 28.7 28.7 28.7 Somewhat Agree 213 42.2 42.2 70.9 Somewhat Disagree 47 9.3 9.3 80.2 Strongly Disagree 58 11.5 11.5 91.7 DK 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7u Agreement: City government does a good job developing or redeveloping commercial and industrial areas in Roanoke. Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 73 14.5 14.5 14.5 Somewhat Agree 244 48.3 48.3 62.8 Somewhat Disagree 83 16.4 16.4 79.2 Strongly Disagree 63 12.5 12.5 91.7 DK 41 8.1 8.1 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7v Agreement: City government does a good job of historical preservation and protection in the City. Cumulative F reauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 143 28.3 28.4 28.4 Somewhat Agree 256 50.7 50.8 79.2 Somewhat Disagree 38 7.5 7.5 86.7 Strongly Disagree 51 10.1 10.1 96.8 DK 15 3.0 3.0 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 504 99.8 100.0 Missing System 1 .2 Total 505 100.0 q7w Agreement: Downtown is a vibrant and dynamic destination offering a good mix of restaurants, entertainment, and cultural attractions. Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 229 45,3 45.3 45.3 Somewhat Agree 187 37.0 37.0 82.4 Somewhat Disagree 44 8.7 8.7 91.1 Strongly Disagree 34 6.7 6.7 97.8 DK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 87 q8 How much of the time do you think you can trust the City to do what is right? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Just About Aiways 21 4.2 4.2 4.2 Most of the Time 207 41.0 41.0 45.1 Only Some of the Time 248 49.1 49.1 94.3 Never 28 5.5 5.5 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9a Services: response to citizen complaints and requests? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Vaiid Excellent 29 5.7 5.7 5.7 Goad 203 40.2 40.2 45.9 Fair 164 32.5 32.5 78.4 Poor 81 16.0 16.0 94.5 Not Familiar 21 4.2 4.2 98.6 DKlRF 7 1.4 1.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9b Services: fire protection services? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Vaiid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 211 41.8 41.8 41.8 Goad 240 47.5 47.5 89.3 Fair 32 6.3 6.3 95.6 Poor 6 1.2 1.2 96.8 Not Familiar 13 2.6 2.6 99.4 DKlRF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9c Services: emergency and rescue services? Cumuiative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 230 45.5 45.5 45.5 Good 224 44.4 44.4 89.9 Fair 35 6.9 6.9 96.8 Poor 6 1.2 1.2 98.0 Not Familiar 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 88 q9d Services: weekly trash collection? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 207 41.0 41.0 41.0 Goad 224 44.4 44.4 85.3 Fair 49 9.7 9.7 95.0 Poor 22 4.4 4.4 99.4 Not Familiar 2 .4 .4 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 qge Services: pick-up of large trash items and brush? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 181 35.8 35.8 35.8 Good 199 39.4 39.4 75.2 Fair 68 13.5 13.5 88.7 Poor 49 9.7 9.7 98.4 Not Familiar 3 .6 .6 99.0 DKlRF 5 1.0 1.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9f Services: recycling? Cumulative Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 138 27.3 27.3 27.3 Good 221 43.8 43.8 71.1 Fair 68 13.5 13.5 84.6 Poor 35 6.9 6.9 91.5 Not Familiar 38 7.5 7.5 99.0 DKlRF 5 1.0 1.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9g Services: police services? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 166 32.9 32.9 32.9 Goad 227 45.0 45.0 77.8 Fair 67 13.3 13.3 91.1 Poor 29 5.7 5.7 96.8 Not Familiar 12 2.4 2.4 99.2 DKlRF 4 .8 .8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 89 q9h Services: public library services? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 209 41.4 41.4 41.4 Good 218 43.2 43.2 84.6 Fair 37 7.3 7.3 91.9 Poor 7 1.4 1.4 93.3 Not Familiar 33 6.5 6.5 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9i Services: City parking facilities? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 54 10.7 10.7 10.7 Good 204 40.4 40.4 51.1 Fair 136 26.9 26.9 78.0 Poor 83 16.4 16.4 94.5 Not Familiar 22 4.4 4.4 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9j Services: management of emergency situations like natural disasters? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 86 17.0 17.0 17.0 Good 245 48.5 48.5 65.5 Fair 67 13.3 13.3 78.8 Poor 15 3.0 3.0 81.8 Not Familiar 70 13.9 13.9 95.6 DKlRF 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9k Services: mowing right of ways, street medians, and roadsides? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 91 18.0 18.0 18.0 Good 242 47.9 47.9 65.9 Fair 114 22.6 22.6 88.5 Poor 52 10.3 10.3 98.8 Not Familiar 5 1.0 1.0 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100,0 100.0 810 q91 Services: removal of snow and ice from City streets? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 101 20.0 20.0 20.0 Goad 235 46.5 46.5 66.5 Fair 110 21.8 21.8 88.3 Poor 56 11.1 11.1 99.4 Not Familiar 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9m Services: street lighting? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 82 16.2 16.2 16.2 Good 265 52.5 52.5 68.7 Fair 114 22.6 22.6 91.3 Poor 44 8.7 8.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9n Services: street paving, maintenance and repair? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 6.5 6.5 Good 170 33.7 33.7 40.2 Fair 180 35.6 35.6 75.8 Poor 119 23.6 23.6 99.4 DKlRF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q90 Services: street sweeping? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 46 9.1 9.1 9.1 Good 206 40.8 40.8 49.9 Fair 131 25.9 25.9 75.8 Poor 82 16.2 16.2 92.1 Not Familiar 34 6.7 6.7 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 811 q9p Services: the 911 emergency call center? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 205 40.6 40.6 40.6 Good 205 40.6 40.6 81.2 Fair 30 5.9 5.9 87.1 Poor 8 1.6 1.6 88.7 Not Familiar 54 10.7 10.7 99.4 DK/RF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9q Services: transportation planning for traffic? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 39 7.7 7.7 7.7 Good 186 36.8 36.8 44.6 Fair 160 31.7 31.7 76.2 Poor 78 15.4 15.4 91.7 Not Familiar 33 6.5 6.5 98.2 DK/RF 9 1.8 1.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9r Services: the quality of the City's new sidewalk construction? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 67 13.3 13.3 13.3 Good 206 40.8 40.8 54.1 Fair 99 19.6 19.6 73.7 Poor 49 9.7 9.7 83.4 Not Familiar 72 14.3 14.3 97.6 DK/RF 12 2.4 2.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9s Services: the maintenance ofthe City's existing sidewalks? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 37 7.3 7.3 7.3 Good 197 39.0 39.0 46.3 Fair 166 32.9 32.9 79.2 Poor 75 14.9 14.9 94.1 Not Familiar 27 5.3 5.3 99.4 DK/RF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 812 q9t Services: the City's recreation programs? Cumulative F rea uencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 85 16.8 16.8 16.8 Good 226 44.8 44.8 61.6 Fair 108 21.4 21.4 83.0 Poor 32 6.3 6.3 89.3 Not Familiar 43 8.5 8.5 97.8 DKlRF 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9u Services: the quality of Roanoke's athletic fields and facilities? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 63 12.5 12.5 12.5 Good 200 39.6 39.6 52.1 Fair 113 22.4 22.4 74.5 Poor 79 15.6 15.6 90.1 Not Familiar 43 8.5 8.5 98.6 DKlRF 7 1.4 1.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9v Services: cleanliness and maintenance of community recreation centers such as Eureka Park, Grandin Court, and Garden City? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 46 9.1 9.1 9.1 Goad 220 43.6 43.6 52.7 Fair 99 19.6 19.6 72.3 Poor 31 6.1 6.1 78.4 Not Familiar 90 17.8 17.8 96.2 DKlRF 19 3.8 3.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9w Services: cleanliness and maintenance of parks and recreation facilities in general? Cumulative Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 55 10.9 10.9 10.9 Good 265 52.5 52.5 63.4 Fair 121 24.0 24.0 87.3 Poor 25 5.0 5.0 92.3 Not Familiar 29 5.7 5.7 98.0 DKlRF 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 613 q9x Services: cultural activities and events in the City? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 87 172 17.2 17.2 Goad 255 50.5 50.5 67.7 Fair 109 21.6 21.6 89.3 Poor 34 6.7 6.7 96.0 Not Familiar 14 2.8 2.8 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 . 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9y Services: mowing and maintenance of City parks? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 16.0 16.0 Goad 290 57.4 57.4 73.5 Fair 86 17.0 17.0 90.5 Poor 11 2.2 2.2 92.7 Not Familiar 27 5.3 5.3 98.0 DKlRF 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9z Services: the maintenance oftrees along City streets and within parks? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 58 11.5 11.5 11.5 Good 272 53.9 53.9 65.3 Fair 112 222 22.2 87.5 Poor 49 9.7 9.7 97.2 Not Familiar 6 1.2 1.2 98.4 DKlRF 8 1.6 1.6 1000 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9aa Services: City beautification programs, such as the hanging flower baskets and landscaping along City roads and community gateways? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 160 31.7 31.7 31.7 Good 244 48.3 48.3 80.0 Fair 67 13.3 13.3 93.3 Poor 22 4.4 4.4 97.6 Not Familiar 7 1.4 1.4 99.0 DKlRF 5 1.0 1.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 B14 q9bb Services: animal control? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 64 12.7 12.7 12.7 Good 245 48.5 48.5 61.2 Fair 108 21.4 21.4 82,6 Poor 56 11.1 11.1 93.7 Not Familiar 24 4.8 4.8 98.4 DKlRF 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9cc Services: regulation and zoning for land use? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 20 4.0 4.0 4.0 Good 178 35.2 35.2 39.2 Fair 154 30.5 30.5 69.7 Poor 43 8.5 8.5 78.2 Not Familiar 84 16.6 16.6 94.9 DKlRF 26 5.1 5.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9dd Services: weed abatement, or the cutting of weeds on vacant lots? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 19 3.8 3.8 3.8 Good 153 30.3 30.3 34.1 Fair 159 31.5 31.5 65.5 Poor 127 25.1 25.1 90.7 Not Familiar 40 7.9 7.9 98.6 DKlRF 7 1.4 1.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 qgee Services: the enforcement of property maintenance codes and other nuisance codes? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 5.5 5.5 Good 168 33.3 33.3 38.8 Fair 153 30.3 30.3 69.1 Poor 98 19.4 19.4 88.5 Not Familiar 46 91 9.1 97.6 DKlRF 12 2.4 2.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 815 q9ff Services: efforts of the City to improve the quality of housing in the City? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 38 7.5 7.5 7.5 Gaad 198 39.2 39.2 46.7 Fair 177 35.0 35.0 81.8 Paor 59 11.7 11.7 93.5 Not Familiar 27 5.3 5.3 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 . 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9gg Services: economic development assistance to businesses? Cumulative Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 5.5 5.5 Good 193 38.2 38.2 43.8 Fair 130 25.7 25.7 69.5 Poor 24 4.8 4.8 74.3 Not Familiar 104 20.6 20.6 94.9 DKlRF 26 5.1 5.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9hh Services: citizens getting information about City services and activities? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 54 10.7 10.7 10.7 Good 216 42.8 42.8 53.5 Fair 148 29.3 29.3 82.8 Poor 58 11.5 11.5 94.3 Not Familiar 22 4.4 4.4 98.6 DKlRF 7 1.4 1.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9ii Services: the convenience of paying City bills? Cumulative Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 16.0 16.0 Good 270 53.5 53.5 69.5 Fair 79 15.6 15.6 85.1 Poor 54 10.7 10.7 95.8 Not Familiar 15 3.0 3.0 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 816 q9jj Services: maintenance of the storm drainage systems? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 6.5 6.5 Good 217 43.0 43.0 49.5 Fair 143 28.3 28.3 77.8 Poor 81 16.0 16.0 93.9 Not Familiar 23 4.6 4.6 98.4 DKlRF 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9kk Services: the City's efforts to promote environmental awareness to citizens? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 6.5 6.5 Good 199 39.4 39.4 45.9 Fair 158 31.3 31.3 77.2 Poor 67 13.3 13.3 90.5 Not Familiar 34 6.7 6.7 97.2 DKlRF 14 2.8 2.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q911 Services: maintenance of City-owned buildings? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 55 10.9 10.9 10.9 Good 259 51.3 51.3 62.2 Fair 114 22.6 22.6 84.8 Poor 29 5.7 5.7 90.5 Not Familiar 36 7.1 7.1 97.6 DKlRF 12 2.4 2.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9mm Services: building inspections? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 5.5 5.5 Good 195 38.6 38.6 44.2 Fair 106 21.0 21.0 65.1 Poor 34 6.7 6.7 71.9 Not Familiar 112 22.2 22.2 94.1 DKlRF 30 5.9 5.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 817 q9nn Services: the building permits application and review process? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 31 6.1 6.1 6.1 Good 172 34.1 34.1 40.2 Fair 96 19.0 19.0 59.2 Poor 28 5.5 5.5 64.8 Not Familiar 138 27.3 27.3 92.1 DKlRF 40 7.9 7.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q900 Services: City government support of neighborhood organizations? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 43 8.5 8.5 8.5 Good 212 42.0 42.0 50.5 Fair 130 25.7 25.7 76.2 Poor 41 8.1 8.1 84.4 Not Familiar 63 12.5 12.5 96.8 DKlRF 16 3.2 3.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9pp Services: the availability of parking at the Roanoke Civic Center? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 51 10.1 10.1 10.1 Good 166 32.9 32.9 43.0 Fair 129 25.5 25.5 68.5 Poor 134 26.5 26.5 95.0 Not Familiar 19 3.8 3.8 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9qq Services: the quality of entertainment events like concerts and circuses offered by the Civic Center? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 72 14.3 14.3 14.3 Good 205 40.6 40.6 54.9 Fair 127 25.1 25.1 80.0 Poor 68 13.5 13.5 93.5 Not Familiar 24 4.8 4.8 98.2 DKlRF 9 1.8 1.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 818 q9rr Services: the quality of cultural events like musicals and plays offered by the Civic Center? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 80 15.8 15.8 15.8 Good 220 43.6 43.6 59.4 Fair 119 23.6 23.6 83.0 Poor 43 8.5 8.5 91.5 Not Familiar 32 6.3 6.3 97.8 DKlRF 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9ss Services: the current level of bagged leaf collection service? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 71 14.1 14.1 14.1 Good 264 52.3 52.3 66.3 Fair 101 20.0 20.0 86.3 Poor 32 6.3 6.3 92.7 Not Familiar 29 5.7 5.7 98.4 DKlRF 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9tt Services: the current level of loose leaf collection service? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 53 10.5 10.5 10.5 Good 229 45.3 45.3 55.8 Fair 126 25.0 25.0 80.8 Poor 58 11.5 11.5 92.3 Not Familiar 29 5.7 5.7 98.0 DKlRF 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q10a Other services: Health Department? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 60 11.9 11.9 11.9 Good 227 45.0 45.0 56.8 Fair 62 12.3 12.3 69.1 Poor 19 3.8 3.8 72.9 Not Familiar 107 21.2 21.2 94.1 DKlRF 30 5.9 5.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 819 q10b Other services: Roanoke Public Schools? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 58 11.5 11.5 11.5 Goad 219 43.4 43.4 54.9 Fair 111 22.0 22.0 76.8 Poor 57 11.3 11.3 88.1 Not Familiar 48 9.5 9.5 97.6 DKlRF 12 2.4 2.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q10c Other services: Sewer services? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 47 9.3 9.3 9.3 Goad 300 59.4 59.4 68.7 Fair 97 19.2 19.2 87.9 Poor 22 4.4 4.4 92.3 Not Familiar 30 5.9 5.9 98.2 DKlRF 9 1.8 1.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q10d Other services: Water services? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 16.0 16.0 Good 313 62.0 62.0 78.0 Fair 76 15,0 15.0 93.1 Poor 27 5.3 5.3 98.4 Not Familiar 4 .8 .8 99.2 DKlRF 4 .8 .8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q10e Other services: Valley Metro bus transportation services? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 93 18.4 18.4 18.4 Good 228 45.1 45.1 63.6 Fair 54 10.7 10.7 74.3 Poor 28 5.5 5.5 79.8 Not Familiar 86 17.0 17.0 96.8 DKlRF 16 3.2 3.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 820 q11 Have you or any member of your household participated in any parks and recreational programs during the last 12 months? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 133 26.3 26.3 26.3 No 370 73.3 73.3 99.6 DKlRF 2 .4 .4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q12 Do you currently recycle with the City of Roanoke? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 303 60.0 60.0 60.0 Na 202 40.0 40.0 100.0 Tatal 505 100.0 100.0 q14a Do you recycle: newspapers? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 229 45.3 75.6 75.6 No 74 14.7 24.4 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14b Do you recycle: junk mail? Cumulative Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 185 36.6 61.1 61.1 No 118 23.4 38.9 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14c Do you recycle: magazines? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 197 39.0 65.0 65.0 No 106 21.0 35.0 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 621 q14d Do you recycle: computer paper? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 105 20.8 34.7 34.7 No 196 38.8 64.7 99.3 DKlRF 2 .4 .7 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14e Do you recycle: cardboard? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 193 38.2 63.7 63.7 No 110 21.8 36.3 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14f Do you recycle: clear glass bottles? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 231 45.7 .76.2 76.2 No 72 14.3 23.8 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14g Do you recycle: plastic? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 245 48.5 80.9 80.9 No 58 11.5 19.1 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14h Do you recycle: cans? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 237 46.9 78.2 78.2 No 66 13.1 21.8 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 822 q15 Are you aware that the Roanoke Civic Center offers free shuttle bus service to supplement its parking for large events? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 417 82.6 82.6 82.6 No 88 17.4 17.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q16 Have you used this service? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 100 19.8 24.0 24.0 No 317 62.8 76.0 100.0 Total 417 82.6 100.0 Missing System 88 17.4 Total 505 100.0 q17 Are you aware that the City has free wireless Internet access capability in the downtown area and in the library? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 300 59.4 59.4 59.4 No 204 40.4 40.4 99.8 DKlRF 1 2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q18 Have you used this service? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Vaiid Yes 86 17.0 28.7 28.7 No 214 42.4 71.3 100.0 Total 300 59.4 100.0 Missing System 205 40.6 Total 505 100.0 q19 Would it benefit you if City of Roanoke customer service information offered to citizens at the library and other City locations were available in another language such as Spanish, or Vietnamese? Cumulative Frequency Percent Vaiid Percent Percent Valid Yes 149 29.5 29.5 29.5 No 342 67.7 67.7 97.2 DKlRF 14 2.8 2.8 100.0 Totai 505 100.0 100.0 B23 q20_1 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Spanish Cumulative F reouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 33 6.5 22.1 22.1 Chosen 116 23.0 77.9 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_2 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Vietnamese Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 118 23.4 79.2 79.2 Chosen 31 6.1 20.8 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_3 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Other Cumulative Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 113 22.4 75.8 75.8 Chosen 36 71 24.2 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_ 4 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: DKlRF Cumulatiye Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 133 26.3 89.3 89.3 Chosen 16 3.2 10.7 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q21 How satisfied are you with the overall quality of services that the City of Roanoke government provides? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Satisfied 109 21.6 21.6 21.6 Somewhat Satisfied 324 64.2 64.2 85.7 Somewhat Dissatisfied 56 11.1 11.1 96.8 Very Dissatisfied 14 2.8 2.8 99.6 DKlRF 2 .4 .4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 824 q22 How safe do you feel in your neighborhood? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 258 51.1 51.1 51.1 Somewhat Safe 200 39.6 39.6 90.7 Somewhat Unsafe 30 5.9 5.9 96.6 Not at all Safe 17 3.4 3.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q23 How safe do you feel in the park or recreation facility closest to your home? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 162 32.1 32.1 32.1 Somewhat Safe 210 41.6 41.6 73.7 Somewhat Unsafe 33 6.5 6.5 80.2 Not at all Safe 32 6.3 6.3 86.5 OK/Don't Go There 68 13.5 13.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q24 How safe do you feel downtown? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 182 36.0 36.0 36.0 Somewhat Safe 231 45.7 45.7 81.8 Somewhat Unsafe 36 7.1 7.1 88.9 Not at all Safe 14 2.8 2.8 91.7 OK/Don't Go There 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q25 How safe do you feel in the City's parking garages? Cumuiative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 69 13.7 13.7 13.7 Somewhat Safe 219 43.4 43.4 57.0 Somewhat Unsafe 56 11.1 11.1 68.1 Not at all Safe 52 10.3 10.3 78.4 OK/Don't Go There 109 21.6 21.6 100.0 Totai 505 100.0 100.0 q26 How safe do you feel at the Civic Center parking lot? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 196 38.8 38.8 38.8 Somewhat Safe 221 43.8 43.8 82.6 Somewhat Unsafe 21 4.2 4.2 86.7 Not at all Safe 12 2.4 2.4 89.1 OK/Don't Go There 55 10.9 10.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 825 q27 Do you have regular access to the Internet? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 328 65.0 65.0 65.0 No 177 35.0 35.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q28 On average, how often do you visit the City's web site? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid At least once a day 15 3.0 4.6 4.6 At least once a week 41 8.1 12.5 17.1 At least once a month 67 13.3 20.4 37.5 Less than once a month 122 24.2 37.2 74.7 Never 83 16.4 25.3 100.0 Total 328 65.0 100.0 Missing System 177 35.0 Total 505 100.0 q29 Are there any services that are not currently offered that you would like to see available on the City's web site? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 29 5.7 11.8 11.8 No 205 40.6 83.7 95.5 DKlRF 11 2.2 4.5 100.0 Total 245 48.5 100.0 Missing System 260 51.5 Total 505 100.0 q30 Do you receive the City's magazine called Roanoke Citizen, at your home? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 291 57.6 57.6 57.6 No 199 39.4 39.4 97.0 DKlRF 15 3.0 3.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 626 q31 When you receive the magazine would you say you usually... Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Read it cover to cover 81 16.0 27.8 27.8 Scan the articles and read the ones that 147 29.1 50.5 78.4 interest you Flip through it but don't 48 9.5 16.5 94.8 read many articles Don't read it at all 15 3.0 5.2 100.0 Total 291 57.6 100.0 Missing System 214 42.4 Total 505 100.0 q32 On average, how often do you watch the City's Inside Roanoke television show on Roanoke Valley Television Channel 3? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid At least once a week 103 20.4 20.4 20.4 At least once a month 104 20.6 20.6 41.0 A few times a year 114 22.6 22.6 63.6 Never 178 35.2 35.2 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_1 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: through a magazine mailed to you by the City several times a year? Cumulative Frequencv Percenl Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 293 58.0 58.0 58.0 Chosen 212 42.0 42.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_2 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: through an e-mail sent to you periodically by the City? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 454 89.9 89.9 89.9 Chosen 51 10.1 10.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 827 q33_3 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by visiting the City's web site yourself? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 456 90.3 90.3 90.3 Chosen 49 9.7 9.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_ 4 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by watching the City's TV shows on RVTV Channel 3? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 416 82.4 82.4 82.4 Chosen 89 17.6 17.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_5 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by reading the newspaper, listening to radio news, or watching news? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 184 36.4 .' 36.4 36.4 Chosen 321 63.6 63.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_6 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: or some other way? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 476 94.3 94.3 94.3 Chosen 29 5.7 5.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33J What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: DKlRF Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 502 99.4 99.4 99.4 Chosen 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 828 q34a Agreement: City government employees are generally friendly, courteous, and helpful. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 174 34.5 34.5 34.5 Somewhat Agree 275 54.5 54.5 88.9 Somewhat Disagree 31 6.1 6.1 95.0 Strongly Disagree 17 3.4 3.4 98.4 DK 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34b Agreement: City parking facility staff are generally polite and responsive. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 158 31.3 31.3 31.3 Somewhat Agree 223 44.2 44.2 75.4 Somewhat Disagree 19 3.8 3.8 79.2 Strongly Disagree 9 1.8 1.8 81.0 DK 96 19.0 19.0 100.0 Totai 505 100.0 100.0 q34c Agreement: It is easy to contact the appropriate City government office when you need a particular service or have a question. Cumulative , Freauency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 135 26.7 26.7 26.7 Somewhat Agree 202 40.0 40.0 66.7 Somewhat Disagree 70 13.9 13.9 80.6 Strongly Disagree 74 14.7 14.7 95.2 DK 24 4.8 4.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34d Agreement: City government employees provide prompt service. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 127 25.1 25.1 25.1 Somewhat Agree 267 52.9 52.9 78.0 Somewhat Disagree 51 10.1 10.1 88.1 Strongly Disagree 37 7.3 7.3 95.4 DK 23 4.6 4.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 829 q34e Agreement: City government employees treat citizens fairly. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 139 27.5 27.5 27.5 Somewhat Agree 270 53.5 53.5 81.0 Somewhat Disagree 38 7.5 7.5 88.5 Strongly Disagree 30 5.9 5.9 94.5 DK 28 5.5 5.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34f Agreement: Convenient parking at City government offices is generally available. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 52 10.3 10.3 10.3 Somewhat Agree 180 35.6 35.6 45.9 Somewhat Disagree 105 20.8 20.8 66.7 Strongly Disagree 118 23.4 23.4 90.1 DK 50 9.9 9.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34g Agreement: City government office locations are convenient. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 126 25,0 25.0 25.0 Somewhat Agree 242 47.9 47.9 72.9 Somewhat Disagree 65 12.9 12.9 85.7 Strongly Disagree 50 9.9 9.9 95.6 DK 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34h Agreement: City government office hours are convenient. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 167 33.1 33.1 33.1 Somewhat Agree 223 44.2 44.2 77.2 Somewhat Disagree 55 10.9 10.9 88.1 Strongly Disagree 40 7.9 7.9 96.0 DK 20 4.0 4.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid 1907 2 .4 .4 .4 1913 1 .2 .2 .6 1914 1 .2 .2 .8 1916 2 .4 .4 1.2 1917 3 .6 .6 1.8 830 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid 1918 2 .4 .4 2.2 1919 2 .4 .4 2.6 1920 3 .6 .6 3.2 1921 6 1.2 1.2 4.4 1922 4 .8 .8 5.1 1923 4 .8 .8 5.9 1924 5 1.0 1.0 6.9 1925 8 1.6 1.6 8.5 1926 4 .8 .8 9.3 1927 3 .6 .6 9.9 1928 7 1.4 1.4 11.3 1929 4 .8 .8 12.1 1930 13 2.6 2.6 14.7 1931 8 1.6 1.6 16.2 1932 6 1.2 1.2 17.4 1933 7 1.4 1.4 18.8 1934 6 1.2 1.2 20.0 1935 4 .8 .8 20.8 1936 3 .6 .6 21.4 1937 5 1.0 1.0 22.4 1938 3 .6 .6 23.0 1939 10 2.0 2.0 25.0 1940 7 1.4 1.4 26.3 1941 12 2.4 2.4 28.7 1942 8 1.6 1.6 30.3 1943 7 1.4 1.4 31.7 1944 15 3.0 3.0 34.7 1945 7 1.4 1.4 36.0 1946 13 2.6 2.6 38.6 1947 11 2.2 2.2 40.8 1948 12 2.4 2.4 43.2 1949 7 1.4 1.4 44.6 1950 11 2.2 2.2 46.7 1951 15 3.0 3.0 49.7 1952 7 1.4 1.4 51.1 1953 5 1.0 1.0 52.1 1954 11 2.2 2.2 54.3 1955 9 1.8 1.8 56.0 1956 17 3.4 3.4 59.4 1957 8 1.6 1.6 61.0 1958 7 1.4 1.4 62.4 1959 4 .8 .8 63.2 1960 10 2.0 2.0 65.1 1961 10 2.0 2.0 67.1 1962 12 2.4 2.4 69.5 1963 6 1.2 1.2 70.7 1964 11 2.2 2.2 72.9 1965 9 1.8 1.8 74.7 1966 12 2.4 2.4 77.0 1967 5 1.0 1.0 78.0 1968 18 3.6 3.6 81.6 831 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative Frequency Percent Vaiid Percent Percent Valid 1969 7 1.4 1.4 83.0 1970 5 1.0 1.0 84.0 1971 5 1.0 1.0 85.0 1972 4 .8 .8 85.7 1973 5 1.0 1.0 86.7 1974 5 1.0 1.0 87.7 1975 6 1.2 1.2 88.9 1976 3 .6 .6 89.5 1977 4 .8 .8 90.3 1978 2 .4 .4 90.7 1979 5 1.0 1.0 91.7 1980 9 1.8 1.8 93.5 1981 4 .8 .8 94.3 1982 2 .4 .4 94.7 1984 2 .4 .4 95.0 1985 5 1.0 1.0 96.0 1986 5 1.0 1.0 97.0 1987 5 1.0 1.0 98.0 DK/RF 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q36 Do you consider yourself to be White, African American or alack, Asian, Hispanic or Latino, or a member of some other group? Cumulative Frequency Percent Vaiid Percent Percent Valid White 377 74.7 74.7 74.7 African American (Black) 105 20.8 20.8 95.4 Asian 1 .2 .2 95.6 Hispanic (Latino) 3 .6 .6 96.2 Other 11 2.2 2.2 98.4 DK/RF 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 B32 q37 Please stop me when I get to the bracket that includes your best estimate of your total family income before taxes last year. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid less than $15,000 74 14.7 14.7 14.7 between $15,000 and 81 16.0 16.0 30.7 less than $25,000 between $25,000 and 68 13.5 13.5 442 less than $35,000 between $35,000 and 84 16.6 16.6 60.8 less than $50,000 between $50,000 and 70 13.9 13.9 74.7 less than $75,000 between $75,000 and 33 6.5 6.5 81.2 $100,000 over $100,000 37 7.3 7.3 88.5 DKlRF 58 11.5 11.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q38 Gender Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Male 184 36.4 36.4 36.4 Female 321 63.6 63.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 833 .' Appendix C Response Frequencies With City Service Items Tabulated Excluding Responses of "Not Familiar With Service" and "Don't Know" q1 First, do you live in the City of Roanoke? Cumulative F reQ uency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 505 100.0 100.0 100.0 q2 How would you rate Roanoke as a place to live today, in 2005? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 150 29.7 29.7 29.7 Good 238 47.1 47.1 76.8 Fair 88 17.4 17.4 94.3 Poor 26 5.1 5.1 99.4 DKlRF 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q3 How would you rate the City government's efforts to improve the local economy? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 21 4.2 4.2 4.2 Good 191 37.8 37.8 42.0 Fair 183 36.2 36.2 78.2 Poor 80 15.8 15.8 94.1 DKlRF 30 5.9 5.9 100.0 , Total 505 100.0 100.0 q4 How would you rate the educational resources and opportunities available to you and your family in Roanoke? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 94 18.6 18.6 18.6 Good 245 48.5 48.5 67.1 Fair 100 19.8 19.8 86.9 Poor 34 6.7 6.7 93.7 DKlRF 32 6.3 6.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q5 How would you rate the quality of life in the community? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 109 21.6 21.6 21.6 Good 270 53.5 53.5 75.0 Fair 100 19.8 19.8 94.9 Poor 26 5.1 5.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C1 q6 How would you rate the effectiveness of the City of Roanoke government in meeting community needs? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Effective 42 8.3 8.3 8.3 Somewhat Effective 308 61.0 61.0 69.3 Somewhat Ineffective 93 18.4 18.4 87.7 Not at all Effective 47 9.3 9.3 97.0 DKlRF 15 3.0 3.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7a Agreement: Roanoke City officials actively involve citizens in the business of City government. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 30 5.9 5.9 5.9 Somewhat Agree 274 54.3 54.3 60.2 Somewhat Disagree 106 21.0 21.0 81.2 Strongly Disagree 62 12.3 12.3 93.5 DK 33 6.5 6.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7b Agreement: City government performance is improving in Roanoke. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 57 11.3 11.3 11.3 Somewhat Agree 252 49.9 49.9 61.2 Somewhat Disagree 112 22.2 22.2 83.4 Strongly Disagree 61 12.1 121 95.4 DK 23 4.6 4.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7c Agreement: Roanoke City officials do a good job of bringing higher paying jobs to the City. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 36 7.1 7.1 7.1 Somewhat Agree 160 31.7 31.7 38.8 Somewhat Disagree 134 26.5 26.5 65.3 Strongly Disagree 134 26.5 26.5 91.9 DK 41 8.1 8.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C2 q7d Agreement: There is a good mix of housing types and affordability in Roanoke. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 171 33.9 33.9 33.9 Somewhat Agree 207 41.0 41.0 74.9 Somewhat Disagree 63 12.5 12.5 87.3 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 96.8 DK 15 3.0 3.0 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7e Agreement: Roanoke's transportation system allows for a good mix of transportation options like auto, public transit, pedestrian, and bicycle traffic. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 176 34.9 34.9 34.9 Somewhat Agree 216 42.8 42.8 77.6 Somewhat Disagree 60 11.9 11.9 89.5 Strongly Disagree 42 8.3 8.3 97.8 DK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7f Agreement: Roanoke's neighborhoods are good places to live. Cumulative , Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 187 37.0 37.0 37.0 Somewhat Agree 244 48.3 48.3 85.3 Somewhat Disagree 43 8.5 8.5 93.9 Strongly Disagree 30 5.9 5.9 99.8 DK 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7g Agreement: Overall, Roanoke's neighborhoods provide the necessary businesses, community services, and activities that people need. Cumulative F reouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 153 30.3 30.3 30.3 Somewhat Agree 241 47.7 47.7 78.0 Somewhat Disagree 55 10.9 10.9 88.9 Strongly Disagree 52 10.3 10.3 99.2 DK 4 .8 .8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C3 q7h Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of focusing on the unique needs of youths. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 63 12.5 12.5 12.5 Somewhat Agree 188 37.2 37.2 49.7 Somewhat Disagree 92 18.2 18.2 67.9 Strongly Disagree 105 20.8 20.8 88.7 DK 57 11.3 11.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7i Agreement: The City does a good job of offering multicultural events and attractions. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 180 35.6 35.6 35.6 Somewhat Agree 222 44.0 44.0 79.6 Somewhat Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 89.1 Strongly Disagree 41 8.1 8.1 97.2 DK 14 2.8 2.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7j Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of supporting existing businesses. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 90 17.8 17.8 17.8 Somewhat Agree 248 49.1 49.1 66.9 Somewhat Disagree 62 12.3 12.3 79.2 Strongly Disagree 39 7.7 7.7 86.9 DK 66 13.1 13.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7k Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of attracting new businesses. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 75 14.9 14.9 14.9 Somewhat Agree 202 40.0 40.0 54.9 Somewhat Disagree 109 21.6 21.6 76.4 Strongly Disagree 77 15.2 15.2 91.7 DK 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C4 q71 Agreement: Clean air and water are valued by the Roanoke community. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 220 43.6 43.6 43.6 Somewhat Agree 209 41.4 41.4 85.0 Somewhat Disagree 41 8.1 8.1 93.1 Strongly Disagree 22 4.4 4.4 97.4 DK 13 2.6 2.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7m Agreement: The services provided by the City of Roanoke are worth the taxes paid by its citizens. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 120 23.8 23.8 23.8 Somewhat Agree 219 43.4 43.4 67.1 Somewhat Disagree 65 12.9 12.9 80.0 Strongly Disagree 86 17.0 17.0 97.0 DK 14 2.8 2.8 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7n Agreement: Roanoke is actively expanding cooperative efforts with other local governments in our region. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 80 15.8 15.8 15.8 Somewhat Agree 236 46.7 46.7 62.6 Somewhat Disagree 59 11.7 117 74.3 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 83.8 DK 82 16.2 16.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q70 Agreement: Roanoke's air transportation system effectively links the region to major national destinations. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 116 23.0 23.0 23.0 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 61.2 Somewhat Disagree 76 15.0 15.0 76.2 Strongly Disagree 76 15.0 15.0 91.3 DK 44 8.7 8.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C5 q7p Agreement: Roanoke's greenway development effort is a valuable asset to the City and its residents. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 187 37.0 37.0 37.0 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 75.2 Somewhat Disagree 37 7.3 7.3 82.6 Strongly Disagree 26 5.1 5.1 87.7 DK 61 12.1 12.1 99.8 RF 1 2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7q Agreement: City government does a good job of educating citizens about City services. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 108 21.4 21.4 21.4 Somewhat Agree 225 44.6 44.6 65.9 Somewhat Disagree 83 16.4 16.4 82.4 Strongly Disagree 78 15.4 15.4 97.8 DK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7r Agreement: Roanoke's downtown is the region's economic engine and cultural center. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 164 32.5 32.5 32.5 Somewhat Agree 199 39.4 39.4 71.9 Somewhat Disagree 72 14.3 14.3 86.1 Strongly Disagree 48 9.5 9.5 95.6 DK 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7s Agreement: The community does a good job of promoting Roanoke as a tourist destination for outdoor and family vacations. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 127 25.1 25.1 25.1 Somewhat Agree 193 38.2 38.2 63.4 Somewhat Disagree 96 19.0 19.0 82.4 Strongly Disagree 72 14.3 14.3 96.6 DK 17 3.4 3.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C6 q7t Agreement: Roanoke does a good job of providing health and human services to its citizens who need them. Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 145 28.7 28.7 28.7 Somewhat Agree 213 42.2 42.2 70.9 Somewhat Disagree 47 9.3 9.3 80.2 Strongly Disagree 58 11.5 11.5 91.7 DK 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7u Agreement: City government does a good job developing or redeveloping commercial and industrial areas in Roanoke. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 73 14.5 14.5 14.5 Somewhat Agree 244 48.3 48.3 62.8 Somewhat Disagree 83 16.4 16.4 79.2 Strongly Disagree 63 12.5 12.5 91.7 DK 41 8.1 8.1 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q7v Agreement: City government does a good job of historical preservation and protection in the City. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 143 28.3 28.4 28.4 Somewhat Agree 256 50.7 50.8 79.2 Somewhat Disagree 38 7.5 7.5 86.7 Strongly Disagree 51 10.1 10.1 96.8 DK 15 3.0 3.0 99.8 RF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 504 99.8 100.0 Missing System 1 .2 Total 505 100.0 q7w Agreement: Downtown is a vibrant and dynamic destination offering a good mix of restaurants, entertainment, and cultural attractions. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 229 45.3 45.3 45.3 Somewhat Agree 187 37.0 37.0 82.4 Somewhat Disagree 44 8.7 8.7 91.1 Strongly Disagree 34 6.7 6.7 97.8 DK 11 2.2 2.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C7 q8 How much of the time do you think you can trust the City to do what is right? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Just About Always 21 4.2 4.2 4.2 Most of the Time 207 41.0 41.0 45.1 Only Some of the Time 248 49.1 49.1 94.3 Never 28 5.5 5.5 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q9a Services: response to citizen complaints and requests? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 29 5.7 6.1 6.1 Good 203 40.2 42.6 48.6 Fair 164 32.5 34.4 83.0 Poor 81 16.0 17.0 100.0 Total 477 94.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 21 4.2 DKlRF 7 1.4 Total 28 5.5 Total 505 100.0 q9b Services: fire protection services? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 211 41.8 43.1 43.1 Good 240 47.5 49.1 92.2 Fair 32 6.3 6.5 98.8 Poor 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 489 96.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 13 2.6 DKlRF 3 .6 Total 16 3.2 Total . 505 100.0 q9c Services: emergency and rescue services? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 230 45.5 46.5 46.5 Good 224 44.4 45.3 91.7 Fair 35 6.9 7.1 98.8 Poor 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 495 98.0 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 10 2.0 Total 505 100.0 C8 q9d Services: weekly trash collection? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 207 41.0 41.2 41.2 Good 224 44.4 44.6 85.9 Fair 49 9.7 9.8 95.6 Poor 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 502 99.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 2 .4 DKlRF 1 .2 Total 3 .6 Total 505 100.0 qge Services: pick-up of large trash items and brush? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 181 35.8 36.4 36.4 Good 199 39.4 40.0 76.5 Fair 68 13.5 13.7 90.1 Poor 49 9.7 9.9 100.0 Total 497 98.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 3 .6 DKlRF 5 1.0 Total 8 1.6 Total 505 100.0 q9f Services: recycling? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 138 27.3 29.9 29.9 Good 221 43.8 47.8 77.7 Fair 68 13.5 14.7 92.4 Poor 35 6.9 7.6 100.0 Total 462 91.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 38 7.5 DKlRF 5 1.0 Total 43 8.5 Total 505 100.0 C9 q9g Services: police services? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 166 32.9 33.9 33.9 Good 227 45.0 46.4 80.4 Fair 67 13.3 13.7 94.1 Poor 29 5.7 5.9 100.0 Total 489 96.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 12 2.4 DKlRF 4 .8 Total 16 3.2 Total 505 100.0 q9h Services: public library services? Cumulative Freauencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 209 41.4 44.4 44.4 Good 218 43.2 46.3 90.7 Fair 37 7.3 7.9 98.5 Poor 7 1.4 1.5 100.0 Total 471 93.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 33 6.5 DKlRF 1 .2 Total 34 6.7 Total 505 100.0 q9i Services: City parking facilities? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 54 10.7 11.3 11.3 Good 204 40.4 42.8 54.1 Fair 136 26.9 28.5 82.6 Poor 83 16.4 17.4 100.0 Total 477 94.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 22 4.4 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 28 5.5 Total 505 100.0 C10 q9j Services: management of emergency situations like natural disasters? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 86 17.0 20.8 20.8 Good 245 48.5 59.3 80.1 Fair 67 13.3 16.2 96.4 Poor 15 3.0 3.6 100.0 Total 413 81.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 70 13.9 . DKlRF 22 4.4 Total 92 18.2 Total 505 100.0 q9k Services: mowing right of ways, street medians, and roadsides? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 91 18.0 18.2 18.2 Good 242 47.9 48.5 66.7 Fair 114 22.6 22.8 89.6 Poor 52 10.3 10.4 100.0 Total 499 98.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 5 1.0 DKlRF 1 .2 Total 6 1.2 Total 505 100.0 q91 Services: removal of snow and ice from City streets? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 101 20.0 20.1 20.1 Good 235 46.5 46.8 66.9 Fair 110 21.8 21.9 88.8 Poor 56 11.1 11.2 100.0 Total 502 99.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 3 .6 Total 505 100.0 q9m Services: street lighting? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 82 16.2 16.2 16.2 Good 265 52.5 52.5 68.7 Fair 114 22.6 22.6 91.3 Poor 44 8.7 8.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C11 q9n Services: street paving, maintenance and repair? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 6.6 6.6 Good 170 33.7 33.9 40.4 Fair 180 35.6 35.9 76.3 Poor 119 23.6 23.7 100.0 Total 502 99.4 100.0 Missing DKlRF 3 .6 Total 505 100.0 q90 Services: street sweeping? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 46 9.1 9.9 9.9 Good 206 40.8 44.3 54.2 Fair 131 25.9 28.2 82.4 Poor 82 16.2 17.6 100.0 Total 465 92.1 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 34 6.7 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 40 7.9 Total 505 100.0 q9p Services: the 911 emergency call center? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 205 40.6 45.8 45.8 Goad 205 40.6 45.8 91.5 Fair 30 5.9 6.7 98.2 Poor 8 1.6 1.8 100.0 Total 448 88.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 54 10.7 DKlRF 3 .6 Total 57 11.3 Total 505 100.0 q9q Services: transportation planning for traffic? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 39 7.7 8.4 8.4 Good 186 36.8 40.2 48.6 Fair 160 31.7 34.6 83.2 Poor 78 15.4 16.8 100.0 Total 463 91.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 33 6.5 DKlRF 9 1.8 Total 42 8.3 Total 505 100.0 C12 q9r Services: the quality of the City's new sidewalk construction? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 67 13.3 15.9 15.9 Good 206 40.8 48.9 64.8 Fair 99 19.6 23.5 88.4 Poor 49 .9.7 11.6 100.0 Total 421 83.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 72 14.3 DKlRF 12 2.4 Total 84 16.6 Total 505 100.0 q9s Services: the maintenance of the City's existing sidewalks? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 37 7.3 7.8 7.8 Good 197 39.0 41.5 49.3 Fair 166 32.9 34.9 84.2 Poor 75 14.9 15.8 100.0 Total 475 94.1 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 27 5.3 DKlRF 3 .6 Total 30 5.9 Total 505 100.0 q9t Services: the City's recreation programs? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 85 16.8 18.8 18.8 Good 226 44.8 50.1 69.0 Fair 108 21.4 23.9 92.9 Poor 32 6.3 7.1 100.0 Total 451 89.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 43 8.5 DKlRF 11 2.2 Total 54 10.7 Total 505 100.0 C13 q9u Services: the quality of Roanoke's athletic fields and facilities? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 63 12.5 13.8 13.8 Good 200 39.6 44.0 57.8 Fair 113 22.4 24.8 82.6 Poor 79 15.6 17.4 100.0 Total 455 90.1 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 43 8.5 DKlRF 7 1.4 Total 50 9.9 Total 505 100.0 q9v Services: cleanliness and maintenance of community recreation cente.rs such as Eureka Park, Grandin Court, and Garden City? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 46 9.1 11.6 11.6 Good 220 43.6 55.6 67.2 Fair 99 19.6 25.0 92.2 Poor 31 6.1 7.8 100.0 Total 396 78.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 90 17.8 DKlRF 19 3.8 Total 109 21.6 Total 505 100.0 q9w Services: cleanliness and maintenance of parks and recreation facilities in general? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 55 10.9 11.8 11.8 Good 265 52.5 56.9 68.7 Fair 121 24.0 26.0 94.6 Poor 25 5.0 5.4 100.0 Total 466 92.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 29 5.7 DKlRF 10 2.0 Total 39 7.7 Total 505 100.0 C14 q9x Services: cultural activities and events in the City? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 87 17.2 17.9 17.9 Good 255 50.5 52.6 70.5 Fair 109 21.6 22.5 93.0 Poor 34 6.7 7.0 100.0 Total 485 96.0 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 14 2.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 20 4.0 Total 505 100.0 q9y Services: mowing and maintenance of City parks? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 17.3 17.3 Good 290 57.4 62.0 79.3 Fair 86 17.0 18.4 97.6 Poor 11 2.2 2.4 100.0 Total 468 92.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 27 5.3 DKlRF 10 2.0 Total 37 7.3 Total 505 100.0 q9z Services: the maintenance of trees along City streets and within parks? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 58 11.5 11.8 11.8 Good 272 53.9 55.4 67.2 Fair 112 22.2 22.8 90.0 Poor 49 9.7 10.0 100.0 Total 491 97.2 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 6 1.2 DKlRF 8 1.6 Total 14 2.8 Total 505 100.0 C15 q9aa Services: City beautification programs, such as the hanging flower baskets and landscaping along City roads and community gateways? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 160 31.7 32.5 32.5 Good 244 48.3 49.5 81.9 Fair 67 13.3 13.6 95.5 Poor 22 4.4 4.5 100.0 Total 493 97.6 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 7 1.4 DKlRF 5 1.0 Total 12 2.4 Total 505 100.0 q9bb Services: animal control? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 64 12.7 13.5 13.5 Good 245 48.5 51.8 65.3 Fair 108 21.4 22.8 88.2 Poor 56 11.1 11.8 100.0 Total 473 93.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 24 4.8 DKlRF 8 1.6 Total 32 6.3 Total 505 100.0 q9cc Services: regulation and zoning for land use? Cumulative . Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 20 4.0 5.1 5.1 Good 178 35.2 45.1 50.1 Fair 154 30.5 39.0 89.1 Poor 43 8.5 10.9 100.0 Total 395 78.2 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 84 16.6 DKlRF 26 5.1 Total 110 21.8 Total 505 100.0 C16 q9dd Services: weed abatement, or the cutting of weeds on vacant lots? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 19 3.8 4.1 4.1 Good 153 30.3 33.4 37.6 Fair 159 31.5 34.7 72.3 Poor 127 25.1 27.7 100.0 Total 458 90.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 40 7.9 DKlRF 7 1.4 Total 47 9.3 Total 505 100.0 qgee Services: the enforcement of property maintenance codes and other nuisance codes? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 6.3 6.3 Good 168 33.3 37.6 43.8 Fair 153 30.3 34.2 78.1 Poor 98 19.4 21.9 100.0 Total 447 88.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 46 9.1 DKlRF 12 2.4 Total 58 11.5 Total 505 100.0 q9ff Services: efforts of the City to improve the quality of housing in the City? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 38 7.5 8.1 8.1 Good 198 39.2 41.9 50.0 Fair 177 35.0 37.5 87.5 Poor 59 11.7 12.5 100.0 Total 472 93.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 27 5.3 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 33 6.5 Total 505 100.0 C17 q9gg Services: economic development assistance to businesses? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 7.5 7.5 Good 193 38.2 51.5 58.9 Fair 130 25.7 34.7 93.6 Poor 24 4.8 6.4 100.0 Total 375 74.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 104 20.6 DKlRF 26 5.1 Total 130 25.7 Total 505 100.0 q9hh Services: citizens getting information about City services and activities? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 54 10.7 11.3 11.3 Good 216 42.8 45.4 56.7 Fair 148 29.3 31.1 87.8 Poor 58 11.5 12.2 100.0 Total 476 94.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 22 4.4 DKlRF 7 1.4 Total 29 5.7 Total 505 100.0 q9ii Services: the convenience of paying City bills? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 16.7 16.7 Good 270 53.5 55.8 72.5 Fair 79 15.6 16.3 88.8 Poor 54 10.7 11.2 100.0 Total 484 95.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 15 3.0 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 21 4.2 Total 505 100.0 C18 q9jj Services: maintenance of the storm drainage systems? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 7.0 7.0 Good 217 43.0 45.8 52.7 Fair 143 28.3 30.2 82.9 Poor 81 16.0 17.1 100.0 Total 474 93.9 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 23 4.6 . DKlRF 8 1.6 Total 31 6.1 Total 505 100.0 q9kk Services: the City's efforts to promote environmental awareness to citizens? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 33 6.5 7.2 7.2 Good 199 39.4 43.5 50.8 Fair 158 31.3 34.6 85.3 Poor 67 13.3 14.7 100.0 Total 457 90.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 34 6.7 DKlRF 14 2.8 Total 48 9.5 Total 505 100.0 q911 Services: maintenance of City-owned buildings? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 55 10.9 12.0 12.0 Good 259 51.3 56.7 68.7 Fair 114 22.6 24.9 93.7 Poor 29 5.7 6.3 100.0 Total 457 90.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 36 7.1 DKlRF 12 2.4 Total 48 9.5 Total 505 100.0 C19 q9mm Services: building inspections? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 28 5.5 7.7 7.7 Good 195 38.6 53.7 61.4 Fair 106 21.0 29.2 90.6 Poor 34 6.7 9.4 100.0 Total 363 71.9 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 112 22.2 DKlRF 30 5.9 Total 142 28.1 Total 505 100.0 q9nn Services: the building permits application and review process? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 31 6.1 9.5 9.5 Good 172 34.1 52.6 62.1 Fair 96 19.0 29.4 91.4 Poor 28 5.5 8.6 100.0 Total 327 64.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 138 27.3 DKlRF 40 7.9 Total 178 35.2 Total 505 100.0 q900 Services: City government support of neighborhood organizations? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 43 8.5 10.1 10.1 Good 212 42.0 49.8 59.9 Fair 130 25.7 30.5 90.4 Poor 41 8.1 9.6 100.0 Total 426 84.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 63 12.5 DKlRF 16 3.2 Total 79 15.6 Total 505 100.0 C20 q9pp Services: the availability of parking at the Roanoke Civic Center? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 51 10.1 10.6 10.6 Good 166 32.9 34.6 45.2 Fair 129 25.5 26.9 72.1 Poor 134 26.5 27.9 100.0 Total 480 95.0 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 19 3.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 Total 25 5.0 Total 505 100.0 q9qq Services: the quality of entertainment events like concerts and circuses offered by the Civic Center? Cumulative Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 72 14.3 15.3 15.3 Good 205 40.6 43.4 58.7 Fair 127 25.1 26.9 85.6 Poor 68 13.5 14.4 100.0 Total 472 93.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 24 4.8 DKlRF 9 1.8 Total 33 6.5 Total 505 100.0 q9rr Services: the quality of cultural events like musicals and plays offered by the Civic Center? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 80 15.8 17.3 17.3 Good 220 43.6 47.6 64.9 Fair 119 23.6 25.8 90.7 Poor 43 8.5 9.3 100.0 Total 462 91.5 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 32 6.3 DKlRF 11 2.2 Total 43 8.5 Total 505 100.0 C21 q9ss Services: the current level of bagged leaf collection service? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 71 14.1 15.2 15.2 Good 264 52.3 56.4 71.6 Fair 101 20.0 21.6 93.2 Poor 32 6.3 6.8 100.0 Total 468 92.7 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 29 5.7 DKlRF 8 1.6 Total 37 7.3 Total 505 100.0 q9tt Services: the current level of loose leaf collection service? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 53 10.5 11.4 11.4 Good 229 45.3 49.1 60.5 Fair 126 25.0 27.0 87.6 Poor 58 11.5 12.4 100.0 Total 466 92.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 29 5.7 DKlRF 10 2.0 Total 39 7.7 Total 505 100.0 q10a Other services: Health Department? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 60 11.9 16.3 16.3 Good 227 45.0 61.7 78.0 Fair 62 12.3 16.8 94.8 Poor 19 3.8 5.2 100.0 Total 368 72.9 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 107 21.2 DKlRF 30 5.9 Total 137 27.1 Total 505 100.0 C22 q10b Other services: Roanoke Public Schools? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 58 11.5 13.0 13.0 Good 219 43.4 49.2 62.2 Fair 111 22.0 24.9 87.2 Poor 57 11.3 12.8 100.0 Total 445 88.1 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 48 9.5 DKlRF 12 2.4 Total 60 11.9 Total 505 100.0 q10c Other services: Sewer services? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 47 9.3 10.1 10.1 Good 300 59.4 64.4 74.5 Fair 97 19.2 20.8 95.3 Poor 22 4.4 4.7 100.0 Total 466 92.3 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 30 5.9 DKlRF 9 1.8 Total 39 7.7 Total 505 100.0 q10d Other services: Water services? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 81 16.0 16.3 16.3 Good 313 62.0 63.0 79.3 Fair 76 15.0 15.3 94.6 Poor 27 5.3 5.4 100.0 Total 497 98.4 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 4 .8 DKlRF 4 .8 Total 8 1.6 Total 505 100.0 C23 q10e Other services: Valley Metro bus transportation services? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Excellent 93 18.4 23.1 23.1 Good 228 45.1 56.6 79.7 Fair 54 10.7 13.4 93.1 Poor 28 5.5 6.9 100.0 Total 403 79.8 100.0 Missing Not Familiar 86 17.0 DKlRF 16 3.2 Total 102 20.2 Total 505 100.0 q11 Have you or any member of your household participated in any parks and recreational programs during the last 12 months? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 133 26.3 26.3 26.3 No 370 73.3 73.3 99.6 DKlRF 2 .4 .4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q12 Do you currently recycle with the City of Roanoke? Cumulative , FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 303 60.0 60.0 60.0 No 202 40.0 40.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q14a Do you recycle: newspapers? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 229 45.3 75.6 75.6 No 74 14.7 24.4 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14b Do you recycle: junk mail? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 185 36.6 61.1 61.1 No 118 23.4 38.9 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 C24 q14c Do you recycle: magazines? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 197 39.0 65.0 65.0 No 106 21.0 35.0 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14d Do you recycle: computer paper? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 105 20.8 34.7 34.7 No 196 38.8 64.7 99.3 DKlRF 2 .4 .7 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14e Do you recycle: cardboard? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 193 38.2 63.7 63.7 No 110 21.8 36.3 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14f Do you recycle: clear glass bottles? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 231 45.7 76.2 76.2 No 72 14.3 23.8 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q14g Do you recycle: plastic? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 245 48.5 80.9 80.9 No 58 11.5 19.1 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 C25 q14h Do you recycle: cans? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 237 46.9 78.2 78.2 No 66 13.1 21.8 100.0 Total 303 60.0 100.0 Missing System 202 40.0 Total 505 100.0 q15 Are you aware that the Roanoke Civic Center offers free shuttle bus service to supplement its parking for large events? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 417 82.6 82.6 82.6 No 88 17.4 17.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q16 Have you used this service? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 100 19.8 24.0 24.0 No 317 62.8 76.0 100.0 Total 417 82.6 100.0 Missing System 88 17.4 Total , 505 100.0 q17 Are you aware that the City has free wireless Internet access capability in the downtown area and in the library? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 300 59.4 59.4 59.4 No 204 40.4 40.4 99.8 DKlRF 1 .2 .2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q18 Have you used this service? Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 86 17.0 28.7 28.7 No 214 42.4 71.3 100.0 Total 300 59.4 100.0 Missing System 205 40.6 Total 505 100.0 C26 q19 Would it benefit you if City of Roanoke customer service information offered to citizens at the library and other City locations were available in another language such as Spanish, or Vietnamese? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 149 29.5 29.5 29.5 No 342 67.7 67.7 97.2 DKlRF 14 2.8 2.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q20_1 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Spanish Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 33 6.5 22.1 22.1 Chosen 116 23.0 77.9 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_2 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Vietnamese Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 118 23.4 79.2 79.2 Chosen 31 6.1 20.8 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_3 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: Other Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 113 22.4 75.8 75.8 Chosen 36 7.1 24.2 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 q20_ 4 In what additional languages would you like information to be offered: DKlRF Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 133 26.3 89.3 89.3 Chosen 16 3.2 10.7 100.0 Total 149 29.5 100.0 Missing System 356 70.5 Total 505 100.0 C27 q21 How satisfied are you with the overall quality of services that the City of Roanoke government provides? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Satisfied 109 21.6 21.6 21.6 Somewhat Satisfied 324 64.2 64.2 85.7 Somewhat Dissatisfied 56 11.1 11.1 96.8 Very Dissatisfied 14 2.8 2.8 99.6 DKlRF 2 .4 .4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q22 How safe do you feel in your neighborhood? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 258 51.1 51.1 51.1 Somewhat Safe 200 39.6 39.6 90.7 Somewhat Unsafe 30 5.9 5.9 96.6 Not at all Safe 17 3.4 3.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q23 How safe do you feel in the park or recreation facility closest to your home? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 162 32.1 32.1 32.1 Somewhat ,Safe 210 41.6 41.6 73.7 Somewhat Unsafe 33 6.5 6.5 80.2 Not at all Safe 32 6.3 6.3 86.5 DKlDon't Go There 68 13.5 13.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q24 How safe do you feel downtown? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 182 36.0 36.0 36.0 Somewhat Safe 231 45.7 45.7 81.8 Somewhat Unsafe 36 7.1 7.1 88.9 Not at all Safe 14 2.8 2.8 91.7 DKlDon't Go There 42 8.3 8.3 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q25 How safe do you feel in the City's parking garages? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 69 13.7 13.7 13.7 Somewhat Safe 219 43.4 43.4 57.0 Somewhat Unsafe 56 11.1 11.1 68.1 Not at all Safe 52 10.3 10.3 78.4 DKlDon't Go There 109 21.6 21.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C28 q26 How safe do you feel at the Civic Center parking lot? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Very Safe 196 38.8 38.8 38.8 Somewhat Safe 221 43.8 43.8 82.6 Somewhat Unsafe 21 4.2 4.2 86.7 Not at all Safe 12 2.4 2.4 89.1 DKlDon't Go There 55 10.9 10.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q27 Do you have regular access to the Internet? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 328 65.0 65.0 65.0 No 177 35.0 35.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q28 On average, how often do you visit the City's web site? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid At least once a day 15 3.0 4.6 4.6 At least once a week 41 8.1 12.5 17.1 At least once a month 67 13.3 20.4 37.5 Less than once a month 122 24.2 37.2 74.7 Never 83 16.4 25.3 100.0 Total 328 65.0 100.0 Missing System 177 35.0 Total 505 100.0 q29 Are there any services that are not currently offered that you would like to see available on the City's web site? Cumulative Frequencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 29 5.7 11.8 11.8 No 205 40.6 83.7 95.5 DKlRF 11 2.2 4.5 100.0 Total 245 48.5 100.0 Missing System 260 51.5 Total 505 100.0 q30 Do you receive the City's magazine called Roanoke Citizen, at your home? Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Yes 291 57.6 57.6 57.6 No 199 39.4 39.4 97.0 DKlRF 15 3.0 3.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C29 q31 When you receive the magazine would you say you usually... Cumulative Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Read it cover to cover 81 16.0 27.8 27.8 Scan the articles and read the ones that 147 29.1 50.5 78.4 interest you Flip through it but don't 48 9.5 16.5 94.8 read many articles Don't read it at all 15 3.0 5.2 100.0 Total 291 57.6 100.0 Missing System 214 42.4 Total 505 100.0 q32 On average, how often do you watch the City's Inside Roanoke television show on Roanoke Valley Television Channel 3? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid At least once a week 103 20.4 20.4 20.4 At least once a month 104 20.6 20.6 41.0 A few times a year 114 22.6 22.6 63.6 Never 178 35.2 35.2 98.8 DKlRF 6 1.2 1.2 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_1 What metl;lod of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: through a magazine mailed to you by the City several times a year? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 293 58.0 58.0 58.0 Chosen 212 42.0 42.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_2 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: through an e-mail sent to you periodically by the City? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 454 89.9 89.9 89.9 Chosen 51 10.1 10.1 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C30 q33_3 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by visiting the City's web site yourself? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 456 90.3 90.3 90.3 Chosen 49 9.7 9.7 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_ 4 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by watching the City's TV shows on RVTV Channel 3? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 416 82.4 82.4 82.4 Chosen 89 17.6 17.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_5 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: by reading the newspaper, listening to radio news, or watching news? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 184 36.4 36.4 36.4 Chosen 321 63.6 63.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33_6 What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: or some other way? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 476 94.3 94.3 94.3 Chosen 29 5.7 5.7 1000 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q33J What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government: DKlRF Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Not Chosen 502 99.4 99.4 99.4 Chosen 3 .6 .6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C31 q34a Agreement: City government employees are generally friendly, courteous, and helpful. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 174 34.5 34.5 34.5 Somewhat Agree 275 54.5 54.5 88.9 Somewhat Disagree 31 6.1 6.1 95.0 Strongly Disagree 17 3.4 3.4 98.4 DK 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34b Agreement: City parking facility staff are generally polite and responsive. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 158 31.3 31.3 31.3 Somewhat Agree 223 44.2 44.2 75.4 Somewhat Disagree 19 3.8 3.8 79.2 Strongly Disagree 9 1.8 1.8 81.0 DK 96 19.0 19.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34c Agreement: It is easy to contact the appropriate City government office when you need a particular service or have a question. Cumulative FreQuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 135 26.7 26.7 26.7 Somewhat Agree 202 40.0 40.0 66.7 Somewhat Disagree 70 13.9 13.9 80.6 Strongly Disagree 74 14.7 14.7 95.2 DK 24 4.8 4.8 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34d Agreement: City government employees provide prompt service. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongiy Agree 127 25.1 25.1 25.1 Somewhat Agree 267 52.9 52.9 78.0 Somewhat Disagree 51 10.1 10.1 88.1 Strongly Disagree 37 7.3 7.3 95.4 DK 23 4.6 4.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C32 q34e Agreement: City government employees treat citizens fairly. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 139 27.5 27.5 27.5 Somewhat Agree 270 53.5 53.5 81.0 Somewhat Disagree 38 7.5 7.5 88.5 Strongly Disagree 30 5.9 5.9 94.5 DK 28 5.5 5.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34f Agreement: Convenient parking at City government offices is generally available. Cumulative Frenuencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 52 10.3 10.3 10.3 Somewhat Agree 180 35.6 35.6 45.9 Somewhat Disagree 105 20.8 20.8 66.7 Strongly Disagree 118 23.4 23.4 90.1 DK 50 9.9 9.9 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34g Agreement: City government office locations are convenient. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 126 25.0 25.0 25.0 Somewhat Agree 242 47.9 47.9 72.9 Somewhat Disagree 65 12.9 12.9 85.7 Strongly Disagree 50 9.9 9.9 95.6 DK 22 4.4 4.4 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q34h Agreement: City government office hours are convenient. Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Strongly Agree 167 33.1 33.1 33.1 Somewhat Agree 223 44.2 44.2 77.2 Somewhat Disagree 55 10.9 10.9 88.1 Strongly Disagree 40 7.9 7.9 96.0 DK 20 4.0 4.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative Freouencv Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid 1907 2 .4 .4 .4 1913 1 .2 .2 .6 1914 1 .2 .2 .8 1916 2 .4 .4 1.2 1917 3 .6 .6 1.8 C33 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid 1918 2 4 .4 2.2 1919 2 .4 .4 2.6 1920 3 .6 .6 3.2 1921 6 1.2 1.2 4.4 1922 4 .8 .8 5.1 1923 4 .8 .8 5.9 1924 5 1.0 1.0 6.9 1925 8 1.6 1.6 8.5 1926 4 .8 .8 9.3 1927 3 .6 .6 9.9 1928 7 1.4 1.4 11.3 1929 4 .8 .8 12.1 1930 13 2.6 2.6 14.7 1931 8 1.6 1.6 16.2 1932 6 1.2 1.2 17.4 1933 7 1.4 1.4 18.8 1934 6 1.2 1.2 20.0 1935 4 .8 .8 20.8 1936 3 .6 .6 21.4 1937 5 1.0 1.0 22.4 1938 3 .6 .6 23.0 1939 10 2.0 2.0 25.0 1940 7 1.4 1.4 26.3 1941 12 2.4 2.4 28.7 1942 8 1.6 1.6 30.3 1943 7 1.4 1.4 31.7 1944 15 3.0 3.0 34.7 1945 7 1.4 1.4 36.0 1946 13 2.6 2.6 38.6 1947 11 2.2 2.2 40.8 1948 12 2.4 2.4 43.2 1949 7 1.4 1.4 44.6 1950 11 2.2 2.2 46.7 1951 15 3.0 3.0 49.7 1952 7 1.4 1.4 51.1 1953 5 1.0 1.0 52.1 1954 11 2.2 2.2 54.3 1955 9 1.8 1.8 56.0 1956 17 3.4 3.4 59.4 1957 8 1.6 1.6 61.0 1958 7 1.4 1.4 62.4 1959 4 .8 .8 63.2 1960 10 2.0 2.0 65.1 1961 10 2.0 2.0 67.1 1962 12 2.4 2.4 69.5 1963 6 1.2 1.2 70.7 1964 11 2.2 2.2 72.9 1965 9 1.8 1.8 74.7 1966 12 2.4 2.4 77.0 1967 5 1.0 1.0 78.0 1968 18 3.6 3.6 81.6 C34 q35 In what year were you born? Cumulative . Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid 1969 7 1.4 1.4 83.0 1970 5 1.0 1.0 84.0 1971 5 1.0 1.0 85.0 1972 4 .8 .8 85.7 1973 5 1.0 1.0 86.7 1974 5 1.0 1.0 87.7 1975 6 1.2 1.2 88.9 1976 3 .6 .6 89.5 1977 4 .8 .8 90.3 1978 2 .4 4 90.7 1979 5 1.0 1.0 91.7 1980 9 1.8 1.8 93.5 1981 4 .8 .8 94.3 1982 2 .4 4 94.7 1984 2 .4 .4 95.0 1985 5 1.0 1.0 96.0 1986 5 1.0 1.0 97.0 1987 5 1.0 1.0 98.0 DKlRF 10 2.0 2.0 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q36 Do you consider yourself to be White, African American or Black, Asian, Hispanic or Latino, or a member of some other group? Cumulative Freouency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid White 377 74.7 74.7 74.7 African American (Slack) 105 20.8 20.8 95.4 Asian 1 .2 .2 95.6 Hispanic (Latino) 3 .6 .6 96.2 Other 11 2.2 2.2 98.4 DKlRF 8 1.6 1.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C35 q37 Please stop me when I get to the bracket that includes your best estimate of your total family income before taxes last year. Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid less than $15,000 74 14.7 14.7 14.7 between $15,000 and 81 16.0 16.0 30.7 less than $25,000 between $25,000 and 68 13.5 13.5 44.2 less than $35.000 between $35,000 and 84 16.6 16.6 60.8 less than $50,000 between $50.000 and 70 13.9 13.9 74.7 less than $75,000 between $75,000 and 33 6.5 6.5 81.2 $100,000 over $100,000 37 7.3 7.3 88.5 DKlRF 58 11.5 11.5 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 q38 Gender Cumulative Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Valid Male 184 36.4 36.4 36.4 Female 321 63.6 63.6 100.0 Total 505 100.0 100.0 C36 Appendix D Responses For Open-Ended Survey Items Q13. Why do you not recycle with the City of Roanoke? ResTJondent # ResTJonse 3 They pick up different hems on different days, i1 is hard to keep track of schedule 4 None in area 5 In the habit of throwing everything away 6 Recycling attracts rats and other critters 7 Never called to ask to do it 13 Not sure of pick up day. Would recycle ifpick up schedule was provided 14 Don't take the time it's easier to toss it all together 16 Not enough stuff 18 Don't know 22 Don't know 23 No bin provided 28 Haven't done it for several years 29 Nothing to recycle 33 Friends told respondent that service was poor 37 Recycling bin went missing 38 Too much trouble 41 Has not been told how to 47 Has never been asked as far as respondent knows, husband takes care of all that 48 Would like to know how 52 They quit doing it the old way and it is too confusing 53 Respondent puts out paper they say they are picking up glass, when glass is put ou1 they say they want paper 55 Was told not to recycle 56 It is too much of a hassle and can't keep up with when they pick up 57 Not offered 58 Can't get one of the recycling containers, has called several times 59 Too much of a pain, containers too small 62 Nothing to recycle 81 They quit 83 Don't have the time 84 Do not have information on pick-up times, don't have a bin 91 They took our can. The trash collection moved from the alley to the front which causes many problems with bugs 92 Not offered in neighborhood 97 Not enough trash to recycle 98 Doesn't have much 101 Trash cans are awkward to use, too small to accommodate the quantity of recycled items 104 Don't provide it 106 It is not manda10ry III Just don't do it DI Q13. Continued. Respondent # Response 113 114 lIS 119 121 124 130 132 133 138 144 149 151 154 163 165 166 170 Building maintenance takes care of it Pick up issue, don'1 do regularly Doesn't empty the garbage Doesn't know anything about it Apartment does not recycle Disabled and alone They have just about s10pped in respondent's neighborhood Doesn't think the bins have been brought around No bins No bins Doesn't recycle much lust hasn't since moving four years ago Has just one trash can and no recycling bins No one to pick it up Don't have the time Called for a bucket but they will not provide one free of charge Apartments do not provide bins Pu1s i1 outside and it is not picked up. Can't pick it up if it gets knocked over Don't know Don't have a bin Not aware of process, no bins Has no bin Laziness Don't know how to start No bins Lives alone, doesn't have that much Too inconvenient It is a pain Time No good reason, just don't think about i1 No bins Husband had a run in with the people No particular reason Think it is silly Hasn't given it much thought Not provided with an opportunity Doesn't consume enough to recycle Not physically able Lately has not had the time, has been taking it to Cycle Systems No bins Doesn't have much Did at one time but it became too complicated with the sorting 173 179 180 182 185 189 191 192 194 198 199 202 207 211 213 216 219 224 226 227 232 234 240 241 D2 Q13. Continued. Respondent # Response 246 Doesn't need to and rides the bus 247 No bins 251 Apartments not big enough to keep recycling inside between pick ups 252 Lives alone and doesn't have enough 255 Lives in apartment that does not recycle 263 Too much trouble 274 Don't know 275 Too lazy 279 Don't produce a lot of waste, out of town often 280 Doesn't have much 281 Don't offer it with apartment 282 Too inconvenient 284 Doesn't separate trash 286 Too much of a hassle (don't come by and pick it up any more) 293 Just don't do it 297 No bin provided 298 Renting 300 Just don't think about it 310 Can't get the items out to the street due to age 312 Don't have the time 313 Don't use recyclable things 321 Don't have time 327 Don't have much to recycle 330 Not worth the effort, doesn't have much 331 Don't want to wash it before putting it out 333 Don't know 334 The way 1hey had it set up was hard to deal with 341 Don't usually buy the things that can be recycled 343 Recycles cans himself 345 Don't have much 10 recycle 347 Just don't do it 348 Takes it over to the county 357 They throw out 1he stuff and respondent can't find it 360 Don't have bin 362 Respondent moved and just hasn't done it 369 Lives in apartment complex 372 They don't make it easy to do 379 Landlord provides no bins 380 Lives in a housing development where the process is unclear 381 Keeping up with the schedule is difficult 383 Physical disability 386 Had bins but they quit picking them up 389 Don't know 03 Q13. Continued. ResfJondent # ResfJonse 400 405 409 410 412 416 418 419 420 425 427 430 431 433 435 436 437 439 445 449 452 456 460 466 467 468 469 476 477 484 487 488 489 501 504 508 511 514 515 517 518 519 522 Don't know Just moved in and don't know enough to do it ye1 Did at one time but not know, they won'1 pick up the bottles Used to when on the river but not in new home Private recycling Don't know Just not in the area to recycle Used to, too tiresome They took respondent's bin away Nothing to recycle Doesn't have recycling Don't have a container and don't know how to get one Don't have a bin Don't know Too much of a hassle Don't know Has moved and no recycling available Don't take the time Doesn't have bin Don't have the space Just easier to put things in trash No place to recycle items other than cardboard Done it already Don't have a bin 11 is a pain Don't pick it up Don't know Don't think about it Lives in housing projects Don't think about it Convenience Containers are not large enough Don't recycle with the City but recycle with the Boy Scouts Does not see locations for recycling No bins Lives in apartment complex Time Usually doesn't have anything Never really thought about it Just don't do it Don't know anything about it Lives alone, doesn't have that much recycling Recycling is a waste of time D4 Q13. Continued. Respondent # Response 526 Lives in apartment that does not recycle 529 Give it to the church 538 Church friends collect the items 540 Though1 that they quit doing it 544 Recycle in the trash 546 Don't produce a lot of trash 548 Just don't do it 553 Don't pick it up 554 Neighborhood has not been selected for it 555 Doesn't recycle 557 Don't know 564 Don't have much to recycle 574 Don't have much to recycle 576 Don't use that many things that can be recycled 577 Because they didn't give me a bin. They dropped them at every other house in my neighborhood 578 Not worth it 584 Not available on respondent's route 588 Nothing to recycle 590 Don't know 592 Too much of a hassle 596 Choose not to 597 Don't know 599 When services were changed, pick-up times became unclear. Respondent used to recycle all the time 602 Because they make it too hard 608 Has dumpsters (lives in complex) so not able 620 They don't pick up on a regular basis 621 No place to put the recycling bin 623 Don't think about it 624 Just have not taken the steps to do it 625 In an apartment 628 Lives by himself and doesn't have anything to recycle 632 Lives in apartment 633 Feels that she should 635 Not convenient 636 Respondent's son does 637 Has alternate me1hods for recycling D5 Q20. In what additional languages would you like information to be offered? Respondent # Response 411 African, Spanish, Haitian 203 All languages 342 Any 477 Arabic 104 Asian languages like Japanese 311 Bosnian, Somalian 73 Chinese 200 Chinese, Jamaican 134 French 276 French 421 French 639 French 123 French 121 French 5 French 508 French 300 French, Chinese 35 German 285 German, French 636 German, French 380 Indian 502 Indian languages 224 Indian languages 241 Jamaican, Brazilian 556 Japanese 274 Japanese 97 Japanese 357 Mandarin 427 More African languages 297 Phillipino, the Caribbean languages 294 Romance languages, Japanese, Chinese 208 Serbian 90 South African 633 Spanish 130 Spanish Q29. Are there any services that are not currently offered that you would like to see available on the City's web site? "Yes" responses specified. Respondent # Response 413 A detailed listing of indoor activities in the surrounding areas as well as the sights 480 Ability to submit building permits online D6 Q29. Continued. Respondent # Response 10] Areas and hours of road repairs Canine good citizens test Classes, pottery, art, dancing, etc. Free online bill payment Getting pedophiles off the street Housing auctions and other rea] estate information How much money they are spending for things they never do It should be promoted more, would use it if more aware ofwha1 it offered Looking for a car you have to go 1hrough all the cars to find a car in your pnce range More details about recycling, such as times of pickup, pickup procedures, what is accepted. Any type of cultural announcements that are Roanoke specific, not Civic Center specific, locally based cultural activities More help for single working parents More related to the school system. It would be considerate to publish what each classroom is doing since the teachers have to plan in advance. That way the parents could know what the children are expected to do Need to offer more for the seniors Needs more informational to the citizens about day to day activities and what is going on in Roanoke. More open and up front Recent updates of local sex offenders Restaurant reviews, Roanoke has good restaurants and those should be noted on the website Search function Services for maintaining the quality oflife, more things for college students Takes too long to find a job on the web site The ability to view persona] property tax or real es1ate tax bill amoun1s online The library does offer genealogy, bu1 only when you are on a site like Ancestry.com. The state ofKY has a system in the libraries to allow you to do it off site/at home The web site should allow for open discussion and comment and not bottle up the complaints There should be more accessibility on the web-site for citizens to give feedback to the City government and Council regardless if the feedback is positive or negative They could add more music links Transportation for the elderly When businesses have a "trading as" name it would be more convenient if they were cross referenced in some way Would like to pay bills online 278 206 ]50 446 468 ]23 ]78 259 360 79 94 52 338 30 ]68 455 54] 22 437 84 ]36 599 587 277 253 487 D7 Q33. What method of communication do you prefer for receiving information from the City of Roanoke government? "Other" responses specified. Respondent # Response 311 Billboards 541 Bulletin boards that remind people of the shows on RVTV Channel 3 45 Calendars 519 Calendars are good 401 From the Internet 231 Letters 474 Mail 573 Mail 402 Mail 50 Mail 164 Mail 235 Mail 463 Mail 464 Mail 576 Mail 219 Mail 227 Mail 91 Mail 477 Mail 380 Mail-- especially new laws 347 Mail a newsletter 274 Mailing letters 291 Newsletter 524 Newsletter 3 79 Newsletter 334 Newsletter 411 Newsletter 383 Talking to someone 42 Telephone calls Q36. Race/Ethnicity. "Other" responses specified. Respondent # Response 256 African American, White and Native American 431 Bi-racial (White and Black) 467 Brown 154 Cherokee and Blackfoot 588 Child of God 13 9 Greek 531 Mixed 468 Mixed 30 Mixed race, some Cherokee Indian, French and Black 311 Native American D8 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853.1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, VA Dear Mayor Harris and Members of Council: Subject: Roanoke Redevelopment Housing Authority Project Update This is to request space on Council's agenda for a 10 minute review of the above referenced subject. Respectfully submitted, ~ Darlene L. Bu ,cham City Manage ! DLB:sm c: City Clerk City Attorney Director of Finance CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, VA Dear Mayor Harris and Members of Council: Subject: Update on Street Restoration Standards This is to request space on Council's agenda for a 20 minute presentation on the above referenced subject. Darlene L. Bu City Manager DLB:sm c: City Clerk City Attorney Director of Finance CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fax: (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, VA Dear Mayor Harris and Members of Council: Subject: Zoning Ordinance Revision This is to request space on Council's agenda for a 10 minute review of the above referenced subject. Respectfully submitted, Darlene L. Bur City Manager ~ DLB:sm c: City Clerk City Attorney Director of Finance CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fax: (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, VA Dear Mayor Harris and Members of Council: Subject: New Parking Ticket Procedure This is to request space on Council's agenda for a 20 minute presentation on the above referenced subject. Respectfully submitted, Darlene L. B rcham City Manager DLB:sm c: City Clerk City Attorney Director of Finance CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #15-110-230 Judith M. St.Clair, Secretary Roanoke Arts Commission Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. St.Clair: This is to advise you that Edward W. Barnett has qualified as a member of the Roanoke Arts Commission, to fill the unexpired term of Mark C. McConnel, resigned, ending June 30, 2007. 7\~J.f~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew pc: Stephanie M. Moon, CMC, Deputy City Clerk Oath or Affirmation of Office Commonwealth of Virginia, City of Roanoke, to-wit: I, Edward W. Barnett, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support the Constitution of the United States of America and the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties incumbent upon me as a member of the Roanoke Arts Commission, to fill the unexpired term of Mark C. McConnel, resigned, ending June 30, 2007, according to the best of my ability (So help me God). W$/J' Subscribed and sworn to before me thiSU day of~ 2005. BRENDA L. HAMILTON, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT BYP'\ ~JJ~,^- ~ (~:tL~j\..!UEPUTY CLERK K:\oath and leaving service\Arts Commission\Edward W. Barnett oath05.doc CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK 215 Church Avenue, S.w., Room 456 Roanoke, Vrrginia24011-1536 Telephone: (540) 853-2541 Fax: (540) 853-1145 E.mail: clerk@ci.roanoke.va.us STEPHANIE M. MOON, CMC Deputy City Clerk SHEILA N. HARTMAN Assistant City Clerk MARY F. PARKER, CMC City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #110-543 Thomas A. Wood, Secretary Towing Advisory Board 2020 Mt. View Road Vinton, Virginia 241 79 Dear Mr. Wood: This is to advise you that Phyllis A. Johnson has qualified as a member of the Towing Advisory Board, for a term ending June 30, 2008. 'lA~ :JP~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew pc: Stephanie M. Moon, CMC, Deputy City Clerk Oath or Affirmation of Office Commonwealth of Virginia, City of Roanoke, to-wit: I, Phyllis A. Johnson, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support the Constitution of the United States of America and the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Virginia, and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties incumbent upon me as a member of the Towing Advisory Board, for a term ending June 30, 2008, according to the best of my ability (So help me God). ~Iit~ (L~I)(J Subscribed and sworn to before me this(iL day of.bm..L 2005. BRENDA L. HAMilTON, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT BY~fV\.\.~~~ ~^O\,~, DEPUTY CLERK K:\oath and leaving service\Towing Advisory Board\PhylJis A Johnson oath05.doc CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk December 8, 2005 Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk File #323 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of a resolution adopted by the Library Advisory Board with regard to the Comprehensive Library Study. The resolution was referred to you for report to the Council. MFP:ew S?\y~ }fJ~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk pc: Stanley G. Breakell, Chair Roanoke Public Library Board, 3256 Allendale Street, S. W., Roanoke, Virginia 24014 Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Sheila Umberger, Acting Director of Libraries L:\CLERKlDATA\CKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05\Oec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc CITY OF ROANOKE LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD A RESOLUTION URGING THE ROANOKE CITY COUNCIL TO BEGIN THE IMMEDIATE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ROANOKE LIBRARY COMPREHENSIVE STUDY WHEREAS, City Council commissioned a comprehensive study of the City of Roanoke Public Library System, and the Roanoke Library Comprehensive Study (Study) was received by City Council at its meeting of October 3, 2005; WHEREAS, although Roanoke is a vibrant community, which has been voted as one of America's most "livable" cities, the library system in the City and the Roanoke Valley is a quality ofJife element in which the City and Valley are clearly deficient; WHEREAS, the current annual appropriations for City library staffing, facilities, collections, technology and programs are inadequate; WHEREAS, the City allocates only $2.99 per capita for library collections while Roanoke County aIlocates $4.61 per capita and upper quartile peer libraries nationally allocate $9.79 per capita; WHEREAS, with the exception of the Law Library, all City Library facilities were built prior to the mid-1970's; WHEREAS, the City Library staffing level is .42 staff per 1,000 population while the national staffing level for public library systems serving similar base populations (100,000 to 250,0(0) is .74 staff per 1,000 population; 50021900011333213.1 WHEREAS, a healthy local economy is more and more dependent upon information technology and the growth of knowledge industries, and public libraries are an economic development tool, as well as an important ingredient ofa community's quality ofJife; WHEREAS, if Council's vision of "a community of stable, safe, healthy, caring and friendly neighborhoods" is to be achieved, then neighborhood libraries must be provided that are learning and recreational havens for Roanoke citizens; and WHEREAS, the Roanoke Public Library Advisory Board urges a meaningful and timely response to the Roanoke Library Comprehensive Study; THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Roanoke Public Library Advisory Board as follows: 1. The Library Advisory Board concurs with the regrettable fmding of the Study that City Libraries are under utilized because staffing, facilities, collections, technology and programs are inadequate. 2. The Study recommends that the City begin a phased program of funding the capital needs of the City Library System which are estimated to total $41.2 million ($37.9 million in facilities and $3.3 million in technology), and the Library Advisory Board urges that City Council immediately begin the process of designating funding for Phase I of the needed system capital improvements recommended by the Study ($6.6 million in facilities and $ 1.0 million in technology). 3. The Study fmds that an additional appropriation of $1.9 million per year will be required to meet the operating cost needs of the City Library System, and the Library Advisory 5002190OO/1333213.1 2 Board urges City Council to immediately adopt a phased program that will meet the operating costs needs of the City Library System as recommended by the Study. 4. Although the Library Advisory Board believes that merger of the City Library System and the COIUlty Library System would result in a more efficient and effective unified system, the Board recognizes that this goal may not be immediately achievable, and the Board urges close cooperation between the two systems, particularly with respect to the location of library facilities. 5. The Library Advisory Board wishes to express its appreciation to City Council for its continuing interest in the City Library System and for Council's careful consideration of the critical needs of the City Library System as documented by the Comprehensive Study. ATTEST: Stanley G. Breakell, President Library Advisory Board Date: 500219000/1333213.1 3 System Capital Cost Phase I NeighboorhQo<LCenter Kiosk Branch Renovation Allowance Full Service Branch Library Total Facilities 1 Technology . Collection Operating System .Radio Freq. Tags(308.106X .70) .SelfCheck out Stations (17X$22,000) .AN Allowance (ex:Safari Systems) . Computers(12 7X$ 750) . Kiosk (Information) .2417 Hold Lockers (2X$4500) Total Technology TOTAL CAPITAL COST Phase I .. $50,000 $200,000 $6,398,000 $6.648.000 $375,000 $215,675 $374,000 $ 24,075 $ 95,250 $ 10,000 $ 9,000 $1.103.0QQ $7,751,000 Additional Annual Operational Cost Staff (Adding 31 FTE) $1,238,000 Collection Development $ 355,388 Technology Upgrade Allowance $ 200,000 Special Program Allowance $ 200,000 Additional Operational CoSt2 $1,993,338 ll.and Cost not Included 2Cost are in addition to current 2004 funding levels of $3,364,721 ExHIBIT 6. RoANoKE LIBRARY CoMPREHENSIVE STUDY RECOMMENDATION OF COSTS FACIUTY COST ANAL VSIS To Illustrate the cost beneflt of coordinating the planning and library Administration functions of the City of Roan"e and Roanoke County, two capital expansion scenartos are presented. SCENARIO 1 (AI Oty 0' Roanoke PublIC Library capitol COst .ebIH..1 Neighborhood Cemer Kiosk SSO.ooO RenOVltlCNl Allowlnee 5200,000 Stomronl 1 . Full SeJYlce Branch a Library 56,398.000 Resource/Regional 3.. L1bnlry (72.500 sf) City of ROinote Annual Cost 16,648.000 CIIY' of Roanoke Building Cost Parking Car. (300Cllu) . I Storefront lease spac. 1 Assumes addition to an existing branch library J Land costs Is not Induded In constrUCtIon estimates .. par1c.lng cost for cemralllbr.ry IS not Included ROANOIai UtIIWlY COMI'IIQ1ENSM SlVD'I' ...n ~ ~U: McCoMII Page I CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 The Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council Roanoke, Virginia Dear Mayor and Members of Council: I would like to sponsor a request from Library Advisory Board to share with City Council a resolution on the Comprehensive Library Study. arlene L. Burc am City Manager DLB:sm c: City Attorney Director of Finance City Clerk CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #60-67-236-304 Jesse A. Hall Director of Finance Roanoke, Virginia Dear Mr. Hall: I am attaching copy of Budget Ordinance No. 37260-120505 appropriating additional funds in the amount of $12,464.00, for the Summer Food Program Grant, and amending and reordaining certain sections of the 2005-2006 Grant Fund Appropriations. The above referenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. SA'.,JP~ Mary F. Parker, CMe City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment pc: Darlene L. Burcham, City Manager Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget Steven C. Buschor, Director, Parks and Recreation L:\CLERKlDATA\CKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05lDec 05lDec 5 2005 oorrespondence.dac K IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37260-120505. AN ORDINANCE appropriating additional funding for the Summer Food Program Grant, amending and reordaining certain sections of the 2005- 2006 Grant Fund Appropriations, and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance. BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke that the following sections of the 2005-2006 Grant Fund Appropriations be, and the same are hereby, amended and reordained to read and provide as follows: Appropriations Temporary Employee Wages 035-630-5189-1004 Revenues Summer Food Program Grant FY05 035-630-5189-5289 $ 12,464 12,464 Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with. ATTE~ -) ~ ~Ierk. CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #60-67-236-304 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of Resolution No. 37261-120505 authorizing the City Manager to accept additional allowable reimbursements from the USDA Food and Nutrition Service, in the amount of $12,464.00, to provide for nutritional needs of children and youth during the summer months, as more fully set forth in a letter from the City Manager addressed to the Council under date of December 5, 2005. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. S~':, ;. p~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment L:ICLERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05lDec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc Darlene L. Burcham December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget Steven C. Buschor, Director, Parks and Recreation L:\CLERKlDATA\CKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCE\agenda correspondence 05lDec 05IDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc 7~ 'r~l \',\ IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37261-120505. A RESOLUTION authorizing acceptance of additional allowable reimbursements from the USDA Food and Nutrition Service in the amount of$12,464.00 on behalf of the City to provide for the nutritional needs of children and youth during the summer months, and authorizing execution of any and all necessary documents to comply with the terms and conditions of the grant and applicable laws, regulations, and requirements pertaining thereto. BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Roanoke that: 1. Additional funding from the USDA Food and Nutrition Service in the amount of $12,464.00 to provide for the nutritional needs of children and youth during the summer months, as set forth in the City Manager's letter dated December 5, 2005, to City Council, is hereby ACCEPTED. 2. The City Manager, or the City Manager's designee, is authorized to execute, and the City Clerk is authorized to attest, for and on behalf of the City, any and all requisite documents pertaining to the City's acceptance of the additional funding from the USDA Food and Nutrition Service and to furnish such additional information as may be required in connection with the City's acceptance of the foregoing funds. All documents to be executed on behalf of the City shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney. AI), "-f -J. P ~ City Clerk. 1,'."'.'i\;\']}.{i{I,. " I~ ' -.'!' , '-"'). " '\!c',",-~ .' . CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone. (540) 853-2333 Fax< (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Summer Food Program The City of Roanoke has continued to provide for the nutritional needs of children and youth during the summer months while the young people are out of school. Parks and Recreation Youth Services Division continues to supervise the Summer Nutrition Program. Breakfast, lunch and snack are provided to the young people throughout the City. Approximately 56,712 meals were served at 31 sites during this year, an increase of 4 sites from 2004. Administrative review stated - "very good review", "records were very easy to review, we compliment you on a well run program." Funds for the program are provided through the United States Department of Agriculture Food & Nutrition Services (USDA). The program concept is based on the National School Lunch Program with eligibility requirements determined either by census track or school location based on free or reduced priced meals during the school year. The purpose is to provide nutritionally balanced, healthy meals to children, ages one through eighteen and those with special needs. The City is reimbursed on a per meal basis. Local funds in the amount of $40,000, and federal funds in the amount of $143,315 were originally appropriated for a total 2005 Summer Foods program of $183,315. Due to an increase in allowable reimbursements from USDA, the City has received an additional $12,464 over the previous adopted amount. As a result, the revenue estimate and expenditure budget may be increased. The Honorable Mayor and Members of Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 additional funding will be available to begin the 2006 Summer Food program next year. Recommended Action(s): Authorize the City Manager and City Clerk to execute and attest respectively, any forms necessary to accept the additional funds, approved as to form by the City Attorney. Adopt the accompanying budget ordinance to increase the revenue estimate in account 035-630-5189-5289 in the amount of $12,464, and to appropriate funding of the same to expenditure account 035-630-5189-1004 in the Grant Fund for the 2005 Summer Food Program. Respectfully submitted, ~ Darlene L. City Mana DLB:MVH:na c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Steven B. Buschor, Director of Parks and Recreation CM05-001l8 CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC . City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #24-32 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of Ordinance No. 37262-120505 amending !l7-5, AdoDted: where copies filed, and !l7-35, Definitions, of Article II, Buildina Code, of Chapter 7, Buildina Reaulations, of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, to update code enforcement regulations. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5,2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. SA'"" J (J ~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment L:ICLERKlDATAICKEW1\AGENOA CORRESPONOENCElagenda correspondence 05IDec 0510ec 5 2005 correspondence.doc Darlene L. Burcham December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: The Honorable Robert P. Doherty, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable William D. Broadhurst, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Clifford R. Weckstein, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Charles N. Dorsey, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The HonorableJonathan M. Apgar, Chief Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable James R. Swanson, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Julian H. Raney, Jr., Chief Judge, General District Court The Honorable Vincent A. Lilley, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Francis W. Burkart, III, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Jacqueline F. Ward Talevi, Judge, General District Court The HonorableJohn B. Ferguson, Chief Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph M. Clarke, II, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Philip Trompeter, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph P. Bounds, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Sheila N. Hartman, Assistant City Clerk, (For transmittal by electronic mail to Municipal Code Corporation) Municipal Code Corporation, P. O. Box 2235, Tallahassee, Florida 32316 Ronald S. Albright, Clerk, General District Court David C. Wells, Clerk, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Kozuo Webb, Office of the Magistrate Lora A. Wilson, Law Librarian Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning, Building and Economic Development Karl S. Cooler, Building Commissioner Ford P. Weber, Director, Housing and Neighborhood Services L:\CLERK\DATA\CKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda carrespondenee 05IDec 05IDec 5 2005 carrespondenee.doc t ~\oS '/ \~f:; IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37262-120505. AN ORDINANCE amending 97-5, Adopted: where copies filed, and 97-35, Definitions, of Article II, Building Code, of Chapter 7, Building Regulations, of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, to update code enforcement regulations; and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance. BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke that: 1. The Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, is hereby amended and reordained by amending 97-5,Adopted: where copies filed, and 97-35, Definitions, of Article II, Building Code, of Chapter 7, Building Regulations. to read and provide as follows: Sec. 7-5. Adopted: where copies filed. The provisions, requirements and regulations contained in the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code (2003 ;WOO edition), and each of the component parts, including, but not limited to, the International Building Code (2003;woo edition), the International Property Maintenance Code (2003 ;WOO edition), the International Plumbing Code (2003 ;WOO edition), the International Mechanical Code (2003 ;WOO edition), the National Electrical Code (2002 -l-999 edition), the International Fuel Gas Code (2003 ;WOO edition), the International Energy Conservation Code (2003 ~ edition), the International Residential Code for One and Two-Family DweJlings (2003 ;WOO edition), and the International Existing Building Code (2003 edition), including all supplements to such component parts, as the same may from time to time be amended by the State Board of Housing and Community Development, are hereby adopted by the city and incorporated herein by reference as if set out at length herein. The Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code (2003 ;WOO edition), and its component parts, shall be controJling in the construction, reconstruction, alteration, enlargement, repair, maintenance, conversion or demolition of buildings and other structures O-CA-BldgCodeO I 2004 contained within the corporate limits of the city. Such code, or any of its components, shall be referred to in this chapter as the building code. Copies of the building code shall be kept on file in the office of the building commissioner and in the office of the city clerk. *** Sec. 7-35. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: * * * Building code means that portion of the building code entitled, "lGG International Property Maintenance Code", as referred to and adopted by reference in section 7-5 of this Code, and any amendments to, or subsequent editions of, the lGG International Property Maintenance Code. *** 2. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with. ATTf\~ J~ City Clerk. O-CA-BldgCodeO I 2004 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wish neff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Amendment to City Code Section 7-5 and 7-35 regarding building regulations Background: Effective November 16, 2005, The Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development adopted the 2003 edition of the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code (USBC) for the purpose of establishing minimum regulations to govern the construction and maintenance for buildings and structures. The provisions of the USBC are based on nationally recognized model building codes published by the International Code Council, Inc. and are made part of the USBC by reference. The USBC also contains administrative provisions governing the use of the model codes and establishing requirements for the enforcement of the USBC code by the local building departments and other code enforcement agencies. Considerations: Amending the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended (City Code), will reflect in the City Code the recent amendments to the Virginia USBC, by referring to the updated USBC sections which were adopted by the State and which are enforced at the local level. Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 Recommended Action: City Council adopt an ordinance (attachment) amending Sections 7-5 and 7-35 of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, to bring the City Code into conformity with the recent amendments to the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code. DLB:mmh c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Brian Townsend, Director, Planning Building and Economic Development Karl S. Cooler, Building Commissioner Ford P. Weber, Director, Housing and Neighborhood Services CM05-00176 CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #42-60-289 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of Resolution No. 37263-120505 providing for an amendment to the fees charged for use of market spaces at the Roanoke City Market, effective January 1, 2006; and directing amendment of the City's Fee Compendium. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council ofthe City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5,2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. MFP:ew Sincerely, /) A w..., .J. f/~t..~- Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Attachment L:ICLERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCE\agenda oarrespondence 05lDec 05lDec 5 2005 oarrespondence.doc Darlene L. Burcham December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: David Diaz, President, Downtown Roanoke, Inc., 213 Market Street, S. W. Roanoke, Virginia 24011 Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning Building and Economic Development Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget L:ICLERKlDATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05\Oec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc jJ,Y: IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37263-120505. A RESOLUTION providing for an amendment to the fees charged for the use of market spaces at the Roanoke City Market, with such changes to be effective January 1, 2006; and directing amendment of the Fee Compendium. BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Roanoke as follows: 1. As set out in the City Manager's letter to Council dated December 5, 2005, the market space fees for the use of spaces at the Roanoke City Market shall be, and hereby are, amended in accordance with the following fee schedule, which shall be effective on January 1,2006: DAILY PERMIT: · Monday through Thursday - $10.00 per space per day. · Friday and Saturday - $15.00 per space per day. PRIMARY/SHARED PERMIT: . SIX MONTH PERMIT: Six month permits at $35.00 per space per month. . SINGLE MONTH PERMIT: Monthly permits at $40 per space per month only during the months of January through October. . SATURDAY ONLY PERMIT: Six month minimum at $40 per space per month. · HOLIDAY SEASON PERMIT: (November 1 through December 31). Two month minimum at $75 per space per month. . SPREADING FEE: $5.00 per space per day. . CLEANUP FEE: Actual cost of cleanup per Section VIII (C) of the Market Handbook. 1 2. The Fee Compendium of the City, maintained by the Director of Finance and authorized and approved by City Council by Resolution No. 32412-032795, adopted March 27, 1995, effective as of that date, as amended, shall be amended to reflect the new market space fees for the Roanoke City Market as set forth above. ATTEST: /7 A~Jr~b City Clerk. . 2 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone: (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Proposed Fee Schedule Changes For Use of City Market Spaces Background: Downtown Roanoke, Inc. (DR!) handles the day to day operations for the Historic Roanoke City Market for the City of Roanoke. The vendors selling goods on the City Market currently pay DRI a monthly market space fee ranging from $35.00 to $40.00 and a daily rate of $10.00 per space. DRI uses fee revenues for DRI management fees and to fund operational and marketing expenses for the City Market. The fees were last revised in September 2003 with an effective date of January 1, 2004. DRI staff worked with the Market Rules Committee, which included several vendors, to evaluate and revise the fees for use of Market spaces, as well as revisions to the Market Handbook. On November 11, 2005, the proposed revised fees were approved by the Market Rules Committee. The DRI Executive Committee has also approved such fees. On November 18, 2005, a scheduled quarterly meeting was held with Market vendors, and they were briefed on the proposed revised fees. Most of the Market vendors are in agreement with the proposed revised fee schedule set forth herein. On November 15, 2005, the DRI Executive Committee, acting on behalf of the DRI Board of Directors, voted in favor of the proposed revised fee schedule. Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5,2005 Page 2 The effective date for such proposed revised fee changes will be January 1, 2006. Considerations: In light of the need for updating the market fee schedule and enhancing promotional efforts, which has been expressed many times by vendors participating in this process, the recommended fees are set forth below. The proposed revised market space fees would be as follows for each market space covered by such permit or license: DAILY PERMIT: · Monday through Thursday - $10.00 per space per day. · Friday and Saturday - $1 5.00 per space per day. PRIMARY/SHARED PERMIT: · SIX MONTH PERMIT: Six month permits at $35.00 per space per month). · SINGLE MONTH PERMIT: Monthly permits at $40 per space per month only during the months of January through October. · SATURDAY ONLY PERMIT: Six month minimum at $40 per space per month. · HOLIDAY SEASON PERMIT: (November 1 through December 31). Two month minimum at $75 per space per month. SPREADING FEE: $5.00 per space per day. CLEANUP FEE: Actual cost of cleanup per Section VIII (C) of the Market Handbook. Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5, 2005 Page 3 Recommended Action: City Council approve the market space fees for the City Market as mentioned above and amend the City's Fee Compendium to reflect the revised market space fees set forth above, with an effective date of January 1, 2006. Respectfully submitted, Darlene L. Bur City Manager c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Brian Townsend, Director of Planning, Building and Economic Development CM05-00177 CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk December 8, 2005 Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk File #60-72 Jesse A. Hall Director of Finance Roanoke, Virginia Dear Mr. Hall: I am attaching copy of Budget Ordinance No. 37264-120505 appropriating additional funding in the amount of $465,000.00 from the Commonwealth of Virginia for various Department of Social Services programs, and amending and reordaining certain sections of the 2005-2006 General Fund Appropriations. The above referenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5,2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. MFP:ew Sincerely, ~ I\~ ::J ~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Attachment pc: Darlene L. Burcham, City Manager Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Jane R. Conlin, Director of Human/Social Services L:ICLERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05lDec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc K IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37264-120505. AN ORDINANCE to appropriate funding frol'!l the Commonwealth for various Department of Social Services programs, amending and reordaining certain sections of the 2005-2006 General Fund Appropriations, and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance. BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke that the following sections of the 2005-2006 General Fund Appropriations be, and the same are hereby, amended and reordained to read and provide as follows: Appropriations Refugee Resettlement ADC Foster Care Special Needs Adoption Adoption Incentive Funds Subsidized Adoption IV-E Revenues Foster Care Refugee Program 001-630-5313-3150 001-630-5314-3115 001-630-5314-3130 001-630-5314-3131 001-630-5314-3155 9,000 232,000 81,000 1,000 142,000 001-110-1234-0675 001-110-1234-0679 456,000 9,000 Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with. Ani\~ ~~ City Clerk. CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Additional State Funding for Social Service Programs Background: Social Services, through our Foster Care Program, provides out-of-home placements for children who are in need of protection and can no longer live at home. For those children who are deemed eligible for Title IV-E funding, the Federal and State governments will reimburse localities for the costs of out-of- home placements at 100% of the maintenance, day care and visitation-related transportation. Federal and State funding is also available to assist with maintenance costs and special needs for adoptive families and assist with refugee resettlement. Considerations: The City of Roanoke will receive additional funding for Foster Care, Special Needs Adoption, Adoption Incentive, Subsidized Adoption and Refugee Resettlement for FY 2005-2006 in the amount of $465,000. Social Services currently maintains over 600 children who are in Foster Care or who receive some type of adoption assistance and the cost of providing services to these children continues to increase. Many of these children have difficulties which require special needs payments. Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 Recommended Action: Adopt the accompanying budget ordinance to increase General Fund revenue estimates by $465,000 and appropriate funding in the same amount as outlined below: Revenues 001-110-1234-0679 (Refugee Program) 001-110-1234-0675 (Foster Care) $ 9,000 456.000 465,000 $ 9,000 232,000 81,000 1,000 142.000 465,000 ADorooriations 001-630-5313-3150 (Indo-Chinese) 001-630-5314-3115 (ADC Foster Care) 001-630-5314-3130 (Special Needs Adoption) 001-630-5314-3131 (Adoption Incentive) 001-630-5314-3155 (Subsidized Adoption) Respectfully submitted, 0~ Darlene L. Bu cham City Manage DLB:icb c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Jane R. Conlin, Director of Human Services/Social Services CM05-00174 CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk December 8, 2005 Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk File #207-450 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of Ordinance No. 37265-120505 authorizing the City Manager to execute a Performance Agreement among the City of Roanoke, the Industrial Development Authority of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, and Faison-Southern Lane, LLC, that provides for certain undertakings by the parties in connection with the development of certain property located along U.S. Route 220/Franklin Road, in the City of Roanoke; upon certain terms and conditions as more fully set forth in a letter from the City Manager addressed to the Council under date of December 5, 2005. The above referenced measure was adopted by the Council ofthe City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5,2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. MFP:ew Sincerely, j) A~j.r~t< Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Attachment L:ICLERKlDATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 051Dec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc Darlene L. Burcham December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning, Building and Economic Development James F. Douthat, Attorney, Woods Rogers PLC, P. O. Box 14125, Roanoke, Virginia 24038-4125 Dennis R. Cronk, Vice-Chair, Industrial Development Authority, 3310 Kingsbury Circle, S. W., Roanoke, Virginia 24014 Harwell M. Darby, Jr., Attorney, Industrial Development Authority, Glenn, Feldmann, Darby and Goodlatte, 210 First Street, S. W., Roanoke, Virginia 24011 L:ICLERKlDATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda carrespondenee 05IDec 05lDec 5 2005 carrespondenee.doc p:l' , IN THE COUNCil- OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37265-120505. AN ORDINANCE authorizing the proper City officials to execute a Performance Agreement among the City of Roanoke (City), the Industrial Development Authority of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, (IDA), and Faison-Southern Lane, LLC (FSL) that provides for certain undertakings by the parties in connection with the development of certain property located along U.S. Route 220/Franklin Road, in the City of Roanoke; and dispensing with the second reading by title of this Ordinance. WHEREAS, FSL has proposed the development of certain property located along U.S. Route 220/Franklin Road; WHEREAS, the development of the site will require significant infrastructure cost for the site development in order to provide for retail activity; WHEREAS, FSL has requested an economic development grant through the IDA to assist in the unusual expense for development of the site; WHEREAS, City staff has advised Council that such Project will benefit economic development within the City and the Roanoke Valley; and WHEREAS, the City and the IDA wish to encourage FSL in connection with the development of the Project in order to enhance and promote economic development within the City and the Roanoke Valley. THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke as follows: 1. City Council hereby approves the terms of the Performance Agreement among the City, the IDA, and FSL, as set forth in the attachment to the City Manager's letter to Council K:\Measures\FSL Perl'ormance Agreementrtf 1 dated December 5, 2005, which provides for certain undertakings and obligations by FSL, as we1l as certain undertakings by the City and the IDA. City Council further finds that the economic development grant provided for by the Performance Agreement will promote economic development within the City and the Roanoke Valley. 2. The City Manager and the City Clerk are authorized on behalf of the City to execute and attest, respectively, a Performance Agreement among the City, the IDA, and FSL, upon certain terms and conditions as set forth in the City Manager's letter to Council dated December 5, 2005. The Performance Agreement sha1l be substantia1ly similar to the one attached to such letter and in a form approved by the City Attorney. 3. The City Manager is further authorized to take such actions and execute such documents as may be necessary to provide for the implementation and administration of such Performance Agreement. 4. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this Ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with. A~'^7J. ~ City Clerk K:\MeasuresIFSL Perfonnance Agreement.rtf 2 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wish neff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Performance Agreement for an Economic Development Grant: Faison-Southern Lane, LLC The City and Faison-Southern Lane, LLC (FSL), the developer of property located along US Route 220/Franklin Road (across from Lowe's), have negotiated an annual Economic Development Grant Performance Agreement. The Economic Development Grant will be funded by the City, but issued and administered through the Industrial Development Authority of the City of Roanoke, Virginia (IDA). Such grant would assist in the provision of necessary infrastructure to make the site developable including a heightened level of water quality improvements to the site's stormwater system and enhanced aesthetic finishes to certain retaining walls built adjacent to Franklin and Griffin Roads. The grant would also assist in the provision a new street extension with sidewalks, landscaping, street lighting, and related storm water improvements which will be dedicated to the City with connections to the Southern Hills neighborhood. In addition, FSL will fund the provision of a pad for the construction of a Home Depot retail store, all related pad infrastructure improvements, and facilitate the development of two retail outparcels. The project will provide additional tax revenue, jobs, and services to and benefit the citizens of the City and the Roanoke Valley in addition to being an economic benefit to the City. Consideration: The proposed Agreement outlines the obligations of FSL in order to qualify for and receive the grant. A copy of the proposed Agreement is attached to this letter. Some of the main provisions provide FSL must Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Page 2 December 5, 2005 complete the road extension with the connection to Southern Hills within 18 months after the date of the Agreement. Within 30 months after the date of the Agreement, a Home Depot retail facility will be opened to the public for business. FSL will have spent or caused to have been spent at least $4,500,000 on the development of the Project, including at least $1,768,825 on the street extension and related infrastructure improvements and enhancements as detailed in the Agreement. After the Home Depot store is opened, FSL can make up to ten (10) annual grant requests to the IDA under certain conditions. The various tax revenues, as listed in the Agreement, the City actually receives for the Property or Project must exceed $400,000 for the preceding grant year. If so, then FSL may make a grant request to the IDA for up to an amount equal to 50% of the amount of revenue the City actually received during the preceding grant year, subject to certain other provisions as set forth in the Agreement. However, the maximum amount of all grant funds FSL may receive shall not exceed $1,768,825. The Agreement requires FSL to provide the City and the IDA appropriate supporting documentation for each grant request. Funding for each annual grant request will be subject to appropriation by the City Council to the IDA. Recommended Action: Approve the terms of the Performance Agreement among the City, FSL, and the IDA, as set forth in the attachment to this letter, and determine such grant will promote economic development within the City. Authorize the City Manager to execute a Performance Agreement among the City, FSL, and the IDA, substantially similar to the one attached to this letter, and to execute such other documents and take such further action as may be necessary to implement and administer such Performance Agreement, with the form of such Agreement to be approved by the City Attorney. Respectfully submitted, ~ arlene L. Bu City Manager Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Page 3 December 5,2005 Attachment cc: William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Mary F. Parker, City Clerk Rolanda Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Brian Townsend, Director, Planning Building & Economic Development James F. Douthat, Attorney, Woods, Rogers Dennis Cronk, Chairman, Industrial Development Authority Harwell M. Darby, Attorney, Industrial Development Authority CM05-00179 PERFORMANCE AGREEMENT This Performance Agreement (Agreement) is dated , 2005, by and among the City of Roanoke, Virginia, a municipal corporation (City), Faison-Southern Lane, LLC, a North Carolina Limited Liability Company (FSL), and the Industrial Development Authority of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, an industrial development authority organized and existing under the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia (IDA), WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, FSL has proposed a development of certain property located along Southern Hills Drive, consisting of tax map numbers 5470102, 5470103, 5470104, 5470108, 5470109,5470110,5470111, 5470112,5470113,5470114,5470115,5480701,5480704, 5480717 and 5480718 (Property), on which FSL will construct a pad (Pad)for a Home Depot retail facility (Facility) and will also create outparcels; WHEREAS, the City recognizes the development of the Property will require significant cost for site development to attract substantial retail activity; WHEREAS, FSL intends to develop the Property by constructing streets, developing commercial sites and a Pad, and by leasing such Pad for the Facility, together with associated infrastructure, for businesses on the Property (Project). A drawing showing the Property, including outparcels, and the Project is attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit A; WHEREAS, a public road extension of Griffin Road (Road Extension) is needed to provide better access to the Facility and to the Southern Hills neighborhood; WHEREAS, FSL will construct such Road Extension in substantial conformity to that shown on Exhibit A and upon completion will dedicate such extension to the City, subject to the City's acceptance of the same; WHEREAS, FSL has indicated such Road Extension will allow for a significant investment to be made in the Facility and for the Project; WHEREAS, FSL has requested economic development grants through the IDA to assist in the cost of the Road Extension and other infrastructure, but not for the Facility; WHEREAS, the City and the IDA desire that the Project proceed and have determined that such Project will promote economic development within the City and within the Roanoke Valley. Such Project will provide additional tax revenue and services to benefit the citizens of the City and the Roanoke Valley; WHEREAS, the IDA, based on the undertakings of FSL, has determined to make an annual economic development grant for a specified period to FSL from funds to be provided to the IDA by the City, all in accordance with the terms of this Agreement; and 1 WHEREAS, the parties wish to reduce to writing the understanding of the parties concerning this matter. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties, in consideration of the promises and obligations contained herein, mutually agree as follows: SECTION 1. IDA ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GRANT. Subject to the terms of this Agreement, the IDA will make up to 10 annual Economic Development Grants (Grant), the total of which shall not exceed $1,768,825.00 to FSL in order to assist with the development of the infrastructure for the Project for the purposes of promoting economic development in the City and the Roanoke Valley. The IDA's obligations hereunder are not general obligations of the IDA, but are special obligations of the IDA limited to those funds which are provided by the City and received by the IDA under the terms set forth herein. SECTION 2. OBLIGATIONS OF FSL. FSL agrees and promises that in order to qualify to receive and to continue to receive the Grant for each grant year (as defined in this Agreement), FSL will do or provide each of the following: A. Within 18 months after the date of this Agreement, complete construction of the Road Extension and ensure such Road Extension meets the applicable standards and requirements of the City and/or the Virginia Department of Transportation and complete dedication of such Road Extension to the City, subject to the City's acceptance of such Road Extension. Such Road Extension will connect with Southern Hills Drive, Griffin Road, Roy Drive, Southern Lane and U.S. Route 220 - Franklin Road as shown in Exhibit A. B. Provide a letter of credit or performance security in a form acceptable to the City's Planning, Building and Economic Development Department and the IDA to guarantee the proper construction of and workmanship on the Road Extension and all other improvements in the public right-of-way for a period of one year from the date of acceptance of such Road Extension by the City. C. Within 30 months after the date of this Agreement, a Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., a Delaware Corporation, (HD) retail facility (Facility) will be opened to the public for business on the Property and will be developed and constructed in substantial conformity to the proffers accepted in Ordinance number 37159- 081505, adopted August 15, 2005, and any subsequent amendments adopted by City Council. 2 D. FSL shall enter into a 10 year or longer base lease with HD for HD to operate such retail Facility on the Property. FSL will provide sufficient documentation to the City and IDA of such lease agreement. E. 1. Within 30 months after the date of this Agreement, FSL will have spent or caused to have been spent at least $4,500,000.00 on the development of the Project as contemplated in Ordinance No. 37]59- 081505, adopted August 15, 2005 and any subsequent amendments to that ordinance adopted by City Council. The $4,500,000.00 will include the cost of items shown on Exhibit B attached hereto and made a part hereof, together with architectural, engineering and legal fees related thereto and all permits, licenses, water and sewer impact fees and off site improvements directly required for the development. However, the cost to purchase the Property and the vertical building improvements on the Pad, which will constitute the Facility, shall not be part of the required expenditure of the $4,500,000.00. Either the IDA or the City may request FSL in writing for documentation of the expenditure of the $4,500,000.00 and, if so, FSL will provide such documentation within 30 days of any such written request. 2. As part of the $4,500,000.00 expenditure, the amount of $] ,768,825.00 must be spent or caused to have been spent by FSL for the items set forth in Exhibit C attached hereto and made a part hereof. FSL shall provide verification of the expenditures for such items, and their related costs, referenced in Exhibit C by submitting invoices, statements and/or other documents and information to evidence the expenditures incurred and as listed on Exhibit C, which information shall be provided at 12 month intervals from the date of this Agreement. 3. Verification of expenditures submitted by FSL shall be sufficient to allow the IDA and the City to determine if FSL has met the expenditure requirements of Exhibit C and, if requested, Exhibit B. If the information submitted by FSL for verification of the expenditures of either Exhibit B or C is not sufficient to evidence such expenditure, either the IDA or the City may request further documentation, which will be provided by FSL within 30 days of receipt of the request for further documentation. All of the documents or information produced by FSL to verify such costs or expenditures shall be provided to the City and the IDA without cost or charge to either the City or the IDA. 4. Although specific items listed in Exhibit B and Exhibit C will have an estimated cost, as long as the total expenditures for the items set forth in Exhibit B amount to $4,500,000.00 or more, and the total expenditures for the items set forth in Exhibit C amount to 3 $1,768,825.00 or more, the required expenditures by FSL for each respective Exhibit will have been met. F. FSL will file all appropriate and applicable real estate tax and other tax forms or notices with the City, ensure it has received assessments from the City for such taxes, and FSL will have paid all such taxes to the City and not claimed any exemptions from real estate taxes or other taxes for any periods of time for which Grant funds are requested. FSL will also try to ensure that HD and any occupants of any outparcels file and pay all applicable taxes and fees to the City. SECTION 3. ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT GRANT. Subject to the conditions as set forth in this Agreement, the IDA will provide certain Grant funds, limited to those funds which are received by the IDA from the City, as set forth below, to FSL, in order to assist with the development of the Property and associated infrastructure for the Project as follows: A. At the option of FSL, it may request a yearly Grant for (i) the grant year starting as of July 1, prior to the date the HD Facility opens to the public (which will be a short year) or (ii) the grant year after the HD Facility opens to the public, provided FSL must submit a request to the IDA each year for such a Grant and provide the IDA sufficient documentation as to FSL's compliance with this Agreement. For purposes of this Agreement, a "grant year" means July 1 through June 30 (for example, if HD opens on January 15, 2007, FSL may select as the first grant year the period beginning (i) July 1,2006, to June 30,2007, or (ii) July 1,2007, to June 30, 2008). B. Such Grant may be requested for a maximum of 10 consecutive years, which will include the first Grant request. Furthermore, if no Grant request is made for the grant year mentioned above, such 10 consecutive year period shall be deemed to start to run from the grant year after the HD Facility opens and end 10 years thereafter. The 10 year period continues to run whether or not a Grant request is made for any particular year. All Grant requests must be submitted to the IDA between the period of September 1 and December 1, for the preceding grant year or no Grant will be considered or given for that particular year. For example, if FSL wants to make a request for the grant year of July 1,2006, to June 30, 2007, FSL must do so between September 1, 2007, and December 1, 2007. Also, in such an example the 10 consecutive years for which a grant could be requested would be July 1, 2006, through June 30, 2016. The City will cooperate with FSL by providing public information relevant to tax revenue received from the Property or the Project. C. Subject to the provisions of this Agreement, the amount of each Grant request can be up to an amount equal to 50% of the amount of revenue the City 4 actually received during the preceding grant year from the Property, the HD Facility on the Property, any outparcels on the Property, and any taxes directly related to any businesses conducted on such outparcels. subject to the limit set forth herein, directly resulting from the Property or Project and coming from real estate taxes, the City's portion of general sales tax (currently the local option is 1%), professional and occupational license tax, tangible personal property tax (inclusive of tangible personal property used in business), and prepared food and beverage tax. Any new local tax or increase in the rate of any of the aforementioned taxes for the purpose of dedicating the incremental revenue for a specific project or purpose shall be excluded from such amount of tax revenue resulting from the Property or Project. In no event shall any request be made or granted if the above total revenue for any specific grant year is less than $400,000.00. Furthermore, there shall be no carryover from one grant year to the next for any funds from the prior year or years or for purposes of determining the revenue for any grant year. Each grant year must be looked at separately to see if the requirements for a Grant request have been met. Provided further, for the first grant year, if the sales tax revenue to the City from the Home Depot Store located at 3217 Hershberger Road in the City declines from the total sales tax amount received by the City in the last full City fiscal year before the new HD Facility opens, I % of the amount of such difference of the total revenue from the Hershberger Road Home Depot Store for that year shall be deducted from the total revenue from the Property and Project for the first grant year. For the second grant year, if the sales tax revenue to the City from the Hershberger Road Home Depot Store declines from the total sales tax amount received by the City in the last full City fiscal year before the new HD Facility opens, 1 % of the amount of such difference of the total revenue from the Hershberger Road Home Depot Store for that year shall be deducted from the total revenue from the Property and Project for the second grant year. FSL shall provide the City sufficient documentation to establish the above sales amount for the Hershberger Road Home Depot Store. D. The maximum amount of all Grant funds FSL may receive under this Agreement shall in no event exceed a total of $1,768,825.00. Once this maximum amount is paid to FSL, FSL may not make any further Grant requests and no further Grant requests will be considered. E. By Way of Example only, assuming FSL has complied with its obligations under this Agreement, if the HD Facility opens on January 1, 2007, and FSL selects the short grant year, it would run from July 1, 2006, through June 30, 2007. If FSL wants to make a Grant request it must deliver such request to the IDA between September 1 and December I, 2007. FSL must show that the total amount of revenue the City actually received from the taxes referred to in the Agreement for the period of July I, 2006, through June 30, 2007, amounted to over $400,000.00, not including the deductions mentioned in the 5 Agreement. Then the following examples would apply, with some of the examples modifying some of the above assumptions: I. This example would apply for both grant years I and 2: Total applicable revenue received by the City Deduction for drop in sales from Home Depot Store on Hershberger Rd (Gross sales drop of $5,000,000 x 1%) (Note: If gross sales drop is different for the second grant year, this amount would change.) Amount of Qualified Revenue $402,000.00 $ 50.000.00 $352,000.00 Since this amount is below the $400,000.00 minimum required by the Agreement, no Grant request should be made and no Grant request would be approved. However, this would be considered the first grant year of the total of 10 years for which a Grant request can be made. 2. This example would apply for both grant years I and 2: Total applicable revenue received by the City Deduction for drop in sales from Home Depot Store on Hershberger Rd (Gross sales drop of $500,000 x 1%) (Note: If gross sales drop is different for the second grant year, this amount would change.) Amount of Qualified Revenue $425,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $420,000.00 Since this amount is over the required $400,000.00 minimum required by the Agreement, FSL could request a grant amount equal to 50% of the above amount of $420,000.00, which would equal a $210,000.00 Grant request. 3. This example would apply to each grant year after the first two grant years: Amount of qualified revenue received by the City $395,000.00 Since this is below the $400,000.00 minimum required by the Agreement, no Grant request should be made and no Grant request would be approved. However, even though no Grant request would be made or approved, this year will be considered as one of the 10 consecutive years for which a Grant request could be made. 4. This example would apply to each grant year after the first two grant years: 6 Amount of qualified revenue received by the City - $1,200,000.00 Since this amount is over the $400,000.00 minimum required by the Agreement, FSL could request a Grant amount equal to 50% of the above amount of $1,200,000.00, which would equal a $600,000.00 Grant request. SECTION 4. DISTRIBUTION OF GRANT FUNDS. Upon FSL's compliance with the obligations set forth in this Agreement, FSL may request in writing that the IDA obtain and provide the Grant funds mentioned above in accordance with the terms of this Agreement. Such request must be accompanied by sufficient documentation to establish to the reasonable satisfaction of the IDA and the City FSL's compliance with the obligations set forth in this Agreement. Upon receipt of such request, and approval by the IDA (approved request), the IDA will forward the approved request to the City Manager and Director of Planning, Building, and Economic Development. The written Grant request(s) from FSL to the IDA will be on a form approved by the IDA's counsel, such approval not to be unreasonably withheld. The IDA may disapprove any request that does not comply with the terms of this Agreement or require that a revised request be submitted. After the IDA approves a request, the IDA will make a written request to the City for the distribution to the IDA of the City's appropriation of such funds. The City will process such approved request within 45 days of receipt thereof, subject to such funds being appropriated. The IDA will make any approved payments to FSL within 10 working days from the date of receipt of the funds from the City, provided, however, that the IDA has no liability in the event the City delays processing the IDA's requisition. The IDA's obligations shall be limited to those funds which the IDA shall receive from the City and shall not be a general obligation, but a special obligation of the IDA. Furthermore, no Grant requests may be made by FSL or considered by the IDA after December 1 of the end of the tenth grant year or after the payment of the maximum Grant amount to FSL, whichever occurs first. SECTION 5. PAYMENT OF IDA'S FEES. FSL promises and agrees it will pay all reasonable fees, costs, and expenses of the IDA in connection with this matter, including any action necessary to collect reimbursement hereunder or litigation of any type, all of which includes the reasonable fees of the IDA's counsel. Payment of such items shall not be made from any Grant funds. The IDA will submit statements to FSL for such items and FSL will pay such statements within 30 days after receipt. SECTION 6. REPORTS TO THE IDA AND CITY. During the term of this Agreement, FSL agrees to report to and provide the IDA and the City on a semi-annual basis, on or before June 30 and December 31 of each year, sufficient information related to FSL' s compliance with the conditions of this Agreement 7 and to provide appropriate documentation to support such compliance. FSL also agrees to allow the City and/or its representative to inspect, audit, copy, or examine any of FSL's books, documents, or other relevant material in connection therewith upon written request by the IDA or the City. All such documents, information (including electronic data), or access shall be provided or made available within thirty (30) days of a written request from either the IDA or the City. SECTION 7. COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS. FSL agrees to comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, rules, and regulations. SECTION 8. COOPERATION. Each party agrees to cooperate with the other in a reasonable manner to carry out the intent and purpose of this Agreement. SECTION 9. SEVERABILITY. If any term of this Agreement is found to be void or invalid, such invalidity shall not affect the remaining terms of this Agreement, which will continue in full force and effect. The parties intend the remaining provisions of this Agreement be enforced to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law. SECTION 10. AUTHORITY TO SIGN. The persons who have executed this Agreement on behalf of the parties represent and warrant they are duly authorized to execute this Agreement on behalf of their respective entity. SECTION 11. COUNTERPART COPIES. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterpart copies, each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which together shall constitute a single instrument. SECTION 12. SUCCESSORS. The terms, conditions, provisions and undertakings of this Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each of the parties hereto and their respective successors and assigns. SECTION 13. NONDISCRIMINATION. A. During the performance or term of this Agreement, FSL agrees as follows: 8 1. FSL will not discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, religion, color, sex, national origin, age, disability, or any other basis prohibited by state law relating to discrimination in employment, except where there is a bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of FSL. FSL agrees to post in conspicuous places, available to employees and applicants for employment, notices setting forth the provisions of this nondiscrimination clause. u. FSL in all solicitations or advertisements for employees placed by or on behalf of FSL will state FSL is an equal opportunity employer. UI. Notices, advertisements and solicitations placed in accordance with federal law, rule or regulation shall be deemed sufficient for the purpose of meeting the requirements of this section. B. FSL will include the provisions of the foregoing Section A (i, ii, and iii) in every subcontract or purchase order of over $10,000, so that the provisions will be binding upon each subcontractor or vendor. SECTION 14. ASSIGNMENT. FSL agrees not to assign or transfer any part of this Agreement without the prior written consent of the City and the IDA, which will not be unreasonably withheld, and any such assignment shall not relieve FSL from any of its obligations under this Agreement. SECTION 15. INDEMNITY. FSL agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the IDA, the City, and their officers, directors, and employees free and harmless for and from any and all claims, causes of action, damages or any liability of any type, including reasonable attorney's fees, on account of any claims by or any injury or damage to any persons or property growing out of or directly or indirectly resulting or arising in any way out of any actions, omissions, or activities of FSL or its agents, employees or representatives arising out of or connected in any way to any of the matters involved in this Agreement or any performance thereunder. SECTION 16. FORUM SELECTION AND CHOICE OF LAW. By virtue of entering into this Agreement, FSL agrees and submits itself to a court of competent jurisdiction in the City of Roanoke, Virginia, and further agrees this Agreement is controlled by the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia, with the exception of Virginia's choice of law provisions which shall not apply; and all claims, disputes and other matters shall be decided only by such court according to the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia as aforesaid. 9 SECTION 17. NONWAIVER. Each party agrees that any party's waiver or failure to enforce or require performance of any term or condition of this Agreement or any party's waiver of any particular breach of this Agreement by any other party extends to that instance only. Such waiver or failure is not and shall not be a waiver of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement or a waiver of any other breaches of the Agreement by any party and does not bar the nondefaulting party from requiring the defaulting party to comply with all the terms and conditions of this Agreement and does not bar the nondefaulting party from asserting any and all rights and/or remedies it has or might have against the defaulting party under this Agreement or by law. SECTION 18. CAPTIONS AND HEADINGS. The section captions and headings are for convenience and reference purposes and shall not affect in any way the meaning or interpretation of this Agreement. SECTION 19. EASEMENTS. FSL promises and agrees to grant and dedicate to the City and/or the Western Virginia Water Authority all reasonably necessary easements on FSL's Property for the construction of infrastructure improvements needed for or benefiting the Project or surrounding areas, including, but not limited to, storm drainage, sanitary sewers, and/or water, all at no cost to the City and/or the Western Virginia Water Authority. SECTION 20. APPROPRIATION OF FUNDS. All obligations or funding undertaken by the City or the IDA in connection with the Project or this Agreement are subject to the availability of funds and the appropriation of such funds by City Council as may be necessary for such obligations or funding. SECTION 21. PERFORMANCE. If FSL fails to substantially comply with any of the obligations of this Agreement as determined by the City in its sole discretion, FSL will not be entitled to be eligible for and/or receive and/or continue to be eligible for and/or receive any such Grants or Grant funds as referred to above or in this Agreement. SECTION 22. NOTICES. All notices hereunder must be in writing and shall be deemed validly given if sent by certified mail, return receipt requested or by a nationally recognized overnight courier, addressed as follows (or any other address the party to be notified may have designated to the sender by like notice): 10 If to City, to: City of Roanoke, City Manager 364 Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, SW Roanoke, Virginia 24011 Fax No. 540-853-1138 With a copy to: Director of Planning, Building and Economic Development III Franklin Plaza, Suite 200 Roanoke, Virginia 24011 Fax No. 540-853-1213 If to IDA to: Chair, Industrial Development Authority Of the City of Roanoke, Virginia c/o Harwell M. Darby, Jr., Esquire Glenn, Feldmann, Darby & Goodlatte 210 First Street, SE Roanoke, VA 24011 Fax No. 540-224-8050 With a copy to: Harwell M. Darby, Jr., Esquire Glenn, Feldmann, Darby & Goodlatte 210 First Street, SE Roanoke, VA 24011 Fax No. 540-224-8050 If to FSL, to: Faison-Southern Lane, LLC Attn: Director of Real Estate c/o Faison Associates 121 West Trade Street Charlotte, NC 28202-5399 Fax No. 704-972-2698 With a copy to: James F. Douthat, Esquire Woods Rogers PLC 10 South Jefferson Street, Suite 1400 Roanoke, Virginia 24011 Fax No. 540-983-7711 Notice shall be deemed delivered upon the date of personal service, two days after deposit in the United States mail, or the day after delivery to a nationally recognized overnight courier. SECTION 23. FAITH BASED ORGANIZATIONS. 1 1 Pursuant to Virginia Code Section 2.2-4343.1, be advised that the City does not discriminate against faith-based organizations. Section 24. FORCE MAJEURE. A delay in or failure of performance by any party shall not constitute a default, nor shall FSL, the City or IDA be held liable for loss or damage, or be in breach of this Agreement, if and to the extent that such delay, failure, loss, or damage is caused by an occurrence beyond the reasonable control of such party and its agents, employees, contractors, subcontractors and consultants, which results from Acts of God or the public enemy, compliance with any order of or request of any governmental authority or person authorized to act therefore, acts of declared or undeclared war, public disorders, rebellion, sabotage, revolution, earthquake, floods, riots, strikes, labor or employment difficulties, delays in transportation, inability of party to obtain necessary materials or equipment or permits due to existing or future laws, rules, or regulations of governmental authorities or any other causes, whether direct or indirect, and which by the exercise of reasonable diligence said party is unable to prevent. For purposes of this Agreement anyone delay caused by any such occurrence shall not be deemed to last longer than 6 months and all delays caused by any and all such occurrences under any circumstances shall not be deemed to last longer than a total of 9 months. Any party claiming a force majeure occurrence shall give the other parties written notice of the same within 30 days after the date such claiming party learns of or reasonably should have known of such occurrence, or any such claim of force majeure shall be deemed waived. Notwithstanding anything else set forth above, after a total of 9 months of delays or failure of performance of any type have been claimed as being subject to force majeure, no further delays or claims of any type shall be claimed as being subject to force majeure and/or being an excusable delay. SECTION 25. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement of the parties and supersedes all prior agreements between the parties. No amendment to this Agreement shall be valid unless made in writing and signed by the appropriate parties. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Performance Agreement by their authorized representatives. ATTEST: CITY OF ROANOKE City Clerk Darlene L. Burcham, City Manager (SEAL) WITNESS: Faison-Southern Lane, LLC 12 By: Printed Name and Title Printed Name and Title (SEAL) WITNESS: INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA By: Dennis R. Cronk, Chair , Secretary Approved as to Form Approved as to Execution City Attorney Date: City Attorney Date: Appropriation and funds required for this Agreement are subject to future appropriation. Director of Finance Date Acct # 1 3 OCT-04-2005 09:52 ECONOMIC DEUELDPMENT 540 853 1213 P.02/02 /~ I L , /l : i, I . --t~'~'(~;~~~~;) ~t \~\ "<4~~::~~~::~:' jil/'III '1 \'1' --- ---::::~- I\~;..~~~ \~/) 1 if l! ~ (' v, . . \ S I \ .. ..._'--', " '----.... t! :....- \ \ '-0. "'.'-'- ;1' \" .0_) 0 \~.1 Ct \J \, , ot"<IlCC'oofot":"'CI(1""'",CoI ..." !li . = fllluun.lill II I / I . ' :jl:l.~i " I: Po I I, 'II' J ./"Ij I I i ~ \i I I;' ,',,' kll'- J', J /' I I . I r~., :-..' 1'___- _ __ r. h I I I -- .:- - ..~J- " , ." ....j- - -.#" Ii 'I' '(if : . __-..l _--I _--- /' ,1., ,"- '1- \ \..- I 1'1" I ..... li'I' 'fi'e:i' L----- ii, {' ! , J' '-11--: :1', 1:1 , ~ - 'C:: , .rill! (ri\ \ L-",-'\ \ ;1 . . ---..... \ / \ ) \ I ~ ~ \_.J-::;';'1~~~ r~ " i \.. \ ' \\~~~ , ~,\ \ " . I \~~ \ \'~~ \ i- \ ~\YL- \ '\, \~... ~..\' .......~ , ' . , " \ ,..., \~\.. !"\IIU'\:~ t.( \ . '\Hl1.Lu-'-J,"--: --~ _ ,J:.. i \::... .~ - - '-' - I.-.'.d ~.-:'11'.(C~. . \:7- ~"fffr'f1i . , \__-,,_C- UBI" .,",?~ l',U . I ,/1 il.ij "t i dlJ I '1 ' . << , ]raJhlrI/-ml.o ........ I 11"l',1, :~= ~$CNIf: PlAN I~~~~~ [ -:;'''G! _ , II M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LLC COMM # 2358.A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT CTY UNIT TOTAL NO, COST I, PAVEMENT I CURB I SIDEWALK: ROAD: Griffin Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM.9,5 (2" IQ) 3768 sv) TN 435 $70,00 $30,450 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25.0 /3" TN 670 $65,00 $43,550 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21-B), 10" Thick TN 2,620 $13.00 $34,060 SIDEWALK (4" thick) S.Y, 340 $30,00 $10,200 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L.F. 2,165 $15.00 $32,475 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG.2 L,F. 240 $15,00 $3.600 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F, 650 $50,00 $32,500 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F. 2,900 $1.50 $4,350 Old Griffin Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 (2" IQ) 785 sv) TN 90 $70,00 $6,300 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE. BM-25.0 3") TN 140 $65.00 $9,100 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.B), 10" Thick TN 540 $13,00 $7,020 SIDEWALK (4" thick) SY. 0 $30,00 $0 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L.F. 651 $15,00 $9,765 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 L.F. 0 $15.00 $0 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F. 0 $50,00 $0 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F, 300 $1.50 $450 DRIVEWAY APRON EA 1 $800,00 $800 Southern Hills Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE. SM-9,5 (2" IQ) 1202 svl TN 139 $70,00 $9.730 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25,O /3") TN 215 $65.00 $13,975 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.B , 10" Thick TN 800 $13.00 $10,400 SIDEWALK (4" thick) S.Y, 186 $30.00 $5,580 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L,F. 690 $15,00 $10.350 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG.2 L.F, 0 $15,00 $0 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F. 250 $50,00 $12,500 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F. 700 $1,50 $1,050 Roy Drive: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 (2" IQ) 621 svl TN 72 $70,00 $5,040 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM.25.0 13" TN 0 $65.00 $0 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.B), 8" Thick TN 328 $13,00 $4,264 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S.Y. 0 $30,00 $0 VDOT CG.6 CURB & GUTTER L.F. 500 $15,00 $7,500 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 L.F. 0 $15.00 $0 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F, 0 $50,00 $0 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F, 400 $1,50 $600 Franklin Road Turn Lane: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9,5 (2" IQ) 400 sv) TN 46 $70.00 $3,220 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25,O 3"1 TN 71 $65,00 $4,615 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.Bl, 10" Thick TN 303 $13.00 $3.939 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S.Y. 0 $30,00 $0 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L.F, 460 $15,00 $6,900 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG.2 L.F. 0 $15,00 $0 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F. 0 $50,00 $0 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F, 1,200 $1.50 $1.800 Subtotal: $326,083 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 1 016 EXBIBIT B.xls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LlC COMM # 2358-A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QTY UNIT TOTAL NO, COST SITE / HOME DEPOT: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 (2" @ 24,347 s TN 2.800 $70.00 $196,000 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25,O (3") TN 1,633 $65.00 $106,145 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21-BI, 10" Thick TN 12.000 $13,00 $156,000 SIDEWALK (4" thick) S,Y, 0 $48,00 $0 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L.F, 2.800 $15,00 $42,000 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 L.F, 2,600 $15.00 $39.000 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F. 10.500 $1.50 $15,750 CONCRETE PAVEMENT S,Y, 1,100 $65,00 $71,500 Subtotal: $626,395 TOTAL PAVEMENT / CURB / SIDEWALK $952,478 II, EARTHWORK: ROAD: CLEARING & GRUBBING AC 5 $2,000.00 $9,000 STRIP TOPSOIL AND STOCKPILE ON-SITE CY 2,500 $3,00 $7,500 Griffin Road: FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 18,500 $8.50 $157,250 CUT TO FILL IN ROAD AREA CY 2,000 $3.50 $7,000 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 0 $100,00 $0 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 300 $20.00 $6,000 Old Griffin Road: FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 0 $5,00 $0 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 1,765 $3.50 $6,178 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 100 $50.00 $5,000 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 0 $20.00 $0 Southern Hills Drive: FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 14,500 $8,50 $123,250 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 0 $3.50 $0 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 0 $100,00 $0 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 200 $20.00 $4,000 Roy Drive: FILL FROM ON-SITE CUT CY 0 $5,00 $0 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 1.500 $3.50 $5,250 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 120 $100.00 $12.000 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 0 $20,00 $0 Subtotal: $342,428 SITE / HOME DEPOT: STRIP TOPSOIL AND STOCKPILE ON-SITE CY 4,500 $3,00 $13.500 CLEARING & GRUBBING AC 11 $2,000,00 $21.000 FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 30,000 $8,50 $255,000 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 30,000 $3.50 $105,000 HAUL IN FROM OFF-SITE AND PLACE CY 0 $3,50 $0 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 200 $100.00 $20,000 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 200 $20.00 $4,000 Subtotal: $418,500 TOTAL EARTHWORK: $760,928 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 2 of 6 EXBIBIT B.xls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison ~ Southern Hills, LLC COMM # 2358.A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA NO_ COST III. STORM DRAIN STRUCTURES /INLETS: ROADWA Y / PUBLIC: DI-3B EA 15 $2,600,00 $39,000 DI-3C EA 2 $2.200,00 $4.400 FLARED END SECTION (18") EA 2 $1,600.00 $3,200 ROCK EXCAVATION / UNDERCUT LS 1 $5,000,00 $5,000 Subtotal: $ 51,600 SITE / HOME DEPOT SYSTEM: DI.1 EA 10 $2,200.00 $22,000 DI-3B EA 3 $2,600,00 $7,800 MANHOLE EA 2 $2,200,00 $4,400 HEADWALL EA 0 $3,200.00 $0 ROCK EXCAVATION / UNDERCUT LS 1 $2,500,00 $2,500 FLARED END SECTION EA 0 $1,600,00 $0 Subtotal: $36,700 TOTAL STORM DRAIN STRUCTURES: $88,300 , IV, STORM DRAIN PIPE: ROAD I PUBLIC SYSTEM: 15" RCP, Class III L.F. 987 $36.00 $35,532 18" RCP. Class III L.F. 110 $42.00 $4,620 30" RCP, Class III L.F, 0 $75,00 $0 JUNCTION STRUCTURE. A EA 1 $5,000,00 $5,000 JUNCTION STRUCTURE - B EA 1 $10,000,00 $10,000 60" UL TRA.FLO STORM PIPE L.F. 660 $200.00 $132,000 DOUBLE 6' X' 6 CONCRETE BOX CULVERT L.F, 850 $600,00 $510,000 HEADWALL FOR CONCRETE BOX CULVERTS EA 1 $5,500.00 $5,500 ROCK EXCAVATION / UNDERCUT L,S. 1 $5,000.00 $5,000 Subtotal: $707,652 SITE I HOME DEPOT SYSTEM: 15" RCP, Class III L,F. 216 $36,00 $7,776 18" RCP, Class III L.F, 301 $42,00 $12.642 24" RCP. Class III L,F. 666 $54.00 $35,964 8" PVC ROOF LEADERS / DRAIN L.F. 250 $18,00 $4,500 10" PVC ROOF LEADERS / DRAIN L.F, 600 $24.00 $14.400 ROCK EXCAVATION / UNDERCUT L.S. 1 $2,500,00 $2,500 Subtotal: $77,782 TOTAL STORM DRAINAGE: $785.434 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 3 of 6 EXBIBIT B,xls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LlC COMM # 2358.A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA NO_ COST V, SANITARY SEWER: ROAD I PUBLIC SYSTEM: MAN HOLE: 6 - 8' Depth EA 2 $2,800.00 $5,600 MANHOLE: 8.10' Depth EA 1 $3,500,00 $3,500 MANHOLE: 10 - 12' Depth EA 1 $4.200,00 $4,200 MANHOLE: 12.14' Depth EA 1 $5,600.00 $5,600 MANHOLE: 14 -16' Depth EA 1 $6.400,00 $6.400 MANHOLE: 22 - 24' Depth EA 2 $9.600,00 $19,200 12.' DUCTILE IRON PIPE L.F. 1,600 $75.00 $120,000 DROP CONNECTION V,F. 12 $30,00 $360 ROCK EXCAVATION LS 1 $2.500,00 $2,500 ADJUST MANHOLE FRAME & COVER V.F, 5 $350.00 $1.750 BACKFILL I GROUT EXISTING SS LINE LS 1 $2,500,00 $2,500 Subtotal: $171,610 SITE I HOME DEPOT SYSTEM: MANHOLE 8.10' Depth EA 0 $1,600.00 $0 MANHOLE 12.14' D"",th EA 0 $2,200.00 $0 B" PVC TRUSS PIPE L.F, 0 $38.00 $0 4" 16" SERVICE LINE L.F. 600 $18,00 $10,800 CLEAN OUT EA 8 $250,00 $2,000 ADJUST MANHOLE FRAME & COVER V,F, 0 $350.00 $0 Subtotal: $12,800 TOTAL SANITARY SEWER: $184,410 VI, WATERLINE: RDAD I PUBLIC SYSTEM: 6" FH ASSYW/6" GATE VALVE & LINE EA 2 $1,800,00 $3,600 12"x 12"x 4 TEE EA 0 $600.00 $0 12"x 12"x 8" TEE EA 0 $850,00 $0 12"x 12"x 12" TEE EA 2 $1.000,00 $2,000 12" GATE VALVE EA 7 $1,500.00 $10,500 12" 90 145 DEG. BEND EA 10 $400.00 $4,000 BLOW.OFF ASSY I AIR RELEASE VALVE EA 1 $600,00 $600 8" WATERLINE LF 0 $55.00 $0 12" WATERLINE LF 1,900 $75,00 $142.500 Subtotal: $163,200 HOME DEPOT SYSTEM: 6" FH ASSY WI 6" GATE VALVE & LINE EA 4 $1,800,00 $7.200 8.'x 8"x 6" TEE EA 1 $600,00 $600 8" GATE VALVE EA 1 $1,200.00 $1,200 8" 90 DEG. BEND EA 1 $400,00 $400 12" WATERLINE LF 200 $75,00 $15,000 FIRE VAULT & FIRELlNE LS 1 $10,500,00 $10,500 Subtotal: $34.900 TOTAL. WATERLINE: $198,100 VII, DEMOLITION I REMOVAL: ROADWAY PAVEMENT S.Y, 3,839 $10,00 $38,390 POWER POLES EA 6 $600.00 $3,600 48" CULVERTS EA 4 $2,500.00 $10,000 HEADWALLS EA 5 $550.00 $2,750 Subtotal: $54,740 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 4 of 6 EXBIBIT Rxls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, lLC COMM # 2358,A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA NO, COST VIII, EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL: INLET PROTECTION EA 40 $300.00 $12,000 CONSTRUCTION ENTRANCE EA 2 $3,500,00 $7.000 SILT FENCE L.F, 3,000 $3.00 $9,000 SEDIMENT TRAP EA 2 $3,200.00 $6.400 SEDIMENT BASIN EA 2 $6,000,00 $12,000 RIP-RAP S.F, 300 $12,00 $3.600 DIVERSION L,F. 2.000 $4,00 $8,000 CULVERT INLET PROTECTION EA 2.0 $2.400,00 $4,800 TEMPORARY SEEDING AC 10 $500,00 $5,000 SLOPE PROTECTION S.Y. 1.500 $2,50 $3,750 DITCH LINING: $0 -GRASS S,Y. 1,000 $0.50 $500 -RIP RAP SF 200 $12.00 $2.400 PERMANENT SEEDING AC 5 $600,00 $3,000 MAINTENANCE,10% L.S, 1 $7,745,00 $7,745 Subtotal: $85,195 IX_ RETAINING WALLS; ROAD WALL. ~': RETAINING WALL SF 6.131 $35.00 $214,585 ROAD WALL - '8': RETAINING WALL SF 3,508 $35,00 $122,780 ROAD WALL. 'C': RETAINING WALL SF 7,201 $25,00 $180,025 ROAD WALL - 'D': RETAINING WALL SF 800 $25.00 $20,000 Subtotal: $537,390 X, LANDSCAPING: ROAD: TREES EA 52 $300,00 $15,600 SHRUBS EA 48 $100.00 $4,800 GROUND COVER SF 3,600 $2,00 $7,200 Subtotal: $27,600 HOME OEPOT SITE: TREES EA 55 $300,00 $16,500 SHRUBS EA 220 $100.00 $22,000 GROUND COVER SF 10,000 $2,00 $20.000 IRRIGATION LS 1 $40,000,00 $40,000 Subtotal: $98,500 TOTAL LANDSCAPING: $126,100 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 5 016 EXBIBIT B.xls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT B SITE DEVELOPMENT COST SUMMARY PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LLC Southern Hills I Home Depot City of Roanoke, VA Mattern & Craig COMM # 2358-A LOCATION: BY: DATE: CHKD BY: 11/14/2005 WTA DESCRIPTION TOTAL EA 8 $3,200,00 $25,600 LF 2,100 $4.00 $8.400 LF 4,200 $1.75 $7,350 Subtotal: $41,350 HOME DEPOT SITE: POLES WI FIXTURE EA 12 $3,200,00 CONDUIT LF 2.160 $4.00 CONDUCTOR LF 4,320 $1.75 MISCELLANEOUS: NEIGHBORHOOD SIGN FLOODPLAIN REVISION & CLOMR ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES I MITIGATION TEMPORARY UTILITIES POWERLlNE I POLE RELOCATION AEP TRAFFIC SIGNAL MODIFICATIONS STORM WATER DETENTION WATER QUALITY TRAFFIC SIGNAGE . ROAD TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL FOR ROAD Subtotal: LS LS LS LS LS LS LS LS LS $5,500.00 $15,000.00 $100,000,00 $10,000,00 $170,000.00 $25,000,00 $150,000,00 $1,500,00 $30,000,00 $5,500 $15,000 $100,000 $10,000 $170,000 $25,000 $150.000 $1,500 $30,000 $507,000 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 6 of 6 EXBIBIT B,xls M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT C EXTRAORDINARY SITE DEVELOPMENT COST PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LlC COMM # 2358.A Southern Hills I Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 1111412005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT QTY UNIT TOTAL NO, COST I, PAVEMENT / CURB I SIDEWALK: ROAD: Griffin Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 12" @ 3768 sv) TN 435 $70,00 $30.450 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25,O 13") TN 670 $65.00 $43,550 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.B), 10" Thick TN 2,620 $13.00 $34,060 SIDEWALK 14" thick S.Y, 340 $30,00 $10,200 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER L,F, 2.165 $15,00 $32.475 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG.2 L.F. 240 $15,00 $3.600 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS LF. 650 $50,00 $32,500 PAVEMENT MARKINGS LF, 2,900 $1.50 $4,350 Old Griffin Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 2" @ 785 sV) TN 90 $70,00 $6,300 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25.0 13") TN 140 $65,00 $9,100 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I 1#21.B), 10" Thick TN 540 $13,00 $7.020 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S.Y. $30,00 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER LF. 651 $15.00 $9,765 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 LF. $15.00 GUARD RAIL w/ END SECTIONS L.F, $50.00 PAVEMENT MARKINGS LF. 300 $1.50 $450 DRIVEWAY APRON EA 1 $800.00 $800 Southern Hills Road: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9,5 (2"!iiJ 1202 svl TN 139 $70.00 $9,730 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25,O (3") TN 215 $65,00 $13,975 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE 11#21-B), 10" Thick TN 800 $13,00 $10.400 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S,Y. 186 $30,00 $5.580 VDOT CG.6 CURB & GUTTER LF. 690 $15,00 $10,350 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 LF. $15.00 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L,F, 250 $50.00 $12,500 PAVEMENT MARKINGS L.F, 700 $1,50 $1.050 Rov Drive: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM.9,5 (2" !iiJ 621 sv\ TN 72 $70.00 $5,040 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM.25.0 13"1 TN $65,00 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21-B\, 8" Thick TN 328 $13.00 $4.264 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S.Y, $30,00 VDOT CG.6 CURB & GUTTER L.F, 500 $15.00 $7,500 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 L.F. $15,00 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS LF. $50,00 PAVEMENT MARKINGS LF, 400 $1.50 $600 Franklin Road Turn Lane: ASPHALT CONCRETE, SM-9.5 (2" @ 400 sv) TN 46 $70,00 $3,220 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, BM-25.0 3"\ TN 71 $65,00 $4.615 AGGREGATE BASE, TYPE I (#21.B), 10" Thick TN 303 $13,00 $3,939 SIDEWALK 14" thick) S,Y. $30,00 VDOT CG-6 CURB & GUTTER LF. 460 $15,00 $6.900 VDOT CURB & GUTTER CG-2 L,F. $15,00 GUARD RAIL wi END SECTIONS L.F, $50.00 PAVEMENT MARKINGS LF. 1,200 $1,50 $1,800 TOTAL PAVEMENT / CURB / SIDEWALK $326,083 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 1 of 3 M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT C EXTRAORDINARY SITE DEVELOPMENT COST PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LLC COMM # 2358-A Southern Hills J Home Depot LOCATION: City of Roanoke, VA DATE: 11/14/2005 BY: Mattern & Craig CHKD BY: WTA NO, COST II, EARTHWORK: ROAD: CLEARING & GRUBBING AC 5 $2.000,00 $9,000 STRIP TOPSOIL AND STOCKPILE ON,SITE CY 2,500 $3,00 $7.500 Griffin Road: FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 18,500 $8.50 $157,250 CUT TO FILL IN ROAD AREA CY 2,000 $3,50 $7.000 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY $100,00 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 300 $20.00 $6,000 Old Griffin Road: FILL FROM OFF.SITE BORROW CY $5,00 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 1.765 $3.50 $6,178 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 100 $50,00 $5.000 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY $20,00 Southern Hills Drive: FILL FROM OFF-SITE BORROW CY 14,500 $8.50 $123,250 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY $3,50 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY $100,00 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY 200 $20,00 $4.000 Rov Drive: FILL FROM ON-SITE CUT CY $5.00 CUT TO FILL IN SITE AREA CY 1,500 $3.50 $5,250 ROCK ALLOWANCE CY 120 $100.00 $12,000 UNDERCUT ALLOWANCE CY $20,00 III, STORM DRAIN STRUCTURES 1 INLETS: ROADWA Y / PUBLIC: DI-3B EA 15 $2.600.00 $39,000 DI.3C EA 2 $2,200,00 $4,400 FLARED END SECTION 18") EA 2 $1,600,00 $3,200 ROCK EXCAVATION 1 UNDERCUT LS 1 $5,000.00 $5,000 TOTAL STORM DRAIN STRUCTURES: $51,600 IV, STORM DRAIN PIPE: ROAD 1 PUBLIC SYSTEM: 15" RCP, Class III LF. 987 $36,00 $35,532 18" RCP, Class III L.F, 110 $42,00 $4,620 30" RCP, Class III LF. $75.00 JUNCTION STRUCTURE. A EA 1 $5,000,00 $5.000 JUNCTION STRUCTURE - B EA 1 $10,000,00 $10,000 60" UL TRA-FLO STORM PIPE L.F. 660 $200.00 $132.000 DOUBLEI I I LF, 850 $600,00 $510,000 HEADWALL FOR CONCRETE BOX CULVERTS EA 1 $5,500,00 $5,500 ROCK EXCAVATION / UNDERCUT L.S. 1 $5.000,00 $5,000 TOTAL STORM DRAINAGE: $707,652 11/21/2005/4:49 PM Page 2 of 3 M&C FORM #107 EXHIBIT C EXTRAORDINARY SITE DEVELOPMENT COST PROJECT: Faison - Southern Hills, LLC Southern Hills I Home Depot City of Roanoke, VA Mattern & Craig COMM # 2358-A LOCATION: BY: DATE: CHKD BY: 11/1412005 WTA DESCRIPTION TOTAL 11121/2005/4:49 PM Page 3 of 3 Attachment to Exhibit - C Extraordinary Development Cost Home Depot, South Roanoke, Virginia November 23, 2005 1, Purpose: a, The purpose of this document is to demonstrate and/or provide additional justification for consideration of certain items as extraordinary development cost items, 2, Items: a, Roadway and Site Retaining Walls 1. WallA (1) Located along the western edge of Southern Hills Drive, the north propertyline of the outparcel, and the right-of-way of Franklin Road and Griffin Road - this wall is required to permit the reconstruction of Southern Hills Drive and Griffin Road to the grade and alignment as presented, (2) Key factors are: (I) the grade at the intersection Southern Hills Drive and Griffin Road was raised 6' - 8' in order to meet minimum grade requirements (12,5%) requested by the Planning Commission, and (2) without the wall it would be necessary to extend the box culvert an additional 300' and fill in Ore Branch Tributary_ (3) Since this wall is the gateway to the development, the developer is proposing the following aesthetic enhancements to this wall; (I) Select material for the wall facing ("Country Manor" stone by Keystone), (2) Pilaster to break the face vertically, decorative fencing along the top, and extensive landscaping along the wall face, (4) Benefits to the public include providing Planning Commission approved grades on Southern Hills Drive and Griffin Road, and preservation of portions of existing Ore Branch Tributary, (5) Total Anticipated Cost = $214,585, ( 6) We are requesting that 50% of this cost be considered as extraordinary cost, Requested consideration = $107,293, II, Wall B (I) Located along Franklin and Griffin Road and the project site at the main entrance, (2) The wall is required to construct Griffin Road to the alignment and grade presented and to permit the Home Depot site to respond to the grades along Franklin Road (12' vertical rise), Extraordinary Development Cost Home Depot, South Roanoke, Virginia November 23, 2005 Page 2 of 3 (3) Since this wall is the gateway to the development, the developer is proposing the following aesthetic enhancements to this wall; (I) Select material for the wall facing ("Country Manor" stone by Keystone), (2) Pilaster to break the face vertically, decorative fencing along the top, and extensive landscaping along the wall face, (4) Benefits to the public include providing Planning Commission approved grades on Griffin Road, aesthetic upgrades of the wall face, and increased screening of Home Depot building, (5) Total Anticipated Cost ~ $122,780, Due to the extensive aesthetic enhancements proposed, we are requesting that 50% of this cost be considered as extraordinary cost. Requested consideration ~ $35,080, b, Stonnwater Management & Water Quality Enhancements 1. The project proposes to implement stonnwater management (detention) that meets or exceeds the City requirements_ In addition, the project proposed to implement water quality enhancement measures currently not required by City Code, ii, Special conditions of the project site include: (I) stonnwater runoff from Hunting Hills and Pheasant Ridge run through the project site, and (2) stonnwater runoff from Southern Hills neighborhood runs through the site, This stonnwater must be accommodate on this site and "passed through," the site stonnwater system, iii, Detention for the Home Depot site will be provided through an underground detention system, A surface detention pond will not be constructed, This will improve appearance of the site and minimize or eliminate issues related to surface ponds (e_g, stagnant water, fencing, security and safety), Extraordinary Development Cost Home Depot, South Roanoke, Virginia November 23, 2005 Page 3 of 3 IV, Water Quality enhancements will be provided through the use of Sand Filters conforming to Minimum Standard 3,12 of the Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook, First Edition, 1999, The sand filters consist of three components: (I) Grit & Oil Chamber - will allow grease and oil and hydrocarbons to "float" within the chamber and separate from the main flow while grit and other non-floatable solids settle to the bottom of the chamber. The chamber uses two separation walls and a series of orifices and weirs to control the flow, (2) Sand Filter Chamber - the sand filter chamber is a dual media filter which uses clean sand (ASTM C-33 Concrete Sand) and washed gravel (Vi" to 2") to filter the stormwater runoff via a slow gravity filtering method, The sand chamber is underlaid with perforated HOPE pipe and is wrapped in filter fabric, (3) Clear Well - the clear well provides an inspection and sampling point for the filtered discharge and provides and access point to clean and maintain the system, v, Total Anticipated Cost = $150,000, We are requesting that 50% of this cost be considered as Exceptional Cost. Requested consideration = $75,000, CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M, Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #22-373 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Burcham: I am attaching copy of Ordinance No.3 7266-120505 authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the Lease Agreement dated June 5, 2001, between the City of Roanoke and the Commonwealth of Virginia, by the Department of Health to extend the term of the current lease agreement by one year, with an expiration date of June 30, 2006, and an option to renew on a month-to-month basis for an additional one year period, for office space located at 515 and 530 8'hStreet, S. W" for the Virginia Department of Health, upon certain terms and conditions, as more fully set forth in a letter from the City Manager dated December 5, 2005, to the Council. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5,2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. Sincerely, j f2~L ,_, - n~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment L:ICLERKlDATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 051Dec 051Dec 5 2005 correspondence,doc Darlene L. Burcham December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Sherman M. Stovall, Director, Office of Management and Budget Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning Building and Economic Development Lisa Poindexter-Plaia, Economic Development Specialist L:ICLERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05IDec 05IDec 5 2005 correspondence,doc ,,~ IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37266-120505. AN ORDINANCE authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the Lease Agreement dated June 5, 2001, between the City of Roanoke and the Commonwealth of Virginia, by the Department of Health ("VDH"), to extend the term of the current lease agreement by one year, with an expiration date of June 30, 2006, and the option to renew on a month-to-month basis for an additional one year period, for office space located at 515 and 530 8th Street for the VDH, upon certain terms and conditions, and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance_ BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke as follows: 1, The City Manager and City Clerk are hereby authorized to execute and attest, respectively, on behalf of the City, in form approved by the City Attorney, an amendment to the Lease Agreement dated June 5, 2001, between the City of Roanoke and the Commonwealth of Virginia, by the VDH, to extend the term of the current lease agreement by one year, with an expiration date of June 30, 2006, and the option to renew on a month-to-month basis for an additional one year period, for office space located at 515 and 530 8th Street for the VDH, at a lease fee of $38,950,00 per quarter, and if the lease is extended past the one year period on a month-to- month basis rent will be paid monthly in the amount of $12,983.33, as more particularly set forth in the City Manager's letter dated December 5, 2005, to this Council. 2_ Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with, AA: ~-J ~ City Clerk. K:\ORDINANCES\O-LEASEAMEND-HEALTHDEPTI20~05.DOC CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S,W" Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice-Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Lease of City Owned Property at 51 5 and 530 8th Street Background: The City of Roanoke and the Commonwealth of Virginia, by the Virginia Department of Health (VDH), entered into a Lease Agreement dated June 5, 2001, granting the Virginia Department of Health permission to lease City owned office space located at 515 and 530 8th Street in the City of Roanoke. The term of this Lease Agreement began July 1, 2001, and terminated June 30, 2004. The VDH and the City of Roanoke amended this lease to extend the term by one (1) year, which established a new expiration date of June 30, 2005, The Virginia Department of Health has leased this space from the City of Roanoke for a number of years prior to this most recent Lease. VDH has continued to occupy such office space and desires to continue leasing the space for another year as the build out of new space for the VDH proceeds at the Civic Mall facility on Williamson Road. Considerations: The VDH has proposed amending the current Lease Agreement to extend the term by one (1) year, retroactive to July 1, 2005, and which will Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council Page 2 December 5, 2005 establish a new expiration date of June 30, 2006, with the option to renew on a month-to-month basis for a period of up to one (1) additional year. All other terms and conditions of the Lease will remain unchanged. The VDH will continue to pay rent in the amount of $38,950.00 per quarter for the one (1) year extension. If the Lease is extended past the June 30, 2006, date, it will be on a month-to-month basis for up to an additional twelve months, and rent will be paid monthly in the amount of $12,983.33 Recommended Action: Authorize the City Manager to execute the appropriate documents, approved as to form by the City Attorney, to amend the Lease Agreement dated June 5, 2001, to lease City owned space located at 515 and 530 8'h Street, to the Commonwealth of Virginia for use by the Virginia Department of Health. The proposed Amendment shall be in accordance with the provisions outlined in the Second Amendment to Deed of Lease, a copy of which is attached, Respectfully submitted, Darlene L. Bu City Manage DLB:lpp c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M, Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Rolanda Russell, Assistant City Manager Brian Townsend, Director Planning, Building and Economic Development David Collins, Assistant City Attorney Lisa Poindexter-Plaia, Economic Development Specialist CM05-00175 DGS Lease Amendment Form June 10,2004 Lease #601-L-425 SECOND AMENDMENT TO DEED OF LEASE This Second Amendment to Deed of Lease (the "Amendment"), dated . 20 , is made part of the Deed of Lease dated June 5, 2001, (the "Lease") by and between the CITY OF ROANOKE, as Lessor, and the COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA, by the Department of Health, as Lessee, WITNESSETH WHEREAS, by the terms of the Lease, Lessor leased to Lessee those certain parcels ofland situated in the city of Roanoke, Virginia 24016 known as 515 and 530 Eight Street, SW, together with the buildings thereon known as the "Health Center Building" and the "Health Center Annex" containing 20,000 square feet including use of the public parking lot; and, WHEREAS, the original term of the Lease began July 1,2001, and ended June 30, 2004, and, WHEREAS, the First Amendment to Deed of Lease extended the term to end June 30, 2005, and, WHEREAS, the parties hereto desire to amend the Lease as hereinafter set forth, NOW THEREFORE, it is agreed that the Lease be amended as follows: 1. The Initial Term of the Lease, as amended, shall be extended twelve (12) months (the "Extension Period") and shall now terminate on June 30, 2006, Rent shall continue to be paid in installments ofThirty Eight Thousand Nine Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Dollars ($38,950,00) due and payable in arrears at the end of each quarter. The initial term of the lease may be extended for an additional period of one month each, for a period not to exceed 12 months upon expiration of the initial term of the lease, For such renewal term rent shall be paid in the monthly amount of Twelve Thousand Nine Hundred Eighty-Three and 33/100 Dollars ($12,983.33), Except as amended herein, the Lease shall remain in full force and effect. This Amendment shall not be effective or binding unless and until signed by both parties and approved by the Governor of Virginia pursuant to Section 92,2-1149 ofthe Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, DOS Lease Amendment Form June 10, 2004 Lease #601-L-425 In WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have affixed their signatures and seals. LESSOR: CITY OF ROANOKE By: Title: LESSEE: COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH By: Title: STATE OF VIRGINIA CITY/COUNTY OF , to wit: The foregoing Amendment was acknowledged before me this 20_ by acting in his/her capacity as for the City of Roanoke on behalf of the city, day of My commission expires Notary Public STATE OF VIRGINIA CITY/COUNTY OF , to wit: The foregoing Amendment was acknowledged before me this day of _, 20_ by acting in his/her capacity as ofthe Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of Health, on behalf of the agency, My commission expires Notary Public DGS Lease Amendment Form June 10, 2004 Lease #601-L-425 RECOMMEND APPROVAL: Division of Engineering and Buildings RECOMMEND APPROVAL: Department of General Services By: By: Director Director APPROVED BY THE GOVERNOR Pursuant to Section S2.2-1149 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, and by the authority delegated to me under Executive Order 88(01), dated December 21, 2001, I hereby approve this Amendment to Deed of Lease and the execution of this instrument for and on behalf of the Governor of Virginia. Date Secretary of Administration .j';' CITY OF ROANOKE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 215 Church Avenue, S,W_, Room 461 P,O, Box t220 Roanoke, Virginia 24006-1220 Telephone: (540) 853-2821 Fax: (540) 853-6142 ANN H, SHAWVER Deputy Director email: ann_shawver@ci.roanoke.va.us JESSE A. HALL Director of Finance email: jesse_hall@ci.roanoke.va.us December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T, Fitzpatrick, Jr" Vice Mayor Honorable M, Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T, Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman p, Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J, Wish neff, Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: 5ubject: October Financial Report The adopted budget for the fiscal year 2006 totaled $223,8 million representing a 5,7% increase over the previous year's adopted budget, This financial report covers the first four months of activity for fiscal year 2006, The following narrative provides com mentary on the significant events of this period, Revenues Revenues through October 2005 increased 8,3% compared to the prior fiscal year, led by growth in real estate and the increased meals tax, Variances from the prior year are addressed as follows: General Property Taxes increased 8.4% as a result of growth in reassessments and new construction, The first installment of the real estate tax was due October 5'", This tax is expected to grow 9,3 % as a whole in FY 2006, and actual growth has followed this trend as collections of real estate tax are up 9,2%, Personal property taxes decreased slightly through October; however, the majority of collections occur in the spring, Other Local Taxes increased 14,5% through October_ The Prepared Food and Beverage tax rate increased from 4% to 5% effective July 1" resulting in the overall double.digit increase in local taxes, Through October, this rate increase has provided approximately $495,000 in additional revenue and is expected to provide revenue growth of approximately $2 million throughout the fiscal year, Notwithstanding the rate increase, Prepared Food and Beverage tax increased 5,2%, a positive trend in this tax, Also indicative of a positive trend in our economy is growth in the performance of the Sales Tax and Transient Room Tax, with 4,9% and 7_7% increases respectively, Growth in Transient Room Tax revenues is influenced by positive performance at local hotels, as well as results from ongoing tax audits_ Honorable Mayor and Members of Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 Revenue from the Use of Money and Property increased significantly over the prior year as a result of interest income on the Budget Stabilization Reserve, The reserve was established in late FY05 by transfer from the Debt Service Fund_ Internal Services revenues increased 5,6% as a result of an increase in reimbursement from the Roanoke Regional Airport for Fire Safety expenditures due to an increase in personnel costs in the current fiscal year. A timing difference in billings to departments for engineering charges also contributed to the increase, Miscellaneous Revenue increased 5,9% as a result of insurance proceeds resulting from a water leak in the Municipal Building and the receipt of registration fees for the Building New Partnerships Conference, Exoenditures The FY06 expenditure budget includes funding of approximately $1.4 million to cover contracts and purchase orders made during FY05 but not paid by the end of that year, City Council approved re'appropriation of this funding when adopting the General Fund budget in May, General Fund expenditures as a whole increased 2,9%, All departments are affected by the 3% average pay raise granted to City employees beginning July 1, 2005, Additionally, a change in the billing methodology of the Fleet and Department of Technology (DoT) funds will affect user departments, Beginning in FY06, the General Fund will fund capital outlay for Fleet and DoT through a billing to user departments instead of by a General Fund transfer as in prior years, This will cause a decline in the Nondepartmental category and an offsetting increase in numerous other categories throughout FY06, Other variances between FY05 and FY06 are addressed as follows, Public Works expenditures decreased despite the aforementioned changes in part due to a reduction in maintenance contracts in the current fiscal year. Health and Welfare expenditures decreased 9,9% in the current year due to a timing difference in the encumbrance of the recently approved Health Department subsidy, Parks, Recreation and Cultural expenditures increased 16,0% in part due to the reclassification of Event Zone, Virginia Amateur Sports, and Downtown Roanoke Inc expenditures from Community Development to Parks and Recreation Administration, There was also an increase in special project expenditures for Youth Services, Community Development costs declined 8,3% due to the aforementioned reclassification of various contribution expenditures to the Parks, Recreation, and Cultural category which were previously funded by Community Development cost centers_ A timing difference in the second quarter subsidy payment to the Roanoke Valley Convention and Visitor's Bureau also contributed to the difference, Honorable Mayor and Members of Council December 5, 2005 Page 3 Transfer to Debt Service Fund increased 8,6% primarily due to debt service payments on the 2004B public improvement bonds which were issued in November 2004, Transfer to School Fund increased 7,2% in part due to a timing difference in the School's request for their portion of General Fund undesignated fund balance, Additionally, the Schools are due to receive more in undesignated fund balance than in the prior year. Nondepartmental expenditures declined 20,9% due to a decrease in the amount of undesignated fund balance transferred to the Capital Projects Fund, The above mentioned change in internal service billing methodology also contributed to the reduction of expenditures in this category, Sincerely, 9:::::;al~ 4ft Director of Finance JAH:DLH:ca Attachments c: Darlene L Burcham, City Manager William M, Hackworth, City Attorney Mary F, Parker, City Clerk Rolanda B, Russell, Assistant City Manager James Grigsby, Acting Assistant City Manager Sherman M, Stovall, Director of Management and Budget CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA GENERAL FUND STATEMENT OF REVENUE Year to Date for the Period Percentage of Change 8.36 % 14.51 % -2.39 % -0.97 % 90.27 % 4,15 % - % -2.12 % 5.63 % 5.91 % 8.28 % Current Fiscal Year Percent of Revised Revenue Revenue Estimate Estimates Received $ 93.243.000 34.45% 65.801.000 18.86% 1.069,000 39.21% 1 .354,000 34.05% 722,000 47.47% 49,926,105 22.90Dk 38,000 0.00% 8,891.000 29.79% 2.527.000 25.19% 384,000 55.47% $ 223.955.105 27.10% Revenue Source General Property Taxes Other Local Taxes Permits, Fees and Licenses Fines and Forfeitures Revenue from Use of Money and Property Grants-in-Aid Commonwealth Grants-in-Aid Federal Government Charges for Services Internal Services Miscellaneous Revenue Total July 1 . October 31 2004.2005 $ 29,645.068 10.837.586 429.375 465.583 180.150 10,978.552 July 1 ~ October 31 2005.2006 $ 32.122.622 12.410,437 419.104 461,089 342,764 11.433.630 2,706,123 602.677 201.108 $ 66.046.232 2.648.628 636,591 213,001 $ 60.687.866 STATEMENT OF EXPENDITURES AND ENCUMBRANCES Year to Date for the Period Current Fiscal Year Percent of July 1 - October 31 July 1 - October 31 Percentage Unencumbered Revised Budget Expenditures 2004.2005 2006.2006 of Change Balance Appropriations Obligated General Government 3,596,511 3.893.582 8.26 % $ 8.258.706 $ 12,152,288 32,04% Judicial Administration 1.919.233 1,972,617 2.78 % 5,031.659 7.004,276 28.16% Public Safety 18,205.088 19,313,129 6.09 % 36.875,221 56,188,350 34.37% Public Works 9,291,948 9.290.161 -0.02 % 14,295,144 23,585.305 39.39% Health and Welfare 10,553,122 9.513.961 -9.85 % 21.254.194 30,768.155 30.92% Parks, Recreation and Cultural 2.946,965 3,417,905 15.98 % 6,379,971 9,797,876 34.88% Community Development 2,153,008 1,974,545 .8.29 % 3,762,711 5,737,256 34.42% Transfer to Debt Service Fund 11.178,273 12.142.586 8.63 % 5.582.132 17,724,718 68.51% Transfer to School Fund 17.732,102 19.010.288 7.21 % 36,234,866 55,245,154 34.41% Nondepartmental 2.867.342 2.267.473 -20.92 % 7,967.069 10,234,542 22,16% Total $ 80,443.593 82.796.247 2.92 % $ 145.641.673 $ 228,437 ,920 36.24% CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA CIVIC FACILITIES FUND COMPARATIVE INCOME STATEMENT FOR THE FOUR MONTHS ENDING OCTOBER 31,2005 FY 2006 FY 2005 Operating Revenues Rentals $ 130,751 $ 204,826 Event Expenses 37,793 62,610 Display Advertising 34,668 45,839 Admissions Tax 59,116 173,155 Electrical Fees 3,540 8,115 Novelty Fees 16,004 45,061 Facility Surcharge 45,860 96,911 Marketing Promotions 8,165 Charge Card Fees 14,606 45,820 Commissions 12,114 36,180 Catering/Concessions 203,997 268,803 Other 3,772 5,457 Total Operating Revenues 562,221 1,000,942 Operating Expenses Personal Services 586,570 597,149 Operating Expenses 467,357 477,683 Depreciation 187,619 159,548 Total Operating Expenses 1,241,546 1,234,380 Operating Loss (679,325) (233,438) Nonoperating Revenues (Expenses) Interest on Investments 15,346 6,625 Transfer from General Fund 42,324 Transfer to Debt Service Fund (47,809) (48,409) Interest and Fiscal Charges (31,314) (31,774) Miscellaneous (356) 5,430 Net Nonoperating Revenues (Expenses) (64,133) (25,804) Net Loss $ (743,458) $ (259,242) 2 CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA PARKING FUND COMPARATIVE INCOME STATEMENT FOR THE FOUR MONTHS ENDING OCTOBER 31,2005 FY 2006 FY 2005 Operating Revenues Century Station Parking Garage $ 142,510 $ 120,797 Williamson Road Parking Garage 175,720 175,270 Market Square Parking Garage 75,369 76,342 Church Avenue Parking Garage 213,087 186,008 Tower Parking Garage 144,235 138,254 Gainsboro Parking Garage 40,165 33,018 Williamson Road Surface Lots 27,971 29,004 Norfolk Avenue Surface Lot 12,255 22,818 Gainsboro Surface Lot 15,881 16,814 Church Avenue Surface Lot 15,200 15,200 Bullitt Avenue Surface Lot 26,971 26,492 Salem Avenue Surface Lot 7,678 7,350 West Church/YMCA Surface Lots 10,015 4,088 Total Operating Revenues 907,057 851,455 Operating Expenses Operating Expenses 368,502 375,366 Depreciation 193,266 211,946 Total Operating Expenses 561,768 587,312 Operating Income 345,289 264,143 Nonoperating Revenues (Expenses) Interest on Investments 20,041 7,989 Interest and Fiscal Charges (100,054) (107,485) Net Nonoperating Expenses (80,013) (99,496) Net Income $ 265,276 $ 164,647 3 CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA MARKET BUILDING FUND INCOME STATEMENT FOR THE FOUR MONTHS ENDING OCTOBER 31,2005 FY 2006 FY 2005 Operating Revenues Retail Space Rental $ 92,739 $ 70,301 Total Operating Revenues 92,739 70,301 Operating Expenses Operating Expense 64,367 89,437 Depreciation 2,599 2,532 Total Operating Expenses 66,966 91,969 Operating Income (Loss) 25,773 (21,668) Nonoperating Revenues Interest on Investments 971 206 Miscellaneous 130 Net Nonoperating Revenues 1,101 206 Net Income (Loss) $ 26,874 $ (21,462) 4 CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA CITY TREASURER'S OFFICE GENERAL STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THE MONTH ENDED OCTOBER 31, 2005 TO THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE: GENERAL STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE CITY TREASURER OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE. VIRGINIA FOR THE FUNDS OF SAID CITY FOR THE MONTH ENDED OCTOBER 31. 2005. BALANCE AT BALANCE AT BALANCE AT FUND SEPT 30, 2005 RECEIPTS DISBURSEMENTS OCT 31, 2005 OCT 31, 2004 GENERAL $25,575,277.01 $20,673,559,26 $24,120,104.61 $22,128,731,66 $1,727,834.49 WATER 420.00 0.00 0.00 420.00 420.00 WATER POLLUTION CONTROL 1,738,22 0.00 0,00 1,738,22 1,738.22 CIVIC FACILITIES 5.093,845,36 98,085,31 1,153.161,52 4,038,769.15 689,533.00 PARKING 3,336,503.06 217,543,57 214,168.83 3,339,877,80 811,691.77 CAPITAL PROJECTS 54,072,183,18 463.689.57 984,943,93 53,550,928.82 50,268,418.46 MARKET BUILDING OPERATIONS 130,534.69 21,909.43 45.914,10 106,530.02 (7.678.09) CONFERENCE CENTER 3,792,127.93 7.529.17 4,119.48 3,795,537,62 3,949,278,67 DEBT SERVICE (5,291,791,08) 6.365,000.87 234,287,23 838,922,56 15,080.570.15 DEPT OF TECHNOLOGY 4,068,048.85 690,137.41 276,163.04 4,482,023,22 3.573,254,02 FLEET MANAGEMENT 180,709.93 1,336,699.79 242,167.00 1,275,242_72 (101,676.93) PAYROLL (13,024.944,36) 16,663.174.77 16,894,514.81 (13,256,284,40) (12,829,520.32) RISK MANAGEMENT 10.889,038.86 1.026,468.31 635.339,80 11,280,167.37 12,119.822.40 PENSION 399,547.88 1,839,212,03 1,791,691.00 447,068,91 629,631.65 SCHOOL FUND 6,280,480.28 7.736.903.14 7.481.441.33 6,535,942,09 6,998,078.58 SCHOOL CAPITAL PROJECTS 4,317.956,66 10,689.34 2.692,201.89 1,636,444,11 824,682.92 SCHOOL FOOD SERVICE 78,101.17 597.034.90 608.234,00 66,902,07 (278,958.05) FDETC 0.00 0.00 0,00 0,00 129.00 GRANT 846,006.60 1,396.419,29 523,100.99 1,719,324,90 371,954,02 TOTAL $100,745,784.24 $59.144,056.16 $57,901,553.56 $101,988,286,84 $83,829,203,96 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE FOREGOING IS A TRUE STATEMENT OF MY ACCOUNTABILITY TO THE CITY OF ROANOKE. VIRGINIA, FOR THE FUNDS OF THE VARIOUS ACCOUNTS THEREOF FOR THE MONTH ENDED OCTOBER 31, 2005. THAT SAID FOREGOING: CASH CASH IN HAND CASH IN BANK INVESTMENTS ACQUIRED FROM COMPETITIVE PROPOSALS: COMMERCIAL HIGH PERFORMANCE MONEY MARKET COMMERCIAL PAPER LOCAL GOVERNMENT INVESTMENT POOL MONEY MANAGEMENT ACCOUNT REPURCHASE AGREEMENTS U, S. AGENCIES VIRGINIA AIM PROGRAM (U, S. SECURITIES) VIRGINIA SNAP PROGRAM (U. S. SECURITIES) TOTAL $8,208,74 399,365,87 6,850,000.00 3,938,882,23 9,720,622,80 10,793,732,74 14,000,000,00 18,563,501,60 21,812,782,97 15,901,189,89 $101,988,286,84 NOVEMBER 18, 2005 5 CITY OF ROANOKE PENSION PLAN STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN PLAN NET ASSETS FOR THE FOUR MONTHS ENDED OCTOBER 31,2005 FY 2006 FY 2005 Additions: Employer Contributions $ 2,478,057 $ 1,841,732 Investment Income Net Appreciation (Depreciation) in Fair Value of Investments 5,380,134 3,251,940 Interest and Dividend Income 613,394 508,772 Total Investment Income (Loss) 5,993,528 3,760,712 Less Investment Expense 3,011 6,392 Net Investment Income (Loss) 5,990,517 3,754,320 Total Additions (Deductions) $ 8,468,574 $ 5,596,052 Deductions Benefits Paid to Participants Administrative Expenses Total Deductions $ 7,122,045 $ 6,679,578 20,861 21,137 7,142,906 6,700,715 1,325,668 (1,104,663) Net Increase (Decrease) Net Assets Held in Trust for Pension Benefits: Fund Balance July 1 Fund Balance October 31 318,675,367 $320,001,035 306,925,352 $305,820,689 6 CITY OF ROANOKE PENSION PLAN BALANCE SHEET OCTOBER 31, 2005 FY 2006 FY 2005 Assets Cash $ 446,517 $ 625,857 Investments, at Fair Value 321,349,224 306,866,606 Due from Other Funds 1,431 1,431 Other Assets 6,531 Total Assets $ 321,797,172 $ 307,500,425 Liabilities and Fund Balance Liabilities: Due to Other Funds $ 1,795,523 $ 1,679,637 Accounts Payable 614 99 Total Liabilities 1,796,137 1,679,736 Fund Balance: Fund Balance, July 1 318,675,367 306,925,352 Net Gain (Loss) - Year to Date 1,325,668 (1,104,663) Total Fund Balance 320,001,035 305,820,689 Total Liabilities and Fund Balance $ 321,797,172 $ 307,500,425 7 . - ',. d '3'-tpv, CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk ~ Mary F, Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File #2-53 The Honorable Brenda S, Hamilton Clerk of Circuit Court Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Hamilton: I am attaching a certified copy of Resolution No. 37267-120505 authorizing the sale of not to exceed $3,975,000.00 principal amount of general obligations ofthe City of Roanoke, Virginia, in the form of General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds, Taxable Series 2005. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005. Pursuant to provisions of Section 3 of the above referenced measure, I am required to file a certified copy of the resolution with the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, in accordance with Section 15.2-2607, Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. ~~ ;(J~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment The Honorable Brenda S, Hamilton December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: Donald G. Gurney, Esquire, Hawkins, Delafield and Wood, LLP, 67 Wall Street, 11'" Floor, New York, New York 10005 Gary Ometer, BB&T Capital Markets, P. O. Box 1575, Richmond, Virginia 23218-1575 The Honorable Evelyn W. Powers, City Treasurer Darlene L. Burcham, City Manager Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Sherman M, Stovall, Director, Management and Budget ~ ~ IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37267-120505. A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SALE OF NOT TO EXCEED TIIREE MILLION NINE HUNDRED SEVENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($3,975,000) PRINCIPAL AMOUNT OF GENERAL OBLIGATIONS OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, IN THE FORM OF GENERAL OBLIGATION PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT BONDS, TAXABLE SERIES 2005, OF SUCH CITY, FOR THE PURPOSE OF PROVIDING FUNDS TO PAY THE COSTS OF THE ACQUISITION OF LAND FOR REDEVELOPMENT; DELEGATING TO THE CITY MANAGER AND THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE CERTAIN POWERS WITH RESPECT TO THE SALE AND THE DETERMINATION OF THE DETAILS OF SUCH BONDS; AND OTHERWISE PROVIDING WITH RESPECT TO THE ISSUANCE, SALE AND DELIVERY OF SUCH BONDS VIRGINIA: BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, SECTION 1. The Council (the "Council") of the City of Roanoke, Virginia (the "City"), hereby finds and determines: (a) On June 20,2005, the Council adopted Resolution No. 37104-062005 (the "Authorizing Resolution"), authorizing the issuance of general obligations of the City, in the fonn of General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds of the City, including not to exceed $3,975,000 principal amount of General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds for the purpose of providing funds to pay the costs of the acquisition of land for redevelopment. (b) The Council has detennined to authorize the sale of not to exceed $3,975,000 principal amount of its General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds, Taxable Series 2005 (the "Bonds"), pursuant to and in accordance with the provisions of the Authorizing Resolution, and to delegate to the City Manager and the Director of Finance certain powers with respect to the sale and the determination of the details of the Bonds, SECTION 2, (a) The Bonds shall be sold at negotiated sale on such date and at such price as shall be determined by the City Manager and the Director of Finance, The City Manager and the Director of Finance, without further action of this Council, (i) are hereby authorized to determine the dated date of the Bonds, the date the Bonds shall mature, the dates on which interest on the Bonds shall be payable, the aggregate principal amount of the Bonds and the principal amount of the Bonds maturing in each year, and (ii) are hereby further authorized to sell the Bonds at negotiated sale to such purchaser or purchasers as shall be 487255,3027991 RES -2- selected by the City Manager and the Director of Finance and to fix the rates of interest to be borne by the Bonds of each maturity; provided, however, in no event shall the true interest cost with respect to the Bonds exceed seven percent (7_00%). The City Manager and the Director of Finance are hereby authorized to detennine the provisions relating to the redemption of the Bonds upon the advice of the City's financial advisor; provided, however, in no event shall any redemption premium payable by the City exceed two percent (2_000/0), (b) The Bonds shall be issued in accordance with the provisions of the Authorizing Resolution and this Resolution; provided that the provisions of Section 6 of the Authorizing Resolution shall not apply to the Bonds, (c) All actions and proceedings heretofore taken by this Council, the City Manager, the Director of Finance and the other officers, employees, agents and attorneys of and for the City in connection with the issuance and sale of the Bonds are hereby ratified and confirmed, SECTION 3, The City Clerk is hereby directed to file a copy of this Resolution, certified by such City Clerk to be a true copy hereof, with the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, all in accordance with Section 15_2-2607 of the Code of Virginia, ]950, SECTION 4, All ordinances, resolutions and proceedings in conflict herewith are, to the extent of such conflict, repealed_ ~~ :J.~ City Clerk. A "":J~ 487255,3027991 RES CITY OF ROANOKE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE 215 Church Avenue, S,W" Room 461 P,O, Box 1220 Roanoke, Virginia 24006- t220 Telephone: (540) 853-2821 Fax: (540) 853-6142 ANN H, SHAWVER Deputy Director email: ann_shawver@ci.roanoke.va.us JESSE A. HALL Director of Finance email: jesse_hall@ci.roanoke.va.us December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr" Council Member Honorable Sherman p, Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff Council Member Dear Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Authorization of Sale of Bonds Resolution 37104, adopted by City Council on June 20, 2005, authorized the issuance of bonds for various projects including $3,975,000 principal amount of General Obligation Bonds to finance the costs of acquisition of land for redevelopment, specifically the Countryside Golf Course. The resolution authorized the City Manager and Director of Finance to complete the sale of the bonds using either a negotiated or competitive method, The resolution provided the authority to complete a competitive sale, but did not authorize acceptance of bids for a negotiated sale. In coordination with our financial advisor, BB& T Capital Markets, we determined that sale of bonds for this project by negotiated sale would be in the best financial interest of the City. This was due to the relatively small size of the bonds needed for this project coupled with our desire for flexibility in the bonds based on the fact that we are uncertain of the ultimate disposition of the property. Additionally, since development of the property will be in coordination with a private developer, the bonds needed to be issued as taxable debt. It should be noted that general obligation bonds will be sold via competitive sale for the remaining projects outlined in the aforementioned resolution as well as for others previously approved by City Council. The total amount of the Honorable Mayor and Members of Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 bonds to be sold by competitive sale in late January 2006 will approximate $35 million, all of which will be tax exempt, These bonds will fund projects such as the Patrick Henry High School renovation, the Civic Center renovation, the South Jefferson redevelopment area, the City's contribution to the Art Museum, and others. Recommendation: Adopt the accompanying resolution to authorize the sale of $3,975,000 taxable bonds to provide funds for the acquisition of land for redevelopment and to delegate to the City Manager and the Director of Finance authority as outlined in the resolution to complete the sale of the bonds. Sincerely, ()~ A rt--~ -fe:se A. Hall Director of Finance c: Darlene L. Burcham, City Manager William M, Hackworth, City Attorney Mary F, Parker, City Clerk CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F, Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk December 8, 2005 Sheila N, Hartman Assistant City Clerk File #51 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Richard A. Rife, Chair City Planning Commission 1326 Grandin Road, 5. w. Roanoke, Virginia 24015 Dear Ms. Burcham and Mr. Rife: I am attaching copy of Ordinance No.3 7268-120505 amending and reordaining the Code ofthe City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, by repealing Chapter 36.1, Zonina, consisting of 9936.1-1 through 36.1-730, and enacting Chapter 36.2, Zonina, consisting of 9936,2-1 through 36.2-840, and accompanying Appendices A, Band C, such Chapter 36.2 being a comprehensive revision of the zoning regulations of the City. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council ofthe City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. MFP:ew Sincerely, ;) ~ ~ .J r~t".. ~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Attachment L:ICLERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05IDec OSlDec 5 2005 correspondence,doc Darlene L. Burcham Richard A. Rife, Chair December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: The Honorable Robert p, Doherty, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable William D. Broadhurst, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Clifford R. Weckstein, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Charles N. Dorsey, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Jonathan M, Apgar, Chief Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable James R. Swanson, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Julian H. Raney, Jr., Chief Judge, General District Court The Honorable Vincent A. Lilley, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Francis W. Burkart, III, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Jacqueline F. Ward Talevi, Judge, General District Court The HonorableJohn B, Ferguson, ChiefJudge,Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph M. Clarke, II, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Philip Trompeter, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph P. Bounds, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Sheila N. Hartman, Assistant City Clerk, (For transmittal by electronic mail to Municipal Code Corporation) Municipal Code Corporation, P. O. Box 2235, Tallahassee, Florida 32316 Ronald S. Albright, Clerk, General District Court David C. Wells, Clerk, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Kozuo Webb, Office of the Magistrate Lora A. Wilson, Law Librarian William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Susan S. Lower, Director, Real Estate Valuation Steven J, Talevi, Assistant City Attorney R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning, Building and Economic Development Martha P. Franklin, Secretary, City Planning Commission Nancy C. Snodgrass, Zoning Administrator Philip C. Schirmer, City Engineer l:IClERK\DATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05lDec 05lDec 5 2005 correspondence,doc ~,,\l \'J-\ IN THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37268-120505. AN ORDINANCE amending and reordaining the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, by repealing Chapter 36,1, Zoning, consisting of ~~36,1-1 through 36.1-730, and enacting Chapter 36.2, Zoning, consisting of ~~36.2-1 through 36.2-840, and accompanying Appendices A, B and C, such Chapter 36.2 being a comprehensive revision of the zoning regulations ofthe City; and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance, WHEREAS, on August 20,2001, City Council adopted Vision 2001-2020 ("Comprehensive Plan"), a new Comprehensive Plan for the City, which plan has necessitated a comprehensive revision of the City's zoning regulations; WHEREAS, the City conducted ten (10) stakeholder focus group sessions on June 25, June 26, and August 1, 2002, with sign industry representatives, neighborhood group leaders, land use attorneys, regional development leaders, business leaders, design and development professionals, and governmental boards and commissions, to identifY opportunities and issues relating to growth and development in the City and to identifY regulations which needed to be amended or adopted; WHEREAS, the City conducted a housing issues roundtable on July 31, 2002, to which representatives of various groups interested in, and knowledgeable about, housing issues in the City were invited, and a public forum on August 1, 2002, to which the general public was invited, to identifY additional opportunities and issues relating to growth and development in the City and to identifY zoning regulations which needed to be amended or adopted; WHEREAS, in July 2002, the City Manager appointed a Steering Committee consisting of representatives from the stakeholder groups, City Council, the Planning Commission for the City of Roanoke ("Planning Commission"), the Board of Zoning Appeals for the City of Roanoke, the K:\oRDINANCES\O-CA.REPEAL CHAPTER. 36.1, ZONING (ONLY) 120505.DOC 1 Architectural Review Board for the City of Roanoke, and City staff, to provide direction for the development of the new zoning ordinance, to review and revise draft zoning regulations, and to provide on-going feedback during the process; WHEREAS, from September 2002 until December 2003, the Steering Committee conducted twenty-five (25) sessions to review and revise the draft zoning regulations; WHEREAS, in February 2004, the Steering Committee released for public discussion a draft of the new zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, on March 8, March 12, March 16, March 17, March 18, March 22, March 23, March 25, March 29, March 30, April 1, April 5, April 6, Apri113, Apri128 and Apri129, 2004, City staff conducted six (6) public open houses and eleven (11) stakeholder.focus group sessions with sign industry representatives, neighborhood group leaders, land use attorneys, business leaders, homebuilders, design and development professionals, and real estate industry representatives, to elicit public comment pertaining to the draft of the new zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, to provide for public awareness of the open houses and the stakeholder focus group sessions, the City (1) placed two (2) easels and flyers with calendars, indicating the dates, times and locations of the open houses and sessions, in the lobby area ofthe Municipal Building and in the Departments of Housing and Neighborhood Services and Planning, Building and Economic Development, (2) posted open house schedules on the RVTV Message Board, (3) published two (2) block advertisements in the Roanoke Times, advertising the open house schedules, (4) placed drafts of the zoning ordinance in all branches of the City of Roanoke public library, (5) mailed a copy of the draft ordinance, with an explanation of the public comment process and how to participate in such process and provide input, to all neighborhood group leaders, (6) set up and staffed an information and comment table on Citizen Appreciation Day on Apri117, 2004, at Valley View Mall, (7) conducted meetings with, and gave presentations to, neighborhood and civic organizations, K:\ORDJNANCES~.REPEAL CHAPTER 36.1, ZONING (ONLY) 120.50,.DOC 2 including the Roanoke Neighborhood Advocates, Downtown Roanoke, Inc., Williamson Road Area Business Association, the Roanoke Regional Chamber of Commerce, the Roanoke Regional Homebuilders Association, Neighbors in South Roanoke, Old Southwest, Inc" the Gilmer Neighborhood Steering Committee, and the Gainsboro Steering Committee, and (8) posted on the City's web site a copy of the draft zoning ordinance, which posting was viewed 1,117 times during the February 2004 to May 2004 period; WHEREAS, from February 2,2004 until May 31, 2004, the City documented more than 1,100 comments, including those on the draft zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, beginning in June 2004, the Steering Committee met fourteen (14) times to consider all of those documented comments on the draft zoning ordinance and to recommend changes to the draft zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, in December 2004, the Steering Committee completed its assigned task and presented to the Planning Commission a draft zoning ordinance for the City; WHEREAS, between December 2004, and July 2005, City staff continued to meet with various civic and neighborhood organizations, including Old Southwest, Inc" Riveriand Alert Neighbors, Gilmer Neighborhood, the Greater Raleigh Court Civic League and the Williamson Road Area Business Association, as well as individual property owners by request, regarding the draft zoning ordinance, to oversee questions and to elicit additional public comment; WHEREAS, public news releases, newspaper articles, status reports and communications were disseminated by the City throughout the process to advise interested persons of the status of the process; WHEREAS, after due and timely public notice, including a legal advertisement consisting of a special insert published on two dates, one week apart, in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Roanoke in which all interested persons were advised of the City's intent to repeal Chapter K:\ORDINANCES\O-CA.RErEAL CHAPTER 36.1, ZONING (ONI. y) 120505.DOC 3 36,1, Zoning, and to adopt a new Chapter 36,2, Zoning, a descriptive summary of the terms of which was contained in the insert, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on July 28,2005, on the draft zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, in addition to the published legal advertisement described in the preceding paragraph, the City sent by first-class mail to all owners ofthe approx.imately 44,000 parcels of real estate in the City of Roanoke notice of (1) the City's intent to repeal Chapter 36,1, Zoning: (2) the City's intentto adopt a new Chapter 36,2, Zoning; (3) a descriptive summary of the terms ofthe new Chapter 36.2, Zoning; and (4) the date, time and place, of the Planning Commission's public hearing at which the new Chapter 36.2, Zoning, would be considered; WHEREAS, following the Planning Commission's public hearing on July 28, 2005, the Planning Commission held fifteen (15) work sessions during which it considered the new Chapter 36.2, Zoning. and all comments received pertaining to it; WHEREAS, the City Clerk for the City of Roanoke placed a notice on the public calendar in her office for all Steering Committee meetings, all Planning Commission work sessions and the public hearing held on July 28, 2005; WHEREAS, on September 29,2005, the Planning Commission unanimously recommended to City Council Chapter 36,2, Zoning, and on November 4, 2005, the Planning Commission unanimously certified Chapter 36.2, Zoning. to City Council; WHEREAS, a public hearing was held on the new zoning ordinance by City Council at its meeting on November 21, 2005, after due and timely public notice thereof, including a legal advertisement consisting of a special insert published on two dates, one week apart, in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Roanoke in which all interested persons were advised of the City's intent to repeal Chapter 36.1, Zoning, and to adopt Chapter 36,2, Zoning, a descriptive summary of the text of which as recommended by the Planning Commission was contained in the K:\ORDlNANCES\O-CA_REJ'EAL CHAPTER 36.1, ZONING (ONLY) 12050.5.DOC 4 insert, at which hearing all parties in interest and citizens were given an opportunity to be heard; WHEREAS, after such public hearing, City Council revised Chapter 36.2, Zoning, as the same was recommended by the Planning Commission, to address comments and concerns stated at the public hearing; WHEREAS, this Council, after considering the proposed zoning ordinance, as revised, is of the opinion that the proposed zoning ordinance, as revised, helps promote and provide for adequate light, air, convenience of access; safety from flood, fire, crime and other dangers; reduce or prevent congestion in the public streets; facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; facilitate the provision of adequate police and fire protection, disaster evacuation, civil defense, transportation, water, sewerage, flood protection, schools, parks, forests, playgrounds, recreational facilities, airports and other public requirements; protect against destruction of, or encroachment upon, historic areas; protect against overcrowding ofland, undue density of population in relation to the community facilities existing or available, obstruction oflight and air, danger and congestion in travel and transportation, and loss oflife, health, or property from fire, flood, panic or other dangers; encourage economic development activities that provide desirable employment and enlarge the tax base; provide for the preservation of agricultural and forestal lands and other lands of significance for the protection of the natural environment, approach slopes and other safety areas of licensed airports; and promote the creation and preservation of affordable housing suitable for meeting the current and future needs of the City, as well as a reasonable proportion of the current and future needs of the planning district within which the City is situated; and WHEREAS, this Council, after considering the proposed zoning ordinance, as revised, is of the opinion that the proposed zoning ordinance, as revised, is consistent with Vision 2001- 2020, the City's Comprehensive Plan, is required by the public necessity, convenience, general welfare, is good zoning practice, and ought to be adopted in order to implement the Comprehensive Plan, K:\ORDINANCES\O-CA_REPEAL CHAPTER 36.1, WNlNG (ONLY) 120305.DOC 5 THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAlNED by the Council of the City of Roanoke as follows: 1. Chapter 36.1, Zoning, consisting of 9936,1-1 through 36.1-730 of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, is hereby REPEALED. 2. The Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, is amended and reordained by the addition of a new Chapter 36.2, Zoning. consisting of 9936.2-1 through 36_2-840, and accompanying Appendices A, B and C, to read and provide as set out in the copy of such Chapter 36.2 attached to the City Manager's letter dated December 5, 2005, to City Council, and filed with the City Clerk. 3, A landowner's rights shall be deemed vested in a land use and such vesting shall not be affected by the adoption of Chapter 36,2, Zoning, of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, if the landowner (i) obtains or is the beneficiary of a significant affirmative governmental act which remains in effect, allowing development of a specific project, (ii) relies in good faith on the significant affirmative governmental act, and (iii) incurs extensive obligations or substantial expenses in diligent pursuit of the specific project in reliance on the significant affirmative governmental act prior to the effective date of this ordinance, 4, Pursuant to the provisions ofSection-12 of the City Chart~, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with, ATTEST: .J P ~ /\i~erk' K:\ORDINANCES\O-CA.REPEAL CHAPTER 36.1, ZONING (ONLY) 120jOUX>C 6 Chapter 36.2, Zoning, of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended City Council December 5, 2005 Chapter 36.2 ZONING ARTICLE 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS ~ 36.2-100 ~ 36,2-101 ~ 36,2-102 ~ 36,2-103 ~ 36,2-104 ~ 36.2-105 ~ 36,2-106 ~ 36.2-107 ~ 36,2-108 Title General Purpose and Intent Applicability Consistency with Comprehensive Plan Coordination with Other Regulations Rules of Interpretation and Construction Permits and Certificates Severability Vested Rights ARTICLE 2. ZONING DISTRICfS ~ 36.2-200 ~ 36.2-201 ~ 36,2-202 ~ 36,2-203 ~ 36,2-204 ~ 36.2-205 Purpose Establishment of Districts Zoning Map Development Standards and Supplemental Regulations Use Regulations Dimensional Regulations ARTICLE 3. REGULATIONS FOR SPECIFIC ZONING DISTRICfS $ 36,2-300 Purpose Division 1. ~ 36,2-310 ~ 36.2-311 ~ 36,2-312 ~ 36,2-313 ~ 36,2-314 ~ 36,2-315 Division 2. ~ 36,2-320 ~ 36,2-321 ~ 36,2~322 ~ 36,2-323 ~ 36,2-324 ~ 36,2-325 ~ 36.2-326 ~ 36,2-327 ~ 36,2-328 Division 3. ~ 36,2-330 ~ 36_2-331 ~ 36,2-332 ~ 36,2-333 ~ 36,2-334 ~ 36,2-335 ~ 36,2-336 Base Districts - Residential, Commercial, and Industrial Residential-Agricultural District (RA) Residential Single-Family Districts (R-12, R-7, R-5, R.3) Residential Mixed Density Districts (RM-l, RM-2) Residential Multifamily District (RMF) Commercial Districts (CN, CG, CLS) Industrial Districts (I-I, 1-2) Base Districts - Special Purpose Districts Purpose Downtown District (D) Mixed Use District (MX) Institutional District (IN) Recreation and Open Space District (ROS) Airport Development District (AD) Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) Industrial Planned Unit Development District (IPUD) Overlay Districts Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-l) Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2) Neighborhood Design Overlay District (ND) Floodplain Overlay District (F) Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RCC) Comprehensive Sign Overlay District Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 1 Table of Conlents Division 4, ~ 36,2-340 ARTICLE 4. SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS ~ 36,2-400 ~ 36,2-401 ~ 36.2-402 ~ 36,2-403 ~ 36,2-404 ~ 36,2-405 ~ 36.2-406 ~ 36.2-407 ~ 36,2-408 ~ 36,2-409 ~ 36.2-410 ~ 36,2-411 ~ 36,2-412 ~ 36,2-413 ~ 36.2-414 ~ 36.2-415 ~ 36,2-416 ~ 36,2-417 ~ 36.2-418 ~ 36,2-419 ~ 36,2-420 ~ 36,2-421 ~ 36,2-422 ~ 36.2-423 ~ 36.2-424 ~ 36.2-425 ~ 36,2-426 ~ 36,2-427 ~ 36,2-428 ~ 36,2-429 ~ 36,2-430 ~ 36.2-431 ~ 36,2-432 Use Matrix Use Matrix Purpose Applicability Accessory Apartments Accessory Uses and Structures Adult Uses Bed and Breakfast Car wash Commercial Motor Vehicle Sales and Service, New or Used Day Care Centers, Child Drive-through Facilities Fences and Walls Gasoline Stations Group Care Facilities Home Occupations Junk Yards, Wrecker Yards, and Recycling Centers Mini- Warehouses Mixed Use Buildings and Live-Work Units Mobile Homes Motor Vehicle or Trailer Painting and Body Repair Motor Vehicle Repair or Service Establishment Motor Vehicle Sales and Service Establishment, New Motor Vehicle Sales and Service Establishment, Used Outdoor Display Areas Outdoor Storage Parking of Motor Vehicles in Residential Districts Parking or Storage of Recreational Vehicles, Motor Homes, Boats, Campers, or Trailers Parking Structures Satellite Dish Antennas Stables, Commercial Temporary Uses Towing Services Townhouses and Rowhouses Wireless Telecommunications Facilities and Broadcasting Towers ~ 36,2-500 ARTICLE 5. PROCEDURES Division 1. ~ 36,2-510 ~ 36.2-511 Division 2. ~ 36,2-520 ~ 36,2-521 ~ 36.2-522 ~ 36,2-523 Purpose Generally General Procedural Requirements Post-Decision Proceedings Administrative Permits Purpose General Applicability Zoning Permits Certificates of Occupancy Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 11 Table of Contents Division 3. ~ 36,2-530 Division 4. ~ 36.2-540 ~ 36,2-541 Division 5, ~ 36,2-550 ~ 36.2-551 ~ 36,2-552 ~ 36.2-553 Division 6. ~ 36,2-560 ~ 36,2-561 ~ 36,2-562 ~ 36,2-563 Division 7. ~ 36,2-570 ~ 36,2-571 Certificates of Appropriateness Certificates of Appropriateness Zoning Amendments and Conditional Rezoning Zoning Amendments Conditional Rezonings Development Plans Purpose Development Plans, Generally Basic Development Plans Comprehensive Development Plans Special Exceptions, Variances, and Appeals Special Exceptions Variances Appeals to Board of Zoning Appeals Appeals from Board of Zoning Appeals Enforcement Purpose Zoning Violations ARTICLE 6. DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS ~ 36,2-600 Division 1. ~ 36.2-610 Division 2, ~36,2-620 ~ 36.2-621 ~ 36,2-622 ~ 36,2-623 ~ 36,2-624 ~ 36.2-625 Division 3. ~ 36,2-630 Division 4. ~ 36,2-640 ~ 36.2-641 ~ 36,2-642 ~ 36.2-643 ~ 36_2-644 ~ 36,2-645 ~ 36,2-646 ~ 36,2-647 ~ 36,2-648 ~ 36.2-649 Division 5. ~ 36,2-650 ~ 36,2-651 ~ 36,2-652 A pplica bili ty Utilities Utilities Outdoor Lighting Purpos e Applicability Exempt Lighting Definitions Lighting Plan Outdoor Lighting Standards General Development Standards General Development Standards Landscaping and Screening Purpose Applicability General Landscaping and Screening Standards Preservation of Existing Landscape Features Overall Tree Canopy Requirements Street Yard Trees Fa~ade Planting Buffer Yards Parking Area Landscaping Screening of Specific Uses and Facilities Off-Street Parking and Loading Purpose Applicability Minimum Off-Street Parking Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoka 12/05105 III Table of Contents ~ 36,2-653 ~ 36.2-654 ~ 36,2-655 Division 6. ~ 36,2-660 ~ 36.2-661 ~ 36,2-662 ~ 36,2-663 ~ 36,2-664 ~ 36,2-665 ~ 36,2-666 ~ 36.2-667 ~ 36.2-668 ~ 36,2-669 ~ 36.2-670 ~ 36,2-671 ~ 36,2-672 ~ 36,2-673 ~ 36,2-674 ~ 36.2-675 Maximum Off-Street Parking Off-Street Parking Area Standards Off-Street Loading Signs Purpose Applicability Definitions Prohibited Signs Zoning Permits for Signs Removal of Abandoned Nonconforming Signs Illuminated Signs Calculation of Sign Area and Number of On-Premise Signs Types and Number of On-Premise Signs Permitted Dimensional Standards for On-Premise Signs Freestanding Signs Building-Mounted Signs Upper Story Wall Signs Temporary On-Premise Signs Public Service Message Boards Outdoor Advertising Signs ARTICLE 7. NONCONFORMING USES, STRUCTURES, AND LOTS ~ 36,2-700 Purpose ~ 36,2-701 Generally ~ 36.2-702 Actual Construction Begun Prior to Adoption or Amendment of Chapter Nonconforming Lots Nonconforming Structures Nonconforming Uses Repairs and Maintenance Change of Nonconforming Use to Another Use Nonconforming Characteristics of Use Certain Uses Deemed Not Nonconforming ~ 36.2-703 ~ 36,2-704 ~ 36,2-705 ~ 36.2-706 ~ 36,2-707 ~ 36,2-708 ~ 36.2-709 ARTICLE 8. ADMINISTRATIVE COMMISSIONS, BOARDS, AND OFFICIALS ~ 36.2-800 Purpose Division 1. ~ 36,2-810 ~ 36.2-811 ~ 36,2-812 ~ 36,2-813 ~ 36,2-814 ~ 36,2-815 ~ 36,2-816 ~ 36.2-817 Division 2. ~ 36,2-820 ~ 36.2-821 ~ 36.2-822 City Planning Commission Definition Establishment Membership Meetings Quorum and Vote Officers; Agent; Staff; Special Requests Rules and Records Powers and Duties Architectural Review Board Definition Establishment Membership Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoke 12105105 iv Table of Contents ~ 36,2-823 ~ 36,2-824 ~ 36.2-825 ~ 36,2-826 ~ 36.2-827 Division 3. ~ 36,2-830 ~ 36,2-831 ~ 36,2-832 ~ 36.2-833 ~ 36,2-834 ~ 36.2-835 ~ 36,2-836 ~ 36.2-837 Division 4. ~ 36,2-840 Meetings Quorum and Vote Officers; Agent; Staff Rules and Records Powers and Duties Board of Zoning Appeals Definition Establishment Membership Meetings Quorum and Vote Officers; Staff Rules and Records Powers and Duties Zoning Administrator Zoning Administrator APPENDIX A. DEFINITIONS APPENDIX B, SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS B-1 Basic Development Plan B-2 Comprehensive Development Plan B-3 Landscape Plan C-1 APPENDIX C. AGREEMENTS Off-Site Parking Agreement Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 V Table of Contents List of Tables Table 205-1. Permitted Yard Encroachments.... ........................,.................... ....... ....9 Table 310-1. Dimensional Matrix for Residential Agricultural District (RA).................. .......14 Table 311-1. Dimensional Matrix for Residential Single-Family Districts (R-12, R-7, R-5, R-3).... ,..""..",...... ,."..,....,.."..." '..,.,.."..,..",.., ,......,15 Table 312-1. Dimensional Matrix for Residential Mixed Density Districts (RM-l, RM-2).,..,,"..,......"'.."'.."..."'.., ......,...,.."""...,.. ,..", ............. ,16 Table 313-1. Dimensional Matrix for Residential Multifamily District (RMF)..., , , , ,........" " , "...,17 Table 314-1. Dimensional Matrix for Commercial Districts (CN, CG, CLS),............ ......... ..19 Table 315-1. Dimensional Matrix for Industrial Districts (I-I, 1-2)............,.... ,....... ...... ....,..20 Table 321-1. Dimensional Matrix for Downtown District (0). ..............,.................... ......22 Table 322-1, Dimensional Matrix for Mixed Use District (MX)............,.................... ......,23 Table 323-1. Dimensional Matrix for Institutional District (IN).......... ......................... ....25 Table 324-1. Dimensional Matrix for Recreation and Open Space District (ROS)...................26 Table 325-1. Dimensional Matrix for Airport Development District (AD).................... ....,.,28 Table 326-1. Dimensional Matrix for Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD). , , , . , , . , , ,., , , , , , , , '" , , , .. , , , '" ' .. , " , " . , , , , , , " , " , . , , ,. .. , ..,. , , ,.". " , '" ,,30 Table 327-1. Dimensional Matrix for Institutional Planned Unit Development District ~~""",.,",.,',.,"""""""""""",.".,"""""""',.,"',.".".,...,'~ Table 328-1. Dimensional Matrix for Industrial Planned Unit Development District (IPUD) , ,..""..,..""......",..""..,.."""""",..,..,..""..""..".." ,......, ..,34 Table 340-1. Use Matrix.",."""..".. ,.....",..,..""", ,.'"""..""",.,,'..,..,.., ,.,.., ...... ,..58 Table 429-1. Temporary Uses..." ,.,..,.., ,.,..." .....',..,..""""".."".."""" '.,.,,'......., ..,86 Table 510-1. Recommending and Decision-making Bodies"".'" ,.,..,..."""....,....,.., ..........99 Table 642-1. Trees: Approved Plant Ust, Minimum Size at Planting, 20-Year Canopy, and Suitability"".".". ,.'..""..""..,..,..""..,.., ......."...."",..,..."""...., ....,124 Table 647-1. Buffer Yard Categories: Minimum Widths and Required Planting and Screening Materials"."'.".".."'.""'."'."'.,..".".,.,.""""""'.""".,..."..,...., ..,..,130 Table 647-2. Required Buffer yards"..,......".".."",." ,.,."",..,..,....,'..' ....,.., ...... ..... ,131 Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 List of Tables VI Table 652-1. Shared Parking Calculations""""..,..,..",....",.".., '.,..""",.., ...."""" ....135 Table 652-2. Required Off-Street Parking Spaces""," ......,..,..""..""....",...,...."".." ..136 Table 654-1. Off-Street Parking Dimensions (minimum values in feet),.""".."",......"" ....144 Table 654-2. Driveway Widths, except for lots containing single-family detached dwellings"......."'.. ,., ........",..".."""""..,..,..,..",..""..".., ....".... ....145 Table 655-1. Off-Street Loading Requirements,....",..,..,.. ,..,........,.."......,.." .....,.... ..146 Table 668-1. Types and Number of On-Premise Signs Permitted by Zoning Districts,'" '.'.."", ,.,....,..",..",..",..",'..',..,..""...,....."""..,...., ......,158 Table 669-1. On-Premise Signs: Dimensional, Height, and Setback Regulations.......... ...... ....159 Table 673-1. Temporary Signs: Maximum Square Footage of Sign Area.... ......... ........ ......160 Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 vii LIe! of Table. Ceneral Provisions 36.2-100 Title TIlls Chapter shall be known, cited, and referred to as the "Zoning Ordinance" and shall include all provisions contained herein, together with the City's zoning map. (a) The location and boundaries of the zoning districts established by this Chapter shall be as shown upon a series of certain electronic maps entitled "Official Zoning 1fap, City of Roanoke, Virginia," dated December 5, 2005, as amended, which are maintained by the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development and are hereby made a part of this Chapter. Such maps, together with all notations, references, and other information shown thereon, and all amendments thereto, shall be referred to in this Chapter as the "Official Zoning Map," (b) Upon the adoption of ordinances amending the Official Zoning Map, the City Clerk shall forward to the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development attested copies of such ordinances. Upon receipt of these ordinances, the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development shall amend the Official Zoning Map, 36.2-101 General Purpose and Intent Pursuant to Section 15,2-2283, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, zoning regulations and districts are set forth in this Chapter for the general purposes of implementing the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Roanoke and promoting the health, safety, and general welfare of the puhlic. To these ends, this Chapter is designed for the following purposes: (a) To provide for adequate light, air, convenience of access, and safety from fire, flood, crime, and other dangers; (b) To reduce or prevent congestion in the public streets; (c) To facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive, and harmonious community; (d) To facilitate the provision of adequate police and fire protection, disaster evacuation, civil defense, transportation, water, sewerage, flood protection, schools, parks, forests, playgrounds, recreational facilities, airports, and other public requirements; (e) To protect against destruction of or encroachment upon historic areas; (1) To protect against one or more of the following: overcrowding of land, undue density of population in relation to the community facilities existing or available, obstruction of light and air, danger and congestion in travel and transportation, or loss of life, health, or property from fire, flood, panic, or other dangers; ZonIng Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 Article 1 1 (g) To encourage economic development activities that provide desirable employment and enlarge the tax base; (It) To provide for the preservation of agricultural and forestal lands and other lands of significance for the protection of the natural environment; (i) To protect approach slopes and other safety areas of licensed airports; 0J To promote the creation and preservation of affordable housing suitable for meeting the current and future needs of the locality as well as a reasonable proportion of the current and future needs of the planning district within which the City is situated; and (k) To protect surface water and ground water as defined in Section 62,1-255, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, 36.2-102 Applicability (a) General applicability The provisions of this Chapter sltaIl apply to all property located within the corporate limits of the City of Roanoke to the extent pennitted by law. (b) Exemptions Except where specifically provided for in this Chapter, nillroad tracks, signals, bridges, and similar facilities located on a milroad right-{)f.way sltaIl be exempt from the regulations of this Chapter, Such exemption shall not apply to milroad yards, cillroad shops, and similar facilities, 36.2-103 Consistency with Comprehensive Plan This Chapter implements the Comprehensive Plan of the City of Roanoke, as amended, including all documents adopted as elements of the Comprehensive Plan. 36.2-104 Coordination with Other Regulations The use of buildings and land within the City is subject to all other regulations as well as this Chapter, whether or not such other provisions are specifically referenced in this Chapter, References to other regulations or provisions of this Chapter or other chapters of this Code are for the convenience of the reader, Lack of a cross.reference sltaIl not be consttued as an indication that other regulations do not apply, 36.2-105 Rules of Interpretation and Construction (a) Higher standards govern Wherever any regulation in this Chapter imposes higher or more restrictive standards than are required in any other statute, ordinance, or regulation, this Chapter sltaIl govern, Whenever any other statute, ordinance, or regulation imposes higher or more restrictive standards, such other statute, ordinance, or regulation shall govem. (b) (1) Applicability of regulations The regulations set forth in this Chapter shall be considered the minimum requirements to protect public health, safety, comfort, prosperity, and genetaI welfare, and to provide a remedy for existing conditions which are detrimental thereto, ZonIng Ordlnanea - City of Roanoka 12/05105 2 Artlela 1 (2) No J.nd or structure shall be altered, used, or occupied, and no structure shall be locared, erected, constructed, reconstructed, altered, repaired, maintained, or moved, except in conformity with the regulations specified herein, (3) No part of a yard or other open space or off-street parking or loading space required for the purpose of complying with this Chapter shall be used to satisfy similar requirements of any other building, except as may be specifically provided. (c) (1) General construction of language The headlines of the articles, divisions, and sections of this Chapter are intended as catchwords to indicate the contents thereof and shall not be deemed or taken to be titles of such sections, or any part thereof, (2) The specific shaD control the general. (3) All words in the present tense include the future tense, (4) All words in the singular nwnber include the ptw:al and the plw:al includes the singular. (5) The word "person" includes a linn, association, organization, partnership, trust, company, or corporation, as well as an individual, (6) The word "shall" is mandato')', The word "may" is permissive, (T) The word "includes" or ''including'' shall not limit a term to the specified examples, but is intended to extend its meaning to all other instances or circumstances of like kind or character. (8) The word "yard" shall mean the required yard, minimwn or maximwn, (d) Terms not defined Where terms are not defined in this Chapter, they shall have their ordinarily accepted meanings, within such context as they are used (e) Measurement of distance All distances specified in this Chapter for the purpose of sepamting uses shall be measured in a horizonml plane from the closest property line of one (1) use to the closest property line of the other use, and for the purpose of separating structures shall be measured in a hotizonml plane from the closest point of one (1) structure to the closest point of the other structure, Specified distances between a use and a residentially zoned district shall be measured in a horizonml plane from the property line of the use to the nearest point of the boundaty line of the residentially zoned district. (f) (1) Zoning district boundaries Where uncertainty exists as to the boundaries of zoning districts shown on the OfliciaJ Zoning Map, the following mles shall apply: (A) District boundaries indicated as approximately following the centerlines of streets, rights-of-way, alleys, railroad lines, or streams or other bodies of water shall be construed to follow such centerlines; (8) District boWldaries indicated as approximately following platted lot lines or city limit lines shall be construed as following such lines; and (C) District boWldaries indicated as approximately paralld to or extensions of features indicated above shall be so construed, and at such distances as indicated on the Official Zoning Map, Distances not specifically indicated on the Official Zoning Map shall be detennined by the scale of the map, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 3 Article 1 (2) In case of annexation to the city, or in case property comes into the tenitoriaI jurisdiction of the city other than by annexation, the regulations applying to the R-l2, Residential Single-Family District, shaIl apply to all such annexed or new tenitory pending an amendment of this Chapter, (3) Whenever any dedicated street, alley, or other public right-of-way is vacated by the Gty Council, the zoning district boundaries adjoining each side of such street, alley, or public right-of-way shall automatically be extended to the centerline of the vacated right-of-way, (4) All water areas, waterways, alleys, roads, streets, highways, r:Wroads, and "ther rights-of-way, if not otherwise specifically designated, shall be deemed to be in the same zoning district as that of the inunediately abutting property, Where the centerline of such described water areas, waterways, or rights-of-way serves as a zoning district boundary, the zoning of such areas, unless otherwise specifically designated, shall be deemed to be the same as that of the abutting property up to such centerline, (5) Where a lot in single ownership is divided by one (1) or more district boundary lines, each portion of the lot shall be subject to all the regulations applicable to the district in which it is located 36.2-106 Permits and Certificates No construction may commence, no use may be established or changed, and no structure shall be constructed, erected, altered, moved, or demolished unless and until all permits required by Article 5 of this Chapter have been issued. 36.2-107 Severability Should any section or any provision of this Chapter be decided by the courts to be unOOllStitutionaI or invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the Chapter as a whole, or any part thereof other than the part so held to be unconstitutional or invalid, and such remainder of this Chapter shall continue in full force and effect. 36.2-108 Vested Rights (a) Nothing in this Chapter shall be construed to authorize the imp<rirment of any vested right Without limiting the time when rights might otherwise vest, a property owner's rights shall be deemed vested in a land use and such vesting shaIl not be affected by a subsequent amendment to this Chapter, when the property owner (1) obtains or is the beneficiary of a significant affinnative governmental act which remains in effect allowing development of a specific project, (2) relies in good faith on the significant affinnative govemmental act, and (3) incurs extensive obligations or substantial expenses in diligent pursuit of the specific project in reliance on the significant affinnative governmental act (b) For purposes of this section and without limitation, the following are deemed to be significant affinnative governmental acts allowing development of a specific project (1) The Gty Council has accepted proffers or proffered conditions which specify use related to a zoning amendment; (2) The Gty Cuuncil has approved a petition for a rezoning for a specific use or densi!), (3) The Board of Zoning AppeaIs has granted a speciaI exception; (4) The Boani of Zoning Appeals has approved a variance; (5) The Gty Council or its designated agent has approved a preliminary subdivision plat, site plan, or plan of development for the property and the applicant pursues approval of the finaI plat or plan within a reasonable period of time under the circumstances; or Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoke 12/05105 4 Article 1 (6) The City Council or its designated agent has approved a final subdivision plat, site plan, or plan of development for the applicant's property. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 5 Article 1 Zoning Dish k..1s 36.2-200 Purpo_ The pwpose of this Article is to establish the zoning districts of the City, both base and overlay, and to provide the genernl roles for the regulation of each district The established districts provide densities that are appropriate for the context of a built environment and establish a building furm relating to the public realm. The districts reflect Roanoke's character in the region as an urban conununity with a compact development pattem and effective street grid. 36.2-201 Establishment of Districts In order to carty out the pwposes of this Chapter, the City of Roanoke shall be divided into zoning districts as established below: (a) Base districts The following base zoning districts are hereby established: (I) Residential zoning districts: Residential-AgricuItur.Il District (RA) R-12 Residential Single-Family District R-7 Residential Single-Family District R-S Residential Singte-Family District R-3 Residential Single-Family District RM-I Residential Mixed Density District RM-2 Residential Mixed Density District Residential Multifamily District (RMF) (2) ConunerciaI zoning districts: Commercial-Neighborhood District (CN) Commercial-General District (CG) Commercial-Large Site District (CLS) (3) Industrial zoning districts: Light Industrial District (1-1) Heavy Industrial District (1.2) Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoka 12/05105 6 Arllela 2 (4) Special purpose zoning districts: Downtown District (D) Mixed Use District (MX) Institutional District (IN) Recreation and Open Space District (ROS) Airport Development District (AD) Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) Institutional Planned Unit Development District (lNPUD) Industrial Planned Unit Development District (!PUD) (b) Overlay zoning districts The following overlay zoning districts are hereby established: Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-l) Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2) Neighborhood Design Overlay District (ND) Floodplain Overlay District (F) Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RCC) Comprehensive Sign Overlay District 36.2-202 Zoning Map The boundaries of the zoning districts established in Section 36,2-201 shall be as shown upon the Official Zoning Map as set forth in Article 1 of this Chapter. 36.2-203 Development Standards and Supplemental Regulations In addition to the regulations for specific zoning districts set forth in Article 3 of this Chapter, development standards applicable to all zoning districts, unless otherwise provided, are set forth in Article 6, and supplemental regulations applicahle to particular uses or building types, within one or more districts, are set forth in Article 4, 36.2-204 Use Regulations (a) Applicability Pursuant to Section 15.2-2280, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, Article 3 of this Chapter regulates the use of all land and structures for commercial, industrial, residential, and other categories ofland uses, (b) (1) Permitted uses The pennitted uses, as of right and by special exception, for each base zoning district are set forth in matrix fonnat in Section 36,2-340 and are referred to in this Chapter as a "Use Matrix." (2) Uses pennitted as of right or by special exception shall be subject to all provisions of this Chapter, (c) (1) Interpretation of use matrix In the case of mixed uses, the regulation for each use, as provided in Article 3, shall apply to that portion of the building or land so utilized, unless otherwise provided, (2) If a use is specifically identified in the Use Matrix, while a more general use category is also listed, the regulations and applicability of the specifically identified use shall govern, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoka 12/05105 7 Artlela 2 (3) For a use not identified in the Use Matrix, the Zoning Administrator may determine that such use is substantially the same as another use otherwise pennitted in the Use Matrix. Such decision of the Zoning Administrator shall be recorded in writing, 36.2-205 Dimensional Regulations (a) (1) Applicability Each section of Article 3 establishes minimum and ma:ximum standards for the size, height, area, and bulk of structures, the areas and dimensions of land and air space to be occupied by structures and uses, and yards and other open spaces to be left unoccupied by uses and structures, pursuant to Section 15.2-2280, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. (2) Supplement>! regulations (Article 4) that conlllin certain dimensional requirements shalJ supersede the dimensional requirement of the applicable zoning district as set forth in Article 3 or this section. (3) In addition to the dimensional regulations set forth in Article 3 for each zoning district, dimensional regulations shalJ be further defined as set forth in Section 36,2-205 (b) through (k), (b) (1) Density When calculating the ma:ximum allowable density for any lot, any fractional dwelling count shalJ be equal to zero dwdling writs, (2) Any lands nonnalIy submerged under water shalJ not be included in computing the allowable number of dwdling writs for any lot (3) For single-family detached dwellings, except in the MXPUD District, no ma:ximum number of tot>! permitted dwellings is established because the tot>! number of dwdling writs shalJ be governed by the minimum lot area. (c) Lot area Any lot, legally in existence at the time this Chapter was adopted, which does not meet the minimum lot area or minimum lot frontage requirements of the district in which it is located, as set forth in Article 3 of this Chapter, may be developed, subject to the use and other dimensional requirements of the applicable district (d) (1) Lot frontage EveI)' building erected or moved shalJ be located on a lot that has frontage on an improved public street or a private street in a MXPUD, INPUD, or IPUD District (2) Lots that existed prior to the adoption of this Chapter that have no frontage on a public street may provide access from a private street that has been approved by the City Manager, No such lot may be further subdivided unless frontage on a public street is provided consistent with the applicable zoning district regulation. (3) In all residential districts, the minimum lot frontage requirements for developments on cul-de-sacs shalJ be measured at the point of the required depth of the front yard but in no case shalJ the frontage at the right-of- way line be less than thirty-five (35) feet (4) Lot frontage requirements fur townhouses and rowhouses shalJ be govemed by Section 36,2-431. (5) In addition to the lot frontage required by the applicable zoning district, all structures shalJ be tocated on lots so as to comply with any adopted ordinances of the City relating to public service and fire protection. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 8 Article 2 (e) (1) Yards, generally Applicability: YaIds shall be defined as set forth in Appendix A and applied as set forth in Article 2, except as may otherwise be provided in this Chapter. Whenever more than one principal building is located on a lo~ the yards required by the applicable zoning district shall be estllblisbed and maintained on the lot around the group of buildings, Buildings shall be sepamted by any distance prescribed by the fire prevention and protection regulations of Chapter 12 of this Code. (2) P=nitted encroachments in yards: Yards shall be unoccupied and unobstructed as defined in Appendix 1>. except that encroachments over thirty (30) inches in height into yards shall be pennitted as set forth in Table 205-1, provided the structure with which the encroaclunent is associated is confonning, or if the structure is nonconfonning, provided the encroachment does not increase any nonconforming characteristic of the structure. Table 205-L Pennitted Yard EncroachmenlB (A) (B) (q (D) Feature Front Side Rear Bay windows, projecting no more than 2 feet into yanI Y N Y Chimneys, projecting no more than 2 feet into yanI Y Y Y Flagpoles Y Y Y Handicap tamps in residential application only, projecting into yanI no Y-7feet Y - 4feel Y - 10 feet more than distance specified in CollUDDs (B), (q, and (D), respectively Heating and cooling units or solar panels, projecting no more than 2 feet N Y Y intoyanl Overhanging roof; eave, gutter, comice, or awning, projecting into yanI no Y -2 feet Y-lfoot Y-2feet more than distance specified in CollUDDs (B), (q, and (D), respectively Protective hoods or overhangs over a doorway, projecting no more than 2 Y N Y feet into yanI Retaining walls Y Y Y Unenclosed decks, terraces, steps, stoops, or pooches of a height not exceeding 4 fee~ projecting no more than 2 feet into yard "Unenclosed" N N Y means that the feature has no. walls or other pennanent vertical or horizontal enclosures other than a or balustrade, Rules of InteIpretlltion for Table 205-1: CollUDD (A) lists the encroaclunen~ and in certain circumstances defines the maximwn distance the encroachment may project into the yanI where such encroachment is pennitted. Columns (B) through (D) indicate the yanI types, with "Y" meaning that the encroachment is pennitted in the yanI, and "N" meaning that the encroaclunent is not pennitted in the yanI, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 9 Article 2 (f) Front yards (1) The depth of a front yard shaIJ be measured at a right angle to the street line. In the case of a curved street line, the depth shaIJ be measured on the tadiaI line, (2) In the R-7, R-5, and R-3 Residential Single-Family Districts and the RM.l and RM,2 Residential Mixed Density Districts, the required depth of the front yard shaIJ be determined and applied in accordance with subsections (A), (B), and (C), below, provided that, in the application of subsection (A) or (B), the Zoning Administrator may require a greater yard depth for public safety reasons, (A) Where there are buildings on adjoining lots, the minimwn and maximwn front yard depths for the applicable zoning district shaIJ not appty, and the minimwn front yaId depth shaIJ be equal to the shalJowest of the established building lines on the adjoining lots and the maximwn front yard shaIJ be five (5) feet from that established minimwn front yard; (B) Where there are no buildings on adjoining lots but there are existing buildings on the block face, the minimwn and maximwn front yaId depths for the applicable zoning district shaIJ not appty, and the minimwn front yard depth shaIJ be equal to the shalJowest of the established building lines on the block face and the maximwn front yard shaIJ be five (5) feet from that established minimwn front yard; or (C) Where there are no buildings on the block face, the minimwn and maximwn front yard depths for the applicable zoning district shaIJ apply, (3) In all zoning districts, other than those set forth in subsection (2) above, the required depth of the minimwn and maximwn front yards shaIJ be established by the applicable zoning district regulations as set forth in Article 3, (4) In the application of maximwn front yards as required by this Chapter, at least sixty (60) pettent of the building ~ade shaIJ abut the line of the maximwn front yaId depth or shaIJ lie between the lines of the minimwn and maximwn front yard depths, Building Facade . Maximwn Front Yard Minimwn Front Yard 60% of building facade within min.lmax. front yard lines (5) When more than one (1) principal structure is located on a lot, as pennitted by this Chapter, and where maximwn front yards apply, at least fifty (SO) pettent of the yard width shaIJ contain facades of principal structures. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoko 12/05105 10 Article 2 (g) Side yards The required width of a side yard shall be measured at right angles to the adjacent side lot line, (h) Rear yards The depth of a rear yard shall be measured at a right angle to the rear property line, (i) (1) Yards - Corner lots In the case of a comer lot with two (2) street frontages, in the R.7, R-5, and R-3 Residential Single-Family Districts and the RM-l and RM-2 Residential Mixed Density Districts, minimwn front yard depths shall be determined as follows: (A) One front yard shall be provided pursuant to the requi=nents of Section 36,2-205(1)(2); and (B) A second front yard shall be provided ofhalf the depth required pursuant to subsection (A), above, but not to be less than ten (10) feet (2) In the case of a comer lot with two (2) street frontages in all zoning districts other than those set forth in subsection (1) above, minimwn front yards shall be provided as follows: (A) One front yard shall be provided pwsuantto the minimwn front yard reqwrements of the applicable zoning district; and (B) A second front yard shall be provided of at least one-half (1/2) the depth resulting from subsection (A) above, (3) In the case of a comer lot with more than two (2) slreet frontages in the R.7, R-5, and R-3 Residential Single- Family Districts and the RM-l and RM-2 Residential Mixed Density Districts, minimwn front yards shall be provided as follows: (A) Two (2) front yards shall be provided pursuant to Section 36,2-205(1)(2); and (B) Additional front yards shall be provided of at least one.half (1/2) the depth required pursuant to subsection (A) above, but not to be less than ten (10) feet (4) In the case of a comer lot with more than two (2) Slreet frontages in all zoning districts other than those set forth in subsection (3) above, front yards shall be provided as follows: (A) Two (2) front yards shall be provided pursuant to the minimwn front yard requi=nents of the applicable zoning district; and (B) Additional front yards shall be provided of at least one-half (1/2) the depth of one (1) of the yards resulting from subsection (A) above, (5) In the case of any comer lot, any yards =naining after full and half-depth front yards have been established, as set forth in subsections (1), (2), (3), and (4) above, shall be considered side yards, (6) In the case of any comer lot, where maximwn front yards are established by this Chapter, such maximwn front yard requi=nents shall apply to only one (1) of the front yards, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 11 ArtIcle 2 (i) (1) Yards - Through lots In the case of a through lot, front yanIs shall be provided on both frontages, (2) In the R-7, R-5, and R-3 Residential Single-Family Districts and the RM.l and RM-2 Residential Mixed Density Districts, two (2) front yanIs shall be provided pursuant to Section 36.2-205(1)(2). (3) In all zoning districts other than those set forth in subsection (2) above, the required depth of the minimum and maximum front yards shall be established by the applicable zoning district regulations as set forth in Article 3, (4) In the case of a through lot, side yards shall extend from the rear lines of the front yards required, (5) In the case of a through lot, where maximum front yards are established by this Chapter, such maximum front yard requirements shall apply to only one (1) of the front yanIs, (k) (1) Height Applicability: The maximum height regulations set forth in Article 3 for each hase zoning district shall apply to principal and accessoty buildings, Ths Chapter contains other applicable height standards for signs (Article 6) and fences, walls, and certain other structures set forth in the supplemental regulations of Article 4, (2) Exemptions: (A) In all zoning districts, except for properties in the Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN), the maximum height regulations set forth in Article 3 shall not apply to any of the following parts or appurtenances of a building not intended for human occupancy: (i) Church spires, belfries, cupolas, chimneys, smokestacks, flagpoles, attached whip antennas less than eight (8) feet in length, and similar structures; (n) Elevator penthouses, towers, and mechanical or electrical equipment except satellite dishes, located on a roof provided that such features shall be erected only to the height necessaty to accomplish the putpose they are intended to serve and the total area covered by such features shall not exceed twenty (20) percent of the horizontal area of the roof on which they are located; and (Ui) Parapet walls or cornices, without windows, which do not exceed the maximum height requirement for the district in which they are located by more than four (4) feet (B) In all zoning districts, except for properties in the Heavy Industrial District (1-2), the maximum height regulations set forth for each base zoning district shall not apply to wireless telecommunications facilities, stealth wireless telecommunications facilities, and broadcasting towers, subject to the provisions of Section 36.2-432. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 12 Article 2 Regulations for Specific Zoning Districts 36.2-300 Purpose The pwpose of this Article is to estllblish use, dimensional, open space, and cerlllin specific regulations for each zoning district. Division 1. Base Districts - Residential, Commercial, and Industrial 36.2-310 Residential-Agricultural District (RA) (a) Purpose The pwpose of the ResidentiaI-AgricuItumI District (RA) is to provide for the continued use of agricultunilly productive lands, Uses and standards in this district are intended to preserve and protect agricultumllands by maintaining a low population density and a roraI character of development (b) Uses The uses permitted as of right or by specillI exception in the RA District shaII be as set forth in Section 36.2-340. (c) Principal structures per lot In the RA District, only one (1) principal structure shaII be permitted on a single lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standanIs forlots within the ResidentiaI-Agticultuml District (RA) shaII be as set forth in Table 310.1. (e) Livestock In the RA District, no livestock shall be fenced, stllbled, quartered, or allowed to graze within one hW1dred (100) feet of any tot not located within an RA District. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 13 Article 3 Table 310-L Dimensional Matrix for Residential-Agricultural District (RA) Standard RA Density (minimum square footage oftot area per dwelling unit) 43,560 Lot area, minimum (square feet) 43,560 Lot area, maximum (square feet) -. Lot frontage, minimum (feet) 150 Lot frontage, maximum (feet) -- Front yard, minimum (feet) 30 Front yard, maximum (feet) .. Side yards, minimum combined width (feet) 25 Side yard, minimum (feet) 10 Rear yard, minimum (feet) 50 Height, maximum (feet)' 45 Floor area ratio, maximum. -- Impervious surface ratio, maximum 25% 1 Silos in the RA District shall be exempt from maximum height regulations, except for properties in the Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN), Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 14 Article 3 36.2-311 Residential Single-Family Districts (R-12, RoT, R-5, R-3) (a) Purpose The residential single-family zoning districts are intended to protect residential neighborhoods, to provide a range of housing choices, and to incorporate neighborhood principles including lot frontages, huilding setbacks, and densities that are CUStomaI)' in urban and suburban neighborhoods, (b) Uses The uses pennitted as of right or by special exception in the R-I2, R-7, R-5, and R-3 Districts shall be as set forth in Section 36,2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the R-12, R-7, R-5, and R-3 Districts, only one (I) principal structure shall be permitted on a single lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standards for lots within the R-I2, R-7,R-5, and R-3 Districts shall be as set forth in Tahle 311-1. Table 311-L Dimensional Mattix for Residential Single-Family Districts (R-12, R-7, R-S, R-3) Standard R-12 R-7 R-S R-3 Density (minimwn square footage oflot area per dwelling unit) 12,000 7,000 5,000 3,000 Lot area, minimwn (square feet) 12,000 7,000 5,000 3,000 Lot area, maximwn (square feet) - - -- - . Lot frontage, minimwn (feet) 80 60 50 30 Lot frontage, maximwn (feet) - -- - - Front yatd, minimwn (feet)' 20 20 20 15 Front yatd, maximwn (feet)' - - 40 25 Side yards, minimwn combined width (feet) 18 10 10 8 Side yatd, minimwn (feet) 8 4 4 4 Rear yatd, minimwn (feet) 30 15 IS IS Height, maximwn (feet) 35 35 35 35 Floor area ratio, maximum - - -- - Impervious surface ratio, maximum 50% 50% 60% 70% I Suhject to the provisions of Section 36.2-205(1), 2 Suhject to rhe provisions of Section 36.2-205(1), Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 15 Article 3 36.2-312 Residential Mixed Density Districts (RM-1, RM-2) (a) Purpose The residentiaI mixed density zoning districts are intended to allow for a mix of single-family detached, two-family, townhouse, and multifamily dwellings in order to provide a tango of housing choices, (b) Uses The uses pennitted as of right or by special exception in the RM.l and RM-2 Districts shall be as set forth in Section 36.2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the RM-l District, only one (1) principal structure shall be pennitted on a single lot In the RM,2 District, more than one (1) principal structure may be pennitted on a single lot subject to the yard and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 312-1, When a lot contains more than one (1) principal structure, the tot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 312-1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal stmctures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standatds for lots within the RM-l and RM-2 Districts shall be as set forth in Table 312.1. Table 312-1- Dimensional Matrix for Residential Mixed Density Districts (RM-1, RM-2) Standard RM-t RM-2 Density (minimum square footage of lot area per dwelling unit), 2,500 2,500 except Two-family d~\ling (dupte~) Density (minimum square footage of lot area per dwelling unit), 3,500 2,500 Two-family dwellinl!; (duptex) Lot area, minimum (square feet) 5,000 5,000 Lot area, maximum (square feet) -- 25,000 Lot frontage, minimum (feet) 50 50 Lot frontage, maximum (feet) -. 150 Front yard, minimum (feet)' 10 10 Front yard, maximum (feet)' 30 30 Side yards, minimum combined width (feet) 8 8 Side yard, minimum (feet) 4 4' Rear yard, minimum (feet) 15 IS' Height, maximum (feet) 35 45 Floor area ratio, maximum -- -. Impervious surface ratio, maximum 60% 70% I Subject to the provisions of Section 36,2.205(1), , Subject to the provisions of Section 36.2-205(1), 3 Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum side yard established in Table 312-1, the required buffer yard shall govern the minimum side yard requirement. 4 Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum rear yard established in Table 312-1, the required buffer yard shall govern the minimum rear yard requirement, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 16 ArtIcle 3 36.2-313 Residential Multifamily District (RMF) (a) Purpose The Residential Multifamily District (RMF) is intended to pennit dense housing development by providing for multifamily and townhouse dwellings, (b) Uses The uses pennitted as of right or by specW exception in the RMF District shall be as set forth in 36.2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the RMF District, more than one (1) principal structure may be pennitted on a single lot subject 10 the yard and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 313-1. When a tot contlins more than one (1) principal structure, the lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 313.1 shall appty only to the lot, and not 10 the principal structures on the to!. (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standards for lots within the RMF District shall be as set forth in Table 313-1. (e) Usable open space for multifamily dwellings For multifamily dwellings in the RMF District, one hundred (100) square feet of usable open space per dwelling unit on the lot shall be provided, Table 313-1. Dimensional Matrix for Residential Multifamily District (RMF) Standard RMF Density (mimmwn square footage of lot area per dwelling unit) 1,000 Lot area, mimmwn (square feet) 15,000 Lot area, maximum (square feet) -- Lot frontage, mimmwn (feet) 100 Lot frontage, maximwn (feet) -- Front yard, mimmwn (feet) 10 Front yard, maximwn (feet) .- Side yards, mimmwn combined width (feet) ,- Side yard, mimmwn (feet) IS' Rear yard, mimmwn (feet) IS' Height, maximwn (feet) 45' Floor area ratio, maximwn -- Impervious surface ratio, maximum 70% 1 Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), that is greater than the required mimmwn side yard established in Table 312-1, the required buffer yard shan govern the mimmwn side yard requirement, 2 Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). that is greater than the required minimum rear yard established in Table 312-1, the required buffer yard shall govern the mimmwn rear yard requirement. , The maximwn height of slnlctures may be increased, up to a maximwn height of sixty (60) feet, provided that for every one (1) foot of height above forty-five (45) feet, one (1) foot shall be added to all mimmwn side and rear yards. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 17 Article 3 36.2-314 Commercial Districts (CN, CG, CLS) (a) Purpose This section establishes regulations for the following commercial zoning districts: (1) The Commercial-NeighbOl:hood District (CN) is intended to encowoge a concentration of neighborhood- scaled retail, office, and service uses, in clearly defined, compact areas in close proximity to residential neighborhoods, The regulations of the district are intended to control the scale of non-residential buildings in a manner that makes them compatible with and appropriate for sunounding residential areas and to encowoge a development pattem that consists of ground floor commercial uses wirh offices and residential uses on the upper floor levels, The district is intended to promote pedestrian-oriented development, with buildings located close to the street, pedestrian-scaled signage, main entrances oriented to the street frontage sidewalk, windows or display cases along building facades which face the street, and significant building coverage of the site. Although parking areas may be provided, they are genetally limited in size and are de- emphasized by their toeation on rhe site. (2) The Commercial-Genernl District (CG) is intended to pennit motor vehicle dependent uses that are genetally developed as single use developments on individual lots, subject to landscaping, access, and signage standards, Such development is generally chaIacterized by individual curh cuts, access drives, and signage, It is intended that this district be applied primarily along heavily traveled arterial streets, with an emphasis on clustering such development at major intersections, While recognizing the motor vehicle traffic genCIated by the uses pennitted in this district, it is the intent of the regulations of the district to encowoge and recognize pedestrian access and public ttansit forms of transportation by locating parking to the side and rear of buildings and minimizing conflict through landscaping and signage standards, The uses pennitted in this district genetally require a high volume of traffic along the frontage of the establishment and incIode horizontally oriented buildings, Such permitted uses include genernl retail establishments, offices, service establishments, motor vehicle related sales and service, eating establishments, and entertaimnent uses. The CG District is also intended to acconunodate travel-oriented uses such as hotels, motels, and gasoline stations. (3) The Conunercial-Latge Site District (CLS) is intended to accommodate multiple buildings and uses that are large in scale and genetally chaIacterized by multiple tenants or uses on a single zoning tot which share common parking, curb cuts, driveways, and access to and from public streets. These uses and areas are heavily dependent on the motor vehicle and tend to result in large parking areas and outdoor display of merchandise. CLS District uses include large motor vehicle sales and service establishments and commWlity and regional shopping centers. The district standards provide for landscaped buffers to minimize the impact of CLS uses on SUIIOunding areas. (b) Uses The uses pennitted as of right or by special exception in the CN, CG, and CLS Districts sbaII be as set forth in Section 36,2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the CN, CG, and CLS Districts, more than one (1) principal structure may be permitted on a single lot, subject to the yanI, floor area Illtio, and impervious surface IlltiO requirements of Table 314-1. When a lot contains more than one (1) principal structure, the lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 314-1 sbaII apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot. (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standaIds fortots within the CN, CG, and CLS Districts sbaII be as set forth in Table 314-1. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 18 Article 3 (e) Pedestrian access In the CN, CG, and as Districts, designated pedestrian pathways shall be provided and marked from the public sidewalk, or the public right-of-way where there is no public sidewalk, to the public entrance of any principal building, (f) (I) Development standards for CN District Maximum buiIding footprint Unless otherwise stated, the maximum gross ground floor area (the "footprint") of any new structure in the CN District shall be fifteen thousand (15,000) square feet (2) Fa<;ade treatment In the CN District, in order to promote pedestrian interest and activity and to enhance security and safety by pennitting visibility into and out of buildings, a minimum of fifty (SO) percent of the ground floor primary building facade shall be transparent from the street through the provision of glass. Such transparency shall begin at a height no greater than three (3) feet above the gmcle of the adjacent sidewalk or the finished gmcle of the site, Table 314-1. Dimensional Matrix for Commercial DistrictB (CN, CG, CLS) Standard CN CG CLS Density (minimum square footage oflot area per dwelling unit) 1,800 - -- Lot area, minimum (square feet) 5,000 10,000 90,000 Lot area, maximum (square feet) 20,000 130,680 -- Lot frontage, minimum (feet) - 100 ISO Lot frontage, maximum (feet) 200 - -- Front yard, minimum (feet) - 10 20 Front yard, maximum (feet) 10 30 - Side yards, minimum combined width (feet) - - - Side yard, minimum (feet)' -- - 25 Rear yard, minimum (feet)' - - 25 Height, maximum (feet) 45 --' __4 Floor area ratio, maximum -- 5,0 5,0 Impervious surface ratio, maximwn 100% 85% 80% , Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 362-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum side yard established in Table 314-1, including where no minimum side yard is required, the required buffer yard shall govern the minimum side yard requirement. 'Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum rear yard established in Table 314-1, including where no minimum rear yard is required, the required buffer yard shall govem the minimum rear yard requirement. 3 There shall be no maximum height of structures in the CG District, except that where a lot in the CG District abuts a residential district, the maximum heigbt of any structure in the CG District shall be forty,five (45) feet, 4 There shall be no maximum height of a structure in the as District, except that where a lot in the as District abuts a residential district, the maximum height of any structure in the CLS District shall be one (1) foot of height for one (1) foot of setback from the abutting residentially zoned tot, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 19 Article 3 36.2-315 Industrial Districts (1-1, 1-2) (a) Purpose Tbis section establishes regulations for the following industrial zoning districts: (1) The Light Industrial District (I-I) is intended for a =ge of wholesale, warehousing, distribution, stoIage, repair and service, assembly or processing, fabrication or manufacturing, accessory commen:iat and oflice uses, intensive commetcial uses, and other types of uses such as flex space, The regulations of the I-I District are intended to mitigate conflict between adjacent uses within the district and to protect neighboring non- industrial districts and uses, (2) The Heavy Industrial District (I-2) is intended for a =ge of intensive industrial uses, including manufacturing. assembly, fabrication, bulk storage, and processing as well as limited, closely related support commercial uses. The 1-2 District regulations are intended to protect other districts from the potentially harmful effects of pennitted 1-2 uses, (b) Uses TIle uses pennitted as of right or by special exception in the 1-1 and 1.2 Districts shall be as set forth in Section 362-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the 1.1 and 1.2 Districts, more than one (1) principal structure may be pennitted on a single lot, subject to the yard, /loor area ratio, and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 315-1. TIle lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 315-1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional stlndan\s for lots within the 1-1 and 1-2 Districts sball be as set forth in Table 315-1. Table 315-1. Dimensional Matrix for Industrial Districts (1-1, 1-2) Standard 1-1 1-2 Density - - Lot area, minimum (square feet) 10,000 20,000 Lot area, maximum (square feet) - .- Lot frontal!e, minimum (feet) 100 100 Lot frontal!e, maximum (feet) - .. Front yard, minimum (feet) - 30 Front yard, maximum (feet) 30 -- Side yards, minimum combined width (feet) ,- .. Side yard, minimum (feet)' .. - Rear yard, minimum (feet) --' 30 HeiRht, maximum (feet)' .. .. Floor area ratio, maximum 20 2,0 Impervious surface ratio, maximwn 90% 90% I No minimum side yard is required, except that if a buffer yard is required as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c), the depth of such buffer yard shall establish the minimum side yard requirement. 'No minimum rear yard is required, except that if a buffer yard is required as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), the depth of such buffer yard shall establish the minimum rear yard requirement , There shall be no maximum height in the 1.1 and 1-2 Districts, except that where an I-lor 1-2 District abuts a residential district, the maximum height of any structure in the I-lor 1-2 District shall be one (1) foot of height for one (1) foot of setback from the abutting residentially zoned lot Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 20 Attlcle 3 Division 2. Base Districts - Special Purpose Districts 36.2-320 Purpose The special pmpose districts are intended to provide for the suitable regulation ofland uses and development pattems that do not fit traditionlll residential, conunetciaI, and industrial zoning classifications, The pmpose of the standards of these special pwpose districts is to allow for greater flexibility in site design while maintaioing the integrity and achieving the goals of these areas, Such districts are generally applied to areas contaioing special land uses, having unique character, or contaioing mixed land uses which are difficult to regulate using unifonn bulk and density standards, Each special pwpose district is intended to promote the policies set forth in the City's Comprehensive Plan and to encourage land use and development in compliance with the principles set forth in such Plan. 36.2-321 Downtown District (D) (a) Purpose The Downtown District (1)) is intended to allow a wide variety of uses and relatively intense development in the downtown, consistent with historic development patterns, in a manner that protects and enhances the business and cultural center of the City and region, Toward that end, the Downtown District is intended to accomplish the following: (1) To facilitate pedestrian ways and create a convenient and hannonious development ofbuilding>, streets, and open space; (2) To protect and enhance the public interest in downtown as a source of economic vitality, the retention and creation of jobs, and tax revenue; (3) To protect existing investment in downtown, to protect agoinst the demolition of downtown's historic buildings, to promote activity on public streets, and to protect amenities provided through public investment; and (4) To provide for a mix ofhigh density residential, commercial, retail, government services, entertainment and cultural facilities, and live/work space, (b) Uses The uses permitted as of right or by special exception in the Downtown District (1)) shall be as set forth in Section 36,2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the Downtown District (1)), more than one (1) principal structure may be permitted on a single lot, subject to the yard, floor area 1'oltio, and impervious surface 1'oltio requirements of Table 321-1. When a lot contains more than one (1) principal structure, the lot frontage and tot area requirements of Table 321.1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensionlll standards for lots within the Downtown District (1)) shall be as set forth in Table 321.1. (e) Development standard In the Downtown District (1)), in order to promote pedestrian interest and activity and to enhance security and sarety by permitting visibility into and out of buildings, a minimum of fifty (50) percent of the ground floor primary building facade shall be transparent from the street through the provision of glass, Such transparency shall begin at a height no greater than three (3) feet above the grade of the adjacent sidewalk or the finished grade of the site, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 21 Artlele 3 Table 321-L Dimensional Matrix for Downtown District (D) Standard D Density - Lot area, minimum - Lot area, maximum - Lot frontage, minimum - Lot frontage, 1llllXimum .- Front yard, minimum -- Front yard, 1llllXimum' 10 feet Side yards, minimum combined width -- Side yard, minimum --' Rear yard, minimum --' Height, 1llllXimum (feet) - Floor area mtio, maximwn 15,0 Impervious surface ratio, maximum - 1 There shall be no maximum front yard requirement in the D District if the proposed development provides a civic space, accessible to the general public, between the building line and the adjacent public right-of-way, which civic space meets the following standards: (a) At least fifty (50) percent of the civic space shall consist of a plaza or courtyard within which is provided at least one (1) linear foot of seating for each fifty (50) square feet of plaza or courtyard and at least two (2) of the following amenities: ornamental fountains, sculptures, trellises, planted beds, or clock pedestals; and (b) The balance of the civic space shall include one (1) tree per 350 square feet, one deciduous or evergreen shrub per five (5) square feet, and vegetative ground cover. , No minimum side yard is required, except that if a buffer yard is required as set forth io Section 36.2-647(c), the depth of such buffer yard shall establish the minimum side yard requirement, , No minimum rear yard is required, except that if a buffer yard is required as set forth in Section 36,2--647(c), the depth of such buffer yard shall establish the minimum rear yard requirement Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 22 Article 3 36.2-322 Mixed Use District (MX) (a) Purpose The 1\.fuced Use District (MX) is intended to accommodate residential uses, office uses, and support services within the same district. The intent of the district is that 00 retail sales uses be permitted and that the district facilitates a harmonious mixture of office and residential uses. The regulations of the district are intended to protect the character and scale of such a mixed-use development pattern by permitting low-intensity development at a scale that recognizes and respects residential patterns of development. (b) Uses The uses permitted as of right or by specia! exception in the MX District shall be as set forth in Section 36.2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the MX District, more than one (1) principal structure may be permitted on a single lot, subject to the yard, floor area mtio, and impervious surface mtio requi=nents of Table 322,1. When a lot contains more than one (1) principal structure, the lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 322-1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standards for lots within the MX District shall be as set forth in Table 322-1. Table 322-1. Dimensional Matrix for Mixed Use District (MX) Standard MX Density (minimum square footage oftot area per dwelling unit) 2,500 Lot area, minimum 5,000 Lot area, maximum -- Lot frontage, minimum (feet) 50 Lot frontage, maximum (feet) - Front yard, minimum (feet) 10 Front yard, maximum (feet) 30 Side yan:Is, minimum combined width (feet) - Side yard, minimum (feet)! 5 Rear yard, minimum (feet)' 15 Height, maximum (feet) 45 Floor area ratio, maximwn 1.0 Impervious surface mtio, maximum 70% I Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum side yard established in Table 322-1, the required buffer yard shall govern the minimum side yard requirement. 2 Where a buffer yard is required, as set forth in Section 36,2-647(c), that is greater than the required minimum rear yard established in Table 322-1, the required buffer yard shall govern the minimum rear yard requi=nent. Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoke 12/05105 23 Article 3 36.2-323 Institutional District (IN) (a) Purpose The Institutional District (IN) is intended to provide stlndards for the accommodation of institutional developments of one (1) principal peonilled use on zoning lots of five (5) acres or less in onler to achieve the following specific purposes: (1) Recognize the unique needs of institutional uses and their relationship with neighboring land uses; (2) Reduce ttaffic congestion, provide adequate padring, and promote pedestrian linkages; (3) Facilitate the creation of a convenient and hannonious development of buildings, padring, and open spaces for individual institutional uses; (4) Ensure the proper functioning of such institutional uses; and (5) Minimize the potential for adverse impacts of institutional uses on adjacentIand uses, (b) Uses The uses pemUlled as of right or by special exception in the IN District shall be as set forth in Section 36.2-340. (c) Principal structures per lot In the IN District, more than one principal structure may be pemUlted on a single lot, subject to the yard and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 323-1. When a tot contains more than one (1) principal slnlcture, the lot frontage and tot area requirements of Table 323.1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional Stlndards for tots within the IN District shall be as set forth in Table 323-1. (e) Pedestrian access In the IN District, designated pedestrian pathways shall be provided and marked from the public sidewalk, or the public right-of-way where there is no public sidewalk, to the public entrance of any principal buikling, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 24 ArlIcle 3 Table 323-1. Dimensional Matrix for Institutional District (IN) Standard IN Density - Lot area, minimum - Lot area, maximum 5 acres Lot frontage, minimum 100 feet Lot frontage, maximum - Front yatd, minimum and maximum (where IN District Same as abutting zoning district abuts; sirurle zoni= district in the same block fuce) Front yatd, minimum and maximum (where IN District Av=ge of the two (2) abutting zoning districts abuts two different zoni= districts in same block fuce) Front yatd, minimum (where IN District extends for 20 feet entire block face) Front yard, maximum (where IN District extends for 40 feet entire block face) Side yards, minimum combined width - Side yatd, minimum 1 0 fee~ unless subject to a greater buffer yard reauirement as set forth in Section 36,2417(c) Rear yatd, minimum 1 0 fee~ unless subject to a greater buffer yard reauirement as set forth in Sec1ion 36,2417(c) Heigh~ maximum 40 feet Floor area ratio, maximum -- Impervious surface ",rio, maximum 80% Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 25 Article 3 36.2-324 Recreation and Open Space District (ROS) (a) Purpose The Recreation and Open Space District (ROS) is intended to recognize and enhance active parlt and recreation lands, passive open spaces, and significant natmal and scenic features by encouraging these areas to protect unique land reSOUICes from degradation, consistent with the recommendations of the City's Comprehensive Plan, It is further intended to prevent the encroachment of incompatible land uses, while peunitting limited construction within open space areas which is supportive of their function and which promotes their use and enjoyment (b) Uses The uses peunitted as of right or by special exception in the ROS District sball be as set forth in Section 36.2-340, (c) Principal structures per lot In the ROS District, more than one principal structure may be permitted on a single lot, subject to the yard and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 324-1. When a lot contains more than one (I) principaI structure, the lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 324-1 sball apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot (d) Dimensional standards The dimensional standards for lots within the ROS District shall be as set forth in Table 324- 1. Table 324-1. Dimensional Matrix for Recreation and Open Space District (ROS) Standard ROS Density -- Lot area, minimum -- Lot area, maximum -. Lot frontage, minimum -. Lot frontage, maximum -- Front yard, minimum 30 feet Front yard, maximum -. Side yards, minimum combined width -. Side yard, minimum 30 feet Rear yard, minimum 30 feet Height, maximwn 35 feet Floor area ratio, maximum -- Impervious surface ratio, maximum 15% Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 26 Article 3 36.2-325 Airport Development District (AD) (a) Purpose The Aitport Development District (AD) is intended to permit and encournge the development of uses dependent on or related to air transportation in the areas in and around the Roanoke Regional Airport Such uses support airport functions, are dependent on air transportation, are unlikely to pose a threat to flights or airport opemtions, or are less sensitive to airport openltions than most commetcial or industrial uses, The AD District is intended to provide space for the efficient layout and operation of Roanoke Regional Aitport, including facilities for commetcial airline operations, air cargo, general aviation, and an appropriate range of retail and service uses that serve airport customers, and to pennit transportation-related and opemtions-related activities, latge-scale reseatth and development and office uses, and certain manufacturing uses in the immediate vicinity of the airport that are compatible with or supportive of the airport facilities whether or not directly airport related, (b) (1) Applicability The Aitport Development District (AD) shall apply to those properties owned by the Roanoke Regional Airport Commission and certain properties immediately adjacent to and in the vicinity of the airport that should be utilized for airport-supportive or airport-related uses. (2) The development of properties in the Aitport Development District (AD) that are owned by the Roanoke Regional Aitport Commission and are contiguous to one another shall be exempt from the following regulations: (A) The dimensional standards set forth in Section 36,2-325(e); (B) The sign regulations set forth in Article 6, Division 6, of this Chapter; and (q The landscaping and screening regulations set forth in Article 6, Division 4, of this Chapter, (3) Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to exempt properties owned by the Roanoke Regional Aitport Commission that are located within the Aitport Development District (AD) from the zoning amendment procedures and zoning pennit requirements as set forth in Sections 36,2-540 and 36,2-522, (c) Uses The uses permitted as of right or by special exception in the AD District shall be as set forth in Section 36.2-340. (d) Principal structures per lot In the AD District, more than one (1) principal structure may be pennitted on a single lot, subject to the yard, floor area nltio, and impervious surface ratio requirements of Table 325-1. When a lot contains more than one (1) principal structure, the lot frontage and lot area requirements of Table 325-1 shall apply only to the lot, and not to the principal structures on the lot. (e) Dimensional standards The dimensional standards for lots within the AD District shall be as set forth in Table 325-1. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 27 Article 3 Table 325-1. Dimensional Matrix for Airport Development District (AD) Standard AD Density - Lot area, minimwn 20,000 square feet Lot area, maximwn - Lot frontage, minimwn 100 feet Lot frontage, maximwn -- Front yard, minimwn - Front yard, maximwn - Side yards, minimwn combined width - Side yard, minimwn - Rear yard, minimwn -- Height, maximwn -- Floor area ratio, maximwn 2,0 Impervious surface ratio, maximwn 70% Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoka 12/05105 28 ArtIels 3 36.2-326 Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) (a) Purpose The Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) is intended to encol1lll8" the onledy development of mixed residential/commercial sites and to encourage innovative development pattems that create a desirable environment, particularly for lots which contllin a nwnber of constraints to conventional development These regulations are designed to achieve the following objectives: (1) Promote efficient use of land and infrastructure through high quality urban design; (2) Promote a development pattern in hattnony with existing development and the objectives of the City's Comprehensive Plan; (3) Permit a compatible mix of commerciaJ and residential uses; (4) Provide safe, efficient access and traffic circulation; (5) Create opportunities to use new technologies in managing the quality and quantity of storm water; and (6) Encol1lll8" the preservation of steep slopes, floodplains, historic structures and areas, and wrique, natural, or geological fonnarions, (b) (1) Applicability Any area meeting the requirements of this section may, by amendment to this Chapter, be zoned Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD), and such area shaIl be designated MXPUD on the Official Zoning Map, (2) Development within an area zoned MXPUD shaIl occur on one (1) lot, or if more than one (1) lot, on lots which are contiguous or would be contiguous but for their separation by a street or an alley. (3) Development within an area zoned MXPUD shaIl include a combination of peunitted residential and commercial uses or a combination of different permitted residential uses. (c) Uses Uses permitted as of right or by special exceprion in the MXPUD District shaIl be as set forth in Section 36,2-340 and may be designated in a development plan for a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD), subject to review by the Planning Commission and approval by the City COWlcil. (d) Development standards All petitions for review and approval of a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) shaIl comply with the following standards of development (1) General standards: (A) The development plan shaIl emphasize compatibility with the SurroWlding neighborhoods, (B) The development shall be designed and arranged in such a way as to promote energy efficiency and encourage solar access. (C) Proposed streets, parking areas, and pedestrian circulation systems shaIl provide safe and convenient access to and from the development and for all lots within the development (I)) Sewage collection and water distribution systems shaIl be laid out in an efficient manner, Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoka 12/05105 29 Artlcla 3 (E) Landscaping and open space shall be used to provide shading, screening, and erosion and sedimentation control (F) The development shall reflect the existing topography and natutal chatacter of the site by minimizing grading and by preserving existing trees. (2) Dimensional standards: The dimensional standards within the MXPUD District shall be as set forth in Tahle 326-1. (3) Utilities: All utility lines, including electric power, telephone, and cable television lines, and simiIar utilities, shall be located W1dergrow1d, Table 326-L Dimensional Mattix for Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District (MXPUD) Standard MXPUD Density (minimum square footage of lot area per dwelling 1,800 square feet unit' Shall be specified during the review and approval Lot area, minimum of the development plan for the MXPUD District Shall be specified during the review and approval Lot frontage, minimum of the devetopment plan for the MXPUD District Shall be specified during the review and approval Front yard, minimum of the development plan for the MXPUD District Shall be specified during the review and approval Side yard, minimum of the development plan for the MXPUD District Side yard within the MXPUD which abuts the perimeter of 30 feet in depth the MXPUD District (minimum) Shall be specified during the review and approval Rear yard, minimum of the development plan for the MXPUD District Rear yanI within the MXPUD which abuts the perimeter 30 feet in depth of the MXPUD District (minimum) No maximum height, except where MXPUD District adjoins a residential district, in which Height, maximum case the height of any structure within the MXPUD District shall not exceed one (1) foot of height for one (1) foot of setback from the adiacent residentiallv-zoned lot Impervious surface ratio (maximwn cumulative ratio for a 80% MXPUD District) . Usable open space (minimum square footage per dwelling 300 square feet unit' (e) Procedural requirements In addition to the requirements for zoning amendments set forth in Sections 36,2-540 and 36,2-541, petitions for a MXPUD District shall include a proposed development plan, drawn to scale, containing the following infmmation and necessary explanatory materials: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 30 Article 3 (1) Boundaries of the proposed MXPUD District and the ownership of properties contained therein, as well as all existing public and private streets, alleys, and easements within and immediately adjacent to the distric~ (2) Location, size, and use of existing buildings and the location, size, and use of proposed buildings or additions to existing buildings; (3) Location of all existing parking facilities and the approximate tocation of all proposed surface parlcing lots or parking structures, including the number of parking spaces for each lot or structure and all existing and proposed means of access to parking areas and to public or private streets, alleys, and easements; (4) Proposed changes in the location, width, or character of public streets, alleys, or easements within and adjacent to the district, and the delineation of any private driveways or loading spaces that intersect with public rights-of-way or easements; (5) Existing and proposed pedestrian routes, including links between various buildings; (6) Genetll! use of major existing and proposed open spaces within the site and specific features of the development plan, such as screening, buffering, or retention of natural areas, which are intended to enhance compatibility with adjacent properties, and calculations of the percentage of usable open space for the district; IJ) Infrastructure plans indicating the size and location of existing and proposed stonnwater, sanit:uy sewer, and water lines as well as estimates of impacts of the proposed deveIopment on infrastructure capacity in the district and impacts on collector lines immediately outside of the district; and (8) Information to demonstrate the compatibility of all structures with the sunmmding neighbothood, 36.2-327 Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) (a) Purpose The Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) is intended to encowage harmonious development of institutional uses and mixed-use campus developments, to provide flexibility for creative development, to minimize potential negative impacts of institutional uses on neighboring uses, and to recognize the speciaI complexity and interrelationships ofland uses and activities in these institutional complexes. (b) (1) Applicability Any area zoned Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) shall: (A) Consist of one (1) lot, or if more than one (1) lot, tots which are contiguous or would be contiguous but for their separation by a street or an alley; and (B) Consist of at least two (2) acres, (2) Any area zoned Institutional Planned Unit Developroent District (INPUD) by the adoption of this Chapter shalI be exempt from the development standards and the procedural requirements set forth in subsections (d) and (e) of this section at the time of the adoption of this Chapter. Any developroent of such area after the effective date of this Chapter shalI comply with the use regulations, developroent standards, and procedural requirements of this section, (c) Uses Uses permitted as of right or by special exception in the Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) shalI be as set forth in Section 36,2.340 and may be designated in a development plan for an Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD), subject to review by the Planning Commission and approval by the City Council Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 31 Article 3 (d) Development standards All uses and development within an InstitutioruU Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) shall comply with the following standards of development (1) Dimensional standatds: The dimensioruU standatds within the INPUD District shall be as set forth in Table 327-1. (2) Utilities: All utility lines, including electric power, telephone, and cable television lines, and similar utilities, shall be located undetground Table 327-1. Dimensional Matrix for Institutional Planned Unit Development District (INPUD) Standard INPUD Density (minimum square footage oflot area 1,800 square feet per dwelling unit) No minimum yard requirements; Shall be specified during the Yanls, front, side, and rear review and approval of the development plan for the MXPUD District No maximum height, except where INPUD District adjoins a residential district, in which case the height of any structure Height, maximum within the INPUD District shall not exceed one (1) foot of height for one (1) foot of setback from the adjacent residentiallv-zoned lot Floor area ratio (maximum cumulative ratio of all principal and accessory buildings within 10,0 the INPUD District) Impervious surface ratio (maximum 80% cumulative ratio for an MXPUD District) Usable open space (minimum square footage 300 square feet per dwe1Iing unit) (e) Procedural requirements In addition to the requirements for zoning amendments set forth in Sections 36,2,540 and 36.2-541, petitions for an INPUD District 6led after the effective date of this Chapter, or any change to an INPUD District created by the adoption of this Chapter, shall include a proposed development plan, drawn to scale, containing the following information and necessary explanatory materials: (1) Boundaries of the proposed INPUD District and the ownership of properties contained therein, as well as all existing public and private streets, alleys, and easements within and immediately adjacent to the district; (2) Location, size, and use of existing buildings and the toeation, size, and use of proposed buildings or additions to existing buildings; (3) Location of all existing parking facilities and the approximate location of all proposed surface parldng lots or parldng structures, including the number of parldng spaces for each lot or structure and all existing and proposed means of access to parking areas and to public or private streets, alleys, and easements; (4) Proposed changes in the loeation, width, or character of public streets, alleys, or easements within and adjacent to the district, the delineation of any private driveways or loading spaces that intersect with public rights-of-way or easements, and if applicable, the delineation of routes for emetgency vehicles accessing the district; Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoke 12/05105 32 ArtIcle 3 (5) Existing and proposed pedestrian routes, including links between mous buildings; (6) General use of major existing and proposed open spaces within the site and specific features of the development plan, such as screening, buffering, or retention of natural areas, which are intended to enhance compatibility with adjacent properties, and calculations of the percentage of usable open space for the district; (T) Infrastructure plans indicating the size and location of existing and proposed stormwater, sanitary sewer, and water lines as weII as estimates of impacts of the proposed development on infrastructure capacity in the district and impacts on collector lines immediately outside of the district; and (8) Information to demonstrate the compatibility of all structures with the character and appearance of the surrounding neighborhood by virtue of rhe structures' height, bulk, and tocation within rhe INPUD. 36.2-328 Industrial Planned Unit Development District (IPUD) (a) Purpose The lndustriaI Planned Unit Development District (lPUD) is intended to encourage rhe orderly devdopment of uses which require an integration of large-sca1e office, research, commercial, and manufacturing facilities in separate structures, designed as a unit, in a campus-like environment. This district encourages flexibility in design, promotes the appropriate use of land, facilitates the adequate and economic provision of streets, utilities, and other improvements, and preserves and enhances the natural and scenic qualities of open space. Development standards for the mutual protection of uses in the district, adjacent districts, and the Gty are provided, (b) (1) Applicability Any area meeting the requirements of this section may, by amendment to this Chapter, be zoned lndustriaI Planned Unit Development District (lPUD), and such area shal1 be designated JPUD on the Official Zoning Map, (2) Development within an area zoned JPUD shal1 occur on one (1) lot, or if more than one (1) lot, on lots which are contiguous or would be contiguous but for their separation by a street or an alley, (3) An JPUD District shal1 consist of at least five (5) acres, (c) Uses Uses pennitted as of tight or by special exception in the JPUD District shall be as set forth in Section 362-340 and may be designated in a devdopment plan for an IndustriaI Planned Unit Development District (lPUD), subject to review by the Planning Commission and approval by the Gty Council. (d) Development standards All petitions for review and approval of an IndustriaI Planned Unit Development District (IPUD) shal1 comply with the following standards of development (1) General standards: (A) Grculation and traffic access: All streets and driveways within an JPUD District shall be designed to serve adequately their intended traffic function and the volume of traffic anticipated to be generated by the development. (8) Energy: The devdopment of any site within an JPUD District shall be designed and arranged in such a way as to promote energy efficiency, (2) Dimensional standards: The dimensional standards within the JPUD District shal1 be as set forth in Table 32S-1. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 33 Article 3 (3) Utilities: All utility lines, including electric power, telephone, and cable television lines, and similar utilities, shall be located underground, Table 328-L Dimensional Matrix for Industrial Planned Unit DeveIopment District (lPUD) Standard lPUD No minimwn yard requirements, except that buffer yards Yards, front, side, and rear shall be provided as required in Section 36.2-647; Shall be specified during the review and approval of the development plan for the MXPUD District No maximwn height, except where IPUD District abuts a residential district, in which case the maximum height of Height, maximwn any structure within the IPUD District shall be one (1) foot of height for one (1) foot of setback from the adjacent residentially-zoned lot Roor area ratio (maximum cumulative ratio of all principal and accessory bui\ding5 within the IPUD 2.0 District) Impervious surtace ratio (maximum cumulative 80% ratio for an IPUD District) Usable open space, minimum (shall be accessible 10% of the area of an INPUD District to all employees of the uses in the district) (e) Procedural requirements In addition to the requirements for zoning amendments set forth in Sections 36.2-540 and 36.2-541, petitions for an IPUD District shall include a proposed development plan, drawn to scale, containing the following information and necessary explanatory materials: (1) Boundaries of the proposed IPUD District and the ownership of properties contained therein, as well as all existing public and ptivate streets, alleys, and easements within and immediately adjacent to the district; (2) Location, size, and use of existing buildings and the location, size, and use of proposed buildings or additions to existing buildings; (3) Location of all existing parking facilities and the approximate location of all proposed surface parl<ing lots or parking structures, including the number of parking spaces for each lot or structure and all existing and proposed means of access to parking areas and to public or ptivate streets, alleys, and easements; (4) Proposed changes in the location, width, or character of public streets, alleys, or easements within and adjacent to the district, and the delineation of private driveways or toading spaces that intersect with public rights-of-way or easements; (5) Existing and proposed pedestrian routes, including links between various buildings; (6) General use of major existing and proposed open spaces within the site and specific features of the development plan, such as screening, buffering, or retenrion of natural areas, which are intended to enhance compatibility with adjacent properties, and calculations of the percent>ge of usable open space for the district; (T) Infrastructure plans indicating the size and location of existing and proposed stonnwater, sanitary sewer, and water lines as well as estimates of impacts of the proposed development on infrastructure capacity in the district and impacts on collector lines immediately outside of the district; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 34 Article 3 (8) Infonnation to demonsttate the compatibility of all structures with the chatacter and appearnnce of the sw:rounding neighborhood by virtue of the structures' height, bulk, and location within the IPUD. Division 3. Overlay Districts 36.2-330 Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-1) (a) Purpose The pmpose of the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) is to identify, preserve, enhance, and maintain architectural and historic landmarks, structures, and districts that are listed, or are eligible for listing, on the VIrginia Landmarks Register or the National Register of Historic Places, or which have local significance, An additional purpose of the H-I Overlay District is to develop and maintain appropriate settings and environments for such landmarks, structures, and districts, (b) (I) Applicability The City Council may, in the manner provided for amending this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36,2-540, designate as a Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) appropriate areas which: (A) Contain landmarks or structures that are listed, or are eligible for listing, on the Vttginia Landmarks Register or the National Register of Historic Places, or which have local significance; (B) Are adjacent to landinarks designated as historic by the Vttginia Department of Historic Resources; (C) Are adjacent to any other structures within the City having important historic, architectural, or cultural interest; or (0) Contain buildings or sites having special public value because of notable architecture, historic events, or other worthy features relating to the social, cultural, or artistic heritage of the community, which are of such significance as to warrant conservation and presenration. (2) Any Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) designated by the City Council as provided for in subsection (I), above, shall be shown as an overlay to the existing undedying district on the Official Zoning Map. As such, the provisions in this section shall serve as a supplement to the underlying hase wning district regulations, Where a conflict exists between the regulations relating to the H,I Overlay District and those of any underlying base zoning district, the more restrictive provisions shall apply. (c) Certificate of Appropriateness A Certificate of Appropriateness (see Section 36,2-530) shall be required for the demolition, moving, erection, reconstruction, alteration, or restoration of any structure or historic landmark in the H.I Overlay District A Certificate of Appropriateness shall not be required for ordinary maintenance as defined in Section 36.2-530(b)(4), The Zoning Aclministtator, in consultation with the Agent to the Architectural Review Board, shall determine whether an activity requires a Certificate of Appropriateness. (d) Review standards modifications The following standards shall be applied by the Architectural Review Board in considering a request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for new construction or exterior modifications to an existing structure in the H-l Overlay District. for new construction or exterior (I) Generally: (A) The relationship of the changes to the historic, architectural, or cultural significance of the structure and the surrounding district; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 35 Article 3 (B) The appropriateness of the change in terms of architectur.1l compatibility with the distinguishing historic and architectw:al features of the structure and the disttict. Architectw:al compatibility shall be judged in tenns of a proposed structure's mass, dimensions, materials, color, ornamentation, architectural style, lighting, and other criteria deemed pertinent (2) Renovations: For renovarions, the ten (10) following hasic standatds, set forth by the Secretaty of the Interior's Standatds for Rehabilitation, sbaIl apply: (A) A property shall be used for its historic purpose or be placed in a new use that requires minimal change to the defining characteristics of the building and its site and environment (B) The historic character of a property sbaIl be retained and preserved The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces that characterize a property shall be avoided, (CJ Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time, place, and use, Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectwal features or architectw:al elements from other buiIdings, shall not be lUldertlken. (1)) Most properties change over time; those changes that have acquired historic significance in their own tight sbaIl be retained and preserved, (E) Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a property shall be preserved, (F) Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by docwnentaty, physical, or pictorial evidence, (G) Chemical or physical treatments, such as sandblasting, that cause damage to historic materials shall not be used. The surface cleaning of structures, if appropriate, shall be lUldertai<en using the gendest means possible. (H) Significant archaeologicaI resoun:es affected by a project shall be protected and preserved, If such resources must be disnubed.. mitigation measures shall be undertaken. (I) New additions, exterior alterations, or related new construction sbaIl not destroy historic materials that characterize the property, The new work shall be differentiated from the old and shall be compatible with the massing, size, scale, and architectural features to protect the historic integrity of the property and its environment (J) New additions and adjacent or related new construction sbaIl be undertaken in such a manner that if removed in the future, the essenrial form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired. (3) New construction: For new construction, the following standatds shall apply: (A) The design for new construction shall be sensitive to and take into accolUlt the special characterisrics that the disttict is established to protect Such consideration may include building scale, height, and orientation, site coverage, sparial separation from other buildings, facade and window pattems, entrance and porch size and general design, materials, textures, color, architectural detaiIs, roof forms, emphasis of horizontal or vertical elements, walls, fences, and any other features deemed appropriate; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 36 Article 3 (B) The design of the new construction shall recognize the relationships among buildings in the immediate setting Illther than specific styles or details since architectu1ll! styles and details may vory from one (I) section of the district to another, (4) Signage: For signage, the following standards shall apply: (A) Signs shall be compatible with and relate to the design elements of the building with which they are associated or to which they are attached, Illther than obscure or disrupt such design features; (B) Signs shall be compatible with other signs and buildings in the district and adjacent to the property; and (C) Compatibility shall be judged in tenns of dimensions, materials, color, letter style and placemen~ lighting, and overall geneta! effect on the building and district. (5) Accessory structures: For accessory structures, the following standards shall apply: (A) Existing characteristic features such as walls, fencing, walkways, and other similar structures or site features that reflect the building's or district's history and development shall be retained; and (B) Accessory structures shall be appropriate to and compatible with the architectu1ll! features of the principal structure and the district. (6) In addition to the standards set forth in subsections (I) through (5), above, the Architectu1ll! Review Board may adopt specific Architectu1ll! Design Guidelines for the H.I Overlay District, or a portion of the H-I Overlay District. The Architectu1ll! Review Board shall consider the applicable guidelines in its decisions to issue or deny Certificates of Appropriateness. (e) Review standards for demolition The following standards shall be applied by the Architectu1ll! Review Board in considering a request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a structure or historic landmark within the H-I Overlay District (I) The purpose and necessity of the demolition are in accordance with the intent of the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I); (2) Loss of the structure would not be adverse to the district or the public interest by virtue of its uniqueness or its contribution to the district; and (3) Demolition would not have an adverse effect on the character and surrounding environment of the district. 36.2-331 Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2) (a) Purpose The purpose of the Historic NeighbOl:hood Overlay District (H.2) is to identifY, preserve, enhance, and maintain those architectutal and historic landmarks, structures, and districts which are listed, or are eligible for listing, on the Vttginia Landmarks Register or the National Register of Historic Places, or which have local significance, Moreover, the H-2 Overlay District is intended to encourage new construction that is compatible with the district and to develop and maintain appropriate settings and environments for such landmarks, structures, and districts, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 37 Article 3 (b) (1) Applicability The City Council may, in the manner provided for amending this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36,Z-54O, designate as a Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2) appropriate areas which: (A) Contain Iandmarl<s or structures that are listed, or are eligible for listing, on rhe ViIginia Landmarks Register or rhe National Register of Historic Places, or which individually or collectively represent a distinguishable entity oflocal historic, cultural, or aIchitectw:al importllnCe; (B) Are adjacent to IandmaJ:ks designated as historic by rhe Virginia Department of Historic Resomces or are adjacent to other structures, landmarks, or areas having important historic, aIchitectural, or cultural interest; or (C) Contain buildings or places in which historic events occurred or which have special public value because of notable aIchitectural or other features relating to the cultural or artistic heritage of the conununity, or are of such significance as to wanant conservation and preservation. (2) Any Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H.2) designated by rhe City Council as provided for in subsection (1), above, shall be shown as an overlay to the existing under1ying district on the Official Zoning Map. As sneb, the provisions in this section shall serve as a supplement to the underlying hase zoning district regulations, Where a conflict exists between the regulations relatiog to the H-Z Overlay District and those of any under1ying base zoning district, the more restrictive provisions shall apply, (c) Certificate of Appropriateness In the H-Z Overlay District, a Certificate of Appropriateness (see Section 36,Z-530) shall be required for the erection of any new structure, the demolition, moving, reconstruction, altetation, or restoration of any existing structure or historic landmark, including the installation or replacement of siding, or rhe tednction in the floor area of an existing building, including the enclosure or removal of a porch, A Certificate of Appropriateness shall not be required for onlinaty maintenance, as defined in Section 362.530(b)(4), or in-kind replacement with the same materials, proportions, and design. The Zoning Adntinisttator, in consultation wirh the Agent to the Architectw:al Review Boatd, shall detemtine whether an activity requires a Certificate of Appropriateness, (d) Review standards modifications (1) The following standards shall be applied by the Architectural Review Boatd in considering a request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for new constmction or exterior modifications to an existing structure in the H-Z Overlay District for new construction or exterior (A) The design shall be compatibte with rhe character of the H-2 Overlay District with respect to buiIding location and scale, roof forms, windows and donts, siding, trim, and porches; and (B) The design of existing aIchitectw:al features, with respect to proportion and textnre, shall be retained (2) In addition to rhe standards of subsection (1), above, the Architectural Review Board may adopt specific Architectural Design Guidelines for the H.2 Overlay District, or a portion of rhe H-2 Overlay District. The Architectural Review Board shall consider the applicable guidelines in its decisions to issue or deny a Certificate of Appropriateness, (e) Review standards for demolition The following standards shall be applied by the Architectural Review Board in considering a request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for demolition of a structure or historic landmark within the H-2 Overlay District (1) The purpose and necessity of rhe demolition are in accotdance wirh the intent of the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2); Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 38 Article 3 (2) Loss of the structure would not be advetse to the district or the public interest by virtue of its w1iqueness or its contribution to the district; and (3) Demolition would not have an adverse effect on the character and sun-ounding environment of the district. 36.2-332 Neighborhood Design Overlay District (ND) (a) Purpose The Neighborhood Design Overlay District (NO) is intended to promote quality City design by coon:linating the development of designated Rehabilitation and Conservation Areas, The City finds and detennines that the standards of the NO Overlay District promote compatibility between buildings and structures in the City's traditional neighbomoods, maintain property values, and promote pedestrian-friendly, walkable streets, (b) (1) Applicability The City Council may, in the manner provided for amending this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36,2-540, apply the Neighbomood Design Overlay District (NO) to areas of the City that are designated Rehabilitation and Conservation Areas, The regulations of this section sball apply to new dwellings, new accessoty buildings, or expansions of existing dwellings in a designated NO Overlay District (2) Any Neighborhood Design Overlay District (NO) designated by the City Council as provided for in subsection (1), above, sball be shown as an overlay to the existing underlying district on the Official Zoning Map, As such, the provisions in this section sball serve as a supplement to the underlying hase zoning district regulations, Where a conflict exists between this section relating to the ND Overlay District and those of any underlying base zoning district, the more restrictive provisions sball apply. (c) Design standards In considering an application for a zoning pencil, the Zoning Administrator sball apply the following standards for a new dwelling, a new accessol}' building that is accessol}' to a dwelling, or expansion of an existing dwelling in the NO Overlay District (1) Building location and massing: (A) The required front yard shall be determined by Section 36,2-205(f)(2), (B) A new dwelling shall have two stones where lots on both sides have lw1>-stol}' dwellings, A new dwelling sball have one stol}' where lots on both sides have one-stol}' dwellings, Where no dwelling exists on either or one side, the nmnber of stones shall be the same as the majority of dwellings on the same side of the same block. For the purposes of this section, a slol}' sball be a finished floor level with at least seven hundred (700) square feet that is at or above the grade of the front yard, (C) The width of single- and lw1>-family dwellings sball be within twenty (20) percent of the ave<age of the widths of other sing1e- and two-family dwellings on the same side of the same block. The front of multifamily dwellings shall be broken into sections of thirty (30) feet or less in widm through offsets of the vertical plane of me facade of at least twelve (12) inches, (0) The foundation height shall be aligned with the foundation heights of dwellings on the adjoining lots or, where there are no dwellings on adjoining lots, with the majority of dwellings on me same side of the same block. (2) Roofs: (A) The rise,to-run ratio for the dwelling's main roof sball be 6:12 or steeper, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 39 Article 3 (B) The dwelling's main roof form shall have a complex roof form such as a hipped, intetsecting. offset, or dormered roof, except where the gable faces the street and the roof covers a full-width pooch, in which case the roof may have a simple two-surface configuration. (q Eave and gable overl1angs for all dwellings and additions to dwellings shall be at least twelve (12) inches, (1)) The rise-to-nm ratio of roofs covering porches or entrances shall be equaI to or shallower than the main roof (E) Above-grade entrances on the front or side of a dwelling shall be covered with a roof with a minimum width and depth of thirty-six (36) inches, (3) Entrances and windows: (A) The dwelling shall have at least one entrance facing the primary front yard. The number of doors facing the primary front yard shall be limited to one door for every twenty (20) feet of dwelling width. A second entrance facing the primary front yard may be included on a side of a single- or two-fiunily dwelling if recessed at least six (6) feet behind the main front entrance. (B) Doors facing a street shall have panel insets or windows, (q At teast fifteen (15) percent of the front of the dwelling shall consist of window or door openings, At teast ten (10) percent of the side of a dwelling which is not the front of the dwelling and which faces a street shall consist of window or door openings. Roofs, gables, and foundations shall not be included in determining the area of the front or the side of the dwelling, (1)) Wmdows on the front facade shall have a height that is a least one and one-half (1 \/,) times their width, (E) Wmdows on the front of the dwelling shall be arranged in a manner that is compatibte with that of other dwellings in the district, In genetal, windows on separate stories of the front should be vertically aligned and windows on the same story should be horizontally aligned. (F) All stairs shall have solid risers, (G) A sidewalk at teast four (4) feet in width shall be provided between the front porch and the street. The sidewalk shall be constructed of an impervious material customarily used for sidewalks in the district. (4) Siding and trim: (A) The siding of any dwelling or accessory structure, exclusive of trim materials, shall not be vertically oriented, (B) Wmdows and doors shall be surrounded by trim which is at least three and one-half (3\/,) inches wide, except for dwellings with masonry siding, in which case no trim around doors or windows is required, (q VetricaI comer boards at least three and one-half (3\/,) inches wide shall be provided on all dwelling comers, except where the siding material is brick or stucco, (1)) All wooden elements of the dwelling shall be painted or be stained with an opaque stain, (5) Porches: (A) Singte- and two-fiunily dwellings shall have a covered porch at least one-half (1/2) the width of the dwelling's facade with a depth of at least six (6) feet The porch shall face the primary front yard, (B) For new and existing dwellings, the front porch shall not be enclosed with siding, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 40 Article 3 (C) Front potch railings shall have a top and bottom tail. Balustet ends shall not be exposed. (I)) Potch colwnns shall be wUfonn in shape and style and shall be at least five and one-half (5\1,) inches wide at their bottom and top. (E) The undetSide of potches between piet supports and the undetside of exterior stairways shall be enclosed. (6) Addirions and accessory structures: (A) Demched accessory buildings, including garages and carports, shall be located behind the back of the dwelling. (B) An attached garage or carport shall be offset at least twenty-four (24) inches behind the front facade of the dwelling. The hay door of an attached garage shall not face the primary front yard. (C) An addirion to an existing dwelling shall be located on the rear or side of the dwelling, except a potch may be added to the front of the dwelling. An addirion to the side of a dwelling shall be set back from the dweUing's front face by twenty-four (24) inches or more. 36.2-333 Floodplain Overlay District (F) (a) Purpose The purpose of the Floodplain Overlay District (F) is to provide mandatory floodplain restrictions for FEMA compliance, along with addirional smndards to restrict impervious surfaces in the floodplain. The inteot of the regulations in this section is to prevent the loss of property and life, the crearion of bealth and safety hazanls, the disruption of commetCe and governmental services, the extraordinary and unnecessary expenditure of public funds for flood protection and relief; and the impairment of the llIX hase by: (1) Regulating uses, activities, and development which, alone or in combination with othet existing or future uses, activities, and development, if unregulated, will cause unaccepmble increases in flood heights, velocities, and frequencies; (2) Restricting or probibiting cettain uses, activities, and development from locating within areas subject to flooding; (3) Requiring all those uses, activities, and developments that do occur in flood-prone areas to be protected or flood-proofed ag.rinst flooding and flood damage; and (4) Protecting individuals from buying land and structures which are unsuited for intended purposes because of flood hazards. (b) Establishment of floodplain areas For the purpose of the regulations prescribed in this section, thete are heteby created various floodplain areas subject to inundation by waters of the one hundted- (100) year flood. The basis for the delineation of the floodway, the flood- fringe, and the approximated floodplain shall be the flood insurance study for the City of Roanoke prepared by the Fedetal Emergency Management Agency, Federal Insurance Administtation, Volume 1 of 3 and Volume 3 oB dated Oerobe< 15, 1993, and Volume 2 oB dated October, 18, 1999, as amended. A copy of the flood insurance study, City drainage smndards, and accompanying maps, as amended, shall be filed in the offices of the City Clerk and the City Engineer and are heteby declared to be a part of these regulations. The floodplain areas shall consist of the foUowing: (1) The floodway is delineated, for purposes of these regulations, using the criterion that cettain areas within the floodplain must be capable of canying the waters of the one hundted- (100) year flood without increasing the water surface elevation of that flood more than one (1) foot at any point These floodways are specifically Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 41 Article 3 defined in Table 4 of the flood insurance study and as genetaliy shown on the accompanying flood insurance rate map. (2) The flood-fringe shall be that area of the one hundted- (100) year floodplain not included in the floodway. The basis for the outermost boundary of the flood-fringe shall specifically be the one hundted- (100) year flood elevations conmined in the flood profiles of Table 4 of the flood insurance study and as genetally sho\VIl on the accompanying flood insurance rate map. (3) The approximated floodplain shall be that floodplain area for wbich no detailed flood profiles or elevations are provided but where a one hundted- (1 (0) year floodplain boundary has been approximated. Such areas are shown as Zone A on the flood insurance rate map. Where the specific one hundted- (1 (0) year flood elevarion cannot be detetmined for this area using othet sources of data, such as the U.S. Army Cotps of EngineetS Floodplain Information Reports or the U.S. Geological Survey Flood-Prone Quadrangles, then the applicant for the proposed use, development, or acrivity shall determine this elevation in accordance with hydrologic and hydraulic engineeting techniques. When a Zone A area is located between two numbered zones, one hundted- (100) year flood elevarions shall be Iineady interpolated between known elevations, along the centerline of the channel Hydrologic and hydraulic analyses shall be undett>tken only by the applicanfs professional enginCetS who shall certifY that the technical methods used correctly reflect currently accepted technical concepts. Studies, analyses, and compumtions shall be submitted in sufficient demil to allow a thorough review by the City Engineet. (c) (1) Applicability The floodplain areas described above shall be overlays to the existing underlying base zorting districts as shown on the Official Zoning Map. As such, the provisions of the Floodplain Overlay District (F) shall serve as a supplement to the undedying base zoning district provisions. With any conflict between the provisions or requirements of the Floodplain Oveday District (F) and those of the undedying base zorting district, the more restrictive provisions shall apply. (2) The boundaries of the floodplain areas previously described in subsection (b), above, shall be esmblished as shown on the flood insurance rate map. (3) The delineation of any of the floodplain areas described in subsection (b), above, may be revised by the City Council whete natural or manmade changes have occurred or whete more detailed studies have been conducted or undett>tken by the U.S. Army Cotps of Engineers or other qualified agency, or an individual documents to the satisfaction of the Zoning Administtator and City Engineet the need for such change. However, prior to any such change, approval shall be obmined from the Fedetallnsurance Administrarion. (4) Intetpremrions of the boundaries of the floodplain areas described in subsection (b), above, shall be made by the Zoning Administrator. (5) No land or use shall be developed within the esmblisbed floodplain areas, and no structure shall be located, relocated, constructed, reconstructed, enlarged, or sttucturally altered, except in full compliance with the terms and provisions of the regulations of this section and any othet applicable ordinances and regulations which apply to uses within the City. (6) Filling in those portions of the flood-fringe area that contribute to bypass flooding shall be permitted in accordance with the regulations as set forth in this section. (d) (1) Abrogation and greater restrictions These regulations supersede any regulations in effect in floodplain areas. However, any underlying regulations or restrictions shall remain in full force and effect to the extent that their provisions are more restrictive than the regulations as set forth in this secrion. (2) Whetevet any regularion in this secrion imposes higher or more restrictive smndards than are requited in any othet smtute, ordinance, or regulation, the provisions of this section shall goVetU. Whenever the provisions Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 42 Article 3 of any other statute, ordinance, or regulation impose higher or more restrictive standards than are required in this secrion, the provisions of such othet smtute, ordinance, or regulation shall govetn. (e) Severability If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause, or phrase of this section shall be declared invalid for any reason whatevet, such decision shall not affect the remaining potrions of this section or Chapter. The remaining portions shall remain in full force and effect, and for this putpose, the provisions of this section and Chaptet are heteby declared to be severable. (f) Definitions Cettain terms and words used in this secrion shall be defined as set forth below. Where any conflict exists between the definitions below and those set forth in Appendix A, the definitions of this subsection shall govetn for the purposes of the regulations of this secrion. Base flood/One hundred- (100) year flood: A flood that, on the avetage, is likely to occur once every one hundted (100) years (that has a one petCent chance of occutring each year, although the flood may occur in any year). Base flood elevation: The Fedetal Emergency Management Agency designated one hundred- (100) year watet surface elevation. Basement Any area of the building having its floor subgrade (below ground level) on all sides. Channe~ A perceptible natural or artificial waterway which periodically or continuously conmins mnving water confined to a definite bed and banks. Conditional letter of map revision (CWMR): A letter from FEMA commenting on whether a proposed project, if built as proposed, would justify a National Flood Insurance Program (NFlI') map revision to modify the existing regulatory floodway or effective base flood elevation. Development Any manmade change to improved or unimproved real esmte including, but not limited to, structures, the placement of manufactured homes, paving, utilities, filling, grading, excavation, mining, dredging, drilling operations, or the storage of equipment or materials. FEMA: Fedetal Emergency Management Agency. Flood: A genetal and temporary condition of partial or complete inundation of normally dry land areas from (1) the over:t1ow of inland waters, or (2) the unusual and rapid accwnulation of run-off of surface waters from any source. Flood elevation: A determination by the Fedetallnsurance Administtation of the watet surface elevations of the base flood, that is the flood level that has a one (1) petCent or greatet chance of occurrence in any given year. Flood insurance <ate map: An official map of the City of Roanoke, on which the Federal Insurance Administtation has delineated both the special hazard areas and the risk premium zones applicable to the City of Roanoke. Floodplain: Any land area susceptible to being inundated by water from any source. Floodproofing: Any combination of sttuctural and non-structural additions, changes, or adjustments to structures which reduce or eliminate flood damage to real esmte or improved real property, water and sanimry facilities, or structures and their contents. FIoodway: The channel of a rivet or other wateocoutse and the adjacent land areas that must be reserved in order to discharge the base flood without cumulatively increasing the base flood elevation mote than one (1) foot Freeboani: A factor of safety usually expressed in feet above a flood level for purposes of floodplain managetnent Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 43 Article 3 Historic structure: For the purpose of this secrion only, any structure that is: (1) Listed individually in the National Register of Historic Places or preliminarily detetmined by the Secremry of the Interior as meeting the requirements for individual listing on the National Register; (2) Certified or preliminarily determined by the Secremry of the Interior as contributing to the bistorical significance of a registered historic district or a district preliminarily determined by the Secremry to qualify as a registered historic district; (3) Individually listed on the VIrginia Landmarks Register or determined eligible by the Vitginia Department of Historic Resources for such register; or (4) Individually listed on the City inventory of bistoric places or as determined eligible for such inventory by the Roanoke City Architectural Review Board. Letter of map revision (LOMR): A letter from FEMA officially revising the current National Flood Insurance program (NFlP) map to show changes to floodplains, floodways, or flood elevations. Lowest floor: The lowest floor of the lowest enclosed area (mcluding basement). An unfinisbed or flood resismnt enclosure, usable solely for the parlci:ng of vehicles, building access, or storage in an area other than a basement area, is not considered a building's lowest floor, provided that such enclosure is not built so as to rendet the structure in violation of the applicable non-elevation desigo requirements of this section. Start of construction: For a "substantial improvement," start of construction means the first altemtion of any wall, ceiling, floor, or othet sttuctural part of a building, whether or not that alterarion affects the extemal dimensions of the building. Structure: For purposes of this section only, a walled and roofed building, including a gas or liquid storage tank, that is principally above ground, as well as a manufactured home. Substantial damage: Damage of any origin susmined by a structure wheteby the cost of restoring the structure to its before damaged condition would equal or exceed fifty (SO) percent of the market value of the structure before the damage occurred. Substantial improvement: Any reconstruction, rehabilimtion, addition, or othet improvement of a structure, the cost of which equals or exceeds fifty (SO) percent of the market value of the structure before the "5_ of consttucrion" of the improvement. This term includes structures which have incurred "subsmnrial damage" regardless of the actual repair work performed. The term does not, however, include either: (1) any project for improvement of a structure to correct existing violations of smte or local health, sanimry, or safety code specifications which have been identified by the local code enforcetnent official and which are the minimum necessary to assure safe living conditions, or (2) any alteration of a "historic structure," provided that the altetation will not preclude the structure's conrinued designarion as a "historic structure." Watercouroe: A natural or artificial channel for passage of nuuting water fed from natural sources in a definite channel and discIwging into some stream or body of water. (g) (1) Floodplain development regulations Pennit requirement All uses, acrivities, and development occurring within any floodplain areas shall be undett>tken only upon the issuance of a zoning permit by the Zoning Administrator. Such development shall be undett>tken only in strict compliance with these regulations and with all othet applicable codes and ordinances. Prior to the issuance of any such permit, the Zoning Administtator shall require all applications to include compliance with all applicable smte and federal laws. Undet no cin:umsmnces shall any use, activity, or development adVetSeIy affect the capacity of the channels or floodway of any watetCOurse, drainage ditch, or any other drainage facility or system. (2) Alterarion or relocation of watercourse: Prior to any proposed alteration or relocation of any channel with a regulatory floodplain, within the City, a permit shall be obmined from the U.S. Army Cotp ofEngineetS, the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality, and the Virginia Marine Resources Commission. Furthetmore, notilicarion of the proposal shall be given by the applicant to all affected adjacent jurisdictions and the Department of Conservarion and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 44 Article 3 Recreation {Division of Soil and Water Conservation). If the channel to be altered or relocated conmins a regulatory floodplain, a conditional letter of map revision shall be secured from FEMA, prior to construction. (3) Zoningpennits: All applications for zoning permits for structures in the floodplain as defined for purposes of this section shall include a smndard FEMA elevarion certificate completed by a licensed surveyor or engineet. For all such pennits, the Zoning Administrator shall obmin and mainmin a record of the following informarion: (A) The elevarion of the one hundted- (100) year flood; (B) T opograpbic information showing existing and proposed ground elevation; (C) For structures to be elevated, the elevation (lU relation to mean sea level) of the lowest floor (tncluding basement) of any proposed new or subsmntially improved structures; (I)) For non-residential structures to be floodproofed, the elevation (lU relation to mean sea level) to which the structure will be floodproofed; (E) Whete a nonresidential structure is inteoded to be made watertight below the base flood level, a registered professional engineet or architect shall develop and review structural design, specificarions, and plans for the construction, and shall certifY that the design and methods of construction are in accordance with accepted smndards of practice for meeting the applicable provisions of the Virginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code; and (F) Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, an elevarion certificate of the as-built construction. (4) Manufactured or mobile homes: All manufactured homes or mobile homes to be placed or substantially improved within the flood-fringe shall be placed on a permanent foundarion and anchored in accordance with the Virginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code. (5) Floodway: In the floodway, no encroachments, including fill, new construction, subsmntial improvements, rebabilimtion of subsmntially damaged structures, and othet development, shall be pennitted unless the applicants professional engineer detnonstrates through hydrologic and hydraulic analyses performed in accordance with smndard engineeting pracrices that the proposed encroachment would not result in any increase in the one hundted- (100) year flood elevation, or a conditional letter of map revision is approved. The requirements of subsection (g)(4) and (g)(6) shall apply to encroachments permitted by this section. (6) Flood-fringe and approximated floodplain: In the flood-fringe and approximated floodplain, the development or use of land shall be permitted in accordance with the regulations of the undedying base zoning district, provided that all such uses, activities, or development shall be undett>tken in strict compliance with the floodproofing and related provisions conmined in the Virginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code and all othet applicable codes and ordinances; and provided furthet that the lowest floor of any structure shall be elevated to a minimum of two (2) feet above the base flood elevation, or, when allowed in the Virginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code, shall be floodproofed to two (2) feet above the base flood elevation. In addition, all electrical, heating, ventilation, plumbing, air conditioning equipment, and othet service facilities, including ductwork, for new construction or subsmntial improvement shall be elevated or floodproofed to two (2) feet above the base flood elevarion. (J) Approximated floodplain: Within the approximated floodplain, all proposed developments shall include within such proposals base flood elevarion data. The applicant's professional engineet shall also delineate a floodway area based on the Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 45 Article 3 requirement that all existing and future development not increase the one hundted- (100) year flood elevarion more than one (1) foot at any "one (1) point The engineeting principle identified as equal teducrion of conveyance shall be used to make the deteunination of increased flood heights. Within the floodway area delineated by the applicants professional engineer, the provisions of subsection (g)(S), above, and subsecrions (h) and (i), below, shall apply. (h) Permitted uses in floodway The following uses shall be permitted as of right in the floodway to the extent that they are otherwise pennitted in the undedying base zoning district and are not probibited by any othet ordinance, and provided they do not employ stroctures, fill, or storage of materials and equipment within the floodway which may cause any increase in one hundred- (1 (0) year flood height and velocity: (1) Agricultural operations, such as genetal fiuming, pasture, grazing, outdoor plant nurseries, hotricu1ture, truck fiuming, forestry, sod fiuming, and wild crop harvesting; (2) Public and private recreational uses such as parks, picnic grounds, golf courses, boat launching or swimming areas, biking or horseback riding trails, wildlife and nature presetVes, fishing areas, and lIllp and skeet game xanges; (3) Botanical gardens; and (4) Accessory residential uses such as yard areas, gardens, and play areas. (i) Special exception uses in floodway The following uses shall be permitted in the floodway by special exceprion granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals provided such uses are permitted in the undedying base zoning district (1) Structures accessory to the uses set forth in subsections (h)(l) through (h)(3), above. (2) Utilities distribution: gas/electric compressor smtion or subsmtion, or watet pump/lift smrion. (3) Sewage treatment facility or watet treatment facility. (4) Quarry and mining operations, including excavarion of sand, gravel, or clay, provided no increase in the level of flooding or velocity is caused. (5) Storage of materials and equipment provided that they are not buoyant, flanunable, or explosive, and are not subject to major damage by flooding, or provided that such material and equipment is finnly anchored to prevent flomrion or mOVetUent, or can be readily removed from the area within the rime available after flood wanting. (j) (1) Design criteria for public utilities and facilities All new or replacement sanitary sewer facilities and private sewage treatment plants (mcluding all pumping starions and collector systems) shall be designed to minimize infillIlltion of flood waters into the systems and discha<ges from the systems into the flood watetS. In addition, they must be located and constructed to minimize flood damage and impairment (2) All new or replacement pomble watet facilities shall be designed to eliminate infilttarion of flood watetS into the system and sba11 be located and constructed to minimize flood damages. (3) All storm drainage facilities shall be designed to convey the flow of stormwater runoff in a safe and efficient mannet, without damage to pet50US or property. The systems shall ensure proper drainage along streets, and provide positive drainage away from buildings and on-site waste disposal sites. The City may require a primarily underground system to accommodate frequent floods and a secondary surface system to Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 46 Article 3 accommodate hu:ger, less frequent floods. Dminage plans shall be consistent with local and regiona1 drainage plans. The facilities shall be designed to prevent the discharge of excess runoff onto adjacent properties. (4) All othet utilities, such as gas lines and electrical, telephone, and cable television systems, being placed in flood-prone areas shall be located, elevated (whete possible), and constructed to minimize the chance of impairment during a flood occurrence. (5) Streets, drainage improvements, and sidewalks shall be designed to prevent increasing flood levels by more than one (1) foot Any new structure encroaching in a floodway shall receive a conditionallertet of map revision (CLOMR) prior to construcrion and a lertet of map revision (LOMR) following complerion. (k) Existing structures in the floodplain A structure or use of a structure or premises which lawfully existed before the enactment of these provisions, but which is not in conformity with these provisions, may be continued subject to the following conditions: (1) Existing structures or uses located in the floodway shall not be expanded or enlarged, unless the effect of the proposed expansion or enlargement on one hundted- (100) year flood heights is fully offset by accompanying stream or channel improvements. (2) For the purpose of this section, any modification, alteration, repair, reconstruction, or improvement of any kind to a structure or use located in a floodplain to an extent or amount less than fifty (SO) percent of its market value shall be elevated or floodproofed in accordance with the Vuginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code to the greatest extent possible. (3) For the purpose of this section, any modification, altetation, repair, reconstruction, or improvement of any kind to a structure or use located in a floodplain to an extent or amount of fifty (SO) percent or more of its market value shall be undett>tken only in full compliance with the provisions of this Chapter and the Vuginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code. (I) (1) Variances When an application for a variance from the regulations of this secrion has been made, the procedure for processing the variance request shall be as set forth in Section 362-561. (2) In considcting an application for a variance from the terms of this section, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall satisfy all smndards and findings set forth in Section 362-561 (c) and (d) and shall considet the foDowing additional factors: (A) The danget to life and property due to increased flood heights or velocities caused by encroachment No variance shall be granted for any proposed use, development, or activity within any floodway that will cause any increase in the one hundred- (1 (0) year flood elevarion without approval of a conditional lertet of map revision (G..OMR); (B) The danget that materials may be swept onto other lands or downstream to the injury of othets; (C) The proposed watet supply and sanimtion systems and the ability of these systems to prevent disease, contamination, and unsanitary conditions;. (I)) The susceptibility of the proposed facility and its contents to flood damage and the effect of such damage on the individual owners; (E) The importance of the services provided by the proposed facility to the community; (F) The requirements of the facility for a waterfront location; (G) The availability of alternative locations not subject to flooding for the proposed use; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 47 Article 3 (H) The compatibility of the proposed use with existing development and development anticipated in the foreseeable future; (I) The relationship of the proposed use to the City's Comprehensive Plan and floodplain management program for the City; (J) The safety of access by ordinary and emergency vehicles to the property in rime of flood; (K) The expected heights, velocity, duration, rate of rise, and sediment ttansport of the floodwaters expected at the site; (1.) The repair or rehabilimtion of historic structures upon a determination that the proposed repair or rebabilimtion will not preclude the structure's continued designation as a bistoric structure and the variance is the minimum necessary to preserve the historic character and design of the structure; and (M) Such othet factors which are relevant to the purposes of Section 36.2-333. (3) The Board of Zoning Appeals may forward any application and accompanying documenmtion pettaining to any request for a variance to the City Engineet or othet qualified person or smte or fedetal agency for technical assismnce in evaluating the proposed project in relation to flood heights and velocities, and the adequacy of the plans for flood protection and othet related martets. (4) Variances shall be issued only after the Board of Zoning Appeals has determined that the granting of such variance will not result in probibited increases in flood heights, additioua\ threats to public safety, or extraordinary public expense, and will not create nuisances, cause victimization of the public, or conflict with City laws or ordinances. (5) The Board of Zoning Appeals shall notify the applicant for a variance, in writing, within ten (10) business days of the public hearing, that the issuance of a variance to construct a structure below the one hundred- (100) year flood elevation increases the risks to life and property and will result in increased premium rates for flood inSllWlce. (6) A record of the above notification as well as all variance acrions, including justificarion for their issuance, shall be mainmined by the Zoning Administtator. Any variances which are issued shall be noted in the annual or biennial report of the City submitted to the Fedetallnsurance Administtator. (m) Application exception uses in req uirements floodways for variances and special All applications for a variance or a special exceprion use in any floodway, as defined herein, shall include the following: (1) Plans in triplicate, drawn to scale not less than one (1) inch to one hundted (100) feet horizontally, showing the location, dimensions, and contours (at two-foot intervals) of the lot, existing and proposed structures, fill, storage areas, water supply, sanimry facilities, and relationship of the floodway to the proposal; (2) A typical valley cross-section as necessary to adequately show the channel of the stream, elevarion of land areas adjoining each side of the channel, cross-sectional areas to be occupied by the proposed deve1opment, floodway limits, and l00-year flood elevation; (3) A profile showing the slope of the bottom of the channel or flow line of the stream; (4) A summary report, prepared by professioual engineers or oth= of demonstrated qualifications, evaluating the proposed project in relation to flood heights and velocities, the seriousness of flood damage to the use, and othet pertinent technical matters; Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 48 Article 3 (5) A list of names, addresses, and officiallllX numbers of adjoining property ownetS and ownetS of property within three hundted (300) feet of the subject property; and (6) A conditional letter of map revision (CLOMR) prior to the issuance of any such variance or spectU exception in the floodway. 36.2-334 Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) (a) Purpose Public health, public and aviation safety, and the general welfare require a minimum clear space or buffet between opetating aircraft and othet objects. The buffer may be achieved by limiting the locarion and height of these objects. The purpose of the Airport Navigarion Overlay District (AN) is to regulate and restrict the height of structures, objects, and natural growth and to address design and construcrion issues by creating the appropriate zones and esmblisbing the boundaries theteOf for the Roanoke Regional Airport in ordet to avoid hazards to and interference with flight navigation. (b) Applicability The Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) shall be applied to the Airport Navigation Zone as set forth and defined in subsection (d), below, and shall be an overlay to the undedying base zoning districts as shown on the Official Zoning Map. As such, the provisions for the Airport Navigation Oveday District (AN) shall serve as a supplement to the undedying base zoning district provisions, superimposed over the existing base zones, being more specifically zones of airspace that do not affect the uses and activities of the base zoning districts except as provided for in subsection (g) below. An area located in more than one (1) of the sub-wnes identified in subsection (d), below, is consideted to be only in the zone with the most restrictive heightlimimtion. In addition, with any conflict between the provisions or requirements of the Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) and those of the undedying base zoning district, the more restrictive provisions shall apply. (c) Definitions Cettain terms and wotds used in this section shall be defined as set forth below. Whete any conflict exists between the definitions below and those set forth in Appendix A, the definitions of this subsection shall govetn for the purposes of the regulations of this section. Aeronautical study: A study conducted by the Fedetal Aviation Admiuisttation (FAA) in response to the filing of a Form 7460-1, as amended, wheteby the FAA examines the effect of an obsttucrion or structure on factors such as aircraft opetational capabilities, electronic and procedural requirements, and airport hazard standards. AUport: The Roanoke Regional Airport Aviation navigational aid: Instruments and equipment installed and mainmined by the FAA or Airport owner for the safe operation of aircraft, such as air surveillance radar, approach lighting aids, radio beacons, and radio transmitters for aircraft navigation and commw1ications. Beginning elevation: The begimting e1evarion for the Runway 6 Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surface is 1151.9 MSL The begimting elevation for the Runway 33 Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surface is 1142.1 MSL. Hazard to air navigation: An obsttucrion determined by the Fedetal Aviation Administration to have a substantial advetS< impact on the safe and efficient utilization of the airport or navigable airspace. Height: For the purpose of determining the height limits in all zones and shown on the zoning map, the datum shall be mean sea level (North American Vettical Datum of 1988) unless othet specified. Nonconfonning use: Any structure, object of natural growth, or use of land which is inconsisteot with the provisions of this section or any amendment thereto. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 49 Article 3 Obstruction: Any structure, growth, or othet object, including a mobile object, which exceeds a limiting height, or penettates any surface floor, set forth in this section. Some obstructions are hazards to air navigation; othetS are not Part 77.13 Swface: An area defined in Part 77.13 (a)(2)(i), Subpart B (Notice of Construction or Alterarion), of TIde 14 Code of Fedetal Regulations, extending at a slope of 100 feet horizontally for each foot Vettically for a dismnce of 20,000 feet from the nearest point of the nearest runway at the Airport Person: An individual, firm, pattnetShip, cotporation, company, association, joint stock association, public or private utility, or governmental entity, and including a trustee, a receiver, an assignee, or a similar representative of any of them. Precision Instrument Runway: A runway having an existing instrument approach procedure using an Instrument Landing System (ILS) or Localizet Directional Approach (LOA); at the Airport such runways are Runway 6 and Runway 33. Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surface: A surface longitudinally centered on the extended runway centerline, begimting at the end of the Part 77.13 surface at the begimting elevarion of the applicable runway and extending outwatd and upward at the slope of forty (40) feet horizontally for each foot vettically for a dismnce of 30,200 feet Its perimeter coincides with the perimeter of the Precision Instrument Runway Approach Zone. Precision Instrument Runway Approach, Part 77.13 and Transitional Zones: The zones are defined in subsection (d) heteof. Runway: A specified area on an airport prepared for the landing or mke off of aircraft. Structure: An object, including a mobile object, constructed or installed by a person, including, but without Iimimtion, buildings, towetS, cranes, smokesmcks, earth formations, poles, electric lines and ovethead ttansmission lines, flag poles, and ship masts. Tower: A type of freesmnding structure or device of more than twenty (20) feet in height designed for communication purposes or transmitting or receiving electrical, radio, or other signals. Transitional surfaces: These surfaces exteod outwatd at a slope of seven (1) feet horizontally for each foot Vettically from the sides of the precision instrument runway approach surface for a dismnce of five thousand (5,000) feet measured horizontally from the edge of the approach surface at a ninety (90) degree angle to the extended runway centerline. Vegetation: Any object of natural growth, including, withoutlimimtton, trees. Zones: All areas provided for in subsection (d) heteof; genetally deseribed in three dimensions by refetence to ground elevation, vetrical dismnces from the ground elevation, and horizonral dismnces from the runways, runway centerlines, and other surfaces or zones. 1bis includes 5U~zones. (d) (1) Establishment and definition of airport safety zones Thete is hereby esmblished within the City the Airport Navigation Zone, consisting of cettain sub-zones as defined in subsection (2) below. Such Airport Navigation Zone and its sub-zones are shown on a cettain electronic map prepared for the Roanoke Regional Airport by Delm Airport Consulmnts, Ino., entitled Airport Navigation Zone, dated January 2005, which map is hereby declared to be a part of this section by reference. (2) The Airport Navigarion Zone includes all of the area and airspace lying equal to and above the Part 77.13 Surface, the Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surfaces, and the Transirional Approach Surfaces, with each sub-zone defined as follows: (A) Part 77.13 Zone: The Part 77.13 Zone extends around the Airport, away from each runway for 20,000 feet, with the floor set by the Part 77.13 Surface; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 50 Article 3 (B) Precision Instrument Runway Approach Zone: The innet edge of this approach zone begins at the end of the Part 77.13 Zone and is 6,940 feet wide and is at beginning elevarion of 1596.9 MSL for Runway 6 and 1587.1 MSL for Runway 33. The Precision Instrument Runway Approach Zone expands outward wUfonnly to a width of 16,000 feet at a horizontal dismnce of 30,200 feet from the end of the Part 77.13 Zone. Its centerline is the continuation of the runway centerline and the floor is set by the Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surfaces; and (C) TranaitionaI Zones: The ttansitional zones are the areas that extend five thousand (5,000) feet outward from the edge of the Precision Instrument Runway Approach Zones, petpendicuIar to the extended runway centerline, with the floor set by the seven to 1 (7:1) slope of the Transitional Surfaces. (e) Height limitations (1) Except as othetwise provided in this section, no structure shall be etected, altered, or mainmined, and no vegemtion shall be allowed to grow, in the Airport Navigation Zone esmblisbed herein, so as to penettate any ref=ced surface, known as the floor, of the Part 77.13 Zone, the Precision Instrument Runway Approach Zone, or the Transitional Zone at any point (2) The height restrictions, or floors, for the individual zones shall be those planes delineated as surfaces and defined in subsection (c) heteof as the Part 77.13 Surface, Precision Instrument Runway Approach Surface, and the Transitional Surface. (3) In addition, heightlimimtion shall be applied within the Airport Navigarion Zone as follows: (A) To construction or alteration of any structure more than two hundted (200) feet above the ground level at its site, even if not penettating the floor of any surface; and (B) To any towet. (f) Exemption from height restrictions The following shall be exetnpt from the heightlimimtions for the Airport Navigation Zones: (1) Any structure or vegemtion of a height which is thitty-five (35) feet or less above the surface of the land, except for towetS; (2) Any tower which is of a height which is twenty (20) feet or less above the surface of the land; or (3) Any air navigation aid or facility, airport visual approach or landing aid, aircraft arresting device, or airfield direcrional signs. (g) Use restrictions No use may be made of land or water within any zone esmblished by this section in such a mannet as to: (1) create electrical or othet intetference with navigational signals or radio communication between the airport and aircraft; (2) diminish the ability of pilots to distinguish between airport lights and other lights; (3) result in g1are in the eyes of f1yetS using the airport; (4) impair visibility in the vicinity of the airport; (5) create the poteotial for bird strike hazards; (6) reduce the efficiency and effectiveness of any aviation navigatioual aid; or (T) othetwise in any way endanget or intetfete with the landing, mkeoff; or maneuvering of aircraft. (h) Consideration determination When reviewing applications for zoning pennits within the Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN), the Zoning Administtator shall considet all provisions of this section. The applicant for a zoning pennit sball submit adequate information and detail necessary to ensure that the limimtions and probibitions of this section shall not be exceeded or violated. In the event that the Zoning Administrator is unable to determine whethet the limimrions and probibitions of this section will be exceeded or violated, no pennit shall be issued until a completed Fedetal Aviarion Administtation of zoning permit application; FAA Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 51 Article 3 (FAA) Form 7460-1, as amended, has been submitted to the FAA, an aetOnautical study has been completed by the FAA, and a determination of thete being no hazard to air navigation and no violation of the use restricrions conmined in subsection (g) above has been made by the FAA and submitted to the Zoning Administtator. (i) Variance conditions (1) Nonconforming uses or obstrucrions wbich are determined by the FAA to be a hazard to air navigarion or violate the use restrictions in subsection (g) above shall not be pennitted. Nonconforming uses or obsttucrions which the FAA has determined do not constitute a hazard.to air navigation so long as they are mitigated may be permitted provided that (A) Such mitigation procedures, such as use of lights or marketS, shall be installed and continuously mainmined at the property owner's expense and shall be requited pursuant to and in acconlance with specific, wrilteo FAA direction, as well as any requirements deemed necessary by the Board of Zoning Appeals; and (B) The Airport's Executive Director bas determined in writing that the proposed mitigation procedures will not in any way impact, limit, restrict, or require a change in the Airport's use or opetarinn. (2) A permit may be issued for a nonconforming use that the FAA determines is an obsttucrion but is not a hazard to air navigation, does not violate the use restrictions conmined in subsecrion (g) above, is properly marked and lighted, and does not intetfere with airport opetarions. (3) All mitigation measures requited of and imposed upon any person for a nonconforming use etected, created, or permitted to grow after Augost 29, 1966, shall be mainmined, repaired, removed, and replaced, when necessary, by such person or his successor. (j) Applicability of regulations to pre-existing structures, uses, or vegetation (1) Except as provided in subsection (2), below, the requirements prescribed by this section shall not be construed to require the removal, lowering, or other changes or alteration of any structure or vegetation not conforming to the regularions as of Augost 29, 1966, or whet< applicable, as of the effective date of any subsequent amendment to these regulations. Nothing conmined in this section shall require any change in the construction, alteration, or intended use of any st:ructure, the construction or alteration of which was begun prior to Augost 29, 1966, or whete applicable, prior to the effective date of any subsequent amendment hereto, and is diligently prosecuted, except as to subsecrion (h) of this section. (2) The ownet of any structure, vegemtion, or use which existed prior to Augost 29,1966, or whete applicable prior to the effecrive date of any subsequent amendment to this secrion, and which is inconsisteot with or in violation of this section or an amendment thereto, shall be required, as a condition of the continued mainteoance of such structure, tree, or use, to permit any mitigarion procedures deetned necessary including, withoutlimimtion, the City's installation, opetation, and mainteoance thereon of such markets and lights as shall be deemed necessary by the Fedetal Aviarion Administtation (FAA) so as to indicate the presence of such object or hazardous use to opetators of aircraft in the vicinity of the airport. Such markets and lights shall be installed, opetated, and mainmined at the expense of the City and not of such ownet. (3) No permit shall be granted that would allow a nonconforming use or structure to become a greater hazard to air navigation that it was on the effecrive date of this Chapter. (4) Whenevet the Zoning Administtator determines that a nonconforming structure has been abandoned or more than fifty (SO) percent destroyed, physically deteriorated, or decayed, no permit shall be granted that would enable such structure to be rebuilt, reconstructed, or othetwise refurbished so as to exceed the applicable height limit or othetwise deviate from the Airport Navigation Overlay District (AN) regulations conmined herein. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 52 ArtIcle 3 (k) Conflicting regulations Whete thete exists a conflict between any of the regulations or limimtions prescribed in this secrion and any othet provisions applicable to the same subject, whete the conflict is with respect to the height of structures, vegemtion, or use of land, or any othet maller, the more stringentlimimtion or requirement shall govetn. 36.2-335 River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RCC) (a) Purpose The purpose of the River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RcC) is to recognize the Roanoke River and its tribumries as valuable water resources in the City and to designate cettain areas along their banks as being critical to their protecrlon in order to ensure that such streams and adjacent lands will fulfill their natural functions. Stream systems are comprised of the stream and their drainage basins. Streams have the primary natural funcrions of conveying storm and ground watet, storing floodwatet, and supporting aquatic and othet life. Vegemted lands adjacent to the stream channel in the drainage basin serve as a buffet to protect the stream system's ability to fulfill its natural funcrions. Primary natural functions of the buffet include protection of water quality by filtering pollumnts, provision of storage for floodwaters, and provision of suimble babimts for wildlife. The inteot of the regulations of this section is to establish performance and development smndards in the critical areas along the banks of the Roanoke River and certain tributaries in a manner that protects and restores water quality and conserves surface water functions. The regulations of this district shall be in addition to those of the Floodplain Overlay District (F). In order to provide for the health, safety, and genetal welfare of the citizens of the City, the regularions of the RCC Overlay District are inteoded to: (1) Avoid land uses and development activities that pose a danget to, and degradation of; these water resources; (2) Minimize clearing and grading activities or similar activities that disturb or destroy site vegemtion, with the goal that the natural vegemtton, features, and qualities of properties along the Roanoke River and its tribumries will be protected to the maximum extent possible, consisteot with the recommendations of the City's Comprehensive Plan; and (3) Implement additional etOsion and sediment control practices, the mainteoance and installation of buffet areas of natural vegemtion, and the use of best management pracrices in ordet to minimize the impacts of excessive soil loss and the advetse effects of non-point source pollumnts on the water quality of the Roanoke Rivet and its tribumries. (b) (1) Applicability The City Council may, in the manuet provided for amending this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 362-540, apply the River and Creek Cotridors Oveday District (RCC) to properties that abut the banks of the Roanoke RiVet or its unenclosed tribumries. For purposes of the application of this oveday district, any property separated from the bank of the Roanoke River or a tribumry by a public right-of-way or railroad right-of-way shall not be deetned to be abutting the bank. (2) Any River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RCC) designated by the City Council as provided for in subsection (1), above, shall be shown as an overlay to the existing undedying district on the Official Zoning Map. As such, the provisions in this section shall serve as a supplement to the undedying base zoning district regularions. Whete a conflict exists between the regularions relating to the RCC Overlay District and those of any underlying base zoning district, the more restricrive provisions shall apply. (3) Upon development of any property within the River and Creek Corridors Overlay District (RCC), such property shall comply with the buffet requirements of this section, except those which, as of the effective date of this Chapter, have previously secured a vested property right pursuant to Section 36.2-108. (4) Redevelopment of a property, or expansion of existing structures or uses, shall comply with the buffer requirements of this section; howevet, uses and structures previously approved and constructed in a buffer may remain. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 53 Article 3 (5) Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect the applicability of the regulations of the Floodplain Overlay District (F). The regulations of this section are in addition to those of the Floodplain Overlay District (F). When any conflict exists between this section and the regulations of the Floodplain Overlay District, the strictet provision shall govern. (c) Definitions Cettain words and tetmS used in this section shall be defined as set forth below. Whete any conflict exists between the definitions below and those set forth in Appendix A, the definirions of this subsection shall govetn for the purposes of the regulations of this section. Best Management Practices (BMPs): A sttuctural or nonsltuctural management based pracrice used singuIady or in combination to reduce non-point source input to receiving watetS in ordet to achieve water quality protecrion goals. Nonsttuctural BMPs are non-engineered methods to control the amount of non-point source pollution and may include land use controls and vegemted buffetS. Sttuctural BMPs are engineeted structures that are designed to teduce the delivery of pollumnts from their source or to divert contaminants away from the rivers and tribumties. Structural BMPs may include wet deteotion ponds, deteotion basins, grass swales and ditches, and infi!ttarion devices. Dtainage basin: The area of laud which drains to a given point on a body of water. Riparian buffi:r: A natural vegemted area left undixturbed or an esmblisbed vegemted area, adjacent to the bank of a watercourse, through which stormwater runoff flows in a diffuse manner so that the runoff does not become channelized and which provides for infiltration of the runoff and filteting out sediment and othet non-point source pollutants from runoff before it reaches a 'Watercourse. Stream: Any part of a watercourse, naturally occurring or artificially created, for the purpose of conveying water from gromd water or surface runoff. Top of bank: The boundary line between a body of water and the laud. This line shall consist of the sloping margin of; or the ground bordering, a rivet or creek and serving to confine the water to the natural channel during the normal course of flow. It is best marked whete a distinct channel bas been etoded to the valley floor or whete there is a cessation of land vegemtion. (d) (1) Riparian buffer req uirement Within the RCC Overlay District, a riparian buffet shall be esmblished and shall consist of all land adjacent to, and fifty (SO) feet landward from, the top of the banks of the Roanoke River or the applicable tribumry. The fifty (50) feet buffer width shall be measured horizontally on . line petpendicular to the surface water, landward from the top of the bank on each side of the rivet or tribumry. When the landward boundary of the riparian buffet fa1ls within an improved public right-of-way, the riparian buffet shall be defined as the remaindet of the improved public right-of-way and shall not extend beyond that public right-of-way. (2) The riparian buffer boundaries shall be cleady delineated on all site-specific plans submitted for approval pursuant to this Chapter. (3) The riparian buffer boundaries shall be cleady marked on-site prior ro any land disturbing activities, and shall remain marked until all land disturbing acrivity has been completed. (4) All land disturbing acrivity within the requited riparian buffet shall comply with Chapter 11.1, Erosion and Sediment Contro~ of this Code. (5) No principal or accessory uses or structures shall be permitted within the area of the requited riparian buffet. (e) (1) Riparian buffer standards To minimize the adverse effects of land use activities on the Roanoke River and its tributaries, a fifty (50) foot buffer area of vegetation that is effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 54 Article 3 filtering non-point source pollution from runoff, shall be retained and maintained if present, and where it does not exist, shall be established and maintained upon any land disturbing activity, except as provided in Section 36.2-335(1)(1), in any area delineated in subsection (d) above as a riparian buffer. (2) In order to mainmin the functional value of the riparian buffer area, indigenous vegemtion shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible. (3) Within the required riparian buffer area, no vegemtion may be cleared or otherwise significantly disturbed, except as provided in subsection (4) below, no grading or excavation work may be performed, and no fill or other materials may be placed except as shown on the approved Erosion and Sediment Control Plan. (4) Retnoval of vegemtion within the required riparian buffer area shall be permitted only in accordance with the following provisions: (A) Trees may be pruned or removed as necessary to provide limited sight lines and vistas, provided that where removed, they shall be replaced with other vegetation that is equally effective in retarding runoff, preventing erosion, and filtering non-point source pollution from runoff. (B) Dead, diseased, or dying trees may be removed. (5) All unvegemted areas within the requited riparian buffet area shall be vegemted with appropriate riparian, erosion controlling plant material. Riparian material shall be defined as indigenous vegemrion which naturally occurs along the rivet and creek and is suited to local conditions. (6) With the approval of the Zoning Administtator, manmade materials may be used in conjuncrion with vegetarion to stabilize the riverbank or creek bank only where it is shown that vegetation alone will not smbilize the bank. (J) Access paths shall be constructed and surfaced so as to effectively control etOsion. (8) Runoff from new development or tedevelopment shall be directed toward areas coVeted with vegemtion for surface infilttation catch basins, avoiding channeling and preventing concentrated flows of surface water. Piped storm sewers shall be permitted. (f) Permitted buffer impacts The following development activities shall be permitted within the requited riparian buffet area of the RCC Overlay District, provided no more land is disturbed than is necessary to provide for the desired installation or construcrion, all requited permits have been issued, and any land disturbance activity complies with all etOsion and sediment control requirements of Chaptet 11.1 of this Code for the smbilization of disturbed areas to minimize negative effects on the quality of surface watetS: (1) Any maintenance activity of an existing use or structure, provided it does not change or affect the quality, rate, volume, or location of surface water discharge, or involve the destruction of vegetation, as determined by the Zoning Administrator in consultation with the City Engineer; (2) Emergency removal of debris resulting from floods or other natural disasters; (3) Linear utility lines, railroad tracks, and public streets or other public infrastructure improvements; (4) Public passive recreation uses such as greenways and pervious trails, provided that to the extent possible, such pathways use existing and proposed utility aligrunents or previously cleared areas and minimize tree cutting to the maximum extent practicable; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 55 Ar1lcle 3 (5) Individual pedestrian paths connecting homeowners to the river or creek in the form of narrow, pervious footpaths with minimal tree disturbance; or (6) Historic preservation of existing structures or archaeological activities. (g) Variances When a hardship would result from adhetence to the application of the requirements of this secrion, a request for a variance may be made pursuant to the procedures set forth in Secrion 36.2-561. 36.2-336 Comprehensive Sign Overlay District (a) Purpose The Comprehensive Sign Overlay District is inteoded to provide the opportunity for innovarive comprehensive signage plans for developments which conmin a number of consttaints to conventional sigo placement and allocation regulation while at the same time serving the public purposes set forth in Section 36.2-660. (b) Applicability Any area meeting the requirements of this secrion may, by amendment to this Chapter, be zoned Comprehensive Sign Overlay District, and such area shall be designated as such overlay on the Official Zoning Map. (c) Standards All petitions for review and approval of a Comprehensive Sign Overlay District shall comply with the following smndards: (1) A Comprehensive Sign Overlay District shall be applied as an overlay only to lots with a CLS, MXPUD, INPUD, or AD District zorting designarion; (2) A Comprehensive Sign Overlay District shall consist of at least five (5) acres; (3) The comprehensive signage plan shall emphasize compatibility with the buildings and site design; (4) The ovetall sigo area in the Comprehensive Sign Overlay District shall not exceed the combined total of freesmnding and building-mounted sigo allocation of the othetWise applicable zoning district sigo regulations; and (5) The height limits of the applicable zorting district sigo regulations shall not be exceeded (d) (1) Procedural requirements A request to esmblish and apply a Comprehensive Sign Overlay District to a specific property or contiguous properties may be initiated by petition of the property ownet, conttact purchaser with the owner's written consent, or the owners agent in ordet to provide altemative sigo regulations than would othetWise be requited by this Chapter. Such a request shall be consideted an amendment to the zoning ordinance and Official Zoning Map, and review and approval shall be subject to the amendment requirements as set forth in Section 36.2-540. If a Comprehensive Sign Overlay District is esmblisbed, the sigo limimtion esmblisbed by that overlay district shall goVetU. (2) In addirion to the requirements of Section 36.2-540, a petition to esmblish a Comprehensive Sign OvedaY District shall include a comprehensive signage plan that conmins the following information: (A) A written plan detailing the type, quantity, size (dimensions), shape, color, material, and location of all signs, existing and proposed, within the property that is the subject of the proposed Comprehensive Sign Overlay District; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 56 Article 3 (B) A summary of how the Comprehensive Sign Overlay District, as proposed, will serve the objectives set forth in Section 36.2-660; (C) An illustrarion of each sign included within the proposal, including each sign face; (I)) An illustration of any proposed sign landscaping; and (E) An illustrarion of proposed lighting for any illuminated sigus. (3) In addition to the requirements of Section 36.2-540, the Planning Commission and City Council shall consider a petition to establish a Comprehensive Sign Overlay District to determine that the Comprehensive Sign Overlay District, as proposed, meets the smndards set forth in this section and will serve the public purposes and objecrives set forth in Section 36.2-660 at least as weD, or better, than the sigoage that would othetwise be required by this Chapter for the subject property. (4) Following adoption of a Comprehensive Sign Oveday District by the City Council, the regulations of the district shall apply unifonnly to all lots located within the boundaries of the Overlay District (5) Comprehensive Sign Overlay Districts which have been properly esmblisbed may be amended or varied only upon submission and approval of a zoning amendment petition pursuant to Secrion 36.2-540. Division 4. Use Matrix 36.2-340 Use Matrix The uses permitted as of right or by special exception within each zoning district shall be as set forth in Table 340-1. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 57 Article 3 Table 340.1. Use Matrix kl) "P" ITll<l1l'plfl1lHt\d ~s of llt~h( I' IJlllllllPllllsl , ":-," Illllll"pllllllttull!\ "J1l1111lXllpllOll IS I j1111Illl'1111 t \ 1,111l1 ldll11l111 pflllubltlJ lndlf "Anl,sun [1st s," "1\" nllJlh plfmllt,d J, an \( (l ",on lbl, "s" 01lanS plfIllll!\t1 h SPl lllllX(lptlC)l] \, III lll(",OI\ IISl, and a bl mk cdllTlll1h prolnll1ftd ~ .~ .~ l . ~ ~ ~ a a ~ ~ e a ! a a . ~ a a oJ: 0; oJ: Q ~ ;;; ., Q ~ i ] ,g e . . ,;, ., " ~ ~ 8 ::> ,;, . . .. .. .~ .!I> ~ u .. u .r .. 'S j ;; Q !o .r .r .r ::s ::s ::s Z ~ ,3 ;; . ::> ;; .. olI . g Use ., ;; ... 'S Q ::> .. ., ., ., ] ;; ... .. 'S ~ .. ~ ] ;; ] ] .. .. .. .. a x ] . 1l a ] .. . . . ~ ~ ~ a " .8 .~ . .lj :9 . ~ ] .!l ~ ::> .. . :9 . . . :51 . . .. . ::s ! a . ~ . :9 .. a a " t } :51 . ~ a ] :51 . . ~ ~ a a ~ . u I . ~ . . . .. a 8 .. . ~ .~ .. ~ Q . ~ ~ . - 8 8 .!I> :li ::s ! ~ Q .. .. ~ "I .. ... ., :i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ z " ~ - ::: Q ~ i!:i 0 sl ::> '" '" <.J <.J <.J . Q .. .. - - - Accessory uses, not otherwise listed in this table, A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A subiect to Sec. 36.2-403 Accessorv anartment, subiect to Sec. 36.2402 S S S S S S A S S A Home occupation, excluding personal service, A A A A A A A A A A A A A A subiect to Sec. 36.2-413 Home occupation, Personal service, subject to Sec. S S S S S S S S A A S A S A 36.2413 Outdoor dicnlav area, subiect to Sec. 36.2422 A A A A Outdoor recreation facility lighting or sports S S S S S S S S stadium liahting, subject to Sec. 36.2-403 Outdoor stoI'1l2e, subiect to Sec. 36.2423 A A A A A A Recycling collection point, subject to Sec. 36.2. S A A A 403 Resident manager apartment, subject to Sec. 36.2- A A A A 403 A A Dwel1i~ Sirwie.familv detached P P P P P P P P P Dwellino, Two-familv S p P P Dwellino, Multifamilv p p S P P P P Dwelling, Townhouse or Rowhouse, subject to p S p p p p p Sec. 36.2431 Dwelline:, Manufactured home P Dwelling, Mobile home, subject to Sec. 36.2-417 P Bed and breakfast, subject to Sec. 36.2-405 p S S S S S S S S S S Boardino: house S Donnitorv p p Group care facility, Congregate home, Elderly, p S p P subject to Sec. 36.2412 Group care facility, Congregate home, not otherwise listed in this table. subject to Sec. 36.2- S S S 412 Group care facility, Group care home, subject to S S S Sec. 36.2-412 Group care facility, Halfway house. subject to Sec. S S S 36.2412 Group care facility. Nursing home, subject to Sec. p S p P 36.2412 Group care facility, Transitional living facility, S subject to Sec. 36.2-412 Group home, subject to Virginia Code 15.2-2291 P P P P P P P P P P P P P Hotel or motel p p p p p p Zonklg Ordinence - City of Ro.noke 12105105 Mlcle3 50 Table 340-1. Use Matrix !"-C\ "J> Ill( l11~ Tlll1T1lttlJ l~ O[ orht a~ a pnllClI)lll1~l , "~ ml.llh]1l111l1ItldiJ\ ~pllldl)'(lP(111111~ lj\tltllll'lllhl \ !JIUlk "II 111\ IIl'- prol11bttld l 'ndlr "\ln~S()n l SlS," II \" nil ,ln~ Pl rmlttld a~ an alll ~~()n lJ~(. ":-," TTIt ltl~ Pll rmtlt d 11 'J1luil \\l\PTj(J!1 h III ll(c"'-{fl\ U~l, and a 111 mL u 11 fT1l l1lS prohlbtlld .t t l . ,t ,t ,t ,t a '; ,t u 1! ! B B ! . c!l .~ !. '" B '" '" 2 "' . . ~ '" '" .Ii "I "' "' .. .. :B 1! f> . i ~ ;l .. .Ii .Ii . . ~ !!. ! .. u .~ .!/ .~ .~ .. .il' ~ 'S 0 ;; '" 'C .~ .~ .~ ::s ::s ::s ~ <!i j - . ;l i '5 .. . . Use i '" '" '" '" ] ] ] :i '" >II .ll ;l .8 .. ] ] ;; ] .. <I i . ;; . ~ 11 ;; . . . 'e ~ . . S 'S .~ . .~ . . . ~ . i ;; .~ .~ .~ .. . . . ~ . 'g . . . . :'51 :'51 . . B - ::s a . :'51 ~ . . B B .. ~ c . .. :'51 :'51 . . . ~ - ~ . s u ~ - 'g . ~ ~ . B ~ .ll '" .. . ~ . . .. ~ .~ .. ~ '" - ~ .. ~ ~ - "I oS ! . ~I; a < ;l ~ '" ~ ~ "' ~ :I: - '" ~ ~ ~ 'I' ~ ~ ~ z " - ~ ~ .. .. :! z z u u u "" - - Blood bank or-:iasma center p P P Business service establishment, not otherwise p p p p p S P P P listed in this table E~ent ortem~aborservice p p Financial institution p p p p p p p p P l.aborat~ dental, medical, or nntical P P P P P P P P P P Laboratorv, testinD and research S S P P S P P P Medical clinic p p p p p p p Office, Deneral or nrofessional P p P P P P P P P Office, lleneral or nrofessional~ scale P P P P P P P P P P Outpatient mental health and substance abuse S S clinic Animal hospital or veterinary clinic, no outdoor p P P P P P P lnens or "nms" Animal hospital or veterinary clinic, with outdoor p S lnens or "nms" Caterer, commercial p P P P P Communitv market p p p p Orive.throuoh facilitv, subiect to Sec. 36.2-409 S P P P S P P Drive-throuo:h kiosk, subiect to Sec. 36.2409 S P P S P Flea market, indoor p p Flea market, outdoor S S Funenll home p p p Kennel, no outdoor "ens or "nms" P P P P Kennel, with outdoor rwonc: or "runs" S Live.work unit, subiect to Sec. 36.2416 P P P P P P P Mixed use buildino:, subiect to Sec. 36.2416 p P P P P P P Outdoor advertising sign, subject to Sec. 36.2-675 P P P P Studio/multimedia production facility p p p p p p p p P Bakery, confectionary, or similar food production, p p p p p p p Retail Body piercing establishment S S S BuildiDll: sunnlies and materials, Retail p P P P P Car wash, not abutting a residential district, p P P sub;ect to Sec. 36.2-406 Car wash, abutting a residential district, subject to S S S Sec. 36.2-406 Commercial motor vehicle rental establishment P Commercial motor vehicle sales and service p establishment, New, subiect to Sec. 36.2-407 Commercial motor vehicle sales and service p establishment, Used, subiect to Sec. 36.2-407 Contractor or tradesman's shop, General or Special S p P P P S Tnlde ZOning Ordln.nee . City of RotInoke 121051O! Article 3 se Table 340--1. Use Matrix kll ")'" l11lJ.l1'. pl nnlltld J.~ oj rlhlU l~ 1 pll11Llp Ilu'l, ";:-.' llll Ins pl 11ll1ttl d 11\ ~pllllll \ll ptll.n ,l~ .1 1'1111\ lp 1111'( \ hIm!' (< I] 11H III prohlbltl'd Undlr"i\(TlSSOn l ~ts.1i"\"mLIIl'pCrml1tld:lsJ.llaltl~S()n uSl."S"mClllsptrl1l11tldlll SI'llld(\((l'IIIITIIS 11l1({( ~()I \1Sl. and:l blInk cell ITlll1b pro\111lHt d B .t .t i u B B B a a B !. i ! a a a u ~ ~ M Q ~ in "' Q Q B '" ~ ~ ~ '" '" - . li ~ .. .. .. .~ .~ e ~ .~ 8. u ~ } .r .. .. .. .!i' ~ 0 I g .r .r .r ::ll ::ll ::ll u ~ j .. . u ) Z ;; . Use "' "' "' "' ;; :a ~ :i 'S 'S i5 011 Q .. ~ ] :a .. :a .. :i ., a 1 . ~ '" ~ . . ~ a ~ .j u .; . .. u u u ~ ~ s '" ! i Q .~ . u . . . :!l :!l :!l u u .!l .. ~ ::ll a a .lj :!l ~ ~ u a a '" ~ :!l . . . a ~ u .g u I! ~ ! .. . u u u ~ a .:; ~ .~ Q ~ . ~ . .. .. .. 8 ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ N '" 8 .!i' = I~ ! I~ Q Q 5:l ~ ~ ~ ... "' ~ ~ i:i <;- ~ '? ~ Z " ~ :1 ~ 0 "' .. "' .. <.J <.J <.J ~ Q .. Dry cleaning and laundrY nick.:uDStation p p p p p p p n;:;-cleanin;;;tant or commercial Iatuldrv- p p p Gasoline station, sublect to Sec. 36.2411 S P P P S General service establishment, not otherwise listed P p P P P P P in this table Janitorial services establishment p p Laundromat p p p P Lumber vani p p p Manufactured or mobile home sales p Motor vehicle rental establishment, without p p p p p p p inventory on-site Motor vehicle rental establishment, with inventory p p p S p P on-site Motor vehicle repair or service establishment, p p p p S subject to Sec. 36.2419 Motor vehicle sales and service establishment, p p New, subject to Sec. 36.2-420 Motor vehicle sales and service establishment, p p Used, subject to Sec. 36.2-421 Nursery or I!reenhouse, commercial p p p p p Personal service establishment, not otherwise p p p p S P listed in this table Pet grooming p p p p p p Recreational vehicle or boat sales P Retail sales establishment, not otherwise listed in p p p p p this table Storaoe buildino sales p p p Tattoo parlor S S S Asnhalt or concrete -nlant S Bakery, confectionary, or similar food production, p p p Wholesale Biosolids field S Building sunnlies and materials, Wholesale p p p p Commercial nrintino establishment p p p p p Composting facility S S S Contractor's shOD," HeavY construction p p Dairy products, processing, bottling, and wholesale p p p distribution Electrical component assembly, wholesale p p p p distribution Fuel oil distribution S p P Fuelino station, commercial or wholesale p p p p P Junk yard. subject to Sec. 36.2-414 S S Manufacturing: Beverage or food processing, excluding poultry and animal slaughtering and p p p dressing Zoning Ordlnenctl - City of Roan. 12105105 ...""", 6. Table 340-1. Use Matrb. kl} "I'r llll,m,., pllllllltld 1'" ot lll'hr h a pflllllpll U~l , ":- fllllll" )1111l111!ld III ~pll1I1lXll[1flrJll l' I J1111111J' Ii lhe \ 1>11111 \tllmllll' prolllbttcd lndlf "ACClS~()n ll~l~,"" \" mlan~ rLfmtttul;1,~ an alClS~Of} lhL, ";,' mlan~ rlflntttU! bl '1'( 11 d ~X(( ptl{ln I' III llll 'S1111 \1,.,(, and a him!. cd! mUlh prohllJlttd .t .,. I l ,t ,t ,t ,t . 'il ,t . il ~ ~ e e u c!i ~ Q e u; '" Q Q B '" . ol: 1l ~ il . a ~ '" "I .. ;0 .. ... ... ... u u .~ Il. u J/ .~ .~ .!f> ~ II' ~ .. Q u .~ . 0 1 'C .~ .~ .~ :Ii :Ii :Ii u ~ ,3 ] ~ ~ r z ] .. 011 oS Use '" :a ;; :3 Q ;0 ;; '" '" '" :a .J. . ~ ." ;; ;; :a ." . ! 1 .. .. . . . .~ .~ e ! ~ ~ u B 'S ." . ." ." u ~ . 'lI ~ ;0 Q .~ .. c . . u u u ] ! . u :;a :;a u e ~ ." :Ii ; u :;a ~ u u e .. e } :;a :;a :;a . . . e ~ ~ u B u ~ 'lI . Ol Ol ~ .a Q . u . ~ ~ Ol e ~ .~ ." Ol Q ~ Ol .. Ol - 8 ! u :Ii . ~ ~ Q "I '" iI: .ll '" !:I ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ S ;:i .. ~ ~ '"I Z 8 - N Z :il .. u u .. .. Q ~ Manufacturing: Chemical, refming or processing, including the manufacture, refining or processing of ammonia, bleach, bluing, calcimine, chlorine, corrosive acid or alkali, dyes, fats, fertilizer, gutta S percha, gypsum, lampblack, oils, oxygen, paints, plaster of Paris, potash, rubber, shellac, tar, turpentine, vinegar, yeast Manufacturing: Chemical, refining or processing, p p p not otherwise listed in this table Manufacturing: General, not otherwise listed in p p p p this table Manufacturing: Steel Of metal production, S p p S fabrication, or processing Manufacturing: Wood nrntIucts p Meat nacking and noultry processinsz S MiIlin2 or feed and flour mills S S S Motor vehicle or trailer painting and body repair, S S S P subject to Sec. 36.2-418 Quarrv S Rccyclinsz center, subject to Sec. 36.2-414 S S Tire recanping S Towing service, subiect to Sec. 36.2-430 p P Weldinll or machine shon p p p _sec. 36.2-4l4 S S Distribution center. not otherwise listed in this p p p p table Mini~warehouse, subiect to Sec. 36.2-415 p P P Storalle of commercial motor vehicles p p Storage ofmotor vehicles for rental (no on-site p p rental or leasing facility) Tank fann, petroleum bulk station and terminal, or S other above ground storage of flammable liquids Warehouse p p p P Adult uses, subject to Sec. 36.2-404 S Amphitheater p Amusement, commercial, indoor S p P P S Amusement, commercial, outdoor p p P Botanical Rarden or arboretum p p p P Club, lodge, civic, or social organization S p p p S p p Zon,"; Ordln.nce . City of RoIWloke 12105105 MloIo . 61 T.ble 340-1. Use M.trb: kLl lip r mll!l~ 11lflll1tt,J 1~ ul flt'IH l~ 1 pnllu)lalu'l. n;-." I1ll111~ l'lflll1l1lJ III ~llll1d lHlptl<!Il h 11'11I1(1j'1111 , \111[11 tllJllltlll rrolllultcd llndlrII \lClSS()1\ 1 Sl<t"\"nl(;\ll~rlrl111tllJballalt(~sOfllJ~l.";-."mLMbplfmlltldll\ ~1'((111(\((J1t1'l!11' 1I111((~,OI\ (l';,. and a bl1nk ((1\ 1Tl, lib prnhlhl1lJ .t to 8 . 6' .. f f f a . 6' 1 i! ! u ~ -e .~ Q ~ ~ !l Q a "' .:: .:: i! '" . 'il .. '1 'li .. e> ~ ~ .. .. .. u u !!. u u .r .lI .~ .~ .. .!if ~ 'S 0 ! '" Q .. .r .r .r :ll :ll :ll Z u ~ ] ~ 1 ~ Use f '" ~ ] .. oil .lI :a "' '" '" ;; :a :a .; .. S Q . t ] :a :a ;; 'C .. 1 .. 'C . . . 'e ~ ~ ; 11 K .8 ~ a 'C . u ~ u u ] j P Q 'C . :9 . . . :'0 u u e ~ . . . u u u u :'0 S S ] ~ } .!i . :'0 :'0 :'0 :'0 . . . e 5' a ~ ] . ~ u u ~ S .ll Q . ~ ~ . ~ '" . 'C Q u ~ '" (3 '" .!if u I; ~ ~ ~ ~ N "' :I: ~ ~ 5:l ~ ~ ~ '" ~ 9 ':' ~ "1 ~ 5 S ~ ::t .. '" '" '" . Q ~ Communitv center P P P P P P P P Eatinn establishment P P P P P P P P P Eating and drinking establishment, not abutting a p p p p p S residential district Eating and drinking establishment, abutting a S S S S S residential district Entertainment establishment, abutting a residential S S S S S district Entertainment establishment, not abutting a S p P P S residential district Exhibition, convention, or conference center P P Gamino establishment S S S G<Kart track S Golfcourse P p Health and timess center p p p p p p Meeti;;- hall S P P P P Paint ball faci~ outdoor S Park or playgrOlmd p p p p p Place of worshin p p p p p p p Recreation, indoor P P P P P Re<:reation, outdoor P P P Sports stadium, arena, or coliseum P S Theater, movie orner:fonniR2 arts p P P P Zoo P ~uarium or-;;Ianetarium p p Artist studio P P P P P P Cemeterv p Communitv food nneration P p Communitv Darden P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P Dav care center, Adult P P P P P P P P Day care center, Child, subject to Set. 36.2-408 P P P P S P P p OIW care home, Child p P P P P P P P P P P P P Educational facilities, Business school or non- p p p p p S p p p p p industrial trade school Educational facilities, CoU.....e / universitv p P P P Educational facilities, p p p p p Elementary/middle/secondary Educational facilities, Industrial trade school P p P P Educational facilities, School for the arts P P P P S P P P Fire, nolice, or emeroen"" services S S S S S S S P P P P P P P P P Government offices or other government facility, p p p p p p p p p p not otherwise listed in this table Hosnital p p Library P P P P P P P P Milit<ol"\l reserve or National Guard center p p p P Museum P P P P P P P Zoning Ordln.n~ - City of RoIInob 12105105 Artlc1li3 82 Table 340-1. Use Matrix ktl nJl" 1TIlln__ pl rnllttlll ,I' III ngh! ,I' a pnlllll',t111~l , ";-." (J\l,L11~ pll1ll1ttl d hI Sp( t I II t Xl t I'tHlll l' 1 1'111]( 1]' 1111 (. \]']111] ullllll111 prohlbltlJ l'nlkr" \CClSS(lf\ I __( s," ",\" mLlns plnnlltul ,ts.l11 :lCCcsson llSl, ":-;" nIL ,Ill" P( nnltrl d hI SP\ U 11 (\l( ]JIlIlll 1,:111 lU< "'(l1\ lN, ami a bllllk nll ffi< llhprohlhlltd ~ ~ 1 ~ .., ~ f .. 'il ~ i . i! a 's a " c!i ~ . l'l a ~ in '" l'l l'l i "' . ol: .. j i! . . ;, .Ii "' "' .. j ~ .Ii .Ii .Ii " " u K. " .. u If .~ .~ . .!t' ~ 'S 0 l ;; l'l 'C .11' .11' .11' :ll :ll :ll ~ c:s ;; " ;, ~ in ] .~ . . Use 'S oil .li ;, .. '" '" '" ] ] ] .... .... l'l .8 ;; ] ] ] ., ., ., = " ;; .8 ~ '2 ] . 'C . . . ~ ~ ~ = ] . . a 'C . " I ;, .~ 'C . " . . . :9 :l2 .lj " " " ] I . = " :l2 " " :9 a a a '2 ~ } :ll .! :l2 :l2 . . .. ~ ~ ] :l2 . 01 " 01 a ~ .. .~ u I~ . 01 . . . .. " l'l 01 01 01 01 <3 ! :li ~ = .. - "I ~ ~ l'l s:l ~ '" ~ ~ d l'l - '" Is ;, ~ .. .. .. ~ z C> - :l z 0 ~ .. u u - l'l .. - Post Office p p p p p p p p P Su""lv Dantrv P P P P Training facility for police, fire, or emergency p p S p p P services Airport or airport~related commercial and personal p service uses Bus maintenance, includina repair and storaae P P P Bus passenaer tenninal or station P S Limousine service p p p p p Motor freiRht tenninal or truck tenninal p p p p Parkina lot facility S S P Parking structure facility, subject to Sec. 36.2-426 P Railroad freight yard, repair shop, and marshalling p lyard IRailroad O8SSemler terminal or station P ITaxicab business p P P P Broadcastina studio or station P P P P P P Broadcastina tower, subiect to Sec, 36,2-432 S S S S S Hazardous materials facility S S S Utility distribution or collection, Basic P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P Utility distribution or collection, Transitional S S S S S S S S S P P P P P S P P P S P P Utilitv tiZeneration or treatment P Utilitv maintenance and service facility P P P Wireless telecommunications facility, subject to S S S S S S S S S S S S p S S S S S p p p Sec. 36.2-432 Wireless telecommunications facility, Stealth, p P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P subject to Sec. 36.2-432 A21icultural ooerations P Animal shelter p p p Stable, commercial, subiect to Sec. 36.2-428 p P Wildlife rescue shelter or refuge area p P Zoning Ordln~. City of Roanoke 12105105 ArtIc'-3 63 Supplemental Regulations 36.2-400 Purpose The regulations of this Article are intended to supplement the applicable zoning district regulations and the othet development smndards of this Chapter in a manuet that specifically addresses the unique development challenges of cetmin uses, facilities, and structures. 36.2-401 Applicability The supplemenmry regularions of this Article shall apply to the uses, structures, and facilities as set forth in this Article, shall apply in all zoning districts unless othetwise smted herein, and shall supplement the requirements of the applicable zoning district regulations and the othet applicable smndards of this Chapter. The supplemenmry regulations are applicable to new development, tedevelopment, or a change of use. (a) The standards listed as genetal standards shall apply in all zoning districts in which the use, structure, or facility is permitted by right or by special exception. (b) Whete a specific zoning district is indicated, the smndards listed shall apply to that zoning district, in addition to any genetal smndards listed for the use, structure, or facility. 36.2-402 Accessory Apartments In oroet that the single-family charactet of the property be mainmined and an accessory apartment remain subordinate to the principal single-family demched dwelling with which it is associated, such accessory apartments, whet< permitted by this Chaptet, shall be subject to the following standards: (a) An accessory apartment shall be located in a building that is accessory to, and is located on the same lor as, a single-family demched dwelling; (b) Only one accessory apartment shall be permitted on anyone (1) lo~ (c) An accessory building in which the accessory apartment is located shall not be separately meteted for utilities from the principal single-family demched dwelling; and (d) The accessory apartment shall not exceed four hundted (400) square feet of gross floor area devoted to the secondary residential use. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 64 Article 4 36.2-403 Accessory Uses and Structures (a) Applicability Principal uses which are allowed by right or by special exceprion may inchme accessory uses and structures as defined in this Chapter, provided such uses and structures are directly associated with and incidental to the principal pennitted use, and provided they are designed and located in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter. The suppletnenral regulations of this section shall apply, both generally and as specifically delineated within this section, to accessory uses and structures. (b) General standards (1) An accessory use shall not include the conduct of trade unless pennitted in conjuncrion with a pennitted use. (2) An accessory use shall be located on the same lot as the principal use which it serves. (3) An accessory structure shall not be used for human habimtion unless othetwise specifically pennitted in this Chapter. (4) An accessory structure in residential districts shall not be separately metered for utilities from the principal structure. (5) An accessory use shall be subject to the same screening and buffeting requirements of this Chapter as may apply to the principal use. (6) The cumulative square foomge of all accessory stmctures shall not exceed forty (40) percent of the gross floor area of the principal structure, provided that for purposes of such calculation, basement areas which are not considered a story above grade plane, as defined and determined by the Virginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code, and unfinished attics shall not be included in the gross floor area of the principal structure. (J) In any residential zoning district, a manufactured home, mobile horne, trailer, camper, or motor vehicle, or portion thereof, shall not be used as an accessory structure for the purpose of storage or for any other accessory use. (c) Setbacks and spacing standards, general Except for fences, walls, or outdoor light support structures, or as otherwise provided in this section, the following setback and spacing requirements shall apply to accessory structures: (1) Accessory structures shall be located no closer than five (5) feet to a rear or side lot line, except as provided in subsection (f), below. (2) Accessory structures shall be located no closer to any public street than the principal building, except as set forth in (A) and (B) below. (A) In the case of any comer lot with more than two (2) street fronmges or any through lot, such requirement shall apply to only one (1) public street, provided no accessory structure shall be located closer than five (5) feet to any such lot line abutting a public street; or (B) In the case of any comer lot with two (2) street fronmges, such requirement shall not apply to a second front yard, provided no accessory structure shall be located closer than five (5) feet to such front lot line. (3) Accessory structures shall be located no closer than six (6) feet to a principal structure or anothet accessory structure. Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 65 Article 4 (d) Amateur radio towers and antennas Amateur radio toWetS and antennas shall be pennilled by right as accessory structures in all zoning districts, subject to the following supplemental regulations: (1) Amateur radio towers and anteonas shall not be subject to the masimum height regulations of the applicable zoning district, provided that in no case shall they exceed a height of seventy-five \15) feet above ground level; (2) Amateur radio toWetS and anteonas shall comply with the yard requirements of the principal building; and such yard requirements shall apply to any guy wire supports as well as the radio tower and antenna; (3) Amateur radio towetS and antennas, including any guy wires, shall be located no closer to the public street on which the principal building fronts than the principal building; and (4) Amateur radio tOWetS and antennas shall be dismantled and removed from the site within one hundted eighty (180) calendar days of the toWet no longet being used. (e) Dumpsters or refuse containers Whete dumpsters or refuse conminers for non-residential uses are located on a lot which abuts a residentially zoned lot, such conminetS shall be located no closer than fifteen (15) feet to the abutting residentially zoned lot (f) Garages or carports, detached Minimum setbacks for demched garages or ca<ports shall conform to subsection (c), above, except that the minimum setback requirement from a lot line abutting an improved alley shall be three (3) feet (g) Outdoor recreation facility lighting or sports stadium lighting Lighting for outdoor recreation facilities or sports smdiums, as pennitted by this Chapter, shall not be subject to the masimum height regulation of the applicable zoning district The location, height, and aiming cutoff angles of light emissions for such lighting systems shall be esmblisbed by special exception granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals. In addition to the smndards set forth in Section 36.2-S60(c), the Board of Zoning Appeals shall determine the appropriateoess of such application for special exception for outdoor recreation facility or sports stadium lighting based on the following smndards: (1) The lighting system minimizes the projection of light and glare beyond the propetty lines; (2) The mounting height of the lighting fixtures is appropriate to the application; (3) The light fixtures utilize intemal or extemal shields, 10UVetS, or similar devices to minimize the component of light above honzonral when luminaries need to be tilted or aimed; (4) The mounting heights, spacing of poles, and aiming angles are designed to provide wUform illuminance as may be required for the safety of the participants on the field or court, while minimizing ref1ected light beyond the property; and (5) The mounting heights and aiming angles reduce glare in an adjacent, unintended, field of view and minimize light trespass beyond the property lines. (h) Parking structures Parking structures may be located closer to the street than the principal building, but shall not be located in the required front yard. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 66 Article 4 (i) Recycling collection points Recycling collection points, wbere permitted as accessoty uses by this Chaptet, shall be subject to the following suppletnental regulations: (1) Whete recepmcles for recyclable materials are located outside of a building, they shall be located so as not to dismpt or interfete with on-site traffic cittulation, requited fire lanes or requited parking, or requited loading or stacking spaces. (2) A specific cittulation pattetn shall be esmblisbed to provide safe and easy access to recycling recepmcles. Adequate space shall be provided for the unloading of recyclable materials. (3) Whete recepmcles for recyclable materials are located outside of a building, they shall be screened from view from any abutting residentially zoned lot by the provision of a buffet yard as set forth in Secrion 36.2-647(c). (i) Stables, private Private smbles, whet< permitted by this Chapter, shall require a minimum lot area of two (2) acres for each horse in the smble. (k) Swimming pools and tennis courts Swimnting pools and tennis courts shall comply with the setbacks and spacing requirements for accessory structures as set forth in subsection (c) above. 36.2-404 Adult Uses (a) Applicability In any district in which an adult use is pennitted, if such use constitutes an "adult use" as defined in this section, the minimum requirements and smndards set out in this section shall apply to such use. (b) Definitions In this section, unless the context otherwise requires, the following words and teans are defined as set out below: Adult bookstore: An esmblishment that devotes more than fifteen (15) percent of the total floor area utilized for the display of books and periodicals to the display and sale of the following: (a) books, magazines, periodicals or othet printed matter, or photographs, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, slides, tapes, records, or other forms of visual or audio represenmrions which are characterized by an etnpbasis upon the depiction or description of "specified sexua1 activities" or "specified anatomical areas;" or (b) instruments, devices, or paraphernalia which are designed for use in connection with "specified sexual activities." An adult bookstore does not include an establishment that sells books or periodicals as an incidental or accessory part of its principal stock-in-trade and does not devote more than fifteen (15) percent of the total floor area of the establisbmentto the sale of books and periodicals. Adult use, Any adult bookstore, adult motion picture theatre, adult mini-motion picture theatre, adult motion picture arcade, adult model studio, adult drive-in theatre, or massage parlor, as defined in this subsection. Adult motion picture theatre: An esmblisbment, with a capacity of fifty (50) or more persons, whete, for any form of consideration, films, morion pictures, video cassettes, slides, or similar photographic reproducrions are shown; and in which a subsmnrial potrion of the toral presenmtion rime is devoted to the showing of material which is distinguished or characterized by an etnphasis upon the depiction or description of "specified sexua1 activities" or "specified anatomical areas" for observation by patrons. Adult mini-motion picture theatre: An esmblisbment, with a capacity of more than five (5) but less than fifty (SO) petsons, where, for any fonn of consideration, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, slides, or similar photographic reproducrions are shown, and in which a subsmnrial portion of the toral presenmtion rime is devoted to the showing of Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 67 Article 4 material which is distinguished or characterized by an etnphasis upon the depiction or description of "specified sexual activities" or "specified anatomical areas" for observation by patrons. Adult motion picture ateade: Any place to which the public is pennirted or invited whete coin or slug-operated or electronically, electrically, or mechanically controlled still or motion picture machines, projectors, or other image producing devices are mainmined to show images to five (5) or fewet persons pet machine at any one (1) time, and whete the images so displayed are distinguished or characterized by an etnpbasis on depicting or describing "specified sexual activities" or specified "anatomical areas." Adult drive-in-theatre: An open lot or part theteof, with appurtenant facilities, devoted primarily to the presenmtion of motion pictures, films, theatrical productions, and other forms of visual productions, for any form of consideration, to persons in motor vehicles or on outdoor seats, and presenting material distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on matter depicting, describing or relating to "specific sexual activities" or "specified anatomical areas" for observarion by patrons. Adult model studio: Any esmblishment open to the public where, for any form of consideration of gratuity, figure models who display "specified anatomical areas" are provided to be observed, sketched, drawn, painted, sculptured, photographed, or similady depicted by persons, othet than the proprietor, paying such consideration or gratuity. This provision shall not apply to any school of art which is opetated by an individual, 6nn, association, partnership, corporation, or institution which meets the requirements esmblished in the Code ofVttginia (1950), as amended, for the issuance or conferring ot: and is in fact authorized thereunder to issue and confer, a diploma. Massage parlor: Any esmblisbment defined as a massage pador by Section 21-135 of this Code. Specified anatomical areas: (a) Less than completely and opaquely coveted: (1) Human genitals, pubic region, (2) buttock, and (3) female breast below a point immediately above the top of the areola; and (b) Human male genitals in a discernibly turgid smte, even if completely and opaquely cOVeted. Specified scxual acriviries: (a) Human genitals in a smte of sexual stimulation or arousal; (b) Acts of human masturbation, sexual intetCourse, or sodomy; and (c) Fondling or other erotic touching of human genitals, pubic region, buttock, or fetnale breast (c) (1) Requirements and standards No adult use may be esmblished within one thousand (1,000) feet of any othet such adult use in any zorting district. (2) No adult use may be esmblished within five hundted (500) feet of a residentially zoned district, or a schoo~ educational institution, place of worship, public park, playground, playfield, or day care center. (3) The "esmblisbment" of an adult use as refetted to in this section includes the opening of such business as a new business, the relocation of such business, the enlargement of such business in either scope or area, or the convetSion, in whole or part, of an existing business to any adult use. 36.2-405 Bed and breakfast (a) Applicability The suppletnental regulations set out in this secrion shall apply to bed and breakfast esmblisbments pennitted by this Chapter as of right or by special exception. (b) Location requirements In any zoning district in which bed and breakfast esmblisbments are pennitted, such esmblisbments shall meet the foDowing location requirements: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 68 Article 4 (1) The bed and breakfast esmblishment shall be located within a single-family demched dwelling that existed at the rime this Chaptet was adopted (2) The bed and breakfast esmblishment shall not be located closer than five hundred (500) feet to any othet bed and breakfast esmblisbment whete the esmblisbment is petmitted by special exceprion. The applicant shall provide a scaled map of the lot lines for the subject property and the lot lines for the nearest bed and breakfast esmblisbment as part of any application for a special exception, development plan approvol, or zoning petmit (c) (1) General standards No exterior changes to the single-fumily demched dwelling occupied by the bed and breakfast shall be petmitted unless such change is requited by the Zoning Administrator for safety purposes or such change can be shown to be in harmony with the structure's architectural and historic value. (2) The owner of the single-fumily demched dwelling occupied by the bed and breakfast esmblisbment shall reside in the dwelling. (3) No more than sis (6) guest sleeping rooms shall be utilized for a bed and breakfast esmblisbment and the number of guest occupants shall not exceed twelve (12). (4) Rooms shall be rented only on a daily basis. (5) One (1) sign attached to the building shall be petmitted. Such sign shall have a sign area not exceeding two (2) square feet and shall not be illuminated. (6) Only accessory uses or structures wbich are incidental and subordinate to a single-family demched dwelling shall be petmitted in conjunction with a bed and breakfast esmblisbment 36.2-406 Car Wash (a) Applicability The suppletnental regulations of this section shall apply to any car wash permitted by this Chapter, by right or by special exception. (b) (1) Standards When abutting a residenrially zoned lot, a buffer yard shall be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (2) Smoking spaces and smcking lanes shall be subject to the requirements of Sec. 36.2-409, Drive-through Facilities. 36.2-407 Commercial Motor Vehicle Sales and Service, New or Used Application for a zoning pennit for a new or used commercial motor vehicle sales and service establiShment shall require that the applicant submit a basic or comprehensive development plan in compliance with the following suppletnental regulations: (a) A landscaping strip of a minimum depth of eight (8) feet shall be provided along any adjacent public street right-of-way and shall be subject to the following requirements: (1) A minimum of one (1) evergreen or deciduous shrub, spaced at a rate of no greater than three (3) feet on center and with a minimum height at planting of twenty-four (24) inches, sbal1 be planted in the requited landscaping strip; and Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 69 ArtIcle 4 (2) The storage or display of motor vehicles within, upon, or in a manuet which ovethangs any potrion of the required landscaping strip shall be probibited. (b) Any display area in conjunction with commero.J motor vehicle sales shall be limited to improved surfaces and shall be subject to the same construction smndards set forth for off-street parking areas in Section 36.2-654(b). Undet no circumsmnces shall a display area be located closer than five (5) feet to a side or rear property line. (c) When abutting a residentially zoned lot, a buffet yard shall be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (d) A new or used commero.J motor vehicle sales and service esmblisbment shall require a minimum lot area of twenty thousand (20,000) square feet designated for such use. 36.2-408 Day Care Centers, Child (a) Applicability The supplemental regulations set out in this section shall apply to child day care centetS whete permitted by this Chapter. (b) (1) Standards Floor area pet child: All child day care centers shall provide a minimum of thirty-five (35) square feet of designated common floor area per child, for the total number of children to be accommodated at such day care center. The designated common floor area shall consist only of those areas in which children sleep, eat, receive instruction, or play, and shall not include offices, hallways, restrooms, kitchen areas, closets, or other storage areas. (2) Outdoor play area: All child day care centers permitted by this Chapter, except such centetS in the CN, CG, and D Districts, shall provide outdoor play areas for children to be accommodated at such day care centers in accordance with the following smndards: (A) A minimum of seventy-five (75) square feet of outdoor play area per child, for the total numbet of children to be accommodated at such day care center, shall be provided; (B) The outdoor play area shall be located on the same lot as the day care center and shall be located no closer to any street than the main building occupied by the day care center; and (C) The outdoor play area shall be fenced to provide a safe enclosure, and pedestrian access to such outdoor play area shall not require the crossing of any vehicular right-of-way. 36.2-409 Drive-through Facilities (a) Purpose The following smndards for drive-through facilities are inteoded to allow for such facilities in a manuet that promotes public safety and efficient operation by addressing their unique cbal1enges, such as the siting of the building, high volumes of ttaffic, vehicular access, and on-site circulation. The specific purposes of this section are to: (1) Minimize the negative impact of drive-through facilities created by additional ttaffic hazards from motor vehicles entering and exiting the site; (2) Promote safet and more efficient on-site vebicular and pedestrian circulation; (3) Reduce conflicts between queued motor vehicles and ttaffic on adjacent streets; and Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 70 Article 4 (4) Minimize the negative impacts drive-through facilities create on abutring residential properties. (b) Applicability The suppletnental regulations of this section shall apply to any drive-through facility as permitted by this Olapter. (c) Definitions For the purposes of this section, the following words and terms are defined as set forth below: Access: A way or means of approach to provide inotor vehicle or pedestrian entrance to or exit from a property. Access connection: Any driveway, street, curb cut, tumout, or other means of providing for the movement of motor vehicles to or from the public street network. Stacking lane, An area of stacking spaces and driving lane provided for motor vehicles waiting for drive-through service that is physically separated from othet motor vehicle and pedestrian citculation on the site. stacking space' An area within a smcking lane for a motor vehicle waiting to oroet or finish a drive-through transaction. (d) (1) Standards Drive-through facilities shall provide a minimum number of smcking spaces on site in acconlance with the smndards below: Use with which Drive-Though Minimum Number of Facility is Aooociared Stacking Spaces Requited per Suckiluz Lane Earin2 esmblisbment 5 Financial institution 3 Car wash, self-service 1 Car wash, automated 5 Drive-thro~ kiosk 2 Others not 5 listed 2 (2) Each stacking space shall be a minimum of twenty (20) feet in length and teo (10) feet in width along straight portions. Smcking spaces and stacking lanes shall be a minimum of twelve (12) feet in width along curved segments. (3) The minimum dismnce to any access connection for the site from the centerline of the final ttansaction window shall be forty (40) feet. (4) Smcking lanes shall be cleady identified and delineated from ttaffic aisles and parking areas by means of striping, curbing, landscaping, or the use of alternative paving materials or raised medians. (5) Entrances to smcking lanes shall be cleady marked and shall be located at a minimum of forty (40) feet from the intetS<ction with the public street The dismnce shall be measured from the property line along the street to the begimting of the entrance. The entrance into the drive-through lanes shall not conflict with genetal access to the site. (6) Smcking lanes shall be designed so that they do not interfere with citcularion both on site and on adjacent public streets. Toward that purpose, smcking lanes shall be designed so they: (A) Do not impede or impair access into or out of parking spaces; (B) Do not impede or impair motor vehicle or pedestrian ttaffic movetnen~ Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 71 Article 4 (C) Minimize conflicts between pedestrian and motor vehicular ttaflic with physical and visual separarion between the two; and (I)) Do not intetfere with requited loading and ttasb storage areas, and loading or ttasb operarions shall not impede or impair motor vehicle moVetUent If separate smoking is curbed, an etnergency by-pass or exit shall be provided. (J) Smoking lanes shall not enter or exit direcdy from or into a public right-of-way. (8) The intersection of smoking lanes and walk-in customer access shall be a minimum of twenty (20) feet from any access connections and transaction windows. Such intersections shall be provided with a crosswalk. that uses alternative paving and striping and includes warning signage aimed at both the pedestrian and motor vehicle. IJ) SpeaketS shall be located at least fifty (SO) feet from the property line of any residentially zoned property. (10) Menu boards, which shall not count toward freesmnding sigo allocations set forth in Atricle 6, Division 6, shall be a maximum of fifty (50) square feet, with a maximum height of eight (8) feet 36.2-410 Fences and Walls (a) Applicability Fences and walls shall be subject to the supplemental regulations of this section. For the putpose of this section, ''walls'' shall include decorative walls and walls inteoded as a buffet or screen. The supplemental regulations of this section shall not apply to remining walls. (b) (1) Standards No fence or wall that exceeds a height of thirty (30) inches from graded ground level shall be permitted within a sight dismnce triangle. (2) No fence located in an area as set forth in (A) and (B) below shall be a solid fence, unless otherwise requited by this Chapter. Lattice, open wire, or any othet fence type with fifty (SO) percent or more open area shall be permitted (A) On a lot with only one (1) lot fronrage: Between the building line and the lot fronrage; or (B) On . lot with more than one (1) lot fronrage: Between the building line on which the principal entrance to the building is situated and the lot fronrage which it faces. (3) The maximum height for fences and walls shall be based on the following schedule: Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 72 Article 4 Zoning District Location on Lot Maximum Height ofFence or Wall On a lot with only one (1) lot fronmge: between the building line and the lot fronmge; or On a lot with more than one (1) lot fronmge: 3 feet between the building line on which the principal entrance to the building is situated and the lot RA, R-l2, R-7, R-S, fronla2e which it faces R-3,RM-l,RM-2, On a lot with more than one (1) lot fronmge: RMF, IN, MX, between any building line on which the principal 6 feet MXPUD entrance to the building is not situated and the lot fronmge which that building line faces 6 feet, except whete one of these districts abuts a D, Any requited side or rear yard ROS, CN, CG, CLS, 1-1, 1-2, lPUD, INPUD, or AD District, maximum height shall be that of the abutting district along that abutting property line D, ROS, CN, CG, Any requited yard 8 feet CLS, INPUD 1-1,1-2, IPUD,AD Any requited yard 10 feet 36.2-411 Gasoline Stations (a) Purpose This section reconciles the interests of the City and residential neighborhoods relating to health, safety, traffic, and property values, with the economic interests and public needs relating to gasoline smrions. This secrion addresses these concerns by esmblisbing smndards for canopies 0Vet the gas pump islands of any gasoline smtion and the buffeting of residential districts. (b) Applicability This section shall apply to any gasoline station permitted by this Chapter. (c) General standard When abutting a residentially zoned lot, a buffer yard sball be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (d) Additional standards in the CG, CLS, and 1-1 Districts In addition to the genetal smndard set forth in subsection (c) above, any gasoline smtion located in the Conuneteial- Genetal District (CG), Commetcial-Large Site District (CIS), or Light Industrial District (1-1), shall be subject to the following smndards for any canopy OVet a gas pump island: (1) Such canopy sball have a maximum clear, unobstructed height to its underside not to exceed fourteen (14) feet six (6) inches and a maximum overall height not to exceed sixteen (16) feet six (6) inches; (2) There shall be no illumination of any potrion of the fascia of the canopy; (3) Any lighting fixtures or sources of light thar are a part of the undetSide of the canopy sball be recessed into the undetSide of the canopy so as not to protrude below the canopy ceiling. All such lighting associated with the canopy shall be directed downward toward the pump islands and sball not be directed outwaId or away from the site. (4) The vertical dimension of the fascia of such canopy shall be no more than two (2) feet and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 73 Article 4 (5) Signs attached to or on such canopy shall not be illuminated and shall not extend beyond the ends or extremities of the fascia of the canopy to which or on which they are attached. (e) Additional standards in the eN and D Districts In addition to the genetal smndard set forth in subsecrion (c) above, any gasoline smrion located in the Commercial- Neighborhood District (CN) or Downtown District (I)), shall be subject to the following smndards: (1) Any canopy oVet a gas pump island shall be subject to the following smndards: (A) Such canopy shall have a maximum clear, unobstructed height to its undetside not to exceed fourteen (14) feet six (6) inches and a maximum overall height not to exceed sixteen (16) feet six (6) inches; (B) There shall be no illumination of any portion of the fascia of the canopy; (C) Any lighting futtures or sources of light that are a part of the underside of the canopy shall be recessed into the undetside of the canopy so as not to protturle below the canopy ceiling. All such lighting associated with the canopy shall be directed downward toward the pump islands and shall not be directed outward or away from the site; (I)) The Vettical dimension of the fascia of such canopy shall be no more than two (2) feel; (E) No sign shall be attached to or on such canopy; and (F) Such canopy shall be set back a minimum of ten (10) feet from the street (2) In the CN District, no more than four (4) fuel dispensing pumps shall be located on site. (3) In the CN District, fuel dispensers shall be located at least fifty (SO) feet from the property line of any abutting residentially zoned lot 36.2-412 Group Care Facilities (a) Purpose The inteot of the regulations of this section is to permit the development of group care facilities in appropriate locations throughout the City, to ensure compatibility of these uses within the neighborhoods in which they are located, and to esmblisb smndards to encourage an adequate quality of service to the users of such facilities. (b) Applicability The supplemental regulations of this section shall apply to any group care facility petmitted by this Chaptet. (c) (1) Standards No group care facility shall be located closer than one thousand five hundted (1,500) feet to anothet group care facility. This spacing requirement shall apply to any group care facility on a separate lot, regardless of whethet or not the group care facilities are under common ownetSbip, except that such spacing requirement shall not apply to a group care facility in an Institutional Planned Unit Development (INPUD). The applicant shall provide a sealed map of the lot lines for the subject property and the lothnes for the nearest group care facility as part of any applicarion for a special exception, development plan approval, or a zoning petmit (2) The maximum numbet of occupants of a group care facility, including supervisory p=onnel and fami1y members living on the premises, shall be based on the following schedule: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 74 Article 4 Zoning District Square footage of facility required per occupant RM-2 800 RMF 500 MX 400 INPUD, MXPUD 300 (3) A group care facility shall provide one hundted (1 (0) square feet of usable open space per occupant (4) If thete is no buffer yard otherwise requited by Section 36.2-647(c), on-site parking and exterior activity areas for a group care facility shall be screened from adjoining properties by a minimum Category "A" buffer yard as prescribed in Section 36.2-647(b). 36.2-413 Home Occupations (a) Purpose The purposes of the home occupation supplemental regulations and performance smndards of this section are to: (1) Esmblish criteria for the operation of home occuparions in dwelling units; (2) Pennit and regulate the conduct of home occupations as an accessory use in a dwelling unit, whethet owner or rentet-occupied; (3) Ensure that such horne occupations are compatible with, and do not have a deleterious effect on, adjacent and nearby residential propetties and uses; (4) Ensure that public and private services such as streets, sewer, water, or utility systems are not burdened by the home occupation to the extent that usage exceeds that normally associated with residential use; (5) Allow residents of the community to use their residences as places to enhance or fuUill personal economic goals undet cetmin specified smndards, conditions, and criteria; (6) Enable the fair and consistent enforcement of these home occupation regulations; and !J) Promote and protect the public health, safety, and genetal welfare. (b) Applicability Regulations of this section shall apply to all home occuparions in any zoning district in which they are permitted as of right or by special exception. No home occupation, unless othetwise provided in this section, may be initiated, esmblished, or mainmined except in conformance with the regulations and performance smndards set forth in this section. (c) Prohibited home occupations The following uses shall be specifically excluded as home occupations or personal service home occupations: motor vehicle repair or service; appliance repair, machine shop, welding shop, escort service, Iandseape or lawn service operation, and contractor's or subcontractor's office or storage yard. (d) General standards for all home occupations Any home occupation, including a personal service home occupation, shall be subordinate and incidental in both character and scale to the use of a dwelling unit for residential purposes. Home occupations shall not compromise the residential character of an area, shall not generate conspicuous traffic, shall not visually call Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 75 Article 4 unusual attention to the home, and shall not generate noise of a nonresidential level. There shall be no limit to the number of home occupations permitted per dwelling unit, provided that any home occupation, including a personal service home occupation, shall be subject to all of the following standards: (1) The home occupation shall be conducted entirely within the interior of the principal residential structure or within an accessory structure located on the same lot. (2) There shall be no change in the outside residential appearance of any structure for the purpose of the esmblisbment of the home occupation. (3) Thete shall be no addition of parking spaces to accommodate the home occupation. (4) Home occupations shall not occopy more than a cumulative total of two hundred fifty (250) squsre feet of the finished floor area of any dwelling unit or accessory structure in which the home occupations are located. (5) There shall be no outdoor storage of goods, products, equipment, or othet materials associated with the home occupation. (6) Thete shall be no display of goods, metChandise, or products visible from the stteel or any adjoining property. (I) No equipment or processes not nonnally associated with a dwelling unit or wbich cannot be accommodated on existing utility or smndard electrical services shall be permitted. (8) No commercial motor vehicle shall be used, parked, or stored on the site in connection with the home occupation. (9) Mechanized equipment shall be used only in a completely enclosed building. (10) No equipment or process wbich genetates dust, odors, noise, vibration, or electrical interference or fluctuarion that is detectable beyond the property line or through common walls shall be used in a home occupation. (11) Deliveries related to a home occupation shall be limited to the United SOltes Posral Service, parcel delivery services, and messenger seMces. The home occupation or personal service home occupation shall not involve the commercial delivery by ttactor lr.liler of materials or products to or from the premises. (12) A home occupation shall comply with all local, smte, or fedetal regularions petrinent to the activity pursued, and the requirements of or authorization granted by this Chapter shall not be construed as an exetnption from such regulations. (13) No sign may be placed on the property advettising the home occupation. (e) Specific standards for home occupations as permitted accessory uses Home occupations, except those defined as personal service home occupations, shall be permitted as accessory uses as set forth in the Use Matrix in Section 36.2-340, subject to the general smndards set forth in subsection (d), above, and the following additional standards: (1) No more than a total of one (1) person othet than family metnbers residing on the premises shall be engaged in or etnployed by such home occupations, regardIless of the numbet of home occupations associated with the dwelling unit; and (2) No customet or client shall travel to the dwelling in connection with the home occupation. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke 12/05105 76 Article 4 (f) Specific standards for personal service home occupations Any personal service home occupation permitted by this Chapter by special exceprion or as of right shall be subject to the general standards for home occupations as set forth in subsection (d), above, and the following additional standards: (1) No persons othet than family members residing on the premises shall be engaged in or employed by such p=onal service home occupation. (2) Not more than one (1) separate enttance or exit to the residence or accessory structure solely for the purpose of the p=onal service home occupation shall be permitted. The creation of any such separate enttance shall not be permitted on the front fa~ade of the residential dwelling. (3) The numbet of clients or custometS who may visit the personal service home occupation at any one rime may be esmblisbed by the Board of Zoning Appeals as a condition of the approval of a special exception. 36.2-414 Junk Yards, Wrecker Yards, and Recycling Centers (a) Purpose For the purpose of promoting the public safety, bealth, and we1fare and to protect public and private investment, the supplemental regulations of this section are intended to regulate and restrict the esmblisbment, opetation, and mainteoance of junk yards, wrecket yards, and recycling centers. (b) (1) Standards All junk yards and wrecker yards permitted by this Chapter shall comply with Section 33.1-348, Code of Vuginia (1950), as amended. (2) Junk yards, wrecket yards, and recycling centers esmblisbed or expanded after the effective date of this Chapter shall be located at least three hundred (300) feet from any residential zoning district or conforming residential use. (3) Any new junk yard, wrecket yard, or recycling center, and any subsmntial intensification of an existing junk yard, wrecker yard, or recycling center, shall require approval by special exception. For the purposes of regulating junk yards, wrecket yards, and recycling centetS, "subsmntial inteosificatiotf' shall mean the following: (A) Any gengrapbic expansion of the facility; or (B) The addition of any shredding, grinding, baling, or packing equipment for the handling of scrap or salvage materials, or the replacement of any existing shredding, grinding, baling, or packing equipment for the handling of scrap and salvage materials. (4) An application for a special exceprion for a junk yard, wrecket yard, or recycling center shall provide the following: (A) A vicinity plan; (B) A description of natural features, including streams, rivers, lakes, wetlands, and major topograpbical features, located within three hundred fifty (350) feet of the site; (C) A descriprion of the proposal and how it compares to land uses within three hundred fifty (350) feet of the site; (I)) A description of any potential environmenral hazard due to existing or proposed land uses, including soil, water, and air conmntioation; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 77 Artlcle 4 (E) A sound attenuation plan describing sources of sound and indicating conformance with all applicable sound and noise regulations; (F) A drainage plan for stormwater tna1llIl\flI1ent and runoff; and (G) A traffic plan describing the numbet of truck trips the proposal will genetate and the principal access routes to the facility, including a description of the facility's traffic impact on the surrounding area. (5) No material shall be placed in a junk yard, wrecket yard, or recycling center in such a manner that it is capable of being transferred from the junk yard, wrecker yard, or recycling center by wind, water, or othet natural forces. The loose storage of paper and the spilling of flammable or othet liquids into streams or sewetS shall be probibited. (6) All materials shall be stored in such a manner as to prevent the breeding or harboring of rats, insects, or othet vermin. Where necessary, this shall be accomplished by enclosure in conminers, the raising of materials above the ground, separation of types of materials, preventing the collection of stagnant water, extennination procedures, or othet means. Professional monthly extenninating services shall be required, and a log indicating the dates and findings of such professional services shall be mainmined on the premises. (T) A junk yard, wrecker yard, or recycling center shall require a Category "E," Oprion 1, buffer yard, as defined in Secrion 36.2-647(b), along the perimeter of the lot (8) In addition to the requirements of subsecrions (1) through (T) above, a wrecket yard shall be subject to the following additional smndards: (A) The lot area shall conmin a minimum of twenty thousand (20,000) square fee~ (B) Thete shall be no storage of a damaged or inoperative motor vehicle or trailer outside a wholly enclosed building for more than one hundred twenty (120) calendar days, unless documenmtion satisfactory to the Zoning Administrator is provided that such a damaged or inopetative motor vebicle or trailet is the subject of an on-going law enforcement or insurance investigation or is the subject of a proceeding being pursued as expeditiously as possible by the wrecker service pursuant to Section 43-34 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended; and (q Any parts removed from a damaged or inoperative motor vehicle or trailer shall be stored within a wholly enclosed building. 36.2-415 Mini-warehouses (a) Purpose This purpose of this section is to esmblisb screening, landscaping, layout, height, and bulk smndards for mini- warehouses. (b) Standards Whete permitted by this Chapter, mini-warehouses shall comply with the following smndards: (1) A development plan shall be submitted to the Zoning Administtator indicating the location, orienmtion, and size of buildings, lot area, number and size of storage units, type and size of signs, height of buildings, parking layout with points of ingress and egress, and location and type of visual screening and landscaping. (2) When abuning a residentially zoned lot, a minimum Category "E" buffer yard, as defined in Section 36.2- 647(b), shall be installed along the applicable abuningproperty lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (3) The floor area of any storage unit or cubicle shall not exceed four hundred (400) square feet Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 78 Article 4 (4) The maximum length of any single building housing such individual storage units or cubicles shall be two hundred (200) feet (5) All storage shall be within a completely enclosed building. The outdoor storage of inventory, materials, vehicles, or metehandise shall be probibited. (6) The dismnce between mini-warehouse structures shall be a minimum of twenty (20) feet Whete vehicular circulation lanes and parking and loading spaces are to be provided between structures, the minimum separation dismnce shall be increased accordingly in order to ensure vehicular and pedestrian safety and adequate emergency access. (7) No activities such as the sale, repair, fabrication, or selVicing of goods, motor vehicles, appliances, equipment, or materials shall be conducted from mini-warehouse units. (8) The storage of explosive, flammable, or hazardous materials shall be prohibited. 36.2-416 Mixed Use Buildings and Live-Work Units (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to esmblisb smndards for densities and distribution of uses in mixed-use buildings and live-work units in a manner that provides for innovative, mixed use developments in compliance with the policies of the City's Comprehensive Plan. (b) Mixed-use buildings and live-work units Mixed-use buildings and live-work units, as permitted by this Chapter, shall comply with the following smndards: ..........". ................. ,,"_n .......... ...n..................... Ii Development Mixed-Use Building Live-Work Units Standards _m.. ._.......,._.~ I, .____.__ ................._........m.._................."............................_...._" ...... .~l:a~~~~~~~:~:~~;~.I! (m-Location crit~ri~ Where permitted by the Use Matrix of the aoolicable zonin" district ......".n...-.".. ._n. ............ ..m_...'''''.."......''.........._........ ................ .....0...... ...-..........."....--. ..-........... ...... Types of land uses Residential dwelling units; Uses pennitted ! Residential dwelling unitsj Uses ; allowed in the applicable zoning district permirted in the applicable zoning I I I district Permirted density or No density restrictions apply. The See subsection (c), below. The intensity building is subject to the dimensional building is subject to the requirements of the Dimensional Matrix dimensional requirements of the , , for the applicable zoning district. Dimensional Matrix for the ; , aonlicable zoniru> district. , ['''''Distribution of uses by ..... r" " ~.. .........]1 ..m......". II I ! floor: . Uses pennitted on Nonresidential uses permitted in the Nonresidential uses permitted in the first floor applicable zoning district I applicable zoning district I (Residential uses may be located to I the rear of the orincioai buildin".) I , ...-.... ... ..........--.. ........-..................... ............-..-. . Uses pennitted on I Residential dwelling units; Uses permitted . r"'~sidential dwelling units; Uses , second floor in the applicable zoning district permitted in the applicable zoning , district , ....------...... .............._-_._---...-.. ....... ..--~-----~ -.... ..---..........- m........__...._.... ........ . Uses permitted Residential dwelling unitsj Professional or Residential dwelling units; Uses I above second floor I general offices , permirted in the applicable zoning , district , - - -- .- - - Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 79 Article 4 (c) Mix of uses and density for live-work units Where live-work units are permitted by this Chaptet, live-work units shall comply with the following residential density and ratio of uses standatds: r r- , Maximum Density (minimum lot area required pet dwe' unit 2,400 square feet II 1,800~;"re fe~t---ll 1:1 2:1 -iI ._._.._.....~ 36.2-417 Mobile Homes (a) Applicability This section applies to mobile homes on individual lots, whete permitted by this Chapter. (b) Standards No mobile home shall be erected, installed, occupied, or sold in the City, except in accordance with the foUowing: (1) A mobile home shall have a minimum width of nineteen (19) feet (2) A mobile home shall be declared a petmanenlly affixed dwelling and shall be subject to the yard requirements for a principal structure. (3) A mobile home shall have a two and one-half inch (2.5'') in twelve-inch (12'') minimum pitch roof. The roof shall be coveted with non-reflecrive materials, such as fiberglass shingles, asphalt shingles, or wood shakes. (4) A mobile home shall have the tow assembly and wheels retnoved, be mounted on and anchored to a permanent foundation, and be skirted in accordance with the Vu:ginia Uniform Smtewide Building Code. (5) A mobile home shall be covered with a non-reflective material customarily used on a site-built dwelling, such as lap siding, plywood, brick, stone, or stucco. (6) A mobile home site shall have a storage area enclosed on all sides, having at least 300 cubic feet and desigoed to store yard equipment and supplies. Such storage area may be attached or demched from the prinripal structure. 36.2-418 Motor Vehicle or Trailer Painting and Body Repair (a) General standard All painting or body repair activities associated with any motor vehicle or trailet painting and body repair esmblisbment permitted by this Chapter, as of right or by special exception, shall occur in a wholly enclosed building. (b) Additional standards in the CG and CLS Districts In addition to the genetal smndard set forth in subsection (a), above, a motor vehicle or tr.Uler painting and body repair esmblisbment in the Commercial-General District (CG) or the Commercial-Large Site District (CLS) shall be subject to the following regulations: (1) There shall be no outdoor storage of damaged motor vehicles or trailers, equipment, parts, or othet materials; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 80 Article 4 (2) The minimum gross floor area of the building shall be not less than teo thousand (10,000) square feet (c) Additional standards in the 1-1 and 1-2 Districts In addition to the genetal standard set forth in subsection (a), above, a motor vehicle or trailer painting and body repair esmblisbment in the Light Industrial District (1-1) or the Heavy Industrial District (1-2) shall be subject to the following requirements: (1) The lot area shall conmin a minimum of twenty thousand (20,000) square feet; (2) The outdoor storage area shall be accessory to a building on the same lot and shall have a maximum area of no greatet than eighty (80) percent of the gross floor area of the building; and (3) The outdoor storage area shall be screened from view from adjacent properties and public streets by providing a Category "E," Option 1, buffet yard, as defined in Secrion 36.2-M76(b), along the perimeter of the storage area. 36.2-419 Motor Vehicle Repair or Service Establishment (a) General standards Any motor vehicle repair or service esmblisbment permitted by this Chaptet, regardless of zoning district, shall be subject to the following genetal standards: (1) When abutting a residentially zoned lot, a buffet yard shall be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-M7(c). (2) All repair or mainteoance activities shall occur in a wholly enclosed building; (3) The exterior display or storage of new or used motor vebicle parts is prohibited; and (4) Such esmblisbment shall be limited to the incidental sale of up to five (5) repaired or rebuilt motor vehicles or trailers within one (1) calendar year at that location; however, the sale of repaired or rebuilt motor vehicles or trailers for the purpose of satisfying a lien for services rendeted or parts supplied shall not be included in the total of such pennitted incidental sales. (b) Additional standards in the CG, CLS, and D District In addition to the genetal standards set forth in subsecrion (a), above, any motor vebicle repair or service esmblisbment in the Commercial-Geoetal District (CG), Commercial-Luge Site District (CLS), or Downtown District (I)) shall be subject to the following smndards: (1) No repair or mainteoance activities shall include the repair or maintenance of commercial motor vehicles; and (2) No repair or mainteoance activities shall include any motor vebicle or trailet painting or body repair. 36.2-420 Motor Vehicle Sales and Service Establishment, New Application for a zotting pennit for a new motor vehicle sales and service esmblisbment shall require that the applicant submit a basic or comprehensive development plan in compliance with the following supplemental regularions: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 81 Article 4 (a) A landscaping strip of a minimum depth of eight (8) feet shall be provided along any adjacent public street right-of-way and shall be subject to the following requirements: (1) A minimum of one (1) evergreen or deciduous shrub, spaced at a rate of no greater than three (3) feet on center and having a minimum height at planting of twenty-four (24) inches, shall be planted in the requited landscaping strip; and (2) The storage or display of motor vehicles within, upon, or in a manuet whicb overhangs any potrion of the requited landscaping strip shall be prolubited. (b) Any display area in conjunction with motor vehicle sales shall be limited to improved surfaces and shall be subject to the same construcrion standards set forth for off-street parking areas in Section 36.2-654(b). Undet no circumsmnces shall a display area be located closer than five (5) feet to a side or rear property line. (c) When abutting a residentially zoned lot, a buffet yard shall be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (d) A new motor vehicle sales and service esmblisbment shall require a minimum lot area of forty thousand (40,000) square feet designated for such use, except as provided in subsecrion (e), below. (e) A new motorcycle sales and service esmblisbment shall require a minimum lot area of teo thousand (10,000) square feet designated for such use. 36.2-421 Motor Vehicle Sales and Service Establishment, Used Application for a zoning permit for a used motor vehicle sales and service esmblisbment shall require that the applicant submit a basic or comprehensive development plan in compliance with the following supplemental regulations: (a) A landscaping strip of a minimum depth of eight (8) feet shall be provided along any adjacent public street right-of-way and shall be subject to the following requirements: (1) A minimum of one (1) evergreen or deciduous shrub, spaced at a rate of no greater than three (3) feet on centet and having a minimum height at planting of twenty-four (24) inches, shall be planted in the requited landscaping strip: and (2) The storage or display of motor vehicles within, upon, or in a manuet which overhangs any potrion of the requited landscaping strip shall be probibited. (b) Any display area in conjuncrion with motor vehicle sales shall be limited to improved surfaces and shall be subject to the same construction smndards set forth for off-street parking areas in Section 36.2-654(b). Undet no circumsmnces shall a display area be located closer than five (5) feet to a side or rear property line. (c) When abutting a residentially zoned lot, a buffer yard shall be provided along the applicable abutting property lines as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c). (d) A used motor vehicle sales and setvice esmblishment shall require a minimum lot area of fifteen thousand (15,000) square feet designated for such use 36.2-422 Outdoor Display Areas Outdoor display areas, where permitted by this Chapter as accessory uses, shall comply with the following smndards: (a) Such outdoor display area shall be located on the same lot as the principal use and shall be customarily incidental to the principal use; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 82 Arllcle 4 (b) The principal use with which the outdoor display area is associated shall occupy a minimum of five thousand (5,000) square feet of gross floor area; (c) Such outdoor display area shall be limited in square fooOtge to fifteen (15) percent of the area of the principal building; (d) The maximum height of stacked displayed metehandise in such outdoor display area shall be limited to six (6) feet; (e) Such outdoor display area shall be furnished with a surface material such as asphalt or concrete; and (I) MetCbandise shall not be placed or located so as to interfere with pedestrian or building access or egress, required vehicular parking and handicap parking, drive aisles, site access or egress, loading spaces or access theteto, public or private utilities, drainage systems, fire lanes, alanns, hydrants, standpipes or othet fire protecrion equipment, or emergency access or egress. 36.2-423 Outdoor Storage Whete permitted by this Chapter, outdoor storage shall comply with the following requirements: (a) Outdoor storage areas shall not be located in any requited yard, in any area included in the calcularion of required open space, or in any required off-street parking spaces, vehicular or pedestrian access, or landscaped areas. (b) Outdoor storage areas shall not be located closer to a public street than the primary building fa~ade on the lot. (c) Outdoor storage areas in the Residential-Agricultural District (RA) shall not be located closer than one hundred fifty (150) feet to any lot line of adjoining property that is not within an RA District (d) Outdoor storage areas that are visible from a public street shall be screened from view by providing a Category "C" buffer as defined in Section 36.2-647(b). (e) Outdoor storage areas abutting zoning district boundaries as identified below shall provide the type of buffet as set forth below and as defined in Section 36.2-647(b). Abutting Zotting District Buffer Yard Category Required RA, R-l2, R-7, R-S,R-3, RM-l, RM-2, RMF,MXPUD D CN, CG, CLS, D, MX, IN, ROS, INPUD, IPUD C 1-1,1-2 Not requited 36.2-424 Parking of Motor Vehicles in Residential Districts No motor vehicle inteoded or designed to ttansport caustic, flammable, explosive, or otherwise dangerous materials, and no commercial motor vehicle or panel truck, shall be parked or left smnding in a residential district for more than two (2) hours at any rime except for. (a) School buses and emergency vehicles; (b) Vehicles being loaded or unloaded; (c) Vehicles belonging to or used by the occupant of a business premises, when the business premises constitute a legally nonconforming use; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 83 Article 4 (d) V chicles, the occupantl; of which are actually engaged in work on the premises; (e) Vehicles being used in connection with utility or street work; and (I) Tow trucks and roll back tow trucks which are on call on the City's towing list 36.2-425 Parking or Storage of Recreational Vehicles, Motor Homes, Boats, Campers, or Trailers A motor home, boat, truck camper, inhabimble bus, recrearional vehicle, travel trailer, boat trailer, or other trailet may be parked or stored, but not inhabited for a period exceeding twenty-four (24) hours, in a residential district or in a CN or MX District, provided that such motor vehicle or equipment shall be: (a) Licensed for the current year; (b) Located no closer to any street than the principal building; and (c) Not oVet thirty-two (32) feet in length or nine (9) feet in height. 36.2-426 Parking Structures (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to esmblish cetmin standards to address the impact of parking structures on the building bulk on a site. (b) Standards All parking structures in the Downtown District (I)) with fronmges exceeding one hundred fifty (150) feet in length shall incotporate vettical or horizontal variation in setback, material, or fenesttation along the length of the applicable facade, in at least one of the following ways: (1) Vettical facades shall incotporate intervals of architectural variation at least every sixty (60) feet over the length of the applicable fac;ade, utilising one or more of the following methods: varying the arrangement, proportioning, or design of garage floor openings; incotporating changes in architectural materials, including texture and color; or projecting or recessing potrions or elementl; of the parking structure fac;ade. (2) Horizontal facades shall be designed to diffetentiate the ground floor from uppet floors, utilising one or more of the following methods: stepping back the uppet floors from the ground floor parking structure facade; changing materials between the parking structure base and uppet floors; or including a continuous cornice line or pedestrian weathet protecrlon element between the ground floor and the uppet floors. 36.2-427 Satellite Dish Antennas (a) Applicability This section applies to any satellite dish antenna, except as follows: (1) An anteona that is used to receive direct broadcast satellite service, including direct-to-home satellite service, or to receive or transmit fixed wireless signals via satellite, and is one meter (3.28 feet) or less in diameter; Zcnlng Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 84 Article 4 (2) An anteona that. (A) Is used ro receive video programming services via multipoint distribution services, including multi- channel multipoint distribution services, instructional television fixed services, and local multipoint distribution services, or to receive or transmit fixed wireless signals othet than via satellite, and (B) Is one meter (328 feet) or less in diameter or diagonal measurement; (3) An antenna that is used to receive television broadcast signals; (4) A mast suppotring an anteona described in (a)(l) through (a)(3) of this secrion; (5) A satellite eatth station anteona that is two meters (6.56 feet) or less in diametet and is located or proposed to be located in any commercial or industrial zoning district; or (6) A satellite eatth smtion anteona that is one meter (3.28 feet) or less in disrueter in any area, regardless of land use or zoning category. (b) Location A satellite dish antenna shall not be located or mounted: (1) In any front or side yard as may be requited in any residential or commercial zoning district; or (2) On the roof or wall of a building which faces a public right-of-way. (c) Development plan approval A satellite dish anteona shall require basic development plan approval. (d) Screening Without restricting its operation, a satellite dish anteona located on the ground or on the top of a building shall be screened from view from public streets. (e) Height A satellite dish antenna located on the roof of a building shall be subject to the regulations for the maximum height of structures of the applicable district 36.2-428 Stables, Commercial Commercial smbles, whete permitted by this Chapter, shall be subject to the following requirements: (a) A minimum lot area of five (5) acres shall be requited; and (b) The stable shall not be located closer than three hundred (300) feet to any lot line of adjoining property not under the same ==hip. 36.2-429 Temporary Uses (a) Applicability Authorized temporary uses, including permitted locations, duration, and maximum numbet pet calendar year, and whethet or not a zoningpermir is required, sball be as set forth in Table 429-1: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 85 Article 4 r-- -- "" -- - -. "- 1\ Table 429-1. Temporary Uses ~ II ! .n ___ I Activity Zoning Districts Maximum Maximum Zoning Pennit I where permitted I Duration Number per Required? I Calendar Year ! for Lot 11 - - 1: 11 --"l' --,- 1f "' , Auction Any district 3 calendar days 1 No 1\ ! Christmas tree sales II RA, eN, eG, CLS, I 60 calendar days Ii 1 II Yes 1-1 1-2 II -c;;~';~~ri;;~:~ei~t~"'" r---A'~y"'diStrict ".. 'IF~;d~;.ati.~ti.~{ _..n..........".. Not applicable Yes activities or model home offi~~~~biect to , construction activity subsection , below r.---- ...---..."".-.- - -. . ._."~_. - .n._. I _.".m._.""' --- ....11 :lO;:>.i;ti.dard~y;- -,...". .......'"n'______ "W . ~---_.~_..,._- -.-. 11 ! Fireworks stand, CG, CLS 1 Yes ! subject to Section 21- , 207 of this Code , r<3utdoor retail sales, CG,CLS - li10 calendar days li Yes I 4 : subject to subsection Ic),below , ..A~y--d;trict.. ._---," -. .. I~; ~~;R~~;5,.... .-...- ----."'...-...,...-...".-- I - .....--- - ...-...-.-. ......--...... : See maximum Yes , duration I ' , , I RMF, MX, MXPUD, i , i 21 consecutive calendar : days, limited to one (1) I permit per any 6-month Portable storage , I period per lot; I containers, subject to I I I subsection (d), below CN, CG, CLS, 1-1, 1-2, D, IN, ROS, AD, ! I I I INPUD,IPUD: I , j 4 consecutive months, I I ! llimired to one (1) I I permit per calendar year nerlot ]I RA, CN, CG, CLS, < 90 calendar days, ~ Not applicable iYes Produce stand (not 1-1,1-2 I limired to one (1) applicable to permit per any 90- I community markets) I calendar day period per I lor CN, CG, CLS, D, i iNot applicable I - II Public events, subject : I 14 calendar days Yes to subsection (e), below IN, ROS, 1-1, 1-2, IPUD,INPUD I r"-A~y'-~'~id'~.~thli ..".......... 2, with an interval I ....\1 Yard or Garage Sales, , 2 consecutive calendar No subject to subsection i district or dwelling I days, limited to the of at least 3 , unit I daylight hours months between (f),below sales , I - (b) (1) Construction-related activities Temporary structures are permitted in connection with the site of building and land development or redevelopment, as set forth in Table 429-1. Such building and land development or redevelopment shall include grading, paving, installation of utilities, building construcrion, and the like, and such structures may include offices, model home offices, construction trailers, and storage buildings, as well as portable storage containers and construction refuse containers. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 86 Article 4 (2) Refuse conminetS on construction sites shall be subject to the following requirements: (A) No consrrucrion refuse conminer may impede pedestrian or vehicular access to and from adjoining properties or othetwise create an unsafe condition for pedestrian and vehicular traffic; (B) Eve<y construction refuse conminer shall cleady identify the ownet of such dumpstet and telephone number and shall be cleady labeled for the purpose of conminment of consrruction materials only; and (C) Eve<y consrrucrion refuse conminet shall be etnptied when full so as not to create an unsightly or dangerous condition on the property resulting from the deposit, existeoce, and accumulation of consttucrion materials. (c) (1) Outdoor retail sales This subsecrion shall apply to any tetnporary outdoor relllil sales acrivity, except for the following uses which shall be exetnpt from the regulations of this subsection: mobile food vendors in the Downtown District (I)), mobile food vendors intended for job and construction sites, and mobile ice cream vendors; the sale of goods as part of a neighborhood fioir or othet special event which has an approved zoning permi~ and produce smnds, Ouistmas tree sales, fueworks smnds, or temporary uses regulated elsewhere in this section. (2) A tetnporary outdoor relllil sales display sball be permitted as set forth in Table 429-1, provided that (A) The sales activity is incidental to the principal use; (B) The sales activity is conducted by an on-site tenant who sells similar or related metebandise; (C) The temporary outdoor relllil sales display area shall not encroach into a public right-of-way and shall not utilize requited parking or loading spaces; and (I)) T etnporary relllil sales activities shall be probibited on vacant propetty. (d) Portable storage containers The provisions of this section shall apply to the placetnent, locarion, erection, or relocation of any portable storage conminer, except as provided in Section 36.2-429(b). Portable storage conminetS sball be probibited in all zoning districts except that such portable storage conminetS shall be permitted as temporary uses as set forth in Table 429-1, subject to the following additional standards: (1) The following smndards shall apply to any portable storage conminer permitted as a tetnporary use by this Chapter. (A) The placement of any portable storage conminer on a lot shall be permitted only upon issuance of a zoning permit Such zoning permit shall be displayed on the outside of the conminet in such manner as to be plainly visible; (B) Portable storage conminetS shall not be permitted on any lot that does not conmin a principal building; (C) Portable storage conminers shall be permitted only for storage purposes as an accessory use to the principal use of the lot on which such conminer may be located; (I)) Portable storage conminetS shall not be connected to any utilities; (E) No more than two (2) signs having a mas:imum area of four (4) square feet per sign may be displayed on any portable storage conminer, and such sign shall be limited to identification of the suppliet of the conminer and the supplier's phone number; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 87 Article 4 (F) No portable storage conminer shall be located closer than five (5) feet to any side or rear lot line, but in no case shall such conminet be located within a requited buffer yard; and (G) The Vettical smoking of portable storage conminetS and the smoking of any othet materials or metehandise on top of any pottable storage conminet shall be probibited. (2) In addition to the genetal smndards set forth in subsection (1) above, portable storage conminetS in the residential districts (RA, R-12, R-7, R-S, R-3, RM-l, RM-2, RMF), MX District, and MXPUD District shall be subject to the foUowing regulations: (A) No more than one (1) portable storage conminet shall be allowed on a lot, and such conminet shall be pennitted only in connection with a construcrion, rehabilimtion, or restorarion activity on the lot; (B) No portable storage conminet shall have dimensions greater than sisteen (16) feet in length, eight (8) feet in width, and eight and one-half (8-1 /2) feet in height; and (C) A portable storage conminet may be located on a driveway, so long as requited parking spaces are not obstructed and such conminet is not closer than teo (10) feet to the front property line. (3) In addition to the genetal smndatds set forth in subsection (1) above, portable storage conminetS in the CN, CG, CLS, 1-1, 1-2, D, IN, ROS, AD, INPUD, and IPUD Districts shall be subject to the following regulations: (A) One (1) or more portable storage conminetS may be permitted per zoning lot per zoning permit; (B) No portable storage conminer shall be located closer to a public street than the principal building; and (C) No portable storage conminet shall be placed or located on, or block access to, a requited parking space, circulation aisle, or fire access lane, or cause a visual obstruction to pedestrians or motor vehicles leaving or entering the property. (e) Public events For purposes of this section, a temporary "public event" means an event, series of events, or organized activities for a bistorical, social, educationa1, cultural, or special thetne, held for a limited period of rime and open to the public. T etnporary public events shall include, withoutlimimtion, carnivals, festivals, esbibits, outdoor dance, liIDdniisers, fairs, and concetlS. Tetnporary public events, including associated tetnporary structures such as teots, shall be pennilted as set forth in Table 429-1, provided that (1) No such temporary structure, including any teot, shall be pennilted to remain on site for a period longet than two (2) calendar days following the rime period for which the zoning permit for the tetnporary public event is issued; (2) Sufficient space for parking shall be provided on the site to meet the anticipated needs; (3) Adequate provision shall be made for utility services; and (4) Such public event shall not occur between the hours of 2:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. (f) Yard or garage sales For purposes of this secrion, a ''yard or garage sale" means a public sale at a dwelling at which personal items belonging to the residents of the dwelling are sold. Yard or garage sales shall be pennilted as set forth in Table 429-1, provided that (1) Items purchased elsewhere expressly for resale at a yard or garage sale shall be probibited; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 88 Article 4 (2) Goods inteoded for sale shall not be stored or displayed in the front or side yards of a dwelling except on the day of the sale. 36.2-430 Towing Services Towing services pennilted by this Chaptet shall be subject to the following smndards: (a) The lot area designated for the towing service use shall conmin a minimum of twenty thousand (20,000) square feet; (b) Thete shall be no outdoor storage of any damaged or inoperative motor vehicles or trailetS for a period exceeding one hundred twenty (120) calendar days, unless documenmtion is provided that is satisfactory to the Zoning Administrator evidencing that such a damaged or inoperative motor vehicle or trailet is the subject of an on-going law enforcement or insurance investigation or is the subject of a proceeding being pursued as expeditiously as possible by the towing service pursuant to Section 43-34 of the Code ofVttginia (1950), as amended; and (c) The storage area for any damaged or inopetative motor vehicles or trailers shall be screened from view from adjacent properties and public streets by providing a Category "E," Option 1, buffet yard, as defined in Section 36.2-647(b), along the petimetet of the storage area. 36.2-431 Townhouses and Rowhouses (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to esmblisb smndards for townhouses and rowhouses that pennit appropriate densities, minimize curb cuts, and provide for usable open space. It is the inteot of this section that townhouses and rowhouses make efficient, economical, comfortable, and convenient use of land and open space and serve the public purposes of zoning by alternative arrangements of yards and buildings. (b) Applicability The regulations conmined in this section shall be applicable in any zoning district in which townhouses or rowhouses are a use pennilled as of right or by special exception. (c) Standards In accordance with the genetal purpose set out in this section, townhouses and rowhouses shall be subject to the following supplemental regulations: (1) Contiguous units: No contiguous row of townhouse or rowhouse dwelling units shall extend more than three hundred (300) feet (2) Minimum width for individual townhouse or rowhouse lots: The minimum width of an individual townhouse or rowhouse unit lot shall be eighteen (18) feet (3) Lot size and lot fronrage: The minimum lot area and lot fronrage requirements for a building housing townhouse or rowhouse units shall be as set forth in the zoning district in which it is located. (4) Density: The pennitted density of residential development shall be govetned by the density regulations set forth for the zoning district in which the townhouse or rowhouse units are located. (5) Yards: The depth of yards shall be govemed by the minimum yard requirements of the zoning district in which the townhouse or rowhouse units are located, except that interior townhouse or rowhouse dwelling units shall be exetnpt from side yard requirements. Where a lot conmining townhouse or rowhouse units abuts a lot which is zoned R-l2, R-7, or R-S, such aburtingyard shall have a minimum depth often (10) feet Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 89 Article 4 (6) Separarion of buildings: Any building conmining townhouse or rowhouse units or an accessory structure related to a building conmining such townhouse or rowhouse units shall be located no closer than twenty (20) feet to another townhouse or rowhouse building or accessory structure related to such building. (I) Off-street parking: No off-street parking spaces or driveways shall be permitted between a public or private street and any principal building, except when parking is provided for each individual townhouse unit and provided furthet that the townhouse dwelling units are greater than twenty-five (25) feet in width, the driveways are no greater than teo (10) feet in width, and the garage doors are no greater than teo (10) feet in width. Off-street parking spaces may be grouped in bays if not located between a public or private street and any principa1 building. (8) Usable open space: For multiple townhouse or rowhouse dwelling units located on a single zoning lot, a minimum of one hundred (1 (0) square feet of usable open space shall be provided for each dwelling unit Whete each townhouse or rowhouse dwelling unit is located on individual zoning lots, a minimum of one hundred (100) square feet of usable open space shall provided on each such zoning lot (d) Subdivision Nothing in this Chapter shall prevent the creation of a subdivided unit lot for individual townhouse or rowhouse dwelling units within a townhouse or rowhouse zoning lot 36.2-432 Towers (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to promote the health, safety, and genetal welfare of the public by esmblishing standards for the location and construction of wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting towers. The provisions of this section are inteoded to: Wireless Telecommunications Facilities and Broadcasting (1) Regulate the siting of wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting toWetS in a manuet that allows for a range oflocations, subject to clear buffering, safety, and compatibility smndards; (2) Minimize the impacts of wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting towers on public safety, the natural environment, and surrounding properties by esmblishing smndards for location that encourage broadcast services and personal wireless services providers to locate their facilities, to the extent possible, in areas whete the advetse impact on the community is minimal; (3) Encourage the location and collocation of wireless telecommunications equipment on existing structures thereby minimizing public safety impacts, the effects upon the natural environment and wildlife, reducing the need for additional anteona-supporting structures or towetS, and minimizing adVetSe visual impacts; (4) Accommodate the growing need and denmnd for wireless telecommunications services; (5) Encourage coordination between providetS of wireless telecommunications services; (6) Protect the charactet, scale, viability, and quality of life of the residential districts of the City by establishing certain reasonable standards on the placement of wireless telecommunications facilities; (I) Respond to the policies embodied in the Telecommunications Act of 1996 in such a manuet as not to discriminate unreasonably between providet'S of fimctionally equivalent personal wireless service or to probibit or have the effect of probibiting petSonal wireless service in the City; (8) Esmblisb predictable and balanced regulations and review procedures goVetUing the construction and location of wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting towers to ensure that applications for such facilities are reviewed and acted upon within a reasonable period of time; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 90 Article 4 (9) Provide for the removal of discontinued antenna-supporting structures. (b) (1) Applicability The regulations set forth in this secrion shall apply to all new and replacetnent wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting towetS permitted by this Chapter. (2) No modification to increase the height, size, type, or location of any existing wireless telecommunications or broadcasting toWet or associated facilities, excluding anteonas, shall be made unless such modifu:arion results in the full compliance of the toWet and facilities with all of the requirements of this Chapter. (3) Whete permitted as of right by this Chapter, stealth wireless telecommunications facilities shall be subject to the provisions of Sections 36.2-432(d)(3) and 36.2-432(e), provided such facility does not increase the height of the existing structure or structure's appurreoance by which it is camouflaged (4) The smndards set forth in this section shall not apply to any antenna or toWet that is less than seventy-five (75) feet in height and is owned and operated by a citizens band radio operator or fedetaliy licensed amateur radio opetator or is used exclusively for receive only antennas. (c) Definitions The words, terms, and phrases used in this section shall be defined as set forth in this subsection. For the purposes of this section, to the extent of any inconsistency between the definitions set forth below and the definitions in Appendix A, the definitions provided in this subsecrion shall controL Ancillal:y appurtenance: Equipment associated with a wireless telecommunications facility or bmadcasting towet including, but not limited to, antennas, attaching devices, transmission lines, and all other equipment mounted on or associated with such facility. Ancillary appurtenances do not include equipment enclosures. Antenna: Any apparatus, or group of apparatus, designed for transmirting or receiving electromagnetic waves that includes, but is not limited to, telephonic, radio, or television communications. Anteonas include dish antennas, pane1 antennas, whip antennas, or similar devices used for broadcast, transmission, or reception of radio frequency signals, but do not include satellite earth stations. For purposes of this section, a reference to an antenna does not include the towet. Antenna, dish: A parabolic, sphetical, or elliptical antenna intended to receive wireless communications. Antenna, flush-mounted: An antenna that is attached flush to an antenna-supporting structure, without the use of sidearms or othet extension devices. Flush-mounted shall mean that protrusions from the face of a pole are no greatet than one-half the diameter of the pole itself and in no case greater than twelve (12) inches. Antenna, pane~ A direcrional antenna designed to transmit or receive signals in a directional palletn that is less than three hundred sixty (360) degrees and is not a flush-mounted or dish antenna. Antenna, roof-mounted: An antenna that is attached to the surface of a roof or to the parapet or penthouse. Antenna, surface-mounted: An antenna that is attached to the surface or fa~ of a structure othet than an antenna-supporting structure. Antenna, whip: A cylindrical, omni-directional antenna designed to transmit or receive signals in a three hundred sixty (360) degree pattern. Antenna-supporting structure: A Vettical projection, including a foundation, designed and primarily used to support one (1) or more antennas or which constitutes an antenna itself, which is commonly referred to as "tower," "cell tower," "communications tower," "telecommunications tower," or "broadcasting tower." Antenna-supporting structures do not include stealth wireless telecommunications facilities, but do include roof-mounted and surface- mounted antennas that extend above the roofline. Antenna-supporting structures are not considered utility equipment Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 91 Article 4 Antenna-supporting structure, broadcast: An antenna-suppotring structure, including replacements, which conmins antennas that transmit signals for broadcast radio and television communications. Such structure is commonly refetred to as a "broadcasting towet." Antenna-supporting structure, lattice: A self-supporting, smnd-alone anteona-suppotring structure, not supported by guy wires, which consists of vettical and horizontal supports with multiple legs and cross bracing of structural steel Antenna-suppotting structure, guyed: An antenna-suppotring structure supported by a series of guy wires that are connected to anchors placed in the ground or on a building. Antenna-supporting structure, monopole: A freesmnding antenna-suppotring structure that is composed of a single shaft attached to a foundation. This type of anteona-suppotring structure is designed to support itself without the use of guy wires or othet smbilization devices. (Those using guy wires are defined as "goyed anteona-suppotring structures.'~ Monopole structures are mounted to a foundation that rests on or in the ground or on the roof of a building. Antenna-supporting structure, roof-mounted: An antenna-supporting structure that is mounted on the roof of a building and extends above the roof1ine. Broadcasting tower: See "Anteona-suppotring structure, broadcast." Ceo tower: See "Anteona-suppotring structure." Collocation: A situation in which two or more providers place an antenna on a common antenna-supporting structure, or the addition or replacetnent of antennas on an existing structure provided they meet the tetmS of the first installation. Communications tower. See "Antenna-supporting structure." Eqttipment enclosure: An enclosed structure, cabinet, or shelter located at the base of or near a wireless telecommunications facility or broadcasting tOWet within which is housed batteries, electrical equipment, or othet equipment necessary for the ttansmission or reception of wireless telecommunications signals. Such equipment within the enclosure is genetally connected to the anteona by cable. FAA: FedetalAviationAdministtation. FCC: Fedetal Commw1icarions Commission. Height: The height of a wireless telecommunicarions facility, or bmadcasting tOWet, measured as set forth in Appendix A. The height of a wireless telecommunications facility or broadcasting tower includes all anteonas and other ancillary appurtenances. Whete ovetali height requirements set forth in this section conflict with those set forth in Section 36.2-20S(k) or the height regulations for the applicable zoning district, those set forth in this section shall goVetU. PetsOnaJ wireless setvice: Commercial mobile services (which includes cellular, personal communication services, specialized mobile radio, enhanced specialized mobile radio, data, and paging), unlicensed wireless services, and common carrier wireless exchange access services, as defined in the Telecommunications Act of 1996. Personal wireless service-does not include broadcasting or amateur ra.dio operations. Provider: Any business, cotporation, partnetShip, or other entity licensed by the FCC to provide wireless services in the City of Roanoke, Vttginia. Radio frequency emissions: Any electromagnetic radiation or other communications signal emitted from an antenna or antenna-related equipment on the ground, antenna-supporting structure, building, or othet vertical projection. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 92 Article 4 Roofline: In the case of a flat or pitched roof; the uppermost line of the roof of a building; and in the case of a parapet, the uppermost height of the parapet Satellite earth station: Any device or antenna, including associated mounting devices or anteona-supporting structures, used to transmit or receive signals from an orbiting satellite, including television broadcast signals, direct broadcast satellite services, multi-channel multipoint distribution services, fixed wireless communications signals, and any desigoated operations indicated in the FCC Table of Allocations for satellite services. Stealth wireless telecommunications facility: A wireless telecommunicarions facility that is bidden or not readily detectable by means of camouflage or concealment Camouflage shall mean a way of painting and mounting a wireless telecommunications facility that requires minimal changes to the host structure in ordet to accommodate the facility. Concealment shall mean to enclose a wireless telecommunications facility within an existing structure or appurtenance of a structure resulting in the facility being eithet invisible or made part of the feature enclosing it Such structures or appurreoances may include church steeples, bell towers, church spires, clock tOWetS, cupolas, light smndards, chimneys, utility poles, and flagpoles displaying flags. For the purposes of the regulations of this secrion, stealth wireless telecomm~cations facilities shall include the use of existing structures or appurtenances of strucnl1'es in which the facility is concealed by embedding all anteonae within the structure or appurteoance, anteonas mounted to the sides (Vettical face) of a watet mnk and not extending above the highest horizontal line on the face of the tank, and a single anteona array attached to a telecommunications pole constructed and integrated within an existing electric transmission toWet in which the height of the pole and anteona array does not exceed ten (10) feet above the existing electric transmission tower. Tower: See "Antenna-supporting structure." Wireleas telecommunications: Any personal wireless service and any othet radio frequency signals, but not including signals transmitted to or from a satellite earth smtion. Wireless telecommunications facility: Any facility used for the transnusSlon or reception of wireless telecommunications, usually consisting of an antenna or group of antennas, transmission lines, ancillary appurtenances, and equipment enclosures, and which may include an antenna-supporting structure. The following are consideted wireless telecommunications facilities: antenna-supporting structures, collocated antennas, roof-mOlU1ted structures, surface-mounted anteonas, and stealth wireless telecommunications facilities. Wireless telecommunications tower: See "Antenna-supporting structure," (d) (1) Application requirements .A.ll potential applicants for wireless telecomnllUlicattons towers or broadcasting towers shall consult with the Zoning Administtator prior to submitring an application for a proposed tOWet. During this consulmtion, the applicant shall present information to the Zoning Administtator on the system objectives, proposed covetage areas, and altetnative sites consideted and rejected. The Zoning Administtator shall provide the applicant with information on the City's policies and standards for wireless telecommunications and broadcasting tOWetS and shall discuss with the applicant possible alternatives to tower consttucrion. (2) All applicants for a special exception for wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tOWetS shall provide the following at the rime of application: (A) The location of all othet wireless telecommunications tOWet sites considered and rejected by the applicant, and the specific technical, legal, or othet reasons for the rejecrion. (B) The location of all possible collocation sites for a wireless telecommunications tower considered and rejected by the applicant, and the specific technical, legal, or other reasons for the rejection. (C) Description of tower design and a sample photograph showing the type of proposed tOWet. (I)) Elevation drawing, showing tower and antennae height Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 93 Article 4 (E) Accurate, to seale, photograpbic simulations showing the relationship of the proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting toWet or associated antennae to the surroundings. Photographic simulations shall also be prepared showing the relationsbip of any street, access, or utility corridors constmcted or modified to serve the proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower site. The numbet of simulations, and the perspectives from which they are prepared, shall be esmblished by the Zoning Administtator at the consulmtion requited in Section 362-432(d)(l), above. (F) A computerized terrain analysis showing the visibility of the proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tOWet and antenna at the requested height and location. If new or modified street, access, or utility corridors are proposed, the terrain analysis shall also show the visibility of these new or modified features. (G) Information on how the proposed wireless telecommunications towet site relates to the applicant's existing wireless telecommunicarions system, including the number of other sites within the Roanoke Valley and the location of the anteona(s) at each site. (H) Results of an on-site "balloon" or comparable test, conducted by the applicant at the applicant's expense. The purpose of such test shall be to demonstrate the poteotial visual impact of the proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower. The dates and periods of these tests shall be esmblisbed with the applicant at the pre-application consulmtion as requited in Section 36.2-432(d)(l). (I) An engineeting report certifying that the proposed wireless telecommunications towet is compatible for collocation with, and the sttuctural integrity of the tOWet will support, one (1) to three (3) othet providers of wireless tdecommunications services and new equipment (I) Copy of the applicant's collocation policy for wireless telecommunications towers. (K) ASAC Obsttucrion Evaluation Report, or comparable evaluation opinion, conducted in accordance with the Fedetal Aviation Regulations (FAR) Part 77 and the Fedetal Communications Commission (FCC) Rules Part 17. (L) Documenmtion of filing of FAA Form 7460-1, as amended. (M) Documenmtion from medical helicopter patient transportation providetS of non-intetfetence with esmblished routes. (N) A landscape plan, pursuant to Section 36.2-432(e)(l1), showing the locations, species, and size at planting for the landscaping proposed for the wireless telecommunications or broadcasting towet site. (3) All applicants for stealth wireless telecommunications facilities, whete permitted as of right by this Chapter, shall provide the following at the rime of application: (A) Description of the desigo of the stealth facility and a sample photograph showing the type of proposed stealth wireless telecommunications facility. (B) Elevarion drawing, showing facility height (C) Accurate, to scale, photograpbic simulations showing the relationship of the proposed stealth wireless telecommunications facility to the surroundings. Photographic simulations shall also be prepared showing the relationship of any street, access, or utility corridors constructed or modified to serve the proposed stealth wireless telecommunications facility site. The number of simulations, and the perspecrives from which they are prepared, shall be esmblisbed by the Zoning Administtator at the consulmtion requited in Section 36.2-432(d)(l). (I)) A computerized termin analysis showing the visibility of the proposed stealth wireless telecommunications facility at the requested height and location. If new or modified street, access, or Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 94 Article 4 utility corridors are proposed, the tetrain ana1ysis shall also show the visibility of these new or modified features. (E) An engineeting report certifying the sttuctural integrity of the proposed stealth wireless telecommunicarions facility and the structure to which it is to be attached or within which it is to be located. (F) ASAC Obstrucrion Evaluation Report, or comparable evaluation opinion, conducted in accordance with the Federal Aviarion Regulations (FAR) Part 77 and the Fedetal Communications Commission (FCC) Rules Part 17. (G) DocumenmtionoffilingofFAAForm 7460-1,asamended. (H) Documenmrion from medical helicopter patient ttansportation providetS of non-interfetence with esmblisbed routes. (l) A landscape plan, pursuant to Section 36.2-432(e)(l1), showing the locations, species, and size at planting for the landscaping proposed for any ground-mounted equipment (4) An administtattve fee esmblisbed by the City Council shall accompany each application for a zoning pennit or special exception for a wireless telecommunications tow<<. Such fee shall be used by the City to engage an engineer or othet qualified consulmnt to review the technical aspects of the application, including the review of coverage maps, analysis of the need for such facilities, and ana1ysis of the location requested. Payment of such special review fee shall in no way be a substitute for any othet application fees othetwise requited by this Chapter and established by the City Council. (e) General standards The following smndards shall apply to any wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tow<< pennitted by this Chaptet as of right or by special exception: (1) Except for proposed wireless teleconununications or broadcasting towers and associated antennae in the Heavy Industrial District (1-2), the maximum height of which shall be regulated by the height regulations for the 1-2 District as set forth in Section 36.2-31S(d), the maximum height of any proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tow<< and associated anteona shall be esmblisbed by a condition of a special exception pennit or the development plan of an approved PUD District, but in no case, shall any tower and antenna exceed one hundred ninety-nine (199) feet in height, whethet by special exception or by right (2) Wueless telecommunications or broadcasting tOWetS shall conform, at a minimum, to the yard requirements for principal structures in the applicable zoning district; howevet, in no case sball the base of a tOWet be located closer than fifty (50) feet or forty (40) percent of the height of the tOWet, wbichevet is greater, to any residentially zoned lot The depth of any requited yard shall be measured from the closest sttuctural member of the tower, excluding guy wires. (3) The minimum yard requirement for any othet structure associated with a wireless telecommunications or broadcasting towet shall be as ser forth in the applicable district regulations or supplemental regulations. (4) More than one (1) wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower may be permitted on a lot provided all applicable requirements of this Chaptet have been met (5) Wtteless telecommunications or broadcasting towetS shall not be illuminated with any type of lighting apparatus, unless such lighting is a requirement of the FAA or FCC. When lighting is proposed to conform to fedetal requirements, the applicant shall provide to the Zoning Administtator evidence from the fedetal agency that verifies the necessity of lighting and determines the minimal amount and type of lighting necessary to comply with fedetal guidelines. Security lighting may be installed on structures associated with a wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 95 Article 4 (6) Except for stealth wireless telecommunications facilities, and except for roof-mounted or surface-mounted antennas, any wireless telecommunications tow<< approved shall be st:ructurally designed to carry sufficient loading, and the site approved shall be sized to accommodate the equipment necessary, for one (1) to three (3) additional vendors/providetS of wireless telecommunications services in ordet to minimize the prolifetation of new wireless telecommunications toWetS in the vicinity of the requested site. In addition, by applying and being granted a zoning permit for a wireless telecommunications tow<<, the applicant and the ownet of the land agree to make the wireless telecommunications tOWet and tower site av.rilable for additional leases within the structural capacity of the wireless telecommunicarions tow<< and at reasonable costs adequate to recover the capital, operating. and maintenance costs of the wireless telecommunications tow<< locarion requited for the additional capacity. (J) Wneless telecommunications or broadcasting towers shall be a monopole design unless it is determined that a lattice design or alternative tower design would better blend into the SUIroOOding environment or such monopole design is not technically feasible as supported by accepted technical and engineeting dam. Cost shall not be a criterion for determining tower design. This smndard shall not apply to stealth wireless telecommunications facilities which design shall be govetned by the definition thereof. (8) By applying for and being issued any permit for a wireless telecommunicarions or broadcasting tow<<, or petitioning for and receiving approval of a MXPUD, INPUD or JPUD District which development plan includes a wireless te1econununications or broadcasting tower, the applicant or petitioner and the owner of the land agree to dismantle and remove such towet and associated facilities from the site within ninety (90) calendar days of the tower no longer being used. Dismantling and removal from the site shall only be requited after notice by the Zoning Administtator. If antennas on any approved tow<< are relocated to a lower elevation, the towet shall be shortened to the height of the highest antenna. A guarantee may be required as part of the approval of a special exception permit Such guarantee shall be in an amount sufficient ro ensure removal of the tow<< and all associated facilities and returning the site as closely as possible to its original condition. (9) All anteonae shall be flush-mounted, and all wireless telecommunications and broadcasting towers and associated hardware, anteonas, and facilities shall be a flat matted finish so as to reduce visibility and light reflection unless otherwise required by the FCC or FAA. (10) No business or othet related sign shall be permitted on any wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower or associated facilities or equipment, except as may be required for public safety purposes, or as required by the FCC or FAA. No materials or markings conmining any advettisement shall be permitted on any wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower or associated facilities or equipment (11) A buffet yard shall be provided surrounding wireless telecommunications facilities or broadcasting toWetS, including the base of any such facility. The required buffet yard category shall be as set forth in Section 36.2- 647(c). For purposes of this secrion, in those circumsmnces whete Section 36.2-647(c) does not require a buffet yard, a Category "A" buffer yard shall be provided. Existing mature tree growth on the site shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible. In locations whete the visual impact of the wireless telecommunications tow<< would be minimal, the landscaping buffet requirement may be reduced by the Board of Zoning Appeals as part of a special exception approval process. (12) Wireless telecommunications or broadcasting towers and associated facilities shall be enclosed by security fencing. (13) Thete shall be no outdoor storage associated with a wireless telecommunicarions or broadcasting facility. (f) General review policies In addition to the general standards for consideration of an application for a special exception, as set forth in Section 36.2-S60(c), the Board of Zoning Appeals shall consider a special exception application for a new wireless telecommunications facility or broadcasting tower, including the replacement or modification of an existing tower, on the basis of the following criteria: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 96 Article 4 (1) For a request for a wireless telecommunications tower, the availability of other existing structures, based upon independent analysis and evaluation, of suimble height, design, and location for the requested antenna; (2) The base and top elevation of the proposed wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tOWet and its associated antennae relative to surrounding natural land forms, with tower locations below surrounding ridgelines preferred; (3) The visibility of the wireless telecommunications or broadcasting tower and its compatibility as determined by the submitted computet simulations, terrain analysis, and balloon or comparable test; and (4) The degree to which the proposed towet location, site design, and facilities, including fencing, landscaping, buildings, othet ground-mounted equipment, and access or utility cotridors, are located, designed, and constructed to be compatible with the adjacent propetries. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 97 Article 4 Procedures 36.2-500 Purpose In ordet to meet development needs while protecting the public welfare and safety, this Article is inteoded to set forth the procedures for obmining permits pursuant to this Chapter. Division 1. Generally 36.2-510 General Procedural Requirements (a) Application process The specific procedures requited for reviewing various applications diffet. Genetaliy, the procedures for all applications have three common eletnents: submittal of a complete application, including applicable informarion and payment of the required fee; review of the submittal by designated officials, commissions, and boards; and action to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application. Submittal dates or filing deadlines are esmblisbed by the requirements of the specific application. (1) Applicarion materials: Current application materials shall be made available in the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development. Applications shall be accompanied by payment of all fees and charges as set forth in the fee sehedule esmblisbed by the City CounciL Applications that require a public hearing or public meeting pursuant to this Chapter or the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, shall be filed by a deadline as esmblished by the applicable conunission or board. (2) Completeoess review: The Zoning Administrator shall review any application or petition filed pursuant to this Chapter for completeoess. Non-payment of requited fees shall deem an applicarion or petition incomplete. Prior to processing an application or petition pursuant to this Chapter, the applicant or petitionet may be requited to produce satisfactory evidence that any delinquent real esmte llIXes owed to the City have been paid. (b) Decision-making bodies The bodies, officials, agents, and etnployees of the City, as set forth in Colwnn (C) of Table 510-1, shall be designated as the body or official with authority to rendet a detenninarion as to the approval, approval with conditions, or denial of the applications for development approval set forth in Colwnn (A). The bodies, officials, agents, and etnployees of the City, as set forth in Colwnn (B) of Table 510-1, are designated as the body or official with authority to submit a recommendation relating to the application for development approval to the body with final decision-making authority (the ''Decision-maker''). Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 98 Article 5 Table 510-L Recommending and Decision-making Bodies (A) (8) (q ACfION REQUESTED RECOMMENDING DECISION-MAKER BODY OR OFFICIAL Zoning Permit Zoning Administtator Certificate of Occupancy -- Zoning Administtator Certificate of Appropriateoess Agent to Architectural Review Board Arcbitectural Review Board Comprehensive Plan Amendment Planning Commission City Council Zoning Amendment Planning Commission City Council Conditional Rezoning Planning Commission City Council Basic Development Plan -- Zoning Administtator Comprehensive Development Plan - Agent to Planning Commission or Planning Commission Special Exception Zoning Administtator Board of Zoning Appeals Variance - Board of Zoning Appeals Appeal - Board of Zoning Appeals (c) (1) Notice provisions Notice requirements shall be as prescribed in the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, and as may be further prescribed in the individual subsections of this Article. (2) The reviewing body may mke any action on the petition or applicarion that is consisteot with the notice given, including approval of the petition or application, approval of the petition or application as amended, or denial of the petition or application. The reviewing body may allow amendments to the petition or application if the effect of the amendments is to allow a lesser change than that requested on the original petition or application or to reduce the impact of the development or to reduce the amount of land involved from that indicated in the notices of the hearing. The reviewing body shall not, in any case, permit a greatet intensity of development, or a use falling in a diffetent general use category, or a larger land area than indicated in the o:dginal petition or application, or a greater variance than was indicated in the notice. (d) Public hearings The purpose of a public hearing is to allow the applicant or petitionet and all othet interested parries a meaningful and fair opportunity to be heard, to present evidence relevant to the application or petition, and to rebut evidence presented by othetS. All hearings undet this secrion shall be open to the public and shall be conducted in an impatria\ mannet. The conduct of a public hearing before the Planning Commission, the Board of Zoning Appeals, or the City Council shall be as set forth in the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, and othet applicable secrions of this Article. Whete appropriate, additional rules governing the public hearing may apply, including the provisions of othet chapters of this Code applicable to the body conducting the hearing and any of the body's adopted rules or procedures. The body conducting the hearing may adopt rules of procedure to limit the rime for each presenmtion or each speaker. The body conducting the hearing shall record the minutes of the proceedings by any appropriate means as prescribed by rule and consisteot with VIrginia law. 36.2-511 Post-Decision Proceedings Any person, including any officer or body of the City, aggrieved by a final administrative determination on a development permit or administrative development approval by the Zoning Administtator or final decision-maker may appeal such final determination to the appellate body designated by this Article, if any, in the manner provided in this Article. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 99 Article 5 Division 2. Administrative Permits 36.2-520 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to esmblish procedures for permits which do not require administtative or legislative notice, or a public hearing. A public hearing is not requited for permits set forth in this Division for one or more of the following reasons: (a) Public hearings have already been conducted relating to the permit application, and the permit applicarion procedure for a zoning permit or CertiJicate of Occupancy is desigoed to ensure that the proposed use complies with a previously approved subdivision plat, development plan, or conditional rezoning; or (b) The proposed use is permitted as of right in the applicable zoning district 36.2-521 General Applicability No development may be undett>tken unless all applicable permits are issued in accordance with this Chapter. At a minimum, no development may occur until a zoning permit has been obmined from the Zoning Administtator and a building permit is obmined from the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development 36.2-522 Zoning Permits (a) Applicability (1) No person shall erect, construct, reconstruct, move, detnolisb, add to, or structurally alter any structure without a zoning permit issued by the Zoning Administrator. (2) The use of a property shall not be changed, and cleating, grading, or excavating shall not be conunenced, without a zoning permit issued by the Zoning Administtator. (3) A zoning permit shall not be issued by the Zoning Administrator except in strict conformity with this Chaptet. Where development plan review is required, no zoning permit shall be issued until such plan has been approved. (b) (1) Procedures An application for a zoning permit shall be submitted to the Zoning Administrator prior to the issuance or consideration of issuance of any pennit. (2) One (1) copy of the application and accompanying plans shall be returned to the applicant by the Zoning Administrator, after the Zoning Administtator shall have marked such copy as eithet approved, approved subject to condirions, or disapproved, and attested to the same by signature. (3) If a zoning permit is denied, reasons for the denial shall be smted upon the application. (c) (1) Scope Zoning permits issued undet the provisions of this Chapter, on the basis of applications and plans approved by the Zoning Administtator, and other officials and botlies where additional approval is required, are deetned to authorize only the use, arrangement, location, and construction indicated in such approved plans and application, and no other. Any use, arrangement, location, or construction not in compliance with such authorization shall be deemed a violarion of this Chapter. (2) If the work described in any zoning permit has not begun within six (6) months from the date ir was issued, or within the rime limits esmblished by a special exception or variance, the permir shall expire. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 100 ArtIcle 5 (A) Upon wrilteo application submitted by the original applicant, or his successors in title or under law, within ninety (90) calendar days after the expiration of the original zoning permit, the Zoning Administrator may issue a new zoning permit for work other than that involving a variance or special exception, using the original application and plans, if in the opinion of the Zoning Administrator such original application and plans are still adequate. The Zoning Administtator may not issue a zoning permit extending rime limits set by the Board of Zoning Appeals, except on specific omet of the Board. (B) Failure of a p=on to apply for a new zoning permit within ninety (90) calendar days after expiration of the original zoning permit shall cause the Zoning Administtator to order such work on the premises involved as may be necessary to remedy conditions wbich would, in the opinion of the Zoning Administtator, cause imminent peril to life or property. The failure of any person who was the original applicant for a zoning permit, or who is the successor in tide or undet law to the original applicant, to do work ordered in such case shall be consideted a violarion of this Chapter. In addirion to othet remedies and penalties, the Zoning Administrator may, in such cases, order such work done, with chatges to be assessed, undet procedures provided by law, against the property. 36.2-523 Certificates of Occupancy (a) Applicability (1) New or altered uses: (A) It shall be unlawful to use or occupy any structure or land, individually or in combination, in whole or in part, in which or on which a new use is created or an existing use is changed, converted, enlarged, or moved, until a Certificate of Occupancy is issued. (B) If a zoning permit was not obmined prior to the application for a Certificate of Occupancy, such certificate shall not be issued until approval has been obmined from the City Engineet, or his agent, for changes to or usage of publicly dedicated street rights-of-way. (C) A tetnporary Certificate of Occupancy may be issued by the Zoning Administrator for a period not exceeding six (6) months during alterations or partial occupancy of a structure pending completion, provided such temporary certificate may require such conditions and safeguards as will protect the safety of the occupants and the public. (2) Nonconforming uses: No person shall renew or resume after discontinuance or abandonment, or change, move, enlarge upon, expand, or extend, any nonconforming use of any land or structure, individually or in combination, in whole or in part, unless and until a Certificate of Occupancy for such use shall have been issued by the Zoning Administtator. (b) (1) Procedures Application for a Certificate of Occupancy shall be made to the Zoning Administtator before any permit shall be issued for the erection, conversion, moving, or enlargement of any structure, or for the creation of a new use or change of use of any land or premises. (2) A Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued only upon completion of the work in confonnity with the provisions of this Olapter, after inspecrion by the Zoning Administtator indicates that the use and occupancy are in compliance with the application and the provisions of this Olapter. Such application for new uses or altered uses shall require the approval by signature of the Zoning Administtator. (3) The Board of Zoning Appeals shall bave the authority to and may, pursuant to the procedures provided in Section 36.2-561 for authorization of variances, upon appeal of an applicant to the Zoning Administtator for a Certificate of Occupancy for a nonconforming use, and upon showing made to the Board that the nonconfonning use was existing on or prior to the effective date of this Chapter, or prior to a subsequent amendment of this Olapter making such use nonconfonning, that it haz not been discontioued for a period Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 101 Article 5 of rime exceeding two (2) years aftet the aforesaid date, and that such use is not detrimental to the neighbothood, direct the issuance by the Zoning Administrator of a Certificate of Occupancy for such nonconforming use. (c) Scope Certificates of Occupancy issued undet the provisions of this Chapter, on the basis of applications and plans approved by the Zoning Administrator, and other officials and bodies whete additional approval is required, are deemed to authorize only the use, arrangement, location, and consttucrion indicated in such approved plans and application, and no other. Any use, arrangement, location, or construction not in compliance with such authorization shall be deemed a violation of this Chapter. (d) Records The Zoning Administrator shall mainmin a record of all Certificates of Occupancy, and a copy shall be furnished to any person on request Division 3. Certificates of Appropriateness 36.2-530 Certificates of Appropriateness (a) Purpose This section is designed to encourage the preservation and enhanCetnent of the City's historic districts and encourage rehabilitation and new consttuction in conformance with the existing scale and character of the districts. (b) (1) Applicability Within the H-l or H-2 Oveday District, no structure or historic landmark shall be etected, reconstructed, altered, demolished, moved, or restored until a Certificate of Appropriateoess has been issued by the Architectural Review Board or, on appeal, by the City CounciL (2) No Certificate of Appropriateoess shall be issued unless the Architectural Review Board, or the City Council on appeal, finds that the proposed eteetion, reconstruction, alteration, or restoration is atCbitecturally compatible with the structures or bistoric landmarks in the applicable bistoric district. (3) Where a Certificate of Appropriateness is requited by this section, the Zoning Administrator shall not issue a pennit for the erection, reconstruction, alteration, restoration, demolition, or moving of any structure or biSlOnc landmark until such certificate has been issued. Once the pemUt bas been issued, the work shall be routinely inspected to ensure compliance with the tetmS of the Certificate of Appropriateness. (4) Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent the ordinary mainteoance of any structure or historic landmark in the H-l or H-2 Oveday District. For the purposes of this section, "ordinary mainteoance" means any activity relating to a structure or landmark which constitutes a minor repair of any element of a structure or landmark which is, or should be, performed on a regular and relatively frequent basis to mainmin architectural and structural integtity. The determination of whether an activity constitutes ordinary maintenance, or whether an installation or modification otherwise requires a Certificate of Appropriateness undet this section, shall be made by the Zoning Administrator in consulmtion with the Agent to the Architectural Review Board (A) In the H-l Overlay District, painting shall be deetned ordinary maintenance, provided that the color of a structure is nor changed; however, changing the color of paint or the painting of previously unpainted masonry surfaces shall require a Certificate of Appropriateness. (B) In the H-2 Overlay District, painting shall be deetned ordinary maintenance; however, painting of previously unpainted masonry surfaces shall require a Certificate of Appropriateness. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 102 Article 5 (C) In the H-2 Overlay District, the replacetnent of potches, stairs, awnings, roofing materials, or windows, or other similar modifications to an eletnent of a structure or landmark, shall be deemed ordinary mainrenance, provided that such replacetnent is performed using materials that are of the same desigo as those on the structure or landmark, and provided that such replacetnent mainmins the architectural defining features of the structure or landmark (5) Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent the detnolition of a structure or historic landmark which the building maintenance code official certifies in writing is requited for public safety because of an unsafe or dangerous condition. (c) (1) Procedures The Architectural Review Boanl may authorize its Agent to issue any Certificate of Appropriateoess. The Agent, pursuant to such delegation, shall act only upon an application completed pursuant to the applicable district regularions, and shall apply the same guidelines and review smndards applicable to the Board Any person aggrieved by any decision of the Agent made pursuant to this delegarion may appeal to the Architectural Review Board by filing with the Boanl a notice of appeal specifying the grounds theteOf within thirty (30) calendar days from when the decision is rendeted by the Agent (2) In ordet to be heard by the Architectural Review Board at its next regular meeting, a complete applicarion for a Certificate of Appropriateness shall be made to the Secretary to the Board, on forms provided, at least fifteen (15) calendar days prior to the next scheduled meeting. In the event of an appeal pursuant to subsection (1), above, a notice of appeal shall be filed with the Secretary to the Board at least fifteen (15) calendar days prior to the next scheduled meeting. (3) The Architectural Review Board shall vote and announce its decision on any matter not later than fifteen (15) calendar days aftet the conclusinn of the hearing on the matter unless the time is extended with the written consent of the applicant. The Boanl shall not reconsider any decision made by it, except as provided for in this section. Having once consideted an application, the Board sball not bear subsmntially the same applicarion for one (1) year. (4) In the case of disapproval of an application before the Architectural Review Board, the Board shall briefly smte its reasons in writing, and it may make recommendations to the applicant In the case of disapproval accompanied by recommendations, the applicant may ag.Un be heard before the Board, if an amended application that addresses the recommendations of the Board is filed by the applicant within ninety (90) calendar days. (5) Any property ownet aggrieved by any decision of the Architectural Review Board may present to the City Council a petition appealing such decision, provided such petition is filed within thirty (30) calendar days after the decision is rendeted by the Board. The City Council shall schedule a public hearing and rendet a decision on the mattet within sixty (60) calendar days of the receipt of the petition, unless the property ownet and the Agent to the Architectural Review Boanl agree to an extension. The City Council may affinn the decision of the Board, reverse or modify the Board's decision, in whole or in part, or refer the matter back to the Board. (6) Upon approval by the Architectural Review Board, or the City Council on appeal, of any erection, reconstruction, alteration, restoration, or detnolition, a Certificate of Appropriateoess shall be made available to the applicant (J) In the event City Council denies an appeal of a decision of the Architectural Review Board, the applicant may file an appeal in Circuit Court pursuant to subsection (d), below. (d) Appeals from City Council decision Any property ownet aggrieved by any final decision of the City Council pursuant to this section may present to the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke a petirion sening forth the alleged illegality of the acrion of the City Council, provided such petition is filed within thirty (30) calendar days aftet the final decision is rendeted by the City Council Zcnlng Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 103 Article 5 The filing of such petition shall smy any acrion pursuant to the decision of the City Council pending the outcome of the appeal to the court, except that the filing of such petition shall not smy any acrion pursuant to the decision of the City Council if such decision denies the right to detnolisb a structure or bistoric landmark. The court may reverse or modify the decision of City Council, in whole or in part, if it finds upon review that the decision of the City Council is contrary to law or that its decision is arbitrary and constitutes an abuse of discretion, or the court may affian the decision of the City Council. (e) Scope A Certificate of Appropriateoess is valid for a period of one (1) year from the date of the action of the Architectural Review Board or the City Council on appeal. (f) (1) Demolition; offer to sell In addirion to the right of appeal of the City Council's decision as set forth in Section 36.2-S30(d), the owner of a structure or historic landmark within the H-l or H-2 Overlay District, the detnolition of wbich is subject to this section, shall have the right to detnolish such structure or landmark provided that (A) The property owner has applied to the City Council for such right; and (B) The ownet has for the period of time set forth in the time schedule esmblisbed in subsection (2) below, and at a price not more than its fair market value, made a bona fide offer to sell such structure or landmark and the land pettaining thereto, to the City, or to any person, firm, cotporation, or government or agency thereof, which gives reasonable assurance that it is willing to preserve and restore the structure or landmark and the land petmining theteto; and (C) No bona fide contract binding upon all parties theteto, shall have been executed for the sale of any such structure or landmark and the land petmining thereto, prior to the expiration of the applicable time period set forth in the time schedule in subsection (2), below. (2) The time schedule for offers to sell shall be as follows: (A) Three (3) months when the offeting price is less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000.00); (B) Four (4) months when the offeting price is twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000.00) or more but less than forty thousand dollars ($40,000.00); (C) Five (5) months when the offeting price is forty thousand dollars ($40,000.00) or more but less than fifty-five thousand dollars ($55,000.00); (I)) Six (6) months when the offeting price is fifty-five thousand dollars ($55,000.00) or more but less than seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000.00); (E) Seven \I) months when the offeting price is seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000.00) or more but less than ninety thousand dollars ($90,000.00); and (F) Twelve (12) months when the offeting price is ninety thousand dollars ($90,000.00) or more. (3) Before making a bona fide offet to sell, as provided above, an owner shall first file a smtement with the Secremry to the Arcbitectural Review Board identifying the property and smting the offeting price, the date the offet of sale is to begin, and the name of the real esmte agent No time period as set forth in the sebedule in subsection (2), above, shall begin to run until such smtetnent has been filed. Within fourteen (14) business days of receipt of such smtetnent, the Secremry to the Board shall distribute copies to the City Council, the Architectural Review Board, and the City Manager. Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 104 Article 5 (4) Such bona fide offet to sell, in accordance with the provisions of this section, must be made within one (1) year after a final decision by the City Council. If not, an ownet must renew his request to the City Council to approve such demolition in order to demolish a structure or historic landmark. (5) Any appeal mken pursuant to Section 36.2-S30(d), shall not affect the right of the ownet of a structure or bistoric landmark to make the bona fide offer to sell refetted to above. Division 4. Zoning Amendments and Conditional Rezoning 36.2-540 Zoning Amendments (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to establish procedures for initiating and processing petitions to amend the provisions of this Chapter and to amend the Official Zoning Map. (b) Applicability Whenevet the public necessity, convenience, genetal welfare, or good zoning pracrice requires, the City Council may by ordinance amend, suppletnent, or change this Chapter, including the text and the Official Zoning Map. Any such amendment may be initiated by resolution of the City Council or by motion of the Planning Commission. An amendment to the Official Zoning Map may be initiated by petition of the ownet, conttact purchaset with the owner's written consent, or the ownet'S agent of the property which is the subject of the proposed zoning map amendment (c) (1) Procedures; filing of petition Prior to the filing of a petition to amend the Official Zoning Map, the petitionet shall meet with the Zoning Administrator to determine that all filing requirements bave been met and that all information is conect. (2) A petition to rezone property shall be in writing, addressed to the City Council, and filed in the Office of the City Clerk, accompanied by payment of all fees and charges esmblisbed by the City Council. (3) A petition for the rezoning of propetty shall include the following: (A) A description of the purpose for the requested zoning district classification and the proposed use of the property; (B) A concept plan outlining features of the proposed use of the property including buildings, parking, access, and similar features; (C) A map or maps of the area requested for rezooing; (I)) Names, signatures, and addresses of the ownet or owners of the lots or property included in the proposed change; and (E) Names, addresses, and officiallllX numbers of owners of the lots or property immediately adjacent to and those directly opposite theteto; provided, however, that inaccuracy or inadequacy of any such list of adjacent ownetS shall not in any manuet affect the validity of any proceedings had or mken by the City Council with respect to the matters conmined in such petition. (4) Upon the filing of such petition, and the payment of all applicable fees and charges, the City Clerk sball note the filing of the same and shall immediately transmit the petirion to the Planning Commission for study, report, and recommendation to the City Council, with a copy of such petition mailed or delivered to the mayor and metnbers of the City Council and to the Zoning Administtator. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 105 Article 5 (5) Once City Council has consideted a petition, a peritionet may not request consideration of subsmntially the same peririon for one (1) year. Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit City Council's ability to reconsidet a petition under Rule 10 of Section 2-15, Rules of procedure. of this Code. (d) (1) Planning Commission action All proposed amendments to this Chapter shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for consideration and recommendarion. The Planning Commission shall study proposals to determine: (A) The need and justification for the change; (B) When pettaining to a change in the district classification of property, the effect of the change, if any, on the property and on the surrounding neighborhood; (C) When pettaining to a change in the district classification of property, the amount of undeveloped land in the genetal area and in the City having the same district classification as requested; and (I)) The relationship of the proposed amendment to the purposes of the general planning program, with appropriate considetation as to whethet the proposed change will furthet the purposes of this Chapter and the City's Comprehensive Plan. (2) Prior to making recommendations on any proposed amendment to the provisions of this Chapter or to the Official Zoning Map, the Planning Commission shall conduct a public hearing on such proposal, after notice of such hearing is given pursuant to Section 36.2-540(1). (3) Within sixty (60) calendar days from the date that any proposed amendment is refetted to it (unless a longet period shall have been esmblished by mutual agreement between the petitionet and the Planning Commission in the particular case), the Planning Commission shall submit its report and recommendation to the City Council The recommendation of the Planning Commission shall be advisory only and shall not be binding on City Council If the Planning Conunission does not submit its report within the presctibed time, the City Council may proceed to act on the amendment, without further awaiting the recommendation of the Planning Commission. (e) City Council hearing Prior to amending the provisions of this Chapter or the Official Zoning Map, the City Council shall conduct a public hearing on such proposed amendment, after notice of such hearing is given porsuant to Section 36.2-540(1). (f) Notice of hearing Prior to conducting any public hearing requited by this Chapter before the City Council or the Planning Commission, notice shall be given as requited by Section 15.2-2204 of the Code of ViIginia (1950), as amended. The expense of advetrising shall be bome by the applicant Any affidavits requited by Section 152-2204, Code ofVttginia (1950), as amended, shall be filed with the City Oerk. In addition, at least teo (10) business days prior to the public hearing before the Planning Commission, the Zoning Administtator shall etect a sigo indicating the zoning district requested, identification of the subject property, and the time, date, and place of such public hearing as set forth in the schedule below: Scope of Rezoning Petition Sign Posting Requirements Petition to rezone 1-25 llIX parcels, or potrion thereof 1 sigo per street fronmge of contiguous subject llIX pan:els Petition to rezone 26-100 llIX parcels, or portion thereof 1 sign per intersecrionconstituring the perimetet of the area proposed to be rezoned Comprehensive rezoning (oVet 100 properties) No sigo posting required Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 106 Article 5 (g) Amendment after hearing; City Council action After the City Council has held a public hearing, it may make appropriate changes or corrections in the proposed amendment and proceed to act without holding a heating on the proposed amendment in its new form. The City Council shall decide whethet to approve or to deny a petition to amend the provisions of this Chapter or the Official Zoning Map. 36.2-541 Conditional Rezonlngs (a) Purpose The purpose of this section is to implement conditional rezoning authority pursuant to Section 15.2-2296 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, in order to provide for the orderly development of land in a manner that provides for a more flexible and adaptable zoning method to permit differing land uses and at the same time to recognize effects of change. It is the purpose of conditional rezoning to provide a flexible and adaptable zoning method to cope with situations whereby a zoning classification may be allowed subject to certain conditions proffered by the petitioner for the protection of the community that are not generally applicable to land similar1y zoned. (b) Applicability Conditional rezonings may be granted pursuant to the provisions of Sections 15.2-2296 through 15.2-2302, Code of Vrrginia (1950), as amended. A conditional rezoning may be initiated only by petition of the ownet, contract pon:haset with the owners written consent, or the ownet'S agent of the property which is the subject of the proposed zoning map amendment The owner must sign such petition if conditions are proffered. (c) Procedures The procedures for the filing and approval of a conditional rezoning shall be the same as the procedures to amend the Official Zoning Map as set forth in Section 36.2-540, subsections (c) through (I), except as othetwise provided in this section. The acceptance of proffers or other conditions, enforcement, recordation, amendments, and variations of conditions, shall be as set forth in the provisions of Sections 15.2-2296 through 15.2-2303, Code ofVrrginia (1950), as amended. Procedures specifically applicable to a request for a conditional rezoning shall be as foUows: (1) The ownetS of property for wbich a petition is being made for an amendment to the Official Zoning Map may, as part of the petition, voluntarily proffer, in writing, reasonable conditions which shall be in addition to the regulations of the zoning district classification requested by the petirion. Any conditions proffered by petition of a property ownet shall be drafted in such a way that they are clearly undetStood and enforceable and shall adbete to the following smndards: (A) The rezoning itself must give rise for the need for the condirions; (B) The conditions shall have a reasonable relation to the rezoning; (C) The conditions shall not include a cash contribution to the City; (I)) The conditions shall not include mandatory dedication of real or personal property for open space, parks, schools, fire departments, or other public facilities not otherwise provided for in Section 15.2- 2241, Code ofVrrginia (1950), as amended; (E) The conditions shall not include a requirement that the petitioner create a property owners' association under Chaptet 26 (Section 55-508 et seq.) of Tide 55, Code ofVrrginia (1950), as amended; (F) The conditions shall not include payment for or constmction of off-site improvements except those provided for in Section 15.2-2241, Code ofVrrginia (1950), as amended; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 107 Article 5 (G) No condition shall be proffeted that is not related to the physical development or physical operation of the property; and (H) All such conditions shall be in conformity with the City's Comprehensive Plan. (2) Such conditions may be proffeted prior to the public hearing before the Planning Commission. Altematively, or in addition, in considerarion of comments expressed during the Commission deliberations on a petition, the property owner may, prior to the final public hearing conducted by the City Council, choose to proffet original conditions or revised conditions. (d) Approval criteria The decision as to whethet to accept a condition or a proffer shall be consideted a legislative decision, and shall be conunirted to the sole discrerion of the City Council subject to any criteria set forth in the applicable provisions of Sections 15.2-2296 through 15.2-2302, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, or any other applicable provision of smte or fedetallaw. (e) (1) Scope of approval Proffeted conditions shall be consideted supplemental to and in addition to the provisions conmined elsewhere in this Chapter or othet City ordinances and shall not authorize less than full compliance with all other applicable provisions of this Chaptet. (2) Once proffered and accepted by the City Council as part of an amendment to the Official Zoning Map, such conditions shall continue in full force and effect \.Ultil a subsequent amendment changes such conditions or the zoning on the property coVeted by the conditions; however, the conditions shall continue if the subsequent amendment is part of a comprehensive implemenmrion of a new or subsmntially revised zoning ordinance. (3) Conditions once proffeted and accepted by the City Council shall immediately become effective with approval of the petition to amend the Official Zoning Map. Upon approval, any development plan, subdivision plat, or development plan submitted for the development of the property in quesrion shall be in conformance with all proffeted conditions, and no development shall be approved by any City official in the absence of such conformance. (f) Recording of conditions The Official Zoning Map shall show by an appropriate symbol on the map the existence of condirions attached to the zoning district designation on the map. The Zoning Administtator shall keep in the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development and make available for public inspection a conditional zoning index. Such index shall provide ready access to each ordinance creating such conditions. The index shall also provide ready access to all proffeted cash payments and expenditures disclosure reports prepared by the City Council pursuant to Section 15.2- 2303.2, Code ofVuginia (1950), as amended. The Zoning Administtator shall update the index annually and no later than Novetnber of each year. (g) (1) Enforcement of conditions Failure to meet all conditions of a conditional rezoning shall constitute cause to deny the issuance of any requited permit or certificate, as may be appropriate, and to seek such remedy as provided under the terms of this Chapter. The Zoning Administtator (See Section 15.2-2286.4, Code ofVuginia, 1950, as amended) shall be vested with all necessary authority on behalf of the City Council to administer and enforce such condirions as may be attached to an amendment of the Official Zoning Map, including: (A) The ordeting in writing of the remedy of any non-compliance with such conditions; (B) The bringing oflega! action to ensure compliance with such conditions, including injunction, abatement, or othet appropriate acrion or proceeding; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 108 Article 5 (C) Requiring a guarantee, satisfactory to the City Council, in an amount sufficient for and conditioned upon the consttucrion of any physical improvements requited by the condirions, or a conttact for the consttuction of such improvements and the contractor's guarantee, in like amount and so conditioned, which guarantee shall be reduced or released by the Zoning Administtator upon the submission of satisfactory evidence that construction of such improvements has been completed in whole or in part. (2) Any zoning applicant or any other person who is aggrieved by a decision of the Zoning Administtator made pursuant to the provisions of subsection (1), above, may petition the City Council for review of the decision of the Zoning Administrator. All petitions for review shall be filed with the Zoning Administtator and the City Clerk within thirty (30) calendar days from the date of the decision for which review is sought and shall specify the grounds upon which the petitionet is aggrieved. (h) Amendment of conditions Amendment of conditions created pursuant to this secrion shall be made only as an original perition for amendment to the zoning ordinance, pursuant to the procedures set forth in this Division including poblic notice and hearing. Division 5. Development Plans 36.2-550 Purpose The purpose of the development plan regulations is to ensure compliance with the general purposes of this Chapter and the City's Comprehensive Plan. The development plan regulations are intended to mainmin or enhance the character and integrity of residential neighborhoods and commercial and industrial areas by promoting excellence of development, preventing traffic hazards or congestion, preventing undue land or site hazards, and encouraging the most appropriate development and use of land in harmony with the neighborhood. 36.2-551 Development Plans, Generally (a) Applicability (1) All applications for a zoning permit requited pursuant to Section 36.2-522 shall be accompanied by a basic or comprehensive development plan (2) A development plan is inteoded to represent grapbically all components of a proposed development requited for review pursuant to this Division. Development plans may include, whete necessary, written dam or compumtions and additional plans or drawings necessary to explain cleady the proposed development (b) Combination of lots When a basic or comprehensive development plan involves multiple lots of record, internal lot lines sball be vacated, relocated, or othetwise alteted as a part of an othetwise valid and properly recorded plat of subdivision or resubdivision to create a single lot of record. (c) Pre-application meeting Prior to a formal submission of a development plan for review and approval, the applicant should meet with the Zoning Administtator to detetmine whethet a basic or comprehensive development plan is required and what information must be provided. (d) General review guidelines Review of a development plan shall enllli1 considetation of all aspects of the proposed development necessary to carry out the inteot of this Division and shall include a review of. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 109 Article 5 (1) The compatibility of the development with its environment and provision for such things as grading, screening, buffering, lighting, and landscaping; (2) The ability of the development to provide for parking areas and the convenient and safe internal and extemal movetnent of vehicles and pedestrians; and (3) The location and adequacy of necessary drainage, storm watet management, sewage, utilities, and etOsion and sediment control measures. (e) Scope of approval (1) Upon receipt of an approved and signed copy of the development plan, and provided that all other requirements of this Chapter have been met, the Zoning Administtator shall issue a zotting pennit to the applicant (2) An approved basic or comprehensive development plan shall expire and be null and void unless a building pennit has been issued or use of the land has commenced within five (5) years from the date of approval. Upon request, revalidation of the development plan may be granted for an additional six (6) months if all factors of the original development plan review are the same, provided that written notice requesting revalidation shall be received by the Zoning Administtator prior to expiration of the original five-year (S-year) period. (f) Building permits and Certificates of Occupancy All building pennits and Certificates of Occupancy shall require compliance with the provisions of the approved basic or comprehensive development plan. . (g) Phasing In ordet to enforce compliance with permit conditions, a development plan may be approved in phases, subject to a condition that building permits and Certificates of Occupancy in a phase of the development may be withheld subject to compliance Vlith pemrit conditions in a prior phase. 36.2-552 Basic Development Plans (a) Applicability A basic development plan shall be submitted with all zotting pennit applications in the following cases: (1) Construction, reconstruction, moving, or addition to a single-family demched dwelling or pennirted accessory structure and including associated grading and clearing, when development is not in conjunction with the construcrion, reconstruction, moving, or addition to anothet single-family demched dwelling or pennitted accessory structures on the same lot or on an adjacent lot under the same ownership at the time of application; or (2) Construction, reconstruction, moving, or addition to a rwo-family dwelling and including associated grading and clearing, when development is not in conjunction with the construction, reconsttuction, moving, or addition to other two-family dwellings on the same lot or on an adjacent lot under the same m.vnership at the time of application; or (3) Additions to buildings or inteosification of uses not exceeding ten (10) percent of the floor area of a building and whete the number of requited parking spaces is increased no more than three (3) spaces; or (4) Additions of up to, but not more than, four (4) parking spaces; or (5) Additions of less than 2,000 square feet of impervious surfaces othet than rooftops or parking areas. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 110 ArtIcle 5 (b) Filing of plan The applicant shall file a basic development plan with the Zoning Administrator, pursuant to the submittal requirements of Section B-1, Appendix B. (c) Decision The Zoning Administtator shall approve or deny a basic development plan within teo (10) business days. In the case of denial, the Zoning Administtator shall inform the applicant, in writing, of the reasons for denial. (d) Approval criteria Any basic development plan shall comply with all applicable requirements of this Chapter. (e) Amendment of plan If it becomes necessary for an approved basic development plan to be changed, such changes may be made with the approval of the Zoning Administtator. 36.2-553 Comprehensive Development Plans (a) Applicability A comprehensive development plan shall be submitted with all zoning permit applications, except where a basic development plan is requited pursuant to Section 36.2-552. (b) Filing of plan The applicant shall 6le a comprehensive development plan with the Zoning Administtator. Such comprehensive development plan shall be prepared in a clear and legible manner, shall be drawn to scale, and shall comply with the submittal requirements of Section B-2, Appendix B. The comprehensive development plan shall be refetted to the Agent to the Planning Commission for review and approval in accordance with subsecrions (c) and (d), below. (c) (1) Decision The Agenr to the Planning Commission shall approve or disapprove all comprehensive development plaus, except as set out in Section 36.2-SS3(c)(2). (A) The Agent shall process and coordinate the review of comprehensive development plans with the City Engineer, othet applicable departments, and the Westem Virginia Watet Authority. (B) Within fifteen (15) business days aftet the initial submittal of a comprehensive development plan, and within seven (T) business days after a resubmittal, the Agent shall notifY the applicant or his represenmtive, in writing, that (i) The information on the development plan is incomplete, in ettOr, or lacking in detail, and delineate the additional information required or necessary revisions; or (u) The development plan is sufficient in requited information and accuracy and bas been reviewed and approved (2) The Agent to the Planning Commission, the applicant, or the Planning Commission may request that a comprehensive development plan be reviewed and approved by the Planning Commission. (A) If such request is made by the Agent or the Planning Commission, the Agent to the Planning Commission shall notifY the applicant, in writing, within fifteen (15) calendar days of submission or re- submission of a comprehensive development plan that the development plan must be reviewed by the Planning Commission at its next regulady scheduled meeting. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 111 Article 5 (B) All requited plans and information to be submitted to the Planning Commission shall be submitted at least teo (10) business days prior to the scheduled meeting of the Commission. The Agent may prepare a report outlining the various and particular aspects of the plan, with recommendations for the Planning Commission's considetation. (C) The Agent shall inform the applicant, in writing, of the Planning Commission's decision. If the Commission's decision necessimtes revision of the development plan, the applicant shall submit teo (10) copies of the revised development plan to the Agent for final approval. (3) All approved comprehensive development plans shall be signed by the Agent to the Planning Commission, the Zoning Administtator, and the City Development Engineet. (d) (1) Approval criteria The comprehensive development plan shall comply with all applicable requirements of this Chapter. (2) Whete etOsion and sediment controls for the development are requited by the provisions of Chaptet 11.1, Erosion and Sediment Contro~ of this Code, an etOsion and sediment control plan shall be implemented. The design of all drainage improvements shall conform to Chapter 11.2, Stormwater Management, of this Code. (e) Amendment of plan If it becomes necessary for an approved comprehensive development plan to be changed, such changes may be made with the approval of the Zoning Administtator, the Agent to the Planning Commission, and the City Development Engineet. If a proposed change will, in the opinion of the Zoning Administtator, the Agent to the Planning Commission, or the City Development Engineet, subsmntially affect the tetmS of the original approval, a new plan may be requited to be drawn and submitted for review and acrion in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter. Division 6. Special Exceptions, Variances, and Appeals 36.2-560 Special Exceptions (a) Applicability The Board of Zoning Appeals shall bave the power to hear and decide on applications for such special exceptions as may be authorized by this Chapter. (b) (1) Procedures Applications for special exceptions may be made by any property ownet, teoant, government official, department, board, or bureau. Such application shall be filed with the Zoning Administrator in accordance with rules adopted by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Upon receipt of a complete application for a special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall hold a public bearing aftet giving notice as provided in Section 15.2-2204, Code ofVu:ginia (1950), as amended. However, when giving any requited notice to the ownetS, their agents, or the occupants of abutting property and property immediately across the street or road from the property affected, the Board may give such notice by first-class mail rathet than by registeted or certified mai1. No special exception shall be authorized except after such application, notice, and public bearing. The expense oflega! advertisement shall be bome by the applicant (2) Once the Board considetS and rendets a decision on an application for a special exceprion, the Board shall not considet subsmntially the same request within one (1) year, except when such decision is the subject of a motion to rehear. Any such motion to rehear shall be in accordance with rules adopted by the Board of Zoning Appeals. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 112 Article 5 (c) Standards In consideting an application for a special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall determine the appropriateoess of the application based on the following smndards: (1) The use is compatible with the character and appearance of the surrounding neighborhood by vittue of its height, bulk, location on the lot, and the design and location of parking, signage, landscaping, and other outside activities or structures; (2) The use does not create a detnand on public water or sanimry sCWet services that exceeds the design capacity of these systems or that would in any way decrease the quality of service to the surrounding neighbothood; (3) The use does not generate traffic on public streets that exceeds the design capacity of such streets and does not create a dangerous traffic probletn by vittue of driveway location, site clearance, driveway slope, or othet factor; (4) The use does not increase the flood potenrial in the surrounding neighbothood; (5) The use is in conformance with the setback, y:ud, fronmge, lot area, parking, signage, screening, shading, and othet applicable requirements of this Chapter as they pettain to the district in which the use is located or to the specific use, whichevet the case may be; and (6) The use furtbetS the intent of the City's Comprehensive Plan. (d) (1) Scope of approval In authorizing a special exception, the Board of Zoning Appeals may impose such condirions relating to the use for which a pennit is granted as it may deem necessary in the public interest, including limiting the durarion of a pennit, and may require a guarantee to ensure compliance with the conditions imposed. (2) Construcrion shall begin or the use of land for which a special exception has been obmined shall commence within twelve (12) months from the effective date of such permit; othetwise, such pennit shall be void (3) In the event that the use allowed by a special exception is discontinued for a period of two (2) consecutive years, the special exception permit shall become void (e) (1) Revocation The Board of Zoning Appeals may revoke a special exception previously granted if the Board determines that thete has not been compliance with the terms or condirions of the pennit No special exceprion may be revoked except aftet notice and hearing as provided by Section 15.2-2204, Code of Vttginia (1950), as amended. However, when giving any required notice to the owners, their agents, or the occupants of abuning propetty and property immediately across the street or road from the property affected, the Board may give such notice by first-class mail rather than by registered or certified mail (2) A decision to revoke a special exception shall become final thirty (30) calendar days after the date the decision is tendeted, unless appealed. After such effective date of revocation, any activities continuing pursuant to such pennit shall be deetned to be in violation of this Chapter. (3) The right to revoke a special exception permit, as provided in this subsection, shall be cumulative to any othet remedy allowed by law. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 113 Article 5 36.2-561 Variances (a) Applicability The Board of Zoning Appeals sball have the power to authorize, upon appeal or original applicarion in specific cases, variances from the terms of this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures and smndanls set forth in this section. (b) (1) Procedures Applications for variances may be made by any property owner, tenant, government official, department, board, or bureau. Such applicarion for a variance shall be filed with the Zoning Administtator. Upon receipt of a complete application for a variance, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall hold a public hearing after giving notice as provided in Section 15.2-2204, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. However, when giving any required norlce to the ownetS, their agents, or the occupants of abutting property and property immediately across the street or road from the property affected, the Board may give such notice by first-class mail rathet than by registered or certified mail. No variance shall be authorized except aftet such appeal, notice, and public hearing. The expense of legal advertisement shall be bome by the applicant (2) During such public hearing, the chair of the Board of Zoning Appeals, or the acting chair in the absence of the chair, may administer oaths and compel the attendance of wi1nesses. The Board of Zoning Appeals shall keep recordings, transcripts, minutes, or other records of its proceedings on variances sufficient to make possible court determinations on appeal as to the validity of its findings and its reasons thetefor. Such minutes and records of official acrions shall be filed in the office of the Zoning Administtator and shall be public records. (3) Following the close of the public hearing, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall rendet a decision, denying or granting with or without conditions the variance. pursuant to the standards and procedures set forth in Section 36.2-S61(c), (d), and (e). The concurring vote of four (4) metnbers of the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be necessary to effect any variance from this Chapter. (4) Once the Board considetS and rendetS a decision on a variance, the Board shall not considet substantially the same request for one (1) year, except when such decision is the subject of a morion to rehear. Any such motion to rehear shall be in accordance with rules adopted by the Board of Zoning Appeals (c) Standards Subject to the smndanls and procedures set forth in this section, the Board of Zoning Appeals may grant a variance from the terms of this Chapter as will not be conttary to the public interest when, owing to special condirions, a literal enforcetnent of the provisions of this Chapter will result in unnecessary hardship, provided that the spirit of the Chaptet shall be observed and subsmnrial justice done. No variance shall be authorized pursuant to this Chaptet unless the applicant can show that the property was acquired in good faith and that the literal applicarion of the provisions of this Chapter would create an unnecessary hardship that would effectively probibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. The applicant shall provide evidence that the variance being sought satisfies this genetal smndard and those smndanls set forth as follows: (1) The subject property is exceptiotral as compared to other lots subject to the same provision by reason of a unique physical condition, including exceptional narrowness, shallowness, size, or shape; exceptional topographic conditions; or othet extraordinary situation or condition peculiar to and inbetent in the subject property, or to the condition, use, or development of property immediately adjacent theteto. (2) The unique physical condition set forth in subsection (1), above, is not the result of any action or inacrion of the owner or his predecessors in title and existed at the rime of the effective date of the provisions of this Chapter from which a variance is sought (3) The alleged hardsbip is a clearly detnonstrable bardsbip approaching confiscation, as distinguished from a special privilege or conVettience sought by the applicant. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 114 Article 5 (4) The requested variance would not result in a use or development of the subject property that would not be in harmony with the intended spirit and purpose of this Chapter. (d) Findings of the Board U pon the evidence heard by the Board of Zoning Appeals, the Board shall authorize a variance only if it makes all five (5) of the following findings: (1) That the strict application of this Chapter would produce undue hardship; (2) That such hardship is not shared generally by othet properties in the same roning district and the same vicinity; (3) That the authorization of such variance will not be of subsmnrial detriment to adjacent property and that the character of the district will not be changed by the granting of the variance; (4) That the condition or situation of the property conCetned or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a genetal regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this Chapter; and (5) That the variance is no greater than the minimum variation necessary to relieve the unnecessary hardship detnonstrated by the applicant. The Board of Zoning Appeals shall not grant a variance to pennit a use in a district not authorized by that districts regulations. (e) Conditions and guarantees In authorizing a variance, the Board may impose such conditions regarding the location, character, and othet features of the proposed structure or use as it may deem necessary in the public interest, and may require a guarantee to ensure compliance with the conditions imposed. 36.2-562 Appeals to Board of Zoning Appeals (a) Applicability The Board of Zoning Appeals shall have the powet to hear and decide appeals from any ordet, requirement, decision, or detetminarion made by the Zoning Administtator in the administration or enforcement of this Chaptet, except as provided in Section 36.2-541 (g)(2). (b) (1) Procedures An appeal to the Board of Zoning Appeals may be mken by any person aggrieved or by any officet, department, board, or bureau of the City affected by any decision of the Zoning Administtator. Such notice of appeal, specifying the grounds theteof, shall be filed with the Board within thirty (30) calendar days after the date of the decision for which the appeal is filed. If not appealed within thirty (30) calendar days, the decision shall be final and unappealable. Upon notice of appeal, the Zoning Administtator shall transmit to the Board all the pap= constituting the record upon which the action appealed from was mken. (2) An appeal shall smy all proceedings in furthetance of the action appealed from unless the Zoning Administtator certifies to the Board, after the notice of appeal shall have been filed, that by reason of facts smted in writing to the Board, a smy would, in the Zoning Administtator's opinion, cause imminent peril to life or property. In such case, proceedings shall not be smyed othet than by an ordet granted by the Circuit Court upon notice to the Board and to the Zoning Administtator, and for due cause shown. (3) Upon receipt of a notice of appeal, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall fix a reasonable rime for the hearing of the appeal and make its decision within ninety (90) calendar days of the filing of the appeal Notice of the Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 115 Article 5 public heating shall be given as provided by Section 15.2-2204, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. However, when giving any required notice to the owners, their agents, or the occopants of abutting property and property immediately across the street or road from the property affected, the Board may give such notice by first-class mail rathet than by registered or certified mail (4) Following the hearing, the Board of Zoning Appeals shall rendet a decision on the appeal Such decision may revetse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify the appealed ordet, requirement, decision, or determination of the Zoning Administtator. The concucting vote of four (4) members of the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be necessary to reverse any ordet, requirement, decision, or detetmination of the Zoning Administrator. The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings and othet official actions which shall be filed in the office of the Zoning Administtator and shall be public records. The Chair of the Board, or the acting Chair in the absence of the Chair, may administer oaths and compel the alteodance of witnesses. (5) Once the Board considers and rendetS a decision on an appeal, the Board shall not considet subsmntially the same request for one (1) year, except when such decision is the subject of a motion to rehear. Any such motion to rehear sball be in accordance with rules adopted by the Board of Zoning Appeals. (c) Standards The decision on such appeal of any ordet, requirement, decision, or determination made by the Zoning Administrator in the administtation or enfotcement of this Chapter shall be based on the Board's judgment of whethet the Zoning Administtator was correct. The Board shall considet the purpose and inteot of any applicable ordinances, laws, and regulations in making its decision. 36.2-563 Appeals from Board of Zoning Appeals (a) Any person or persons joindy or sevetally aggrieved by any decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals, or any aggrieved llIXpayet or any officer, department, board, or bureau of the City, may file with the Clerk of the Circuit Court for the City a petition specifying the grounds on which aggrieved within thitty (30) calendar days after the final decision of the Board. (b) Upon the presenmtion of such petition, the court shall allow a writ of certiorari to review the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals and shall preseribe thetein the time within which a return theteto must be made and served upon the relator's artomey, which shall not be less than teo (10) calendar days and may be extended by the court The allowance of the writ shall not smy proceedings upon the decision appealed &om, but the court may, on application, on notice to the Board and on due cause shown. grant a restraining order. (c) The Board of Zoning Appeals shall not be required to return the original papers acted upon by it but it shall be sufficient to return certified or sworn copies theteOf or of the portions thereof as may be called for by the writ The return shall concisely set forth such other facts as may be pertinent and material to show the grounds of the decision appealed from and shall be verified. (d) If, upon the hearing, it shall appear to the court that testimony is necessary for the proper disposition of the matter, it may take evidence or appoint a commissioner to take evidence as it may direct and report the evidence to the court with bis findings of fact and conclusions of law, wbich shall constitute a part of the proceedings upon which the determination of the court shall be made. The court may reverse or affirm, wholly or pardy, or may modify the decision brought up for review. (e) In the case of an appeal from the Board of Zoning Appeals to the Circuit Court of an ordet, requirement, decision, or determination of the Zoning Administrator or other administtative officet in the administtation or enforcement of any ordinance or provision of smre law, the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be presumed to be correct. The appealing party may rebut that resumprion by proving by a preponderance of the evidence, including the record before the Board of Zoning Appeals that the Board of Zoning Appeals erred in its decision. Any party may introduce evidence in the proceedings in the court Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 116 Article 5 (I) In the case of an appeal by a person of any decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals that denied or granted an application for a variance, or application for a special exception, the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be presumed to be correct. The petitionet may rebut that presumption by showing to the satisfacrion of the court that the Board of Zoning Appeals applied erroneous principles of law, or where the discretion of the Board of Zoning Appeals is involved, the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals was plainly wrong and in violation of the purpose and intent of the zoning ordinance. (g) Costs shall not be allowed against the Board, unless it shall appear to the court that ir acted in bad faith or with malice in making the decision appealed from. In the event the decision of the Board is aflinned and the court finds that the appeal was frivolous, the court may ordet the person or persons who requested the issuance of the writ of cetrlorari to pay the costs incurred in making the return of the record pursuant to the writ of certiorari. If the petition is withdrawn subsequent to the filing of the return, the Board may request that the court hear the matter on the question of whether the appeal was frivolous. Division 7. Enforcement 36.2-570 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to ensure that this Chapter is observed when development occurs. 1his Division provides remedies for the City when violations occur and implements the policy of the Comprehensive Plan to increase compliance with zoning regulations. 36.2-571 Zoning Violations (a) (1) Generally The Zoning Administtator shall enforce the requirements of this Chapter. The remedies provided in this Division for violations of any provision of this Chapter, or regulation adopted pursuant to this Chapter, shall be cumulative and shall be in addition to any othet remedy provided by law. Except as othetwise provided in this Chaptet, any development or use initiated aftet adoption of this Chapter, or mainmined in violation of this Chaptet, which is not in compliance with this Chaptet is probibited and is referred to as an unlawful development or use. (2) Whenevet the Zoning Administtator receives a complaint alleging a violation of this Chapter, the Zoning Administrator shall investigate the complaint and take such action as is '\V3.tnU1ted in accordance with the provisions set forth in this secrion. (b) Procedures upon discovery of violation If the Zoning Administrator finds that any provision of this Chapter is being violated, the Zoning Administrator shall provide a written notice to the person responsible for such violation, indicating the nature of the violation and ordering the action necessary to correct it. (c) (1) Penalties Violating, causing, or permining the violation of, or failure to comply with any of the requirements of; this Chapter, including violations of any conditions esmblisbed in connection with grants of variances, conditional rezonings, special exceptions, or the issuance of zoning permits or development plan approval, by any person, linn, or corporation, whethet as principal, agent, ownet, lessee, etnployee, or other similar position, shall be unlawful and is subject to the following: (1\.) Criminal Sanctions: Any violation shall be a misdetneanor punishable, upon conviction, as provided in Section lS.2-2286.A.5, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended Zoning Ordlnanco - City of Roanoke 12/05105 117 Article 5 (Bl Injunctive Relief. Any violation or attempted violarion of this Chapter may be resttained, corrected, or abated, as the case may be, by injuncrion or othet appropriate proceeding for relief, alone or in conjunction with any criminal action. (2) Each day that any violation continues after notification by the Zouing Administtator shall be consideted a separate offense for purposes of the penalties and remedies specified in this section. (d) (1) Revocation of permit or approval This secrion shall apply to any situation whete the applicant has supplied materially misIel>~;ng information relating to the approval of a permit issued by the Zoning Administtator. (2) If the Zoning Administtator detetmines that there are reasonable grounds for revocarion of a development permit or approval, the Zoning Administtator shall notify the permit holdet in writing. Such notice shall inform the permit holder of the alleged grounds for the revocation and shall include specific reasons or findings of fact that support the revocation. Revocation of a permit by the Zoning Administtator may be appealed to the Board of Zoning Appeals as set forth in Section 36.2-562. (3) A decision to revoke a development permit shall become final thirty (30) calendar days after the date the decision is rendeted, unless appealed. After such effective date of revocation, any activities continuing pursuant to such permit shall be deemed to be in violation of this Chapter. (4) The right to revoke a development permit, as provided in this section, shall be cumulative to any othet remedy allowed by law. Zoning Ordlnence - City of Roanoke 12/05105 118 Article 5 Development Standards 36.2-600 Applicability This Article applies to any application for a zoning pemUt or development plan approval. Division 1. Utilities 36.2-610 Utilities In all zoning districts, all utility service laterals or service lines associated with a basic or comprehensive development plan shall be located underground; however, utility service laterals or service lines may be located above ground to the point of connection when routed directly to the rear of the structure by way of an alley or utility easement where there are existing overhead distribution lines. Division 2. Outdoor Lighting 36.2-620 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to promote the genetal welfare by controlling light trespass and to protect the public safety through the prevention of glare by regulating the size, height, and placement of outdoor lighting in a manner that (a) Is consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan policy of reducing light pollution, parriculady in residential neighbothoods; (b) Permits the reasonable use of outdoor lighting for safety, utility, commetce, and security; (c) Minimizes glare and obtrusive light on public streets and adjacent properties by limiting outdoor lighting that is misdirected; and (d) Protects residential neighborhoods by limiting light trespass. 36.2-621 Applicability (a) The regulations of this Division shall apply to any outdoor lighting installed or replaced in associarion with: (1) A basic deveiopmentplan; (2) A comprehensive development plan; Zoning Ordlnence - City of Roanoke 12/05105 118 Article 6 (3) The eteetion of a new light support structure exceeding eight (8) feet in height in any zoning distric~ (4) New flood lights or spotlights attached to existing structures in residentially zoned districts; or (5) New lighting fixtures attached to existing structures in non-residentially zoned districts. (b) The routine servicing or lamp replacetnent of any existing outdoor lighting shall not be subject to the requirements of this Division 36.2-622 Exempt Lighting The following outdoor lighting shall be exetnpt from the requirements of this Division: (a) illuminated sigos subject to Section 36.2-666; (b) Landscape lighting two (2) feet or less in heigh~ (c) Accent directional lighting to etnphasize the fa~ade of a building or othet architectural elements, provided they are aimed so as to preclude light projection beyond the immediate objects inteoded to be illuminated; (d) Security lighting controlled by motion sensors which provides illuminarion for fifteen (15) minutes or less; (e) Outdoor recreation facility or sports smdium lighting subject to Secrions 36.2-340 and 36.2-403(g); (f) Tetnporary lighting such as holiday decorative lighting, consttucrion lighting, or etnergency lighting used by or at the direction of police, firefighting, or medical personnel; (g) Lighting of the United SOltes of America or Commonwealth of Virginia flags and other non-commercial flags expressing constitutionally protected speech; (h) Submerged lighting in swimming pools; (i) Code-required lighting for exterior stairs and ramps and exterior exit doors at grade level; and (j) Lighting requited and regulated by the Fedetal Aviation Administtation 36.2-623 Definitions The words, tetmS, and phrases used in this Division shall be defined as set forth in this section and in Appendis A. For the purposes of this Division, to the extent of any inconsistency between Appendix A and this section, the definirions provided in this section shall controL Flood or spot light: A form of lighting, with ref1ectiog or refracting eletnents, desigoed to direct its output in a specific direcrion. Fully shielded fixture: Lighting fixture constructed in such a manner that all light emitted by the fixture, eithet directly from the lamp or a diffusing element, or indirecdy by reflection or refracrion from any part of the luminaire, is projected below the horizontal plane. The lamp or any optical part (a reflector, prismatic lens or a clear non-prismatic lens) is not visible from the side of a luminaire (or any angle above) if it is fully sbielded Shielding devices may include internal or extemallouvers. Lamp: The light source component of a lighting fixture that produces the actual light, commonly called a bulb. Light trespass: Outdoor lighting falling beyond the lot lines of the use it is inteoded to serve and spilling 0Vet and shining onto adjacent properties and public rights-of-way. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 120 Article 6 Lighting fixture: A complete lighting unit consisting of one or more lamps, togethet with the components designed to distribute the light (such as a ref1ector or refractor), to position and protect the lamps, and to connect the lamps to the electrical powet supply. Louvers: A series ofbafRes designed to shield a light source from being viewed directly within cettain angles. Outdoor lighting: Any lighting fixture which is installed outdoors, whether attached to a building, pole, or se1f- supported. Wallpacks: Wall-mounted lighting fixtures, typically surface-mounted on a vertical wall surface, with optical elements (reflectors or refractors) that genetally direct a large potrion of their light at angles near the horizonmL 36.2-624 Lighting Plan The applicant for any basic or comprehensive development plan, or the applicant for a peunit associated with the eteetion or installation of any light support structure exceeding eight (8) feet in height or any lighting fixture as set forth in Section 36.2-621 (a)(4) and (a)(S), shall submit as part of the application evidence that the proposed work will comply with the outdoor lighting requirements of this Division. Such submission sball conmin the following, all or part of which may be part or in addirion to the information requited by othet applicable regulations of the City: (a) The location on the lot of all outdoor lighting fixtures, both proposed and existing; (b) The mounting heights of lighting futtures and the heights of any support structures; and (c) The angle of cut-off of light emissions and a description of any sbie1ding devices to mitigate light trespass and glare to abutting lots and public streets. 36.2-625 Outdoor Lighting Standards (a) Generally (1) All outdoor lighting shall be locared, aimed, and shielded so as not to present glare on abutting lots or public streets and to minimize spill light trespassing across lot lines. (2) No outdoor lighting shall be peunitted which shines directly into abutting residential dwelling units, buildings on adjacent lots, or abutting public streets, or for which the point source of illumination (an: tube) is visible at the property line. (3) With the exception of flood or spotlights which shall be subject to subsection (4) below, control of glare and light trespass shall be accomplished through the application of fully shielded fixtures and a downward aiming angle of no greater than forty-five (45) degrees above straight down (halfway between straight down and straight to the side). (4) Flood or spotlights shall be aimed no highet than forty-five (45) degrees above straight down (halfway between straight down and straighr to the side) when the light source is visible from any abutting lot (5) Outdoor lighting shall not be permitted to be located in any buffer yard requited by this Chapter. (b) (1) Shielding Any structutal part of a fixture providing sbielding to mitigate or control light trespass or glare in otder to comply with the regulations of this Division shall be permanently affixed. (2) All canopy lighting shall be fully shielded or fully recessed. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 121 Article 6 (3) Wallpacks shall be installed and sbielded in such a manuet that they effecrively comply with the smndards of Section 36.2-625(a). (c) Mounting heights (1) Pole-mounted lighting: Lighting fixtures mounted onto a pole or any structure intended primarily for the mounting of lighting shall not exceed a height of fifty (50) peteent of the dismnce of the light pole to the lot line as measured in a horizontal plane, or a maximum height of forty (40) feet, wbichevet is 10Wet, except as provided below: (A) Lighting for tennis courts or swinuning pools on residentially zoned lots shall not exceed twenty (20) feet above court or pool deck surface; and (B) In non-residential districts, heights greater than fifty (SO) peteent of the dismnce from the light pole to the lot line as measured in a horizontal plane but no greater than forty (40) feet shall be permitted provided the light fixture is side-shielded on the side of the lot line. (2) Flood or spotlights mounted to residential dwellings in residential districts: Flood or spotlights attached to single-funily and two-family dwellings in residential districts shall not exceed the height of the eaves. (3) Lighting fixtures mounted to buildings in non-residential districts: Lighting mounted onto buildings in non- residential districts shall not exceed a height highet than fifty (SO) percent of the horizontal dismnce of the light from the lot line, except as provided below: (A) Lighting for facades may be mounted at any height equal to, or less than the total height of the structure being illuminated reganlless of the horizontal dismnce to the lot line; and (B) For buildings less than forty (40) feet from the lot line, outdoor lighting shall be mounted to the vertical facades or the undetSide of canopies at a height of sixteen (16) feet or less. Division 3. General Development Standards 36.2-630 General Development Standards The provision and location of all pedestrian and vehicular ttaffic related facilities, including sidewalks, curbs and guttetS, fronmge roads, and acceleration and deceletation lanes, shall be as requited by the Agent to the Planning Conunission, provided that the property's development directly genetates the need for such infrastructure and provided furthet that the infrastructure requited is in proportion to the level of pedestrian and vehicular activity generated by the development. Such determination by the Agent shall be based upoo a quantifiable need documented by analysis of existing and post-development conditions, such as ttaffic or drainage studies. Division 4. Landscaping and Screening 36.2-640 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to protect the public health, safety, and genetal welfare by incorporating landscaping, screening, and tree canopy preservation requirements into the development process. nus Division establishes minimum requirements for the installation, preservation, and maintenance of planting and screening materials intended to: (a) Ensure development consistent with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan; (b) Reduce soil etOsion; (c) Increase infiltration in permeable land areas to improve srormwater management and aquifet recharge; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 122 Article 6 (d) Mitigate air, dust, noise, and chemical pollution; (e) Reduce the heat island effect of impervious surfaces; (fJ Preserve existing native vegemtion as an integral part of the community; (g) Promote planting techniques that ensure the long-tetm health of landscaping materials; (h) Reduce public costs to llIXpayers for stormwater management, air pollution controls, and related infrastructure; (1) Protect property values by requiting site appropriate landscaping; and (j) Mitigate the impacts of intense development on less inteose uses. 36.2-641 Applicability (a) The provisions of this Division shall apply to any construction or other development requiring a basic development plan or a comprehensive development plan pursuant to Sections 36.2-552 and 36.2-553. (b) When a development plan is submitted to expand an existing building or for other site improvements, the requirements of this Division shall apply only to those portions of the site that are affected by the proposed improvements. (c) When a property abuts an adjacent jurisdiction, the Zoning Administrator shall determine the specific buffer yard and screening requirements along the boundary after consideration of the zoning designation of the adjacent property. Requirements shall not exceed those that would be required between similarly zoned properties within the City. 36.2-642 General Landscaping and Screening Standards (a) (1) General requirements All potrions of a lot which are not included in the calculation of impervious surface ratio shall be landscaped. Landscaping shall include plant materials as may be requited by this Division as well as open areas coveted with grass or othet vegemtive gmundcover. (2) Landscaping within a sight dismnce triangle shall not include any evergreen tree and, furtbetmore, shall not include shrubs or gmund cover exceeding thirty (30) inches in height above the graded gmund level (3) When a detetmination of the number of required trees or shrubs, as set forth in this Division, results in a fraction, any fraction shall be counted as one (1) tree or shrub. (4) If the development of any portion of a lot includes the creation of a slope of two (2) to one (1), horizontal to vertical, or greater, such slope shall be planted with vegemtive cover, subject to detenninarion of the Zoning Administtator that the methods of planting will hold the soil in place and that the proposed vegemtive covet and rate of planting will ensure smbilization of the slope. (b) Planting materials Whete landscaping is requited by this Division, the following smndards shall apply: (1) All trees required by this Division shall be selected from the approved tree list in Table 642-1 and shall meet the applicable minimum height and caliper at the rime of planting and suimbility requirements as set forth in Table 642-1, unless otherwise provided for in this Division. The Zoning Administrator may approve the use of trees not set forth in Table 642-1 to meet the minimum tree Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 123 Article 6 requirements of this Division. subject to the Zoning Administrator's determination that the height. caliper. canopy. and suitability characteristics of such alternative trees are consistent with the intent and standards of this Division. The resource for such determination shall be based on the published reference text, Manual of Woody LandscllPe Plants, fifth edition, 1998, by Michael A. Dirr. (2) Where evergreen or deciduous shrubs are required by this Division, such shrubs shall have a minimum height of twenty-four (24) inches at the rime of planting. (3) Existing vegetation wbich meets the standards prescribed by this Division, as determined by the Zoning Administrator. may be preserved and may be used to meet some or all of the landscaping requirements. (4) All required landscaping materials shall meet the specifications and standards of the American Association of Nurserymen. (5) Where the planting of trees wbich have a height at twenty-year maturity wbich would interfere with overhead utility lines. the Zoning Administrator may, as a part of development plan approval, pennit the substitution of trees with a lesser height at maturity, provided the substitute trees shall be provided at a rate that will result in the same amount of total tree canopy. Cypress, Leyland 5' 113 B 5' 5' 5' s 5' 5' uca 5' Ash, Green Ash, 'White 2" Beech, American 2" Beech, Co r 'l:' Birch, River 'l:' Black Gum/Tu 0 2" Elm, Lacebark 2" Ginkgo {Male Variety 2" 133 P,C 2" 314 C 2" 254 C a 2" 177 P,C Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 124 Article 6 Trees: Approved Plant List, Minimum Size at Planting, 2O-Year Canopy, and Suitability Trees: Approved Plant List, Minimum Size at Planting, 2O-Year Canopy, and Suitability Linden, American 2" 314 C Linden, Little Leaf 2" 177 P,C London Planetree 2" 380 P,C Ma Ie, Red 2" 314 P,C Ma le,S 2" 314 P,C Oak, Chestnut 2" 254 C Oak, Northetn Red 2" 254 P,C Oak, Pin 2" 254 P,C Oak, White 2" 254 C Oak, Willow 2" 254 P,C Redwood, Dawn 2" 177 C Tulitree 2" 254 C Che ,Comelian 5' 113 C,B Cherry, Kwanzan 2" 177 P,C Flo Ch 2" 177 P,C Do 5' 177 P,C Do ood, Kousa 5' 177 P,C Goldenraintree 2" 177 P,C Hawthorn, Was on 5' 113 C,B Ho hombeam, American 2" 201 C Hombeam, .American 2" 177 C Ma Ie, Amur 2" 113 C,B Ma Ie, He 2" 177 P,C,B Ma Ie, a ese 5' 177 C :Ma Ie, Trident 2" 177 C M e,Cm 113 P,C Redbud, Eastetn 177 P,C Service 201 C Sourwood 113 C White F . 113 C *Suimbility Key for Table 642-1: P = Parking Areas or Street Yard Trees C = Tree Canopy for Overall Site B = Buffer Yards Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 125 Article 6 (c) Screening Where screening is requited by this Division, the following smndards shall apply: (1) Screening shall be visually opaque and constructed of a durable material. (2) Screening shall be mainmined by the owner of the property so as to meet the requirements of this Division. (3) Acceptable screening materials shall include stockade fences, decorative masonry walls, brick walls, and earth berms. The Zoning Administrator may approve alternative materials where their characteristics and design meet the intent and standards of this Division. (d) Landscape plan For development plans subject to the requirements of this Division, the following landscaping informarion shall be requited as part of development plan approval: (1) For a basic development plan, the landscaping information as set forth in Section B-1, Appendix B, shall be submitted; or (2) For a comprehensive development plan, a Landscape Plan as ser forth in Section B-3, Appendix B, shall be submitted. (e) Installation The installation of requited tree canopies, landscaping, buffeting, and screening shall meet the following requirements: (1) Only healthy planting materials shall be used for required plantings. (2) The planting of trees shall be done in accordance with either the standardized landscape specifications jointly adopted by the Virginia Nurserymen's Association, the Virginia Society of Landscape Designers, and the Virginia Chapter of the American Society of Landscape Architects, or the road and bridge specifications of the Virginia Department of Transportation. (3) No permanent Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued until either the required landscaping is completed in accordance with an approved development plan or the property owner or developer provides a guarantee in a form acceptable to the City Attorney that ensures installation. (A) A guarantee for required landscaping shall be an amount equal to one hundred ten (110) percent of the cost of the plants, related materials, and installation. (B) All required landscaping shall be installed, inspected, and approved within six (6) months of acceptance of the guarantee. (C) During any water etnergency declared by the governing body in wbich the use of water is restricted, the Zoning Administrator may permit the delayed installation of required trees, plants, or screening materials. In this event, the property owner shall be required to maintain the guarantee. After a declaration of water emergency ends, the property owner shall install the requited plants within six (6) months. (f) Maintenance Aftet approval by the Zoning Administtator that all landscaping requited by this Chapter is complete and in bealthy condition, the property owner shall be responsible for the ongoing protection and maintenance of all required landscaping in a manuet that complies with the requirements of this Chapter and in conformance with the approved development plan. Where necessary to comply with the requirements of this Chaptet and the approved development, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 128 Article 6 dead or damaged landscaping materials shall be replaced by the property ownet within six (6) months of notification by the City. (g) Modification of landscaping requirements The Zoning Administtator may approve in writing a development plan subject to, in whole or in part, alternative landscaping, screening, or buffer yard smndards if the Zoning Administtator finds that any of the following circumsmnces exist on the proposed development site, or surrounding propetries, provided any such altemative plan shall provide the equivalent quantity of required vegemtive material and shall bave no additional advetSe visual impact on adjacent properties or public areas or othetwise be inconsistent with the smted purposes of this Division: (1) Natural land charactetistics, such as topography or existing vegemtion, on the proposed development site would achieve the same intent of this Division; (2) Innovative landscaping or arcbitectural design is employed on the development site to acbieve an equivalent tree canopy, landscaping, screening, or buffcting effec~ (3) The screening and landscaping for a requited buffet would be ineffective because of the proposed topography of the site or the location of the improvements on the site; or (4) The topography of adjacent and surrounding sites would rendet requited screening ineffective. 36.2-643 Preservation of existing landscape features (a) Generally (1) During development, the property owner shall demonsttate reasonable efforts, in light of the proposed developmenr and topography of a particular site, to preserve, replenish, protect, and utilize the following types of landscape features: trees of six (6) inch caliper or larger; ornamental trees of any size; trees within requited yards, along property boundaries, or within twenty (20) feet of streams or lakes, unless necessary to remove for access, tree health, traffic circulation, utilities, or drainage; and streams in their natural condition. (2) The Zoning Administtator shall have the authority to require the replacement of trees destroyed during site development, particularly as delineated in subparagraph (1) above. (3) With the approval of the Zoning Administrator, any existing tree, of six (6) inch caliper or greater, detetmined ro be in healthy condition and of a species permitted and suimble for the requirement of this Division for which credit is requested, as esmblisbed in Table 642-1, and preserved on the site in accordance with Section 36.2-643(b), may receive a tree preservation bonus. For purposes of this subsection, a tree preservation bonus shall provide credit as follows for purposes of satisfying tree canopy requirements: (A) Existing approved tree of at least siz (6) inch calipet shall receive a canopy credit of two (2) trees of the same species; (B) Existing approved tree of at least nine (9) inch calipet shall receive a canopy credit of three (3) trees of the same species; or (C) Existing approved tree of at least twelve (12) inch calipet shall receive a canopy credit of four (4) trees of the same species. (b) Tree protection during construction \X'here, at the option of the developer, existing trees, of at least six (6) inch caliper, or wooded areas, are to be preserved in lieu of planting new materials in ordet to satisfY the tree canopy, landscaping, buffer yard, or screening requirements of this Division, subject to determination of the Zoning Administrator that such trees or wooded areas to be presetVed will serve the putposes of this Division, and as a condition of any approval pursuant to Section 36.2- 643(a)(3), the following requirements shall apply: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 127 Article 6 (1) Groups of trees and individual trees that will be remined on a development site shall be accurately located on a basic development plan (see Section B-1, Appendix B) or on the Landscape Plan of a comprehensive development plan (see Section B-3, Appendix B) and designated as "Tree Protecrion Areas," and shall be cleady marked on the development site prior to any land distuthance. Grading, clearing, storage of materials, dumping of materials, and parking or transporting vehicles and equipment shall be probibited inside any "Tree Protection Areas." (2) Tree protecrion devices as specified in "SID & SPEC 3.38, Tree PresetVarion and Protecrion," in the 1992 edition of the Virginia Erosion and Sediment Control Handbook, shall be used to protect trees in any "Tree Protection Areas." (3) Applicable diagrams of tree protection devices shall be provided as part of any development plan (see Appendix B). Such tree protection devices shall be installed prior to any clearing or grading on the site, shall be mainmined during construction, and shall remain in place until completion of all guaranteed improvements shown on the development plan and final release on all requirements by the City. (4) The Zoning Administrator shall make a detetmination concetning the degree of damage to any tree, whether replaCetnent of any damaged tree is required, or the co=ctive measures to be mken to ensure the survival of damaged trees. The Zoning Administtator shall notify the property owner if any trees must be repaired or replaced because of the damage caused by the stress of constmction. 36.2-644 Overall Tree Canopy Requirements (a) Definition of tree canopy For purposes of this section, "tree canopy" shall include all areas of coverage by existing plant material exceeding five (5) feet in height, and the extent of planted tree canopy at maturity shall be based on the "canopy at 20 years" as set forth in Table 642-1. Whete an existing tree is not listed in Table 642-1, "canopy at maturity" shall be based on the published refetence text, Manual of Woody Landscape Plants, fifth edition, 1998, by Michael A. Dirt. (b) (1) Applicability nus section shall apply to any development that requires submission of a comprehensive development plan or a basic development plan, except that dedicated school sites, playing fields, and othet nonwooded recreation areas, and other facilities and uses of a sim.ila:r nature, shall be exempt from the requirements of this section. (2) The Zoning Administrator may make a determination that provides reasonable deviarion from the requirements of this section WIder the following circumstances: (A) To allow for the reasonable development of farm land or other areas devoid of bealthy or suimble woody materials; or (B) For the preservation of wetlands. (c) (1) Tree canopy requirements The planting or replacement of trees on a development site shall be requited to the extent that, at twenty (20) years, minimum tree canopies will be provided as follows: Zoning District Classification Minimum Tree Canopy Required CG, CLS, 1-1, 1-2, MX, IN, INPUD, IPUD 10% of entire development site RM-2, RMF 10% of entire development site R-3, RM-l, MXPUD 15% of entire develooment site RA,R-12,R-7,R-S,R()S 20% of entire development site Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 128 Artlcle 6 (2) Existing trees which are to be preserved may be included to meet all or part of the canopy requirements of subsection (1), above, provided such preservation is in accordance with the smndards set forth in Section 36.2-643. (3) Existing trees infested with disease or insects or structurally damaged to the extent that they pose a hazard to persons or property, or to the health of other trees on site, shall not be included to meet the tree canopy requirements. (4) This secrion does not replace, or negate full compliance with, the requirements of any other section of this Chapter. Howevet, if the trees provided to satisfy the requirements of street yard trees (Section 36.2-MS), buffet yards (Section 36.2-647) and parking areas (Section 36.2-648) equal or exceed the tree canopy requited by this section, no furthet planting of trees or tree replacement is requited in ordet to comply with the requirements of this section. 36.2-645 Street Yard Trees Deciduous trees, as set forth in Section 36.2-642, Table 642-1, shall be provided between the building line and any public right-of-way when such building line is twenty-five (25) feet or more from the abutting public right-of-way. One (1) such tree shall be provided for each fifty (50) feet of lot fronmge, or portion theteof, exclusive of any perimeter parking area landscaping strips as requited in Section 36.2-648(b)(S). 36.2-646 Fa~de Planting Structures conmining single-family, two-family, townhouse or rowhouse, or multifamily dwelling units shall be subject to the following landscaping requirements: (a) A minimum of one (1) deciduous or evergreen shrub for each four (4) linear feet of building foundation that fronts on a public street shall be planted in the area between the right-of-way of the public street and the principal building. (b) For lots with multiple street fronmges, the regularions of this section shall apply only to the fa~ade of the building that conmins the principal entrance(s) to the structure. 36.2-647 Buffer Yards (a) Buffer yard requirements, generally Whete buffet yards are requited by this section, the following smndards shall apply: (1) Buffet yard areas may be included within setback and othet yard requirements specified in this Chapter for each zorting district. (2) Buffer yards shall be reserved solely for screening and landscaping. No proposed building, building addition, structure, parking area, or any other type of physical land improvement shall be located in a buffet yard; however, a driveway may cross a buffer yard if it is necessary for safe and convenient access to the development site. (3) Buffer yards shall conmin the screening or planting materials as requited in subsecrion (b) below, Table 647-1, and the balance of the buffet yard shall be planted in grass or othet ground cover. (b) Buffer yard requirements, by category Thete shall be five (5) categories of buffet yards, as esmblisbed in Table 647-1, with each category providing two (2) options for requirements for buffer yard width and plant materials or screening. The applicant may plant new trees or plants, or preserve existing trees or plants that meet the criteria of Table 647-1, or a combination thereof; in ordet to meet the planting requirements of this section. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenokel2/05l05 129 Article 6 ~ _'T'"''''''_ , - - .- W"."~"",, ~W..,",..,__,_". ~"""""._,",.__._.".~..._- """ w',_ ~-,,--"" -,,--~ -.-". - ,- , - II Table 647-1. Buffer Yard Categories: Minimum Widths and Required Planting and Screening Materials ,-- - -~ - ~-_..,- " -- 1 -- __,,~_w.'" ---- " -- - ~--'-'-" --1\ BUFFER YARD OPTION 1 OPTION 2 , CATEGORY " .... li6f';;;;bigh';;'~'" " I i5f';;;;~d~wf~;.;cl """""'" 'I' A One row of evergreen trees I D - " , B ! 6 foot high screening : 10 foot wide buffer yard I l 15 foot wide buffer yard ! Evergreen trees and one row of evergreen sbmbs I , 'Evergreen trees , LJ~- ---- - - _w. i C 16 foot high screening 15 foot wide buffet yard ! i i 10 foot wide buffer yard .....-. trees and one row of evergreen shrubs I : iEvergreen trees , [:]"""""""""""""""""""""""""'"""""'-"""""" ,20 foot wide buffet yard , D ,6 foot high screening 1 , 115 foot wide buffer yard -e.-- trees and one row of evergreen sbmbs i , :Evergreen trees 1 [J~~__m_mm '30 foot wide buffet yard i , E i 8 foot high screening , ! 20 foot wide buffet yard 'Evergreen trees, large deciduous trees, and one row of i , Evergreen trees and large deciduous evergreen sbmbs I I' 'trees ,_.._~_,_.~,,_w ~ __.,..."_","w...,,,......,',,,,,._..,, _.,___" _'W"'''''''_. M_'''___ -, _,,'w, - ""._",~-'- ----,-.,.,-". - -- -.--" , -Rules of Intetpremtion for Table 647-1: , , (1) The buffet yard categories esmblisbed in this mble shall be requited as set forth in Section 36.2-647(c), Table i 647-2. I (2) Screening shall meet the smndards of Section 36.2-642(c). (3) Screening heights are minimum height requirements. (4) Where a combination of screening and planting materials is required, requited landscaping shall be located on the exterior side of the screening material (5) Requited planting materials shall be provided at the following density smndards: (a) Evergreen trees: One (1) tree pet eight (8) linear feet, or portion theteOf, in buffet yard categories A., B, C, and D; One (1) tree pet twenty (20) linear feet, or portion theteOf, in buffer yard category E. (b) Small deciduous trees: One (1) tree per twenty (20) linear feet, or portion thereof. (c) Large deciduous trees: One (1) tree per thirty (30) linear feet, or portion theteof. (d) Evergreen sbmbs: Three (3) feet on center or less. (c) Where buffer yards are required Buffer yards shall be applied along side and rear lot lines as set forth in Table 647-2. For purposes of this subsection, abutting lots shall not include lots separated by a public street, stream, or railroad track. Lots that would abut if not for their separation by an alley shall be considered abutting lots for purposes of this subsection and shall be subject to the requirements for buffer yards. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 130 Article 6 Table 647-2 Re uired Buffer Yards Zo' District of Abu Zoning District of the Zoning Lot(s) on Which Development is Proposed ..; =: .". =: ~ 6: - <'i - of \:l U ~ I B C I B D C A D C B D D C E E C To be detetmined c c D A B B C C Rules ofIntetpremtion for Table 647-2: (1) "A", "B", ''C'', ''0'', and "E"; Bufferyatdcategories as established in Table 647-1. (2) A dash ("--") means no buffer yard shall be required. 36.2-648 Parking Area Landscaping (a) Applicability The landscaping requirements of this section shall apply to the development of seven (I) or more off-street parking spaces. (b) Parking area landscaping standards Parking areas shall be subject to the following landscaping smndards: (1) Wheel stops, curbing, or other barriers shall be provided to prevent damage to requited landscaping by motor vehicles. (2) In ordet to protect planting materials and allow for proper growth and tree canopy maturation, planting areas provided for requited landscaping within the interior of parking areas shall be a minimum of eight (8) feet in width and eighteen (18) feet in length, shall provide a minimum soil depth of two (2) feet, and shall include surface landscaping, mulch, grass or othet vegemtive ground COVet. (3) In ordet to allow for proper growth and tree canopy maturation, deciduous trees requited by this section shall be planted no closer than twenty (20) feet on centet for small deciduous trees and thirty {3D) feet on center for large deciduous trees. (4) Trees required by this section shall be selected from those species listed in Table 642-1 as being suimble for parking areas. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 131 Article 6 (5) Landscaping strips along the perimetetS of all parking areas that front on a public street shall be provided at a minimum width of eight (8) feet and shall include the following: (A) Small deciduous trees, as permitted in Table 642-1, spaced at a minimum rate of one (1) such tree for each thirty (30) feet of fronmge, exclusive of driveways, or large deciduous trees, as permitted in Table 642-1, spaced at a minimum rate of one (1) such tree for each forty (40) feet of fronmge, exclusive of driveways; and (B) Evergreen or deciduous shrubs spaced no farthet apart than at a rate of three (3) feet on centet. (6) With the development of seven (7) to twenty (20) parking spaces, trees shall be provided along the perimetet or within the interior of parking areas at a rate that represents a twenty (20) year tree canopy of ten (10) percent of the total square foomge of the parking area, excluding driveways or aisles that do not directly access parallel, petpendicular, or angled parking spaces. (A) Trees planted to satisfy the requirement along the perimeter of a parking area that fronts on a public street, as set forth in Section 36.2-648(b)(S), shall be credited toward the ten (10) percent tree canopy requirement. (B) When the requirements of Section 36.2-648(b)(S) do not meet the teo (10) percent tree canopy requirement, the balance of such tree canopy requirement shall be met by the planting of trees within the interior of the parking area or along othet perimetetS of the parking area provided any such perimeter tree is located within eight (8) feet of any parking space. ''Within the interior of the parking area" shall be defined as any planter island or peninsula that is surrounded on at least three (3) sides by off-street parking spaces or access aisles abutting off-street parking spaces. (7) With the development of twenty-one (21) or more parking spaces, trees shall be provided at a rate that represents a twenty (20) year tree canopy of twenty (20) percent of the total square foomge of the parking area, excluding driveways or aisles that do not direcdy access parallel, petpendicular, or angled parking spaces. No more than fifty (SO) percent of the trees planted to meet this requirement shall be the same species. (A) Trees planted to satisfy the requirement along the perimetet of a parking area that fronts on a public street, as set forth in Section 36.2-648(b)(S), shall be credited toward the twenty (20) percent tree canopy requirement. (B) When the requirements of Section 36.2-648(b)(S) do not meet the twenty (20) percent tree canopy requirement, the balance of such tree canopy requirement shall be met by the planting of trees within the interior of the parking area or along other perimeters of the parking area provided any such perimeter tree is located within eight (8) feet of any parking space, and provided further, that in any case, at least fifty (SO) percent of the balance of the required tree canopy shall be placed within the interior of the parking area. ''Within the interior of the parking area" shall be defined as any planter island or peninsula that is surrounded on at least three (3) sides by off-street parking spaces or access aisles abutting off-street parking spaces. 36.2-649 Screening of Specific Uses and Facilities In addition to the other requirements of this Chapter, the following faciliries and functions of uses shall be screened as follows: (a) Dumpsters and refuse conminers: Refuse dumpstetS and other similar refuse conminetS shall be screened from adjacent public streets and adjoining properties with an enclosure, pursuant to the screening regulations of Section 36.2-642(c), at a minimum height of one (1) foot above the height of the dumpstet or other similar recepmcle. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 132 Article 6 (b) Mechanical equipment on ground: Except for single-family demched dwellings and two-family dwellings, mechanical equipment located on the ground shall be screened or landscaped from view from abutting public streets and from adjoining properties in accordance with one of the following: (1) Screened pursuant to the screening regulations of Section 36.2-642(c); or (2) Landscaped with evetgreen shrubs planted at a rate of three (3) feet on centet or less. (c) Mechanical equipment on roof. In any zoning district, except 1-1, 1-2, or IPUD, all mechanical equipment located on the roof of a building sball be screened from view to the extent that no more than one-half (1/2) the Vetrical height of such equipment may be visible from any adjacent public street or from the same ground elevation of an existing building on an adjacent lot. Division 5. Off-Street Parking and Loading 36.2-650 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to set forth off-street parking and loading requirements for petmitted and special exception land uses, in accordance with the intensity of such uses, in a manner that: (a) Reduces ttaffic hazards and excessive levels of congestion on surrounding streets; (b) Minimizes impact of driveways on the public street system; (c) Reduces conflict between motor vehicles and othet forms of ttansportation; (d) Encourages pedestrian access and alternative modes of ttansportation; (e) Addresses motor vehicle parking, loading, and access issues; (f) Provides options for the provision of adequate parking; and (g) Is consistent with environmental goals such as stonnwater management, clean air, and reduction of the heat island effect of expansive impervious surfaces. 36.2-651 Applicability The off-street parking and loading requirements of this Division shall apply to any new structure or use, any increase in intensity of use, including an addition to or enlargement of an existing structure, or a change of existing use. No Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued until requited off-street parking and loading spaces have been esmblisbed in accordance with the requirements of this Division. 36.2-652 Minimum Off-Street Parking (a) Applicability (1) The requited minimum numbet of off-street parking spaces shall be provided as set forth in Table 652-2, provided the minimum parking space requirements of Table 652-2 shall not apply to the Downtown District (I)) or the Commercial-Neighborhood District (eN). (2) All requited off-street parking spaces shall be located on the same zoning lot as the use or structure to be served, except as provided in Section 36.2-6S2(g). Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 133 Article 6 (3) Spaces allocated to a fleet or accessory vehicles necessary for and direcdy associated with the operarion of a business or service establishment shall not, while so allocated, be used to meet the minimum requirements for off-street parking or portions theteof or counttowanl any maximum parking smndard. A fleet shall mean a group of motor vehicles, such as taxicabs, vans, or trucks, operated as a unit in association with a business or service establishment. (b) (1) Calculation methods When a determination of the number of minimum requited off-street parking spaces or the pennirted maximum number of off-street parking spaces, as set forth in Table 652-2, results in a requirement of a fracrional space, any fracrion shall be counted as one (1) space. (2) For the putposes of off-street parking calculations, the gross area of any parking garage within a building shall not be included within the gross floor area of the building. (3) When computing required minimum off-street parking spaces, the toral numbet of requited spaces shall be based on the use(s) of the zoning lot, or portion thereof In those insmnces where thete are cleady identified multiple uses on a zoning lot, the minimum parking space requirements of Table 652-2 shall apply to each use, resulting in a total parking requirement when summed, except as provided in Section 36.2-652(1). (4) Handicapped accessible parking spaces shall count toward the number of off-street parking spaces provided to satisfy the minimum parking space requirements of Table 652-2. (5) Whete applicable, the provisions of subsections (c), (d), (e), and (I) below, may be applied alone or in any combination to reduce the minimum off-street parking requirement (c) Reduction for proximity to public transit Whete a nonresidential use is located within one thousand two hundred (1,200) feet of a public transit route, the total numbet of requited off-street parking spaces, unassigned to specific persons, may be reduced to eighty (80) percent of that othetwise requited as set forth in Table 652-2. (d) Reduction for on-street parking The toral number of requited off-street parking spaces as set forth in Table 652-2 may be reduced by one (1) space for every twenty (20) feet of lot fronmge on a public street to the extent that on-street parking is pennirted along the same fronmge. (e) Reduction for first 4,000 square feet Whete the off-street parking requirement for a nonresidential use is based on square footage, as set forth in Table 652-2, the total numbet of required off-street parking spaces, for the first 4,000 square feet of net floor area of the use, may be teduced to two (2) spaces. (f) Reduction for shared parking Developments that contain a mix of uses on a single lot or contiguous lots of common ownership, as set forth in Table 652-1, below, may reduce the amount of requited parking in accordance with the following methodology: (1) Determine the minimum parking requirements in accordance with Table 652-2 for each land use as if it were a separate use; (2) Multiply each amount by the corresponding percenmges for each of the five (5) rime periods set forth in Colwnns (B) through (F) of Table 652-1; (3) Calculate the total for each rime period; and (4) Select the total with the highest value as the requited minimum number of parking spaces. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 134 Article 6 Table 652-1. Shared Patking Calculations Weekdav Weekend (A) (8) (C) (D) (E) (F) Land Use Doytime Evening Daytime Evening Nighttime (9 a.m. - 4 p.m.) (6 p.m. - (9 a.m. - 4 p.m.) (6 p.m.- (midnight - 6 a.m.) midni.ht) midn;.nt) Office/Industrial 100% 10% 19% 5% 5% Retail 60% 90% 100% 7ff'!. 5% Hotel 75% 100% 75% 100% 75% Restaurant 50% 100% 100% 100% lff'!. Entetminment/ 40% 100% 80% 100% lff'!. Commercial (g) Off-site parking Minimum off-street parking requirements of a given use may be met with off-site, off-street parking spaces when, and if, all of the following requirements are met For the purposes of this Chapter, off-site, off-street parking provided in accordance with this section shall not be subject to the definition of; or supplemenOtry regulations for, accessory uses or structures. (1) Off-site, off-street parking shall be located within three hundred (300) feet of the lot of the use or structure served. For the purpose of this requirement, the dismnce from off-street parking spaces to the lot served shall be measured in a s1Illigb.tline from the nearest parking space to the lot of the use served; (2) Off-site, off-street parking shall be designared for the purpose of the off-site use it serves and shall nOt be used to meet the minimwn off-street parking requirements of another use, unless the Zoning Administrator detetmines from an Off-Site Parking Agreement as refetenced in subsection (4) that the uses for which the off-street parking spaces are designated do not constitute simulmneous use of the parking spaces; (3) Off-site, off-street parking shall not be permitted on a lot that is zoned R-12, R-7, R-S, R-3, RM-l, RM-2, or RMF; and (4) Off-site, off-street parking shall eithet (i) be located on land in the same 0Wl1etSbip as that of the use or structure served, or (n) be subject to an Off-Site Parking Agreement as set forth in Appendix C, which agreetnent shall be recon\ed by the property owner with the Oerk of the Circuit Court and a copy filed with the Zoning Administrator. Should the legal agreetnent tetminate, the use for which off-site parking was provided shall be consideted nonconforming and any and all approvals, including special exceprions, shall be subject to revocarion. Continuation or expansion of the use shall be probibited unless the use is brought into compliance with the parking regulations of this Chapter. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 135 Article 6 oint r a artment ot a licable 2 er 1,000 sf oss area 1 Not a licable * * R(!JllftwtialUJlf Dwelling, Single. family detached (on lot with street frontage Not applicable * of 30 feet or less) Dwelling, Single-family detached (on lot with street frontage 2 per dwelling unit * of 31 feet or more' Dwellino, Two-familv 2 ner dwellino- unit * Dwellin!iv Multifamily, Elderly (inrended aud designed 0.75 per dwelling unit . exclusive to house the elderlv~ Dwelling, Multifamily, other than elderly 1.5 per dwelling unit . Dwelling, Townhouse or Rowhouse 1.5 per dwelling unit * Dwellino-: Manufactured home 2 oer dwellin2 unit * DwellinO", Mobile home 2 ner dwellinO" unit * Accommodations and Group Linin!! Grou care facili , Con e te home, Elder! Group care facility, Congregate home, not otherwise listed in this table Grou care facili , Grou care home Grou care facili ,Halfwa house Grou care facili ,Nursin home Grou care facili , T ransitionallivin facili Grou home, sub'ect to Vir . . Code 15.2-2291 Hotel or motel er est bedroom Ius 2 for owner er bedroom er 3 beds er 2 beds Ius 1 er 2 em 10 ees * * * * 1 per 8 beds plus 1 per 2 employees * * * * * * Commenial UU'f: OOitC and Related Uj(!J Blood bank or lasma center Business service establishment, not otherwise listed in this table Em 10 ment or tem 0 labor service Financial institution Laborato ,dental, medical, or 0 tical 1 er400sf 1 per 350 sf er 300 sf er 300 sf erem 10 ee * Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 138 Article 6 able 652-2 Required Off-Street Parking Spaces [{uk:; of Interpretation: In Columll (B), "s(' means thl' net 110m area in sLJIJ~lrl' fl'd for till' pnncip;d ~tllJClllH'. Of lJ~l' 1111" use occupies only rart (If J. structurl', unkss othlT\visl' noted in IlK t:lbk. "J 'l11p!O!Tl'" 111(,;\1l~ dw llLllllhn oj l'lll!'I< l\'(TS 'J thl' shiCLln (:()]1I11lfl "( nwam thl' maximum sd f'lrth in :-;(C!I"1l1(1::' (,')') sI1.l111\<.t botato , testin Medical clinic ffiee, oecal or roCessional au atient mental health and substance abuse clinic , , 1 erem 10 ee r400 sf er 400 sf or 300 sf - - - Cmmm1'tial Use.!>: Alifcelldllcous IAnimal hospital or veterinary clinic 1 per employee plus 1 per 100 sf of waiting room area plus 1 net examination foom Caterer, commercial 1 per employee Communitv market 1 per 500 sf of sales area Not applicable (minimum parking Drive-through facility requirement based on use with which drive- throu1!h is associated) IDrive-throul!h kiosk 1 oer emolovee Flea market 1 per 500 sf of indoor or outdoor display area Funeral home 1 per 4 seats in largest chapel or viewing room Kennel 1 per 1,000 sf Live-work unit 2 per unit Mixed use building Subject to the requirements of the uses in the building Outdoor advertisin1! silffi Not aoolicable , tudio/multimedia oroduction facility 1 per 300 sf Commercial UH \: Rctml Sales and S(J71ia Bakerv, confectiona.rv, or similar food production, Retail 1 per 300 sf Body oiercinu establishment 1 per 300 sf Buildinl! suoolies and materials, Retail 1 per 400 sf of retail area Business service establishment, not otherwise listed in this 1 per 350 sf table Car wash 1 ner 3 service bays, olus 1 o~r 2 emoloyees Commercial motor vehicle rental establishment 1 ner emolovee , Commercial motor vehicle sales and service establishment, 1 per 2,500 sf of lot area New or Used Contractor or tradesman's shoo, General or Soecial Trade 1 per 600 sf Drv cleanine: and laundrv oickup station 1 per 250 sf Drv cleanino- nlant or commerciallaundrv 1 per 500 sf Gasoline station 2 spaces General service establishment, not otherwise listed in this 1 per 350 sf mble anitorial services establishment 1 per 350 sf Laundromat 1 per 250 sf Lumber yard 1 oer 1,000 sf Manufactured or mobile home sales 1 oer 500 sf of sales and service buildinl! Motor vehicle rental establishment 1 oer emolovee , Motor vehicle renair or service establishment 3 per service bay Motor vehicle sales and service establishment, New or Used 1 per 1,000 sf plus 3 ner service bay Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 Article 6 137 able 652-2. Required Off-Street Parking Spaces Rules of Interpretallon: III (:o!umn (11), "sf' means the lwl HOOf area ill sljuan: kct (or tll(' prillClpJI stfllClllll', Olll~l' It 1: use occurit'S only rnrt of a struclUfl" unkss otherwise Ilotl'd in tIll" t:lhk. "] :mpl()!','{''' l11(':ITl~ till 1\111111)(1" ,d- l'lll]'!' I\,l'~ < rill' sl1il"1, In (:()lulll1\ "( :", "." mt'~l1lS till' m:D:if1lul11 sd ('lftll 111 ~l("(1< III ')(12(,:;'") ~11.I111l' 'I .lj'I'] Nursery or greenhouse, commercial per 1,000 sf of indoor floor sales area plus 1 per 1,000 sf of greenhouse or net outdoor sales and customer dis la area , III - , III ,. II ,. II ,. III Personal service establishment, not otherwise listed in this table Pet oomin Recreational vehicle or boat sales Retail sales establishment - Large appliances, furniture, household fixtures, swimmin ools, hot tubs, S as Retail sales establishment. not otherwise listed in this table Sto buildin sales Tattoo arlar 1 per 1,500 sf of retail-showroom area 1 r 250 sf of retail area 1 er 500 sf of sales buildin 1 er 300 sf . s halt or concrete lant Bakery, confectionary, or similar food production, oIesale Biosolids field Buildin su lies and materials, Wholesale Commercial rinti establishment Com ostin facili Contractor's sho ,Hea construction Dairy products, processing, bottling, and wholesale distribution Electrical com anent assembI , wholesale distribution Fuel oil distribution Fuelin station, commercial or wholesale unk ard Manufacturing: Beverage or food processing, excluding oul and animal slau hterin and dressin Manufacturin . Chemical, refmin or rocessin Manufacturin . General, not otherwise listed in this table Manufacturing: Steel or metal production, fabrication, or rocessin Manufacturin . Wood rOOucts Meat ackin and ult Millin or feed and flour mills Motor vehicle or trailer aintin and bod re air . 10 ee . <tem 10 ee . erem 10 ee . erem 10 ee . r 600 sf 1 per employee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 per employee . erem 10 ee . erem 10 ee . 1 per employee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 er em 10 ee . 3 er service bay or aint booth 1 erem 10 ee . 1 rem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . 1 erem 10 ee . center lIe reca in owin service eldin or machine sho recker ard \l/aJ"l'housin;.: and Stml1~c Distribution center, not otherwise listed in this table Mini-warehouse Starn of commercial motor vehicles .5 er 1,000 sf Ius 1 er 2 10 ees 1 er 100 individual sto units Not a licable . Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 138 Article 6 Storage of motor vehicles for rental (no on.site rental or leasing facili ank fann, petroleum bulk station and terminal, or other above ound soo of flammable li uids arehouse Not applicable 1 per employee .5 er 1,000 sf Ius 1 er 2 em 10 ees Assemb(y and EntCltainment Adult uses, exCMlt theaters 1 ner 300 sf Adult uses, motion nicture theater 1 ner 5 seats Amphirheater 1 per 6 seats or 600 sf of total assembly area, whichever is vreater Amusement, commercial, indoor Pool or billiards 2 Der table Amusement, commercial, indoor, not othelWise listed in 1 per 250 sf this table Amusement, commercial, outdoor Miniature oolf 1 ner hole Amusement, commercial, outdoor, not otherwise listed in 1 per 1,000 sf of activity area this table Botanical ~nien or arboretum 1 ner 2,500 sf of lot area Club, lodge, civic, social, or fraternal organization 1 per 5 persons of maximum load occunancv Community center 1 per 400 sf or 1 per 4 persons of maximum load occunancv, whichever is Q'teater Eatin----;;:-establishment foer 60 sf of seatinll area , Eatina and drinkin~ ~stablishment 1 ner 60 sf of seatin2 area , 1 per 60 sf of seating area plus 1 per 5 Entertainment establishment persons of maximum load occupancy for all , other assemblv areas Exhibition, convention, or conference center 1 per 8 persons of maximum load occ:unann' Gamin" establishment 1 ner 60 sf of seatinv area , Go-cart track Inerl~OOsfofactivi~area Golf course ~hole Health and fitness center 1 per 5 persons of maximum load IoCcuoancv Meeting hall 1 per 5 persons of maximum load occuoa~cv Paint ball facilitv, outdoor 1 per 2,000 sf of activity area Park or nlavOTound, not otherwise listed in this table Not annlicable , 1 per 4 seats or per 6 linear feet of bench Place of worship seating in the portion of the building to be used for services or the largest assembly room, whichever is llteater Recreation, indoor - Bowlino- allev 2 ner lane Recreation, indoor Ice skatino- or roller skatino- rink 1 ner 200 sf of skatino- area Recreation, indoor or outdoor Basketball courts 1.5 ner court Recreation, indoor or outdoor - Battino- cacres 2 ner cape Recreation, indoor or outdoor SkateboardinQ" course 1 ner 500 sf of skatinQ" area Recreation, indoor or outdoor Swimmine: oools lo~r75sfof~terarea Recreation, indoor or outdoor - Tennis or other racquet 1.5 per court ourts Recreation, outdoor - Athletic fields 20 ner field Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 Article 6 139 Table 652-2. Required Off-Street Parking Spaces J{uks oflntcrprctatl(m: In (:o]Llmn (H). "sf' 111l'J.ns the nd !loof arca in Stj1Jarc flTt [(lr tIll' pnnn]lJI structurl', ()!" lISl' If 11:. llSt' occupies only part of:J. struClLlfl', llllkss otherwisl' tl()ll'd in tlll table. "I':mp\\lycl'" fllC".lIh tIll IHIl1lhn III l'1l1pl,)\n'~ " the shift In (:o]utl1n "(''', ,,,,, nh''.In~ the' rTl:l"illlllJl\ sl't f(lrth ill ;-;,'(li'lll)(''"1 (,~:; sll.lll TI"I Recreation, outdoor - Golf drivin Recreation, indoor, oat otherwise listed in this table Recreation, outdoor. not otherwise listed in this table S arts stadium, arena, or coliseum heater, movie or erfonnin arts Zoo rtist studio Cemete Communi food mtion Communi den Da care center. Adult Da care center, Child Da care home, Child Educational facilities, Business school or non-industrial school Educational facilities, College / university Educational facilities, Elementa Educational facilities, Middle Educational facilities, Second Educational facilities, Industrial trade school Educational facilities, School for the arts Fire, olice, or emer en services Government facili - ail Government offices or other government facility. not otherwise listed in this table Hospital Lib Mill Reserve or National Guard Center Museum Post Office u I an rainin facili for olice, fue, or erne nc servIces 1 tee 1 500 sf of activi area 1 er 1,000 sf of activi area 1 er 5 seats 1 er 4 seats 1 er 2,500 sf of lot area . . . er 8 adult attendees er 8 children . 3 per classroom plus 1 per 5 students 3 per classroom plus 1 per 5 full-time e uivalent students er classroom er classroom er classroom er classroom er 16 students er 8 students er 5 students er 300 sf er em 10 ee er em 10 ee Ius 1 er 25 inmates . . 1 per300 sf 1 per 2 beds plus 1 per 500 sf of outpatient clinic plus 1 per 400 sf of office space plus 1 per 500 sf of laboratory and other support services er 500 sf er 600 sf er 1,000 sf er 400 sf or 500 sf er 600 sf ort~related commercial and us maintenance, includin r us passenger terminal or station rsonal service uses and sto e Limousine service Motor fr . ht terminal or truck terminal 1 per 5 seating accommodations for waiting assen rs 1 er 300 sf 1 erernloee 1 per 5 seating accommodations for waiting assen rs 10 ee 10 ee . . . Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 140 Article 6 roadcastin studio or station Broadcasti tower Hazardous materials facili Utili distribution or collection, Basic Utili distribution or collection, Transitional Utili neration or treatment Utili maintenance and service facili iceless telecommunications facili 1 edOO sf Not a licable 1 erem 10 ee ot a licable ot a licable 1 eremloee 1 eremloee Not a licable * * * * * * * gJimlJurc area * Ius 1 ef4 stalls 36.2-653 Maximum Off-Street Parking (a) The following maximwn off-street parking provisions shall apply in all zoning districts and to all uses, except where maximwn parking is deiineated as not applicable in Table 652-2, or as established in Section 36.2- 653(c). Although the minimwn parking requirements shall not apply to the Downtown District (D) or the Commercial-NeighbOl:hood District (CN), the maximwn off-street parking provisions shall apply. For uses subject to maximwn parking standards, the provision of off-street parking spaces shall not exceed the fonowing amoWlts: (1) If the total nwnber of minimwn required off-street parking spaces is fifty (SO) or less, as set forth in Table 652-2, the maximwn nwnber of off-street parking spaces pennitted shall not exceed one hundred fifty percent (150%) of the minimwn nwnber of spaces required; or (2) If the total nwnber of minimwn required off-street parking spaces is fifty-one (51) or more, as set forth in Table 652-2, the maximwn nwnber of off-street parking spaces pennitted shall not exceed one hundred forty percent (140%) of the minimwn nwnber of spaces required. (b) The maximwn nwnber of off-street parking spaces permitted, as established in Section 36.2-653(a), shall not include required handicapped accessible spaces. (c) The maximwn nwnber of off-street parking spaces pennitted, as established in Section 36.2-653(a), shall not apply to parking structures or parking areas with pervious pavement systems. (d) Maximwn parking standards may be exceeded with the approval of the Board of Zoning Appeals, subject to the following provisions: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 141 Article 6 (1) Such increase in the nwnher of parl<ing spaces shall be approved by the Boanl of Zoning Appeals by special exception, pursuant to the provisions set forth in Section 36.2-560; (2) Such increase in the nwnher of parl<ing spaces shal1 be petmitted only upon the same lot as the principal use which the patking is intended to serve; (3) The total nwnher of parl<ing spaces created for any use shal1 be established by the Boatd, but in no case shal1 the total nwnber of parl<ing spaces provided exceed one hundred seventy-five percent (175%) of the minimwn nwnher of spaces required; and (4) The approval of such increase shal1 be based on findings related to unique peak patking demands created by the operational nature of the use, intensity of building utilization unique to the use, or overlapping shifts or demand. Such documentarinn sha1l be provided by the applicant 36.2-654 Off-Street Parking Area Standards (a) General standards Off-street parl<ing areas sha1l be subject to the following general requirements: (1) All off-street parl<ing areas shal1 be limited to improved surfaces as defined in Section 36.2-654(b)(1). (2) Unobstructed access shal1 be provided to and from a street or an alley. (3) Off-street parl<ing areas sha1l be so designed as not to require or permit the parl<ing of any motor vehicle across a sidewalk. (4) Off-street parl<ing areas shall be so designed as not to require or petmit maneuvering to and from a public street to access or exit an off-street patking space, except for single-family detached and two-family dwellings, where maneuvering to and from a public street shal1 be petmitted. (5) Off-street parl<ing spaces may be located direcdy adjacent to an alley. Where an alley provides access to the rear of the property, maneuvering to and from a patking space to and from an alley sha1l be petmitted. (6) Screening and landscaping of off-street parl<ing areas shal1 be provided pursuant to the requirements of Section 36.2-648. (b) Construction standards Off-street parl<ing areas shal1 comply with the following construction standards: (1) All off-street parl<ing areas shall be graded for drainage and surfaced with concrete, asphalt, bituminous pavement, brick or stone pavers, or a pervious surface pavement system, except as follows: (A) For single-family detached dwellings, the Zoning Administtator may permit gravel driveways off of alleys provided the applicant provides satisfactory specifications for a sub-base and the size, tamping, and containment of gravel (B) The Zoning Administtator may petmit gravel or a similar surface to be used in fleet or motor vehicle storage yaros if the applicant establishes that dust will not be generated in an amount in excess of that which would be generated by a paved surface or pervious surface pavement system. (2) Exclusive of single-family detached dwellings, all off-street patking areas sha1l be boIdered by a curb of concrete, asphalt, or other material acceptable to the Zoning Administtator. Curbing shall not be required if the applicant incorporates low-impact stonnwater design practices consistent with the United States Enviromnental Protection Agency, Low-Impact Development Design Sttategies: An Integrated Design Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 142 Article 6 Approach Gune 1999) and Low-Impact Development Hydrologic Low-Impact Development Hydrologic Analysis Guly 1999). (3) When a curb is not provided, wheel or bwnper guards shall be provided, located, and ananged so that no part of any parl<ed motor vehicle will extend beyond the boundaries of the parl<ing area and so that they preclude motor vehicles from driving onto landscaped areas. (c) Pedestrian access In the CG and CLS Districts, designated pedestrian access shall be provided between off-street parl<ing areas and public enttances of a building or use which is required to provide fifty (50) or more parl<ing spaces, as set forth in Table 652-2. Pedestrian access shal1 consist of sidew:ill<s or other surfaced walkways which are separated from vehicular traffic. (d) Location standards Off-street parl<ing areas shal1 be subject to the following location standards: (1) Except for lots containing single-family detached dwellings, and except as otherwise provided in Section 36.2-654(a)(5), off street parl<ing areas shal1 meet the following requirements for minimwn distances from property lines: (A) No off-street parlring area shal1 be located closer than five (5) feet to any side or rear property line; and (B) No off-street parlring area shall be located closer than eight (8) feet to any property line which abuts a public street. (2) Except for lots containing single-family detached dwellings, and existing lots of record in the CG District with less than one hundred (1 (0) feet of frontage, no off-street parlring spaces shal1 be pennitted between the right-of-way of a public street and the principal buildings in the RM-l, RM-2, RMF, CN, CG, MX, IN, or D District. In the case of comer lots or through lots, this regulation shal1 apply to only one (1) street frontage. (3) In the Neighbothood Design Overlay District (ND), off-street parking, if provided, shall be located to the rear or side of the principal building. (e) Parking space and aisle dimensional standards Off-street parl<ing areas for the provision of the minimwn nwnber of required off-street parlring spaces shal1 be subject to the requirements for size of parl<ing spaces, aisle dimensions, and wheel curb offsets as set forth in Table 654-1. Parlring structures shal1 be exempt from the dimensional standards set forth in Table 654-1. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 143 Article 6 Table 654-1. Off-Street Parking Dimensions (minimum values in feet) D F O. 8'6" 8.5 120 23.0 29.0 60" 8'6" 20.7 18.5 9.8 59.9 55.6 9'0" 9.0 120 23.0 30.0 9'0" 21.0 18.0 10.4 60.0 55.5 9'6" 9.5 120 23.0 31.0 9'6" 21.2 18.0 11.0 60.4 55.6 10'0" 10.0 120 23.0 32.0 10'0" 21.5 18.0 11.5 61.0 56.0 20" 8'6" 14.5 11.0 24.9 40.0 320 70" 8'6" 20.8 19.5 9.0 61.1 58.2 9'0" 15.0 11.0 26.3 41.0 325 9'0" 21.0 19.0 9.6 61.0 57.9 9'6" 15.5 11.0 27.8 42.0 33.1 9'6" 21.2 18.5 10.1 60.9 57.7 10'0" 15.9 11.0 29.2 42.8 33.4 10'0" 21.2 18.0 10.6 60.4 57.0 30" 8'6" 16.9 11.0 17.0 44.8 37.4 80" 8'6" 20.2 24.0 8.6 64.4 629 9'0" 17.3 11.0 18.0 45.6 37.8 9'0" 20.3 24.0 9.1 64.3 627 9'6" 17.8 11.0 19.0 46.6 38.4 9'6" 20.4 24.0 9.6 64.4 627 10'0" 18.2 11.0 20.0 47.4 38.7 10'0" 20.5 24.0 10.2 65.0 63.3 45. 8'6" 19.4 13.5 120 523 46.5 90" 8'6" 19.0 25.0 8.5 63.0 9'0" 19.8 13.0 127 52.5 46.5 9'0" 19.0 24.0 9.0 620 9'6" 20.1 13.0 13.4 53.3 46.5 9'6" 19.0 24.0 9.5 62.0 10'0" 20.5 13.0 14.1 54.0 46.9 10'0" 19.0 24.0 10.0 620 Key for Table 654-1: A - ParlcingAngle B - Stall Width C -Stall to Curb D - Aisle Width E - Curb Length Per Car F-G - Total Width of a Double-loaded Aisle Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 144 Ar1lcle6 (f) (1) Driveway standards Driveways and off-street parking spaces for single-family detached dwelling>, regardless of zoning district, shall be subject to the following location and dimensional requirements, with such requirements applying to the portion of the driveway and off-street parking spaces located between the street and the building line established by the principal structure on the lot. (A) Any driveway shall be predominantly located toward one side of the dwelling unit, except in the case of a circular drive; (B) No driveway entrance or exit shall intersect with a street at a location closer than twenty (20) feet to any street intersection; (q Driveways and off-street parking spaces, except those off-street parking spaces provided in a garage or carport, shall not exceed a maximum of thirty (30) percent of the lot area between the street and the building line established by the principal sttucture on the lot and (D) Lot frontages ofless than one hnndred (100) feet shall be limited to one (1) curb cut. Any driveway on such lot frontage shall meet a minimum width requirement of ten (10) feet and shall not exceed a maximum width of twenty (20) feet or fifty (50) percent of the front lot line, whichever is less. (E) For lot frontages of one hnndred (100) feet or more, the total width of driveway entrances (curb cuts) shall not exceed fifty (50) percent of the lot frontage. Any driveway on such lot frontage shall meet a minimum width requirement of ten (10) feet and shall not exceed a maximum width of twenty (20) feet. (2) Driveways, except for single-family detached dwelling>, shall be subject to the following location and dimensional requirements: (A) No driveway entrance or exit shall intersect with a public street at a location closer than forty (40) feet to any street intersection; (B) The total width of driveway entrances (curb cuts) shall not exceed thirty-three (33) percent of the lot frontage, provided that in no case shall any lot be precluded from providing a maximum of one (1) two- way driveway entrance of eighteen (18) feet in width; and (q Driveways shall meet the width requirements of Table 654-2. Table 654-2. Driveway Widths, except for lots containing single-family detached dwellings! I-way 2-way Zoning Districts Minimum Maximum Minimum Width Width Width Maximum Width (feet) (feet) (feet) (feet)' RM-l 10 12 - - RM-2, RMF 12 15 18 24 CN,MX,1N 12 15 18 24 CG, CLS, D 12 15 18 30 1-1,1-2, !PUP 12 18 18 30 MXPUD, INPUD 12 15 18 24 ROS, AD 12 18 18 30 1 For driveway widths for single-family detached dwellings, in any zoning district, see Section 36.2-654(f)(1). 2 In all districts that have maximum widths for driveways, the maximum width of a driveway with a center median shall be forty-five (45) feet. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 1210Sl05 145 Article 6 (3) For lots under common ownership or an otherwise agreed to unified developmen4 the joint use of driveways, fronmge roads, and patking areas for non-residential uses may be required by the Zoning Administrator along collector and arterial streets. ':Joint use" means a cross-access easenient or other enforceable restriction that provides access between abutting properties. 36.2-655 Off-Street Loading (a) Generally Except for single-family and two-family dwellings, whenever the normal operation of any use requires that goods, merchandise, equipmen4 or refuse shall be routinely deliveted to or shipped from the site, the following regulations shall apply. (1) All required off-street loading spaces shall be located on the same zoning lot as the use served. (2) Space allocated to any required off-street loading shall not, while so allocated, be used to meet the requirements for off-street patking or portions thereof. (3) The minimum number of off-street loading spaces provided shall be as set forth in Table 655-1, except that the minimum loading space requirements of Table 655-1 shall not apply to the Downtown District (0) or the Commercial-Neighborhood District (CN). Table 655-L Off-Street Loading Requirements Net Leasable Area of Building Minimum Number of Loadine: Spaces 1,000 - 69,999 square feet 1 70,000 - 79,999 square feet 2 80,000 -127,999 square feet 3 128,000 -191,999 square feet 4 192,000 or more square feet 5 (b) Dimensional standards A required off-street loading space shall be at least fifteen (15) feet in width and twenty-five (25) feet in length, exclusive of aisle and maneuvering space, and shall provide a minimum vertical clearance of fifteen (15) feet. Where one (1) such space is provided, the minimum width of any additional loading space located alongside, contiguous to, and not separated from the first such loading space shall be twelve (12) feet. (c) Location (1) Off-street loading spaces shall not be permitted in a front yard. (2) Off-street loading spaces shall be provided to acconunodate delivery or shipment operations and refuse collection in a safe and convenient manner, with appropriate means of vehicular access to a street or alley in a manner that will least interfere with traffic movemen4 separated from customer and employee patking and located so as not to require or permit maneuvering, loading, or unloading in or projecting into a public street, sidewall<, or alley. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 148 Article S Division 6. Signs 36.2-660 Purpose The purpose of this Division is to pencit the use of publicly visible signs in a manner that protects the public health, safety, and welfare. It is not the intent of this Division to suppress any activities protected under the First Amendment or to regulate the content of signs, but to enact a content-neutral ordinance which will address the secondary effects of signs. The specific objective of this Division is to establish effective, consistent, and equitable regulations pertaining to the time, location, and manner in which publicly visible signs may be erected and maintained, in on\er to: (a) Promote the genetal health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of the City of Roanoke; (b) Implement the community's goals and policies as set forth in the City's Comprehensive Plan as they relate to the scale, munbeIS, and sizes of signs and the goal of quality, orderly, and harmonious development; (c) Enhance opportunities for the efficient and effective visual communication of information, direction, and business identification; (d) Protect the public investment in the creation, maintenance, and appearance of its streets, highways, and other public areas; (e) Reduce the disttactions, obstructions, and hazards to pedestrians and vehicular ttaffic caused by the nwnber, size, height, and placement of signs; (I) Promote an attractive, healthy economic and business climate by providing for the placement, size, and nwnber of signs in a manner that promotes visibility, legibility, and visually unified commercial areas; (g) Protect and enhance the appearance of the City to residents, tourists, and other visitors as sources of economic development, including the protection of views of the river and surrounding mountains and forests; (h) Preserve the residential character of residential neighbOIhoods; and (i) Protect property values by improving the quality of the built environment and eliminating nuisances to the use of other properties because of sign brightness, size, height, or movement. 36.2-661 Applicability (a) Generally The provisions of this Division shall apply to any new sign or sign structure and to the modification or alteration of any existing sign which is visible from any street, sidewalk, or public or private outdoor common space. For the purposes of this Division, changing the message or content of an approved marquee, or other approved changeable copy sign, electronic readerboard, or public service message board, or approved outdoor advertising sign, shall not be deemed an alteration or modification of such sign. (b) No content restriction No sign is subject to any limitation based on the content of the message contained on such sign. 'This subsection supersedes any other requirement of this Division to the extent of any inconsistency. (c) Exemptions The provisions of this Division, including the requirements for a zoning pennit, sha1l not apply to the following signs, provided that no such sign shall be placed within the public right-of-way or on public property or any closer than two (2) feet from a street right-of-way or any closer than five (5) feet from any side or rear property line, and provided further that if such sign is to be placed on a comer lot, it shall be located outside of any sight distance triangle. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 147 Article 6 Exempted signs shall not be included in the maximwn permissible nwnber of signs or maximwn permissible sign area. Any exempted sign that is to be located in the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-1) or the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2) shall be subject to the requirements of Section 36.2-530 if applicable. (1) Decorative home tlags or national, state, or other governmental tlags and insignias. (2) Legal notice, identification, informational, or directional signs erected by a government body or required to . be erected by a goverrnnent body. (3) Decorative banners attached to light poles, and secured at the top and bottom, which bear no advertising or commercial images. (4) Directional signs not exceeding four (4) square feet in sign area and four (4) feet in height. (5) Signs displaying only the word "open" or "closed," or the hours of operation, neon or otherwise, provided such signs do not exceed one (1) per lot and do not exceed four (4) square feet in sign area. (6) Commemorative plaques, historical markers, and signs which have special historical value or significance to the community, provided such signs are erected by a government body and do not exceed fifteen (15) square feet in sign area. (T) Nameplates not exceeding two (2) square feet in sign area. (8) Neighborhood identification signs, displaying only the name of rhe neighbothood and not exceeding fifteen (15) square feet in sign area. (9) Address sign not exceeding two (2) square feet in sign area. (10) Murals. (11) Political signs, provided that such signs shall be removed within ten (10) days after the election. (12) Real estate signs which advertise for sale, rent, or lease the land or building upon which such signs are located, provided such signs do not exceed one (1) per lot frontage and do not exceed the square footages in the following table. Zoning District in which Maximum Sqnare Footage of Sign Area Real Estate Sign is Located R-12,R-7,R-5,R-3,~-1,~-2 6 square feet RMF 16 square feet MX, MXPUD 32 square feet CN, CG, CL>,1-1, 1-2, D, IN,ROS,AD 60 square feet INPUD, IPUD 60 square feet (13) Off-site directional real estate signs, provided such signs do not exceed five (5) square feet in sign area and written permission is obtained from the property owner on which the off premise directional real estate sign is located. (14) Signs which display the time, date, temperature, or a public service announcement, provided such sign does not display any advertisement and is not located in a residential zoning district. (15) Memotial plaques. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 148 Article 6 (16) Signs placed on temporary structures, fences, and barricades placed around excavations or building projects, whether on public or ptivate property, which are related to safety consideIlltions with the construction. (17) Construction signs erected on the wall of a construction trailer or construction shed or erected on the ground, provided such signs shall be located only on the property on wbich construction is underway or is proposed, shall not be lighted by any means, shall be removed prior to the issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy, and shall not exceed the size or quantities as listed in the following table. Zoning District in which Size Quantity per Development Site Construction Sign is Located R-I2, R-7, R-S, R-3, RM-I, RM-2 6 square feet I per lot frontage RMF 16 square feet I per lot frontage MX, MXPUD 32 square feet I per lot frontage CN, CG, CLS, I-I, 1-2, D,IN,ROS,AD 60 square feet I per lot frontage INPUD,IPUD 60 square feet I per lot frontage 36.2-662 Definitions Signs and their characteristics, as used in this Division, shall be defined as set forth in this section and in Appendix A. For the purposes of this Division, to the extent of any inconsistency between Appendix A and this Division, the definitions provided in this Division shall control Address sign: A sign displaying only the assigned address of a property or building that is attached to a building or sign structure or part thereof. Animated sign: Any sign or part of a sign that changes physical position by any movement, oscillation, or rotation by natural or artificial means or that imitates or gives the visual appearance of such movement. A flashing sign and a sign that indicates only the time, temperature, or date shall not be considered an animated or moving sign. Awning: A structure made of fabric or similar non-rigid material supported by and projecting from the exterior wall of a building and designed to be Iaised, folded, rettacled, or collapsed to a llat position against the face of the supporting building. Awning sign: A sign that is painted on, printed on, or attached to the face of an awning and not projecting vertically above or horizootally beyond the physical dimensions of such awning. Banner: A sign consisting of plastic, canvas, cloth, paper, or fabric of any kind temporarily secured at one (I) or more edges to a pole or other structure, excluding national, state, and municipal flags and official flags of professional, institutional, or educational organizations. Billboard: See "Outdoor advertising sign." Building-mounted sign: A sign erected on, attached to, or painted on the wall, window, or door of a building, or attached to, printed on, or painted on an appurtenance of the building such as a canopy or awning or other accessory structure not otherwise designed or constructed to support signage. For the purpose of calculating the total maximum pennitted sign area for building-mounted signs as provided in this Division, building-mounted signs shall include awning signs, canopy signs, hanging canopy signs, marquee signs, projecting signs, street level wall signs, but shall not include window signs. Canopy sign: A sign that is painted on, printed on, or attached to a canopy. No such sign shall project vertically above or horizontally beyond the physical dimensions of such canopy. Changeable copy sign: A sign. or part of a sign. that is designed so that letters or numbers attached to the sign can be changed manually, or mechanically, to display a different copy or message. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 149 Article 6 Construction sign: A temporary sign that notifies the public of a specific building or development under construction or reconstruction or proposed to be constructed or reconstructed. The sign may also identifY the architect, engineer, contractor, subcontractor, or lending institution engaged in the project on the property on which the sign is located, or the suppliers of materials used thereon. Development identification sign: A sign used to display only the name, address, crest, or trademark of a business or organization, or to display the name of a subdivision, chmch, schoo~ park, or multifamily housing development Directional sign: An on-premise sign designed to guide pedestrian or vehicular traffic on the site by using words such as "Entr.lnce," ''Exit,'' "Parking," "One-Way," or other similar direcrionallanguage and which sign may contain the name of the establis1unent or its commercial logo in addition to the directional language. Double-decker or multi-stacked outdoor advertising sign: ..An outdoor advertising sign that contains two or more signs stacked on top of each other. Double-faced sign: A sign with two (2) sign faces attached to a common support structure and constructed to display the same copy or message on the outer surfaces of two (2) identical and opposite parallel planes not more than thirty-six (36) inches apart or not separated by an interior angle of more than forty-five (45) degrees. Electronic readerboard: A computer generated sign which displays messages with letters, pictogmphic, or symbolic informational content which can be changed or alteted on a fixed display screen by electrically illwninated segments. Embellishment: Letters, nwnerals, figures, images, emblems, logos, or other features extending from within and projecting beyond the framing of the normal sign face of an outdoor advertising sign as a part of a commercial advertising message. Flag: A single piece of canvas, plastic, cloth, paper, or other fabric or any other material which has been attached along one side or edge of a support. Flashing sign: A sign that uses intermittent or sequential flashing or running lights, or lights creating an illusion of movement, to attract attention. Electronic readerboards shall not be considered flashing signs. Freestanding sign: A sign supported by one or more upright poles, columns, or braces placed exclusively in or on the ground. 1bis tenn shall include pole and monwnent signs. For purposes of the regulations of this Division, outdoor advertising signs and public service message boatds shall not be considered freestanding signs. Government sign: Any temporary or permanent sign erected and maintained for any official govenunental purpose. Graphic: Any logo, emblem, insignia, or text fonned by writing, drawing, painting, or engraving. Hanging canopy sign: A small, pedestrian-oriented sign that is suspended beneath a canopy by means of blackets, hooks or chains, and the like, and which face is generally perpendicular or parallel to the building element to which the canopy is attached. Historical marker: A memorial sign limited in content to the identification of a historical building or structure or the site of a historical event Identification sign: A sign which is limited to the name, trademark or other readily recognized symbo~ street address and number, or any combination thereof, of a building. institution, business, organization, or establishment and to the activity carried on in the building, institution, business, or establislunent on the premises where the sign is located, or announcing the name of a subdivision, shopping center, chmch, schoo~ park, or multifamily housing development. Identification signs shall also include nameplates. Illuminated sign: A sign with an artificial light source, incOIporated intemally or externally, for the purpose of illwninating the sign. A neon sign shall be considered an illwninated sign. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 150 Article 6 Inflatable sign: One or more moored balloons, or any other type of tethered object that is capable of being expanded by air or other gas, water, or other means, that exceeds twenty-four (24) inches in di.meter and is used as a means of directing attention to any business, profession, service, product, goods, promotion, activity, or special event Laser light or image projection sign: The projection of light or a laser beam onto a solid surface, or projected into the sky, in order to project an image. Logo: Any emblem used as the symbol of an organization or residential or non-residential commwlity. A logo may include a graphic, text, or both. Marquee: A fixed hood located at the main enlr.lnce of a building, constructed of metal or other permanent material, which is projecting from and supported only by the building to which it is attached and which includes a sign or advertising announcement. Marquee sign: A sign attached to or painred on a marquee. Memorial plaque: A plaque, measuring no more than four (4) square feet in area, designating the name of a building or date of erection and other similar information such as the architect, contractors, or others involved in the building's creation, 'With such information carved into stone or cast in bronze or similar material and made an integral part of the structure. Monument sign: A type of freestanding sign with the entire bottom of the sign mOlUlred or affixed to a base or pedestal or direcdy to the ground, in which the sign and support structure are an integral part of one another. Mural: A picture painred on or affixed to the exterior w:ill or window of a building, gener.illy for the purpose of decoration or artistic expression, and which includes no 'WOrds, graphics, or logos that advertise existing products or services of any entity. A mural may contain words, graphics, or logos that depict products that are no longer available or services or entities that no longer exist. Nameplate: A sign affixed to the w:ill of a building in such a manner as to become an integral part thereof, and which provides only the name or address, or both, of the owner or occupant of a building or premises. Off-site directional sign: A sign that directs traffic to a site other than the lot on wItich the sign is located. Off-premise sign: A sign or sign structure or portion thereof which directs attention to a business, activity, commodity, service, product, entertainment, or attraction not conducted, sold, or offered on the lot where the sign is locared. Such sign may also be known as a billboard or outdoor advertising sign. On-premise sign: A sign which directs attention to a business, commodity, activity, service, product, entertainment, or attraction conducted, sold, or offered on the lot on which the sign is located. Outdoor advertising sign: An off-premise sign or sign structure, commonly referreclto as a "billboard," with display space available for lease and designed so that the copy or pOSler on the sign can be changed frequently. For purposes of this Chapter, an "outdoor advertising sign" shall be regulated as a principal use. Pennant: Any lightweight plastic, fabric, or other similar material, whether or not containing a message or copy of any kind, suspended from a rope, wire, or string, usually in a series, designed to move in the wind. Pole sign: A type of freestanding sign which is mounred on and supported by one or more freestanding stationary poles. Political sign: A sign promoting the candidacy of a person rururing for a governmental office or promoting a position on an issue to be voted on at a govenunent election. Portable sign: A self-supported sign which is movable without involving any structural or support changes, and which is not affixed to a building or building appendage, inclnding but not limited to portable changeable message Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 151 Article 6 cabinets and sandwich board signs. Portable signs include signs with wheels or with wheels removed, signs with chassis or support constructed without wheels, and signs monnted on a motor vehicle, or portion thereof, for the express purpose of advertising a business establishment, product, service, or entertainment when that motor vehicle is parked so to attract the attention of vehicular or pedestrian trllffic. Portable signs shall not include bumper stickers or identification signs directly applied to or painted on motor vehicles identifying the owner of the vehicle, a business name, logo, or emblem. Projecting sign: A sign which is attached to, supported by, and extending more than twelve (12) inches from a building face or wall, in whole or in part, at a ninety (90) degree angle to the building wall from which it projects and to which it is attached. Such sign shall extend no more than six (6) feet from the building to which it is affixed. An awning, canopy, or nuuquee sign shall not be considered a projecting sign. Public service message board: An electronic readerboatd which displays public service messages. Public service messages shall mean the promotion of public events at public facilities (such as festivals, concerts, and sporting events), promotion of events at public facilities (such as in parks, sports/amphitheatre complex, or civic center), infonnation about tourist attractions in the City or conventions in the City, public safety messages (such as weather or traffic warnings), and other similar types of public service messages. Real estate sign: A sign which advertises for sale, lease, or rent the lot or structure, or portion thereof, upon which the sign is located. Refacing: The replacement of a sign face, reganlless of change in copy, of equal size to the original, without altering the sign cabinet, sign frame, or sign support structure. Roof sign: A sign that is monnted on the roof of a building, or any appurtenances thereto, such as a parapet wall, mechanical penthouse, or elevator house, and extending vertically above any portion of the roof or appurtenances thereto. A sign that is monnted to or painted on a parapet wall that is an extension of the fal""ie of the building shall not be considered a roof sign, provided such sign does not extend vertically above the parapet wall to which it is attached. Sandwich board or "A" frame sign: A double-faced sign which is not secured or attached to the gronnd, is readily moved &om place to place, and is constructed in such a manner as to form an "AU or a tent-like shape, hinged or not hinged at the top, with each angolar face held at an appropriate distance by a supporting member. A sandwich boatd or "A" frame sign shall not exceed four (4) feet in height and two and one-half (2-1/2) feet in width. Searchlight or beacon sign: A searchlight or beacon that utilizes stationary or revolving light that flashes or projects illwnination, single color or multicolored, to annOWlce, attract attention, or advertise a business or special event. Sign: Any object, device, structure, or fixture, or portion thereof, which is used to announce, advertise, identify, display, or direct or attract attention to an object, person, institution, organization, business, product, goods, service, special promotion, activity, event, or location. The means used to direct or attract attention include, without limitation, objects, devices, fixtures, words,letters, nwnerals, graphics, figures, emblems, designs, illustration, decoration, symbols, logos, tradematk.s, colors, or projected illumination or images. Sign area: The entire sign face within a single continuous perimeter, enclosing the extreme limits of sign display, including all words, letters, nwnerals, graphics, figures, designs, symbols, fixtures, logos, emblems, insignias, or other drawings or images used to create a sign, together with any backgronnd or surronnding material, panel, frame, border, trim, molding or omamentation, or color that differenriates the sign from the structure, backdrop surface, or object upon or against which it is placed. For purposes of this Division, sign area shall not include any portion of the sign support structure, provided that no message, logo, emblem, or other symbol or any other element of a sign or sign area, as defined in this Chapter, is placed on or designed as a part of the sign support structure. Sign cabinet: A structure that frames and supports the sign face(s). A sign cabinet may enclose internal illuminatinn. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 152 Article 6 Sign face: The area or display surface that is used or can be used to identify, advertise, or communicate information or for visual representation that attracts the attention of the public for any purpose. Sign face shall not include the sign cabinet or sign structure. Sign height: The vertical distance measured from and perpendicular to the average ground level on all sides of the sign support structure to the level of the highest point of the sign or sign structure, whichever is higher. Sign setback: The minimum distance required between any lot line and any portion of a sign or sign structure. Sign support structure: Any structure that supports or is capable of supporting a sign, including uprights on which the sign is placed or btacing or the decotative wall or fence to which a sign is attached. A decotative pole cover shall be considered part of the sign support structure. Snipe sign: Any sign of any material, including paper, cardboanl, wood, metal, or cloth, where such sign is tacked, nailed, stapled, pasted, painted, or attached in any way to any tree, clift; utility pole or support utility tower, radio or television tower, telecommunications tower, vehicular or pedestrian traffic control sign or structure, street name sign, fence or retaining wall, and other similar structures, when such sign does not apply to the activity on the lot on which it is located. Stteamer: Any long, narrow strip of cloth, paper, plastic, or other material. Temporary sign: A sign or other advertising device affixed to a building, building appendage, or existing freestanding sign structure for a specified period of time as delineated in Section 36.2-673. Tempornry signs are designed to be readily relocated and displayed for tempornry purposes such as the identification or announcement of seasona1 or bnef activities, including special commercial sales, holiday events, auctions, grand openings, or a special event or activity. Wall sign, Street leveh A sign painted direcdy on the outside wall of a building, or attached to and erected parallel to the face of a building and supported throughout its length by such wall of the building. Such sign shall project no more than one (1) foot outward from the fa~ade of the building to which it is attached and shall be located or erected with the highest ponion of the sign at or below a height of twenty-five (25) feet above adjacent ground level Wall Sign, Upper story: A sign painted directly on the outside wall of a building, or attached to and erected parallel to the face of a building and supported through its length by such wall of the building. Such sign shall project no more than sixteen (16) inches outward from the fa<;ade of the building to which it is attached and shall be located or erected with the lowest ponion of the sign above a height of twenty-five (25) feet above adjacent ground level Window sign: A sign that is applied or attached direcdy to the intenor or extenor of a window, or that is suspended from or located within twelve (12) inches of a window or door, so that it is visible from any street, sidewalk, or public or private outdoor common space. This tenn shall not include merchandise located in a window. Window area: The total square foorage of the glass area within a frame upon which a window sign is applied, attached, suspended from, or through which it is displayed. Such glass area may include glass windows, doors, sidelights, and lIansoms, fixed or operable. Window sign area: The total area of the imaginary rectangles contiguous to and surrounding each word, picture, logo, logotype, symbo~ banding, or graphic. 36.2-663 Prohibited Signs The following signs and sign charactenstics shall be prohibited in all zoning districts: (a) Animated signs, provided that moveable pane1s of outdoor advertising signs which mechanically rotate to provide different messages shall not be considered animation. (b) Flashing signs, provided that theatre marquees shall be exempt from the prohibition of Bashing signs. Zoning Ordlnanca - City of Roanoke 12/05105 153 Article 6 (c) Inflatable signs, except as a temporary sign under the provisions of 36.2-673. (d) Laser light or image projection signs, except as a temporary sign under the provisions of Section 36.2-673. (e) Off-site directional signs, except for off-site directional real estate signs as provided for in Section 36.2-661(c)(13). (I) Pennants or streamers. (g) Portable signs, except for sandwich board signs as expressly permitted in this Chapter. (h) Projecting signs erected with their lowest portions above a height of twenty-five (25) feet above adjacent ground level. (i) Roof signs, except for existing roof signs located in, or such signs located and relocated within, the Historic Downtown Overlay District (Ii-I). (j) Searchlight or beacon signs, except as a temporary sign under the provisions of Section 36.2-673. (k) Snipe signs. (I) Any sign located within or over a public right-of-way, or public property, except for government signs or signs erected under the provisions set forth in Chapter 27.1 of this Code. (m) Any sign that contains beacons of light resembling or simulating any emergency service vehicle or equipment. (n) Any sign using traffic symbols or colors of red, amber, and green in such combination of shape or color as to be confused with traffic control devices. (0) Any sign attached partially or wholly to the pitched or flat roof of a building, or any sign which projects horizontally or vertically beyond any part of the building to which it is attached. (P) Any sign that produces sound, odor, or visible matter such as smoke or vapor. 36.2-664 Zoning Permits for Signs (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to erect, install, structurally alter, modify, relocate, or replace any sign or sign structure, except for those exempted signs set forth in Section 36.2-661(c), without first obtaining a zoning permit pUISUallt to this section. The refacing of a sign shall not require a zoning permit, (b) A completed application for a zoning permit for a sign shall be submitted to the Zoning Administrator, shall be accompanied by the required application fee as set forth within the most recent fee schedule approved by City Council, and shall include the following: (I) For all signs, specifications regan:ling the type of sign to be constructed, sign height, sign face dimensions, source of illumination, the location of such sign on any wall or property, the official tax map number of the lot on which the sign is to be located, and the zoning district of the subject lot; (2) For building-mounted signs, dimensions of the building wall or appurtenance on which the sign is to be affixed. and the dimensions and locations of the proposed building-mOlUlted signs; (3) For freestanding signs, a scaled drawing showing the location of any proposed freestanding sign, the relationship of the proposed sign to sight distance triangles if applicable, and the relationship of the proposed sign to any other freestanding sign on the lot or to the lot line; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 154 Article 6 (4) In addition to the general requirements for applications for wning pennits for signs as set forth above, applications for wning pennits for outdoor advertising signs shall include additional infonnation as set forth in Section 36.2-{j75(f). (c) In addition to the requirements of subsections (a) and (b) above, an application for a zoning pennit for any sign located in the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-l) or the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2), excluding temporary signs, shall include a copy of a Certificate of Appropriateness issued by the Architeclurll! Review Board or its Agent for the proposed sign, accompanied by renderings. (d) In addition to the requirements of subsections (a), (b), and (c) above, an application for a zoning pennit for any sign to be placed on, or project over, any sidewalk, stree~ alley, or other public property shall include documentation of meeting, and having received approval for, the requirements of Chapter 27.1 of this Code, regarding encroachments, liability insurance, and an indemnification and hold hannless agreement (e) A zoning permit for a sign shall become null and void if the sign is not erected within six (6) months after the rlate the wning pennit is issued. Upon written request and for good cause shown, the Zoning Administrator may grnnt one six (6) month extension. 36.2-665 Removal of Abandoned Nonconforming Signs The Zoning Administrator may order the removal of any nonconforming sign that has been abandoned. For pwposes of this section, a sign shall be considered abandoned if the business or use for which the sign was erected has not been in operation for a period of at least two (2) years. Such nonconfonning sign(s) and its supporting structure shall be removed by the owner of the property on which the sign is located, or the agent for the property owner, or tenant or lessee of the property having beneficial use of the property upon which the sign(s) is located, within thirty (30) days of written notice by the Zoning Administrator. 36.2-666 Illuminated Signs When any sign is illuminated, such lights shall be enclosed in the sign, or if external, such extemallight source shall be located, shielded, or directed so as to concentrate the illumination upon the area of the sign face and so that the point source of the light is not visible from any adjacent street or lot. If ground lighting is used to illuminate a sign, and the point source of the light is not equipped with shielding to prevent its visibility from any adjacent street or lo~ such ground lighting shall be fully screened from view by landscaping material. 36.2-667 Calculation of Sign Area and Number of On-Premise Signs (a) The ca1culation of the number of on-premise signs and sign area allotment shall be based on the applicable lot frontage for freestanding signs and the applicable building frontage or storefront for building-mounted signs. (1) Any freestanding sign shall be located along the lot frontage from which the allotment for the freestanding sign is computed. (2) Any building-mounted sign shall be located on the building fa~ade from which the allotment for the building-mounted sign is computed. For purposes of a building-mounted sign which is attached to an appurtenance of the building or to an accessory structure not otherwise designed or constructed so support signage, such sign shall be located between the building line of the fa~ade from which the building-mounted sign allotment is computed and the public right-<Jf-way which it faces or, where applicable, within the parking lot which abuts the building fac;ade from which the allotment is computed. (b) The following method shall be utilized in the calculation of sign area for on-premise signs: (1) Sign area for freestanding signs and building-mounted signs shall be calculated separately; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke 12/05105 155 Article 6 (2) Each sign face shall count in calculating total sign area, except that in the case of a double-faced sign, only one sign face shall be used in the calculation of sign area; (3) For signs composed of individually attached letters, nwnerals, pictures, logos, symbols, or figures, the sign area shall be detennined by computing the entire area within a single, continuous geometric fonn that encloses the limits of all lettering, nwnerals, figures, designs, symbols, fixtures, logos, emblems, insignias, or other drawings or images; and (4) For signs enclosed by a frame or border or encased by a cabinet, the sign area shall be determined by computing the entire area within a continuous perimeter, enclosing the limits of writing, representation, emblem, or any figure or similar character, together with any cabinet, frame, or other material or color fonning an integral part of the display or used to differentiate the sign from the background against which it is placed. 36.2-668 Types and Number of On-Premise Signs The types and nwnber of on-premise signs by zoning district shall be permitted as set forth in Table 668-1. 36.2-669 Dimensional Standards for On-Premise Signs In addition to the other applicable regulations set forth in this Division, on-premise signs shall meet the dimensional, height, and setback regulations as set forth in Table 669-1. 36.2-670 Freestanding Signs In addition to the regulations set forth in Table 668-1 and Table 669-1, no on-premise freestanding sign, nor any part of such sign other than a supporting pole or brace no greater than eighteen (18) inches in width or diameter, shall be located lower than nine (9) feet from grade within any sight distance triangle. 36.2-671 Building-Mounted Signs In addition to the regulations set forth in Table 668-1 and Table 669-1, on-premise building-mounted signs shall be subject to the following standards: (a) Building-mounted signs shall be permitted only on the facades or appurtenances of buildings or accessory structures which face upon an abutting street or an abutting parking lot on the same lot on which the sign is located. (b) No building-mounted sign, except for a projecting sign, shall cover, cross, or otherwise hide any cornice, column, belt course, window, or balcony of a building, or any portion of such feature. (c) Wmdow sigus shall not exceed fifty (50) percent of the window area to which they are applied or attached, from which they are suspended, or through which they are displayed. (d) No part of any awning or canopy containing a sigu shall extend above the height of the bottom sill of any second story window of the building fa~ade to which it is attached. All lettering and images comprising any portion of an awning or canopy sign shall be located on the face of the awning or canopy and shall not project above or below the face or in any way beyond the physical dimensions of the awning or canopy. 36.2-672 Upper Story Wall Signs Where on-premise upper story wall signs are pennitted as set forth in Table 668-1, the sign area of such wall signs shall be calculated separately and shall not be computed in the maximwn total square footllge of building-mounted sign Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 158 Article 6 area. In addition to the other applicable regulations of this Division, such upper story w:ill signs shall meet the following requirements: (a) Upper story w:ill signs shall be limited to identification signs; (b) No upper story wall sign shall cover. cross, or otherwise hide any comice, colwnn, belt course, window, or balcony of a building, or any portion of such feature; (c) There shall be a maximum of one (1) upper storyw:ill sign for each exposed face of the building; and (d) The maximum sign area for any upper story w:ill sign shall be two (2) percent of the surface area of the building fa9<lde on which the sign is placed, up to a maximum of three hwulred (300) square feet Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 1117 Article 6 I~ av ;- - ;- 2 2 ;- 2 2 2 I'" ~ IE ClfldI 'ClfldN! ;- - ;- ~~ 2 ;- ;- ;- 2 2!:i , ;-"2 - 1" Z-I'l-I ;- ~ ;- 2 2 ;- ;- 2 2 - ~ SD ;- ~ ;- ;- 2 ;- ;- ;- 2 - - ~ 0 " a ;- - ;- ;- ] ;- ;- 2 ;- ..2:.... D::> ;- - ;- ;- 2 ;- ;- ;- 2 I~ SOlI'N! 'xw 'N::> ;- - ;- 2 2 ;;. ;- 2 2 g 'il", <<If)dXI\[ , , , 2 2 is I'" :~I~ ,JW1J ptre z-m "! ""'[] lImA,! dnOJD ;- - ;- 2 2 2 2 2 2 i51'= pm sU~'EpOwwO:J:>V Ii UO~tOp:lWp! ~u;)wdop~ ~:uow .~ @ .10 SJ!Un 9LJO s:)tQwdo~p ;- - ;- 2 2 2 2 2 2 lllJ!Jp&p ,(~I"W I] :!lPUlSIp "",000= U] <Jl - - ~ Ii. ... N ~ ~ "" j '~ 0 .Jl ~ ~ E ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " 5 0 5 B -0 g ~ '" ~ ! -0 II 0 '" 'a j ~ B 5 :E ] B v- a j. ,~ '" II ~ ] ~< B ~ :E ~ B Z II a a tl 0< II "" 1 :E ,~ ,~ '" j, ] ~ a .s <Jl < ~ IJ "' <Jl <Jl - ;;. <Jl ,~ ,~ ] 0 U ,~ g: ~ ~ '" ] <Jl <Jl 0 ] ,~ 1- l .. ~ t J,j <Jl U ~ ~t 1 j ] t i 'E .... J jj~ ~ <Jl ,~ ~i'! ~ } ~ u .~ \0 g - ~ ,~ ~:;j ~ "" 0 ~ ;1l '" ~ tj; 6: ~ ~ ~ c e € "" ~ - ~ jj ,,6'l!.: " . ::' ~ ~.5 ~ o '" ~~ ""EE ao ':8 ell "ot t:..cc :.g 15 at 0 I,,;:; (lI"'O b.O ,$ " " ~ ,$ .- .... = ij ,~" U e ..E v; -='8 u -l uO" ~, :.E - " ~~-g gjB '-"iJ"'O "] 10 ,," B ~ c: l5.. 'lee ~ . - ~. :R'og o .~ 5!fJ >.= '0 ~ .t::.", 8" ell c:...... -8 c;:l u ~ '~~ ~, :p '0 1;; 3 ...... .... ~ 8 ~'" o-5c...... ~',r, a~. 0 ~ .~ 0 "fi ~ ~t'l1!ll'01i ::I !;:; Q.J::: e--E tf a ~g.e... 'S"] "_go .E -s~ C"'[j- .~ .... ...... -..;.... ~ c O..9~ ~t<~~ 5 '0 ';::' l,n ~ ~ ] ~ c "s '"'" ~ 1l .....c:: ~ ~ ~ ~ Z ~~ -S:.=:l -..;.......... '0 ~g .[ ~ ~ ] 1 s g 'if g ~ ~ ~ i:ES!;i, 1l~ "0 N if 8 a ~"" U o ~ ~ .~ '(I; -; ~ ~ ~~.E '0 S.5 'w ~ ... a.... C u.... e;--... o 'if'..9 =a ::; J1 ~ v- i!~""" -;s..c: 1IJ IIJ 5h "'8~~-g';;~~1i lI.JC J:!: ~ c.I ; g.. g "5 8 ~ a ~ "~o " u ~ irJ!-a~1! ~ ell s,"'.............. 0 gj s~ .~ .~:.a 0 = ::g 1 " Iii J! ,u Ii, ~ g " , ~.s ~ ~ '. iO' g"1! o ~ ~ :.f! ~ J:: 8 ~ ~ ~ g":6 t! ~ 5 ~ ""_Gi'~.llE~ ..c .~ ...e c ti '0 t: 0 ] E " jj g " ~ o'~ tIl ~'~:E ~ S,.=; ~ t;; .~ if ~ ~ ~ -;] ] ~ ";';;~~jj]" BB".: <04) lo< ~~ ..."'C'.t:J ~ .~ '0 ~ ~ .~ ~ ~ '~ ~ '5] 81B'~ ~ 's ~ !i! B ~~. ~ u g..~ '0 0 -: "--'~ ~ ~ '" 0,.1 o ~ 0 ~ ti _ -5 '. ;; '" .is ... ,s 'S II,l til c:: "'C II> S g ~ . '" .c '. ~ " !J <.<=o'O'O::;;lU),,=,oe Ee:!F= ..c'E~-€:>. ~ a::i3:><"'o;.IlOlIJo. ~ ] jjl :;;:~2 ~] 8 '^ ~>< ~"t" - " "p, ~ -.;I >''''C (II..c -5 ,13 .E ~.5 g- ~ ~ g ~ i .s~.~ t.~~ '2'~ ~ ~ v-5~Jlll}n'p s~'-'__ u_oE ~ <Jl 0 ~ ~ 1l.I.__ E ~;::. u 0,.1 o.....-;! f.. U 0 >. >. e .~ ~ ~ I:: e ... ~ e e ... ... ... :.;:;':;::'~:;~;.s~] = .. on ~ ~ ~ j o c .. o 0= "5 ~ c:; I " u C .. c '!! 0<0 0>" c- -u c- ot: No( ~ 'i " .S 5 e is Ul ~-< 's ~ '" ~ o "i ~ .!l .Q ~ !-< l? " GOdI 'GOdNl <-101-1 SOlI 'N! ':x:Ji\I 'N:) tGIldXIII ,rnrn pm <-Wl! ~ ~n~!'1 dnOJD 'f1 SUO!l'EpOWWOOJV UO~~U;)P! ,,,,,wdop^"p ~;;uow JO~!lRl 9lJO """WdopA:>p llumo^'P ,(1!W"J~l"l\l "''''!'l'!PJ1'!l''''P!''''UJ c cry S'D a OJ s ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . o ~ ..... U'\ ~ ~ ~ ..... ~ r-- ~ ~ ~ Pl -.0 \00 ~ - ' ..... ~ ~ ;- -.0 ..... ~ r-- Pl '-0 \0 ~ '>0 '>0 ~ -.0 '>0 .! ~ ,21' 6 ~ ~ ~ '0 13 ~ .. ::E v .z.. V> ~l .<i ~ <=1 - -< ..... :z: <=1 o ~ o .... -< ..... :z: o .... -< ..... :z: o .... -< ..... :z: <=1 -< ..... :z: <=1 '" '" . =<: ..... :z: :!:l :<: ..... :z: ~ ;:l_ 0 g G ~ .gp~ "'0 '"' rn...... ~ <:<18 ... 0 <'ll &,'" ;: 110 u .-...... CI,) <'ll ..9 .: 0 <1:! C ;::_ ~ ~ ~..g .~ ~ c &-0 ~ v..g Vl - ..E ~.... ~: v g..Q ...... .B ~ <n '" <:II 0.... ~ c e t: G' .~ ...........:1<.0=0 "'0 o t: E QJ C ~ e ~ .~ ~ t: c S ~ e g" .E g .~ ~ <:<I 0 ~ e <'ll 0"' ..c l.I'l 0 i:P e 1Il .~ ~ ~ ~ Cll ~ _~ r::: .~ :"::l ..s:::.... '-' r;:o CI,) ::I ... ...... ~::l ..c <l.i.o .~ 0 <:<I = e '"' '"' 1f ~ .E .~ ::l ~.B - S .. s ~ - e g .~ .0 . .;: ~ - .21'." S v .. ~ Vl e '" C <:<I ~.5!fJ o .~_ <'ll .s ~ ..c g :; C1.. .~"'2..cu .~ .~ ~ g go ~~o - - ...._ :.Eo- -0-0,- .s ;~ ~O'\ ~~o ..... u c ~ El e ti o :.a g:; 0.... ..9 g ~ c:: ~..... ~o "'..... v ~ 01:.8 t! ~ .... ~ ~ .. c..... .~..9 & ~ ~~ ~o ~ '" <:<I 'Jl r;:o tL... _g ~g~ 8 go -c "'0'-' 1'1 <.l:l 2:'" ..... 0 ..e v 0 ~ o~ ~~ :.a~~ "'0 -5]0: ~~b S ~ ..t: ] -; g -; .!= "t= g............ CI,) .2f13 c ;..:= ..9 ;::;'..8 b() c ~ V <'ll - e <:<I <:<l CI,) .s... '"0 t: c'" ..c "'0 >...8 g ~ 8..E:; 1: ..c.....~ ~ ': t: ~ =:l 1l~ v::l ..Q~C; .<:<1 C ...... CT' ................. ..c .... ~ CI,) '" !'! ~ "'0 : .... .... 8 g ~ cq c ~~ ..; ~ ~ ~ v !:! r:r .0.... :.= ~.Xl ~ v '", ~ ~ ..g ; ::::l 4-< ~ tf: c ~ ... ...~~~N 10 -Sb~~~ .B~~.o: .nE E5::~g. ~ g' go=; 0 ~ .~ 13 ~ 5 go; .~ cq ~ ~ g ~.~ '0 '-t cq :; "'3 .~.~ ~.5 .~ e F1 1: R'~;'; b.O"'O "'0 <;;.;i l< ... 0:0::1 .;::: OIJ -;; "'0 ~ ~ ~ M & e g. 'd" ..g] 15 ,M .~ ~ .~ .~ ': (U~ ~ ~ 1: e ~ ~ 5 -€v~~ti (Uv ::;::3.a~p.. :.:... & p.. p... o.~ ~..... _ l=: c: (U .. 0 -.= 0 (U ~ 0..."'0 ~ v t:: c.. '" l< '"' ~ ... ~~~~0:0::I;! e~ ....(U......~(U "0 .<i.~~'~ 8 g ~o" ~ ;~ ~~ c:: 10.{', '" "" '" 0. "" ..c "'0 ;:g "n ..: ::::l .;::r',-... e::l l< l e;::l"'o 0 .<:"J J:! 0 0 ::I 4-< <:"J ~ ~ ~ ~ 5 0 .; c e li~ ~ ~ c: a .a 0:0::I'l< ~ J:! 0 ';(. ~::; ~o "0 .9 0 0 '0 0:0::I.e .... ..:: - ..t: 0 ~ ';;J .B.B e c:: tf '0 eo"" ..s ... ~ E ~ ~ ~ ..g .~ -; .f5 ] ~ ~ ~ ~.5 ::l ::I ....~ '0 .-... ~ D::I::I ~ "'0 r:r r:r t --0 0 ..E .tl ~ :f; g' go ..t: ou '" ""S 0:0::1 N ou tI ..... t< ca .... -s ca 13 '" d ,2. a: .!!l '0 8 13 '0 C ,..,~ 15 0 a ... ........ Cl (t.l...!:l S .... 0:0::1............ V Ocv 0.0 V ~ ou ~ e e 0 u .... .~ d 0 .a 0 E 15 ell.::3::1u.$! .,2.'neUC::C::::l~ ___ ><i E e q,) c:: ~ ~ t ... ~,~ t.5' :.... ::E .t< .t< ..t: .~ o..c 0. 0 't:: - "'0 l< ......... t'l 0:0::1 .... II'> e .... .... c:: 0:0::1.... ?:..s:E::E..st:,",..sCti..s..9~::E~ :. .... '" ... '" 0.. 0..., ~ ~... 0:0::1 "" "" ::: ~ u os o. o o ;:0 .. ~ v of ~ o ell III ... ... ~ ~ ~ .:! o c ~ o a: o l> o I 1l c ~ c 'e 0", ~.!! 'E .~ ot: N<( 36.2-673 Temporary On-Premise Signs (a) No temporary sign shall be erected or posted until a zoning pennit has been issued pursuant to Section 36.2-664. (b) Any temporary sign shall comply with the regulations of this section and the height standards esrablished by zoning district in Table 669-1 ofSecrion 36.2-669. (c) Temporary signs shall not be included in the compuration of permitted sign area. (d) Except as otherwise provided in this section, no temporary sign shall be erected or placed for a period exceeding thirty (30) days in any 36S-day period. (e) Only one temporary sign per lot frontage shall be erected or posted at any given time on any lot, except when such lot contains multiple esrablishments or uses, one (1) temporary sign shall be permitted for each separately identifiable use or esrablishment located thereon. (I) Except as otherwise provided in this section, temporary signs shall be permitted in accotdance with Table 673-1. Table 673-1. Temporary Signs: Maximum Square Footage of Sign Area (A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (1-1) (I) 0) 0 ;:> '" ~ .>: .,.; .,.; .>: ~ 0 t--" 'N z" ;:> ;"~ '" ~ ~ ~ 0" ~ -" '"i ;:> ~ ~ ;ff~ z" 0 :3 of ~ '" 0 z u u u ~ ~ Maximum square footage of sign area per temporary -- 16 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 si"" (g) One (1) temporary residential subdivision identification sign not exceeding thirty-two (32) square feet in sign area may be erected during constroction at an entrance to the subdivided property, provided such sign is not illwninated intemally or by any extemallight source and not over two (2) such signs shall be erected for any one (1) subdivision. These signs shall be removed upon the issuance of Certificates of Occupancy for seventy-five CIS) percent of the lots in the subdivision. (h) Inflatable signs, laser light or image projection signs, or searchlight or beacon signs shall be permitted as temporary signs, provided such signs meet the following requirements: (1) Permits for such signs shall not be issued unless the applicant provides documentation from the Roanoke Regional Airport and medical helicopter patient transportation providers within the City limits of non-interference with established routes; (2) Only one (1) such sign per lot shall be permitted at anyone time; (3) Permits for such signs shall be limited to two (2) times per year per lot; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 160 Article 6 (4) Any pennit fot a tempor:uy inflatable sign shall be issued for a period not to exceed seven \T) days; (5) Inflatable signs shall be securely fastened to the ground or other immovable object and shall be located a minimwn of eight (8) feet from the lot line; and (6) Any pennit for a tempor:uy laser light or image projection sign, or a searchlight or beacon sign, shall be issned for a period not to exceed three (3) days. 36.2-674 Public Service Message Boards W'here public service message boards are permitted as set forth in Table 668-1, the sign area of such public setvice message boards shall not be included in the calculation of freestanding signs; however, public service message boards shall be permitted only on lot frontages with no other freestanding signs. In the case of a double-faced sign, only one such face shall count in calculating the total sign area of a public service message board. In addition to the other applicable regulations of this Division. public service message boards shall meet the following requirements: (a) No more than one (1) public service message board shall be permitted per lot frontage; (b) No public service message board structure shall have more than two (2) sign faces; (c) A public service message board shall not exceed twenty-five (25) feet in height; (d) A public service message board shall not exceed four hundred fifty (450) square feet of sign area; (e) A public service message board shall have a minimwn setback of five (5) feet from any public right- of-way or lot line; and (f) The copy on a public service message board shall not change or move more than once every six (6) seconds. 36.2-675 Outdoor Advertising Signs (a) Applicability The regulations set forth in this section shall apply to any outdoor advertising sign and shall supplement the general regulations of this Division. (b) Sign area by zoning district Where pennitted by this Chapter, outdoor advertising signs shall not exceed the following square footage of sign area: Zoning District Maximum Area Additional Area for Embellishments per Sign Face (percent of sign surface area) -(sQuare feet) CG,D 300 10% 1-1,1-2 672 10% (c) Setback, height, and sign face standards (1) Outdoor advertising signs shall be subject to the yard requirements of the applicable zoning district. (2) The maximwn height for any outdoor advertising sign shall be twenty-five (25) feet. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 161 Article 6 (3) No outdoor advertising sign structure shall have more than two (2) sign faces and no two (2) such sign faces shall be separated by an interior angle of more than forty-five (45) degrees. (d) Spacing standards (1) No outdoor advertising sign shall be erected as follows: (A) Within three hundred (300) feet of the boundary line of any residential district within the City; (B) Within two hundred fifty (250) feet of the property line of any public school, public library, place of worship, museum, or public park; (C) Within three hundred fifty (350) feet of any outdoor advertising sign on the same side of the street; (D) Within two hundred fifty (250) feet of the nearest edge of the right-of-way of 1-581 and the Roy L. Webber Expressway (Southwest Expressway); (E) Within six hundred sixty (660) feet of the nearest edge of the right-of-way of the Blue Ridge Parkway; or (F) Along an arterial or collector street within five hundred (500) feet of any point in the City at which the City's municipal corporation boundary is intersected by the arterial or collector street. (2) The distances separating outdoor advertising signs from each other, or separating any outdoor advertising sign from any boundary, shall be measured from the nearest point on the proposed outdoor advertising sign to the nearest applicable point of another outdoor advertising sign or boundary. (e) State standards J\.II outdoor advertising signs shall be erected in conformance and compliance with those portions of Chapter 7, Title 33.1, of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, which by the provisions of that chapter are made applicable to areas of the City within six hundred sixty (660) feet of the nearest edge of the right-of-way of any interstate or federal-aid- primary highway, as defined in Chapter 7 of TItle 33.1. (f) Zoning permits for outdoor advertising signs In addition to the requirements for zoning permit applications set forth in Section 36.2-664, applications for zoning permits for outdoor advertising signs shall be accompanied by a hasic development plan. In addition to the required elements of a basic development plan (see Section B-1, Appendix B), a survey shall be provided showing the location of the proposed outdoor advertising sign and the distance from the proposed sign to any other outdoor advertising sign or boundary as necessary to establish compliance with the spacing standards of Section 36.2-675(d) and the yard requirements of the applicable zoning district. Prior to the issuance of any zoning pennit for an outdoor advertising sign, the application shall meet all the State requirements as set forth in subsection (e) above, and the appropriate agent for the State shall have issued tentative approval of the permit application. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 162 Article 6 Nonconforming Uses, Structures, and Lots 36.2-700 Purpose The purpose of this Article is to regulate nonconforming uses, structures, and lots. The intent of these regulations is to: (a) Permit such nonconforming uses, structures, and lots to remain until removed, discontinued, abandoned, or changed to conform with the regulations of this Chapter; (b) Recognize that nonconforming uses, structures, and lots are generally incompatible with the character of the districts in which they occur and, as such, in certain circumstances, such continuances should not be indefinite and that the nonconforming uses should gradually be removed in favor of uses, structures, and lats that conform to this Chapter and the Official Zoning Map; and (c) Recognize that nonconforming uses, structures, and lots need not be entirely unchanged, and that under certain circumstances may change according to. law and the provisions of this Chapter. 36.2-701 Generally Within the districts established by this Chapter, or by amendments which may later be adopted, there exists or may exist lots, strucnrres, uses of land and structures, and characteristics of use, which were lawful before this Chapter was passed or amended, but which would be prohibited, regulated, or restricted under the tenns of this Chapter or future amendment. Some of such structures, lots, and uses are considered nonconforming. A nonconforming use, structure, or lat may continue, as it existed when it became nonconfonning. until removed, discontinued, abandoned, or changed to conform to the regulations of this Chapter. Except as provided within this Article, no nonconforming use, structure, or lot shall be changed, moved, increased, enlarged upon, expanded, extended, or resumed after removal, discontinuance, or abandonment, or used as grounds for adding other lots, structures, uses of land and structures, or characteristics of use nat in keeping with the regulations for the district in which such nonconfonmty exists. 36.2-702 Chapter Actual Construction Begun Prior to Adoption or Amendment of To avoid undue hardship, nothing in this Chapter shall be deemed to require a change in the plans, construction, or designated use of any building on which actual construction was lawfully begun or an affinnative governmental act has been obtained as set forth in Section 36.2-108 prior to the effective date of adoption or amendment of this Chapter and upon which actual construction has been carried on diligently. "Actual construction" is hereby defined to include the placing of construction materials in a pennanent position and fastened in a pennanent manner; except that where demolition or removal of an existing structure has been substantially begun prepamtOIY to new construction, such demolition or removal shall be deemed to be actual construction, provided that work shall be carried on diligently until the completion of the new construction involved, within any time limit set by a zoning permit or building pennit issued under regulations in effect before passage of this Chapter. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 163 Article 7 36.2-703 Nonconforming Lots Any lot, legally in existence at the time this Chapter was adopted, which does not meet the minimum lot size or minimum lot frontage requirements of the district in which it is located, as set forth in Article 3 of this Chapter, may be developed or redeveloped for any principal use permitted in that district. Except for minimum lot size or lot frontage requirements, nothing contained in this section shall be construed to permit less than full compliance with any other requirements of this Chapter. 36.2-704 Nonconforming Structures (a) Where a lawful structure exists at the time of passage or amendment of this Chapter, which structure could not be built under the terms of this Chapter by reason of restrictions on area, bulk, lot covetage, height, yards, or other characteristics of the structure or its location on the lot, such structure may be continued so long as the structure is maintained in its then structural condition and is not enlarged or altered in any way which increases any nonconfonning characteristic of the structure or nonconfonning characteristic of its location on the lot. (b) Should such nonconfonning structure be moved for any reason for any distance on the same lot or to any other lot, it shall thereafter conform to the regulations for the district in which it is locared after it is moved. However, a nonconfonning sign may be relocated on the same property, if such sign was moved due to highway, utility, or other construction for public puqx>ses. (c) Any nonconforming structure which is damaged or destroyed by any fire or other natural disaster, except for flood, to an extent of fifty (50) percent or less of its replacement value at the time of the event, may be rebuilt as long as the structure is not enlarged or altered in any way which increases its nonconforming chatacteristic. Any nonconforming structure which is damaged or destroyed by any fire or other natural disaster, except for flood, to an extent that exceeds fifty (50) percent of its replacement va1ue at the time of the event, may be rebuilt as long as it thereafter conforms to the regulations for the district in which it is located. For purposes of this section, replacement value shall be detemrined by the Building Conunissioner utilizing the building code valuation table published by the International Conference of Building Officials (ICBO). The replacement of nonconforming structures damaged or destroyed by flood shall be governed by the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-333, Floodplain Overlay District. 36.2-705 Nonconforming Uses (a) Where, at the effective date of adoption or amendment of this Chapter, a lawful use exists of a structure, individually or in combination with another structure, which use is made no longer pennissible under the terms of the Chapter as enacted or amended, such use may be permitted so long as it is not abandoned for more than two (2) years and so long as the structure in which sucl1 use is located is maintained in its then structural condition. Abandonment means the intentional stopped use of the property, and that the property has been vacant for two (2) consecutive years. Should a structure in which such nonconforming use is located be enlarged, extended, reconstructed, or structurally altered, except as otherwise permitted by the provisions of this Article, the use of sucl1 a structure thereafter shall conform to the regulations of the district in which it is located. (b) No nonconfomring use shall be enlarged, intensified, increased, or extended to occupy a larger square footage of building or lot area than was occupied on the effective date of the adoption of, or an amendment to, this Chapter, except as provided in subsection (c) below. Such intensification, increase, or extension shall include enlargement of the building or other structure, expansion of the use on the premises, or the erection of an additional principal or accessory structure associated with such nonconforming use on the property on which the nonconforming use is located. Zoning Ordlnsnes - City of Rosnoks12105l05 164 Artlels 7 (c) Nonconforming uses in all zoning districts, except R-I2, R-7, R-5, R-3, RM-I, RM-2, and MX may be exponded with the approval of the Board of Zoning Appeals, subject to the following provisions: (I) Such change shall be approved by the Board of Zoning Appeals by special exception, pursuant to the provisions set forth in Section 36.2-560; (2) Such change to the nonconforming use shall be permitted only upon the same lot as the nonconformity; and (3) Any increase in volume, area, or extent of nonconforming use shall not exceed an aggregate of twenty- five percent (25%) of the existing nonconforming use. (d) No nonconforming use shall be moved on the same lot or to any other lot which is not properly zoned to permit such use. (e) Any use which replaces, in whole or in part, a nonconforming use shall confonn to the requirements of the district in which it is located and the nonconfonning use shall not be resumed. (I) Except for damage from flood which shall be regulated by Section 36.2-333, floodplain Overlay District, any nonconforming use may be resumed or restored after the structure in which the use is located is damaged or destroyed from fire or other natural disaster, to an extent of fifty (50) percent or less of the replacement value of improvements at the time of the event, provided that (I) The replacement value of improvements shall be detennined by the Building Commissioner utilizing the building code valuation table published by the International Conference of Building Officials (ICBO); (2) No such nonconforming use shall be increased beyond its extent prior to its damage or destruction; and (3) The property owner shall take aflinnative steps to restore and resume use of the property within two (2) years of the damage or destruction. (g) If the structure in which a nonconforming use is located is damaged or destroyed from fire or other natural disaster, except for flood which circumstance shall be governed by Section 36.2-333, floodplain Overlay District, to an extent that exceeds fifty (50) percent of the replacement value of improvements at the time of the event, the use shall confonn to the district regulations of this Chapter. For pmposes of this section, replacement value of improvements shall be detennined by the Building Commissioner utilizing the building code valuation table published by the International Conference of Building Officials (ICBO). The Board of Zoning Appeals may grant a special exception, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36.2-560, for the replacement or restoration of nonconforming uses damaged more than fifty percent (50%) by fire or other natural disaster subject to lhe following provisions: (1) The resumption or restoration will not increase the nonconforming use beyond its extent prior to its damage or destruction; and (2) The resumption or restoration will comply with all other requirements of this Chapter. 36.2-706 Repairs and Maintenance (a) On any structure devoted in whole or in part to any nonconforming use, ordinary maintenance wo.tk, or the repair or replacement of nonbearing walls, fixtures, wiring, or plumbing, may be done, provided the cubic content of the building, as it existed at the time of passage or amendment of this Chapter, shall not be increased. (b) Nothing in this Chapter shall be deemed to prevent the strengthening or restoring to a safe condition of any building or part thereof declared unsafe by any official charged with protecting the public safety, on order of Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 165 Article 7 such official; nor shall anything in this Chapter be deemed to exempt any such building from any of the requirements and provisions of any other chapter of this Code or any other code or ordinance of the Gty. 36.2-707 Change of Nonconforming Use To Another Use After public notice and subject to appropriate conditions and safeguatds, the Board of Zoning Appeals may, as a special exception, permit the change of a nonconforming use to another use not genemlly permitted in the district, provided the proposed use, as proposed to be conducted, shall be of a nature more in keeping with the character of the district than the use from which the change is proposed to be made. Failure to conduct the use in the manner approved by the Board shall be grmmds for revocation of the special exception, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36.2-560(e). Where such a special exception has been revoked, the nonconforming status of the use, individually or in combination, shall no longer exist, and future use of the structure or premises, individually or in combination, shall thereafter conform to the regulations of the district in which located 36.2-708 Nonconforming Characteristics of Use If characteristics of use, such as signs, off-street parking or loading, landscaping, outdoor lighting, utilities, or other matters pertaining to use of structures or lands, individually or in combination, are in lawful existence at the time of adoption or amendment of this Chapter, and are not as required by this Chapter as adopted or amended, such characteristics of use may be continued, mless otherwise specified in this Chapter, but no change shall be made which increases nonconformity with the provisions of this Chapter as adopted or amended. 36.2-709 Certain Uses Deemed Not Nonconforming Uses in existence in a district at the time of adoption of this Chapter, for which a special exception permit would be required if they were new uses, shall be deemed conforming uses so long as they continue in existence on the same lot. Once such use is abandoned for any continuous period longer than two (2) years, any new use of the premises must conform to the applicable district regulations. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 166 Article 7 Administrative Commissions, Boards, and Officials 36.2-800 Purpose The purpose of this Article is to ptovide for: (a) A Planning Commission to promote the orderly development of the City and accomplish the objectives set out in Section 15.2-2200, Code ofVuginia (1950), as amended; (b) An Architectural Review Board to administer Certificates of Appropriateness for the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) and the Historic Neighbothood Overlay District (H-2) created by the provisions of this Chapter; (c) A Board of Zoning Appeals to bear and decide on special exception applications, requests fur variances from the provisions of this Chapter, interpretations of the Officiill Zoning Map where nncertllinty exists, and appeals of decisions made in the administration or enforcement of this Chapter; and (d) A Zoning Administrator to administer and enforce the provisions of this Chapter. Division 1. City Planning Commission 36.2-810 Definition For purposes of this Division, the term "Conunission" shall mean the City Planning Conunission as established by this Division. 36.2-811 Establishment The City Planning Conunission heretofore established is hereby continued, and the seven \I) members thereof shall hold office nntil the expiration of the term for which they were appointed, or nntil they resign or are removed. 36.2-812 (a) (I) Membership Qualifications, appointment, and terms The Commission shall consist of seven \I) members, each to be appointed by City Conncil for a term of four (4) years. All members shall be residents of the City, and at least four (4) members shall be owners of real property. No member of the Commission shall hold any elected public office ot be employed on a fulltime basis as an officer or employee of the City. (2) No appointee may serve more than three (3) consecutive terms. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 167 Article 8 (3) Each member of the Commission shall take the oath of office prescribed by the City Charter for officers of the City within ten (10) business days of notice of appointment. (4) New appointees to the Commission shall complete a presctibed certification program within one (1) year of the date of appointment. (5) Vacancies shall be filled by City Council for the unexpired tenn of any member whose term becomes vacant. (b) Removal of members .Any member of the Commission may be removed for malfeasance, misfeasance, or nonfeasance, or other cause, by the City Council, upon written charges and after public hearing. 36.2-813 Meetings The Commission shall hold at least one (1) regular meeting each month, provided it need not meet if there are no petitions or plans pending for review. Special meetings and public hearings, as deemed necessary, may be called by the Chair. 36.2-814 Quorum and Vote Four (4) of the seven (7) members of the Commission shall constitute a quorum, and nO' action of the Commission shall be valid unless authorized by a majotity vote of those members present and voting. 36.2-815 Officers; Agent; Staff; Special Requests (a) (1) Officers; secretary; agent The Commissiou shall elect from the appointed members a Chair and Vice Chair whose tenns shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for re-election. (2) The Commission shall elect a Secretary to the Commission from the staff of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development, whose term shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for re-election. (3) The Commission shall elect an Agent from the staff of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development, whose term shall be for one (I) year, with eligibility for re-election. (b) (1) Staff; special requests The Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development shall provide technical and other services as the Commission may require. (2) All City officials shall, upon request, furnish to the Commission, within a reasonable time, such available information as it may require for its work, provided the furnishing thereof will not unduly interfere with such officials' usual duties. 36.2-816 Rules and Records (a) Rules The Commission shall adopt rules and forms for its procedures, consistent with the Charter and ordinances of the City and general laws of the State. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105105 168 Article 8 (b) Minutes; records The Conunission shall keep minutes of its proceedings and a record of its transactions, which shall be filed in the offices of the Commission and the City Clerk and shall be a public record. (c) Annual report The Commission shall submit a written report of its activities to the City Council at the end of each calendar year. 36.2-817 Powers and Duties (a) Generally The Commission shall have the following powers and duties, in addition to those prescribed elsewhere in this Code and by State law, including those set out in Section 15.2-2221, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended: (1) The Commission shall make a study of the subdivision regulations of the City, as set out in Chapter 31 of this Code, and the Charter and other City ordinances and State statutes of similar purport and design, to assure the orderly subdivision of lands and their development within the City. From time to time, the Commission shall offer suggestions and recommendations to the City Council that such studies by the Commission may reveal to be essential to the attairunent of fair, equitable, and hannonious ordinances and laws and to the promotion, prepamtion, development, and preservation of the Comprehensive Plan and revisions thereof. (2) The Conunission shall promote public interest in and understanding of the Comprehensive Plan, and to that end, may publish and distribute copies of the Comprehensive Plan or of any report and may employ such other means of publicity and education as it may detennine. (3) The Commission shall, from time to time, recommend to the appropriate public officials programs for public structures and improvements and for the financing thereof and shall consult and advise public officials and agencies, public utility companies, civil, education, professional and other organizations, and citizens with relation to complying with or implementing the Comprehensive Plan. (4) The Conunission may controL preserve, and care for all historical landmarks now owned or hereafter acquired by the City; control the design and location of statuary and other works of art which are or become the property of the City; and provide for the removal, relocation, and alteration of any such works belonging to the City. 'Where appropriate by the delineated powers and duties of Division 2 of this Article, Architectural Review Board, and the regulations of the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-1) and the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2), such controL preservation, and care by the Conunission for historico1 landmarks owned by the City shall not infringe on the duties and powers of the Architectural Review Board as set out in this Chapter. (5) The Commission shall make recommendstions to the City Council concerning the following: (A) The design of public streets on new, widened, or reconstructed rights-<>f-way; the design of bridges, viaducts, street fixtures, and other related appurtenances; (8) The design of new public parks and open spaces; renovations to existing public parl<s and facilities contained thereon; (C) The design of new public buildings, including both site and architectural plans; exterior renovations to existing public buildings involving additions or other site improvements including padring lots or the erection of new accessory structures; and (D) The establislunent of design standards or guidelines as they relate to public rights-of-way including lighting fixtures, landscaping, street name and directional signs, benches, and other related appurtenances. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 169 Article 8 (b) (1) Comprehensive Plan The Commission shall prepare and recommend a Comprehensive Plan for rhe physiClli developmenr of rhe City in accordance wirh rhe requirements of Section 15.2-2223, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. (2) In rhe preparation of a Comprehensive Plan, rhe Commission shall conduct such surveys and studies as are required by Section 15.2-2224, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. (3) The Commission shall recommend ro rhe City Council rhe adoption of or the amendmenr of rhe Comprehensive Plan, or parts rhereof; in conformance wirh rhe procedural requirements ser our in Section 15.2-2225 of rhe Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. (4) Whenever rhe Commission recommends a Comprehensive Plan, or part rhereof; and such plan has been approved and adopred by rhe City Council, it shall control rhe gener:l! or approximare location, chatacrer, and extent of each feature shown on rhe plan according to Section 15.2-2232, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. (c) (1) Zoning ordinance and map amendments The Commission may initiate, by motion, an amendment to this Chapter, including any provision of this Chapter or rhe Officid Zoning Map, pursuant ro rhe procedures of Section 36.2-540. (2) The Commission shall review, evaluate, report, and make recommendations to rhe City Council regarding any proposed amendment of any regulation or district boundary provided by this Chapter, pursuant to rhe procedures of Section 36.2-540 and Section 36.2-541. (d) Right of entry The Commission, its members, officers, and employees, in the perfonnance of their functions, may enter upon any land in the City and make examinations and surveys and place and maintain necessary monuments and markers thereon. Division 2. Architectural Review Board 36.2-820 Definition For putposes of this Division, rhe term "Board" shall mean rhe Atchitectwal Review Board as established by this Division. 36.2-821 Establishment The Atchitectutll! Review Board heretofore established for rhe City pursuant to Section 62.02 of rhe City Charter is hereby continued, and rhe seven (7) members rhereof shall hold office until rhe expiration of rhe term for which rhey were appointed, or until they resign or are removed. 36.2-822 Membership (a) (1) Qualifications, appointment, and terms The Board shall consist of seven (7) members, each to be appoinred by City Council for a teun of four (4) years. At least two (2) members, but not more rhan three (3), shall be registered architects. No member of rhe Board shall hold any elected public office. In making an appointment, City Council shall consider rhe appointee's interest or competence in, or knowledge of, historic preservation and the history of the City. (2) No appointee may serve more than three (3) consecutive terms. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 170 Article 8 (3) Each member of the Board shall take the oath of office prescribed by the City Charter for officers of the City within ten (10) business days of notice of appointment (4) Vacancies shall be filled by City Council for the unexpired term of any member whose term becomes vacant (b) Removal of members Any member of the Board may be removed for malfeasance, misfeasance, or nonfeasance, or other cause, by the City Council, upon written charges and after public hearing. 36.2-823 Meetings The Board shall hold at least one (1) regular meeting each month, provided it need not meet if no applications are pending for review. 36.2-824 Quorum and Vote Four (4) of the seven (T) members of the Board shall constitute a quorum, and no action of the Board shall be Vlllid unless authorized by a majority vote of those members present and voting. 36.2-825 Officers; Agent; Staff (a) (1) Officers; secretary; agent The Board shall elect from the appointed members a Chair and Vice Chair whose terms shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for re-election. (2) The Board shall elect a Secretary to the Board from the staff of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development, whose term shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for re-election. (3) The Board shall elect an Agent from the staff of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development, whose term shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for re-election. (b) Staff The Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development shall provide technical and other services as the Board may require. 36.2-826 Rules and Records (a) Rules The Board shall adopt rules and forms for its procedures, consistent with the Charter and ordinances of the City and general laws of the State. (b) Minutes; records The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings and a record of its transactions, which shall be filed in the offices of the Board and the City Clerk and shall be a public record. (c) Annual report The Board shall submit a written report of its activities to the City Council at the end of each calendar year. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 171 Article 8 36.2-827 Powers and Duties (a) Advisory committee The Board may appoint an advisory conunittee, consisting of up to three (3) peISOl1S, for each historic district or identifiable neighborhood under its jurisdiction, to assist rhe Board in understanding specific district issues. Such committee members shall represent a diversity of interest in the historic area. The Board shall meet with such appointed advisory committees at a minimum on an annual basis or as often as mutually agreed upon. (b) (I) Certificates of Appropriateness The Board may authorize its Agent to issue any Certificate of Appropriateness within the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) and the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2), punluant to the procedures of Section 36.2-530. (2) The Board shall hear appeals of a decision of the Agent, pursuant to the procedures of Section 36.2-530. (3) The Board shall review, evaluate, and act upon applications for Certificates of Appropriateness within the Historic Downtown Overlay District (H-I) and the Historic Neighborhood Overlay District (H-2), punluant to rhe procedures of Section 36.2-530. Division 3. Board of Zoning Appeals 36.2-830 Definition For purposes of this Division, the term "Board" shall mean the Board of Zoning Appeals as established by this Division. 36.2-831 Establishment The Board of Zoning Appeals, heretofore established by the City Council punluant to Section 62.01 of the City Charter, is hereby continued, and the seven (T) members thereof shall hold office until the expiration of the tenn for which they were appointed, or until they resign or are removed. 36.2-832 (a) (I) Membership Qualifications, appointment, and terms The Board shall consist of seven (T) members, each to be appointed by City Council for a tenn of three (3) years. No member of the Board shall hold any elected public office. (2) No appointee may serve more than three (3) consecutive terms. (3) Each member of the Board shall take the oath of office presctibed by the City Charter for officers of the City within ten (10) business days of notice of appointment (4) New appointees to the Board shall complete a prescribed certification program within one (I) year of the date of appointment (5) Vacancies shall be filled by City Council for the unexpired term of any member whose term becomes vacant. (b) Removal of members Any member of the Board may be removed. for malfeasance, misfeasance, or nonfeasance, or other cause, by the City Council, upon written charges and after public hearing. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 172 Article 8 36.2-833 Meetings The Board shall hold at least one (1) regular meeting each month, provided it need not meet if there are no applications pending for review. 36.2-834 Quorum and Vote (a) Quorum Four (4) of the seven (1) members of the Board shall constitute a quonnn. (b) Vote The concurring vote of four (4) members of the Board shall be required to reverse upon appeal any order, requirement, decision, or determination made by the Zoning Administrator in the administration or enforcement of this Chapter, or to decide in favor of the applicant for a. special exception or to authorize any variance from the terms of this Chapter. 36.2-835 Officers; Staff (a) (1) Officers; secretary The Board shall elect from the appointed members a Chair and Vice Chair whose teans shall be for one (1) year, with eligihility for re-election. (2) The Board shall elect a Secretary to the Board from the staff of the Department of PIanniog, Building and Economic Development, whose tean shall be for one (1) year, with eligihility for re-election. (b) Staff The Zoning Administrator shall provide technical and other services as the Board may require. 36.2-836 Rules and Records (a) Rules The Board shall adopt roles and forms for its procedures, consistent with the Charter and ordinances of the City and general laws of the state. (b) Minutes; records The Board shall keep minutes of its proceedings and a record of its official actions, which shall be filed in the offices of the Board and the City Clerk and shall be a public record. (c) Annual report The Board shall submit a written report of its activities to the City Council at the end of each fiscal year. 36.2-837 Powers and Duties (a) Appeals to the Board The Board shall have the power to hear and decide appeals from any order, requirement, decision, or detennination made by the Zoning Administrator in the administration or enforcement of this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures of Section 36.2-562. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 173 ArticleS (b) Variances The Board shall have the power to authorize variances from the terms of this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures and standards set forth in Section 36.2-561. (c) (1) Special exceptions The Board shall have the power to hear and deride on applications for such special exceptions as may be authorized by this Chapter, pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 36.2-560. (2) The Board shall have the power to revoke a special exception previously granted, pursuant to Section 36.2-560(e). (d) Interpretation of Official Zoning Map The Board shall have the power to hear and deride applications for interpretation of the Official Zoning Map, where there is any uncertainty as to the location of a district boundary. After public notice and hearing as required generally for Board proceedings, the Board may interpret the map in such a way as to cony out the intent and purpose of this Chapter for the particular section or district in question. The Board shall no~ however, have the power to rezone property or to change substantially the locations of district boundaries as established by ordinance. Division 4. Zoning Administrator 36.2-840 Zoning Administrator Ths Chapter shall be administered and enforced by a Zoning Administrator or designee authorized to act on the Zoning Administrator's behalf. Such Zoning Administrator shall be appointed by the City Manager. The Zoning Administrator may render interpretations of the provisions of this Chapter, including use interpretations. The Zoning Administrator shall have all necessary authority to administer and enforce this Chapter, including ordering in writing the remedying of any condition found in violation of this Chapter. The Zoning Administrator may report any noncompliance with this Chapter to the City Attorney, or the Commonwealth Attorney as appropriate, with the request for appropriate action at law to ensure or obtain compliance with this Chapter. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 174 ArticleS Definitions Tbis Appendix provides definitions for certain uses and terms used in this Chapter. Definitions For the purposes of this Chapter, the following terms and words shall be defined as set forth below, wdess otherwise provided in this Chapter. Abut or abutting Having a common border with, or being separated from such a common border only by a street, alley, stream, or railroad tmcks. Accessory apartment A dwelling unit located within a structure that is accessory to, and is located on the same lot as, a single-family detached dwelling. Accessory structure A structure detached from but located on the same lot as a principal building and customarily accessory and clearly incidental and subordinate to the principal building and used for purposes customarily incidental to that of the principal building. Accessory use A use of land or a structure, or portion thereof, which is customarily accessory and clearly incidental and subordinate in area, extent, and purpose to the principal use of the land or structure and located on the same lot as such principal use. An accessory use may not be accessory to another accessory use. Agent to the Architectural Review Board The staff member of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development who has been elected by the Architectural Review Board to review applications for a Certificate of Appropriateness. Agent to the Planning Commission The staff member of the Department of Planning, Building and Economic Development who has been elected by the Planning Commission to review development plans and other matters related to this Chapter. Agricultural operations The use of property for the purpose of producing agricultural, horticultural, or floricultural products including livestock, poultry, eggs, dairy products, vegetables, trees, or similar products. A garden that is accessory to a residential Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke 12/05105 175 Appendix A use shall not be deemed an agricultural operation. Agricultural operations shall not include principal industrial uses related to food processing or distribution. Airport Any area of land designed, set aside, or used for the landing and take-off of aircraft, and any appurtenant areas designated, set aside, or used for airport buildings or other airport facilities. Such airport facilities and operations may include runways, heliports, air traffic control towers, passenger tenninals, air catgo tenninals, navigational equipment, emergency and maintenance operations, parking lots or structures, airline service and maintenance operations, hangar facilities, general aviation facilities, flight instruction, aircraft sales, rental, or chartering, and fuel storage for on-site distribution. Airport-related commercial and personal service uses Conunercial and personal service uses located within the general aviation tennina1 facility and intended primarily to serve the needs of airline travele", including motor vehicle rental, eating and drinking establishments, eating establishments, financial institutions, general or professional offices, retail sales, and personal service establishments. Amateur radio tower A freestanding or building-mounted structure, including any base, tower or pole, antenna, and appurtenances, intended for non-commercial airway communication purposes by a person holding a valid amateur radio license issued by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Amphitheater An establishment for the perfonning arts with open-air, generally tiered, seating for audiences Amusement, commercial, indoor An establishment primarily engaged in the provision of multiple amusement or entertainment devices or machines or games of skill, chance, or scoring to the general public for a fee, where all such activity occurs enclosed in a building. Such games include billiards, pool, table tennis, dartboards, foosbal1, pinball, video games, and other similar amusement or entertattunent devices, whether or not they are coin-operated. Typical uses include pool halls, video arcades, and game rooms. "Indoor commercial amusement" establislunents may include accessory uses, such as snack bars, which are designed and intended primarily for the use of patrons of the amusement use. "Indoor commercial amusement" establishments do not include gun-firing ranges or any use which is otherwise specifically listed in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Amusement, commercial, outdoor An establishment primarily engaged in the provision of amusement or entertainment devices or games of skill or scoting to the general public for a fee where any portion of the activity takes place outside of a building, including miniature golf course, archery range, or similar facility. "Outdoor commercial amusement" establishments do not include go-cart or motorcycle courses, raceways, drag strips, overnight camping, or gun-firing ranges, or any use which is otherwise specifically listed in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Animal hospital or veterinary clinic An establishment for the care, observation, or treatment of domestic animals, including household pets, and which may include medical or surgical treatment and care. The boarding of anima1s shall be limited to short-time boarding necessitated by and directly related to surgery or medical treatment and shall be clearly incidental to the operation of the anima1 hospital or veterinary clinic. Animal shelter A use in which the principal activity is the temponuy housing of stray, abandoned, abused, neglected, or unwanted domestic animals, placed there for adoption or disposal in a manner regulated by the Virginia Comprehensive Animal Laws, with such use owned, operated, or maintained by a public body, an established humane society, anima1 welfare Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 176 Appendix A organization, society for the prevention of cmelty to animals, or other nonprofit organization devoted to the welfare, protection, and humane treatment of animals. Such establishments may include crematoriwns as an accessory use. Applicant The party applying for approval of a zoning permit, sign permit, Certificate of Occupancy, Certificate of Appropriateness, or development plan, requesting the approval of a special exception or variance, or appealing a decision of the Zoning Administrator, as required by this Chapter. Application The completed fonn(s) and all accompanying documents, exhibits, and fees required of an applicant for review, approval, or permitting purposes for a zoning permit, sign permit, Cerrificate of Occupancy, Certificate of Appropriateness, development plan, special exception, variance, or an appeal of a decision of the Zoning Administrator. Artist studio An esmblishment for preparation, display, and sale of individually crafted artwork, jewelry, furniture, painting, sculpture, pottery, art photography, leather craft, hand-woven articles, candles, hand-blown glass, and similar items. Such space is primarily a working studio where such artist, artisan, or craftsperson may display and sell work, but such esmblislunent may also include the teaching of classes in the applicable fine art or craft, including "the arts" associated with vocal or instrumental music, acting, and writing. Athletic field Outdoor site, often requiring equipment, designed for organized athletic competition in field sports such as softball, baseball, soccer, and football, and which is not a "sports smdium, arena, or coliseum" as defined in this Chapter. Athletic fields may include bleachers, but do not provide locker rooms. Bakery, confectionary, or similar food production, Retail An esmblishment primarily engaged in the preparation, cooking, baking, and retail sale of baked products, confectionary products, or similar food products on the premises. The retail sale of such food products is intended primarily for off site consumption, but such use may include incidental food service on site. While on-site retail sales is a required component of this use, this use may also include the wholesale sales of such food products. Bakery, confectionary, or similar food production, Wholesale An esmblislunent engaged in the preparation, cooking, baking, and selling of baked products, confectionary products, or similar food products intended solely for wholesale or institutional off-premise distribution, and where over-the- counter or other retail dispensing of baked products, confectionary, or similar prepared food products shall be prohibited. Bed and breakfast An owner-occupied, single-family demched dwelling in which bedrooms are provided for overnight guests for monetary compensation, on a daily basis, and offering breakfast meals to such guests. Block face The properties abutting on one (1) side of a street and lying between the two (2) nearest intersecting streets, or nearest intersecting street and railroad right-of-way, watercourse, or city boWldary. Blood bank or plasma center An esmblislunent primarily engaged in the collection and storage of whole blood or blood plasma for foture use, including the collection of blood from donors, typing donated blood, separating such blood into several components, storing such whole blood or blood plasma, and preparing such blood for transfusions to recipients. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 177 Appendix A Boarding house A dwelling, or portion thereof, where up to, but not more than, six (6) furnished bedrooms are provided for lodging for monetaIy compensation on a weekly, monthly, or longer basis, where no more than a total of six (6) persons reside, where the rental or leases are for definite periods of time, and where such establishment is not open to the public or overnight guests. No meals are provided to outside guests. Such establishments provide a common kitchen facility and shared bathroom facilities. A "boarding house" is also commonly known as a rooming house. Body piercing establishment An establislunent which engages in the act of penetrating the skin to make a hole, mark, or scar, generally pennanent in nature. For purposes of this definition, "body piercing" does not include the use of a mechanized, pre-sterilized ear piercing system that penetrates the outer perimeter or lobe of the ear, or both. Broadcasting studio or station An establislunent primarily engaged in the provision of broadcasting services accomplished through the use of electronic mechanisms, and which includes satellite earth station equipment. Typical uses include television studios and tadia stations. ''Broadcasting towers" are not considered customary accessory uses for pw:poses of this definition. Building A structure with a roof supported and wholly enclosed by walls and intended for shelter, housing, or enclosure of persons, animals, activity, process, equipment, goods, or materials of any kind. Building Code The Uniform Statewide Building Code, adopted pursuant to the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, Section 36-97, et seq., and Article II, Chapter 7, of this Code. Building fas:ade That portion of any exterior elevation on a building extending from grade to top of the parapet, wall, or eaves along the entire width of the building e1evation. Building fas:ade, primary That building fa~ade which faces a public right-of-way and contains the principal entrance to the building. Building footprint The outline of the total area covered by a building's perimeter, as measured from the outside of all exterior walls, at the ground level. Building frontage The horizontal linear dimension of the extenor wall of a building that faces upon a public street, a private street in an approved Planned Unit Development District, or an on-site parking lot. Building line The line, parallel to the street right-of-way, that passes through the point of the principal building nearest that street right-of-way. Building supplies and materials, Wholesale Establishments exclusively engaged in wholesale sales, from the premises, of materials which are generally essential to the construction of buildings or sttuctures, including lwnber, concrete, bricks, roofing materials, siding, plwnbing, heating and electrical equipment, windows, doors, insulation, landscaping supplies, and similar materials. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 178 Appendix A Bus passenger terminal or station A facility for the transient housing or parking of buses, and the loading, unloading and interchange of passengers. Business service establishment An establishment primarily engaged in the sale, leasing, or repair of office equipment, supplies, and materials, or the rendering of services used by office, professional, and service establishments. Typical uses include office equipment and supply finns, sma1l business machine repair shops, convenience prinring and copying establishmenlll, management and consulting sernces, office security services, advertising and mailing services, data and records storage, and other professional, scientific, or technical services or administrative or support services not otherwise specifically listed in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Caliper The measurement of a tree trunk's diameter in inches at a height six (6) inches above the ground for trees up to and including four (4) inches in caliper, and at a height twelve (12) inches above the ground for trees for trees exceeding four (4) inches in caliper Canopy A structure made of permanent construction without pillars or poSlll, which is totally or partia1ly attached to a building for the pwpose of providing shelter to patrons or motor vehicles, or as a decorative feature on a building wall. A canopy is not a completely enclosed structure and cannot be raised or retracted. A freestanding, permanent cover, open on at least three (3) sides and located over an outdoor service area, such as a gas pwnp island, shall also be considered a canopy. Car wash The washing, cleaning, waxing, or vacuuming of motor vehicles for compensation, including self-service facilities and the use of personnel in conjunction with or without complete automatic or mechanical devices for purposes of this activity. A "car wash" includes motor vehicle detailing services but does not include the washing of commercial fleets as an accessory use to the principal use with which the fleet is associated. Caterer, commercial The service of preparing and delivering food for off-site consumption at special events, including corporate activities, banquets, parties, weddings, and similar functions, for a fee, with such service generally including the serving of food at such special function. For purposes of this definition. a "commercial caterer" does not include catering services associated with a principal use having a retail component including an "earing establishment," "earing and drinking establislunent." or "retail bakery, confectionary, or similar food production:' Cemetery Land used or dedicated to the burial of the dead, including accessory chapels, columbaria, mausoleums, and necessary sales and maintenance facilities. Club, lodge, civic or social organization Buildings or facilities, or portion thereof, owned or operated by a non-profit corporation, association, or other fonnal association of persons for private social. civic, educational. or recreational purposes, to which access is :restricted to members of such groups and their gueslll. Such principal use may include accessory uses such as recreational facilities and banquet facilities. Commercial motor vehicle Any motor vehicle or ttailer used, designed, or maintained for the transportation of persons or property for compensation or profit. and which is one of the following types of vehicles: trucks. tractor cabs, fa.an tractors, construction equipment, motor passenger buses (excluding school buses currendy used by a public or private Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 179 Appendix A institution of learning), trailets, semi-trnileIS, taxis, limousines, tow trucks, dwnp trucks, roll back tow trucks, flatbed trucks, or step vans, but not including vans, pickup trucks, and panel trucks. Commercial motor vehicle rental establishment An establishment engaged exclusively in the rental of commercial motor vehicles. Included in this use type is the incidental storage, maintenance, and servicing of such equipment Commercial motor vehicle sales and service establishment, New An establishment which engages in only the sale or lease of new and used commercial motor vehicles, the performance of any repair or maintenance work of such commercial motor vehicles, and financial services conducted as an accessory use to the establishment. Commercial motor vehicle sales and service establishment, Used An establishment whose activities include the display of used commercial motor vehicles fur sale or lease, or the performance of any repair or maintenance work of used commercial motor vehicles, but whose activities do not include the sale or lease of new commercial motor vehicles. Commercial printing establishment An establishment which engages in the professional printing and reproduction of publications, including newspapers, magazines or other periodicals, and books. Common ownership Ownership by the same person, corporation, linn, entity, partnership, or unincorporated association; or ownership by different corporations, finns, partnerships, entities, or unincorporated associations, in which a stock owner, partner, or associate owns an interest in each corporation, firm, partnership, entity, or unincorporated association. Community center A place, strucnu:e, area.. or other facility used as a place for meetings, recreation, or social activity and not operated for profit. Such facility is generally open to the public and designed to accommodate and serve significant segments of the community. Such facilities may include those owned or operated by the City to serve a designated segment of the commwtity; those owned or operated by a neighborhood organization and used for meetings or activities of such neighborhood organization; or such facilities owned or operated by a homeowners association, condominium association, or similar entity and located within or adjacent to such residential development for use solely by the residents or guests of such development Community food operation A distribution center for food to persons where prepared food is distributed for immediate conswnption or where on-premises conswnption of the food occurs. Food is distributed primarily for no charge or for less than fair market value. A community food operation is not an "eating establishment" or "eating and drinking establishment" as elsewhere defined and used in this Chapter. Community garden The active cultivation of fruits, flowers, vegetables, or ornamental plants by more than one (1) person or family. For purposes of this Chapter, the definition of a "conununity garden" does not include "retail sales." Community market From a pennanent, fixed location, the offeting for retail sale of fresh produce, prepared food items, other agricultural items, or handmade crafts directly to the conswner from stalls or tables which are not enclosed in a building, where the vendors are generally individuals who have raised the vegetables or produce or have made the crafts or have taken the same on consignment for retail sale. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 180 Appendix A Composting facility A facility where organic matter that is derived primarily from off-site is to be processed by composting or is processed for commetcia1 purposes. Activities of a composting facility may include management, collection, ttansportation, staging, composting, curing, storage, marketing, or use of compost For purposes of this Chapter, the shredding or grinding of wood to create mulch shall be considered a composting facility. Contractor / subcontractor Any business or person who agrees to furnish materials or perform services at a specified price, pertaining to the construction or maintenance of buildings or lands, including general building contractors; special trade contractors who assist in building construction or remodeling, such as carpentry, electrical, masorny, painting, metalworking, cabinetmaking, flooring installation, duct work, plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and roofing; landscape contractors engaged in the decorative and functional alteration, planting, or maintenance of grounds; furniture refinishing or upholstery, sign making, or similar work. Contractor or tradesman's shop, General or special trade An establishment where a general contractor engaged in the construction of residential or commercial stroctures, a special trade contractor that assists in building construction or remodeling including carpentry, electrical, masonry, painting, metalworking, cabinetmaking, flooting installation, duct work, plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and roofing, a landscape contractor engaged in the decorative and functional alteration, planting, or maintenance of grounds, furniture refinishing or upholstery, sign making, or similar work, maintllins its principal office or a permanent business office, where the establishment may engage in the retail sale of goods manufactured, assembled, or serviced on the premises, and where such establishment engages in one (1) or both of the following: (1) The fabrication, assembly, servicing, or storage of products or materials on site within a wholly enclosed building; or (2) Where pennitted by this Chapter, the outdoor storage of construction equipment and other materials customarily used in the trade eamed on by the contractor but not including any construction or demolition debris or waste materials. Contractor's shop, Heavy construction An establishment where a heavy construction contractor engaged in such activities as paving, highway construction, utility construction, or similar work, maintains its principal office or a permanent business office, and where such establishment engages in one (I) or all of the following: (1) The storage of products or materials on site within a wholly enclosed building; (2) The outdoor storage of construction equipment or other commercial motor vehicles on the site; or (3) Where pennitted by this Chapter, the outdoor storage of materials customarily used in the trade carried on by the contractor but not including any construction or demolition debris or waste materials. Day care center, Adult The provision of a supervised, communal setting and supplementary care and protection to four (4) or more aged, infirm, or disabled adults who reside elsewhere, during only a part of a twenty-four (24) hour day. Such center shall not include any overnight stays or overnight sleeping facilities. Services may include aid in personal hygiene, eating and drinking, ambulation, or recreation. 1bis term does not include the home or residence of an individual who cares for only persons related to such resident by blood or marriage. Day care center, Child A regularly operating service arrangement for more than five (5) chi1dren under the age of thirteen (13) who are wuelated to the operator where, during the absence of a parent or guardian, a person or organization has agreed to Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 181 Appendix A assume responsibility for the supervision, protection, and well-being of such children for less than a twenty-four (24) hour period. This teon includes nursery schools, preschools, daytime care, after-school care, and similar uses but excludes public and private educational facilities or any facility offering care to individuals for a full twenty-four (24) hour period. Day care home, Child A child day program offered in the residence of the provider, serving one (1) through five (5) children at anyone time, exclusive of any children related to the provider by blood, marriage, or adoption. A child day program means a regularly operating service arrangement for children where, during the absence of a parent or guardian, a person has agreed to assume responsibility for the supervision, protection, and well-being of children under the age of thirteen (13) for less than a twenty-four (24) hour period. Density The number of dwelling units on a lot divided by the lot area. Development plan The drnfted proposal for a development, including site plans, maps, and other documentation delineating all easements and other conditions relating to use, location, and bulk of buildings, density of development, parking anangements, public access, common open space, landscaping, public facilities, and other such information necessary to determine compliance with this Chapter. Distribution center An establislunent where goods are received, sorted, and dispatched for delivery to the ultimate customer at remote locations. Dormitory A building, or portion thereof; owned or operated by an educatioruU facility or hospital, which provides boarding house style accommodations exclusively to students, faculty, and employees of such institution. Drive-through facility A nonresidential use which provides a service or product directly to a customer who drives a motor vehicle onto the premises and to a window or mechanical device through or by which the customer completes a service transaction or purchases a product without exiting the motor vehicle. This use does not include the selling of fuel at a service station or the functions of a car wash, but does include the drive-up services and windows of uses such as banks, fast food restaurants, pharmacies, dry cleaners, and similar establishments. Drive-through kiosk A freestanding structure for the purpose of vending food, drink, or retail goods from a drive-through window to customers seated in their motor vehicles for consumption off the premises and that provides no indoor or outdoor seating or indoor service. Driveway A private Vlay which establishes a COtUlection between an off-street parking space or an off-street loading space and a street. Dry cleaning and laundry pickup station An establislunent, serving individuals or households, maintained for the pickup and delivery of dry cleaning or laundry, and which may include the maintenance or operation of laundry or dry cleaning equipment or machinery on the prenuses. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 182 Appendix A Dry cleaning plant or commercial laundry An establishment primarily engaged in laundering, cleaning, or dyeing of fabrics, textiles, wearing apparel, or articles of any sort by immersion and agitation, or by inunersions only, in volatile solvents, and the processes incidental thereto. Such establishment does not include a dIy cleaning and laundIy pickup station. Typical uses include bulk laundIy and cleaning plants, diaper services, or linen supply services. A dIy cleaning plant or commerciallaundIy does not include a laundromat. Dwelling A building, or portion thereof, designed to be used for continuous, year-round residential purposes, containing one or more independent housekeeping units and including the following specific types: (1) Dwelling, Single-family detached: A site built, modular, or industrialized building designed exclusively as one dwelling unit for continuous year-round occupancy by one (1) family only, which is located on its own individual lot and which is not attached to any other dwelling by any means. (2) D well i n g, Two - fa m iI y: A building on an individual lot containing two (2) dwelling units, designed for occupancy by not more than two (2) families. (3) D well i n g, M u I t i fa mil y: A building, or portion thereof, designed for the permanent occupancy of three (3) or more families, reg.u:dless of the method of ownership, with the number of families in residence not exceeding the number of dwelling units provided. (4) D well i n g, Man u fa c t u red h 0 me: A factory-built, single-family structure, transportable in one (1) or more sections, subject to federal regulations and constructed after June 15, 1976, which is constructed on a chassis for towing to the point of use, and is not less than nineteen (19) feet in width when assembled, and is set up on a permanent fOWldation on an individual lot for continuous year-round occupancy as a single-family dwelling when connected to the required utilities. (5) Dwelling, Mobile home: A structure, transportable in one (1) or more sections, not subject to federal regulations and constructed prior to June 15, 1976, which is constructed on a chassis for towing to the point of use and designed to be used, with or without permanent foundation, for continuous year-round occupancy as a single-family dwelling when connected to the required utilities. (6) Dwelling, Townhouse or rowhouse: A one-family dwelling unit, with its own independent entrance at ground leve~ which is part of a building consisting of three (3) or more one-family dwelling units, attached horizontally in a linear anangement and separated by common vertical walls. Dwelling unit A room or group of connected rooms occupied or capable of being occupied as an independent and separate housekeeping establishment by only one (1) family, and which contains independent kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping facilities. Eating establishment An establishment engaged in the preparation and selling of food to the customer in a ready-to-consume state, and where the customer consumes these foods on or off the premises. An earing establishment does not sell alcoholic beverages. Such establishment may provide, as an accessory function, live performances with only non-electronic musical instruments or recorded background music and a dance floor not to exceed ten (10) percent of the seating area of the establishment. Eating and drinking establishment An eating establishment also having as a function the sale of beer, wine, or other alcoholic beverages for consumption on the premises. Such establishment may provide, as an accessory function, live performances with only non-electronic Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke 12/05105 183 Appendix A musical instruments or recorded background music and a dance floor not to exceed ten (10) percent of the seating area of the establisbment. Educational facilities, Business school or nonindustrial trade school A specialized instructional establislunent that provides on-site training of business, commercial, vocational, or trade skills such as accounting, data processing, computer repair, secretarial skills, barbering or hair dressing, or other trades of a nonindustrial nature, and not otherwise defined as a "college/Wliversity educational facility," "elementary/middle/secondary educational facility," or a "home occupation." Incidental instruction services in conjunction with another primary use shall nOt be considered a business or trade school. Educational facilities, College/university An institution providing full-time or part -time education beyond the higb scboollevel and authorized by the Commonwealth of Virginia to award associate, bachelor, master, or doctoral degrees. Such use may include lodging or housing for students or faculty. Educational facilities, Elementary / middle/ secondary A public, private, or parochial scbool offering instruction at the elementary (kindergarten through grade 5), middle (grndes 6 througb 8), or secondary (grades 9 througb 12) scboollevel in the branches of learning and study required to be taught in the public schools of the Commonwealth of Virginia. Educational facilities, Industrial trade school A specialized instructional establishment for teaching industrial trade skills in which machinery is employed as a means of instruction. This definition shall not be deemed to include "college/university educational facility," "elementary/middle/secondary educational facility," "home occupation," or incidental instruction services provided in conjunction with another primary use. Educational facilities, School for the arts A school where classes in the various fine arts, including painting, sculpting, photography, music, dance, or dramatics are taught, and where such establishment is not otherwise defined as an "elementary/middle/secondary educational facility," "college/university educational facility," "artist studio," or "home occupation." Elderly Persons of 55 years of age and older. Entertainment establishment An establisbment where entertainment is provided (mcluding magicians, comedians, dancers, stage perfonnances or music performances by more than one instrument or amplified music including amplified recorded sound and electronic musical instruments), or having a dance floor whicb occupies more than ten (10) percent of the seating area of the establishment. Entertainment establisbments include lounges, discos, nightclubs, private clubs, music or dance establishments, and similar facilities, but do not include "indoor commercial recreational facilities" or "indoor commercial amusemenf' establishments. Escort service Any business, agency, or person who, for a fee, commission, or profit., furnishes or offers to furnish names of persons, or who introduces, furnishes of arranges for persons, who may accompany other persons to or about social affairs, entertainments, or other activities. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 184 Appendix A Family The term "family" includes: (1) One (I) or more persons occupying a single dwelling unit and living and cooking together as a single housekeeping unit, or (2) Up to and including eight (8) mentlllly ill, mentlllly retarded, or developmentlllly disabled persons who reside with one (1) or more resident counselors or other staff persons in a residential facility for much the Department of Mental Health, Mental Retardation, and Substance Abuse Services is the licensing authority pursuant to the Code ofVttginia (1950), as amended. The word "family" does not refer to more than four (4) persons unrelated by blood, marriage, or adoption except as specifically provided in (2) of this definition. For purposes of this definition, mental illness and developmental disability shall not include current illegal use of or addiction to a controlled substance as defined in Section 54.1-3401 of the Code ofVitginia (1950), as amended. Financial institution The provision of financial and banking services to consumers or clients, including banks, savings and loan associations, credit unions, lending establishments, and mortgage offices, and which may include their support services such as call centers, training centers, and offices. Flea market A market established at a permanent, fixed location, in an open area or within a stmctnre where goods are offered for sale to the general public by independent vendors from open, semi-open, or temporaIj' stalls, tables, or other spaces and where there are ordinarily no long term leases between sellers and operators. Floor area, gross The swn of the horizontal areas (floors) of the several stories of a building or buildings, measured from the exterior surfaces of the exterior walls, or in the case of a common wall separating two (2) buildings, from the centerline of such common wall. Gross floor area shall include the total floor area of all buildings sitnared on a lot Gross floor area shall include exterior balconies, mezzanines, and porches. Gross floor area shall not include interior parking and loading spaces or air spaces above atriums. Floor area, net The gross floor area of a building excluding hallways, stairwells, utility rooms, and other areas not meant for habitation or public service. For the purpose of this Chapter, net floor area shall equal seventy-five percent (75%) of the gross floor area. Floor area ratio The gross floor area in square feet of all buildings on a lot divided by the area of such lot in square feet Example calculation: Gross floor area = 20,000 square feet Total lot area = 10,000 square feet 20,000 square feet divided by 10,000 square feet = 2.0 Result Floor area ratio is 2.0 or 2 to 1. Fueling station Any lot, or portion thereof, with fuel pwnps and underground stotage tanks for the wholesale sales of motor vehicle fuels or oils, generally by contract, or for the fueling of motor vehicles directly associared with a commercial establishment A fueling station is a stand-alone use which does not include "gasoline stations" or fuel pump areas on the site of a commercial or industrial establishment for pwposes of servicing its own fleet of motor vehicles. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 185 Appendix A Funeral home An establishment engaged in undertaking services such as preparing the dead for hurial and arranging and managing funerals. A funeral home, for purposes of this Chapter, includes a funeral chape~ and may include a crematorium as an accessory use. Gaming establishment The opetation or conducting of any games of chance for the return of money, cash, or prizes, or anything that could be redeemed for money, cash, or prizes. "Gaming establishmentsO' include bingo halls, off-track betting parlors, and the opetation of games of chance played with cards or mechanical or dectro-mechanical devices. 1his definition does not apply to the Virginia Lottety or games of chance opetated by charitahle organizations licensed under the Conunonwealth of Virginia. Garage or carport A building or roofed structure, accessoI)' to a permitted principal residential structure, and providing for the storage of one (1) of more motor vehicles and in which no business, occupation, or service for profit is conducted. Gasoline station Any lot, or portion thereof, with fuel pumps and underground storage tanks for retllil sale to the public of motor vehicle fuels or oils, which establishment may include the sale of propane or kerosene as accessory uses. General service establishment An establishment primarily engaged in repair or maintenance services to individuals and households, tather than husinesses, of household or commercial goods, including appliances, dectronics, computers, and similar goods, hut excluding "personal service," ''business seMce," or "motor vehicle repair or setvi.ce" esmblislunents or any use which is otherwise specifically lisred in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Glare Light coming directly from a light source to the eye, hampering vision or causing visual discomfort, resulting from insufficiently shielded or inappropriately aimed light sources in the field of view. Government offices Govemmental offices providing adntioisttative, clerical, or public contact services that deal directly with the citizen. Typical uses include federal, state, and City offices. Group care facility A residential facility or dwelling unit housing persons unrelated by blood, marriage, adoption, or guardianship, including congregate homes, group care homes, halfway houses, nursing homes, and transitional living facilities as defined below: (1) Co ogre ga te home: A group care facility providing acconunodation and supervision to individuals or families where medical care is not a major element and including homes for orphans, foster children, veterans, victims of domestic violence including battered men, women or children, the elderly, pregnant teenagers, nonresident families of hospitalized patients, mentally handicapped, or similar uses. (2) G r 0 up care horn e : A group care facility in which more than eight (8) mentally ill, mentally retarded, or developmentally disabled persons reside with one (1) or more resident counselors or other staff persons. (3) Halfway house: A group care facility providing acconunodation, rehahilitation counseling, and twenty-four (24) hour a day on-site supervision to persons suffering from alcohol or drng addiction, or Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 186 Appendix A persons suffering from similar disorders, or persons re-entering society after being released from a correctional facility or other institution. (4) N u r sin g h 0 me: A group care facility providing long teun accommodation to the elderly, mentally or physically handicapped, or other individuals incapacitated in some manner for medical reasons and where primary or non-primary medical treatment facilities are a component of the use. (5) Transitional living facility: A group care facility providing shelter to the homeless and generally integrated with other social services and counseling programs to assist in the transition to self-sufficiency through the acquisition of a stable income and permanent housing. Group home, subject to Virginia Code 15.2-2291 A residential facility in which no more than eight (8) mentally ill, mentally retarded, or developmentally disabled persons reside, with one (1) or more resident counselors or other staff persons, and for which the Department of Mental Health, Mental Retardation and Substance Abuse Services is the licensing authority pursuant to the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. For purposes of this definition, mental illness and developmental disability shall not include current illegal use of or addiction to a controlled substance as defined in Section 54.1-3401 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended. A "group home, subject to Virginia Code 15.2-2291" is not considered a "group care facility" for purposes of this Chapter. Guarantee A perfonnance bond, letter of credit, or other foun of surety acceptable to the City Attorney and the City Director of Finance, which is held or provided as secw:ity for the execution, completion, or existence of a requirement of this Chapter or a condition imposed with the granting of a speciaI exception. Hazardous materials facility An establishment in which the principal activity is the testing, storage, treatment, or disposal of hazardous materials or waste. Such facility may consist of severn! treatment, storage, or disposal operational units and includes all areas where hazardous materials or waste may be received, stored, handled, or processed. For purposes of this definition, hazardous materials or waste means any refuse or discarded material or combinations of refuse or discatded materials in solid, semisolid, liquid, or gaseous foun which cannot be handled by routine waste management techniques because they pose a substantial present or potential hazard to human health or other living organisms because of their chemical, geological, or physical properties. Tills use type shall not include uses in which the storage or disposal of hazardous materials is accessOlY and incidental to the principal use. Health and fitness center .An establishment designed and equipped for the conduct of recreational sports, physical exercise, leisure time activities, or other usual recreational activities, and open to members and guests or open to the public for a fee. Such establishments may offer classes or instruction in such activities as physical exercise, weight training, martial arts, or weight control and include such facilities and equipment as handball courts, basketball courts, squash or racquetball courts, gymnasiums, tennis courts, swimming pools, cardio exercise appararns, or weight training equipment. Heat island An urban area in which a greater amount of heat is retained, as by impervious surface, than in nearby areas. Height of structure The vertical distance measured from the average ground level on all sides of the structure to the level of the highest point of the roof or top of a structure having a flat roof, or the mean level between the eaves and the highest point of the roof of a structure having a pitched roof. Fence or wall height shall be measured as the vertical distance from the average level of the ground adjacent to the fence or the wall to the top of the highest projection. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 187 Appendix A Home occupation An occupation conducted as an accessory use within a dwelling unit or within an accessory structure located on the same lot as the dwelling unit, and conducted by the resident thereof, provided that the use is limited in extent and incidental and secondary to the use of the dwelling unit for residential purposes and does not change the chatacter of the dwelling unit or the lot on which the dwelling unit is located. Hospital An institution, licensed by the State department of health, providing primary health services and medical or surgical care to persons, primarily in-patients, suffering from illness, disease, injury, deformity, or other abnormal physical or mental conditions, and including as an integral part of the institution, related facilities such as laboratories, outpatient facilities, or training facilities. A hospital complex may include an eating establishment, medical transport related heliports, physical therapy, employee housing, temporary patient or patient family housing, and shops for medical equipment, pharmaceutical supplies, gifts, books, magazines, toiletries, flowers, candy, or similar items, provided such uses are primarily for the benefit of patients, staff, and visitors. Hotel or motel A building or group of buildings in which lodging units are provided and offered to the public for compensation, which is open to transient guests on an overnight or weekly basis, and which is not a "boarding house" or "group care facility" as defined in this Chapter. Such uses include furnished rooms, a lobby, clerk's desk or counter, facilities for registration, and daily linen and housekeeping services. A hotel or motel is designed, used, or intended, wholly or in part, for the accommodation of travelers on a temporary basis. Impervious surface Any man-made surface or material that does not readily absorb water or that substantially reduces or prevents the infiltration of stormwater. For purposes of this Chapter, impervious surfaces shall include, without limitation, roofs, private streets, decks, sidewalks, outdoor storage areas, and parking and other areas paved with asphalt, concrete, compacted sand, compacted grave~ or clay. Impervious surface ratio That portion of a lot or zoning district which, when viewed from directly above, would be covered by any impervious surface. Compacted gravel parking areas shall be considered impervious for the purpose of calculating impervious surface ratio, unless specially designed to remain pervious as docwnented by an engineer. Impervious surface ratio (percentage) shall be calculated by dividing the area of impervious surface (111 square feet) by the total area of the lot (111 square feet). Example calculation: Area of impervious surface = 10,000 square feet T otallot area = 20,000 square feet 10,000 square feet divided by 20,000 square feet = .50 Result Impervious surface ratio = 50% Improved street or improved alley A street or alley that has a paved surface that conforms to Section 31-90 of this Code. Inoperative vehicle Any motor vehicle on which valid license plates or a valid inspection decal is not displayed, or any motor vehicle which has been wrecked, partially or totally clismanded, or disassembled, such that the vehicle cannot be lawfully operated on a public street Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 188 Appendix A Janitorial services establishment An establishment engaged in the cleaning of dwellings, offices, or places of business, and rendering such service on a fee or contract basis. Junk yard Property which is maintained, operated, or used for the collecting, storing, buying, or selling of scrap material or similar waste or other salvage or discarded materials, including used building materials, machinery, scrap metals, or other scrap materials and similar items, but not including motor vehicles or trailers, or parts thereof. "Ji.mk yard" shall not include the processing or treatment of such "junk" for recycling purposes. Kennel The keeping, raising, breeding, training, showing, renting, selling, or boarding of dogs or cats. Such activity sru.n not be considered a kennel where accessory to a principal residential use, provided that not more than four (4) dogs or four (4) cats exceeding six (6) months of age are kept Laboratory, dental, medical, or optical An establishment primarily engaged in bacteriologica1, biologica1, x-ray, pathological, or similar analytical or diagnostic services to medical doctors or dentists, and the production, fitting, or sale of optical or prosthetic appliances. Laboratory, testing and research An establishment primarily engaged in perfomting scientific research or testing activities in technological fields. Typical uses include biotechnology laboratories, engineering laboratories, environmental laboratories for the analysis of air, water, and soil, and phannaceutica1laboratories only involved in research and development. Excluded from this use are any laboratories which mass produce one (1) or more products directly for the conswner market. Laundromat A facility where patrons, for a fee, wash, dry, or dry c1ean clothing or other fabrics in machines operared by the patron. Library A public facility for the use of literary, musical, artistic, or reference materials. Limousine service The business of offering the public motor vehicles for carrying or transportation of passengers between the airport and points within the City for a fixed charge or fee, or offering a motor vehicle with driver for a fixed charge for transportation of passengers at an hourly rate. Such business may include faciliries for servicing, repairing, and fueling the limousines. Live-work unit A structure or portion of a stru= combining a residential living space with an integrated workspace principally used by the resident. Loading space Space provided for bulk pickups, deliveries, and refuse collection, scaled to delivery vehicles expected to be used, and accessible to such vehicles when required parking spaces are filled. Lot or zoning lot For purposes of this Cbapter, a lot or zoning lot is a clearly defined parcel of land identified on a plat of record, fronting on a public street or an approved private street within a Planned Unit Development, and baving sufficient area Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 189 Appendix A and dimensions to meet minimwn zoning district requirements for area, frontage, use, and coverage. and to provide such yards and other open space as required by the respective zoning district regulations. In this Chapter, the terms '10f' and "zoning lof' have the same meaning and may be used interchangeably. A lot may consist of combinations of contiguous lots of record or portions of lots so recorded, provided that in no case of subdivision or combination shall any residual lot, portion of lot, or parcel be created which does not meet the requirements of this Chapter. Lots include the following specific types: (1) Corne r lot: A lotlocated at the intersection of two (2) or more streets. (2) I n t e ri 0 r lot: A lot with only one (1) frontage on a street. (3) T h r 0 ugh lot: A lot which has frontages on two (2) nonintersecting streets. Lot area The total square footage or acreage ofland within the boundaries of a lot. Lot frontage The horizontal linear dimension between the side lot lines measured from the points where the side lot lines intersect a public street right-<>f-way or a private street in an approved Planned Unit Development District. All sides of a lot that abut a such streets shall be considered frontage. Lumber yard An area used for the storage, distribution, and sale of finished or rough-<:ut Iwnber and Iwnber products, but not including the manufacture or fabrication of Iwnber, lwnber products, or firewood. Manufactured home See ''Dwelling.'' Manufacturing: Beverage or food processing A facility where beverages or foods, excluding ponltty and animal slaughtering and dressing, are processed and packaged for local, regional, or national distriburion. Bottling facilities are included in this use type. Manufacturing: General An establishment engaged in the processing, fabrication, assembly, or mixing of materials to create a new product, and the incidental storage, sales, and distriburion of such products, but excluding any use or establishment which is otherwise listed specifically in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Manufacturing: Wood products A facility where logs or partially processed cants are sawn, split, shaved, stripped, chipped, or otherwise processed to produce wood products. 1bis use type includes lwnber mills, sawmills, and planing mills. Mechanical equipment Heating, ventilating, air conditioning, or power generation equipment. Medical clinic }\11 establishment in which doctors, dentists, or other practitioners licensed by the Commonwealth of Virginia provide health care services to clients, including medical- or health-related physical or massage therapy, counseling, diagnoses, or treatment, exclusively on an outpatient basis. '~edical clinics" provide outpatient care on a routine basis, and may offer minor surgical care, but do not provide overnight care or serve as a base for an ambulance service. For purposes of this definition, "medical clinic" does not include "outpatient mental health and substance abuse clinics:' Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 190 Appendix A Meeting hall A building designed for public assembly for special events or regularly scheduled programs. and available to the genernl public for a fee. ''Meeting ball" includes banquet halls, reception halls, and wedding halls. Mini-warehouse An enclosed storage facility containing cubicles designed to provide independent, individual, fully enclosed storage space, for lease to individuals for long-tenn storage of their household goods or personal property, where each cubicle is enclosed by walls and ceiling, and where each cubicle has a separate entrance for the loading and unloading of stored goods. Such facilities are also called self-service storage facilities. Mixed-use building A single building containing more than one (1) type of land use permitted within a zoning district, including residential, commercial, and office. Mobile home See ''Dwelling unit." Motor freight terminal or truck terminal A facility for the receipt, transfer, short-term storage, and dispatching of goods transported by truck. Loading and unloading is carried on regularly, and minor maintenance of the truck fleet is performed. Included in the use type are mail or package distribution facilities as well as motor freight companies regulated by the public utility conunission or the Interstate Conunerce Commission. Motor vehicle Any vehicle which is self-propelled or designed for self-propulsion. Any device designed, used, or maintained primarily to be loaded on or affixed to a motor vehicle to provide a mobile dwelling, a sleeping place, storage, or office or commercial space shall be considered a part of a motor vehicle. Motor vehicle or trailer painting and body repair Any facility, or portion thereof; used for the repair, replacement, or straightening of a motor vehicle body or &.me or painting of motor vehicles. Mechanical service and engine repair may be performed as an ancillary function of the body work. Motor vehicle rental establishment Establishments engaged exclusively in the renrnl of motor vehicles, including incidental parking and servicing of vehicles for rent or lease, and may include the sale of rental inventory. Commercial motor vehicles shall not be included in the inventoIJ' of a motor vehicle renrnl establishment, except for trucks and trailers serving the purpose of household do-it-yourself movers. Typical uses include motor vehicle rental agencies and truck and trailer rentals for moving household personal property. Motor vehicle repair or service establishment An establishment primarily engaged in the repair or maintenance of motor vehicles or trailers, including the sale, installation, and servicing of equipment and parts. Typical uses include oil and lubrication services, tire sales and installation, wheel alignment and brake shops, repair and replacement of cooling, electrical, fuel, and exhaust systems, replacement of batteries, and similar repair and services activities where minor repairs and routine maintenance are conducted; repair garages, transmission shops, major engine repair, and radiator shops where major engine and transmission repair activities are conducted; motor vehicle upholstery repair or replacement; and motor vehicle radio or stereo system installation or service. For purposes of this Chapter, the definition of motor vehicle repair and service establishments does not include "motor vehicle or trailer painting and body repair." Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 191 Appendix A Motor vehicle sales and service establishment, New ...i\n establishment whose activities include the display, sale, or lease of new and used motor vehicles or trailers, and new and used commercial motor vehicles not exceeding 26,000 ponnds empty gross wcigh~ and the performance of any repair or maintenance work of such motor vehicles and commercial motor vehicles, including painting and body repair, and financial serv1.cesconducted as an accessory use to the sales establishment. The exterior display of motor vehicle inventory for sale or lease shall be considered an outdoor showroom for customers to examine and compare products and as such shall not be considered "outdoor storage" for purposes of this Chapter, provided such exterior display is limited to such motor vehicle inventory, is accessible to the general public, and does not include damaged motor vehicles, motor vehicles or equipment being serviced, materials or parts, or similar products. Motor vehicle sales and service establishment, Used An establislunent which engages in only the display of three or more used motor vehicles or ttaiIers for sale or lease, and may engage in the repair or maintenance of such motor vehicles or trailers, but does not engage in the sale, lease, repair, or maintenance of commercial motor vehicles. The exterior display of motor vehicle inventory for sale or lease shall not be considered "outdoor storage" for purposes of this Chapter, provided such exterior display is limited to such motor vehicle inventory, is accessible to the general public, and does not include damaged motor vehicles, motor vehicles or equipment being serviced, materials or parts, or similar products. Museum An establislunent for preserving and exhibiting artistic, historical, scientific, natural, or man-made objects of interest. Such activity may include the sale of objects collected and memorabilia, the sale of craftwork and artwork, boutiques, and the holding of meetings and social events. Nursery or greenhouse, commercial A retail establishment whose exclusive activity is the sale of plants, slunbs, and trees and the sale of any article, substance, or conunodity related to such planting, maintenance, or harvesting such as packaged fertilizers, soils, chemicals, or other nursery goods or products in small quantities to the consumer. Such establishment may conduct its activities both within an enclosed building and outside in the open. The exterior display of inventory for sale shall not be considered "outdoor storage" for purposes of this Chapter. Office, general An establishment primarily engaged in providing administrative, clerical, and other services not involving the manufacture, assembly, storage, display, or direct retail sale of goods, and not including medical services. Typical uses include real estate, insurance, management, tax preparation, call centers, data processing, computer software development, travel or other business offices, and organization and association offices. Office, professional An establishment primarily engaged in the conduct of professional business by professional persons as defined herein but not including medical services. For purposes of this definition, a professional person is a person who practices an occupation in which some department of science or learning is applied to affairs of others, either advising or guiding them, or otherwise serving their interests or welfare in the practice of an art fonnded on such knowledge. The word professional implies attainments in knowledge as distinguished from mere skill and the application of such knowledge to serve others. Professional person may include an attomey. accountant, professional engineer, architect, surveyor, financial planner, landscape arclUtect, or planner, but shall not include medical- or healthcare-related practitioners licensed by the Commonwealth of Virginia. Office, general or professional, Large scale A general or professional office for which the gross floor area of any building provides at least ten thousand (10,000) square feet of gross floor area dedicated exclusively to the general or professional office use. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke 12/05105 192 Appendix A Open space, usable Open space within or directly related to a multifamily residential development or a Planned Unit Development which is designed and intended for the common use and enjoyment of the residents of the development, or employees of such Planned Unit Development. Such open space is land not covered by parking, driveways, buildings, or stoan water management facilities, except that it may contain structures of a recreational nature (such as picnic shelters, gazebos, swinuning pools, tennis courts, and the like). Usable open space shall consist of open areas of such a size that the smallest dimension is not less than fifteen (15) feet and is of such configuration to allow for the conduct of outdoor activities. Yards required by this Chapter, which meet the foregoing dimensions, may be included in the allocation and calculation of usable open space. Other open or landscaped areas with a dimension ofless than fifteen (15) feet in any direction shall not be credited to the usable open space requirement for the development Outdoor display area The placement of goods or merchandise for sale or for advertisement, outside of the building or structure in which the merchandise is nonnally sold. For putposes of this definition, motor vehicle inventory for sale or lease, motor vehicle rental inventory, motor vehicle and commercial motor vehicle fleets associated with a business establishment, and the sale inventory of a nursery or conunercial greenhouse shall not be considered an "outdoor display area." Outdoor storage The keeping or storing, other than in a wholly enclosed building, of any goods, items, materials, or merchandise. "Outdoor storage" shall be permitted only as an accesso')' use where allowed by this Chapter. For purposes of this definition, motor vehicle inventory for sale or lease, motor vehicle rental inventory, motor vehicle and commercial motor vehicle fleets associated with a business establishment, and the sale inventory of a nursery or commercial greenhouse shall not be considered "outdoor storage." Outpatient mental health and substance abuse clinic An establislunent which provides outpatient services primarily related to the treatment of mental health disOIders, alcohol, or other drug or substance abuse disorders, which services include the dispensing and administering of controlled substances and phannaceutical products by professional medical pIllctitioners as licensed by the Commonwealth of Virginia. Overlay district A zoning district established by this Chapter to prescribe special regulations to be applied to a lot in combination with, and supplemental to, the wtderlying or base district. Paint ball facility An establishment engaged in the provision of a field or facility designated for the use of pnewnatic painthall guns for recreational use. A pnewnatic paintball gun means a paintball gun that expels by action of pnewnatic pressure plastic balls filled with paint for the purpose of marlring the point of impact. Park An area that is predominantly open space, used ptimarily for active or passive recreation, and not used for a profit-making purpose. Parking area An area provided for the temporary storage of motor vehicles, including any related aisles, parking spaces, ingress and egress lanes, and private garages but not including any part of a public right-of-way or public street. Parking lot A surface parking area for motor vehicles where there is no gross building area below the parlcing area and no gross building area or roof above it, and which provides one (1) or more parlcing spaces together with driveways, aisles, Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 193 Appendix A turning and maneuvering areas, incorporated landscaped areas, and similar features meeting the requirements esmblished by this Chapter. For the purposes of this definition, a "parking lot" includes a "parking lot facility" and a parlting lot which is accessory to a pennilled principal use. Parking lot facility Use of a site for a parking lot unrelated to a specific use. A "parlting lot facility" does not include parking 10", accessory to a pennilted principal use. Parking, off-site Off-street parking which is located on a separate lot from the lot containing the use which the parking is intended to serve. Parking space, off-street A space on premises rather than on the street for the parlting of one (1) motor vehicle conforming to the parlting area standards of this Chapter. For purposes of this definition, motor vehicle inventory for sale or lease, motor vehicle rental inventory, or motor vehicle and commercial motor vehicle fleets associated with a business establislunent shall not be considered an "off-street parlting space." Parking structure A structure, or portion thereof; composed of one (1) or more levels or floors used exclusively for the parlting or storage of operable motor vehicles. A parlting structure may be totally below grade (as in an underground parlting garage) or either partially or totally above grade with those levels being either open or enclosed. For purposes of this definition, a "parking structure" includes a "parlting structure facility" and a parking structure which is accessory to a pennilled principal use. Parking structure facility Use of a site for a parlting structure unrelated to a specific use. A "parlting structure facility" does not include parlting structures accessory to a pennitted principal use. Personal service establishment An esmblislunent primarily engaged in the provision of frequent or rerurrent needed individual services generally related to personal needs, such as the care of a person or a person's apparel, or the training and development of a person, including barber shops, beauty shops, nail salons, tanning salons, dressmakers and tailors, shoe repair shops, art or music lessons, and the like, but not including medical services, tattoo parlors, or body piercing establishments or any use which is otherwise specifically listed in the Use Mattix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Personal service home occupation A home occupation that generally provides services to an individual client related to the care of a person, a person's apparel, or the training and development of a person, including, but not limited to, beauty or barber shops, nail salons, dressmakers or tailors, music or art lessons, photography or portrait painting, and tutoring. but not including medical services, tattoo parlors, or body piercing establishments. Pervious pavement system Pavement system with traditional strength characteristics, but which has a proven capability of allowing rainfall to percolate through it Such a penneable pavement system utilizes porous asphalt, pervious concrete, or plastic pavers interlaid in a running bond pattern and either pinned or interlocked in place. Porous asphalt consists of an open graded course aggregate held together by asphalt with sufficient interconnected voids to provide a high rate of penneability. Pervious concrete is a discontinuous mixture of Portland cement, coarse aggregate, admixtures, and water which allows for passage of nmoff and air. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 194 Appendix A Pet grooming An establishment where, for a fee, domestic animals are bathed, clipped, or combed or brushed for the purpose of enhancing their aesthetic value or health, and where all such activity occurs wholly enclosed in a building. For purposes of this definition, "domestic animals" shall include dog.; and cats only. Petition The completed formes), with all documents, exhibits, and fees required of a petitioner for review and approval of a rezoning, conditional rezoning, or an appeal to the City Council or Circuit Court as provided for in this Chapter. Petitioner The party petitioning for approval of a rezouing, conditional rezoning, or filing a petition of appeal to the City Council or Circuit Court as provided for in this Chapter. Place of worship Any structure principally used as an assembly place for religious worship, including churches, synagogues, temples, mosques, and similar buildings, and including accessory uses customarily associated with such primary purpose such as parish houses, religious education buildings, convents, colwnbaria, cemeteries located on the same lot, bookstores inside the church building, and child care on the premises during worship services. "Elementary / middle/secondary educational facilities," "child day care center," "adult day care center," and "supply pantry" are not considered customary accessory uses for purposes of this definition. Playground Land which is improved with recreation equipment and facilities, such as swings, gym bars, and similar equipmen~ for the purpose of active recreation. Portable storage container A portable, weather-resistant receptacle designed and used for the storage or shipment of items, including, but not limited to, household goods, furniture, wares, building materials, equipmen~ or merchandise. The term shall not include dumpsters or refuse containers. Post Office Postal services directly available to the consumer operated by the United States Postal Service for the purpose of a specific zip code area. Such facilities include service windows for mailing packages and letters, post office boxes, offices, and motor vehicle storage areas. Principal structure A structure in which the primary use of the lot on which the structure is located is conducted. Principal use The main use ofland or structures as distinguished from a secondary or accessory use. Quarry A lot or land, or portion thereof, used for the purpose of extracting stone, sand, gravel, clay, or top soil for sale, except where such excavation is for purposes of grading for a building lot or roadway. The exttact:ion of minerals and sand and gravel operations are included in this definition. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 195 Appendix A Recreation, indoor The provision of recreation facilities which are predominantly participatory uses, and which are located and conducted entirely within a building. Typical uses include tennis or other racquet courts, swimming pools, bowling alleys, ice skating or roller skating rinks, batting cages, paint ball facilities, climbing walls, or similar recreation uses. "Indoor commercial recreation" establishments may include accessory uses, such as snack bars, pro shops, and locker rooms, which are designed and intended primarily for the use of patrons of the principal recreational use. "Indoor recreation" establishments shall not include any use which is otherwise specifically listed in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Recreation, outdoor The provision of recreation facilities which are predominantly participatory uses, and which are conducted in open or partially enclosed or screened facilities. Typical uses include swimming pools, tennis or other outdoor racquet courts, basketball courts, athletic fields, batting cages, driving ranges, skateboarding courses, or similar recreation uses. "Outdoor recreation" facilities may include any accessory uses, such as snack bars, pro shops and clubhouses, which are designed and intended primarily for the use of patrons of the principal recreational use. "Outdoor recreation" facilities shall not include paint ball fields or areas, go-cart or motorcycle courses, raceways, drag strips, overnight camping, or gun-firing ranges, or any use which is otherwise specifically listed in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Recreational vehicle A vehicle which can be towed, hauled, or driven, designed and used as temporary living accommodations for recreational, camping, or travel uses only. Recreational vehicles shall include travel trailers, pick-up campers, motor homes, tent trailers, or similar devices for temporary mobile housing. Recycling center A facility for the collection and processing of recoverable resources, such as paper, glass, metal, and plastic products, to return them to a condition in which they can be reused for production. "Processing" means the preparation of material for shipment to a site for remanufacturing into new products or the actual processing or treating for reuse by such means as baling, briquetting, compacting, flattening, grinding, crushing, mechanical sorting, shredding, cleaning and remanufacturing. lbis term does not include the salvaging and recycling of motor vehicles or trailers, or parts thereof. Recycling collection point An accessory use or structure that serves as a drop-off point for the temporary holding of recyclable materials, such as paper, cardboard, glass, metal, or plastic, prior to delivery to a broker or user of such materials. Such use or structure is intended for household or consumer use and does not include use by commercial or industrial establishments or the permanent storage or processing of such items. Resident manager apartment A single dwelling unit located within the structure of a ptincipal permitted use where such dwelling unit is accessory and subordinate to the ptincipal permitted use and which is designated for use only by the resident manager or security personnel of such ptincipal permitted use. Such dwelling unit shall not be sold, leased, or rented for other purposes. Retail sales establishment An establishment engaged in the sale or rental of goods, merchandise, or products directly to the consumer and including the incidental service of such merchandise. Retail sales establishments include warehouse clubs, grocery stores, florists, convenience stores, department stores, furniture stores, electronics stores, appliance stores, clothing stores, jewelry stores, drugstores, photo finishing services and supphes, picture framing, art galleries, bookstores, shoe stores, automobile parts and supplies store, antique stores, stationery stores, and similar retail establishments but shall not include any use or establishment which is otherwise listed specifically in the Use Matrix set furtb in Section 36.2- 340. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 196 Appendix A Retail sales establishment household fixtures, swimming Large pools appliances, furniture, A retail sales establislunent primarily characterized by hu:ge showrooms and floor samples, and where the retail sale is genernlly followed by delivety to the home, and which may include installation of the purchased item. Such establislunents include stores primarily engaged in the sale of hu:ge appliances such as refrigerators, ovens, Wllshers, and dryers, furniture stores, stores primarily engaged in the retail sale of household fixtures such as bathroom fixtures, carpeting or other floor coverings, or lighting, and the retail sale of swimming pools, hot tubs, or spas. Such retail sales establishment sball not include any use or establislunent otherwise listed specifically in the Use Matrix set forth in Section 36.2-340. Retaining wall A wall or terraced combination of walls designed to retain or restrain lateral forces of soil, such soil being similar in height to the height of the wall, and where such retaining wall is of a height no greater than that necessary to serve such stated purpose and is not used to support, provide a foundation for, or provide a wall for a building or other structure. Satellite dish antenna An antenna in the shape of a sballow dish, and appurtenant equipment, used for the direct reception of broadcast signals from orhiting satellites. Screening A method of visually obscuring one abutting or nearby structure or use from another by fencing, walls, or densely planted vegetation. Screening is intended to substantially, but not necessarily totally, obscure visual impacts between adjoining uses, structures, or facilities. Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation The Secretary of the Interior's StandaIds for Rehabilitation, as codified in 36 CFR 67 (U.S. Department of Interior regulations), and Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring, and Reconstructing Historic Buildings (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of the Ioterior, National Park Service, Cultural Resource Stewardship and Partnerships, Heritage Preservation Services, 1995), as amended. Setback The distance from a property line to the closet projection of a structure or from the closest projection of one structure to the closest projection of another structure. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 197 Appendix A Sight distance triangle A sight distance triangle shall mean triangular areas as defined below: (1) 1bat portion of a comer lot, in any zoning district, lying within a triangle area fonned by measuring &om the vertex of that portion of the property line adjacent to the intersecting streets, to a point on each property line running &om the vertex equal to ten (10) feet, and then connecting the two points thus estab6shed with a third line; and _, L-,.I 7",1 ~~-- ,. ~ ~ ! (2) A triangular area fonned by a diagoua1line connecting two (2) points located on a right-of-way line and the edge of a driveway, with such points to be equal to five (5) feet from the intersecting lines for residential driveways, and ten (10) feet from the intersecting lines for non-residential driveways. -r s. ---L Sign .Any object, device, structure, or fixture, or portion thereof, which is used to announce, advertise, identify, display, or direct or atttact attention to an object, person, institution, organization, business, product, goods, service, special promotion, activity, event, or location. The means used to direct or attract attention include, without limitation, objects, devices, fixtures, words, letters, mnnerals, graphics, figures, emblems, designs, illustration, decoration, symbols, logos, trademarks, colors, or projected illwnination or images. For definitions associated with signs, see Section 36.2'<;62.c Solid waste collection or transfer station Any storage or collection facility where solid waste, rubbish, garbage, Of any like materials are regularly shifted, transferred, transloaded, or moved from one carrier, conveyance, or form of transport to any other camer, conveyance, or fonn of transport. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 198 Appendix A Sports stadium, arena, or coliseum A large open or enclosed space specifically designed as a place of public assembly for viewing sporting events or other special entertainment events, including concerts, and where such field or court is partly or completely surrounded by tiers of seats for spectators. Stable, commercial The boarding, breeding, or raising of horses or ponies not owned by the owner or occupant of the property or the riding of horses or ponies by other than the owner or occupant of the property and their non-paying guests. Riding academies, where instruction in riding, jumping, and showing of horses is offered, and where horses may be hired for riding, are included in this definition. Stable, private The keeping, breeding, or raising of horses or ponies exclusively for the personal use and enjoyment of the owner or occupant of the property or the riding of horses or ponies by the owner or occupant of the property and their guests, which stable is accessory to a single-family detached dwelling. Stockade fence A fence constructed of vertical wood or vinyl strips, with no intervening spaces, providing a complete visual barrier. Storefront That portion of the ground floor of a non-residential building consisting of an entryway and windows, and that is leased to or occupied by an individual tenant, business, or other entity. Structure Anything which is constructed or erected with a fixed location on the ground, or attached to something having a fixed location on the gronnd, including buildings, walls, fences, signs, manufactured homes, and swimming pools (m-ground and above-ground). Studio/multimedia production facility A facility for the staging and recording of video or audio productions such as conunercials, film, programs, or music videos. Supply pantry An establishment engaged in the provision or sale of food, clothing, or other essential items at no charge or for less than fair market value where no on-premise consumption of the items being distributed occurs. Such establishments may commonly be referred to as "food banks," "thrift stores," or "clothes banks." Tattoo parlor An establishment which offers or practices the placement of designs, letters, scrolls, figure, symbols, or any other kind of marks upon or under the skin of a person with ink or any other substance, resulting in permanent coloration or marking of the skin, by the aid of needles or other instruments designed to touch or punctnre the skin, except when perfonned by a medical doctor or other medical services personnel licensed pursuant to Title 54.1 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, in the performance ofhis or her professioual duties. Taxicab business A service that offers transportation in passenger motor vehicles to persons in retum for a fee detennined by meter or zone. Such business may include facilities for servicing, repairing, and foeling the taxicabs. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 199 Appandlx A Towing service An establishment whose activities include the recovery, removal, and temporary storage of motor vehicles or tnrilers, but does not include the dismantling, demolition, repair, or salvage of such motor vebicles or tnrilers, or any part of such motor vehicles or trailers. Trailer Any vehicle without motive power designed for carrying property wholly on its own structure and for being drawn by a motor vehicle. Use The specific purpose for which land, water, or a structure is designed, arranged, intended, or for which it is or may be occupied or maintained. Utili ty Any person, firm, corporation, municipal agency, or authority duly authorized to furnish to the public, under regulation, electricity, gas, storm water drains, water, sewerage collection and treatment, steam, cable television, or telephone. Utility distribution or collection, basic Unear utility features for distribution of utility service to the customer, including electric power lines, water lines, gronnd water wells, sewer Jines, telephone lines, cable television lines, and natural gas lines, and other distribution linear features including tnlnsformers and relay and booster devices. Utility distribution or collection, transitional Linear utility features for the compression, "step-down of voltage," switching, storage, or other similar function of a utility service that is necessary for distribution of the utility service directly to the customer, including electric or gas compressor substations, water or sewer pump or lift stations, and storage facilities such as water storage tanks. Utility generation or treatment Gas or electtic generation plants, solid waste collection or transfer station, sewage treatment facility, or water treatment facility. Utility maintenance and service facility A utility facility supporting maintenance, repair, motor vehicle or equipment servicing, material storage, and similar activities associated with the provision of utility services, including storage yards and equipment service centers. Utility service lateral or service line The linear line of a utility extending from a utility's "common network" distribution line or transformer to the customer's property line or point of delivery in order to provide service connection to the customer. For purposes of this definition, "point of delivery" shall mean the point where facilities owned, leased, or under license by a customer connect to the utility's facilities. Veterinary clinic See "Animal hospital" Visually opaque A vertical surface characterized by a solid material through which no visual images can be seen. For purposes of "visually opaque" fencing, the openings of such fence, with gates closed, shall not exceed two (2) percent of anyone Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105/05 200 Appendix A (1) square foot of vertical fence surface area that is more than eight (8) inches above grade, nor shall any opening exceed one-half inch in width. Warehouse A structure, or portion thereof, used for the storage and inventory of goods, materials, or merchandise. Such uses may include the wholesale distribution of such goods, a storage facility for inventory ultimately to be distributed directly to the customer, or a moving/ storage firm facility. Welding or machine shop An establishment in which machines, machine parts. or other metal products are fabricated. Wildlife rescue shelter or refuge area A facility or area maintained for the welfiu:e, protection, and preservation of wildlife species. Wrecker yard Any area or lot, or portions of a lot, which activities include the recovery, removal, and temporary storage of inoperative or damaged motor vehicles or trailers for dismantling, demolition, repair, salvage, or sale of such inoperative or damaged motor vehicles or trailers, or part of such motor vehicles or t::tailers, but whose activities do not include the sale of gasoline or the sale of new motor vehicles or trnilers. Yard An open space, on the same zoning lot as a use or structure, which space is unoccupied and unobstructed &om thirty (30) inches above the graded ground level to the sky, except as otherwise provided in this Chapter. A yard extends along a lot line and to a depth or width specified in the yard requirements for the zoning district in which such zoning lot is located, with such depth or width being measured from the lot line on which the principal structure is located to the closest projection of the principa1structure. Yard, front A yard extentling between side lot lines across the front of a lot adjoining a public street, the depth of which is the horizontal distance between the front lot line and a line patallel thereto on the lot, as required by the respective zoning district regulations. Yard, rear A yard extentling along the full length of the rear lot line and back to a line drawn paralle1 to the rear lot line at a distance equal to the depth specified in the yard requirements for the zoning district in which such lot is located. Yard, side A yard extentling from the rea1line of the required front yard (the setback line) to the rear lot tine, at a depth required by the respective zoning district regulations, unless otherwise provided for in the supplemental regulations. Zoning Administrator The Zoning Administrator of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, or an authorized agent or designee thereof. Zoo An area, structure, enclosure, or premises which contains two (2) or more wild animals on exhibition for viewing by the public. Such use may include accessory retail and service establishments and grounds. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 201 Appendix A Submittal Requirements This Appendix outlines the materials and information that must be submitted in order to provide a complete application for approval of basic development plans, comprehensive development plans, and associated landscape plans. B-1. Basic Development Plan (a) A basic development plan sbaI1 be prepared in a clear and legible manner and shall be drawn to a suitable and fixed scale, such as one (1) inch equals thirty (30) feet This scale may be larger or smaller depending upon the size of the lot or tract involved. (b) A basic development plan submitted for approval shall include a completed application form, accompanied by payment of the required fees, and three (3) copies of a survey plot plan or a basic site plan drawing outlining the following information: (1) Official 1m< map number and current zoning classification, including any conditions that may be applicable to the property. (2) Scale of the drawing. (3) Name and/or labeling of all adjoining streets and alleys. (4) All public easements affecting the property. (5) Accurate dimensions and shape of the lot (6) Location and dimensions, to scale, of all existing and proposed structures on the lot (T) Setback measurements for all existing or proposed structures on the lot from all adjoining property lines. (8) Nwnber, location, and dimensions of all on-site parking spaces, entrances to the site, driveways, or other paved areas. (9) Verification of available water and sanitary sewer facilities. (10) Delineation of all landscaping required pursuant to the regulations of Article 4 and Article 6 of this Chapter, including: (A) Location, size, and description of all required planting areas and planting materials; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 202 Appendix B (B) Tree protection areas and methods of protection for any existing vegetation to be preserved to satisfY any landscaping requirement; and (C) Delineation of any created slope of two (2) to one (1), horizontal to vertical, or greater, and description of vegetative cover pursuant to Section 36.2-642(a)(4). (11) Delineation of any riparian buffers required pursuant to Section 36.2-335. (12) Location, mOWlting heights, and aiming angles and shielding devices, if applicable, of any outdoor lighting regulated by Division 2, Article 6, of this Chapter. (13) For any property located in a floodplain district as established by Section 36.2-333, or if the property is determined to be in such close proximity that a reasonable Wlcertainty exists as to the location of the floodplain district, the mean sea level elevations, prepared by a licensed surveyor or engineer, shall be given for. (A) The floodway and/or the one hWldred- (1 (0) year floodplain; (B) The lowest floor elevation of all existing or proposed structures; and (C) The elevation to which the structure is or will be floodproofed. (14) Other information as may be required by the Zoning Administrator to detemtine compliance with this Chapter. (c) If the application for basic development plan approval proposes construction that will require a land disturbing activity in or upon critical terrain that slopes toward adjacent properties, streets. alleys, Streams. or creeks, or if the proposed land disturbing activity is fOWld by the Zoning Administrator to involve site-specific features which warrant a review of erosion and sediment contro~ a grading and erosion and sediment control plan, prepared by a licensed professional engineer, surveyor, or architect, shall be required. If the proposed construction will not require a land disturbing activity in or upon critical terrain as previously set forth in this subsection and the land disturbing activity being proposed is less than 2,000 square feet, the applicant may be pennitted to execute an agreement in lieu of an erosion and sediment control plan. B-2. Comprehensive Development Plan (a) A comprehensive development plan and associated calculations shall be prepared by a licensed, professional engineer, surveyor, architect, or landscape architect, unless otherwise approved by the Agent to the Planning Commission. (b) A comprehensive development plan may be submitted in either single or multi-sheet form, as appropriate to the needs of the specific development project, and shall comply with the following: (1) The plan shall be prepared in a clear and legible manner and shall be drawn to a fixed scale that is suitable and legible for conveying the information required (2) The submitted plan sheet(s) shall provide a minimwn border of one-half (1/2) inch to the edge of the plan sheet. (3) The sheet size of plans shall be a minimum of eighteen (18) inches by twenty-four (24) inches and shall be no larger than thirty (30) inches by forty-two (42) inches. Sheet sizes of thirty-six (36) inches by forty-eight (48) inches or eleven (11) inches by seventeen (17) inches may be pennitted, when applicable and upon approval by the City Development Engineer. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 203 Appendix B (4) When the plan entails construction, features, and dam too numerous to be legibly shown on one (1) sheet, the comprehensive development plan shall be prepared on separate component sheets and shall be prefaced by a cover sheet with an index listing of the type and tide of the various plan sheets included in the plan. (5) Each plan sheet, whether submitted in single sheet or multi-sheet fonn, shall identify the type of plan (Le., site dimension, layout plan, utility plan, erosion and sediment control plan, stormwater management plan, landscape plan), the name of the property owner, business, linn, or company, and the property location. (c) Ten (10) copies of the comprehensive development plan shall be submitted for review, accompanied by payment of the required fees. Any re-submittal necessitated by information fO\Uld during review to be incomplete, in error, or lacking in detail, pursuant to Section 362-553, shall require the submission of six (6) full size copies and one (1) half-size copy of the comprehensive development plan. (d) A comprehensive development plan shall include, at a minimum, the following: (1) Property owner identification that includes the name, address, and telephone number of the following. (A) Property owner and! or developer; and (B) Submitting engineer, architect, surveyor, or landscape architect. (2) Property identification: (A) Official tax map number(s) of property proposed for development and tot:l! acreage of those identified properties; (B) Zoning classification of property proposed for development and that of abutting properties, and a listing of any conditions to which the property proposed for development is subject by reason of a conditional rezoning or by order of the Board of Zoning Appeals (ordinance number or case number, with effective date, shall be included.); (q Tot:l! acreage ofland being developed; (0) Tot:l! acreage of land to be disturbed (cleared, gmded, excavated, or filled) as a result of proposed development; and (E) Legal reference, lot, block, and section of the recorded subdivision in which the property is situated (If any). (3) Proposed use of the property and buildings: (A) T ot:l! square footage (gross floor area) of all existing and proposed buildings occupying or proposed to occupy the premises; (B) Existing and proposed use of the tot:l! square footage of all buildings on the property, including the square footage existing or proposed for various and separate uses within all buildings on the property; (q Height of all structures; (0) Finished floor elevation for all buildings; and (E) Dimensional layout of all buildings and structures existing or proposed to be constructed, erected, or placed on the property, including the delineation of minimum, and maximum if apphcable, yard depths for front, side, and rear yards, as required by the apphcable zoning district regulations. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12105/05 204 Appendix B (4) Parlcing.loading, and driveway requi=nents: (A) Number of minimum off-street parking spaces required by Section 36.2-652 and the maximum off- street parking spaces permitted as set forth in Section 36.2-653; (B) Number of on-site parking spaces provided by the plan; (C) Number of handicapped parking spaces required; (D) Number of handicapped spaces provided by the plan; (E) Number of off-street loading spaces required by Section 36.2-655; (f) Number of on-site loading spaces provided by the plan; (G) Number of employees to be situated on the premises, including peak shift periods, where applicable to parking requi=nent (H) Dimensional layout of all paved surfaces, with delineation of distances from property lines, including parking areas, loading spaces, driveways, and related curbing, with the parl<ing space angles and dimensions of typical parl<ing and loading spaces, maneuvering aisles, and driveway enttances and exits noted; (I) Statement certifYing that the sight distance at any proposed entrance conforms to American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASillO) guidelines for intersection sight distance unless otherwise approved by the City Traffic Engineer; (J) Type of parking lot pavement shown in typical section; and (K) If applicable, details of pervious pavement system to be utilized to exceed maximum pennitted off-street parl<ing pursuant to Section 36.2-653(c). (5) Where any new curb cut is proposed, location of all enttances and streets within 400 feet of the proposed development site: (A) Tbis sketch may be separate from the site plan itself and may be shown at a smaller scale. (B) In the area immediately adjacent to the proposed site, the site plan shall also include the street pavement width, the existence of curb and gutter or ditches, and the existence of any median. (6) Standard City of Roanoke Construction Procedure Notes and other necessary notes or data. (T) General notes defining estimated amOWlt of material, such as dirt, rocks, stumps, or debris, to be removed from the site. (8) Standard flood statement, staring the flood zone in which the property is located and a declaration that no portion of the subject property is located within the limits of a 100-year flood boundary as designated by cw:rent FEMA maps. (9) Plan scale. (10) Erosion and Sediment Control Narrative, detailing project description, exisring site conditions, adjacent areas, off-site areas, soils, critical areas, erosion and sediment control measures, pennanent stabilization, stormwater runoff considerations, calculations for sediment basins, and other relevant information. (11) Extent of area to be disturbed delineated by means of a solid line encompass. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roenoke12105l05 205 Appendix B (12) Sediment basin and sediment ttaps, showing location, size, and all interior and outfall devices. (13) Contour lines shown at two (2) foot intervals, showing existing and proposed elevations. One (1) foot intervals may be required to provide clarification of site grading. (14) Location of creeks, streams, waterways, pouds, springs, and similar features, with appropriate uames, if any, and the delineation of any riparian buffers required pursuant to Section 36.2-335. (15) Construction entrance and any related appurtenances, such as temporary pipes, with notation of type of stone to be utilized. (16) .All necessary erosion and sediment control measures required to control sediment and erosion on site. (17) Vicinity map showing the location of the site in relation to surronnding features such as streets and major thoroughfares, drawn to a scale of one (1) inch equals eight hnndred (800) feet, or comparable scale or size. (18) North arrow. (19) Abutting streets with proper name, suffix (such as NE., S.W.), and right-of-way width. (20) Metes and bonnds description (bearings and distances) shown along all property lines. (21) Stormwater management (A) Specific information and details showing location and type of all proposed storm drains and stormwater management (filttation) devices, such as pipes, retention ponds, riprap, diversion dikes, detention ponds, rain gardens. infiltration trenches, or similar devices; (B) Calculations for storm sewer systems of stonnwater rnnoffbased on fWloff to be anticipated from a ten (10) year frequency storm or greater if conditions necessitate (provided under separate cover, not on drawings); (C) Calculations of pre-development and post-development and pond routing as required in Chapter 11.2, Stormwater Management, of this Code (provided nnder separate cover, not on drawings); and (D) Profile of all storm sewer systems on site and/or associated with site work. (22) Location, design, and size (mcluding size and type of all pipes and inlets) of all existing and proposed utility facilities (water lines, sewer lines, and storm drains) and related easements, and the location and type of refuse storage facilities. (23) Delineation of drop inlets, manholes, and similar facilities. (24) Concrete curb, gutrer, and sidewalk delineated and noted by type, as required. (25) Outdoor lighting plan as required by Section 36.2-624. (26) Landscape Plan (see Section B-3, Appendix B). (27) If constructing streets to be dedicated for public use, street plans and profiles showing the following shall be required: (A) Existing and proposed drains, sanirary sewers, sewer laterals extended to the property lines, water lines and laterals, fire hydrants, and similar facilities; Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 208 Appendix B (B) Center line grade of the street, the size, depth, and slope of all required dnUns, and the size, location, and depth of water mains; (C) Cross-sections of the streets taken at each fifty (SO) foot station at street intersections or other points required to properly establish the grade of the street may be required by the Agent to the Planning Commission; (D) Plan and profile of all sanitary sewer lines, water lines, or stonn sewers to be dedicated as public improvements; and (E) Existing and proposed contours along any proposed street to the point(s) at which it ties in with existing street(s). (28) Other infonnation as may be required by the Agent to the Planning Commission to detennine compliance with this Chapter. (e) If any development activity is projected to generate an increase in ttaffic of more than 100 vehicles per hour during the peak ttaffic hour of any adjacent street or more than 1,000 vehicles per day, a Traffic Impact Study or Statement, as approved by the City Traffic Engineer, shall be required. Projected trips shall be generated based upon the methodology included in the latest version of the Institute of Transportation Engineers' (!TE) Trip Generation Manual Prior to preparation of the Traffic Impact Study or Statement, the City Traffic Engineer must approve the methodology and asswnptions proposed for the Study. (I) If the development requires the installation of public improvements, such as street dedication, utilities, stoonwater facilities, or erosion and sediment and control measures, anyone (1) or more of the documents set forth below may be required. In all such instances of the need to submit anyone (1) or more of the agreements and/or guarantees delineated below, the preparer of the comprehensive development plan shall submit a schedule of cost estimates in unit quantities, with totals, for all proposed public improvements, erosion and sediment controls practices, and stonnwater management measures, as part of the comprehensive development plan submittaL (1) Development agreement between the developer and the City, guaranteeing the satisfactory instillment of the improvement or erosion and sediment control measures; (2) Perfonnance guarantee (bond, letter of credit, surety) in the amount of the cost estimated for the installation of such improvements or erosion and sediment control measures; or (3) Maintenance agreement between the developer and/or owners of the property and the City providing for future maintenance of certain privately owned stonnwater management facilities. B-3. Landscape Plan (a) A landscape plan shall be drawn to scale of not less than one (1) inch equals fifty (SO) feet, or a scale as necessary to establish compliance with this Chapter, and shall include dimensions and distances. (b) In addition to the infonnation required for a comprehensive development plan, as set forth in Section B-2, Appendix B, a landscape plan shall include the following additional infonnation: (1) Sight distance triangles. (2) ..Areas reserved for dedications and easements, including above groWld easements and ove:dJ.ead utility lines. (3) Delineation of all portions of a lot which are not included in the calculation of impervious surfaces and a schedule of all trees and other plant materials, including grass or other ground cover, required by Division 4, Article 6, of this Chapter, noting the size, caliper, and scientific and common names consistent with the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-642. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 207 Appendix B (4) Delineation of any created slope of two (2) to one (1), horizontal to vertical, or greater, and schedule of vegeOltive cover pursuant to Section 36.2-642(a)( 4). (5) Planting and installation methods. (6) Extent of preservation of existing landscape features and methods of protection: (A) Delineation of existing trees of six (6) inch caliper or greater measnred at four and one-half (4-1/2) feet above grade; existing ornamental trees of any sixe; existing trees within required yanls, along property boundaries, or within twenty (20) feet of streams or other watercourses; and streams in their natural condition; (B) Delineation of existing trees and streams as set forth in subsection (A), above, and any other existing vegeOltion, to be removed; (C) Delineation of existing trees for which a tree preservation bonus is requested pursuant to Section 36.2-643(a)(3); (D) Delineation of Tree Protection Areas for groups of trees and individual trees that will be retained on the development sire, noted by location, sixe, and type; (E) Protective features including trenching, landscape walls, tree wells, stonnwater managemen~ and Best Management P:mctices stroctures; and (F) Plans, cross sections, or illustrations and standard specifications depicting the manner in which the trees of the Tree Protection Areas and existing vegeOltion and streams to remain shall be protected. (I) Delineation of all landscaping, buffering, and screening, including location, sixe, and description of all landscaping material by size, caliper, and scientific and common names consistent with the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-642, for the following: (A) Street yard trees, as required by Section 36.2-645; (B) Buffer yards, as required by Section 36.2-647; and (C) Facade planring, as required by Section 36.2-646. (8) Delineation of screening of specific uses as required by Section 36.2-649, including location, size, and description of screening materials. (9) Delineation of all landscaping for parking areas as required by Section 36.2-648, including location, sixe, and description of all landscaping marerial by sixe, caliper, and scientific and common names consistent with the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-642, and including nOOltion of the following: (A) Name, quantity, location, and spacing of trees, and the name, location, and spacing of shrubs, in landscaping strips along the perimerel:S of parking areas as required by Section 36.2-648; (B) Minimum tree canopy for parking areas as required by Section 36.2-648; (C) Minimum tree canopy within the interior of parking areas as required by Section 36.2-648; (D) Calculation of tree canopy within the interior of parking areas provided by the plan; (E) Calculation of the cumulative tree canopy along the perimeters and within the interior of parking areas provided by the plan; and Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05/05 208 Appendix B (F) Dimensions of all planting islands or peninsulas and perimeter landscaping strips (width, length, and soil depth). (10) Ovetall tree canopy: (A) l\finimum tree canopy required for the development site pursuant to Section 36.2-644; (B) Calculation of total tree canopy on the site provided by the plan; and (C) Location, size, and description of all trees used in the calculation of the tree canopy provided by the plan, noting the size, caliper, and scientific and common names consistent with the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-642 (11) If applicable, delineation of all landscaping, buffer yards, and screening as required by the supplemental regulations set forth in Article 4 of this Chapter, including location, size, and description of all landscaping material by size, caliper, scientific and common names consistent with the regulations set forth in Section 36.2-642, and location, size, and description of screening materials. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 20lI Appendix B Agreements 1ms Appendix provides agreements as may be required by this Chapter. C-1 Off-Site Parking Agreement Following is the Off-Site Parlcing Agreemenr as required by Section 36.2-652(g)( 4). CITY OF ROANOKE OFF-SITE PARKING AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT made and entered into this _ day of 20~ by and between hereinafter referred to as the "Owner of the primary Pared(s)," and . hereinafter referred to as the "Owner of the Secondary Pareel(s)," and the City of Roanoke, VIrginia: WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, the Owner of the primary Pared(s) certifies that he/she/it is/are the record owner(s) of property identified as Official Tax Pared(s) No. on the records of the Conunissioner of the Revenue of the City of Roanoke, and being the same property acquired by the Owner of the Primary Parcel(s) by instrument recorded in the Oerk's Office of the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke in Deed/Will Book ~ page ~ which property is hereinafter referred to as the ''Primary Parcel(s)'"; and WHEREAS, the Owner of the Secondary Parcel(s) certifies that he/she/it is/are the record owner(s) of property identified as Official Tax Pared(s) No. on the records of the Conunissioner of the Revenue of the City of Roanoke, and being the same property acquired by the Owner of the Secondary Parcel(s) by instrument recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke in Deed/Will Book ~ page ~ which property is hereinafter referred to as the "Secondary Pared(s)." NOW, 1HEREFORE, for and in consideration of the approval of the City of a development plan for the Primary Pared(s), and the mutual covenants herein, it is agreed by the parties that Pursuant to the tenns of Section 36.2-652, Chapter 36.2, Zoning, of the Code of the City of Roanoke, off-street parlcing space requirements for the proposed use of the Primary Pared(s), are being satisfied through provision of all or a portion of such required parlcing spaces, numbering on the Secondary Pareel(s). The permanent availability of such parking spaces and associated pedestrian access routes for use on the Secondary Pared in conjunction with the uses conducted on the Primary Pared(s) has been established by execution of an appropriate legal instrument, recorded in the Clerk's Office of the Circuit Court of the City of Roanoke in Deed Book ~page_. Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 210 Appendix C By the signature(s) on this statement, the Owner(s) of the Primary Parcel(s), do hereby acknowledge and agree that should the parking spaces on the Secondary Parcel become unavailable for use at some rime as a result of a breach in the recorded instrument, or for any other reason, that an equal nwnber of parking spaces shall be consttucted and provided either on the Primary Parcel(s) or through another off-site arrangement. Failure to provide or construct such replacement parking spaces within ninety (90) days, weather permitting, shall be deemed a violation of the City's Zoning Ordinance and shall be punishable in accordance with the penalties provided therein. The responsibility of complying with these parking requirements shall run with title to the Primary Parcel(s) and the Secondary Parcel(s), and shall not be affected by ttansfer by lease or of ownership, as long as the use of the Primary Parcel(s) necessitates provision of off-site parking spaces to satisfy the applicable parking standards specified by the Zoning Ordinance. A recorded statement executed by the Owner(s) of the Primary Parcel, indicating that all or a portion of such parking spaces are no longer required, shall be conclusive as to any release from the requirements of this Agreement by the City. WITNESS the following signatures and seals: OWNER OF PRIMARY PARCEL(S) By: Title: Clf signing for a corporation or a partnership) OWNER OF SECONDARY P ARCEL(S) By: Title: Qf signing for a corporation or a partnership) CITY OF ROANOKE By: (title) Approved as to fonn: City Attorney COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA City of Roanoke, to-wit I, a Notary Public for the Conunonwea1th of Virginia at large, do bereby certify that . whose name as the Owner of the Primary Pan:el(s) is signed to the foregoing agreement bearing the date of the _day of . 20~ has acknowledged the same before me in the jurisdiction aforesaid. Given under my hand the _ day of 20_. Notary Public My conunission expires: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 211 Appendix C COMMONWEALlH OF VIRGINIA City of Roanoke, to-wit I, . a Notary Public for the Commonwealth of Virginia at large, do hereby certify that whose ruune as the Owner of the Secondary Parcel(s) is signed to the foregoing agreement bearing the date of the _day of 20~ has acknowledged the same before me in the jurisdiction aforesaid. Given under my hand the _ day of 20_. Notary Public My conunission expires: Zoning Ordinance - City of Roanoke 12/05105 212 Appendix C Tlle Roanoke Times Roanoke, Virginia Affidavit of Publication The Roanoke Times HAi<Y PARKER CITY OF ROANOKE - CITY CLERK MUNICIPAL BLDG RM 456 RO^NOKE VA 24011 REFERENCE, 10154151 56554 8 Standard State of Virginia Cit:.y of Roano:;:e T I (t.he undersigned) an authorized ]=eprese~Lative of =he ?imes-World Corporation, which corpora=ion l~ publisher of the Roanoke ~imes, a daily newspaper published in Roanoke, in the State of Virginia, do certify that the annexed n0tice was published in said newspapers on the fo~lowing dates: City/County of Roanoke, Commonwealth/State of Vir~ia. Sworn and subscribed before me this _~_____ ay of November 2005. Witness my hand and o~~eCll. - --/:.{;1;UA.. ___,A - My (Orclm'-s;;{i:., ex ;} ~ Notary Public ~-3t-t2QU7--- - ,":..' PUEl,:::: :::rE':~::L) ON: 11/15 TOTAL CUS::, ?ILED ON, 8,434.92 11/15/05 - - - + - - - - - ." - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~~:~:~~~:~--~--~~~-----------, Billing Services Representative NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS I I I TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: Pursuant to the provisions of 3315.2-2204 and 15.2-2285, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended ("Code of Virginia"), the City Council of the City of Roanoke will hold public hearings on Monday, November 21. 2005, at 7:00 p.m., or as soon as the matters may be heard, in the Council Chamber, Fourth Floor, Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building, 215 Church Avenue, S. W., Roanoke, Virginia. in order to consider the following ordinances: 1) Repealing Chapter 36.1, Zonina, of the Code of the City of Roanoke (1979), as amended, and adopting a new zoning ordinance for the City of Roanoke, new Chapter 36.2, Zonina, of the Code. 2) Rezoning all property in the City in order to implement new Chapter 36.2, Zonina, and Vision 2001-2020, the City's Comprehensive Plan. The zoning classification of every parcel in the City will change upon the adoption of a new zoning ordinance, which contains a new classification system (a descriptive summary of which follows). This ad contains a large-scale map of the City which shows the proposed new zoning classifications. While all property in the City will be assigned a new zoning classification, existing land uses will be "grandfathered" as provided by law, and the current uses of most parcels will not be affected by the provisions of the proposed Chapter 36.2, Zonina, unless and until the current use of the property is changed or redeveloped. Pursuant to the provisions of 315.2-2297. Code of Virginia, conditions that have previC','sly been proffered and accepted as part of a conditional rezoning will continue in effect. The public purposes for which the proposed new zoning ordinance and zoning map have been drawn include all of those matters set forth in 315.2-2284, Code of Virginia. Complete copies of the text of the proposed Chapter 36.2 and of the proposed zoning maps, which the Planning Commission for the City of Roanoke has considered and recommended for adoption to the City Council for the City of Roanoke, may be viewed at: Department of Pianning Building and Economic Development Room 166, Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue. S. W. Roanoke, Virginia; Roanokeva.gov - the official website of the City of Roanoke. A descriptive summary of proposed Chapter 36.2, Zonina, follows: Article 1. General Provisions Sections 36.2 - 100 through 108 Contains: statements which incorporate the City's zoning map by reference; statements of general purpose and intent of the zoning regulations and districts; description of the applicability of Chapter 36.2, Zonina, and exemptions from its provisions; description of how the zoning ordinance coordinates with other regulations; ruies of interpretation and construction, including general construction of language, determining the meaning of terms not defined, how distances between uses and structures should be measured, and determining and establishing zoning district boundaries; and conditions under which an owner acquires vested rights for a use or structure. Article 2. Zoning Districts Sections 36.2 - 200 through 205 Contains: statements of purpose and estabiishes base and overlay districts; description of the applicability of use regulations and dimensional regulations, including density, lot area, lot frontage, yards (front, side, rear) and yards as pertaining to corner and through lots; and application of maximum building and structure height requirements. If a use is specifically identified in the Use Matrix, while a more general use category is also included, the regulations and applicability of the specifically identified use govern. Land normally submerged under water will not be included in computing the allowable number of dwelling units for any iot. No lot that existed prior to the adoption of Chapter 36.2 that has no frontage on a public street may be further subdivided. unless adequate frontage on a public street is provided. With certain exceptions, yards must be unoccupied and unobstructed from 30 inches above grade levclto the sky. Yard requirements of certain zoning districts may preclude development or expansion of existing uses. Article 3. Regulations for Specific Zoning Districts Sections 36.2 - 300 through 340 . Division 1. Base Districts: Contains statements of purpose, permitted uses, and related development standards, and sets forth dimensional standards. District Description and Purpose Densitv (dwettin!! units/sQ. .It. of lot area) RA Residential Agricultural District 1 dwelling unit/43,560 sq. .It. of lot area Permits uses which provide for the continued use of agriculturally productive lands, and which prolect agricultural lands by maintaining a low popuiation density and a rural character of development. A 101 must have at least 43,560 square feet and 150 feet of frontage. Front yard depth must be alleast 30 feet. side yard width at least 10 feet, and rear yard depth at least 50 feet. Structures are generally restricted to 45 feet in height. Impervious surfaces cannot exceed 25% of the lot area. No livestock may be within 100 feet of any lot not located in an RA District. Residential Single Family Districts R-12 Residential Single Family District 1 dwelling unit/12,000 sq. ft. of lot area R-7 Residential Single Family District 1 dwelling unit/7,000 sq. .It. of lot area R-5 Residential Single Family District 1 dwelling unit/5,000 sq. .It. of lot area R-3 Residential Single Family District 1 dwelling unit/3,000 sq. ft. of lot area Protect residential neighborhoods, provide a range of housing choices, and incorporate dimensional standards and densities customary in urban and suburban neighborhoods. Depending on the specific residential single- family district, a lot must have at least 3.000 - 12,000 square feet, 30 - 80 feet of frontage, 15 - 20 feet depth of front yard (with certain exceptions for infill development), 4 - 8 feet width of side yard, 8 - 18 feet total for side yards, and 15 - 30 feet depth of rear yard, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 50 - 70% of the lot area. Maximum front yard depths of 25 - 40 feet appiy in R-5 and R-3. Structures cannot exceed 35 feet in height. Residential Mixed Density Districts RM-1 Residential Mixed Density District: Single-Family, Townhouse, Multifamily 1 dwelling unit/2,500 sq. ft. of lot area Two-Family 1 dwelling unit/3,500 sq. .It. of lot area RM-2 Residential Mixed Density District 1 dwelling unit/2,500 sq. .It. of lot area Allow for a mix of single family detached, townhouse, two-family, and multifamily dwellings. A lot must have at least 5,000 square feet anej 50 feet of frontage (RM-2 lot cannot exceed 25,000 square feet or 150 feet of frontage). Front yard depths must be at least 10 feet and no more than 30 feet (with certain exceptions for infill development), the minimum side yard width is 4 feet, side yards must total at least 8 feet, the minimum rear yard is 15 feet, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 60% (RM-1) and 70% (RM-2) of the lot area. Structures cannot exceed 35 feet (RM-1) and 45 feet (RM-2) in height. RMF Residential Multifamily District 1 dwelling unit/1,000 sq. .It. of lot area Permits multifamily and townhouse dwellings. A lot must have at least 15,000 square feet and 100 feet of frontage. Front yard depth must be at least 10 feet. side yard width at least 15 feet. and rear yard depth at least 15 feet. Structures cannot exceed 45 feet in height. with some exceptions up' to 60 feet in height. Impervious surfaces cannot exceed 70% of the lot area. For multifamily dwellings, 100 square feet ef usable open space per dwelling unit on the lot must be provided. CN Commercial Neighborhood District 1 dwelling unit/1,800 sq. .It. of lot area Encourages pedestrian-scaled retail, office, and service uses, with buildings located close to the street. A lot must have at least 5,000 square feet and cannot exceed 20,000 square feet er have more than 200 feet of frontage. Front yard depths cannot exceed 10 feet. Structures cannot exceed 45 feet in height. Impervious surfaces of up to 100% of the lot area are permitted. In general, the maximum gross ground floor area of any new structure is 15,000 square feet. Building transparency and pedestrian access requirements apply. CG Commercial General District no density restrictions Permits motor vehicle dependent uses that are generally developed as single use developments on individual lots primarily along heavily traveled arterial streets. A lot must have at least 10,000 square feet and 100 feet of frontage and cannot exceed 130,680 square feet of lot area. Front yard depths must be at least 10 feet and no more than 30 feet, impervious surfaces cannot exceed 85% of the lot area, and the floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 5.0. Structures on lots which abut a residential district cannot exceed 45 feet in height. Pedestrian access requirements apply. CLS Commercial Large Site District no density restrictions 2 Accommodates multiple buildings and uses that are large in scale and generally characterized by multiple tenants or uses on a single zoning lot. A lot must have at ieast 90,000 square feet and 150 feet of frontage. Front yard depth must be at least 20 feet, side yard width at least 25 feet, and rear yard depth at least 25 feet. The floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 5.0, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 80% of the lot area. Structures on lots which abut a residential district are restricted in height to 1 foot of height for 1 foot of setback from the abutting residentially zoned lot. Pedestrian access requirements apply. 1-1 Light Industrial District no density restrictions Provides for a range of wholesale. warehousing, distribution, repair and service, assembly or processing, fabrication or manufacturing, accessory commercial and office uses, and intensive commercial uses. A lot must have at least 10,000 square feet and 100 feet of frontage. The front yard depth cannot exceed 30 feet. The floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 2.0. Impervious surfaces cannot exceed 90% of the lot area. Structures on lots which abut a residentiai district are restricted in height to 1 foot of height for 1 foot of setback from the abutting residentially zoned lot. 1-2 Heavy Industrial District no density restrictions Provides for a range of intensive industriai uses including manufacturing, assembly, fabrication, bulk storage, and processing. and related support commercial uses. A lot must have at least 20,000 square feet and 100 feet of frontage. Front yard depth must be at least 30 feet, and rear yard depth must be at least 30 feet. The floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 2.0, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 90% of the lot area. Structures on lots which abut a residential district are restricted in height to 1 foot of height for 1 foot of setback from the abutting residentially zoned lot. . Division 2. Special Purpose Districts: Contains statements of purpose, permitted uses, and related development standards, and sets forth dimensional standards. D Downtown District no density restrictions Allows a wide variety of uses and intense development in the downtown including high density residential. commercial, retail, government services, entertainment facilities, and live-work spaces. The front yard depth cannot exceed 10 feet, with the exception if certain civic space available to the public is provided. The floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 15.0. Building transparency requirements apply. MX Mixed Use District 1 dwelling unit/2,500 sq. ft. of lot area Accommodates residential uses, office uses, and support services. A lot must have at least 5,000 square feet and 50 feet of frontage. Front yard depths must be at least 10 feet, but no more than 30 feet, the width of a side yard must be at least 5 feet, and rear yard depths must be at least 15 feet. Structures cannot exceed 45 feet in height and the floor area ratio of all buildings on a iot cannot exceed 1.0. Impervious surfaces cannot exceed 70% of the lot area. IN Institutional District no density restrictions Provides standards for institutional developments of one principal use. A lot must have at least 100 feet of frontage but cannot exceed 5 acres. Front yard depths are 20 - 40 feet when the district extends for the entire block face; under other circumstances minimum and maximum front yard depths are determined based on abutting zoning districts. Side yards must be at least 10 feet wide, and rear yards must be at least 1 0 feet deep. Structures cannot exceed 40 feet in height, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 80% of the lot area. Pedestrian access requirements apply. ROS Recreation and Open Space District no density restrictions Recognizes active park and recreation lands and passive open spaces. Front yard depths must be at least 30 feet, side yards must be at least 30 feet wide, and rear yard depths must be at least 30 feet. Structures cannot exceed 35 feet in height, and impervious surfaces cannot exceed 15% of the lot area. AD Airport Development District no density restrictions Permits uses dependent on or related to air transportation in areas in and around the Roanoke Regional Airport. A lot must have at least 20,000 square feet and 100 feet of frontage. The floor area ratio of all buildings on a lot cannot exceed 2.0. Impervious surfaces cannot exceed 70% of the lot area. MXPUD Mixed Use Planned Unit Development District 1 dwelling unit/1 ,800 sq. ft. of lot area Encourages mixed residential - commercial uses. Certain side and rear yards must be at least 30 feet deep, the maximum cumulative impervious surface ratio is 80%, and a minimum of 300 square feet of usable open space per dwelling unit must be provided. Certain height restrictions apply to structures when adjoining a residential district. All utilities must be located underground. INPUD Institutional Planned Unit Development District no density restrictions Encourages development of institutional uses and mixed-use campus developments on sites of at least 2 acres. The maximum cumulative floor area ratio of all buildings within the district is 10.0, certain height restrictions apply 3 to structures when adjoining a residential district, the maximum cumulative impervious surface ratio is 80%, and at least 300 square feet of usable open space per dwelling unit must be provided. All utilities must be located underground. IPUD Industrial Planned Unit Development District no density restrictions Encourages large-scale office, research, commercial, and manufacturing facilities in separate structures on sites of at least 5 acres. The maximum cumulative floor area ratio of all buildings within the district is 2.0, certain height restrictions apply to structures when abutting a residential district, the maximum cumulative impervious surface ratio is 80%. and usable open space must be provided at a minimum of 10% of the district area. All utilities must be located underground. . Division 3. Overlay Districts: Contains statements of purpose, applicability, procedures, development standards, and design standards. The provisions of any overlay district serve as a supplement to the underlying (base or special purpose) district on the Zoning Map. Where a conflict exists between the regulations of the overlay district and those of the underlying base or special purpose district, the more restrictive provisions apply. The H-1, Historic Downtown Overlay District, encourages the architectural compatibility of new construction within the district, which is generally in downtown Roanoke, by requiring, subject to certain exceptions, a certificate of appropriateness for the demolition, moving, erection, reconstruction, alteration or restoration, but not the ordinary maintenance. of any structure. The demolition of a structure may not be adverse to the district or the public interest, and demolition may not have an adverse effect on the character of the district. The H-2, Historic Neighborhood Overlay District, encourages the architectural compatibility of new construction within the district, which is generally in established residential neighborhoods in the City, by requiring, subject to certain exceptions, a certificate of appropriateness for the erection of any new structure, or the demolition, moving, reconstruction, aiteration or restoration of any existing structure. The demolition of a structure may not be adverse to the district or the public interest, and demolition may not have an adverse effect on the district. The NO, Neighborhood Design Overlay District, promotes quality design of residential development within designated rehabilitation and conservation areas. The mass and location on the lot of aft new dwellings. and expansion of existing dwellings, is dependent upon conditions existing on adjoining lots. Additional specific restrictions pertain to detached accessory buildings, attached garages or carports, roofs, entrances, windows, siding, trim, and porches. The F, Floodplain Overlay District, provides floodplain restrictions which comply with Federal Emergency Management Agency regulations. The floodway, fiood-fringe and approximated floodplain are defined and delineated. No land or use may be developed within the established fioodplain areas, and no structure can be located, relocated, constructed, reconstructed, enlarged, or structurally altered, except in full compliance with the floodplain regulations. No use or development may adversely affect the capacity of channels or the floodway of any watercourse. All manufactured homes and mobile homes to be placed in the flood-fringe must be placed on a permanent foundation and anchored in accordance with the Building Code. No encroachments in the flood- fringe, approximated floodplain, or floodway are permitted, uniess certain regulations are met. Only certain limited uses are permitted in the floodway. The AN, Airport Navigation Overlay District, requires clear space between aircraft and other objects, and prevents interference with the landing, taking off, or maneuvering of aircraft, or with communication between aircraft and flight related personnel, by regulating the height of structures, objects, and natural growth, lights, electrical devices and uses near the Roanoke Regional Airport and within certain established approach zones. No nonconforming use may be allowed to expand and become a greater hazard to air navigation. Whenever the Zoning Administrator determines that a nonconforming structure has been abandoned or more than 50 percent destroyed, physically deteriorated, or decayed, no permit may be granted that would enable such structure to be rebuilt, reconstructed, or otherwise refurbished so as to exceed the applicable height limit or otherwise deviate from the AN District regulations. The RCC, River and Creek Corridors Overlay District, limits land uses that pose a danger to and degrade the Roanoke River and its tributaries, minimizes clearing and land disturbance of natural features on lands adjacent to those water resources, and implements erosion and sediment control measures to protect those water resources. On properties that abut the banks of the Roanoke River and its tributaries, a 50 foot buffer area of vegetation must be retained and maintained, if present, and where it does not exist, must be established and maintained, subject to certain exceptions. Within buffer areas, indigenous vegetation must be preserved to the maximum extent possible, no vegetation may be cleared or otherwise significantly disturbed, no grading or excavation work may be performed, and no fill or other materials may be placed, subject to certain exceptions. Within the required riparian buffer area, unvegetated areas must be vegetated with appropriate riparian. erosion 4 controlling plant material. Runoff from new development or redevelopment must be directed toward areas covered with vegetation for surface infiltration catch basins, avoiding channeling and preventing concentrated flows of surface water. Piped storm sewers are permitted. The Comprehensive Sign Overlay District provides opportunity for comprehensive signage plans for certain developments in the CLS, MXPUD, INPUD, or AD Districts on sites of at least 5 acres. In a Comprehensive Sign Overlay District, the overall sign area and height of signs cannot exceed the sign allocation or maximum sign height of the applicable base zoning district. . Division 4. Use Matrix: All lots in the City are subject to a new list of uses permitted by right, by special exception or as an accessory use. Uses not identified in a district as allowed either by right, by special exception, Or as an accessory use, are not allowed. Article 4. Supplemental Regulations Sections 36.2 - 400 through 432 Contains statements of purpose, applicability, definitions, dimensional standards, development standards, and design standards intended to supplement the applicable zoning district regulations and the other development standards of the zoning ordinance in a manner that specifically addresses development of certain defined land uses, facilities, and structures. Supplemental regulations are applicable to new development, redeveiopment, or a change of use. Supplemental regulations are set forth for accessory apartments, accessory uses, accessory structures, amateur radio towers and antennas, dumpsters, detached garages and carports, outdoor recreation facility lighting, recycling collection points, private stables, swimming pools and tennis courts, adult uses, bed and breakfast establishments, car washes, commercial motor vehicle sales and service establishments, day care centers, drive through facilities, fences and walls, gasoline stations, group care facilities, home occupations, junk yards, wrecker yards and recycling centers, mini- warehouses. mixed-use buildings and live-work units, mobile homes, motor vehicle or trailer painting and body repair establishments, motor vehicle repair or service establishments, motor vehicle sales and service establishments, outdoor display areas, outdoor storage. parking of commercial motor vehicles, panel trucks, and certain recreational vehicles in residential districts, parking structures, satellite dish antennas, commerciai stables, temporary uses, towing services, townhouses and rowhouses, and wireless telecommunications facilities and broadcasting towers, which help ensure that such uses are compatible with adjoining uses and surrounding neighborhoods. Article 5. Procedures Sections 36.2 - 500 through 571 Sets out the procedures for zoning permits, certificates of occupancy, certificates of appropriateness, zoning amendments, development plans, special exceptions, variances. and appeals; and sets forth the procedures for the enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance. No certificate of appropriateness in an H-1 or H-2 overlay district may be issued unless the proposed construction is architecturally compatible with the structures or historic landmarks in the applicable historic district. Also establishes procedures for the Board of Zoning Appeals to hear and decide applications for special exceptions, variances from the terms of the Zoning Ordinance, and appeals from any order, requirement, decision. or determination made by the Zoning Administrator in the administration or enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance, and establishes enforcement procedures. Article 6. Development Standards Sections 36.2 - 600 through 675 . Division 1. Utilities: Requires that all utility service laterals and service lines associated with basic or comprehensive development plans be located underground, with the exception that they may be located above ground to the point of connection when routed directly to the rear of a structure by way of an alley or utility easement where overhead distribution lines exist. . Division 2. Outdoor Lighting: Controls light trespass, and prevents light glare by regulating the aiming angles, mounting heights, and location of certain outdoor lighting so as not to present glare or light trespass on abutting lots or public streets. The allowable height of such lighting generally is based on the zoning of the lot On which the lighting is located and the distance from property lines, with established maximum heights. Aiming angles are generally restricted to no greater than 45 degrees above straight down (halfway between straight down and straight to the side), and in certain applications fully shielded fixtures are required. . Division 3. General Development Standards: Provides that the provision and location of all pedestrian and vehicular traffic related facilities, including sidewalks, curbs and gutters, frontage roads, and acceleration and deceleration ianes. must be as required by the Agent to the Planning Commission, provided that the property's development directly generates the need for such infrastructure and that the required infrastructure is in proportion to the level of pedestrian and vehicular activity generated by the development. 5 o Division 4. Landscaping and Screening: Incorporates landscaping, screening, and tree canopy preservation requirements into the development process by establishing minimum requirements for the installation. preservation and maintenance of certain planting and screening materials. Includes the following regulations: o General landscaping and screening standards, including requirements for the vegetative cover of created slopes of 2 to 1 or greater; standards for planting materials including an approved tree list with height and caliper requirements for specific applications; screening standards; landscape plan requirements; installation, approval and guarantee requirements; maintenance requirements; and modification of landscaping requirements. o Preservation of existing landscaping features, including general standards and specific requirements for tree protection during construction. o Overall tree canopy requirements on a development site (by zoning district). o Conditions for provision of street yard trees for new development in all zoning districts. o Provision of fac;:ade planting for new residential development. o General requirements (by zoning district category) for buffer yards, extent of buffer yards (by zoning district category), and location of buffer yards on a zoning lot. o Parking area landscaping standards, including the provision of wheel stops and curbs; minimum dimensions for planting areas and spatial requirements for deciduous trees; landscaping requirements along parking area perimeters that front on a public street; interior parking area tree canopy requirements (based on square footage of parking area and number of parking spaces provided); and a limitation on the use of anyone species of trees. o General standards for screening of dumpsters/refuse containers, mechanical equipment at grade and mechanical equipment on roof. o Division 5. Off-Street Parking and Loading: Sets forth off-street parking and loading requirements for permitted and special exception uses in accordance with the intensity of such uses; provides location, construction, and dimensional standards for motor vehicle parking areas, loading spaces, and driveways; and provides alternatives and options for the provision of adequate levels of off-street parking. Includes regulations and standards addressing: o Minimum off-street parking requirements: Applicability; methods of calculation; reductions in parking requirements for proximity to public transit, availability of on-street parking, shared parking, and first 4.000 square feet of net floor area of a non-residential use; and option for off-site parking. o Maximum off-street parking requirements in all zoning districts, with exceptions for certain uses. o Off-street parking area standards: General, construction, location, dimensional and driveway standards, including surfacing requirements, curbing requirements, minimum setbacks from property lines, minimum and maximum widths of driveways, total of permitted driveway entrances, the restriction of off-street parking spaces between the right-of-way of a public street and the principal buildings in RM-1, RM-2, RMF, CN, CG. MX, IN, and D Districts, with certain exceptions, and pedestrian access requirements for certain uses in ihe CG and CLS Districts between off-street parking areas and public entrances of buildings. o Off-street loading standards: Minimum numbers and dimensional and location standards. o Division 6. Signs: Permits the use of publicly visible signs subject to regulations addressing: o General applicability, exemptions from regulations, and regulations pertaining to placement. o Prohibition of certain types of signs and sign characteristics. o Zoning permits for signs. o Removal of abandoned nonconforming signs and their support structures. o Standards to control the visibility of the point source of lights used to externally illuminate signs. o Methods for calculation of sign area and number of on-premise signs. o Dimensional standards for on-premise freestanding, building mounted, and upper story wall signs (by zoning district), including total sign area, sign area per sign face, height, and setbacks. o Types and numbers of on-premise signs permitted on a lot (by zoning district). . Changeable copy signs and electronic reader boards, including the location, the requirement to be part of a static sign display, and the limitation on size relative to the size of the static sign. . Temporary on-premise signs, including standards for height, number, size, duration, location, and the type of temporary on-premise signs permitted. . Public service message boards, including the number, size, height, location, and operation of such signs. 6 o Outdoor advertising signs including standards for sign area by zoning district, setbacks, interior angle of sign faces, height, number of sign faces, spacing between outdoor advertising signs. location along certain vehicular transportation corridors and streets in the City, and location with respect to residential districts. public schools, public libraries, places of worship, museums, or public parks, to ensure compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood and adjoining uses. The distances separating outdoor advertising signs from each other, or separating any outdoor advertising sign from any boundary, is measured from the nearest point on the proposed outdoor advertising sign to the nearest applicable point of another outdoor advertising sign or boundary. Article 7. Nonconforming Uses, Structures and Lots Sections 36.2 - 700 through 709 Regulates nonconforming uses, structures, and lots to permit such nonconforming uses, structures, and lots to remain, until removed, discontinued, abandoned, or changed to conform with the regulations of Chapter 36.2, to ensure that such continuances are not indefinite and are gradualiy removed in favor of uses, structures, and lots that conform to Chapter 36.2 and the Official Zoning Map, and to provide that under certain circumstances, nonconforming uses. structures and iots may change according to law and provisions of Chapter 36.2. Includes regulations and standards addressing: o General applicability and definition of actual construction begun prior to adoption of Chapter 36.2. o Standards for nonconforming lots. o Standards for nonconforming structures, including circumstances under which a nonconforming structure may be continued, moved. replaced. enlarged or altered. Any nonconforming structure which is damaged or destroyed by any natural disaster, except flood, to an extent that exceeds 50% of its replacement value at the time of the event may be rebuiit only in conformity with the regulations for the district in which it is located. o Standards for nonconforming uses, including circumstances under which a nonconforming use may be moved, intensified, changed, expanded, replaced or restarted after being damaged, destroyed or ceased. Should a structure in which such nonconforming use is located be enlarged, extended, reconstructed, or structurally altered, except as otherwise permitted by Chapter 36.2, the use of such a structure thereafter must conform to the regulations of the district in which it is located. If the structure in which a nonconforming use is located is damaged or destroyed from fire' or other natural disaster, except for flood, to an extent that exceeds 50% of the replacement value of improvements at the time of the event, the use must conform to the district regulations of Chapter 36.2. Ordinary maintenance of a structure housing a nonconforming use may occur, if the cubic content of the building is not increased. o Standards and process for change of a nonconforming use to another use. o Standards and definition of nonconforming characteristics of use. o Certain existing uses which would require a special exception if they were new uses are deemed conforming. Article 8. Administrative Commissions, Boards, and Officials Sections 36.2 - 800 through 840 Provides for definitions, establishment, membership, meetings, quorum, voting procedures, officers, agent and staff, rules and records, and powers and duties of the City Planning Commission. Architectural Review Board, and Board of Zoning Appeals; and establishes and authorizes the powers and duties of the Zoning Administrator. Appendix A. Definitions Provides for definitions of certain uses and terms used in Chapter 36.2. Appendix B. Submittal Requirements Outlines the materials and information that must be submitted in order to provide a compiete application for approval of basic development plans, comprehensive development plans and landscape plans. Appendix C. Agreements Provides forms for agreements as may be required by Chapter 36.2, such as an off-site parking agreement. Questions should be directed to the Department of Planning Building and Economic Development at 853-1730. All parties in interest may appear on the above date and be heard on the questions. . If you are a person with a disability who needs accommodations for these hearings, please contact the City Clerk's Office (853-2541), before 12:00 noon on Thursday, November 17, 2005. 7 GIVEN under my hand this 8th day of November, 2005. Mary F. Parker. City Clerk. Please publish in Roanoke Times on Tuesday, November 8 and Tuesday, November 15, 2005 Please bill: Mary F. Parker. City Clerk Fourth Floor, Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W. Roanoke, VA 24011 (540) 853-2541 \ 8 CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon, CMC Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 8, 2005 File#51 Darlene L. Burcham City Manager Roanoke, Virginia Richard A. Rife, Chair City Planning Commission 1326 Grandin Road, S. W. Roanoke, Virginia 24015 Dear Ms. Burcham and Mr. Rife: I am attaching copy of Ordinance No. 37269-120505 adopting a new zoning map entitled, "Official Zoning Map, City of Roanoke, Virginia," dated December 5, 2005, as amended, as the official zoning map for the City of Roanoke. The abovereferenced measure was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005, and is in full force and effect upon its passage. Sincerely, 0 A .;r~~- I Mary F.~er, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment L:ICLERK\OATAICKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05lDec 05IDec 5 2005 correspondence.doc Darlene L. Burcham Richard A. Rife, Chair December 8, 2005 Page 2 pc: The Honorable Robert P. Doherty, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable William D. Broadhurst, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Clifford R. Weckstein, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Charles N. Dorsey, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Jonathan M. Apgar, Chief Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable James R. Swanson, Judge, Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit of Virginia The Honorable Julian H. Raney, Jr., Chief Judge, General District Court The Honorable Vincent A. Lilley, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Francis W. Burkart, III, Judge, General District Court The Honorable Jacqueline F. Ward Talevi, Judge, General District Court The HonorableJohn B. Ferguson, ChiefJudge,Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph M. Clarke, II, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Philip Trompeter, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court The Honorable Joseph P. Bounds, Judge, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Sheila N. Hartman, Assistant City Clerk, (For transmittal by electronic mail to Municipal Code Corporation) Municipal Code Corporation, P. O. Box 2235, Tallahassee, Florida 32316 Ronald S. Albright, Clerk, General District Court David C. Wells, Clerk, Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court Kozuo Webb, Office of the Magistrate Lora A. Wilson, Law Librarian William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Susan S. Lower, Director, Real Estate Valuation Steven J. Talevi, Assistant City Attorney R. Brian Townsend, Director, Planning, Building and Economic Development Martha P. Franklin, Secretary, City Planning Commission Nancy C. Snodgrass, Zoning Administrator Philip C. Schirmer, City Engineer L:\CLERK\DATA\CKEW1\AGENDA CORRESPONDENCElagenda correspondence 05\Dec 05\Dec 5 2005 correspondence.doc '. " "'",1' or:-', ~: CITY OF ROANOKE Office of the City Clerk , ,~J-~ Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk Stephanie M. Moon Deputy City Clerk Sheila N. Hartman Assistant City Clerk December 15, 2005 File #51 The Honorable Brenda S. Hamilton Clerk of Circuit Court Roanoke, Virginia Dear Ms. Hamilton: Pursuant to Section 15.2-2234, Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, I am required to file a copy of the attached Official Zoning Map of the City of Roanoke, Virginia, dated December 5, 2005, with the Circuit Court within 30 days of the adoption of the zoning map. The zoning map was adopted by the Council of the City of Roanoke at a regular meeting which was held on Monday, December 5, 2005, pursuant to Ordinance No. 37269-120505. With kindest regards, I am Sincerely, ~ YL 1'1 tV 1- 4- , V\. ~ 7. - - Mary F. Parker, CMC City Clerk MFP:ew Attachment -/- \.~ / ,~ ~ " , :-.". ;/' {J',n"- ~.iY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE, VIRGINIA, The 5th day of December, 2005. No. 37269-120505. AN ORDINANCE adopting a new zoning map entitled, "Official Zoning Map, City of Roanoke, Virginia," dated December 5, 2005, as amended, as the official zoning map for the City of Roanoke; and dispensing with the second reading by title of this ordinance, WHEREAS, on August 20, 2001, City Council adopted Vision 2001-2020 ("Comprehensive Plan"), a new Comprehensive Plan for the City, which plan has necessitated a replacement of the Official 1976 Zoning Map, City of Roanoke, Virginia, dated October 11, 1976, as the map and boundaries have been amended from time to time, and a comprehensive revision of the City's zoning regulations; WHEREAS, the City conducted ten (10) stakeholder focus group sessions on June 25, June 26, and August 1, 2002, with sign industry representatives, neighborhood group leaders, land use attorneys, regional development leaders, business leaders, design and development professionals, and governmental boards and commissions, to identify opportunities and issues relating to growth and development in the City and to identify zoning regulations which needed to be amended or adopted; WHEREAS, the City conducted a housing issues roundtable on July 31,2002, to which representatives of various groups interested in, and knowledgeable about, housing issues in the City were invited, and a public forum on August 1, 2002, to which the general public was invited, to identify additional opportunities and issues relating to growth and development in the City and to identify zoning regulations which needed to be amended or adopted; K:\ORDINANCES\O.CA..omCIAL ZONING MAP 120$O'.DOC WHEREAS, in July 2002, the City Manager appointed a Steering Committee consisting of representatives from the stakeholder groups, City Council, the Planning Commission for the City of Roanoke ("Planning Commission"), the Board of Zoning Appeals for the City of Roanoke, the Architectural Review Board for the City of Roanoke, and City staff, to provide direction for the development of the new zoning ordinance, to review and revise draft zoning regulations, and to provide on-going feedback during the process; WHEREAS, in February 2004, City staff released for public discussion a zoning map to accompany the Steering Committee's draft zoning ordinance; WHEREAS, on March 8, March 12, March 16, March 17, March 18, March 22, March 23, March 25, March 29, March 30, April 1, April 5, April 6, April 13, April 28 and April 29, 2004, City staff conducted six (6) public open houses and eleven (11) stakeholder focus group sessions with sign industry representatives, neighborhood group leaders, land use attorneys, business leaders, homebuilders, design and development professionals, and real estate industry representatives, to elicit public comment pertaining to the proposed zoning map; WHEREAS, to provide for public awareness of the open houses and the stakeholder focus group sessions, the City (I) placed two (2) easels and flyers with calendars, indicating the dates, times and locations ofthe open houses and sessions, in the lobby area ofthe Municipal Building and in the Departments of Housing and Neighborhood Services and Planning, Building and Economic Development, (2) posted open house schedules on the RVTV Message Board, (3) published two (2) block advertisements in the Roanoke Times, advertising the open house schedules, (4) mailed an explanation of the public comment process and how to participate in such process and provide input to all neighborhood group leaders, (5) set up and staffed an information and comment table on Citizen Appreciation Day on April 17 , 2004, at Valley View Mall, (6) conducted meetings with, and K:\OJIDINANCES\O-CA-OmCIAL ZONn"lG MAP 12050'.DOC 2 gave presentations to, neighborhood and civic organizations, including the Roanoke Neighborhood Advocates, Downtown Roanoke, Inc., Williamson Road Area Business Association, the Roanoke Regional Chamber of Commerce, the Roanoke Regional Homebuilders Association, Neighbors in South Roanoke, Old Southwest, Inc., the Gilmer Neighborhood Steering Committee, and the Gainsboro Steering Committee, and (7) posted on the City's web site a copy ofthe proposed zoning map, which posting was viewed 1,117 times during the February 2004 to May 2004 period; WHEREAS, from February 2,2004 until May 31,2004, the City documented more than 1,100 comments, including those on the proposed zoning map; WHEREAS, in May 2005, City staff released and posted on the City's web site a revised proposed zoning map; WHEREAS, between December 2004, and July 2005, City staff continued to meet with various civic and neighborhood organizations, including Old Southwest, Inc., Riverland Alert Neighbors, Gilmer Neighborhood, the Greater Raleigh Court Civic League and the Williamson Road Area Business Association, as well as individual property owners by request, regarding the proposed zoning map, to oversee questions and to elicit additional public comment; WHEREAS, public news releases, newspaper articles, status reports and communications were disseminated by the City throughout the process to advise interested persons of the status of the process; WHEREAS, after due and timely public notice, including a legal advertisement consisting of a special insert published on two dates, one week apart, in a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Roanoke in which all interested persons were advised of the City's intent to adopt a new zoning map, a copy of which was contained in the insert, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on July 28, 2005, on the proposed zoning map; K:\ORDINANCES\Q-CA-OFFlClALZONING MAP 120.50.5.DOC 3 WHEREAS, in addition to the published legal advertisement described in the preceding paragraph, the City sent by first-class mail to all owners of the approximately 44,000 parcels of real estate in the City of Roanoke notice of (I) the City's intent to adopt a new zoning map; (2) the proposed zoning of the owner's property under the proposed zoning map; and (3) the date, time and place, of the Planning Commission's public hearing at which the proposed zoning map would be considered; WHEREAS, following the Planning Commission public hearing, the Planning Commission held fifteen (15) work sessions during which it considered all comments received pertaining to the proposed zoning map; WHEREAS, the City Clerk for the City of Roanoke placed a notice on the public calendar in her office for all Steering Committee meetings, all Planning Commission work sessions, and the public hearing held on July 28,2005; WHEREAS, on September 29, 2005, the Planning Commission unanimously recommended to City Council the proposed zoning map; WHEREAS, a public hearing was held on the proposed zoning map by City Council at its meeting on November 21,2005, after due and timely public notice thereof, which public notice included a legal advertisement published on two dates, one week apart, by a newspaper of general circulation in the City of Roanoke in which all interested persons were advised of the City's intent to adopt a new zoning map as recommended by the Planning Commission, a copy of which was contained in the insert, at which hearing all parties in interest and citizens were given an opportunity to be heard; WHEREAS, after such public hearing, City Council revised the zoning map as the same was recommended by the Planning Commission; K:\ORDINANCES\O-CA.oFFlCIAL ZONING MAP 120505.DOC 4 WHEREAS, this Council, after considering the proposed zoning map, as revised, is of the opinion that the proposed zoning map, as revised, helps promote and provide for adequate light, air, convenience of access; safety from flood, fire, crime and other dangers; reduce or prevent congestion in the public streets; facilitate the creation of a convenient, attractive and harmonious community; facilitate the provision of adequate police and fire protection, disaster evacuation, civil defense, transportation, water, sewerage, flood protection, schools, parks, forests, playgrounds, recreational facilities, airports and other public requirements; protect against destruction of, or encroachment upon, historic areas; protect against overcrowding ofland, undue density of population in relation to the community facilities existing or available, obstruction oflight and air, danger and congestion in travel and transportation, and loss oflife, health, or property from fire, flood, panic or other dangers; encourage economic development activities that provide desirable employment and enlarge the tax base; provide for the preservation of agricultural and forestal lands and other lands of significance for the protection of the natural environment, approach slopes and other safety areas oflicensed airports; and promote the creation and preservation of affordable housing suitable for meeting the current and future needs of the City, as well as a reasonable proportion of the current and future needs of the planning district within which the City is situated; and WHEREAS, this Council, after considering the proposed zoning map, as revised, is of the opinion that the proposed zoning map, as revised, is consistent with Vision 2001- 2020, the City's Comprehensive Plan, is required by the public necessity, convenience, general welfare, is good zoning practice, and ought to be adopted in order to implement the Comprehensive Plan. THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Roanoke as follows: I. The zoning map entitled, "Official Zoning Map, City of Roanoke, Virginia," dated December 5, 2005, as amended, and attached to a letter dated December 5, 2005, to City Council K.:\QRDINANCES\O-CA-OmClALZONING MAP 12QS05.DOC 5 from the City Manager, and filed with the City Clerk, is hereby adopted as the official zoning map for the City of Roanoke. 2. Pursuant to section 15.2-2234 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended, the City Clerk is requested to file a copy of the Official Zoning Map, City of Roanoke, Virginia, dated December 5,2005, as amended, in the Office ofthe Clerk of the Circuit Court within thirty (30) days of the adoption of the zoning map. 3. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 12 of the City Charter, the second reading of this ordinance by title is hereby dispensed with. AA--. !. (J~ City Clerk. K:\ORDJNANCES\O..CA-OmClAL ZONING MAP 120$O'.DOC 6 CITY OF ROANOKE OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER Noel C. Taylor Municipal Building 215 Church Avenue, S.W., Room 364 Roanoke, Virginia 24011-1591 Telephone, (540) 853-2333 Fa" (540) 853-1138 City Web: www.roanokeva.gov December 5, 2005 Honorable C. Nelson Harris, Mayor Honorable Beverly T. Fitzpatrick, Jr., Vice Mayor Honorable M. Rupert Cutler, Council Member Honorable Alfred T. Dowe, Jr., Council Member Honorable Sherman P. Lea, Council Member Honorable Brenda L. McDaniel, Council Member Honorable Brian J. Wishneff, Council Member Mayor Harris and Members of City Council: Subject: Revised Zoning Ordinance and Official Zoning Map Background: City Council held its public hearing on Monday, November 21, 2005, on the proposed zoning ordinance and accompanying zoning map, as recommended by the Planning Commission. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the matter was tabled to the December 5 City Council meeting and staff was requested to review the public comments and provide a response to each issue raised. City Council was subsequently provided a list of issues, including staff positions for review and consideration. Each City Council member has provided reactions to the citizen comments and staff positions on those issues. Considerations: Based on the comments received, there was support for making the following two changes to the Official Zoning Map: (1) Designate the Hylton properties on Orange Avenue, N.E. (Tax Nos. 7130102,7130103, and 7130116) as CLS, Commercial-Large Site District. Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5, 2005 Page 2 of 3 (2) Designate two properties (Tax Nos. 3130805 and 3130901) located at the intersection of Liberty Road and Plantation Road to CG, Commercial- General District. Note that Tax No. 3130805 is subject to proffered conditions associated with a rezoning initiated by the owner, so it will have a "CG - conditional" designation. As with other conditional rezonings, the conditions will remain in effect, regardless of the new zoning designation. The following additional map changes as recommended by staff and supported by the responses from City Council, include the following: . Windsor Lake (Tax Map No. 5110104) remapped as ROS . Sewell Lane, S.W. (Tax Map No. 1360137) remapped as ROS . First Church of the Nazarene (Tax Map Nos. 4122 509, 4122 510, 4122511, 4122512, 4122514, and 4122515) remapped as IN . Grandin Court Baptist Church (Tax Map Nos. 1561028, 1561301, 1561315, and 1561317) remapped as IN . Loudon Avenue Christian Church (Tax Map No. 2112104) remapped a IN . 2903 Peters Creek Road (Tax Map Nos. 6410105 and 6410106) remapped as CLS, conditional . Gilford Road, N.W. (Tax Map Nos. 6110414 and 6110436) remapped as RM-2 . 1506 Edmund Road, N.E. (Tax Map Nos. 3210621, 3210622, 3210623, 3210624, and 3210625) remapped as RM-1 Also, responses indicated support for changes to the AD, Airport Development District. Five uses permitted by special exception in the AD District have been recommended for change to permitted by right, and other permitted uses in the district have been added in response to the concerns about the AD district. The AD purpose statement has been revised, the definition of financial institution has been revised to include support services, and the definition of large-scale general or professional offices has been changed to require a minimum of 10,000 square feet rather than 20,000. Specifically, the following uses have been added to the list of permitted uses in the AD District: . Financial institution . Laboratory, dental, medical or optical . Building supplies and materials, retail . Building supplies and materials, wholesale . Commercial printing establishment . Mini-warehouse, subject to See. 36.2-415 . Educational facilities, Business school or non-industrial trade school . Educational facilities, Industrial trade school Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council December 5, 2005 Page 3 of 3 . Government offices or other government facilities . Parking lot facility The following additional changes are proposed: . See. 36.2-41 O(b) - Maximum height of fences on residential corner lots . Table 312-1 - Clarification of density application in RM-l . See. 36.2-340, Use Matrix - Addition of Office, general or professional, large scale as a permitted use in INPUD and MXPUD . Table 668-1 - Permit electronic readerboards in CG District, limited to 22 square feet in sign area . See. 36.2-662 - Revision of definition of "temporary sign" to allow attachment to an existing freestanding sign structure These changes to the text and map are reflected in the enclosed Zoning Ordinance and Official Zoning Map, dated December 5, 2005. Recommended Action: Approve the Zoning Ordinance and Official Zoning Map, dated December 5, 2005. R~ctfu IIY~SUbmi~ted, cAith~~~ Darlene L. B~cham City Manager Ene!. c: Mary F. Parker, City Clerk William M. Hackworth, City Attorney Jesse A. Hall, Director of Finance Rolanda B. Russell, Assistant City Manager for Community Development Brian Townsend, Director of Planning, Building and Economic Development NOTICE Attachments to the City Planning Commission reports for the new Zoning Ordinance are too large to scan and may be reviewed at the Office of the City Clerk, and the Department of Planning Building and Development, 215 Church Avenue, S.W., or online at www.roanokeva.govj "What's New", "Zoning Ordinance Public Hearings I Draft Ordinance".